Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
SPEED RAIL
FAST TRACK TO SUSTAINABLE MOBILITY
2 HIGH SPEED RAIL GENERAL OVERVIEW 3
3
SUMMARY FOREWORD
3 HIGH SPEED RAIL GENERAL OVERVIEW
4-5 HIGH SPEED RAIL HISTORY High speed rail encompasses a complex rea- However high speed rail is not always well
6-7 HIGH SPEED RAIL PRINCIPLES lity involving many technical aspects such as understood as a whole transport system and
infrastructure, rolling stock and operations, its performance is not fully taken advantage
8-11 HIGH SPEED RAIL AND SUSTAINABILITY
as well as strategic and cross-sector issues of, which limits the potential development
12-13 TECHNICAL ASPECTS - INFRASTRUCTURE
including human factors and financial, com- of high speed, the development of classic
14-15 TECHNICAL ASPECTS - ROLLING STOCK mercial, and managerial components. rail, and all other transport modes.
16-19 TECHNICAL ASPECTS - OPERATIONS
In addition, a high speed rail system com- For a long time UIC has been paying parti-
20-21 STATIONS, HIGH SPEED RAIL AND THE CITY bines all these various elements by using cular attention to high speed and has prio-
22-23 HIGH SPEED RAIL AND THE CUSTOMERS the highest level of technology and the most ritised among other objectives the commu-
24-25 ECONOMY AND FINANCES FOR HIGH SPEED RAIL advanced conception for each of them. nication and dissemination of high speed
26-29 HIGH SPEED RAIL AROUND THE WORLD performances, characteristics and potential
High speed is a rapidly expanding new
applications.
30-33 FUNDAMENTAL VALUES OF HIGH SPEED RAIL transport mode and is often described as
34-37 HIGH SPEED RAIL TOWARDS THE FUTURE the transport mode of the future. This is This brochure, published every two years on
38-39 HIGH SPEED RAIL AT UIC due to the three main and very important the occasion of the World Congress on High
characteristics offered to customers and Speed Rail (organised by UIC together with
40 CREDITS
society: safety, capacity (within velocity), a national high speed member) intends to
and sustainability (in particular with respect shed some light on the principles and pos-
to the environment). sibilities of high speed rail, in view of better
and more logical development.
The high speed criteria used by UIC is for operations of at least 250km/h.
Of course, these technical criteria should not mask the performance as per-
ceived by customers in terms of travel time, frequency, comfort, and price that
is really important.
4 HIGH SPEED RAIL HISTORY 5
HISTORY
1964-1981
After the big success of the Shinkansen
operation, technical progress in seve-
ral European countries, particularly
France, Germany, Italy and UK, deve-
loped new technologies and innova-
F R OM B IRT H OF RAI WAYS TO HSR tions aimed to establish the basis for
the passenger railway of the future.
The history of railways is a history of speed. Despite an unknown future (Concorde,
19TH-20TH
CENTURY
Since the origin of railways in Europe during the Industrial Revolution at political opposition, 1973 first petro-
the beginning of the 19th Century, the speed of passenger trains was an leum crisis, etc.) and even if several
essential argument to compete, not necessarily with other transport modes other existing or new transport mo-
(the railway in itself changed the scale of time for passenger travel) but des intended to compete with the
among the different companies. The speed on rails also constituted an classic railway concept, finally SNCF,
evidence of technological development of the most advanced countries the French national railway company,
at that time. started the operation of the first high
Its easy to imagine that the 50 km/h reached by the impressive Rocket speed line between Paris to Lyons on
locomotive from George Stephenson in 1829 represented a true high speed 27 September 1981, at a maximum FROM YESTERDAY TO TOMORROW
consideration for railways since the beginning. speed of 260 km/h. THE HSR OF THE FUTURE
And very soon railways reached even much more impressive speeds: The European HSR was born, but in contrast
100 km/h before 1850, 130 km/h in 1854, and even 200 km/h at the beginning to the Shinkansen concept, the new European A new dimension and a new perspective for HSR started in China on 1
2009 AND
BEYOND
of the 20th century. In any case, these were just speed records. The maximum HSR was fully compatible with existing railways August 2008. The 120 km high speed line between Beijing to Tianjin re-
speed in revenue operation was much more modest but nevertheless and this largely conditioned the further deve-
important, reaching 180 km/h as the top speed and 135 km/h as the average speed between presents just the first step in a huge development to transform the way
lopment of the system in the Old Continent.
two cities in the 1930s, with steam, electric or diesel power.. of travelling for the most populated country in the world. Since 2008,
But the appearance on stage of other transport modes, aviation (offering more speed) and China has implemented almost 20,000 kilometres of new high speed lines
private cars (offering point to point travels in privacy and forgetting frequency), forced passenger and thanks to an enormous fleet of more than 1,500 train sets, carries
railways to use their best arguments to compete. HSR SERVICES SPREA- 800 million passengers per year (2014 and growing), more than the half
DING IN THE WORLD of the total high speed traffic in the world.
And following the example led by China, new high speed systems are under
THE BI RTH O F development around the world: Morocco, Saudi Arabia, USA, etc.
