Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
The postulates of Dalton's atomic theory: which points do we still use today, and what
have we learned since Dalton?
Share to Google ClassroomShareTweetEmail
Key Points
Dalton's atomic theory was the first complete attempt
to describe all matter in terms of atoms and their properties.
Dalton based his theory on the law of conservation of
mass and the law of constant composition.
The first part of his theory states that all matter is
made of atoms, which are indivisible.
The second part of the theory says all atoms of a
given element are identical in mass and properties.
The third part says compounds are combinations of
two or more different types of atoms.
The fourth part of the theory states that a chemical
reaction is a rearrangement of atoms.
Parts of the theory had to be modified based on the
discovery of subatomic particles and isotopes.
1.
2.
Summary
Dalton's atomic theory was the first complete attempt to
describe all matter in terms of atoms and their properties.
Dalton based his theory on the law of conservation of
mass and the law of constant composition.
The first part of his theory states that all matter is made
of atoms, which are indivisible.
The second part of the theory says all atoms of a given
element are identical in mass and properties.
The third part says compounds are combinations of two
or more different types of atoms.
The fourth part of the theory states that a chemical
reaction is a rearrangement of atoms.
Parts of the theory had to be modified based on the
existence of subatomic particles and isotopes.
Dalton's Atomic Theory
It was in the early 1800s that John Dalton, an observer of weather and
discoverer of color blindness among other things, came up with his atomic
theory. Let's set the stage for Dalton's work. Less than twenty years earlier,
in the 1780's, Lavoisier ushered in a new chemical era by making careful
quantitative measurements which allowed the compositions of compounds
to be determined with accuracy. By 1799 enough data had been
accumulated for Proust to establish the Law of Constant Composition ( also
called the Law of Definite Proportions). In 1803 Dalton noted that oxygen
and carbon combined to make two compounds. Of course, each had its own
particular weight ratio of oxygen to carbon (1.33:1 and 2.66:1), but also, for
the same amount of carbon, one had exactly twice as much oxygen as the
other. This led him to propose the Law of Simple Multiple Proportions,
which was later verified by the Swedish chemist Berzelius. In an attempt to
explain how and why elements would combine with one another in fixed
ratios and sometimes also in multiples of those ratios, Dalton formulated
his atomic theory.
The idea of atoms had been proposed much earlier. The ancient Greek
philosophers had talked about atoms, but Dalton's theory was different in
that it had the weight of careful chemical measurements behind it. It wasn't
just a philosophical statement that there are atoms because there must be
atoms. His atomic theory, stated that elements consisted of tiny particles
called atoms. He said that the reason an element is pure is because all
atoms of an element were identical and that in particular they had the
same mass. He also said that the reason elements differed from one another
was that atoms of each element were different from one another; in
particular, they had different masses. He also said that compounds
consisted of atoms of different elements combined together. Compounds
are pure substances (remember they cannot be separated into elements by
phase changes) because the atoms of different elements are bonded to one
another somehow, perhaps by hooks, and are not easily separated from one
another. Compounds have constant composition because they contain a
fixed ratio of atoms and each atom has its own characteristic weight, thus
fixing the weight ratio of one element to the other. In addition he said
that chemical reactions involved the rearrangement of combinations of
those atoms.
Let me point out again the difference between a model of atoms and a theory of
atoms. A model focuses on describing what the atoms are like, whereas the theory not
only talks about what the atoms are like but how they interact with one another and
so forth. Dalton's model was that the atoms were tiny, indivisible, indestructible
particlesand that each one had a certain mass, size, and chemical behavior that
was determined by what kind of element they were. We will use that model of an
atom for now, but we will modify it considerably in a later lesson.
John Dalton
FUN FACTS:
1) All matter is
made of atoms.
Atoms are
indivisible and
indestructible.
2) All atoms of a
given element are
identical in mass
and properties
3) Compounds are
formed by a
combination of two
or more different
kinds of atoms.
4) A chemical
reaction is
a rearrangementof
atoms.
Although the concept of the atom dates back to the ideas of Democritus, the English meteorologist and
chemist John Dalton formulated the first modern description of it as the fundamental building block of
chemical structures. Dalton developed the law of multiple proportions (first presented in 1803) by studying
and expanding upon the works of Antoine Lavoisier and Joseph Proust.
