Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ARTICLE
(Fig. 1). The Bolivian tin-silver deposits are associated the vein systems, with base metals and silver tending to
typically with felsic volcanic domes (Cunningham et al. increase both upwards and outwards at the expense of
1991) of broadly rhyodacitic composition. These frac- tin, bismuth and tungsten (Turneaure 1960).
tionated igneous rocks are relatively reduced and as-
signable to the ilmenite series (Sugaki et al. 1988;
Lehmann et al. 1990). Their reduced character probably Lithocap characteristics
reects the elevated organic carbon content of the thick
underlying prism of early Palaeozoic meta-sedimentary Potos
rocks (Lehmann 1994), which underwent thick-skinned
compressive tectonism at the time of magma generation The lithocap at Cerro Rico crops out over 1 km2 and
(Lamb et al. 1997). exceeds 400 m in thickness (Fig. 2), much of it hosted by
The tin-silver deposits are characteristically of vein rhyodacite porphyry (Fig. 3a). The upper 250 m consist
type, with the ore comprising polymetallic massive sul- of cryptocrystalline quartz, which is largely vuggy
phides accompanied by only relatively minor amounts of (Turneaure 1960; Sillitoe et al. 1975) and residual in
gangue (Turneaure 1960; Ludington et al. 1992). How- origin (Fig. 3a; Sillitoe 1988). Zones of massive silici-
ever, mineralized veinlet stockworks and hydrothermal cation are the product of local quartz introduction. The
breccias are also commonplace. Widespread sericitic underlying 150 m consist of quartz-dickite alteration
alteration and tourmalinization accompany the miner- (Sillitoe 1988; Steele 1996). Traces of pyrophyllite are
alization. Well-developed metal zoning typies many of present with this assemblage near the base of the litho-
cap (Steele 1996). The quartz-dickite alteration shows a
gradational contact with the underlying sericitic altera-
tion which, in turn, grades into quartz-tourmaline al-
teration in the deepest parts of the deposit (Fig. 3a;
Sillitoe 1988; Steele 1996). Hypogene aluminium phos-
phate-sulphate (APS) minerals (Storegen and Alpers
1987), most notably svanbergite, are abundant within
the quartz-dickite zone and common within the lower
portions of the vuggy quartz zone (Steele 1996).
The lithocap is host to disseminated silver mineral-
ization of both hypogene and supergene origin. Ar-
gentite, the principal hypogene silver mineral, inverted
to acanthite and is associated spatially with disseminated
barite (Steele 1996). A sheeted zone of polymetallic veins
cuts the lithocap (Turneaure 1960), with the upper parts
of the veins containing chalcedonic quartz and barite.
Both the veins and the disseminated hypogene mineral-
ization throughout the lithocap underwent pervasive
supergene oxidation in the weathering environment.
Pockets of pyritic hypogene mineralization that escaped
the oxidation demonstrate that the lithocap originally
contained 510 vol % of disseminated sulphides. Veins
of porcellanous supergene alunite were generated im-
mediately beneath the lithocap during the sulphide oxi-
dation. The lithocap at Cerro Rico hosts the world's
largest silver resource, amounting to at least 86 000 to-
nnes (2800 million oz) of silver metal prior to colonial
exploitation.
Pulacayo
lithocap. However, much of the underlying host dome Fig. 2 The Cerro Rico lithocap at Potos , Bolivia, viewed from the
northeast. The vuggy residual quartz zone occupying the upper half of
underwent alteration to chlorite and, locally, sericite. Cerro Rico has a darker-brown colour than the underlying alteration.
Appreciable silver values are absent from the lithocap, The base of the vuggy quartz zone coincides roughly with the change
although remnants of galena and stibnite are noted in from grey sulphidic to brown oxidized material on the numerous mine
minor chalcedonic veins and breccias. The main silver dumps. Photograph: G.B. Steele
concentration at Pulacayo, Bolivia's second largest his-
torical silver producer with a total of 5000 tonnes is most intense along the brecciated margins of the
(160 million oz) of silver metal, was the Tajo massive porphyry bodies, and also occurs in association with
sulphide vein beneath the dome (Fig. 3b; Ahlfeld and open fractures lined by coarse-grained quartz plus hy-
Schneider-Scherbina 1964). pogene tungsten and bismuth minerals with minor na-
tive gold. Tasna was exploited previously for bismuth,
tungsten and tin, and is considered the world's largest
Tasna known deposit of bismuth (Ahlfeld and Schneider-
Scherbina 1964). It was explored recently for gold.