SHI NKANSEN Once again, after the big success
1981-2009
Accordingly with 2015 expectations, and in spite of the development
of the TGV, each European country
of other transport modes (for example the Maglev, automatic driving cars,
looked for the new generation of
After some significant speed re- improvements in aviation, etc.), by 2030-2035, the extension of the wor-
1964 competitive long and medium dis-
cords in Europe (Germany, Italy, tance passenger rail services, in some ld HSR network could reach more than 80,000 kilometres, representing
UK and specially France, 331 km/h cases by developing its new technolo- an important challenge for operators, industry, authorities, etc.
in 1955), the world was surprised gy and in others by importing. High speed must be continuously developed and performed in order to continue to be present
when, on 1 October 1964, Japanese Joining the group of countries offe- in passenger transport in the next 50 years (or more).
national railways started the ope- ring high speed rail services in Europe
ration of a fully brand new 515 km were Italy and Germany in 1988, Spain
standard gauge line (1435 mm, apart in 1992, Belgium in 1997, the United
from conventional lines previously Kingdom in 2003 and the Netherlands
built in Japan, in meter gauge), the Tokaido in 2009.
Shinkansen, from Tokyo Central to Shin Osaka. In the meantime, some similar cases
This line was built to provide capacity to appeared in other countries and re-
the new transport system necessary for the gions, such as China in 2003 (even
impressively rapid growth of the Japanese if the big development came later,
economy. JNR president Shinji Sogo and Vice in 2008), South Korea in 2004, Taiwan
President for Engineering Hideo Shima pro- Railway High Speed Corporation
moted the concept of not only a new line, but in 2007 and Turkey in 2009.
a new transport system, called to be extended
later to the rest of the country and to become
the backbone of passenger transport for the
future generations of citizens in Japan.
The Tokaido Shinkansen was designed to
operate at 210 km/h (later increased), broad
loading gauge, electric motor units powered
at 25 kV AC, Automatic Train Control (ATC),
Centralised Traffic Control (CTC) and other
modern improvements.
High speed rail (HSR) was born.
1830 1903 1964 1981 1988 1989 1992 1997 2003 2004 2007 2007 2008 2009 2015
The Rocket loco- Siemens & AEG 1st October, the The TGV, first Pendolino in Italy The TGV AVE in Spain High speed HS1 in the United KTX in South 574.8km/h world Taiwan High Speed CRH in China High speed in High speed lines
motive by George electric railcar first high speed European high and ICE in Germany Atlantique, in Belgium Kingdom Korea speed record in Rail Corporation the Netherlands in the world
Stephenson obtains 210 km/h system in the wor- speed train, first train to ope- France and in Turkey extends over
reaches 50 km/h ld, Shinkansen operates in France rate regularly at almost 30,000
starts in Japan at 260 km/h 300 km/h kilometres
6 HIGH SPEED RAIL PRINCIPLES 7
1,600 MILLION PASSENGERS PER YEAR CARRIED BY HIGH SPEED TRAINS IN THE WORLD
8
00 MILLION PASSENGERS PER YEAR IN CHINA
1 S T P R INC IP LE : H I GH SPEED RAI L I S A SYSTEM
355 MILLION PASSENGERS PER YEAR IN JAPAN
High speed railways are very complex systems Legal issues, regulations. 130 MILLION PASSENGERS PER YEAR IN FRANCE
which combine the state of the art in many It is essential that all these components 315 M ILLION PASSENGERS PER YEAR IN THE REST OF THE WORLD
different fields: contribute to the quantitative and quali- MODAL SPLIT OBTAINED BY HIGH SPEED TRAINS IN RELATION TO AIR TRANSPORT
Infrastructure (including civil enginee- tative global technical performance and
80% WHEN TRAVEL TIME BY TRAIN IS LESS THAN 2.5 HOURS
ring works, track, signalling, power supply commercial attractiveness. None of them
and catenary, etc.) is to be neglected neither in itself nor T EC H N O LO GY R EQ UIR EMEN T S
Stations (location, functional design, in conjunction with the others. From the
equipment) customer viewpoint, the true speed is the From a strictly technical point of view, ope- The layout parameters (horizontal and vertical
Rolling stock (technology, comfort, design) comparison between the time spent buying rating high speed rail systems require: profiles as well as other parameters such as
Operations (design and planning, a ticket, accessing to and entering the sta- the cant), transverse sections, track quality,
Special Trains
control, rules, quality management) tion or waiting for a taxi on arrival, with the catenary and power supply, and special envi-
High speed operations require train sets ins-
Maintenance strategy and correspon- door-to-door distance and not only the ronmental conditions must be designed so as
tead of conventional trains (locomotive and
ding facilities time saved by using a high speed train as to make high operational speeds sustainable.
cars), because of the power-to-weight ratio
Financing a result of high-level technology and signi- and various other technical reasons, such as Special Signalling System
Marketing ficant investments. aerodynamic , reliability and safety constraints. Line side signals are no longer useable above
Management 200 km/h, because they may not always
Special Dedicated Lines
be observed in time by the drivers. In-cab
2 N D P RINC IP LE : HI GH SPEED RAI L SYSTEMS Conventional lines, even with major up-grades,
signalling is definitely the solution for high
AR E ( E QU A L B UT ) DI FFERENT EVERYWHERE are unable to allow speeds above 200-220 km/h.
speed operation.
