Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Chapter I
Introduction
Literature is a crystal clear stream that reflects the whole canopy of life.
Literature is commonly classified as having two major forms, fiction and non-fiction.
The two major techniques are poetry and prose. Important historical periods in
English Literature includes old English, middle English and renaissance or the
Elizabethan era of the sixteenth century, the seventeenth century, restoration period,
the eighteenth century, the age of enlightenment, and romanticism of the early
nineteenth century and the twentieth century modernism and post modernism.
political influences. In general a genre consists of artistic works that fall within a
certain central theme. An example of genre includes romance, mystery, crime, fantasy
erotica and adventure, among others. Similar to Thomas Hardys Wessex, Narayan
created the fictitious town of Malgudi where he set his novels. Some critics criticize
Narayan for the parochial detached and closed world that he created in the face of the
changing conditions in India at the times in which the stories are set others.
words some aspects of human experiences. Literature has always been a handy tool in
exploring the gender relations and sexual differences. Literature enriches our lives
find meaning in our world and to express it and share it with others. It makes us to
understand particular age, custom, and the mindset of the people. Literature portrays
characters realistically.
2
The beginning of Indian Literature in English is traced back to the end of the
eighteenth century and the beginning of the nineteenth century. When English
education is more or less firmly established in the three major center of British power
in India.
by writing in England. Indo Anglican Literature is both and Indian Literature and a
history. It is only one and a half centuries old. The first book is written by an Indian in
English by Sake Dean Mahomet, titled Travels of Dean Mahomet; Mahomets travel
The first Indian English novel is Bankim Chandra Chatterjees Raj Mohans
Wife (1864). It paved the way for Anand math (1884). Indias first political novel
which gave the Indians their national anthem Vandematharam. This was followed
Mano Basus Jalijangal in the form of English translation as the forest goddess by
writers belonging to the presidencies of Bengal and Madras. Most of these novel were
on social and few on historical issues, especially that of Daniel Defoe, Henry Fielding
and Scott. The twelfth century is game with novelist of more substantial outputs
Michael Madhu Sudan and Bankim Chandra Chatterjee had opened new avenues
Literature and Romesh Chandra too turned to creative writing. Indian English
The works of the pioneers are imitative of British models. This early phase
may be called the phase of imitation. The second phase is of Indigenization, it began
with the works of Toru Dutt is the last quarter of the nineteenth century. The third
national consciousness and even become popular the west. The fourth phase is of
experimentation and individual talent. This phase is remarkable for the growing
contemporary issues. In their novels prevailing social and political problems that
Indians found were given prominence. Indian English Literature has a relatively
The term 'Novel' is derived from the Italian word 'novella' which means a little
new thing. Novella is a short story in Prose and Novel. Novel is the modern meaning
of the word the broader name fiction may properly be applied. Since, we shall see all
novels are fiction but all fiction is by no means novels. The whole development of the
novel indeed is embraced within little more than a century and a half from the middle
of the eighteenth century of the present time. The novel came to express most
inclusively among the literary forms this more vivid realization of mean and turn. The
novel in its treatment of personality began to teach the stone thrown into the water
and The Serpent and the Rope, which is Indian in terms of its story telling qualities.
Women in Raja Raos novels suffer from domestic injustice and tyrannical tradition,
but the writer suggests no way to come out of their dilemma. His women characters,
4
who are a little ambitious end up playing the devoted role of a wife like Savitri in The
responsible for the translation of his own work into English. Dan Gopal Mukerji is the
first Indian author to win a literary award in the United States. The first generation of
Indian writers in English was Raja Rao, R.K.Narayan, Rabindranath Tagore, Mulkraj
Anand etc. They talked about freedom struggle, domestic violence, marginalization
and self-identity.
continued to write till his death recently. Narayans portrayal of women characters
ranges from the meek and submissive wife of margay in The Financial Expert and
Savitri in The Dark Room to the vibrant and radical women characters like Daisy and
women are tender, charming and virtuous and play a significant role in effecting
social change. But in spite of being tender and virtuous they are victimized. Kajoli in
So Many Hungers undergoes immense suffering and misery, but her spirit remains
invisible.
Recent writers in India such as Arundhati Roy and David Davidar show a
trained architect. In 1997, she is the booker prize winner for The God of Small Things,
calls herself a home grown writer. Her award winning book is set in the immensely
physical landscape of Kerala. Davidar sets his the house of Blue Mangoes in Southern
Tamilnadu. In both the books, geography and politics are integral to the narrative. In
5
his novel Lament of Mohini (2000), Shreekumar Varma touches upon the unique
matriarchal system and the sammandham system of marriage as he writer about the
In India, too women writers have come forward to voice their feminist
approach to life, the patriarchal family set-up. They believe that the concept of gender
society.
Women writers on the other hand were mere honest in the portrayal of women
in their novels. Their main contribution is that they view the distinctive female
sensibility with some other feelings like marginalization, self identify, etc. It is a well
known fact that women are natural story tellers. Women writers are not far behind
their western counterparts, in carving a niche for their story telling abilities. They are
renowned for their originality, versatility. The focus of most of the women writers in
scenario of the male dominated society. Each and every one of the woman writers
explores and struggle for identity. This is the underlying theme in the tales of all
Indian woman writers. They were very realistic and appeared as the horizon of Indian
English novels kamala Markandaya, Nayanthara Saghal, Anita Desai are the women
who portrayed some of the above said themes in their novels. The above mentioned
that the Indian women is subjected between her desire to assert herself as an
individual and her duty in the capacity of a daughter, wife and mother. She also points
6
out how the socio-economic condition affect the women much kamala Markandayas
novel Nectar in a Sieve has passing reference to the burning problem of dowry. The
women character of kamala Markandayas novels though not conscious, though not
fully aware, yet are concerned with the fundamental question to the lot of women. An
analysis of her novels reveals that is feminist in her novels by giving and objective
female sensibility. Tale of Rukmani is the tale of any village women in India of the
fifties. Her Two Virgins express her concern with womens situation in modern India.
