Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
byAlexanderBaron
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALI SM?
InfoTextManuscripts,
London,England.(Lgg6)
Printed and bound in the United Kingdom by
StaplesPrinters RochesterLimited
ThbleOfContents
Page 1 Aclotowledgments
Page 2 TbTheReader
Page 3 WhatAreWeTizlkingAbout?
Page 6 Money,ProfrtAndWealth
Page 14 Socialisra MinoitiesAndWorthy Canses
PageA SocialkmAndThektle Of Law
Page29 Religion,ArtsAndMedia
Page 33 Acadcrnig Educaiory HealthAndMedicine
Pagp39 ACloserLookAtTodoy\ Socialists
Page 50 A StraightLookAtBolshevism InPractice
Page 61 MoreAbout TheMedia
Pagp 68 MonopoQ,Marl<etingAndEmployment
Page 79 From Hell OnEarth ToPie In Slq
Page 89 Race...AndTheAppeal Of Fascisrn
Pagp133 TheFightAgainst Socialism...TheWayFonvard
Page1zt0 Bibliography
Page150 NotesAnd Refermces
hge202 Indoc
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
Acknowledgments
This bookwasnritten overa period of severalmonths during 1995.It started
life as a pamphlet but, Iike many of my projects, it just "growedand growed",
and this is the resull It was not written from beginning to end, and althongh
I startetlwith a synopsis,it soonbecameapparentthat a lot morewould have
to beaddedafter the basictext had beencompleted.For this reasonthe astute
reader may find referencesto apparently contemporarAeventsearlier on in
the text than passagestowards the backwhich were completedearlier. Ihis is
not an important point but I stressit in order to avoid confusion.
This book was entirely my own idea,nobody suggestedI nrite it and nobody
gave me any suggestionsfor what to include in the text in any way, rtronnrr
shape or fom. Nevertheless,no man works in a vacuum, and there arr a
number of people I would like to thank in connection with this worlg and
without whoseinvaluableassistanceit would havebeenlesscomplete.These
people are, in no particular order: Chris R. thme, Britain,s leading Liberta-
rian; SeanGabb,Editor of FreeLife; Mike Hutchinsonof PrometheusBooks;
Michael Newland; Nick Griffini John Warburton of tle Mosley Archive; the
stafl of the British Ubrary at Bloomsbury Aldnych and Holborn (SRIS) and
Colindale; the staffofl!'estuinster Central ReferenceLibrary; the staffof the
SupremeCourt Library the staff ofthe Public RecordOftice;Judith, Marjorie,
Jules and Juliette at the ofricel and especiallyto Mark lbha for his invaluable
assistancein prooling the text.
AlexanderBaron,
Sydenham,
London,
England.
January30,1996
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
ToThe Reader
This book is about socialism,in particular, the freedomor othenvisethat
wogld.beenjoyedby peopletiving under it. Although it toucheson the economic
aspectsof socialism,and although I have included a potted history of the
Bolsheviks,this studyis not aboutthe pseudo-economic claptrap of socialism,
nor is about the socialism of Karl Malx, or Lenin, or fuon lhotsky, or Stalin.
It is not about the socialismof Chairman Mao, or Fidel Castro.It is not about
the dialectic, the Third Intemational, the iron law of wages, Democratic
Centralism, or any such drivel. Rather it is about the personal liberty or lack
thereof you would haveif you wereruled by today's socialists,in particular the
peoptewho belongto the socialist workers Party, the NewCommunist Farry,
and similar organisations.
Becauseracerelationshasfor sometime beenoneof the major issuesof our
day,and has, for many years been the field in which socialism's proponents
have scored their most sipificant victories - alwaysat the cost of the dispos-
sessedmajority - I haveincludedin this book a substantialdiscussionof the
raceproblem,and a discussionof the ideologftowardswhichmanyracrfs arrc
attracted, fascism (in oneform or another) , and argued,hopefully conclusively,
that fascism is the Siamesetwin of socialism rather than the demonic entity
which so many socialists truly believethey are struggling to defeat.
2
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
ChapterOne:What AreWeThlkingAbout?
SocialismOr Communism?
The words communism and socialism are often used interchangeably.(1)
There are probably as many dilferent interpetations of each as therc are
socialistsand communists.Communism,as envisagedby Kart Mam, is the
last phase of socialism and will cone about,we are told' whenthe ruling class
has beenfinally overthroumand the workers take control of society.The ideal
of communism envisagesa world where fhere is no state and where no men
rule over other men, exceptperhapsfor purely administrative purposes.