High speed systems depend on how all their from one country to another depending
components are designed and interact. on, among other things, commercial THE POSSIBILITIES OF CLASSIC RAILWAYS
The final system obtained (in terms of cost approach, operation criteria and cost
and performances) can be very different management. Generally speaking, conventional railways can only run trains up to 200-220 km/h
(with certain rare exceptions).
3RD PRINCIPLE: HIGH SPEED RAIL SYSTEMS MEANS CAPACITY This is not only due to technical reasons but also due to the capacity problems
which arise when attempting to operate trains running at speeds differing
Accordingly with the main characteristic of quires accessibility, complementarities and by more than 50 km/h, on the same infrastructure.
railway, high speed rail is synonym of ca- multimodal approach. The coherence in the Revenue services at higher speeds require special consideration and it is at this
pacity and sustainability and consequently, application of all these three principles is es- moment that the concept of a high speed system starts to be of fundamental
will be more adequate when more potential sential in order to obtain the success in the importance. In any case, it is highly important considering the time, cost and
demand of traffic will serve. Also, capacity re- application of this modality of rail transport. trouble necessary to upgrade a classic railway line.
8 H I G H S P E E D R A I L A N D S U S TA I N A B I L I T Y 9
SUSTAINABILITY
AVOID, SH IF T, IMPROVE EX T ER N A LIT IES
There are three primary strategies respon- emissions in the corridor. A study for UIC, Across the various transport modes, the All these costs are called external costs
ding to the challenge of reducing the sus- which analysed HSR in France and China, passenger does not pay the entire cost ge- or externalities (not directly linked to the
tainability impact of transport. concluded that the carbon footprint of HSR nerated by his trip. He may pay the energy, operations) and usually remain partly unco-
can be up to 14 times less carbon intensive than maintenance (even the possession) of the vered and are either a nuisance or a burden
The first is avoid where the demand
car travel and up to 15 times less than aviation vehicle costs, as well as the infrastructure for society as a whole.
for transport is reduced; such as land-
even when measured over the full life-cycle of and operation costs such as the salary of Estimation on average externalities in Eu-
use planning and transport integration
planning, construction and operation. the crew, etc., but he does not pay the full rope for different modes of transport is re-
in order to enable efficient interconnecti-
The potential for modal shift to rail and con- costs of the damage to the environment and gularly updated by UIC and other bodies.
vity and reductions in km travelled.
sequent CO2 reductions in the transport mar- to society generated by his mobility: noise, These calculations can contribute to at least
High speed rail (HSR) does have a part to
ket revealed strong potential. In Europe, the accidents, air pollution, nature and lands- calculating the actual costs of transport and
play to avoid strategies within integrated
Transport White Paper stipulates that the cape, climate change, etc. helping to take adequate decisions.
land use and spatial planning. Reducing
majority of medium-distance passenger
local journeys for intercity and internatio-
nal passengers is one of the main functions
transport should be by rail by 2050. AVERAGE EXTERNAL COSTS 2008 FOR EU
of rail stations. For instance, in the case of city The third strategy is to improve the
centre location, compared to airports, HSR efficiency of existing transport modes. ACCIDENTS OTHER COSTS
allows customers to reduce the needs of ur- In this strategy HSR has worked for a long AIR POLLUTION CLIMATE CHANGE
ban and local transport once the main jour- time to reduce energy costs and to keep 15.3
33.8 NOISE UP&DOWN
/ 1,000 pkm / 1,000 pkm STREAM PROCESSES
ney in the door-to-door chain is completed. and improve the energy advantage of rail, RAIL PASSENGER BUS/COACH
In addition, most of the HSR stations are more efficient vehicles and infrastructure.
important nodal points in city centres and An integrated approach to energy consump-
they serve wider social functions, by offe- tion provides a synergic frame with a high
ring accessibility to a comprehensive and potential of reduction.
wide range of services, such as post offices
or shopping facilities.
The energy consumption per passenger 57.1 64.7
of high speed trains is usually lower than / 1,000 pkm /1,000 pkm
The second strategy is shift, where in existing and slower trains running between AIR CAR
journeys are made by lower CO 2 per the same stations, according to several ad-
passenger emitting modes. HSR advan- vantages of the high speed trains such as a
tages in terms of energy consumption and more homogeneous speed profile, a new line
Green House Gas (GHG) emissions compared design with less distance, a lower ancillary
to competitors are one of the main drivers service consumption, less mass per seat and
to reduce carbon footprint in transport sector. smoother trains, more efficient aerodynamic
profile, bigger trains, better load factor and
Therefore, moving passengers onto high
more efficient electric system.