It is a story of two sisters, Lalitha and Saroja who grew from childhood to woman
hood. Markandaya another novel. A Handful of Rice the two women Nalini and
because she possesses some of the traits of new woman. Thus the novels of kamala
consciousness.
Anitha Desai one of the prominent Indian women English novelists is born on
June 24, 1937 in Delhi to a German mother and a Bengali father. She married Ashwin
Desai a businessman. They have four children. She was short listed for the booker
prize and three times and received a Sahitya academy award in 1978 for her novel
Fire on the Mountain and the British Gandhian prize for The Village by the Sea. Her
daughter Kiran Desai won the man booker prize in 2006 for her second novel The
Inheritance of Loss. She is very distinguished Indian novelist. She has been
recognized as such has written large about women characters through her fiction
throughout her novels and short stories. Desai focuses on the personal struggles of
7
anglicized middle class women in contemporary India. Her novels move around
women character although she is preoccupied with the theme of incompatible marital
couplets.
Most of Desais works engage the complexities of modern Indian culture far
from feminine perspective while highlights the female Indian predicament to maintain
a self identity as an individual. Cry the Peacock is a novel mainly concerned with the
theme of disharmony between husband and wife relationship. It deals with the
detail images, monologues and flashbacks. The female character Maya, in the novel
envelopes the reader as she unfolds the growth, development and climax of her
story unfolds that Mayas father without thinking much married her off to his own
lawyer friend Gautam who is middle aged man. The marriage is never fruitful and
slowly Maya turns into a psychopath whose emotional needs were seen to be collided.
The climax of the story lays when Mayas attachment with her father further develops
into an Electra complex which again acts as the catalyst in the deflowering of her
marital relationship with her husband. Extremely frustrated Maya then looks back to
the class of her childhood spent with her father. The reminiscence of these long lost
days serves as the defense mechanism to set her free from her inner frustration and
conflict.
Nayantara Sahgal yet another prominent Indian women writer dealt with
issues concerning women that later became major issue in the feminist movement
launched in the sixties. She exposes the prejudice women face in a male dominated
society. The Day in Shadow is about the prejudice faced by the divorce heroine Simrit.
Sahgal being a divorce herself reveals in a realistic and vivid manner how Simrit tries
8
to square her equation with her growing children and her ex-husband. she not only
undergoes the humiliation of being a divorce but also faces the cruel consent terms
of the divorce. Her fiction deals with Indias elite responding to the crises engendered
by political change.
She is awarded the Sahitya academy award for English in 1986, for her novel
Rich Like Us (1985). Her novel Rich Like Us is about Sonali the daughter of Marathi
and Kashmir. Sonali the centre character differs from the stereotypes of Indian
womanhood found in fiction. She is very brilliant IAS officer. She goes to oxford to
escape the Indian world of arranged marriage. Sahgal has a limited world of feminist
ideas. She does a close and sensitive study of her elite women characters her
protagonists refuse to remain fettered to their subordinate roles and defy traditional
independence to this group belong writers like Kamala Markandaya, Anita Desai,
Shashi Deshpande, Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, Nergis Dalal, Shobha De and Bharathi
Mukherjee all being well equipped both emotionally and intellectually to treat the
situation appropriately.
its education and culture in North Karnataka. She is the second daughter of famous
Kannada dramatist and writer Adya Rangacharya (Sriranga). At the age of fifteen she
gained a degree in Law. She secured her M.A in English from the University of
Mysore. When, she is living in Mumbai she did a course on Journalism at the
9
Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan and worked for a couple of months as a Journalist for the
magazine Onlooker.
Deshpande is the author of nine novels and number of short stories, the best
novels which are The Dark Holds No Terrors, That Long Silence, Small Remedies
which won the Sahitya Akademi award. She started writing childrens stories for her
two young sons. Her novels are Roots and Shadows, The Dark Holds No Terrors
(1980), If I Die Today (1982), Come Up and Be Dead (1983), That Long Silence
(1989), The Binding Vine (2002), A Matter of Time (2000), Moving On (2004), and In
the Country of Deceit (2008) are the works of fiction that she has contributed to the
domain of Indian English Literature. She published her first collection of short stories
in 1978.
Apart from a number of short Stories and nine novels Shashi Deshpande has
written four books for children: A Summer Adventure, The Hidden Treasure, The Only
Witnessand The Narayanpur Incident. A volume entitled writing from the margin and
other Essays contains several of her perceptive essays. She has also written the screen
play for the Hindi features film Drishti. She is honoured with Padmashri award in
The novels of Shashi Despande sensitively portray the miserable plight of the
contemporary middle class, urban Indian women. In all her novels she focuses in
detail on the working of the psyche of her women characters, who plunge into periods
leads to a stage of self introspection and later self discovery which evinces a fresh
perception of life Shantha on the general lot of women thus. She is a creature who as a
child is sold to the strangers for a bridal price, or when she grows up serves as a
10
supplier of dowry for her husbands family or who as window in a final act of
Sita-Savitri as an immortal.
concentrates on career women and their problems. They face outside the threshold of
women of different ages and has reflected their psyche. Likewise the woman as a
young girl tries to shed off the shackles of parental control as a daughter leading to
her marriage where, she finds that her role as wife or as mother Erlave her in another
framework. Then she ventures out of the house to pursue a career perhaps become
her defense strategies begin to function and she manages to overcome the crisis with
of regional cultures those of the states of Maharashtra and Karnataka. Her search for
slowly subverts the binaries and transcends to a dimension where the woman is
Deshpande has been labeled a feminist because of her concern with women
characters and the situations in which they find themselves. She believes that she
simply writes about what she sees around her and that her ideas follow naturally. Her
work has helped to break the silence on some womens issues which were not
Roots and Shadows her first novel depicts the agony and suffocation
experiences by the protagonist Indu in a male dominated and tradition bound society.
The Dark Holds No Terrors her second novel is all about male ego where in the male
refuses to play a second fiddle role in marriage. That Long Silence her third novel is
about self doubts and dears which Jaya undergoes till she affirms herself. The Binding
Vine her fourth novel deals with the personal tragedy of the protagonist Urmi to focus
attention on victim like Kalpana and Mira victims of mans lust and womans
helplessness.
