Sei sulla pagina 1di 10

See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at:


https://www.researchgate.net/publication/223055639

Decolorization of Textile Industry


Wastewater by Photo Catalytic
Degradation Process

Article in Dyes and Pigments May 2001


DOI: 10.1016/S0143-7208(01)00014-6

CITATIONS READS

321 463

4 authors, including:

Orfan Zahraa
University of Lorraine
81 PUBLICATIONS 1,438 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Orfan Zahraa on 31 July 2015.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125
www.elsevier.com/locate/dyepig

Decolourization of textile industry wastewater by the


photocatalytic degradation process
C. Hachem 1, F. Bocquillon, O. Zahraa, M. Bouchy *
Departement de Chimie Physique des Reactions - UMIR 7630 CNRS ENSIC, 1, rue Grandville, BP 451,
F-54001 - Nancy Cedex, France

Received 24 October 2000; received in revised form 4 December 2000; accepted 15 March 2001

Abstract
The photocatalytic degradation of various dyes (Orange II, Orange G, Congo Red, Indigo Carmine, Crystal Violet,
Malachite Green, Remazol Blue and Methyl Yellow) has been studied, using P25 Degussa as catalyst. All dye solutions
underwent a decolourization. The kinetics of reaction have been studied and were found to be zero or rst order with
respect to the dyes. This was compared with the adsorption properties. The eect of the addition of hydrogen peroxide
has been studied. An enhancement of the rate has been observed in all cases and the order with respect to the additive
was found to be almost zero. It is dicult to give a general picture of the kinetics using these very dierent dyes but the
process was found to be eective for the decolourization of textile wastewater. # 2001 Published by Elsevier Science
Ltd.
Keywords: Dyes; Decolourization; Photocatalysis; Kinetics; Hydrogen peroxide; Textile industry

1. Introduction currently used, which work by direct precipitation


and separation of pollutants [4], or elimination by
Textile industry wastewater is heavily charged adsorption on activated carbon or similar materi-
with unconsumed dyes, surfactants and sometimes als. In this case, the problem is only displaced, and
traces of metals. These euents cause a lot of further treatments are indeed necessary in order to
damage to the environment. In most countries separate the puried euents or to regenerate the
researchers are looking for appropriate treatments adsorbents; therefore, a new and dierent risk of
in order to remove pollutants, impurities and to pollution is faced [5]. Alternatively, a photochemical
obtain the decolourization of dyehouse euents approach has been adopted. Indeed, ultraviolet
[13]. Various chemical and physical processes are irradiation combined or not with oxidative agents
such as ozone or hydrogen peroxide leads to a com-
plete destruction of the pollutants [69], but the
presence of intermediates arising from the photo-
* Corresponding author.
degradation reaction could be more harmful than
E-mail addresses: michel.bouchy@ensic.inpl- nancy.fr (M.
Bouchy), orfan.zahraa@ensic.inpl- nancy.fr (O. Zahraa). the pollutant itself [10,11]. Such inconvenience can
1
Present address: Chemistry Department, Faculty of Sci- be avoided by using the photocatalytic degrada-
ences, Damascus University. tion. In this process, hydroxyl radicals (OH ) are
0143-7208/01/$ - see front matter # 2001 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd.
PII: S0143-7208(01)00014-6
118 C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125

generated when the photocatalyst is illuminated in Fluka. Puried water was obtained from an Elix
the presence of water and air [1214], these ultra Millipore equipment. The titanium dioxide used,
reactive species associated with oxygen are able to TITANDIOXID P25 Degussa, was about 70%
achieve a complete mineralization of organic pol- anatase. According to the manufacturers speci-
lutants into carbon dioxide, water and other non- cations [17], the elementary particle in dry powder
toxic products [15,16]. was approximately spherical in shape with a size
The aim of this study is to analyse the kinetics of of 20 nm. The specic surface area, as measured
decolourization of various types of dyes and to by N2 adsorption at 77 K, was 44 m2 g1 [18].
assess the inuence additives have on the process. The experimental set-up for the photocatalytic
decolourization has been described previously [19].
The photocatalyst has been deposited on 3.848
2. Experimental procedures cm2 glass plates from a suspension of TiO2.