Communismthoughcan only comeaboutwhenall powerhasbeenconcen-
trated in the state. It seemscurious doesit not that the total concentration of
powerwill lead to its total abolition? But that is what many socialists appear
to believe.(2)
SocialismSoundsGood
Socialismsoundsgood,the word has pleasingconnotations;it soundslike
social. But of course, to judge the meaning of a word from its sound is not
particularly intelligenL One might just as well argrre that the word.cyanide
soundsntcer than the word glucose.
What SocialismlsNot
Socialism is not organised labour. Although many members of the trades
'nion moyement often refer to themselvesas socialists, and nany endorse
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
certainappanentaspectsofsocialist policy,egnationalisedindustries,it is an
enormousmisconceptionto lump the trades unions altogether as socialist.The
trades union movement grw out of the struggle of working men to inprove
their lot at a time when pay,conditions of work, and conditions of life for the
vast majority of ordinary working people wereindescribably hard. Onty part
of this u,asdue to social reasons,egthe classsystemlmost of itwas simply that
prcvious generations did not live in such a highly advancedsocietybasedas is
ours on science,technologr,nass production and.mass consumption.
4
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
1) The fallacy that taking from the rich and giving to tle poor makes the poor
riclen
2) T}ie fallacy that only the rich will be plundered
The first fallacy is not immediately obvious,but writing in her ncvsletter for
JuIy 15, LTI4, Ayn f,3afl 5rrmmedit up in a nutshelk "If An averagehouseryife
struggles with her incomprehensiblyshrinking budget and seesa t5rcoonin a
resplendent limousine, 5[s mightwell think f[31j1st one of his diamond cuff
links would solveall her problems. Shehas no way of knowing that if all the
personal luxuries of all the tycoonswere erpropriated, it would not feed her
family-andmillions of otherrsimilarfamilies- foroneweek;andthattheentire
countrywould starye on the first moming of the weekto follow. (Ihis is what
happened in Chile.)..No one tells her that higher taxes imposed on the rich
(and the semi-rich) will not comeout of their consrrmptionexpenditures,but
out of their investment capital, (ie., their savings); that such taxes will mean
less investment, i.e., less production, fewer jobs, higber prices for scarcer
goods;and thatbythe time the rich haveto lowertheir standard of living, hers
will be gone,along with fter savingsand her husbands job..." (1)
A stuuning exampleof the futilify of confrscatingthe capital of the rich was
the announcementin April 195 that one of the privatised water companies
(which were widely believedto have been "profiteering) was to pay out f180
6
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
TheThagedyOf TheCommons:
ABriefNote
T\etragedyof thecommonslies beyondthe scopeof this study,but the rcader
should take note ofthe following. It is a truism thatwhen a serviceis provided
fuw to itsusers,whathappens generallyis that it becomesswamped.Socialists
arc fond of scofling at the profrt motive, but the prices of goods and services
determine not only the profit to the capitalist but also act as a means of
transmiffing market information. Imagine what would happenif a baker were
to giveauraybreadinsteadofsellingit. Ora publicanweretogiveawayalcohol!
Feoptewouldcomefrom far and wide for a free drink Until he ran out, or more
likelywent bankrupt This is what is known as thetragedyof the cornmonslthe
analogr usually made is of the sheepgrazing on common land, and the moral
is that propertywhich is not ownedby someentity (not necessarilyan indiYid'
ual) is quickly plundered.
The current uriter had a personal experienceof the tragedyof thecommons
in August 1995.On August 24,the softwaregiant Microsoft launchedits much
bypd.Wndows 95 program. As part of the promotion it sponsorcdthe Tlrnes
newspaperfor the day; the pal)r was given away free with a 28 page supple-
ment. (3) I left homeabout 9.45amand travelled into Central London spending
sometime in Westminster Central ReferenceLibrary beforevalking up to the
British Library at Bloomsbury, arriving there before lpm. trbom Sydenham
Stationup to the British Libraryincludinglondon Bridgeand CharingCross
Stations,I lookedinto everynewsagentsand vendorrsstand I passed;theTirnes
wasnot to be seenin one of them. Yet usually, this paper doesn't sell out.
Although this is a complex issue, emergencymedical and other treahent
doesnot, generally,fallwithin the remit of thetrage@of the commons,because
fervand far betweenare the peoplewho will break their legs in order to have
the fractures treated for free, or who will set their housesablaze in order to
havethe fires put out for free. And so on.