Her protagonists Sarita in The Dark Holds No Terrors, Indu in Roots and
Shadows and Jaya in That Long Silence from inner conflict, confusion and
indecisions, fail to express themselves. Jaya does not like the role assigned to a
woman in the old system. She is fed up with the daily work of a housewife. But Jaya
is not as bold as Sarita in The Dark Holds No Terrors who defies her mother to
become a doctor, defies her caste to marry outside and violates social norms to liaison
Deshpande connects to the women in her stories in tune with her own life she
says there are three things in her life that shaped her as a woman. Her father is a
writer the fact that she is educated in English and she is a woman. It allows her to
understand the womans mind and the societys reaction to the Second sex in the
Her writing is clearly a part of Indian Literature and emerges from her
rootedness in middle class Indian Society. She uses simple language to describe
simple life especially of the Indian women. She wrote of simple day to day Indian
middle class life. Saptgiri and Dedar in That Long Silence, Bangalore in A Matter of
12
Time, ancestral village in The Dark Holds No Terrors and A Matter of Time these are
just not geographical locations. Rather they are places from where her women
characters come they are ordinary people, Teachers, Lawyers, Doctors, Clerks.
Her female characters she presents portrayal of womans guest for identity in
the patriarchal world. Shashi Deshpandes heroines are courageous enough to revolt
against the attempts of men to marginalize them as is revealed in her novels through
her female characters like Saru in The Dark Holds No Terrors, Jaya in That Long
Silence, Indu in Roots and Shadows and Urmi in The Binding Vine.
Shashi Deshpande holds great worth as an Indian English women novelist. She
is the only Indian author to have made bold attempts at giving a voice to the
feminist.
in the shackles of old tradition the novel deals with the triumph and tragedy of a house
and family. It is a feminist novel in the sense that it deals with Indus struggle to
liberate herself from rotten tradition, her attempt not only at self-assertion but also at
That Long Silence the third novel is about Jaya who despite having played the
role of a wife and mother to prediction finds herself lonely and estranged. The gender
subjects in the novel are traced through their class and gender matrix.
The Binding Vine her fourth novel deals with the personal tragedy of the
protagonist Urmi to focus attention on victims like Kalpana and Mira. Urmila dreams
13
societys attention to the plight of the rape victim and is determined to get Miras
poem published. The Binding Vine is a refreshing change from the earlier novels of
Deshpande.
Small Remedies her latest novel is about Savitribai Indorekar the aging
Doyenne of Hindustani music who avoids marriage and a home to pursue her genius.
A deep analysis of her novels leaves no doubt about her genuine concern for women
caught between tradition and modernity. Her protagonist search for their identity
Her first novel The Dark Holds No Terrors portrays the protagonist Sarita in
relationship to her parents, to her younger brother, to her husband and her children. Its
about the traumatic experience, great humiliation and neglect as a child after marriage
as a wife. It is the pathetic story of Saru and her struggle. Deshpande shows that Saru
gets an inferior treatment at the hands of her mother and her husband on account of
Chapter II
Quest for identity is the main theme of the novel. In all her novels are
concerned with a womans search for her identity, an exploration into the female
encounters in her life. The crisis of identity is because of the darkness that persists in
ones mind. One must come out of this terror and face the problems boldly with
courage.
Through her novels, Shashi Deshpande has performed her role as a protagonist
of the oppressed woman. She feels that a woman not only in India but also in other
countries, is not treated part with man in any sphere of human activity. Deshpande is
grimly aware of plight and the predicament of Indian woman. A careful study of her
novels evinces that her women protagonists have been drawn from the middle class
society. Most of them are sensitive intelligent educated and carrier oriented. Their
pain and torture have been highlighted through the roles of the women protagonist,
Indu, Saru, Urmila and Sumi who find themselves trapped in the roles assigned to
them by the society. They have been portrayed as struggling against social taboos and
In her novel, The Dark Holds No Terrors, Shashi Deshpande post-mortems the
fractured psyche of the protagonist, Sarita. The novel reveals the quest of an
ambitious, anxious and highly self-willed girl. The novel tells the story of a marriage
college. She is a successful doctor. She treats the patients in the daytime but, at night,
lives as a terrified and trapped animal at the hands of her husband. In the end, she
15
learns that her life is her own which she will have to shape on her own. Terror is not
enforced from outside rather it comes from within. It portrays the psychological
problems that a career oriented woman encounters in her life. The crisis of identity is
because of the darkness that persists in ones mind. One must come out of this terror
Man and woman are complementary to each other and one is never a whole
without the other. Both are considered as two wheels, balancing each other. Neither of
them can claim any kind of superiority over the other. Woman is neither biologically
nor intellectually inferior to man but, in human civilization, she is valued inferior to
man. She has been given the secondary status in the society. Though woman possess
the power of endurance, affinity, love and foresight, which contributes to the
happiness of others, yet man has always looked down upon her as a weaker sex, as his
property and as an object of pleasure. She is not recognized as a human being and has
no identity of her own. Even she is known by the name of her husband, son or father.