2.1. Materials 2.2. Procedure

The dyes Orange II, Orange G, Congo Red, A suspension of commercial Degussa P25 TiO2
Indigo Carmine, Crystal Violet, Malachite Green, of 4 g l1 in pure water was prepared, the pH was
Remazol Blue and Methyl Yellow were commercial adjusted to about 3 and it was sonicated. A given
products purchased from Sigma Chemical Co., and volume suspension was carefully poured on the
used without further purication (see Fig. 1). glass plate and allowed to dry out at 100 C for a
Hydrogen peroxide (30%, w/w) was obtained from few hours.

Fig. 1. Developed formulae of various dyes used in this study.


C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125 119

After drying, the plate was red at 475 C for 4 h solution was 0.2 l. The solution was continuously
(Fig. 2). During the heating, OH groups from the circulated with a peristaltic pump, owing freely
catalyst surface and the support can react and lose a over the catalytic surface and stirred in the 0.1 l
molecule of water, creating an oxygen bridge, thus tank and could be considered as being constantly
increasing the adherence of the catalyst to the air-equilibrated. The circulating ow was 0.4 l
support. Before deposition, the glass surface was min1.
treated using a dilute acid solution of HF and As the extent of adsorption or photocatalytic
washed in a basic solution of NaOH in order to degradation was very small during a single pass
increase the number of OH groups. The suspension (0.5 min), the whole system could be considered as
concentration 4 g l1 was chosen so as to get thin a perfectly stirred sealed reactor with respect to
enough deposits. This deposition process was car- the solution. Irradiation of the photocatalyst was
ried out four times in succession so as to increase carried out by a MAZDA-TFN18 18 W UV
the total thickness. As shown in Fig. 3, the rst uorescent lamp emitting around 365 nm and
coat does not cover all the surface but additional positioned parallel to the plate. The average ux
coats lead to a complete coverage. on the plate was estimated to be about 2.103 E
After each run, the catalyst was washed and min1 m2 [20]. Adsorption measurements were
irradiated for several hours in the presence of H2O2 made using the same set-up in the absence of
so that it was regenerated. irradiation.
Electron microscopy was carried out on a Jeol Absorption measurements to monitor the dye
T33OA scanning microscope with the help of the concentration in the aqueous phase were carried
LSGC Laboratory. Prolometry measurements out on a Lambda-2 Perkin-Elmer UV/vis spectro-
were carried out on a UBM optical prolometer photometer.
equipped with a MICROFOCUS probe. Fig. 4
shows the topology of a TiO2 deposit which shows
a uniform surface of roughness of about 5 mm. In 3. Results and discussion
addition, the average thickness was estimated to
be 10 mm [20]. BET areas were determined on a The kinetics of photocatalytic degradation of the
FISON Sorptomatic 1900 sorptometer. various dyes are pictured in Fig. 6ag, as the
Photocatalytic measurements were carried out decrease in the relative concentration C/C  of the
on a homemade reactor designed for testing 3.8 dye with the time of irradiation, where C is the run-
48 cm2 at glass plates carrying the deposited lm ning concentration and C the concentration at the
of catalyst (Fig. 5). The total volume of aqueous beginning of the irradiation. Note that the solution

Fig. 2. Procedure for the preparation of the TiO2 deposits.


120 C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125

Fig. 4. Prologram of a TiO2 deposit.