The Tasna deposit is believed to be more deeply eroded
than either Potos or Pulacayo because porphyritic in-
trusions, as small bodies and dykes, are more volumi- Genetic model
nous at the upper elevations (Fig. 3c). The intrusions are
interpreted as the root zone of an eroded dome complex. A generalized alteration-mineralization model for vol-
At depths >200 m beneath the summit of Cerro Tasna, canic dome-hosted tin-silver deposits in the southern
the deposit contains a horizontal layer of pervasive part of the Bolivian tin belt may be constructed from the
quartz-tourmaline alteration, hosted by folded siltstone alteration and mineralization patterns observed at Pot-
and shale, which passes up into fracture- and lithologi- os , Pulacayo, Tasna and elsewhere (Fig. 4). Alteration
cally controlled advanced argillic alteration dened by typically changes downwards from advanced argillic to
dumortierite, pyrophyllite, diaspore, zunyite, topaz, sericitic and/or quartz-tourmaline, which is paralleled
rubellite (iron- and magnesium-free variety of tourma- ideally by a change in mineralization from silver, anti-
line), APS minerals and minor alunite (Fig. 3c; mony and lesser tin, through tin and base metals to
Thompson et al. 1996). The advanced argillic alteration tungsten, bismuth and lesser tin. However, the lithophile
542
Tsukimura (1997) calculated that reduced magmas Fig. 4 Schematic cross-sectional model of volcanic dome-hosted tin-
contain <20% of the SO2 present in oxidized magmas. silver systems in Bolivia to show relations of advanced argillic
Therefore, bearing in mind that H2S cannot be trans- lithocaps to deeper alteration and mineralization features. The
interpreted positions of Potos , Pulacayo and Tasna in the model
formed to sulphate in the absence of atmospheric oxy- are shown
gen, i.e., below the vadose zone, the aqueous sulphate
activity of the lithocap environment in Bolivian tin-silver
systems should be substantially lower than that in the data) and elsewhere in the Bolivian tin-silver belt
upper parts of oxidized porphyry copper systems. (Dietrich et al. 1997; Redwood and Rice, 1997).
Notwithstanding this argument, the amount of sul- In many high-sulphidation deposits, late-stage sul-
phate generated was still adequate to precipitate phides and associated precious metals tend to be con-
abundant alunite at Pulacayo, and in the lithocaps at centrated in vuggy quartz, probably because of its
Tollojchi (R.H. Sillitoe unpublished report 1991) and hydrothermally enhanced permeability (e.g. Hedenquist
Cosuno (Dill et al. 1997; Fig. 1), as well as the APS et al. 1994). In contrast, zones of quartz-alunite altera-
minerals at Potos . This conclusion assumes that: (1) tion are typically tighter and essentially barren. This
additional sulphate was not provided by drainback of same relationship is evident in the Bolivian lithocaps,
uid from the overlying steam-heated environment where the huge volume of vuggy quartz at Potos hosted
above the palaeo-water table (acid-leached zone; Fig. 4), the world's largest silver resource, whereas the quartz-
where boiled-o H2S encounters atmospheric oxygen in alunite zones at Pulacayo and elsewhere (Fig. 1) are
the vadose zone and undergoes ecient oxidation to poorly mineralized, at least in their preserved basal
produce sulphuric acid (e.g. Giggenbach 1997); (2) H2S parts.
