Sei sulla pagina 1di 6

from Chernobyl, published in Russia

LIFE AND LETTERS in 1997, a young woman describes


watching her husband, a reghter, die

THE MEMORY KEEPER


from radiation poisoning:
At the morgue they said, Want to see what
well dress him in? I do! They dressed him up in
The oral histories of Russias new Nobel laureate. formal wear, with his service cap. They couldnt
get shoes on him because his feet had swelled up.
BY MASHA GESSEN They had to cut up the formal wear, too, because
they couldnt get it on him, there wasnt a whole
body to put it on. It was allwounds. The last
two days in the hospitalId lift his arm, and
meanwhile the bone is shaking, just sort of dan-
gling, the body has gone away from it. Pieces of
his lungs, of his liver, were coming out of his
mouth. He was choking on his internal organs.
Id wrap my hand in a bandage and put it in his
mouth, take out all that stuff. Its impossible to
talk about. Its impossible to write about. And
even to live through. It was all mine. My love.
They couldnt get a single pair of shoes to fit him.
They buried him barefoot.

Alexievich told me, We live in an


environment of banality. For most peo-
ple, thats enough. But how do you get
through? How do you rip off that coat-
ing of banality? You have to make people
descend into the depths of themselves.
Announcing the award, the Permanent
Secretary of the Swedish Academy, Sara
Danius, credited Alexievich with in-
venting a new literary genre, which she
called a history of emotionsa history
of the soul, if you wish.
Alexievichs books are published all
over the world, but mostly by small
presses. Voices from Chernobyl came
out ten years ago in the United States,
released by Dalkey Archive Press, a small
nonprot publisher. (The translator was
my brother, Keith Gessen.) She has won

P lease bring the lady one green tea,


went the request. She has won
the Nobel Prize. Svetlana Alexievich,
After answering an hours worth of ques-
tionsmost of them about Belarusian
and Russian politicsAlexievich had
awards, including a 2005 National Book
Critics Circle Award and, in 2013, the
Peace Prize of the German Book Trade.
the sixty-seven-year-old winner of this walked for blocks in the cold wind be- But her most recent major prize before
years prize in literature, was at a table fore ducking into the restaurant with a the Nobel was the French Prix Mdi-
for ten in the front of a noisy restau- group of friends and publishers. cis Essai, reserved for writers whose
rant in Berlin, where she held her Nobel This years literature Nobel is the rst fame has yet to match their talent.
press conference, two weekends ago. to be awarded to a writer who works Alexievich, who writes in Russian, is
Alexievich is a little over ve feet tall exclusively with living people. Her books from Belarus, a country of fewer than ten
and stocky; her straight shoulder-length deal with historical crisesthe Second million people, which has been run since
hair is dyed a redder shade of brown World War, the Soviet war in Afghan- 1994 by Alexander Lukashenko, a former
than it once was. The waitress nodded istan, the nuclear disaster at Chernobyl, Soviet Army officer. Belarus has main-
respectfully, motioning toward a stack and the collapse of the Soviet Union tained a close relationship with Russia,
SOURCE: ULF ANDERSEN/GETTY

