Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
MEQ
14,2 An analysis of possible
scenarios of medical waste
242
management in Bangladesh
Nasima Akter
Environmental Technology and Management, Urban Environmental
Engineering Program, School of Environment, Resource and
Development, Asian Institute of Technology, KlongLuang, Thailand, and
Josef Trankler
Urban Environmental Engineering Program, School of Environment,
Resource and Development, Asian Institute of Technology, KlongLuang,
Thailand
Keywords Medical products, Waste, Management, Health care, Bangladesh
Abstract This study investigated medical waste management (MWM) practices in Bangladesh:
its present constraints, the health effect of existing practices, and the weaknesses of the current
system. Suggestions for improvement of the MWM situation have also been offered. Those
interviewed included hospital staff, waste pickers and local residents. In-depth field observations
and a questionnaire survey were conducted in June-July 2000 and March 2001. Laboratory
analyses of medical waste were done on different occasions from 1998-2001. Analyses of medical
waste showed severe contamination of pathogenic microorganism and respondents suffered from
various infectious diseases. The study identified the absence of rigorous laws related to MWM
practices. It is a necessity to improve the handling and disposal methods of medical waste in almost
all the available medical facilities.
Introduction
Medical waste generated from diagnosis, monitoring and preventive, curative
or palliative activities in field of the veterinary and human medicine include
infectious, hazardous and benign materials. Improper disposal of wastes in
hospitals places direct and indirect health impacts on those working in
hospitals and the surrounding communities, and on the environment. Such
practices contribute to the spread of disease, as well as pollution of the air, soil
and water. Runoff from untreated infectious wastes or human excrement
dumped on the land can contaminate surface and ground water supplies,
exposing the population to the risk of diseases and parasites. Unintentional
injuries may occur due to the exposure of improperly discarded sharps leading
to life-threatening infections such as HBV, HCV and HIV (World Bank, 2000).
Management of Environmental
Quality: An International Journal
The re-use of unsterilized syringes results in 8-16 million hepatitis B, 2.3-4.7
Vol. 14 No. 2, 2003
pp. 242-255
million hepatitis C and 80,000-160,000 HIV infections annually (WHO, 2000).
q MCB UP Limited Uncontrolled burning of medical waste pollutes the air with acid gases, dioxins,
1477-7835
DOI 10.1108/14777830310470459 furans and heavy metals.
There are currently 645 public and 288 private sector health care Possible
establishments in Bangladesh (Line Director (hospital services), 2000). Most scenarios of
have no provision for safe disposal of medical waste, yet its generation has MWM
been on an increase. An estimated 255 tons of medical waste is generated in
Dhaka every day (Rahman and Ali, 2000), most of which is dumped in
municipal bins (ADB, 1998), since only few hospitals have onsite management
system such as burning, burial, autoclave and/or waste segregation. 243
An overwhelming number of the urban poor in Bangladesh rely on the
collection of secondary materials for their primary source of livelihood. The
wastes pickers sort through waste on site; usually open dumps. They sell all
that can be recycled to agents of various industries. The waste pickers adopt
no protective clothing, exposing themselves to injury and sickness. Moreover,
the municipal dustbins of Dhaka, where the hospitals place their waste
(including human body parts (Rashid, 1996)) are left exposed to the
environment for days before collection (ADB, 1998; Akter et al., 1999). This
increases the risk of epidemics such as viral hepatitis, typhoid, pneumonia
and AIDs (ADB, 1998).
Objectives
There had been no previous study conducted on the impacts of improper
medical waste management (MWM).
The objectives of this study are as follows:
.
to review the current status of medical waste management practices in
Bangladesh;
.
to identify the health effect of existing MWM practices;
.
to identify the weaknesses of waste management; and
.
to provide a set of suggestions, strategies and policies to advance those
that exist.
institute and hospital), two private clinics and two diagnostic centers were
selected to represent each category in this study. These cover approximately
30 percent of total beds. The government hospitals represent the
management system of the country. They were also selected for the
questionnaire survey, interview, waste sampling, and field observation. In
addition, a health institute, an international research center, a military
hospital, a clinic and a diagnostic center were selected for interview and field
observation.