was not oxidized to SO2 as a result of buering by ox- The predominance of silver, tin and antimony, with
idized rocks in the upper crust, an unlikely possibility virtually no or only localized gold, in lithocaps in the
given the predominantly carbonaceous nature of the Bolivian tin-silver belt contrasts markedly with the gold-
Early Palaeozoic succession; and (3) supplementary SO2 copper-arsenic association typical of most porphyry
was not derived from deep-seated mac magma with a copper lithocaps (Sillitoe, 1995). The copper and arsenic
higher oxidation state, for which support may exist at are characteristically present as enargite, which is absent
Tasna (J.F.H. Thompson and J.R. Lang unpublished from the Bolivian lithocaps described here, although
544
present in disseminated form in the Tollojchi lithocap thermal'' to describe deposits in the Bolivian tin-silver
(Fig. 1). The general absence of enargite and its anti- belt (Turneaure 1960).
mony analogue, famatinite, as well as members of the The bulk-tonnage silver deposit at Potos is therefore
tennantite-tetrahedrite series may be attributed to low assignable to the high-sulphidation epithermal category
copper activities in the uid responsible. These obser- (see Sillitoe 1993). Although the sulphide assemblages in
vations suggest that the silver-tin-antimony versus gold- the partly mesothermal massive sulphide veins beneath
copper-arsenic signature ultimately may reect the metal the lithocap at Potos (and elsewhere in the tin-silver
contents of the magmatic uids derived from reduced as belt) possess a low sulphidation state, in the sense of
opposed to oxidized magmas, in a manner comparable Meyer and Hemley (1967), the overlying vuggy quartz
to that proposed by Ishihara (1981) for tin versus copper zone at Potos cannot be considered as the upper part of
systems in general. a low-sulphidation (adularia-sericite) epithermal system,
as proposed recently by Cunningham et al. (1996). In
summary, therefore, the abrupt upward increase of
Discussion sulphidation state from mesothermal massive sulphide
veins to overlying epithermal lithocaps in Bolivian tin-
The Bolivian tin-silver systems, like porphyry copper silver systems is directly comparable to that observed on
systems worldwide, span the mesothermal to epithermal passing from porphyry copper deposits to their overly-
environments (Fig. 4). The polymetallic massive sul- ing lithocaps (Sillitoe 1995; Fig. 5).
phide veins and associated mineralization styles, con-
taining tin, tungsten, bismuth and base metals in
association with quartz-tourmaline and sericitic altera- Conclusions for exploration
tion, lack the textural and mineralogical features used to
dene epithermal deposits and may, like porphyry cop- Advanced argillic lithocaps, representing the shallow
per deposits, be assigned to a somewhat deeper, meso- epithermal parts of tin-silver systems, in the southern
thermal environment in the broad sense of Lindgren part of the Bolivian tin belt and, potentially, elsewhere
(1933). Certainly, the early alteration and massive sul- are prospective for high-grade vein or low-grade bulk-
phide vein formation commenced at temperatures of tonnage silver mineralization. As in lithocap environ-
550450 C (Kelly and Turneaure 1970; Grant et al. ments elsewhere, vuggy residual quartz, widespread at
1980; Thompson et al. 1996 and unpublished data). In Potos , is the most favourable alteration type for bulk-
contrast, the lithocaps described herein, and the associ- tonnage mineralization. The mineralized portions of
ated high-level chalcedony-barite veins at Potos and lithocaps may be concealed beneath relatively barren
Pulacayo, are considered to possess features typical of material, as at Tollojchi (G.B. Steele unpublished data),
the high-sulphidation epithermal setting. This proximity
Fig. 5a, b Schematic comparison between epithermal/mesothermal
of relatively late, shallow, low-temperature and rela- and high-/low-sulphidation environments as applied to a porphyry
tively early, deeper, higher-temperature mineralization copper, and b Bolivian tin-silver systems. Note the contrast in metal
resulted in the use of Buddington's (1935) term ``xeno- suites throughout the two systems
545
and hence dicult to predict at surface. Gold may be Grant JN, Halls C, Sheppard SMF, Avila W (1980) Evolution of
concentrated in structurally controlled root zones of the porphyry tin deposits of Bolivia. In: Ishihara S, Takenouchi
S (eds) Granitic magmatism and related mineralization. Mining
lithocaps, as at Tasna. For the metallogenic reason Geol, Spec Iss 8: 151173
proposed, this is not expected to be a widespread phe- Hedenquist JW, Matsuhisa Y, Izawa E, White NC, Giggenbach
nomenon, although the dome-hosted Kori Kollo gold WF, Aoki M (1994) Geology, geochemistry, and origin of high
deposit is a signicant exception (Columba and Cun- suldation Cu-Au mineralization in the Nansatsu district,
Japan. Econ Geol 89: 130
ningham 1993). Irrespective of whether or not Bolivian Hemley JJ, Hunt JP (1992) Hydrothermal ore-forming processes in
lithocaps are well mineralized with silvergold, they the light of studies in rock-buered systems; II, Some general
have the potential to conceal high-grade tin, base-metal geologic applications. Econ Geol 87: 2343
and/or silver veins like those that crop out widely in Henley RW, McNabb A (1978) Magmatic vapor plumes and
more deeply eroded districts in the Bolivian tin-sliver ground-water interaction in porphyry copper emplacement.