The quest for identity has become a dominant theme in literature since the rise
and development of feminism, which studies various problems, related to women and
the women and for the women. It is a protest, started by women of the west, for equal
Submission of the wife is ensured with the help of socialization that begins in
early childhood and extends well into adolescence and adulthood. Girl children are
trained to think, speak, dress and behave in such a way as to give preference to the
males around them and stereotypes of mythical figures like Sita, Savitri, Draupadi and
Gandhari are given to them to emulate. But, when they grow and get educated, their
16
new sense of identity and equality clash with the internalized sense of submission and
docility and consequently, when they get married later, their marriages threaten to fall
between patriarchy and imperialism subject constitution and object formation. The
figure of woman disappears, not into a positive nothingness, but into a violent
shuttling which is the displaced figuration of the third world woman caught between
tradition and modernization. It is this tension between tradition and modernity that
determined ideas of marriage and wifehood on Indian women. Indu, Saru and Jaya all
desperately try to fit themselves to the prescribed image before they learn to question
the image itself. Our society visualizes women as mothers, daughters, sisters and
wives who care for other never as individuals. The woman accepts this because the
models given her to emulate are mythological women like Sita, Draupadi and
Gandhari who never framed a question regarding their individuality. The protagonist
of The Dark Holds No Terrors can be taken as the role model for the new woman
because it was she who defied and over threw the male patriarchal system represented
by her mother and her husband. The novel does not confine itself to the feminist
problems but Deshpande probes the universally relevant problems which come in
between man-woman relationships. The novel tells the story of a marriage on the
rocks. Sarita is married to Manohar who is an English teacher in a small college. She
is a successful doctor. She treats the patients in the daytime but, at night, lives as a
When the novel opens we find that Saru, the central character of the novel
comes back to her parental home. When she enters home, flashback begins. The true
substance of the novel lies in the mental processes that Saru goes through during
17
apparently eventless existence at her fathers place. She thinks she analyses all the
dark corners of her soul. She introspect judges life and relationships. We find her true
self while she is unweaving her mind through memories and dreams. The novel to a
certain extent resembles Canadian novel entitled surfacing by Margaret Atwood. The
unnamed female protagonist has been hart and deceived by her previous her she got
her pregnancy terminated after the suggestion of her love and later on these previous
wounds, the dark memory started surfacing on her conscious mind and she became
rebellious. The novel The Dark Holds No Terrors exhibits not only the callous mother,
Saru has in her life intolerant nagging mother, nonchalant father , sadist husband,
Society treats the male offspring as an ultimate panacea to all problems but the
girl child is an unwanted burden as she cannot fulfill the parental needs or ungratified
ambitious the given social calculus. The plenitude, warmth and importance given to a
male child are denied to the girl and this makes her either depressed or rebellious.
Saru is victimized and persecuted by her own mother and husband. Her mother could
never forgive her daughter for being alive after her brother had drowned and Saru
could never forget the traumatizing effect of her mothers hysterical outburst.
wife who is made conscious of her gender as a child and whose loveless relationship
with her parents and strained relations with her husband lead to her agonizing search
for herself. The novel opens with Sarus return to her parents house fifteen years after
she left home with a vow never to return. Her relations with her husband become
unbearably strained and she returns for some solace. Here she gets a chance to think
over her relationship with her husband, her children, her parents and her dead brother
Dhruva.
18
Sarus relationship with her brother has been given special presentation. she is
ignored in favor of her brother Dhruva no parental love is showered on her and she is
not giving any importance. Her brothers birthdays are celebrated with much fanfare
and performance of religious rites; where as her birthdays are not even acknowledged.
She even feels that her birth is a horrible experience for her mother as she later recalls
her mother telling her that it had rained heavily the day she is born and it is terrible for
her mother. It seemed to Saru that it is her birth that is terrible for her and not the
rains. She recalls the joyous excitement in the house on the occasion of his naming
ceremony. The idea, that she is a liability to her parents in deeply implanted in her
mind as a child.
Her mothers adoration of her son at her daughters cost is the rallying point
for the novelist to bring her feminist ideas together. The preference for boys over girls
can be openly witnessed in most Indian homes and is inextricably linked to the Indian
psyche sons bring in dowry could be one reason, but the Indian society steeped in
tradition and superstition considers the birth of a son as auspicious as he carries on the
family lineage. The first though that rose is Sarus mind at hearing about her mothers
death is who lit the pyre? She had no son to do that for her Dhruva had been seven
The mother is very attached to her son. Her attitude is a typical one
After all, he is male child and therefore one who will propagate the family
lineage. In another sense, also, the male child is considered more important
than a girl, because he is qualified to give Agni to his dead parents. The
Her mother constantly reminds her that she should not go out in the sun as it
would worsen her already dark complexion Saru recalls her conversation with her
mother. Saru's mother favours to her brother, Dhruva. At him, Saru is insecure and
lonely. Saru's mother believes that a girl is a liability and a boy an asset. Saru
remembers how her mother had installed in her a negative self image: I was an ugly
girl. At least, my mother told me so. I can remember her eyeing me dispassionately
saying. 'You will never be good looking. You are dark for that.(DHNT 63)
This sort of blatant discrimination between Saru and her brother leads to a
sense of insecurity and hatred towards her parents, especially mother, and her
deters the balance beauty of Sarus life. She develops inferiority complex in herself
which makes her too vulnerable and insecure in her relationships with others. She
always feels insecure in her fathers house. She wants to be accepted, loved &
cherished by someone because she always had been spurned and rebuffed by her
mother. She finds love in her relationship with Manohar who was an English teacher
in a small college. In spite of her parents disapproval, She revolts against the parents
and runs away from home to get married to a person of her choice. She marries
Manohar. Sarita is brought up in a traditional atmosphere but the education, that she
receives, makes her a changed person with a rebellious attitude. She was quite
satisfied with her choice. She feels herself lucky for getting Manohar as her husband.
The life was going smooth but it takes a turn when her neighbors become aware of her
professional identity. The respect she gets, as a doctor, disturbs the traditional
equilibrium of the superior husband and inferior wife. Her superior economic
position, of a reputed lady doctor in the society, is not accepted by Manohar. He gets
20
jealous of her popularity. He cant tolerate that his wife enjoys better social prestige
The human personality has an infinite capacity for growth. And so the
esteem with which I was surrounded made me inches taller. But perhaps,
the same thing that made me inches taller, made him inches shorter. He
had been the youngman and I his bride. Now I was the lady doctor and he
typical of most Indian mothers and a common enough phenomenon in the Indian
context. The novel has an echo of The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot. Here the
female protagonist Maggie Gulliver is looked down upon by her mother while her
The turning point in her life is the accidental death of her brother by drowning.