speed rail from air and road transport can
deliver reductions in terms of total CO 2
10 H I G H S P E E D R A I L A N D S U S TA I N A B I L I T Y 11
INFRASTRUCTURE
S P E C IF IC NE E DS O F HI GH SPEED DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT OF THE WORLD HIGH SPEED NETWORK
The world network of high-performance pensive than ballasted track, but it can 45000
be designed, inspected and maintained Though slab track can be recom- 30000
64
75
85
95
05
15
25
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
TRACK FORM OPTIONS SUITABILITY
ASSESSMENT GUIDE TYPICAL PARAMETERS TRACK SUPERSTRUCTURE
FOR NEW HIGH SPEED COMPONENTS (TYPICAL
Technological progress has been very intense lability, operational conditions evolution, LINES BALLASTED TRACK)
on the track field for decades. Under a conti- combination of different types of tracks,
nued evolution trend, the ballasted track has LAYOUT SPECIFICATIONS Rail type: Usually 60kg/m, welded
I nfrastructure technical features:
been largely improving its efficiency. In parallel, Maximum gradient (depending on geogra- Type and number of ties: Concrete
viaducts, tunnels and earthworks sizes, track
new solutions without the ballast as a compo- phic characteristic and operating conditions): monobloc or bi-bloc, 1,666 per km
geometry stability requirements, geotechni-
nent have appeared as new technical options. Passenger traffic only: up to Fastening types: Elastic, many types
cal local features,
35/40mm/m (with suitable rolling stock) Turnouts: Depending on the functio-
As a result of this innovation process there
Environmental conditions: Mixed freight and passenger traffic: nality of the line, they can have movable
are currently a number of available alter-
noise emissions levels, vibrations emissions up to 12/15mm/m or fixed crossings. Technological current
native track forms to be implemented on
levels, CO2 footprint, Track centre distance: limit: maximum speed on deviated track
future construction of High Speed lines.
All of them need to be analysed to provide For 200km/h: 4m is 220 km/h
Each of them with or without ballast as compo-
a robust support to the decision process. For 300km/h: 4.5/5m Electrification: Single phase. The most
nent presents similar performance levels from
Maximum cant: common voltages are 25kV, 50 or 60Hz
the point of view of passenger trains operation. The purpose of this guide is to provide a 150/170mm or 15kV, 16 2/3Hz
However they show significant differences from methodology to rationally assess the most Minimum curve radius: Signalling, communications and other
an economic perspective. The balance for a suitable track typology for a line under stu-
Minimum Ideal Recommended fix equipments: above 200km/h, a full
long-term view not only the capital costs but dy considering all the parameters involved. on-board signalling system is necessary.
the maintenance and materials renewal costs, Some of these parameters are intrinsic to the 200km/h 2,500m 3,500m
have to be considered. Selecting the most sui- track characteristics but some others are re- 300km/h 5,500m 7,000m
table track form for a particular new line is a lated to particular features of the line and the
complex task as it involves a wide number of local conditions where its located. All of them
variables that have to be taken into account together have to be analysed systematically
from a long-term perspective. in the frame of the line life cycle cost approach.
The most relevant of them can be clas-
sified into: UIC report on Track techni-
Functional/operational conditions: cal options on the UIC-High Speed UIC study on Maintenance on high speed lines is available on the UIC-
traffic characteristics, track possession avai- website: www.uic.org/highspeed. High Speed website: www.uic.org/highspeed.
14 TECHNICAL ASPECTS 15
ROLLING STOCK
The number of trainsets in operation for a single line depends on the level of the T Y PES O F H IGH SPEED R O LLIN G ST O C K
expected demand and offer, the type of service and the use of conventional lines. T R A IN S MA IN T EN A N C E
The need to manufacture high speed trains represents an important challenge for
industry, both in terms of quantity and quality of trains to be produced and the cor- Articulated or non-articulated trains Maintenance on high speed rolling stock
responding technological developments to be achieved so as to fit with the service Concentrated or distributed power is essential to guarantee the safety and re-
to provide in terms of both quality and quantity. Tilting or non-tilting liability of the entire system.
So far manufacture and maintenance of rolling stock were often activities handled Single or multiple gauges Fixed inspection time interval for pre-
by separate actors. However, partnerships between industrial bodies and opera- Single or double deck body structure ventive maintenance is broadly applied
tors for manufacturing and maintaining high speed trains have already been Dual power trains Several graded maintenance levels,
successfully experimented. (electric and diesel engines). from daily inspection to overhaul, are
planned according to various steps of use.
UIC study on Necessities for future high speed rolling stock FORECAST FOR THE NUMBER OF TRAINSETS IN 2025
is available on the UIC-High Speed website: www.uic.org/highspeed.
The total number of trainsets required network on high speed, an estimation of the
to operate on ahigh speed line is highly va- global market in the near future could be as
C OM M ON B ASIC CHARACTERI STI CS riable, depending of the level of total and shown in the appended graphic.
OF H IGH S P E E D TRAI NS stationary traffic, type and density of ser- In 2015, more than 3,600 high speed train
vices, type and size of trains and possible sets (able to circulate at least at 250km/h)
Self propelled, fixed composition Several complementary braking systems operation also on conventional lines. were in operation across the world :
and bi-directional Improved commercial performances Just as a magnitude, an average of 13 to ASIA OTHERS
High level of technology High level of RAMS (Reliability, Availabi- 15 trainsets per 100 kilometres can be consi- 2,095 20
Limited axle load lity, Maintainability and Safety) dered as reasonable.