Econ Geol 73: 120
belt. In this regard, most of the Potos veins (Fig. 3a) Ishihara S (1981) The granitoid series and mineralization. Econ
and the major Tajo vein at Pulacayo (Fig. 3b) did not Geol 75th Anniv Vol, pp 458484
attain the present surface. Such concealed veins provide Kelly WC, Turneaure FS (1970) Mineralogy, paragenesis and
exploration targets for high-grade (>5%) tin deposits, geothermometry of the tin and tungsten deposits of the Eastern
Andes, Bolivia. Econ Geol 65: 609680
which could be economically attractive even with cur- Lamb S, Hoke L, Kennan L, Dewey J (1997) Cenozoic evolution of
rent relatively low tin prices. the central Andes in Bolivia and northern Chile. In: Burg J-P,
Ford M (eds) Orogeny through time. Geol Soc Spec Publ 121,
Acknowledgements Data contributed by GBS are taken from a 237264
PhD study completed recently at the University of Aberdeen, Lehmann B (1994) Petrochemical factors governing the metal-
Scotland, with funding for the research provided generously by the logeny of the Bolivian tin belt. In: Reutter K-J, Scheuber
British government through a NERC (CASE) award. EMICRUZ E, Wigger PJ (eds) Tectonics of the southern Central
Ltda. (a joint-venture between Rio Tinto plc and COMSUR S.A.) Andes, structure and evolution of an active continental
is thanked for providing GBS with eld support. JFHT and JRL margin. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg New York, pp
acknowledge the nancial and logistical support provided by Co- 317326
rriente Resources Inc. and the contributions of K. Shannon, Lehmann B, Ishihara S, Michel H, Miller J, Rapela C, Sanchez A,
R. Lau, C. Potherin and L. Aguirre. Reviews of the manuscript by Tistl M, Winkelmann L (1990) The Bolivian tin province and
Nigel Grant and Je Hedenquist are acknowledged with thanks. regional tin distribution in the Central Andes: a reassessment.
Econ Geol 85: 10441058
Lindgren W (1933) Mineral deposits, 4th edn. McGraw Hill, New
References York, 930pp
Ludington S, Orris GJ, Cox DP, Long KR, Asher-Bolinder S
Ahlfeld F, Schneider-Scherbina A (1964) Los yacimientos miner- (1992) Mineral deposit models. In: Geology and mineral re-
ales y de hidrocarburos de Bolivia. Depto Nac Geol Bol 5 sources of the Altiplano and Cordillera Occidental, Bolivia. US
(Especial), La Paz, Bolivia, 388 pp Geol Surv, Bull 1975, pp 6389
Buddington AF (1935) High-temperature mineral associations at Lynch G, Ortega J (1997) Hydrothermal alteration and tourmaline-
shallow to moderate depths. Econ Geol 30: 205222 albite equilibria at the Coxheath porphyry Cu-Mo-Au deposit,
Burnham CW, Ohmoto H (1980) Late-stage processes of felsic Nova Scotia. Can Mineral 35: 7994
magmatism. In: Ishihara S, Takenouchi S (eds) Granitic mag- Meyer C, Hemley JJ (1967) Wall rock alteration. In: Barnes HL
matism and related mineralization. Mining Geol, Spec Iss 8: 1 (ed) Geochemistry of hydrothermal ore deposits. Holt Rinehart
11 and Winston, New York, pp 166235
Columba CM, Cunningham CG (1993) Geologic model for the Redwood SD, Rice CM (1997) Petrogenesis of Miocene basic