All her life she is haunted by the memories of her mother accusing her of intentionally
letting Dhruva dies by drowning. She to on her part has a guilty conscience as she
considers herself responsible for having remained a mute spectator to her brothers
death by drowing. She never refutes the charge leveled against her by her mother. As
G.Dominic Savio observes; Dhruvas demise had always been her subconscious
desire and there is a very thin demarcation between her wish and its fulfillment.
Shashi Deshpande thus reveals the social aspect of keen sibling jealousy born of a
After her brothers death her lot deteriorated from bad to worse. Irrespective of
discrimination in the Indian society setup. Life becomes more desperate to Saru after
Dhruva's death. There is no celebration at home, her much awaited birthday passes off
in silence both at school and at home. Right from the beginning Saru is made to
understand that she is inferior to her brother. Saru feels that men enjoy more liberty
and freedom in Indian society. When a mother differentiates between her own
children for whom she has equally suffered and taken equal pains. This feeling of
insecurity makes a life of a girl more miserable. The ambiguity of Sarus relationship
with her mother is not taken into consideration by many critics who have taken up this
novel for interpretation. Most of the readings of this novel seem to be driven by the
the bondage created by the parental family. The simple need to be independent
eventually becomes a demand of the inflated ego and takes shape as the love for
power over others. She resents the role of a wife with the hope that her new role will
This kind of criticism on the one hand holds such tradition bound notions as
one should be good to the mother and on the other, the western individualistic notion
of freedom. The infectivity to the question of difference the notion that the Indian
woman can be easily defined and identified is accordance with the dominant
Sarus mother could be no exception to this and she loses interest in life after
her sons death. She puts the blame for her own wretched lot squarely on Sarus
shoulders. She snatches every opportunity to reproach her and takes no interest in
education, career or future. Her feeling of being unwanted is so acute that she begins
to hate her own existence as a girl or woman. On attaining puberty she says
scornfully, If you are a woman, I dont want to be one (DHNT 62). The treatment
that is meted out to her during her monthly ordeals is inhuman. She is treated like an
untouchable, segregated from the other members of the family and made to sleep on a
straw mat with a cup and plate exclusively meant for her to be served in from a
distance .She is engulfed with a sense of shame and prays in desperation for a miracle
Thus, unloved and unwanted, she develops hatred towards the traditional
practices during her impressionable years. Her hatred towards her mother is so acute
that she becomes rebellious just to hurt her. She leaves her parental home to start her
Saru always prefers to take the road less travelled. She doesn't like women
friend's who mould themselves into the traditional stereotypes and remain the silent,
nameless waiter at the dining table. On the contrary she has great respect for the
dignified, self reliant teacher-friend Nalu, who despises all compromises and remains
mother. This hatred drives her to leave home for Bombay to seek medicine as a
career. In the medical college she falls in love with a college mate and marries him
23
against her parent wishes. Her orthodox mother was dead against her daughters
Her marital life goes through many ups and downs. Manohar, her husband, is
the master of the family before she got recognition as a doctor. Earlier she is known
as the wife of Manohar but now after the explosion in the factory people recognize
Manohar as the doctor's husband. The explosion provides her an opportunity to prove
her worth and assert herself, though unconsciously. But this shatters their family life.
Saru considers herself is the luckiest woman on earth, as the initial years of
her marriage are sheer bliss. Manu is her savior and the romantic hero who rescues
Saru-a damsel in distress. She marries to secure the lost love in her parental home and
Her dingy one-room apartment with the corridors smelling of urine, the rooms
with their dark sealed in odours, is a heaven on earth for her. But soon all this proves
to be a mere mirage for her. Soon she realizes that happiness is illusory. Saru
remembers how a particular incident becomes a turning point in their blissful marital
relationship. One night she returns home late in her bloodstained coat as she helped
out the victims in a fire accident in a factor nearby. The neighborhood thus comes to
know about her identity, and she gains recognition. People would come to her for
medical help and other related matters. In the beginning Saru could come to her for
medical help and other related matters. In the beginning Saru could not realize the
change that had come in Manu. Her success as a well known and reputed doctor
becomes the cause of her strained marital relations with Manu. In a retrospective
24
mood she says much later: He had been the young man and I his bride. Now I was
when people greet and pay attention to Saru. Beside she is unable to spare time
enough for many and children. Manu and Saru want to move out to some other place
for their own reasons. While Manu feels humiliated and embarrassed, Saru is no
longer happy in that cramped and stinking apartment and wants to move into
something more decent. Earlier she was happy and contented to live on Manus salary
Manu does not love her as he used to earlier. Saru begins to hate this man
woman relationship which is based on need and attraction and not love. She scorns
the word Love now. She realizes there was no such thing between man and woman.
attachment towards husband and children. The most solemn duties towards them
remain unattended to. The children are denied due love and care as she gets late in the
evenings.
While her social and financial status rises gradually, there is an inverse decline
in her conjugal relationship. Her relations with Manu would have somehow moved
on smoothly had she remained contented with treating people in the neighborhood.
But her ambition to move higher in life, by her career through Boozie, who is a
handsome and efficient doctor. He is flirtatious in nature and Saru has no strong
dislike towards flirts. Their relation reaches a stage when Boozie helps her financially
to set up her own practice in a posh area. Saru, blind in ambition, is unscrupulous in
her relationship with Boozie and console herself by treating it as a mere teacher-
25
student relation. Both had their own vested interests in sustaining such a relation.
Boozie openly flaunts his relationship with Saru to hide his homosexual nature and
Saru wanted to exploit him through her feminine wiles to achieve her much coveted
about Saru-Boozie relationship, but this gives rise to a misconception in Manu's mind.
But she had such an unwilling towards Manu that she does nothing to make upset
The womans emancipation is not in repudiating the claims of her family, but
in drawing upon untapped inner reserves of strength. The wife, in the end is therefore
not a rebel but a redeemed wife one who has broken the long silence, one who is no
longer afraid of the dark. She is a wife reconciled as woman and an individual a
marked contrast to the older generation of woman around her with their
Saru is not rebellious daughter who is searching for herself identity for her
freedom, not as an agoist who cannot understand the inferiority complex of her
husband, not as the guilty sister who is responsible for the death of her brother, not as
a daughter who is never forgiven by the mother, not as a traveler who goes to a
spiritual quest that ends in resolutions, but as a woman who possesses White, soft
But Saru's rise in social and financial status in contrast to Manu's status of an
the claims of most feminists, she does not achieve fulfillment in life.