EUROPE TOTAL
(11 to 17 tons for 300 km/h) Airtight structure (sometimes) Taking into account these figures and the
High traction power Technical and safety requirements expectations for the evolution of the world
1,488 3,603
(approx. 11 to 24kW per ton) (compliance with standards)
Power electronic equipment: Compatibility with infrastructure
2015 EUROPE OTHERS
GTO, IGBT > Control circuits. Computer (track gauge, loading gauge, platforms,
network. Automatic diagnostic system catenary, etc.). 2025
Optimised aerodynamic shape
In-cab signalling system/s 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000
The time necessary to design and test a new high speed train (new technical development,
incorporation of innovations, design)can be estimated at 3 to 5 years for the development
of the technology and 2 to 5 years for test and approval.
1
4 NUMBER OF HIGH SPEED ROLLING STOCK MANUFACTURERS IN THE WORLD
16 TECHNICAL ASPECTS 17
OPERATIONS
PLANNING HIGH SPEED TRAFFIC ON NEW LINES REQUIRES OPTIMUM SPEED OPERATING ANY HIGH SPEED LINE
Highly structured train path matrices The maintenance and renewal of all the Concept The maximum operating speeds for high
Regular intervals (an asset commer- components and their interfaces involved in A constant feature in the world of transport speed rail has increased steadily since the
cially, but also efficient from an operatio- a high speed system is essential to ensure the is the desire of passengers to arrive earlier 1960s and continues to increase today.
nal standpoint) main operational parameters at the optimum (accordingly with the idea of the increased The the optimum speed of the system is
Maximum use of available capacity level, at any moment and under any condition. value of time). From the point of view of the not yet reached but some limits are imposed
High quality of service targeted Monitoring, inspection, current mainte- operators, going faster and faster means by physical phenomena, technological bar-
Compatibility with maintenance, nance and major renewal must be compa- being more competitive. riers or criteria of a social nature.
upgrade and repair works. tible with current operations. The process of increased speed in all mo- After analysing the various phenomena
des has led, however, in each of them surrounding train operations at increasing
SOM E M A GNIT U DES TO REALI SE WHAT OPERATI ON to a situation of stabilising around a level at speeds and according to experts, it is consi-
ON H IG H SP E E D LI NES REQUI RES which they become stuck permanently, or at dered that the main factor with regard to
least for a long period of time until a trend limiting speed increases is of aerodynamic
MAGNITUDE OF USUAL BRAKING DISTANCE OPERATING AT 300 KM/H breaking technological leap forward occurs. origin, with its associated noise component.
FROM 200 KMH/ TO 0 This level around which speed stabilises in Factors overlapping between line geome-
1 KM: 12 SEC a unanimous process is the optimum speed
1,900 M try requirements, rolling stock restrictions,
FROM 250 KMH/ TO 0 5 KM: 1 MN for each transport mode. growing needs for acoustic attenuation
3,100 M Due to several reasons, all long-distance measurements and the aerodynamic phe-
HEADWAY 5 MINUTES AT 300 KM/H passenger transport modes have maximum nomenon, point to the optimum speed in
FROM 300 KMH/ TO 0
4,700 M operating speeds stabilised over years that the high speed system appearing in the
25 KM
correspond to the optimum speed of each 500-550 km/h range.
FROM 320 KMH/ TO 0
5,800 M DISTANCE TO ACCELERATE system (120 km/h in the case of the routes and This optimum speed of the system is close
FROM 0 TO 300 KM/H: around 900 km/h in the case of the aviation). to the record speeds achieved to date for the
FROM 350 KMH/ TO 0
6,700 M 10-20 KM/H The railway is the exception because the maxi- two families of railway technologies - wheel-
mum operating speed continues to increase rail running and magnetic levitation - which
as technological improvements arise. have reached 570 km/h and 600 km/h.
700 km/h
574.8KM/H
500 km/h On 3 April 2007, the world
MAXIMUM SPEED RECORD speed record for rail
300 km/h
transport was set at 574.8
MAXIMUM OPERATION SPEED km/h by a special TGV
train on the French TGV
East high speed line.
55
64
80
91
07
15
19
19
19
19
20
20
18 TECHNICAL ASPECTS 19
M AX IM UM DE NSI TY OF OPERATI ON
15TRAINS/HOURS
C A PAC IT Y
SAFETY RECORD
No fatal accidents at more than 200 km/h on high speed lines since the begin-
ning of high speed history.
20 S TAT I O N S , H I G H S P E E D R A I L A N D T H E C I T Y 21
STRATEGIC VALUE
OF STATIONS
H IGH SPEED A LSO these operations will be an essential input
MEA N S H IGH C A PA C IT Y for the functional design of any high speed
station. And, if possible, removing these ac-
Having capacity as a basic characteris- tivities out of the big terminals and out of
tic of high speed, stations are expected the city centres where land is at a lower cost
to handle high traffic volume. Volume may be a good economic and land use poli-
must be understood in terms of trains, cy, as well as an optimisation of the quality
customers, private cars, taxis, and public of operations and service.
transport means.
