11/24/2016 HowtoDesignaTransferFloor

transferload,howto,evaluationofloads,framestaticanalysis,transfer

floordesign
Search

HomeStructuralEngineeringHowtoDesignaTransferFloor

Building Colddrawnsteelwire
Construction Increaseresistancetohightemperaturesanddecreasedeformations.
FloorTypes Gotofibrometals.ae
BuildingJoints StepsinDesigningaTransferFloor
StoneMasonry WhatistheLoadingonaTransferFloor?
Dampnessin
Design of reinforced concrete transfer floors, although routinely
Buildings Advertisements performedbystructuraldesignengineers,isaverychallengingtask.
Building Thetransferfloorsarecommonlyusedinmultistoreybuildings,and
1 CivilEngineeringPDFBooks
ConstructionJobs they are major structural elements carrying a number of floors.
Hydraulic Normallytheentirebuilding,10to15levels,iscarriedbyatransfer
2 CivilEngineeringSoftware slabs.
Structures
Structural The major problem is the evaluation of the loading on the transfer
3 StructuralSteelDesign
Engineering slab, especially the columns and walls terminating at the transfer
Typesof level.Whenacolumnterminatesonatransferbeam,itwillcarrya
4 StructuralDesignSoftware smallerloadsincethebeamsupportingthecolumnisactingasan
Structures
elastic spring. The smaller the beam depth, the smaller the axial
MinimumSteel load in the transfer column. In this case the load is distributed to
Reinforcement 5 FreeeBookDownloads
other columns which are continuous to the footing level. In an
RCCStructure extreme case if we remove the support below the transfer column,
Components the axial load will be reduced to zero, i.e. the column will be
"hanging"onthefloorsabovetakingnoload.
PostTensioningin
Slabs
Prestressingin Theotherchallengeisconsideringthemethodofconstruction.Inany3Dframestaticanalysisweassumethatthe
entire load is applied on the complete structure simultaneously. While in
Concrete
realitytheloadisgraduallyappliedonseveralfloorsastheyareconstructed.
SteelStructures For instance, if we imagine that the entire structure is propped and all the
Structural props are removed after the concrete is fully set, the static analysis will
Analysis capturethestructuralbehavioradequately.Butifthepropsateachfloorare
removed before the floor above is constructed, the static analysis will not
Indeterminate
provideaccurateresults.
StructureAnalysis
BeamAnalysis Ontheotherhand,byusingtheTributaryAreamethodweassumethatthe
Tool entireloadisappliedonthetransferslab,ignoringthestructurefromabove.
This approach will produce the largest possible loading at the transfer column, at the expense of loading to the
TrussAnalysis continuous columns. This approach is considered more conservative, however we may say that it is more
Methods conservativeforthemidspans,atthetransfercolumnsitwillunderestimatetheloadingatanotherlocationsuchas
SFD&BMDof continuouscolumns,sincethetotalloadonthefloormustremainthesame.
Beams
Basicallythemodelingapproachordesignassumptionswillinfluencetheevaluationoftheloadingonthetransfer
BeamAnalysis slab,andultimatelyitwillinfluencetheentiredesignofthestructuralsystem.
Formulas
BridgeEngineering
Adsby Google FoundationDesign BeamDesign SlabDesign
Designing
Neither of these two approaches can be considered superior or more precise, nor more or less conservative.
Instead, we suggest that a very good understanding of the influence of the modeling assumptions and all input
parametersonthefinalresultsisessentialinordertoanalyzeanddesignatransferslab.

Strategy1:EvaluationoftheTransferFloorLoadingbyTributaryAreaMethod

TraditionallywemayevaluatetheloadingonthetransferfloorbyTributaryAreaapproach,ignoringtheflexibilityof
thetransferslabs,anditsinfluenceontheloaddistribution.Also,thetransferslabsmaybeanalyzedindependently,
separatedfromtherestofthestructureandignoringtheflexibilityofthesupportingcolumnsandtheirinfluenceon
thebendingmomentinthetransferbeamsandslab.

Civil
1 Engineering
http://www.aboutcivil.org/transferfloordesignhowto.html 1/3
11/24/2016 HowtoDesignaTransferFloor
Engineering
PDFBooks

Civil
2 Engineering
Software

Structural
3 SteelDesign

Thisapproachwillprovidenovariationinthepointloadsonthetransfer slab. In the figure above (Fig. 2) the two

pointloadsatthemiddleareidentical,regardlessofthesupportingconditionsbelow.
Structural
4 Design
Thisapproachiscommonlyusedanditisconsideredmoreconservative.
Software Its shortcoming is that the load distribution is uniform, ignoring the
influence of the structure itself. The point loads on the transfer slab are
FreeeBook
5 internal forces in the columns above and their magnitude is affected by
Downloads
relative stiffness all structural elements. However, treating the transfer
slab independently and ignoring the rest of the structure is a more
conservativeanalyticalapproach.
Building
6 Construction
Wewillfollowthroughanumericalexampletoillustratethemajorpoints.If
Books weusedR/CBUILDINGsoftwareandifwesetallcolumnsonthetransfer
slabtohavea"footing"support,wecanobtainthesameresultsasthetributaryareamethod.(Fig3)
SteelDesign
7 Solutions
Strategy2:EvaluationofTransferLoadingby3DFrameStaticAnalysis

We can analyze the structure using

Project 1st order static analysis in 3D using
8 Planning R/C BUILDING software, or any
Software other frame analysis software. (Fig.
1) The point loads on the transfer
AboutCi slab will be different form Tributary
234Klikes Area Method. In this case the
reactioninthetransfercolumn(point
loadonthetransferslab)isreduced
significantly,andtheloadingisdistributedontothesurroundingcolumns.
LikePage (Fig 4)This is due to the fact that the transfer column is supported by a beam, which only provides an elastic
support.Inthisexampleweuseda400mmdeepbeam.Ifthebeamdepthisreducedtosay300mmor200mmthe
Bethefirstofyourfriendsto transfercolumnreactionwillbeevensmaller.However,thetotalloadwillremainthesame,butitwillbedistributed
likethis differently.