of books on the table to show that she through the voices of ordinary individ- and is probably the most Soviet of the
understood. Germans were protesting uals. This is oral history stripped down fteen post-Soviet countries, with a
a trade agreement between the United to segments so raw that it can stretch largely state-controlled economy and
States and the European Union, and both credulity and the readers tolerance stringent restrictions on free speech and
the center of the city was closed to traffic. for pain. At the beginning of Voices assembly. For a long time, Alexievichs
books were brought into Belarus from Rus-
You have to make people descend into the depths of themselves, Alexievich says. sia and sold on the black market. In recent
36 THE NEW YORKER, OCTOBER 26, 2015 ILLUSTRATION BY THOMAS FUCHS
years, as Lukashenko has attempted to poetry and plays and screenplays, but
improve relations with the West, her books kept looking, as she puts it, to create a
have been allowed in stores. new text. She drew inspiration from
Alexievich has lived most of her adult her mentor, the Belarusian writer Ales
life in a small apartmenttwo rooms Adamovich, whose genre was oral his-
and a kitchenin a ten-story Soviet-era tory, but she had less patience for au-
apartment block in central Minsk, the thorial intrusions than Adamovich did.
capital. Her parents are dead, and her His best-remembered work, The Book
daughterwho is, in fact, the daugh- of the Siege, written with Daniil Gra-
ter of her late sister, whom she adopted nin, a fellow Soviet-era liberal, is a peo-
when the girl was fourteaches at a ples history of the siege of Leningrad,
trade school in Minsk and is raising her from 1941 to 1944. There is this story
own daughter. A longtime companion of a boy and his mother, who share an
lives in the apartment next door. apartment with a woman who steals,
In recent years, Alexievich has been Alexievich told me. The boy and his
looking for a bigger apartment, but she mother are starving to death. As Alex-
is reluctant to give up the bright light ievich recalled, the boy knows that the
and the view of the Svisloch River, and womans stash includes half a meatball,
hopes to get a place in the same build- and he struggles over whether to take
ing, with windows facing the same di- it. And suddenly there are three pages
rection. The thought of moving lls her of ruminations on the nature of the
with dread. The prize moneya little Russian intelligentsia. The thing I al-
less than a million dollarswill not help, ways say is Dont put yourself next to
she told me, because she cannot dele- the meatball. Youll lose.
gate the renovations: she cannot nd Alexievich wanted to dispense with
anyone in Minsk whose taste matches the authors voice and with the usual
hers. She likes solid shapes, simple lines, chronologies and contexts. She wanted
and no clutter. to approximate the voices she heard in
her childhood, when village women