Acid dyes, Orange II, Orange G, Remazol Blue


and Indigo Carmine exhibited a low adsorption
and in most cases A was not measurable (within
the experimental error of about 0.02). Alterna-
tively, cationic dyes, Malachite Green and Crystal
Violet were easily adsorbed. This dierence can be
attributed to a higher solvation energy for acid
dyes. The sulphonate group can indeed allow the
formation of hydrogen bonds contrary to the
quaternary amines of the cationic dyes [21]. As a
consequence, the equilibrium between the adsorbed
and the solvated forms is more in favour of the
Fig. 3. Electron micrographs of P25 deposits (top: rst coat; adsorption for the cationic than the acid dyes. The
bottom: 4 coats). pH is about 5.5, and, therefore, is close to the iso-
electric pH of 5.8 [22] where the solid surface has a
neutral global charge; there is then little segrega-
was allowed to equilibrate with the catalyst prior to tion according to the charge of the ions. The direct
irradiation so that C is lower that the actual dye Congo Red, which possesses sulphonate
initial concentration of the sample Ci. A typical groups, exhibited a high adsorption (A=0.1),
experiment is given in Fig. 7. which can be attributed to both the high molecular
weight of this molecule compared to the other
3.1. Adsorption on the catalyst acid, and the large hydrophobic middle section.
At a very acid pH, the acid dyes are in neutral
As a rule, adsorption was quite fast and the form, which is less hydrophilic than the ionic form,
equilibrium concentration C was reached within and adsorb strongly. For example, at pH 1.3,
about 45 min. The contact was carried out up to 90 Orange II undergoes a fast and strong adsorption
min, but no signicant change in the concentration leading to a visible colourization of the catalyst.
was observed. Under these conditions, practically no photo-
Although the initial concentrations of the vari- catalytic degradation was observed, which was
ous dyes were comparable, the equilibrium value attributed to a complete coverage of the surface.
for C varied indicating dierent adsorption This indeed prohibits the adsorption of H2O or
properties. The fraction of dye adsorbed was OH on the surface, and inhibits the initial process
expressed as A=(CiC )/Ci as given in Table 1. of formation of the reactive hydroxyl radicals.
C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125 121

Fig. 5. Experimental set-up for reactant adsorption and photocatalytic degradation.

3.2. Kinetics of photocatalytic degradation These orders can be considered to be associated


with the limiting cases of the common Langmuir
The rate of photocatalytic degradation was Hinshelwood model. In this simple model the rate
determined as the rate of disappearance of the r is expressed as [14,23]:
dye. This degradation also is the decolourization  
process, as the possible intermediates formed did KC
r k
not absorb in the visible range. The disappearance 1 KC
was, therefore, followed by absorption in the visible
range. The rate of degradation was expressed as where k is a rate constant (function of the light ux)
the intrinsic rate relatively to the area of deposit and K the adsorption constant. At low adsorption,
(i.e. the area of the glass support) under given r is equal to kKC (order 1) and at high adsorption, r
conditions of catalyst load (12.5 g m2) and intrin- is equal to k (order 0).
sic light ux (2.0 103 E min1 m2); the rate was However, no correlation between the adsorption
then expressed in units of mol min1 m2 deposit. This and the order can be found in the results given in
is of practical interest in designing a photoreactor Table 1. For example, low adsorption dyes,
as doubling the irradiated deposited area doubles Orange II and Orange G, have an order of 1 and 0
the rate of degradation in the reactor. Note that respectively. This can arise from the existence of
this deposit area is not to be mistaken with the specic reactive sites on the surface; these could be
much larger catalyst surface area. The kinetics associated with ecient traps favouring the forma-
were found to be of order 0 or 1 with respect to tion of a reactive hydroxyl radical. If these sites are
the dye. Plotting either C/C or ln (C/C ) versus relatively few with respect to all the sites, the total
time checked the validity of the order. Discriminat- adsorption does not reect the adsorption on these
ing between the two orders requires an extent of specic sites. Therefore, there may be a stronger
reaction higher than 0.3, which is not always the eective adsorption of Orange G compared to
case. When the extent was small, the order has been Orange II. According to the LH model, the rate
assumed to be the same as in experiments carried would reach a maximum value at high adsorption
out in the presence of H2O2 as an accelerating agent. (order 0). However, the rate for Orange G is lower
It can be veried indeed in the case of fast than the rate for Orange II. This discrepancy could
degradations that the order was not altered in the be attributed to a dierent reactivity, which is
presence of this agent. expressed by the rate constant k. The fragile group
122 C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125