Khulna. Total bed number in the 21 hospitals and clinics are
approximately 806, of which 62 percent (500 beds) belongs to three big
hospitals (one district and two private). Of these three, two hospitals
covering 70 percent (350 beds) of 62 percent were studied. Three private
clinics were selected from the remaining 38 percent of beds (42 percent of
38 percent (130 beds)). Therefore, total coverage for this study was 78
percent of all beds present in the city. Four private hospital and clinics,
two diagnostic centers and one government district hospital were selected
for interview and field observation. Khulna was also selected for a case
study of MWM.
The three dumpsites in the country were examined: city corporations
landfill sites at Kamalapur and Matuail in Dhaka and the municipal dumping
site at Khulna.
Data collection Possible
Data were collected through field observations, interviews, and questionnaire scenarios of
survey during June-July 2000 and March 2001: MWM
.
Field observations. Made at each location using a checklist focusing on
potential problems posed by disposal of medical waste. Emphasis was
placed on waste generation in the hospitals (store, OPD, patient ward, 245
operation theatre, pathological laboratory), disposal practices, and disposal
sites. The MWM project of an NGO at Khulna (Prodipan) was visited.
.
Interview. Hospital management authority, divisional head/director,
senior administrative personnel of the hospitals or clinics were
interviewed on general hospital management, health services, waste
management, their basic understanding and view on MWM, and their
suggestions for improvement the system. City Corporation, Department
of Environment (DOE) officials, and Directorate General (DG) health
officials were also interviewed for the legal status and for their awareness
of the importance of proper MWM.
.
Questionnaire survey. Conducted for those providing medical services,
handling and disposing waste (doctors, nurses and waste pickers). Sets of
semi-structured questionnaires were used. The main purpose was to
assess the level of awareness of health effects of improper disposal, the
required skill for waste handling, and to identify the factors limiting
proper disposal. A statistically viable sample of respondents for the
survey were determined using the following equation (1). The
respondents of different categories were randomly selected:
Nz 2 p1 P
n 1
Nd 2 z 2 p1 P
where:
n = sample size to be calculated;
N = total staff 4,313;
z = confidence interval at 90 percent, i.e. 1.645;
p = estimated population proportion (0.5, this maximizes the sample
size);
d = error limit of 5 percent (0.05).
Application of the above formula with the specified values, which in fact
maximizes the sample size, yielded a total required sample of 255
respondents from the total 4,313 hospital staff. This sample was divided
into doctors, nurses and others in the proportion as they appear in the
population. The collected sample size was 385 persons comprising 55
MEQ doctors, 155 nurses and 179 others (cleaners, ward boys). Assuming 50
14,2 percent reserve (from non-response and missing staff) from the required
sample size giving 383 as requirement (255 * 1.5 383 persons).
Other than these, 117 waste pickers/local residents near hospital
vicinity and 100 of those from two municipal dumping sites at Dhaka were
selected when available.
246
247
Figure 1.
Proportion of waste
generation in 20 health
facilities at Khulna City
Existing practices
Currently, hospitals use municipal bins and dumping grounds for disposal.
Wastes can often be found in rivers or canals near larger hospitals. Few
hospitals store waste in their net houses or closed dustbins before sending to
the city corporation bins. Generally, solid wastes, saline bags, and non-sharps
are disposed off in improper ways (Figure 2).
The questionnaire survey revealed that apart from separating
syringes/needles, hospitals do not practice waste segregation before disposal.
The waste includes items such as vials, slides, empty packets, bottles and
saline bags, and used X-ray film developing chemicals. Hence, waste pickers
sort through and sell material to traders that are hazardous.
Figure 2.
Waste disposal from
hospital
MEQ Few places where segregation has been introduced include the Institute of
14,2 Mother and Child Health (IMCH) where sharps, glass, clinical and food wastes
are kept in separate bins. ICDDR,B separates laboratory culture and waste,
needles and glasses. Prodipan, a non-government organization (NGO)-operated
clinical waste management project in Khulna provides an example for superior
practices of MWM.