A lexievich is the rst person to re-


ceive the Nobel for books that are
based entirely on interviews. This has
gathered in the evenings and told sto-
ries about the Second World War. It
was always women, because most of the
led some writers to laud the commit- men had been killed in the war, and the
tee for recognizing a journalist. The few remaining ones were typically passed
headline of a Los Angeles Times piece out drunk. Alexievich was born three
announcing the prize called Alexievich years after the war ended, in Soviet
a reporter, a term she nds almost in- Ukraine, and grew up in Soviet Belarus,
sulting. Ive known since I was ve that where the Nazis had exterminated Jews,
I wanted to be a writer, not a journal- Gypsies, and Slavs, and burned down
ist, she said. In Russian publishing, the entire villages.
line between ction and nonction is When she started gathering material
often blurredher books tend to be for her rst book, she told me, she looked
classied as proza, with literary nov- for women who had stories similar to
elsbut the border between journal- those she remembered from her child-
ism and literature is inviolable. hood and asked them about the things
Her parents were rural schoolteach- I wanted to know. She spoke to women
ers, and she grew up the oldest of three who had been in the military. I had no
children in a family that began in abject interest in how many people they had
poverty and achieved a life that was mod- killed or how; I wanted to know how a
est even by Soviet standards. She applied woman feels. She added, I was young,
to the journalism department of Belar- so they told me stories as older women
usian State University, because it was the do to a younger one. Focussing on
closest thing she could imagine to a writ- women was a wise decision, Alexievich
ing school. A generation earlier, during said: Women tell things in more in-
Stalins reign, her father dropped out of teresting ways. They live with more
the department to serve in the Red Army, feeling. They observe themselves and
and later, after a relative was arrested, their lives. Men are more impressed with
left his career in journalism. action. For them, the sequence of events
She worked at a newspaper, wrote is more important. Womens voices
THE NEW YORKER, OCTOBER 26, 2015 37
predominate in her later work, too. book, most of these narrators had not belling the Soviet military. Called as a
The resulting book, War Has Not been soldiers. Perestroika began in 1985, witness, a soldiers mother said, You
a Womans Face, was published in the year Alexievich became a nationally are saying that I should hate the state
abridged form in 1984, in the Mos- known author. Suddenly, it was possible and the Party. But I am proud of my
cow-based journal Oktyabr, after being to openly question the myths and poli- son! He died an officer in battle. His
rejected by journals in Belarus as pacist cies of the Soviet Union, and Alexievich comrades loved him. I love the country
and naturalistic. It consisted of a series used her newfound fame to make her we used to live in, the U.S.S.R., because
of monologues by female survivors. The way to Afghanistan, where the Soviet my son died for it. And I hate you! I
glorious victory in the Great Patriotic Union had been ghting Afghan rebels dont need your scary truth.
War was the driving myth of Soviet and the mujahideen since 1979. Alexievich prevailed in court, but the
propaganda, and the job of Soviet writ- Boys of Zinc, which featured the trial marked a turning point. The Soviet
ers was to praise Soviet military might voices of Soviet soldiers, their mothers, Union had collapsed in 1991, taking with
and to exalt the Soviet citizen. Instead, and their widows, was published in 1989, it the idea of restructuring (the literal
these women recounted the bloody and the year that the Soviet Union pulled meaning of perestroika) the regime. In
messy tragedies they saw on the ground. out of Afghanistan. (The title of the most of what had been the Soviet Union,
According to Alexievich, Mikhail existing English translation, Zinky reaction set inthe project of question-
Gorbachev read the piece, and then used Boys, is unfortunate; the reference is ing Soviet mythology began to seem ir-
the title in a speech, turning it into a to the sealed caskets in which bodies relevant or, worse, insulting to people
literal Party line. This was the dawn of were shipped back to the U.S.S.R.) Alex- who now felt its loss. In more recent
glasnost, a new openness in literary and ievich had punctured another myth of years, with Vladimir Putin in power, the
intellectual life, and the Soviet people Soviet military might: she showed the official ideology is anti-democratic, na-
were about to focus, briey and pain- soldiers as scared, confused, impover- tionalist, and suspicious of voices like
fully, on the countrys history. War Has ished and humiliated boys. It was my Alexievichs. As her fame increased
Not a Womans Face was published in rst time at a war, she told me. I was abroad, her popularity in Russia faded.
book form in 1985 and eventually sold so shaken by what I was seeingthe On the eve of the Nobel announce-
more than two million copies in Rus- dead, how simply they kill, how then ment, Colta, a highbrow Russian on-
sian, and won Alexievich one of the they drink vodka, sell, laugh, barter. It line culture publication, posted a short
highest Soviet civilian honors, the Lenin was the Soviet period, and they wanted item headed Why You Should Know
Komsomol Prize. An uncensored edi- to get souvenirs for their mothers, but Who Svetlana Alexievich Is. The
tion was not published until after the where did they get the money? They crux of the piece was that Russians
Soviet Union fell, six years later. sold bullets, which, the following day, should care about the writer because
In The Last Witnesses, written after would be used to kill them. foreigners do.
Womans Face but published the same In 1992, some of the subjects of Boys The state-controlled media in Rus-
year, Alexievich spoke to people who had of Zinc, along with an organization sia greeted the Nobel with an outpour-
experienced the Second World War as representing the mothers of soldiers ing of vitriol reminiscent of Soviet news-
children. Unlike the women in her rst killed in the war, sued Alexievich for li- papers reactions to most of the earlier
Russian-language Nobels. Almost in-
variably, the Swedish Academy has rec-
ognized writers who opposed the So-
viet regime. In 1933, the prize went to
the migr writer Ivan Bunin, whom
Literaturnaya Gazeta branded a full-
grown wolf of the counterrevolution.
In 1958, Boris Pasternak was chosen,