26
Certain incidents aggravate the already strained relation between the two to
the extent that in the privacy of their room at night he doesn't behave like a husband,
but a rapist. In an interview with Saru when the interviewing girl happens to ask
Manu innocently: How does it feel when your wife earns only the butter but most of
the bread as well? (DHNT 204). The three Saru, Manu, and the girl merely laughed it
off as if it were nothing. This particular incident is very humiliating to him and he
feels helpless and effeminate. To gain his masculinity he gives vent to his feelings
through his beastly sexual assault on Saru. Although he is a cheerful normal human
being and a loving husband during day, he turns into a rapist, to assert his manhood.
In yet another incident she undergoes this nightmarish experience. Prior to going on a
vacation to Ooty while shopping Manu and Saru happen to meet the former's college
mate and his wife. During the talk Manu tells his colleague that they were going to
Ooty. When his colleagues expresses his inability and bad luck in affording such a
vacation, the colleague's wife replies that he also could have afforded it had he
married a doctor.
A humiliated Manu once again victimizes Saru. She expresses her helplessness
to her father: I couldn't fight back. I couldn't shout or cut, I was so afraid the children
in the next room would hear. I could do nothing. I can never do anything. I just
endure (DHNT 204). Although she has achieved economic independence, her plight
is miserable, as she has to perform double duties. Besides practicing medicine she has
to fulfill the assigned job of a housewife. She expresses her desire to leave her
medical practice but Manu dissuades her from doing so, as their standard of living
During her youth Sarita is an aware of the growing changes in her body and its
demands.
27
Man and woman, male and female, how exciting that game had seemed.
And that she could play that game as well had seemed! And, that she
could play that game as well had seemed even more incredibly exciting.
Youre a woman now,' they had told her when she began menstruating. But
she did not feel then that it made her any different. She was the same
Saru, with the burden of that curse added on to her like an appendage
The emotions of love and the recognition of the demands of sexuality should
be always within the social institution of marriage. Hence a woman should and must
occupy. Some Social space to be identify as a wife, mother, daughter and a sister. She
has to be in the guardian of her father, husband and son. Hence, the woman in Indian
is simply been trapped in the Brahminic world view that she cannot have an
independent existence Sarita has been fed with all these norms; her mother accused
her of her brother Dhurvas death. Why didnt you die? Why are you alive and hes
dead? (DHNT 34-35). To a mother a boy is all the more important but not a girl. Her
father too takes least interest in her studies or development; he shows no love anger or
My brother died because I heedlessly turned my back on him. My mother died alone
(DHNT 220).
28
Although she returns to her parents' place in a detached frame of mind, she
feels strange despite the fact that nothing had changed in the house, not even the
seven pairs of large stone slabs leading to the front door on which she had played
hopscotch as a child. Her father also sounds strange as he talked like an unwilling host
to her as if she is an unwelcome guest. She is in grave need of sympathy but he does
nothing to console her. This reminds her of the fate of a sister of her friend's who had
come home after her disastrous marriage. She remembers how she received care and
sympathy from her parents. Because her marriage had been an arranged one, the
parents too were party to her misfortune. Since Saru is not an arranged one, she makes
herself solely responsible for her disastrous marriage and is guilty conscious. She is
totally confused and feels that she has done great injustice towards her brother,
being asked by her friend Nalu to talk on medicine as a profession for women, to a
Have you noticed that the wife always walks a few steps behind her
truth. A wife must always be a few feet behind her husband. If hes an MA,
you should be a BA. If he is 5'4" tall you shouldnt be more than 53 tall. If
he is earning five hundred rupees, you should never earn more than four
hundred and ninety, if you want a happy marriage. Don't ever try to
can be traumatic, disastrous. And I assure you, it is not worth it. He'll
suffer. You'll duffer and do will the children. Women's magazines will tell
take care that it's unequal in favour of your husband. If the scales tilt in
Neither God nor even her parents can help Sarita. She had married the one
time promising and charismatic young poet against her parents wish. In her many acts
of violation of societal norms, Sarita defines her parents in stating medicine and
becoming a doctor, defines them to marry Manohar and then breaks away from domes
facility as she cannot talk his sadism any more, she escapes from his nightmarish
brutality man other in on her every night when he feels that his wife has overtaken
him professionally and financially. She goes to her fathers home without love and
beyond a life of fulfilling domesticity and wants the old self again.
In the beginning Fulfillment and happiness came not through love alone but
sex. And for me sex was now a dirty word (DHNT133). It had become dirty because
of Manohars ego. All her runner sentiments, sensitivities and herself identity had
been trampled and crushed by his ago. Union with Manohar had turned to slavery of if
everything in a girls life it seemed is shaped to that simple purpose of pleasing male
endless night of pleasing male endless nights of torture make her put in crudely.
Saritas superior economic position of a reputed lady doctor in the society is not
accepted by Manohar continues in hurting her the more she becomes like a patient
having carcinomas dying inch by inch bit by bit and at last waiting for death.
30
The pain and shame she undergoes a deep anguish kill the creativity and
imagination in transforming the person into something different. Her pain her
suffering cannot be uttered in public but she feels her body us a burden which her
husband would not feel even if he had thought that body many pains. The word pain
internalization of social guilt. Sarita feels that she is raped not only physically but also
and mentally.