Proust had studied tin oxides and found that their masses were either 88.1% tin and 11.9% oxygen or
78.7% tin and 21.3% oxygen (these were tin(II) oxide and tin dioxide respectively). Dalton noted from
these percentages that 100g of tin will combine either with 13.5g or 27g of oxygen; 13.5 and 27 form a
ratio of 1:2. Dalton found an atomic theory of matter could elegantly explain this common pattern
in chemistry - in the case of Proust's tin oxides, one tin atom will combine with either one or two oxygen
atoms.
Dalton also believed atomic theory could explain why water absorbed different gases in different
proportions: for example, he found that water absorbed carbon dioxide far better than it
absorbed nitrogen. Dalton hypothesized this was due to the differences in the mass and complexity of
the gases' respective particles. Indeed, carbon dioxide molecules (CO2) are heavier and larger than
nitrogen molecules (N2).
Dalton proposed that each chemical element is composed of atoms of a single, unique type, and though
they cannot be altered or destroyed by chemical means, they can combine to form more complex
structures (chemical compounds). Since Dalton reached his conclusions by experimentation and
examination of the results in an empirical fashion, this marked the first truly scientific theory of the atom.
John Dalton's A New System of Chemical Philosophy
This image from Dalton's A New System of Chemical Philosophy, published in 1808,
depicts various atoms and molecules.
John Dalton, a British school teacher, published his theory about atoms in 1808. His
findings were based on experiments and the laws of chemical combination.
Postulates
1. All matter consists of indivisible particles called atoms.
2. Atoms of the same element are similar in shape and mass, but differ from the
atoms of other elements.
3. Atoms cannot be created or destroyed.
4. Atoms of different elements may combine with each other in a fixed, simple,
whole number ratios to form compound atoms.
5. Atoms of same element can combine in more than one ratio to form two or more
compounds.
6. The atom is the smallest unit of matter that can take part in a chemical reaction.
Contributors
Binod Shrestha (University of Lorraine)
John Dalton
The theory of atomism, proposed by Dalton in the early 19th century and derived
from meteorological studies, is the foundation for our modern concept of the atom.
HOME / LEARN / HISTORICAL BIOGRAPHIES
Early Life
Dalton (17661844) was born into a modest Quaker family in Cumberland, England,
and for most of his lifebeginning in his village school at the age of 12earned his
living as a teacher and public lecturer. After teaching for 10 years at a Quaker
boarding school in Kendal, he moved on to a teaching position in the burgeoning
city of Manchester. There he joined the Manchester Literary and Philosophical
Society, which provided him with a stimulating intellectual environment and
laboratory facilities. The first paper he delivered before the society was on color
blindness, which afflicted him and is sometimes still called Daltonism.
The papers contained Daltons independent statement of Charless law (see Joseph
Louis Gay-Lussac): all elastic fluids expand the same quantity by heat. He also
clarified what he had pointed out in Meteorological Observationsthat the air is not
a vast chemical solvent as Antoine-Laurent Lavoisier and his followers had thought,
but a mechanical system, where the pressure exerted by each gas in a mixture is
independent of the pressure exerted by the other gases, and where the total
pressure is the sum of the pressures of each gas. In explaining the law of partial
pressures to skeptical chemists of the dayincluding Humphry DavyDalton
claimed that the forces of repulsion thought to cause pressure acted only between
atoms of the same kind and that the atoms in a mixture were indeed different in
weight and complexity.
dalton2.jpg
Elements and their combinations as described in John Daltons New System of
Chemical Philosophy (18081827).
Neville Collection, CHF Collections.
The idea of atoms was invented by two Greek philosophers, Democritus and Leucippus
in the fifth century BC. The Greek word oo (atom) means indivisible because
they believed that atoms could not be broken into smaller pieces.
Nowadays, we know that atoms are made up of a positively charged nucleus in the
centre surrounded by negatively charged electrons. However, in the past, before the
structure of the atom was properly understood, scientists came up with lots of
different models or pictures to describe what atoms look like.
Definition 1: Model
For example, an atomic model represents what the structure of an atom could look like,
based on what we know about how atoms behave. It is not necessarily a true picture of
the exact structure of an atom.
Models are often simplified. The small toy cars that you may have played with as a child
are models. They give you a good idea of what a real car looks like, but they are much
smaller and much simpler. A model cannot always be absolutely accurate and it is
important that we realise this, so that we do not build up an incorrect idea about
something.