after Doctor Zhivago had been smug-
gled to the West with the help of the
C.I.A. He has been rewarded for his
willingness to play the bait on the rusty
shing hook of anti-Soviet propa-
ganda, Literaturnaya Gazeta wrote.
Pasternak was forced to decline the
prize. When Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
won, in 1970, his books were banned
in the Soviet Union. After the rst vol-
ume of The Gulag Archipelago was
published in the West, in 1973, Solzhe-
nitsyn was stripped of his Soviet citi-
zenship and exiled. Joseph Brodsky
had been kicked out of the country, for
The woman describes surviving events
more tragic, difficult, and frightening than
UNFORCED ERROR many readers could imagine: being ex-
iled, living in a mud hut, losing her par-
Once: those long wet Vermont summers. ents and her older sister. But Alexievich
No money, nothing to do but read books, swim answers questions of consequenceDid
in the river with men wearing their jean shorts, this person survive? Did she see her fam-
then play bingo outside the church, celebrating when we won. ily again? Was the truth discovered?
Nothing seemed real to me and it was all very alive. not when they would naturally occur to
It took that long to learn how wrong I was the reader, as a journalist might, but, in
over the rim of the horizon the sun burns. the way of a novelist, when her character
Heidegger: Every man is born as many men addresses them, which may be never. I
and dies as a single one. am a writer who happens to use some
The bones in us still marrowful. tools of journalism, she said.
The moon up there, too, an arctic sorrow. When she began writing down speech,
Im sorry, another Scotch? Some nuts? around 1980, Alexievich realized that
I used to think pressing forward was the point of life, she could not take notes by hand. She
endlessly forward, the snow falling, gaudily falling. needed to preserve the subjects every
I made a mistake. Now I have a will. It says when I die word, including the silences. When peo-
let me live. A white shirt, bare legs, bones beneath. ple talk, it matters how they place words
Numbers on a board. A life can be a lucky streak, next to each other, she said. A tape re-
or a dry spell, or a happenstance. corder in Belarus cost about ve hun-
Yellow raspberries in July sun, bitter plums, curtains in wind. dred rubles, roughly three months sal-
ary, money that she borrowed from
Meghan ORourke Adamovich and several other older writ-
ers. She developed a process that she still
uses: she tapes conversations, has them
insisting on writing poetry instead of mer Soviet Union. Often, she includes transcribed, then writes from transcripts,
working a regular Soviet job, fteen years in her books only the subjects name, longhand, often rehearsing the mono-
before he received the Nobel, in 1987. age, and profession. These are import- logue out loud. A book takes between
This year, in Izvestia, Zakhar ant, she said, because they express the ve and ten years and represents the
Prilepin, one of Russias best-known measure of our time on earth and the voices of anywhere from three hundred
writers, said that Alexievich was not angle at which we view life. Occasion- to ve hundred interview subjects. It
a writer, and that she had been cho- ally, she gives the briefest of descrip- contains about a hundred voices, of which
sen only for her opposition to the tions, meant to conrm the subjects tes- ten to twenty are what she calls pillars,
Kremlinand for not actually being timony, as at the end of this fragment subjects shell interview up to twenty
Russian. We get the picture: Bunin, from a conversation with a fty-seven- times each. Its like painting a portrait,
Solzhenitsyn, Pasternak, Brodsky, he year-old writera survivor of internal she said. You keep going back and mak-
wrote. Alexievichs agent, Galina Durst- exile that killed her parentsincluded ing calls, adding a stroke at a time.
hoff, who lives in Cologne, told me in Second-Hand Time (2013), an oral
that she had accumulated a pile of hate
mail from Russia comparable to the
pile of congratulations from elsewhere
history of the post-Soviet legacy:
I am walking with Vladya. . . . We are
A lexievich told me that Voices from
Chernobyl was her easiest book
to write: nothing like those events had
carrying a feather shawl. . . . Its a beautiful
in the world. The writers blasted the thing for some other world. Its made to happened before, so people had no
Nobel committee for awarding the prize order. Vladya knew how to knit, and we lived culture to protect them. She began
to a Russophobe as well as a Jew and on that. The woman paid us and then said, researching the book almost immedi-
How about I cut some flowers for you? A
a lesbian. (Alexievich is not Jewish ately after the disaster, in 1986, so she
bouquet for us? . . . We had only ever thought
and has never made any public state- about bread, but this person saw that we was able to capture raw feeling on the
ments about her personal life.) were capable of thinking of other things too. page. I realized you have to follow
That meant we werent different from other history, she said. This genre works
people. You were locked in, shut down, and a
A lexievich says the word informa-
tion with the kind of disdain that
a different kind of Belarusian might re-
window was cracked for you. . . . She wasnt
going to pick them or grab them, she was
for epic stories only. Still, the events
serve to get at the hidden heart of a
person. I work to create an image of
going to cut them for us in her own garden.
serve for capitalism. Information, in That was the moment. . . . It may have been time and the person who lived through it.
her view, rules the world and means the key. . . . I was handed the key. . . . It While Alexievich was working on
nothing. I just dont believe that new turned me around. . . . I remember those the book, she came to realize that she
flowers. . . . A large bunch of asters. . . . I al-
facts can help us understand anything, ways plant them at my own dacha now. (We was writing a cycle on what she calls the
she told me, referring to the slew of re- happen to be talking at her dacha. The only Red man, the Soviet person. It began
cent books about Russia and the for- things growing here are flowers and trees.) with the most mythologized event in the
THE NEW YORKER, OCTOBER 26, 2015 39
face with realityit is unknowablebut
you can grab a solid substance, some-
thing. Mostly, she encounters pain. Many
of her subjects talk about carrying pain
or handing over pain, as if that is how
they understand their relationship with
the intervieweras the process of trans-
ferring their pain.