248 A total of 21 percent of doctors and 18 percent of nurses stated burning as a
disposal process, however, there are no specific sites where this can occur.
Hence open fields and pavements near hospitals and clinics are used. Burning
is used only for selected solid wastes, e.g. sputum from TB patients, tested
slides, ruined bed-sheets/mattresses. Other items, including cases of
fetuses/placenta, are buried around the medical facilities or within the
hospital compound.
Some medical colleges and tertiary government hospitals have incinerators
on site. Even though no alternative method is prescribed, the DOE does not
permit the operation of incinerators due to environmental concern. Some
private institutes and NGOs operate their own incinerators for infectious waste.
Dustbin, Sir Salimullah Medical College Hospital 2.5 10 6.4 10 2.3 10 3.8 10
Basin water, Sir Salimullah Medical College Hospital 2.7 10 1.1 10 1.1 10 3
Dustbin, Dhaka Medical College Hospital 3.2 10 3.6 10 4.7 10 5.3 10
Basin water, Dhaka Medical College Hospital 3.2 10 1.7 10 15 ,1
Solid waste, Dhaka Medical College Hospital 2.5 10 2.0 10 5.6 10 3.9 10
Wastewater, Dhaka Medical College Hospital 2.9 10 3.1 10 3 1.2 10
Infectious Disease Hospital basin water 1.6 10 35 10 5 ,1
Infectious Disease Hospital dustbin 2.3 10 7.7 10 1.8 10 6.2 10
Delta Medical Center and Clinic soil 3.1 10 7.2 10 3.4 10 2.7 10
Popular Diagnostic Center water 6.8 10 1.2 10 7 5
Possible
different sources in
medical waste
analyzed from
Pathogens in
MWM
September 1998
Table II.
249
scenarios of
14,2
250
MEQ
Table III.
Pathological
collected from
Solid waste, Ibnesina Diagnostic Center 3.2 106 1.7 106 3.2 104 V. cholerae non 01, Absent
non 0139 present
Leachate, Ibnesina Diagnostic Center 1.6 108 1.3 108 3.6 106 Absent Absent
Solid waste, IPGMR 8.4 107 6.0 107 4.4 104 V. cholerae non 01, Absent
non 0139 present
Leachate, IPGMR 7.2 107 4.8 107 1.2 105 V. cholerae non 01, Absent
non 0139 present
Solid waste 1.2 105 1.1 105 V. cholerae non 01, Absent
non 0139 present
Leachate, DMCH 2.2 108 6.0 107 V. cholerae non 01, Absent
non 0139 present
DMCH (medicine) 3.8 107 3.2 107 1.6 106 Absent Absent
DMCH (Surgery) 6.8 108 2.4 108 8.4 107 V. cholerae non 01, Salmonella spp.
non 0139 present present
DMCH (Urology) 3.6 106 2.4 106 3.6 104 Absent
Dustbin, IPGMR 3.9 109 2.9 109 2.0 106 Absent Absent
residents had diseases of some kind within 15 days of contact with hazardous Possible
waste. Apart from that, 11 percent of nurses and cleaners, 19 percent of waste scenarios of
pickers and local residents and 7 percent residents had infectious diseases MWM
(Figure 3). These included skin diseases, allergy, hepatitis B/C, diarrhea and
dysentery.
251
Chronic diseases
Figures 4 and 5 illustrate the findings of chronic diseases and the speculations
as to the origin of the diseases. A total of 47 percent of nurses suffered chronic
diseases, of which 13 percent were infectious. Of these, 45 percent existed for
one year; 37 percent were job related; and about 89 percent of nurses consulted
physicians. They believed the lack of facilities to disinfect hands/instruments
and overcrowded wards caused them to work far beyond their capacity.