The hurting hands, the savage teeth, the monstrous assault of a horribly
familiar body. And above me a face I could not recognize. Total non
began to struggle. But my body, hurt and painful, could do nothing against the
forms of pain, pain of loss, pain of physical suffering and pain of mental traumas. It is
not only the cruelty of her husband that fills her with grief but her brother death and
her dejected life pain and suffering of her mother and herself. The circles of pain that
surround a woman may not possibly redeem her. But pain ultimately becomes a
means of self discovery that enables Sarita to take the decisive step of leaving her
house children and her husband. In order to become free individual land to have an
identity and with a purpose in life she quits her house on hearing through a friend
about her mothers death a month ago Saru wants to visit her fathers house from
where she had left as a young woman she returns back after a gap of fifteen years. She
returns a well established doctor and a mother of two children more out of an urge to
escape from the hell of life. She is passing through she is confessed helpless dull
31
almost thoughtless as a recluse. She comes to her parental house to see her sense of
belonging to the world but the some eludes her Sarita is waiting outside her old house,
like the old friend of Lord Krishna Sudama in rugs waiting outside the palace gets of
Lord krishna and his queen Rukmani. But Sarita, unlike Sudama has a suit case full of
clots full of humility. She gets a cold reception at her father house at times. Thus back
in her old home and with the gradually realized comforting presence of Madhu and
her father around her whose first significant nurturing act of Sarita is to ensure a
hastily made cradle for her to sleep in the old puja room. She expects a loss of
sympathy from her father after having become a helpless victim of her senseless
choice of a love marriage. She moans It is my fault again. If mine had been an
arranged marriage if I had left it to them to arrange my life would we have left me like
traumatic scene of her early childhood when she is only four or five years old. Her
mother had caught her firmly to comb her hair and young. Sarita facing the window
was happy seeing the pony dancing on the green ground near their house.The pony
was jumping running with all the awkward energy of over enthusiasm, clumsy and
awkward though it seemed to be its movement and the gently sloping green ground
Sarita as a young girl is enchanted by this right because the pony is free
dancing and jumping though her mother turns here away from this sight cruelly and
hurtfully she cannot prevent her daughter from seeing an understand. Sarita had never
been allowed to be free and spontaneous. But the only positive aspect her is that
strength of memory to recalls these crucial losses her in her younger days. This helps
her father house she years for security and emotional attachments, she wants her
father to support her against Manu brutality. She memorizes these thoughts words and
sentence to tell her father buy when the real moment comes she blurts out and very
Her father a simple man fails to understand the words like sadism love cruelty
etc. Sarita takes every possible steps to explain her problems and says that she wants
to talk to him not as a daughter, but as a woman to man. Her father expects that they
should talk like matured persons. Because, he says that this kind of relation Woman
and Man of intimacy or sharing of feelings or communicating with each other had
never taken place between him and his wife. He says Silence had become a habit
focus (DHNT 199). As he starts enduring Saru about the events, very slowly his
unnatural composure and indifference disappear. Saru pours her heart out with all
details about the events very slowly his unnatural composure and indifference
disappear. Saru Pours her heart out with all details about Manus brutality and
expresses her helplessness. She wholeheartedly expects moral support from her father
Saritas father without any response leaves her and goes away she feels quitter
isolated and becomes sad, she wants to tell her father that Baba, Im unhappy help
me baba Im in trouble tell me what to do (DHNT 44). Her feelings never get
articulated at times she regrets for having come to her parents house for she
remembers her children her parents and her patients. Actually her visit to her fathers
house is a kind of escape from the sadist husband and loveless marriage. It is again a
kind of solace from her hectic routine to her live with her father and Madhu is a relief
for no demands is made to her. The whole day in her own desires and comforts she
She had lived as a child to Saru the idea of men going to work children going
to school and women staying at home to work clean scrub and sweep appealed as she
finds a supreme harmony in these tasks done by whom who stay at home. This is a
kind of contentment in her new routine life, makes her feel that she has a totally new
life and now as she calls herself as a totally changed person and nothing old Saru is
left. At her felinity she stops thinking about herself as a women. The aspect in doctor
she is more often seen than that of the wife and the mother in her. Her neighborhood
woman now visits her for their physical health. Mostly there simple woman keep
more of their ailments everything as a secret. Sarita thinks that Their very
womanhood a source of deep shame to them stupid silly martyrs she thought, idiotic
heroines. Going on with their tasks, and destroying themselves in the bargain, for
Shashi Deshpande contrasts Saru's life with the lives of her two school
friends- Sunita and Nalu. Sunita leaves no effort to pose as a happily married woman.
All the while she talks about her intimacy with her husband as if she are a non-entity
without him, which only invokes pity in the eyes of the reader and hatred of her two
friends. Nalu also questions her as to why she let her husband change her name from
and hates her for her submissive attitude of sattisfying every whim of his.
On the other hand is Nalu, a spinster who is a teacher and lives with her
brother and his family. Saru contrasts Sunita with the Nalu of her college days who
was full of enthusiasm. But now bitterness has crept into her, and Saru does not blame
her bitterness on her spinsterhood. Saru feels that it would be wrong to say that Nalu
is bitter because she never married, never bore a child. But that would be as stupid as
calling me fulfilled because I got married and I have borne two children
34
(DHNT124). Shashi Deshpande contrasts the lives of Saru, Sunita and Nalu anf shows
that a wife, a mother and a spinster had their own share of joys and sorrows, and it is
almost difficult to conclude as to who is the more happier or the more fulfilled. While
the married women are reported to be dissatisfied with their marriage, the unmarried
A mature Saru now shuns extremes and takes a practical view of the
circumstances. She is neither the typical Western liberated woman not an orthodox
Indian one. Shashi Deshpande does not let herself get overwhelmed by the Western
identity, she does not advocate separation from the spouse but a tactful assertion of
Chapter 3
Conclusion
general life women like male counters want to liberation in all its approaches and
recognition. They struggle for eqality for women rights historically and politically.
Shashi Deshpande has presented in her novels modern Indian women's search for
these definition about the self and society and the relationship that are the central to
women. Shashi Deshpande's novel deals with the theme of quest for a female identity.
a disturbed adolescence. The Indian women has for years been a silent sufferer. While
she has played different roles as a wife, mother, sister and daughter. She has never
been able to claim her own individually. Shashi Deshpande's novels deal with the
women belonging to Indian middle class. She deals with the inner world of the Indian
To the maximum extent Sarita's problems are her own creations. She is a self
made person and her ego, and innate love for power create a number of problems.