I n the early aughts, Alexievich decided


to leave Belarus, in part to protest the
authoritarian politics of Lukashenko, in
part to save her energies for writing. No
one was chasing after me with a Kalash-
nikov, she said. Unlike some Belarusian
intellectuals who were arrested or dis-
appeared, Alexievich was protected by
her international renown. At the same
time, as a public person, she felt she had
to add her voice to the oppositions weak
chorus. In 2000, she co-founded a hu-
man-rights group called Helsinki XXI.
But I was tired of being on the barri-
Studies show that people who allow art into their lives can substantially cades, she said. I realized I was giving
reduce their dependency on selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. in to the passion of the ght. Thats the
most dangerous thing that can happen
to an artist: revolutions are dangerous,
barricades are. They are intellectual traps.
Russian culture is a culture of the barri-
formation of the Red manthe Great Perestroika was a blessed time, Alex- cade. I needed to free myself of this, and
Patriotic Warand ended with the ievich said: People became more inter- I realized that in the world in which I
collapse of the Soviet Empire. Voices esting. They actually started paying more was living there was no one whose ex-
from Chernobyl was the fourth book in attention to details of the past. They were ample I could followno one who had
the series. The fth and nal volume, a different kind of people. When she freed himself of this. One escape route
Second-Hand Time, is her most am- was writing Second-Hand Time, she that intellectuals had used since the nine-
bitious work: many women and a few had the sense that her subjects were nd- teen-seventies was religion (Lyudmila
men talk about the loss of the Soviet ing nothing new for themselves in the Ulitskaya and Alexievichs friend Olga
idea, the post-Soviet ethnic wars, the past or in the present. The hope engen- Sedakova are two writers who took this
legacy of the Gulag, and other aspects dered by perestroika was gone, and peo- path), but this did not appeal to Alex-
of the Soviet experience. Alexievich said, ple were trying to recycle old ideas and ievich. When I see a garden in ower,
We are surrounded by victims. Who attachments. This pursuit appeared so then I believe in God for a second, she
did it all to them? Aliens? Questions like desperate that for a while Alexievich said. But not the rest of the time.
that come up, but these are working ques- thought she was writing a book about She moved to Western Europe, where
tionsI only need them in the process. suicide. In 1993, she published a short she could secure writing fellowships for
Alexievich is now working on two book on the subject, called Enchanted one or two years. She lived in Italy, Ger-
booksone about old age and dying, by Death; those stories later became a many, France, and Sweden, never learn-
and the other about love. Neither cen- part of Second-Hand Time. ing more than a word or two of the lan-
ters on a historical event, and neither, Alexievich keeps in touch with many guage. She made friends with her
she says, is going very well: When I of her subjects, who often tell her new translators, she saw plays based on her
started recording, I found I had a prob- stories; a phone call, she said, can just bookswith their emphasis on human
lem. The older generation is a Soviet blow up that previous knowledge. She speech, they lend themselves to the stage.
generation. They have to talk about often expands her books for new edi- The world became more multicolored,
themselves and they have no experience tions. For, what is a person? she asked. more layered, she said. She hoped that
of doing that. You start talking to them It depends on his mood, and who his while she was abroad Lukashenkos reign
about love, and they talk about how they friends are, and what books hes read, might end. But eventually, she said, I
built Minsk. You start talking to them and even whether you are visiting in the was wrong to think I could sit him out.
about old age, they tell you how diffi- morning or in the evening. Everything She found herself in a different kind of
cult life was after the war. Its like they means something. So what is a person? intellectual trap: she was living where
never had a life of their own. Of course, you can never come face to she could write freely but not use her
40 THE NEW YORKER, OCTOBER 26, 2015
immersion method. She went many by a woman who took care of her dying