mineral deposits of the La Joya district, Oruro, Bolivia. Econ shoshonitic lavas in the Bolivian Andes and implications for
Geol 88: 701708 hydrothermal gold, silver and tin deposits. J S Am Earth Sci 10:
Cunningham CG, McNamee J, Pinto Vasquez J, Ericksen GE 203221
(1991) A model of volcanic dome-hosted precious metal Sillitoe RH (1988) Appraisal of the bulk potential of selected pre-
deposits. Econ Geol 86: 415421 cious-metal properties in Bolivia. United Nations Development
Cunningham CG, Zartman RE, McKee EH, Rye RO, Naeser CW, Programme, Proyecto BOL/87/12, Unpubl rep, New York,
Sanjines V.O, Ericksen GE, Tavera V.F (1996) The age and 25 pp
thermal history of Cerro Rico de Potosi, Bolivia. Mineralium Sillitoe RH (1993) Epithermal models: Genetic types, geometrical
Deposita 31: 374385 controls and shallow features. In: Kirkham RV, Sinclair WD,
Dietrich A, Lehmann B, Wallianos A, Traxel K (1997) The Lower Thorpe RI, Duke JM (eds) Mineral deposit modeling. Geol
Miocene tin porphyry system of Llallagua, Bolivia: bulk rock Assoc Can, Spec Pap 40, 403417
and melt inclusion geochemistry. In: Papunen K (ed) Mineral Sillitoe RH (1995) Exploration of porphyry copper lithocaps. In:
deposits: research and exploration. Where do they meet? Proc. Mauk JL, St George JD (eds) Proc Pacrim Congress 95,
4th Biennial SGA Meeting, Turku, Finland 1997. A.A. Bal- Auckland 1995, Australas Inst Mining Metall Publ Ser 9/95,
kema, Rotterdam, pp 625628 527532
Dill HG, Pertold Z, Riera Kilibarda C (1997) Sediment-hosted and Sillitoe RH, Halls C, Grant JN (1975) Porphyry tin deposits in
volcanic-hosted Sb vein mineralization in the Potosi region, Bolivia. Econ Geol 70: 913927
central Bolivia. Econ Geol 92: 623632 Steele GB (1996) Metallogenesis and hydrothermal alteration at
Giggenbach WF (1997) The origin and evolution of uids in Cerro Rico, Bolivia. Unpub PhD Thesis, University of Aber-
magmatic-hydrothermal systems. In: Barnes HL (ed) Geo- deen, Scotland, 435 pp
chemistry of hydrothermal ore deposits, 3rd edn. John Wiley, Storegen R (1987) Genesis of acid-sulfate alteration and Au-Cu-
New York, pp 737796 Ag mineralization at Summitville, Colorado. Econ Geol 82:
Grant JN, Halls C, Avila W, Snelling NJ (1979) Potassium-argon 15751591
ages of igneous rocks and mineralization in part of the Bolivian Storegen RE, Alpers CN (1987) Woodhouseite and svan-
tin belt. Econ Geol 74: 838851 bergite in hydrothermal ore deposits: products of apatite
546
destruction during advanced argillic alteration. Can Mineral Turneaure FS (1960) A comparative study of major ore deposits
25: 201211 of central Bolivia, Parts I and II. Econ Geol 55: 217254, 574
Sugaki A, Kusachi I, Shimada N (1988) Granite-series and -types 606
of igneous rocks in the Bolivian Andes and their genetic relation Turneaure FS (1971) The Bolivian tin-silver province. Econ Geol
to tin-tungsten mineralization. Mining Geol 38: 121130 66: 215225
Takagi T, Tsukimura K (1997) Genesis of oxidized- and reduced-
type granites. Econ Geol 92: 8186
Thompson JFH, Lang JR, Thompson AJB, Aguirre R, Potherin C,
Lane RW (1996) Vertical and lateral zoning in the Tasna Bi-W-
Sn-Au camp, southern Bolivia. Geol Soc Am Abstr Progs 28:
A-403