Right from her early days we find her opposing traditional codes and marry outside
her community. She even defines social conventions by using Boozie to advance her
career, economic independence became a goal and every move of her life is towards
the realization of that goal. Sarita becomes a reputed and family doctor, she becomes
proud of her social status and her husband becomes insecure. She wants to outshine
other, not through dedicated service but through economic criteria. Manohar's place in
her life becomes diminished. Sarita's love for power is the undercurrent of her life.
Her relation with her mother and husband analyzed as a rival in the game of power, as
36
an authority which had posed a threat to her individuality and self will. Similarly, she
sees in her husband is the element of domination. Through she can be dominated yet
hold something of her reserve. Shashi Deshpande deals with the universally relevant
problems, which encounters in man- woman relationships. Sarita realize that everyone
Saru's self assertion and confrontation with reality but, not escape from it.
Saru gathers strength not to surrender, escape from the problems or to accept at
defeat. She rather accepts the challenge as to prove herself a good daughter, a good
wife, a good mother, a good doctor and a good human being from her own female
viewpoint. She is trying to provide an alternative. Sarita's, who is not prepared to face
her husband at one stage, decides to leave her father and go away somewhere.
She is her own refuge, she never blames others. She has to face her husband
fearlessly. The fear of darkness is faded from her mind. Deshpande makes it clear that
a woman should not be dependent on others. She should make herself determined,
capable enough of standing trials in life alone. The modern woman in this
multifaceted world is more than a mother, sister and a daughter. She is an individual,
capable of playing any role with a strong will power. Saru undergoes the arduous
journey into her and learn to free herself of guilt, shame and humiliation.
inflicted upon women have given birth to collective consciousness of the India
women. The women in Shashi Deshpande's novels portray the struggle against the
patriarchal normal of the society. One half of the community can't be neglected in this
modern world. The chief concern of Shashi Deshpande's novels is the sensitive
37
portrayal of women's quest for identity their own solution to the problems created by
the world.
Saru's journey to her parental home can also be seen as a feminist journey in
feminist battle against her mother to break free. She remembers that in that battle her
father had stood by her. After getting a first division in her intermediate, she had made
up her mind to join the medical college. But she knew that her mother would never
agree with her. She said that they could not afford to waste so much money on her
because they have to get her married also. Between marriage and education she
chooses the later. Her first victory against her mother takes her further away from the
matriarch. When she falls in love with Manohar, a flamboyant Literature student, she
takes it as an opportunity to prove herself against her mother. She enjoys shocking her
When she settles with Manu and starts her medical practice, she thinks that
she is a liberated woman. She has rejected her mother's notions of marriage as the
destination and destiny of a woman. She has proved her independence. Later when
she sets up her own practice and becomes rich and famous as a lady doctor, she
should have been at peace with herself. But it is not to be. When her loving husband
turns a monster in the night because he is unable to accept her success, dhe realizes
the vulnerability of being a woman. Though she is emancipated, she is still not really
free or liberated. She had thought that she would find her identity away from the
confines of home. But now lost in the quagmire of surrender, submission and
savagery, she sees her own feminine self fragmented and splintered around her. Once
sitting in her consulting room, she cuts a piece of paper into bits to the horror of the
38
nurse, and says to herself that they are the bits of her mind falling on the ground. The
despite being emancipated, when locked in an unequal relationship with a man, the
Breaking free from these needs immense courage, resilience and willingness
for a brutal self-criticism. When Saru arrives at her father's home, she is in this second
final stage of her feminist struggle for freedom and individuation. Sitting quietly, she
goes through the entire gamut of her tumultuous experiences spanning the different
stages of her life from early childhood, adolescence and youth to maturity. She thinks
The novel ends with the certainty that how Saru will no longer be a victim of
Manu's frustration. She derives pride in her professional success and decides not to
feel guilt for someone else's failure. Saru realize that the essence of any marriage is
understanding and mutual respect and not subjugation of one by the other. With this
woman and discusses it artistically without crossing the barrier of art. The novel also
transcends feminist constraints and raises issues, which the human beings in general
Saru presents the process of forming a gender identity. In her exit she makes a
distinction between her roles and self. Her gender identity is complete with the final
going back to the inner space. The male-female polarity is kept up and a merger is not
encouraged. Saru is study in conflict. The novelist does not depict her as a woman
surrendering herself before the adverse circumstances. Whenever, her individual self
39
was hurt, she rebelled, she exerted her individuality by getting married with a person
whom her parents did not like. She has shown her husband that she has an
independent self. When she comes back to her parent's home to escape herself from
the monstrous brutalities of her husband, she decides to face the situation. First she
instructs her Baba to open the door if Manu comes and then she herself thinks to open
it.
further enhances their own worthiness as an individual and subsequently utilizing that
So at last to retrieve her own splintered self, Saru turns to the darkness within
herself. She must exorcise the monsters and terrors lurking in the dark. At the end of
the novel she rushes out to attend to one of her patients. She has come out of a
cathartic experience. She has forgiven her mother, her father and her brother. The very
fact that she agrees to meet Manu shows that she is no longer afraid of him. And more
importantly she is able to turn to her profession, in her own interest, not to prove
herself successful and rich but to realize her true and uninhabited free self. After
agonizing trials of errors through progression and regression she moves to self
discovery and strength. Look at the ripeness and maturity reached through her
This novel beautifully records the trauma of sensitive young women who do
not accept anything without reason. Apart from these presenting the clash between
tradition and modernity. This novel records the resentment and frustration of Saru
Work cited
Inheritance." Dowry and Inheritance. Ed. Srirnati Basu. New Delhi: Kali, 2005.
151-170.
Berger, Louis. From Instinct to Identity. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1974.
Parikh, Indira J. Indian Women: An Inner Dialogue. New Delhi: Sage, 1989
Talwar, Sree Rashmi. Woman's Space: The Mosaic World of Marearet Drabble and