ThebendingmomentresultsinthetransferbeamareshowninFig.5.Wecanobservethatthesmallerpointloadof
348kNwillgeneraterelativelysmallbendingmomentsinthebeam.

Colddrawnsteelwire
Increaseresistancetohightemperaturesanddecreasedeformations.
Gotofibrometals.ae
Strategy3:"VeryStiff"TransferSlab

Wecanmakethetransferslabandthebeams"verystiff"byassigningadifferentmaterialproperty,say100times
greatermodulusofelasticity.Thiswillmakethetransferfloormuchstifferincomparisontotherestofthestructure
anditwill"enforce"anevendistributionofthecolumnreactions.(Fig.6)

The introduction of a "Very Stiff" beam will have a similar effect on the reactions as the Tributary Area method.
However this will also have an effect on the bending moments in the beam. (Fig 7). The moment magnitude will
increase, and more importantly we may observe
that the negative moment at the column on the
rightis"lost".Thisisduetotheelasticshortening
(squashing) of the columns below, the columns
supportingthetransferslabs.

Strategy4:"VeryStiff"TransferBeamand
PreventedAxialShorteningofColumns
Below

Inadditiontothe"VeryStiff"beamwecanintroduceanincreasedaxialstiffnessofallcolumns,whichincludesthe
columns below the transfer slab. In R/C BUILDING software there is a global switch that will increase the axial
stiffnessofallcolumnsby100or10,000times.Inthisexamplewewillincreasetheaxialstiffnessofthecolumnsby
10,000times.Itisimportanttonotethatwedonotincreasethecolumnsbendingstiffness,sothecolumnbelowwill
notinfluencethebendingofthetransferbeam.
http://www.aboutcivil.org/transferfloordesignhowto.html 2/3
11/24/2016 HowtoDesignaTransferFloor

Inthiscasethereactions(columnloads)willstillbeidentical(Fig.8)

In this case the bending moments will

havetheexpectedshape(Fig.9).But
the moment magnitude has increased
in comparison to the Elastic Analysis
withnoincreasedstiffness,Strategy2.
This is expected since the load is
larger and the transfer beam has
increased stiffness, and therefore
attractslargerinternalforces.Wemay
sayinthiscasethebeammomentsare"moreconservative".

Now we can say that we have "forced" the column reactions on the transfer slabs to be uniform, i.e. to mimic the
TributaryAreamethod,andwehaveincreasedthebendingmomentsinthetransferbeam,asitisworkingbyitself,
i.e.asitisanalyzedasatwospancontinuousbeamignoringtherestofthestructure.

The increased axial stiffness of the columns will affect the lateral stability analysis. It will provide unrealistically
smallerlateraldeflections.Whentheaxialstiffnessofthecolumnsisincreased,themodelcannotbeusedinlateral
stabilityassessment.

EndNotesandRecommendations

The above example illustrates how we can "force" a structural model to behave in a certain manner by assigning
increasedstiffnesstoselectedelementgroups.Theincreaseofthebendingstiffnessofthetransferbeam/slabby
100 times, and the axial stiffness of the column by 10,000 shows that we can obtain similar results as the hand
calculations,usingTributaryAreamethodsandasimpletwospanbeam.

We must note that this drastic increase of the stiffness of selected element groups "distorts" the structural model,
and might result in an unrealistic and unpredictable distribution on the internal forces, and has to be used very
cautiously. Our suggestion is to use middle ground. This can be achieved by assigning a small increase of the
transfer beam/slabs bending stiffness by using a factor of 4 for the modulus of elasticity, and no axial stiffness
increaseofthecolumns.TheresultsareshowninFig.10below.

This approach distributes the column loads on the transfer floor more evenly, but not identical as in the Tributary
AreaMethod.Themidspanbeammoment(belowthetransfercolumn)isalsokeptrelativelylarge.Thisapproach
willprobablyyieldsaferbuteconomicaldesignsofthetransferfloors.

AlKhaleejSteelFactory ReinforcedConcrete MinimumSteel TypicalRoadStructure

BuildingElementsand... Reinforcementin... CrossSectionRoad...

Ad khaleejsteel.com aboutcivil.org aboutcivil.org aboutcivil.org

DeepBeamsConcept, StructureTypesof Analysis&DesignofSlab CivilEngineeringBooks

Applications,... StructuresDefinition&... inSAP2000 DownloadFree,Ebooks,...

aboutcivil.org aboutcivil.org aboutcivil.org aboutcivil.org

SiteMap|CivilEngineeringTraining|ContactUs| |2014WebTechTix

http://www.aboutcivil.org/transferfloordesignhowto.html 3/3