Finally the fundamental values of railways
Commercial operations in stations re- applied in stations (environment, energy,
quire information, ticketing, vending, in safety, security, civil protection, etc.) are to
some cases access controlling, after tra- be taken into account accordingly with the
vel services, etc. These operations must volume and characteristics of the traffic.
be planned and calculated by thinking in
the functionality of the services: volume of A R C H IT EC T UR E
passengers, high value-add for the travel, A N D UR BA N ISM
accessibility and its coherence with the re-
duction of time travel, etc. High speed stations can be used to pro-
Most often, stations and their nearby sur- mote a high level of architecture and the
roundings are the place where railway revitalisation of abandoned city areas. The
to airports, mass transit and light systems operators do certain operations: replacing costs and benefits of this approach can be
as well as to private transport. crews, cleaning and inspecting trains, wa- carefully studied.
ter refilling, turning around seats, refurbish In high speed stations, the governance (this
In the big cities or big urban areas, the cri- catering, etc.
teria for having one or more stations and the means, who decides what) and the financial
These industrial activities usually share the avai- approach (this means who pays, who finances,
exact emplacement, must take into consi- lable (reduced) space with passengers flows.
deration the requirements of the city, the who does what) are essential concepts.
Planning what, where, why and who is to do
citizens and their intermodality and acces-
sibility, as well as the technical constraints
of the railway system in itself. High speed and the
City 1 & 2, are two UIC studies
A preliminary functional design facto-
on benchmarking on the rela-
The location of high speed stations is ring the result of marketing surveys is ab-
tionship of several big cities and
important and strategic for the success solutely essential. In addition, in house no
their respective high speed and
of the system as a whole. rail business activities are a common feature
transit system. Available on the
of high speed stations, due to the important
Their location has to be optimised UIC high speed website:
volume of customers visiting daily.
so as to take advantage of the reduced travel www.uic.org/highspeed
times. They also have to be well connected
22 HIGH SPEED RAIL AND THE CUSTOMERS 23
DESIGN CONCEPTS
FOR HIGH SPEED
SERVICES
At the beginning of this brochure, it says that the high speed rail encompasses a complex PR IC IN G SY ST EMS D IST R IBUT IO N
reality involving many technical aspects such as infrastructure, rolling stock and opera-
tions, as well as strategic and cross-sector issues including human factors and financial, High speed railway undertakings increa- High speed travellers expect high speed
commercial, and managerial components. In addition, the high speed rail system com- singly use variable prices for different types access to information, reservation and
bines all these various elements by using the highest level of technology and the most of service. Depending on travel purposes ticket purchase.
advanced conception for each of them. (business or private), travel periods or other
But all these elements are compiled and coordinated just for one objective: transpor- circumstances influencing demand, including MA R K ET SH A R E
ting passengers. Consequently, this is the main focus to keep in mind at any stage of the the conditions of purchase, the loyalty and the
process to build or operate any high speed system risk taken (possibility to be refunded in case If a new high speed rail system is well de-
of a change, prices can vary considerably). signed and implemented, the customer res-
In terms of commercial concepts, a broad Various procedures, some imported from ponse is, as a rule, very positive and traffic
range of criteria may underpin high-perfor- the airlines like yield management (which will reliably grow.
mance passenger rail transport systems: aims to maximise the income per train, when Traffic growth can be boosted by mobility
Marketing procedures, including trade- reservation is mandatory for all trains), gains and shifts from other transport modes.
marks, and advertising widespread use of Internet, for information Increasing the rail network also contributes
Information, reservation and and dematerialisation of tickets as well as to traffic expansion. The network effect
ticketing systems the introduction of innovative ideas (like is such that the passenger traffic can grow
Ticket control (including the possibility iD TGV and Ouigo in France) are consistent proportionally more than the total length
of access control) with the high-level technology used in trains, of the network.
On-board customer services, including lines and signalling systems.
WI-FI, and computer aids
DESIGN FOR CUSTOMERS
Post-travel services.
New customer requirements require new
SERVI CES THAT HI GH (*) Freedom means
designs: working and meeting areas, spaces
SPEED CAN OFFER that high speed rail
CUSTOMERS is the only passenger for families, full accessibility, special conside-
transport mode in ration for luggage (larger capacity for tourist
which it is not obliga-
Commercial speed tory to be seated, use
trips, but limited spaces for business trips).
Frequency seat belts or listen to From the technical point of view, as more
Accessibility safety instructions. customers are using mobile phones and com-
While travelling in a
Comfort puters, new facilities such as electric plug
high speed train it is
Attractive travel time (door-to-door) possible to stand or sockets for power supply and on-board WI-FI
Reliability sit, walk around the are expected.
train, have a coffee,
Safety
work on a laptop or
Freedom(*). use a mobile phone
at any time.
UIC study on High speed and territory management is available on
the UIC-High Speed website: www.uic.org/highspeed.