Fig. 6. (a) Photocatalytic degradation of Orange II following dark adsorption (&C =9.9 105 mol l1, irradiation ux 7 107 E
min1); eect of H2O2 (&103 mol l1, * 102 mol l1, * 2 102 mol l1, ~ 5 102 mol l1, ~ 101 mol l1). (b) Photocatalytic
degradation of Orange G (C =9.9 105 mol l1), same conditions as in Fig. 6a. (c) Photocatalytic degradation of Congo Red (C =3.5
105 mol l1), same conditions as in Fig. 6a. (d) Photocatalytic degradation of Indigo Carmine (C =9.5 105 mol l1), same condi-
tions as in Fig. 6a. (e) Photocatalytic degradation of Crystal Violet (C =1.8 105 mol l1), same conditions as in Fig. 6a. (f) Photo-
catalytic degradation of Malachite Green (C =1.9 105 mol l1), same conditions as in Fig. 6a. (g) Photocatalytic degradation of
Remazol Blue (C =9.6 105 mol l1), same conditions as in Fig. 6a.
C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125 123

Cationic dyes exhibit a relatively high adsorp-


tion but the rate of degradation is only twice that
of the low adsorbing Orange II. Moreover,
according to an order of the unity with respect to
the dye, the rate of degradation of the cationic
dyes would be higher at the initial concentration
of the acid dyes (104 mol l1). However, both
adsorption and reactivity play a role in the global
kinetics. It is probable that the azo group is more
likely to be attacked via the abstraction of H on
the NH form by the reactive species, assumed to
be the hydroxyl radical, than the phenyl groups
Fig. 7. Variation of the dye concentration vs. time, showing the via addition. The reactivity of Remazol Blue can
dark adsorption (negative time) followed by the irradiation also be attributed to the presence of an NH group.
at time t=0 (Crystal Violet). The dispersed dye Methyl Yellow has a very low
solubility in water. Solvents such as methanol and
in these dyes is the NH group, which results from dimethylformamide have been used in order to get
an equilibrium between two tautomeric forms [21] a homogeneous solution. A very high rate of
where an H atom is exchanged between O and N as decolourization was then observed, which suggests
shown in Fig. 8. This equilibrium is much inu- a process involving the additional solvent, but this
enced by the electron-attracting sulphonate was not further studied, as the addition of the
groups, which would result in an enhancement in organic solvent cannot be envisaged in an indus-
the amine form in the case of Orange II. Accord- trial process.
ingly, although the adsorption is lower for this dye,
a high reactivity leads to a higher rate of photo- 3.3. Limiting processes
catalytic degradation compared with Orange G.
This shows the diculty in comparing the photo- It is of interest to compare the rate of adsorp-
catalytic degradability of the various dyes. tion ra with the rate of degradation r . This rate ra

Table 1
Properties and kinetics parameters of various dyes

Dye Orange II Orange G Congo Indigo Crystal Malachite Remazol Methyl


Red Carmine Violet Green Blue Yellow

Class Acid Acid Direct Acid Cationic Cationic Reactive Dispersed


Type Azo Azo Diazo Carbonyl Triphenyl Triphenyl Quinon Azo
Color index 15,510 16,230 22,120 73,015 42,555 42,000 61,200 11,020
lmax (nm) 485 480 498.5 610 590 617 595 448
Initial concentration 8.9 9.9 3.9 9.7 2.0 2.0 9.6
Ci (mol l1)105
A <0.02 < 0.02 0.1 0.02 0.1 0.06 <0.02
Initial rate of deg radiation 1.07 0.42 0.38 1.84 1.90 1.92 1.04a 13.44b
r (mol min1 m2)105
Order/dye 1 0 0 0 1 1 0
r H2 O2/r c 2.8 3.7 2 7 1.4 1.5 4.6
Order/H2O2 >0 0 >0 0 >0 >0 >0
" (l mol1 cm1)105 4.48 0.23 0.49 0.22 0.92 0.86 0.13
a
pH=2.85.
b
Average degradation rate over 150 min.
c
(H2O2)=102 mol l1.
124 C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125

Fig. 8. Equilibrium between the two tautomeric forms in the acid dye Orange II.