months between trips to the former So- husband at home:
viet Union, and found that her subjects Is this something I can talk about? Give it
language was changing. A few years ago, words? There are secretsI still dont under-
she returned to Minsk. stand what that was. Even in our last month,
The choice proved even lonelier than hed still call for me at night. He felt desire. He
Alexievich expected. Her mentors are loved me more than he did before. During the
day, Id look at him, and I couldnt believe
dead. Her peers have either emigrated what had happened at night. We didnt want
or faded from view. In Western Europe, to part. I caressed him, I petted him. . . . Do I
she said, she has fascinating friends who need to talk about it? Can I? I myself went to
are in their seventies, but in Belarus him the way a man goes to a woman. What
people over fty believe that life is over. could I give him aside from medicine? What
hope? He didnt want to die.
Even casual acquaintances have disap- But I didnt tell my mother anything. She
peared. I noticed that when I y some- wouldnt have understood me. She would have
where I dont run into people of my judged me, cursed us. Because this wasnt just an
generation at the airport anymore, she ordinary cancer, which everyone is already afraid
said. No one is going anywhere. of, but Chernobyl cancer, even worse. The doc-
tors told me: if the tumors metastasized within
The conventional ways of broaden- his body, hed have died quickly, but instead they
ing her social circle do not appeal to crawled upward, along the body, to the face.
her. I cannot teach, because I cant stand Something black grew on him. His chin went
to repeat myself, she said. Also, there somewhere, his neck disappeared, his tongue fell
are very few talented young people. out. His veins popped, he began to bleed. From
his neck, his cheeks, his ears. To all sides. Id bring
Now that her books are openly sold in cold water, put wet rags against him, nothing
Belarus, she has readers, but readers helped. It was something awful, the whole pillow
can give you nothing but banalities. would be covered in it. Id bring a washbowl
Not that she doesnt like her readers from the bathroom, and the streams would hit
she just does not want to talk to them. it, like into a milk pail. That sound, it was so
peaceful and rural. Even now I hear it at night.
Im not interested in people as such,
she said. A conversation with some- When Alexievich published an ex-
one who can be a real interlocutor, an cerpt from the book, she changed the
actual exchangebut that happens so womans name. Two days later, she calls
rarely. She goes to Moscow to see pho- me and asks, Why did you change my
tography exhibits. The visual images, name? Alexievich said. She told the
she nds, stay with her for a long time woman, I didnt want to expose you to
and help with work. Music also helps: god knows what! She said, I suffered so
Alexievich listens to contemporary much and he suffered so much that I
post-Soviet composers such as the dont want there to be any untruth.
Ukrainian Valentin Silvestrov, the Es- Alexievich kept the speaker anony-
tonian Arvo Prt, and the mous. She has overruled
Russian Sergei Nevsky. other subjects who she
She no longer has much thought were willing to take
patience for ction, even too great a risk. The mob
some that she used to love: accepts art but tears apart
I tried rereading Platonov, people, she said. Her sub-
but that kind of baroque jects sometimes recoil at
voice doesnt do it for me what theyve shared. The
anymore. Even TolstoyI women in War Has Not a
went to read his Sevastopol Womans Face wanted to
Sketches, but I just cant rewrite the book, to replace
abide those masculine superstitions now. the pain with the very banalities Alex-
Shes more interested in nonction, but, ievich had fought. I thought, Thats as
as Russia continues to isolate itself from if the subjects of The Gulag Archipel-
the world, fewer interesting books are ago had tried to rewrite the book.
available in translation. Solzhenitsyns Nobel was awarded
Still, she has all that is essential for forty-ve years before hers, to the day.
work: time and solitude. Alexievich Now, she said, she felt surrounded by
thinks a lot about privacy, both her own the great shadows of past Russian No-
and that of her subjects. The last story bels. She listed Bunin, Pasternak, and
in Voices from Chernobyl is narrated Solzhenitsyn. I have to work, she said.
THE NEW YORKER, OCTOBER 26, 2015 41

Potrebbero piacerti anche