Among the cleaners and workers, 64 percent had chronic diseases, of which
39 percent were infectious, majority of whom suffered for up to a year. The
majority (55 percent) of the waste pickers and local residents around hospitals
suffered from chronic diseases lasting two to five years, of which 41 percent
were infectious. A total of 7 percent had more than one infectious disease. Most
(57 percent) were unaware of the cause of their diseases. It was found that 83
percent waste pickers suffered from chronic diseases of which 24 percent were
infectious. A total of 40 percent suffered for up to one year and 35 percent for up
to five years. Only about half (51 percent) visited a doctor since they often do
not regard allergy or skin diseases as an illness. Frequent illnesses include the
common cold, fevers and headaches. Non-infectious diseases included
abnormal blood pressure, arthritis, rheumatic fever, ulcers, gastric
stomachache, ophthalmic and ear problems, tonsilitis, sinusitis and diabetes.
Of the respondents, 23 percent had more than one infectious disease. Chronic
Figure 3.
Disease within 15 days
among the respondents
MEQ
14,2
252
Figure 4.
Types of chronic
diseases
Figure 5.
Opinion on source of
diseases
References
Akter, N., Kazi, N.M. and Chowdhury, A.M.R. (1999), Medical Waste Disposal in Dhaka City: An
Environmental Evaluation, Special Publication No. 87, February International Center for
Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Mohakhali, Dhaka.
Asian Development Bank (ADB) (1998), Dhaka City Management Reform Pilot Project, Draft
final report Bangladesh Center for Advanced Studies (BCAS) and BRAC, Dhaka.
Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association (BELA) (1996), The Environmental
Preservation Act 1995, Unofficial English Version, BELA, Dhaka.
Bangladesh Gazette (1997), Registered no: DA-1. Ministry of Environment and Forest, access
issue, Bangladesh Gazette
Bangladesh Gazette (2000), Bangladesh Environment Preservation Act, No. 11 Law of 2000,
Bangladesh Gazette.
Colgate, J.D. (2001), Standards for the alternative technological treatment of healthcare waste,
International Directory of Solid Waste Management, The ISWA Yearbook, James & James,
London.
Daily Star (2000), Staff Correspondent report on the Seminar on Urbanization in Bangladesh:
Emerging Challenges organized by Bangladesh Institute of Planners, Department of
Urban and Regional Planning and Poribesh Rokhha Shopoth (Porosh), 1 October.
Dana, T. (1999), Alternatives: health and hospitals: an exploration in search of policy, guidelines
and rules, The Daily Star, Vol. 3 No. 66.
Gleis, M. (1997), Healthcare waste management in Germany and in the European Union, in
Federal Republic of Germany (Ed.), A Selection of Recent Publications, Vol. 5, Federal
Environmental Agency, Berlin.
Kazi, N.M. (1998), Waste management in Dhaka, paper presented at theDhaka City Possible
Management Reform Workshop, Organized by BRAC and Bangladesh Center for
Advanced Studies, Dhaka. scenarios of
Line Director (hospital services) (2000), Situation assessment and analysis of hospital waste MWM
management (a pilot study), in Rahman, A.K.M.S. (Ed.), Directorate General of Health
Services, Mohakhali, Dhaka.
Line Director (hospital services) (2001), Manual for hospital waste management, in Rahmen, 255
A.K.M.S (Ed.), Directorate General of Health Services, Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare. DGHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka.
Rahman, M.M. and Ali, M.A. (2000), Waste management and environmental pollution in
Bangladesh, paper presented at the International Conference on Bangladesh Environment,
ICBEN, at BUET, Dhaka Bangladesh, 14-15 January, p. 2000.
Rashid, S. (1996), Medical Waste Disposal in Dhaka City: A Survey, North-South University,
Dhaka.
Sumon, A. (2000), A Seminar Paper on Hospital Waste Management in Khulna City, Urban and
Rural Planning, Khulna University, Khulna.
World Bank (2000), Healthcare Waste Management Guidance Note, Urban Development
Division, Infrastructure Group, Environment Department and Health, Nutrition and
Population Team, The World Bank, Washington, DC.
World Health Organization (WHO) (2000), Wastes from Health-care Activities, WHO information,
Fact Sheet No. 253, October, WHO, Geneva, available at: www.who.int/inf-
fs/en/fact253.html