can only be estimated if the amount of adsorption


is large enough to allow a measurable decrease in
the dye concentration in the aqueous solution.
This is the case of half the dyes only. As the reac-
tion of degradation follows the adsorption, the
initial rate r is necessarily lower than the initial
rate ra . This is eectively the case in Congo Red
where the ratio r /ra is equal to about 0.4 but the
situation is the reverse in the case of the cationic
dyes where r /ra is equal to about 2.5 and 6.5 for
Crystal Violet and Malachite Green, respectively.
This infers that the adsorption process involved in
the degradation is much faster than the adsorption Fig. 9. Eect of the addition of H2O2 on the initial rate r of
monitored prior to irradiation. This could be due degradation of the dyes (conditions as in Table 1); * Orange
II, * Orange G, ^ Congo Red, ^ Indigo Carmine ( 1/2), ~
the existence of dierent types of sites as suggested
Crystal Violet, ~ Malachite Green, & Remazol Blue.
above or to an enhancement of the adsorption rate
in the presence of irradiation. Another important
process involved in the mechanism is the transport
process. This latter is very fast: as an example, The picture above is a general trend. However,
when a rapid adsorption takes place for Orange H some dyes exhibit a slight dierence. For example,
in acid medium, the initial rate is noticeably higher Congo Red, Orange II and Malachite Green do
than the largest degradation rate observed for the exhibit a slightly positive order with respect to H2O2
most reactive dyes in the presence of H2O2. in the range 102101 mol l1. The case of Orange
II is of special interest as the rate goes through a
3.4. Eect of H2O2 maximum when increasing the concentration of the
additive. This eect could be due to a competition
Usually this additive is known to increase the for adsorption between the dye and the additive.
rate of photocatalytic degradation by allowing an This is in agreement with a low adsorption of this
enhancement in the quantum yield of formation of dye as suggested above.
hydroxyl radical [24,25]. This is observed indeed Addition of H2O2 does not seem to alter the basic
for all dyes in the present study as shown in Fig. 9. kinetics, as the order with respect to the dye is not
In most cases, a limiting rate is reached when modied. The eect could only be due to an increase
increasing the additive concentration, so that there in the OH radical formation. This suggests a similar
is little change between the addition of 102 or limiting value of the rate of decolourization of the
101 mol l1. Addition of a concentration of 103 various dyes at high additive concentration. This
mol l1 is generally not sucient to increase the ideal case is not strictly observed. However, it can
rate signicantly. Consequently, the eect of the be seen from Table 1 that the lower the intrinsic
additive has been given in Table 1 as the factor of rate, the higher it is increased by the additive.
increase in the initial rate when using a con- Indigo Carmine is a noticeable exception to this
centration of 102 mol l1. rule.
C. Hachem et al. / Dyes and Pigments 49 (2001) 117125 125