24 ECONOMY AND FINANCES FOR HIGH SPEED RAIL 25
THE COST
OF HIGH SPEED
RAIL SYSTEM
MA GN IT UD E O F C O ST S O F H IGH SPEED S Y S T E M S
90,000
MAINTENANCE OF 1 KM OF NEW HIGH
SPEED LINE (PER YEAR)
1M
MAINTENANCE OF A HIGH SPEED TRAIN
PER YEAR (2/KM-500,000 KM/TRAIN & YEAR)
K EY ELEMEN T S T O R ED UC E C O ST S
KNOWLEDGE OF OPTIMAL
MARKET
HIGH SPEED SYSTEMS HIGH SPEED
PROCEDURES
& ELEMENTS RAIL SYSTEM
DEFINITION
F U NDING /C ALC ULATI ON COSTS OF MAX SPEED STANDARDISATION FINANCING
& PERFORMANCE
High speed requires significant investment bilities between different public bodies
requiring public funding. Consequently, In some cases, private funding can be
detailed studies traffic forecasts, costs and attracted for part of the investment
benefits encompassing all the positive and PPP (PublicPrivate Partnership)
negative impacts of a project, including or BOT (BuildOperateTransfer) are
in comparison with the doing nothing sce- two possible ways of coordinating to com-
nario are needed. bine public and private resources:
The cost of high speed lines are gene- Private funds obtains Return On Invest-
rally paid for out of public funds ment (ROI)
(Japan, Europe, and Korea) Public funds ensures social benefits.
The trend is to share funding and responsi- (see external costs page 9)
Legend
Commercial operation over 250 km/h
Under construction or planned over 250 km/h
Commercial operation less 250 km/h
Turku !
Under construction or planned less 250 km/h " Helsinki Saint Petersburg
Oslo " !
Others " Stockholm " Tallinn
Gothenburg ! Jnkping
!
" Riga
Edinburgh Kazan
Glasgow ! ! Copenhagen " " !
! Malm Moscow
Vilnius
Gdansk "
!
Leeds
Manchester ! Hamburg " Minsk
Dublin " ! !
Amsterdam Berlin Pozna
Birmingham! " ! " ! d
Hannover "
! Warsaw
London " Antwerp ! Wroclaw
! ! Koln Leipzig !
"
Brussels Krakow " Kiev
Luxembourg Praha " !
" Brno
Paris !
" Vienna Bratislava
Rennes ! ! ""
! Basel Munich
" Budapest Chisinau
Bern " "
Ljubljana " Zagreb
Lyon ! Milan ! Venice "
! Belgrade
Bordeaux ! ! "
Turin ! Bologna
Toulouse ! Sarajevo " Bucharest
San Sebastian Genoa ! Florence "
La Coruna !
! ! !
Marseille Podgorica Sofia
Zaragoza " "
Rome " " Skopje Edirne
! ! Istanbul
Oporto ! ! Barcelona ! "
!
Naples ! Tirana Ankara
Madrid " Bari !
Bursa " Sivas
! Valencia !
Lisbon " ! Kayseri
! Alicante Izmir !
Sevilla ! Murcia Athens " Konya !
!
! Almeria !
Cadiz ! ! Antalya !
Malaga Adana
Tangier !
0 400 800 1600
Kenitra ! Oujda Kilometers
! Fes
! !Taza
Rabat "
Input UIC Members
Situation as in 4.2015 (information given by railway members)
! Marrakech
28 HIGH SPEED RAIL AROUND THE WORLD 29
A S IA USA
1
Harbin ! 2
rmqi Changchun
! !
Sapporo
!
Shenyang
! ! Hakodate-Hokuto
Hohhot Beijing 1
! ! Shin-Aomori ! Sacramento
Kunming
! " Taipei
Under Construction or planned over 250 km/h
Kilometers
0 75 150 300 ! ! Philadelphia
! ! Kaohsiung Commercial operation less 250 km/h
Nanning Guangzhou
Under Construction or planned less 250km/h
! Haikou
!
Washington
Input UIC Members
0 300 600 1200
Kilometers
30 F U N D A M E N T A L VA L U E S O F H I G H S P E E D R A I L 31
COMPREHENSIVE
PROTECTION
understanding of the cultural, social and The second step is to identify, for each
economic environment where railways potential event, the existing measures
are implemented and operating, is the first that deal with the effects (prediction of
step towards the high speed rail comprehen- effects, detection and forecast measures,
sive protection and the consequent consi- prevention of effects during the operation,
deration as an attractive mode of transport. eventually mitigation by fixed measures and
In order to ensure the civil defence and eventually curative measures when the po-
the resilience of railway systems, the role tential event occurred.