Dalton's model of the atom
John Dalton proposed that all matter is composed of very small things which he called
atoms. This was not a completely new concept as the ancient Greeks (notably
Democritus) had proposed that all matter is composed of small, indivisible (cannot be
divided) objects. When Dalton proposed his model electrons and the nucleus were
unknown.
Interesting Fact:
Two other models proposed for the atom were the cubic model and the Saturnian
model. In the cubic model, the electrons were imagined to lie at the corners of a cube. In
the Saturnian model, the electrons were imagined to orbit a very big, heavy nucleus.
James Chadwick
Rutherford predicted (in 1920) that another kind of particle must be present in the
nucleus along with the proton. He predicted this because if there were only positively
charged protons in the nucleus, then it should break into bits because of the repulsive
forces between the like-charged protons! To make sure that the atom stays electrically
neutral, this particle would have to be neutral itself. In 1932 James Chadwick discovered
the neutron and measured its mass.
(1766-1844)
Notice the big old gap between the time when Democritus first shouted, "Atomos! We've
got atomos here!" to the publication of Dalton's more formal theory? Told you Aristotle
threw us back into the atomic dark ages a bit. It's not that nobody was thinking about
atoms at all for nearly 2000 years (check out that expanded timeline), but what Dalton
discovered and what he formally published about atoms earns him the next slot on our
field trip through the history of atomic models.
Where Dalton and Democritus would have agreed (if they hadn't
been separated by 2000 years) is that atoms were the smallest, most basic unit of
matter. Indivisible into smaller parts. (Of course they were both wrong, but we'll get to
that later). Where Dalton advanced atomic theory was by saying we had many different
atoms out there. His model, often dubbed the "billiard ball" model, basically says you
can't divide the atom into smaller pieces.
Dalton also came up with some very important things to know about atoms and how
they combine. Most of these still hold true!
1. All matter is made up of atoms, and these little guys are indivisible (can't break
them apart) and indestructible (can't break them down). He was half right.
2. All atoms of a given element are "the same" (okay, careful here - remember you
know more than Dalton did. "The same" still works for number of protons, but now that
we know about isotopes it's hard to say all atoms of an element are "the same" if by that
you mean identical.)
3. Compounds form when two or more different types of atoms bond chemically,
and they do this is predictable, fixed ratios.
4. Atoms are not destroyed during chemical reactions, they are just rearranged a bit.
Okay, so today we know atoms are made of smaller parts, and you can break them down
in nuclear (not chemical) reactions, but overall Dalton set up a great base of knowledge
for the next group of atomic scientists to build on.
John Dalton (1766-1844) developed the first useful atomic theory of matter around 1803. In the course of
his studies on meteorology, Dalton concluded that evaporated water exists in air as an independent gas.
He wondered how water and air could occupy the same space at the same time, when obviously solid
bodies can't. If the water and air were composed of discrete particles, Dalton reasoned, evaporation might
be viewed as a mixing of water particles with air particles. He performed a series of experiments on
mixtures of gases to determine what effect properties of the individual gases had on the properties of the
mixture as a whole. While trying to explain the results of those experiments, Dalton developed the
hypothesis that the sizes of the particles making up different gases must be different.
Atomic Theory
Dalton's fascination with gases gradually led him to formally assert that every form of matter
(whether solid, liquid or gas) was also made up of small individual particles. He referred to the
Greek philosopher Democritus of Abdera's more abstract theory of matter, which had centuries
ago fallen out of fashion, and borrowed the term "atomos" or "atoms" to label the particles. In an
article he wrote for the Manchester Literary and Philosophical Society in 1803, Dalton created
the first chart of atomic weights.
Seeking to expand on his theory, he readdressed the subject of atomic weight in his book A New
System of Chemical Philosophy, published 1808. In A New System of Chemical Philosophy,
Dalton introduced his belief that atoms of different elements could be universally distinguished
based on their varying atomic weights. In so doing, he became the first scientist to explain the
behavior of atoms in terms of the measurement of weight. He also uncovered the fact that atoms
couldn't be created or destroyed.
Dalton's theory additionally examined the compositions of compounds, explaining that the tiny
particles (atoms) in a compound were compound atoms. Twenty years later, chemist Amedeo
Avogadro would further detail the difference between atoms and compound atoms.
In A New System of Chemical Philosophy, Dalton also wrote about his experiments proving that
atoms consistently combine in simple ratios. What that meant was that the molecules of an
element are always made up of the same proportions, with the exception of water molecules.