4. Conclusion N. TiO2-assisted photodegradation of dye pollutants II.


Adsorption and degradation kinetics of eosin in TiO2 dis-
The photocatalytic process has proved very persions under visible light irradiation. Appl Cat B:
Environ 1998;15:14756.
eective in decolourizing aqueous solutions of the [10] Anderson MA, Yamazaki-Nishida S, Cervera-March S.
various textile dyes. As both adsorption and reac- In: Ollis DF, Al-Ekabi H, editors. Photocatalytic puri-
tivity play a role in the kinetics, it is dicult to get cation and treatment of water and air. Amsterdam:
a satisfactory general picture of the mechanism. Elsevier; 1993. p 40520.
Comparing degradation and adsorption suggests [11] Larson SA, Falconer J. In: Ollis DF, Al-Ekabi H, editors.
Photocatalytic purication and treatment of water and air.
that the degradation takes place on specic types Amsterdam: Elsevier; 1993. p. 4739.
of adsorption sites on the catalyst surface. The [12] Matthews RW. Photooxidation of organic impurities in
order with respect to the dye is either zero or one, water using thin lms of titanium dioxide. J Phys Chem
which may be in relation with a limiting adsorp- 1987;91:332833.
[13] Fox MA. Photocatalysis: decontamination by sunlight.
tion on the active sites. The addition of hydrogen
Chemtech 1992:68096.
peroxide enhances the rate of degradation, which [14] Chen HY, Zahraa O, Bouchy M, Thomas F, Bottero JY.
is of much interest for improving the quantum yield Adsorption properties of TiO2 related to the photo-
of degradation. Finally, it is to be noted that the catalytic degradation of organic contaminants of water. J
irradiation used falls within the UV range avail- Photochem Photobiol A: Chem 1995;85:17986.
able from the sun, which suggests the design of a [15] Tunesi S, Anderson M. Inuence of chemisorption on the
photodecomposition of salicylic acid and related com-
solar photoreactor for a decolourization process in pounds using suspended TiO2 ceramic membrane. J Phys
regions where much solar energy is available. Chem 1991;95:3399405.
[16] Matthews RW, McEvoy SR. A comparison of 254 nm and
350 nm excitation of TiO2 in simple photocatalytic reac-
References tors. J Photochem Photobiol A: Chem 1992;66:35566.
[17] Degussa Corp. Technical bulletin pigments, No. 56. 5th
[1] Galindo C, Jacques P, Kalt A. Photodegradation of the ed. Degussa AG, Frankfurt; 1990.
aminobenzene acid orange 52 by three advanced oxidation [18] Chen HY, Zahraa O, Bouchy M. Inhibition by inorganic
processes: UV/H2O2, UV/TiO2 and VIS/TiO2 compara- ions of the adsorption and the photocatalytic degradation
tive mechanistic and kinetic investigations. J Photochem of organic contaminants in TiO2 aqueous suspension. J
Photobiol A: Chem 2000;130:3547. Photochem Photobiol A: Chem 1997;108:3744.
[2] Akmehmet Balcioglu I, Arslan I. Treatment of textile [19] Zahraa O, Dorion C, Ould-Mame SM, Bouchy M.
industry wastewater by enhanced photocatalytic oxidation Titanium dioxide deposit lms for photocatalytic studies
reaction. J Adv Oxid Technol 1999;4:18995. of water pollutants. J Adv Oxid Technol 1999;4:406.
[3] Porada T, Gade R, Fabler D, Gunther K. Quatum yield [20] Ould-Mame SM. Etude de catalyseurs deposes pour reac-
of TiO2-photocatalysed degradation of Acid Orange 7. J teur photocatalytique de traitement des eaux. PhD thesis.
Adv Oxid Technol 1999;4:2038. Nancy, INPL. 1998.
[4] Wu J, Eiteman MA, Law SE. Evaluation of membrane [21] Galindo C, Jacques P, Kalt A. Total mineralization of an
ltration and ozonation processes for treatment of reac- azo dye [Acid Orange 7] by UV/H2O2 oxidation. J Adv
tive dye wastewater. J Environ Eng 1998;124:2727. Oxid Technol 1999;4:4007.
[5] Homann MR, Martin ST, Choi W, Bahnemann D. [22] Zahraa O, Chen HY, Bouchy M. Photocatalytic degrada-
Environmental applications of semiconductor photo- tion of 1,2-dichloroethane on suspended TiO2. J Adv Oxid
catalysis. Chem Rev 1995;95:6996. Technol 1999;4:16773.
[6] Majcen-Le Marechal A, Slokar YM, Taufer T. Decolora- [23] Mills A, Davies R. In: Ollis DF, Al-Ekabi H, editors.
tion of chlorotriazine reactive azo dyes with H2O2/UV. Photocatalytic purication and treatment of water and air.
Dyes and Pigments 1997;33:2818. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 1993. p. 595600.
[7] Galindo C, Kalt Y, Taufer A. UV/H2O2 oxidation of [24] Salvador P, Decker F. On the generation of H2O2 during
azodyes in aqueous media: evidence of a structure water photoelectrolysis at n-TiO2. J Phys Chem 1984;
degradability relationship. Dyes and Pigments 1999;42: 88:611620.
199207. [25] Jenny B, Pichat P. Determination of the actual photo-
[8] Kuo W. Decolorizing dye wastewater with Fentons catalytic rate of H2O2 decomposition over suspended
reagent. Wat Res 1992;26:8816. TiO2. Fitting to the LangmuirHinshelwood form. Lang-
[9] Zhang F, Zhao J, Shen T, Hidaka H, Pelizetti E, Serpone muir 1991;7:94754.

View publication stats

Potrebbero piacerti anche