of emergency services and crisis manage-
ment is essential, with the aim of mitigating Beyond certain thresholds, natural risks are:
the consequences. High temperature
To complete the previous protection con- Low temperature
cepts, it is necessary consider that rail Snow
transport is vulnerable in the face of natural Frost
disasters, extreme climate conditions and Change of humidity or high humidity
High speed rail related people (customers, workers, outsiders) equipment and premises particular geographic situations. A signifi- Strong sunshine
in particular need protection. cant part of high speed lines in the world Strong wind
The high volume of passengers carried and their expectations as customers (they expect a high are subject to strong weather conditions Sand and dust
level quality of service), the number of staff involved, the value of the required investments, and the impacts on the railway systems and Heavy rain
in both infrastructure and rolling stock, the operation speed, much higher than other transport the operation can be numerous. Flood
modes, the operational performance, etc., makes it necessary to consider protection against Advanced technologies allow some situa- Thunderstorms
any kind of risk. Customers and business partners are confident in how the railway is run and tions to be anticipated and to propose some Embankment collapse
what is being done to secure the railways. This is the origin of the concept of Comprehensive tools to eliminate or just limit the risks ge- Fallen rocks
protection for high speed rail systems, which is the addition of safety, security, civil defence nerated by the environment. Seismic events
and natural risk protection. Even if in certain languages there is no difference between them, In any case, the first step in order to en- Slope fire
there is a big difference between the concepts of safety and security. sure the protection is to identify, for each Fog smoke
risk, the potential dangerous events that Fallen leaves
SAF E T Y & SE C UR I TY could happen, involving just one of the
subsystems integrating the entire railway
Safety is the protection against techni- In contrast to the previous concept, secu-
system (track, catenary, equipment, substa-
cal failures and can be related with many rity is the protection against any kind
tions, signalling and telecommunications),
different elements (signalling, operations, of attack or malicious intent, from graf-
or a combination of several of them.
maintenance quality, training, etc.). The pro- fiti to robbery, vandalism or terrorist acts.
tection is an almost exclusive responsibility These acts correspond to someones will
of railway companies and is independent and must be coordinated by authorities. As
of any human desire (even in the most these are unpredictable, it is not always use-
negligent behaviour, nobody wants a de- ful to look at statistics or historical records. UIC study on Extreme
railment). Statistic and historical series can Security events affect the population and natural conditions for high speed
be established and through assessing and have a heavy impact on governments, systems is available on the UIC-
managing the inherent railway system risks regulating bodies, etc. High Speed website: www.uic.
it is possible to ensure that the rail transport Security management must go beyond org/highspeed
system is safe and reliable. the most obvious of scenarios and a true
32 F U N D A M E N T A L VA L U E S O F H I G H S P E E D R A I L 33
S TA NDA RDS F OR HI GH
S P E E D RAIL SY S T EMS
RESEARCH
& DEVELOPMENT
FUTURE REQUIREMENTS FOR ROLLING STOCK TO BE *LCC = Life Cycle Cost Human factors
CONSIDERED (FROM REPORT ON FUTURE NEEDS AND *RAMS = Reliability, Ergonomics, accessibility for PRM*, cab
REQUIREMENTS FOR ROLLING STOCK) Availability, Maintena-
design, cabin design, i.e. seating, toilet,
bility, Safety
*EMC = Electro- luggage space.
Business & technical management Environment Magnetic Compati-
Development-procurement-approval-de- CO 2 , other gas, and energy, EMC*, noise, Technology
bility
ployment, LCC*, RAMS*, standardisation and LCA*, extreme climate. *LCA = Life Cycle Body and bogie structure, power and bra-
modularity, etc. Aerodynamics Assessment king system, on board train control and
*PRM = People with information system, new auxiliary power
Aerodynamic resistance, tunnel micro-pres-
Basic dimension & performance Reduced Mobility
units, coupling system.
sure wave, flying ballast.
Capacity, loading gauge, axle load, train and
car length, configuration of train set, compa- Comfort
tibility with infrastructure, maximum speed, Ride comfort, noise abatement, tilting sys-
acceleration and deceleration. tem, airtight structure, air conditioning,
passenger service.
Safety and security
Stability, crash resistance, fire safety, crosswind.
THE FUTURE
Maximum speeds in the range More environmentally-friendly (noise,
of 320 -360km/h energy efficiency):
More availability of infrastructure Improvements on safety, security
New conception of infrastructure and comfort
elements: ballasted or unballasted Cross winds, typhoons and earthquake
T ODAYS T E C H NO LOGY I S FULLY COMPETI TI VE track, new fastening systems detection, etc.
New materials (i.e. catenary wires) New technologies (telecommunications,
However it will not continue to be com- speed systems (infrastructure, tracks, elec- Standardisation and modularity WI-FI, etc.).
petitive beyond the next 20 years without tric power supply, signalling, rolling stock, of rolling stock
investments in research and develop- operation and control elements, safety
ment, because the other transport modes and security devices, etc.) must take into
IN T H E C O MIN G Y EA R S, H IGH SPEED R A I L O P E RA-
are quickly evolving and compete more account requirements from customers,
T O R S W ILL R EQ UIR E BUSIN ESS C O N C EPT S T O D E AL
strongly with high speed rail. society, operators, etc.
W IT H T H E FO LLO W IN G:
Research and development for future high
More capacity (double deck &/or 2 + 3 Further reductions in fees for infrastructure use
instead of 2 + 2 rows of seats) More energy efficiency and less energy
Greater availability and maintainability consumption
of trains (RAMS) Optimisation of operating costs (i.e. during
Further reductions in costs of procurement low occupancy)
and maintenance (LCC) Globalisation
38 H I G H S P E E D R A I L AT U I C 39
www.uic.org
ISBN 978-2-7461-1887-4
June 2015