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
to be born rich, it is not true that there are no self-mademen in the modern
era. Many men (and women)havebuilt vast businessempiresin the second
half of the liventieth Century often by their own hard work and/or ingenuity.
For the sake of examplewewill list three here Bill Gatesthe softu,anewizard
and founder of Microsofg (6) Virgtn group founder and CEO Richard Bran-
son, probably the most recogpisable (and extrovert) of the new brand of
multimillionairesl and Anita Roddick (and husband) founder of the Body
Shopchain.
Many morc could be addedto that list, and in fact the ranks of tfrienouveau
riche have long been angmentedby such (at one time) unlikely 6inisn5 a5
best-selling homor and other novelists; successfullatyers; rock musicians;
and lately, eventop rank amateur sportsmen.
Most of the aboveare anything but idle, and indeed someof the wealthiest
and most successfulpeople'slives revolvearound their worl although they do
of course rcap considerablefinancial resards. There is though, another and
far lesswell lmoumfunction the rich servein our society.
At one time, scientific research was the exclusive province of the rich;
astronomy in particular benefitedenormously from the efforts and endow-
ments of wealthy amateurs, and many foundations, medical charities and the
Iilre, were founded by wealthy people.kt's take a brief look at this. The two
greatesttelescopesofthe pre-1850periodwere built by private individuals. (7)
Herschel - who was appointed RoyalAstronomer on his discoveryof Uranus -
nas a lifelong anateur astronomer.He built one.(8) TheAmerican astronomer
George Etlery Hale (1E68-1938),u'as financed by his father' a prosperous
Chicagobusinessman.In 1892,hemettheimmenselywealthy CharlesTYerkes
who financed an observatoryfor $34'900.(9) It openedin 1897and uas named
a1ls him. It was still the largest in the world of its kind in the late seventies.
(10) Around 1908,John D. Ilooker oflos Angelesfinanced a telescopeto the
turneof S45rfi)0,enoughto pay for tle milror! (11) Britain's leading popular
'It
astronomer,Fatrick Moore, hastritten that would be difficult to over'esti-
mate howvaluable the Hooker reflector has beento astronony." (12)
Tino incredibly wealtly nen, Andrew Carnegie (1835-1919)and John D.
Rockefeller I (1&t9-1937),gaveaway a staggering $850million in their life-
times.Ihey funde4 among other things, education, libraries, and scientific
research.(ffi)
10
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
L1
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
nation. Ihis is sinply not true. Ihe reader should alwaysbe careful to draw a
distinction betweenthe rhetoric of socialism:human equality,the brotherhood
of man, helping the doumtrodden,etc,and the reality. Later in this short study
we will reviewthe antecedentsof tle three leading socialists of the Bolshevik
Revolution:knin, Stalin anil Tbotsky,when the readerwill seefor himselfjust
howwide is the gap betweensocialist rhetoric and socialist rality.
Wthout the rich, all patronage,whether it be patronage of the causeslisted
above,or of the arts' or whatever,would emanateentirely and only from the
state. Again, this would mean that any activity or causethe state disapproved
of would never receive a penny of public money' and would probably be
proscrihd by law. As throughout history the state has disapproved of or even
outlawed virtually everything, (17) this would mean, to all intents and pur-
poses,the end of change,and the end of progress. (18)
In conclusion, the existenceof a certain number of independent' wealthy
peoplewhoare preparedto donatetheirmoneyand otherresourcestovarious
worthy, evenlnpopular, canpaips, ensunesfhat a certain amount of dissent
will alwaysexist, the sort of dissentwhich is totally impossible rvhenrYealthis
concentratedentirely in the state. There is though a subtle, if terdble, irony
here. This is that very many of the organisations which wealthy people have
founded have themselvesbecomevehicles for socialist ideologr, and the de-
struction of capitalism and free enterprise. (19) It remains to be seenif the
neasonsfor this are wholly or partly conspiratorial, or entirely of misguided
idealism. (20)
12
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
SocialismAndTheProfit Motive
Hard line socialistsmakemuch of the profit motive, someof them talk about
p"ontr as though theywereevil. Profrteering at the expenseof someonein dire
ieed is evii. fio take an extraordinarT hypothetical example,if you
wenea diabetic,and werestranded miles from anywhereand you neededa shot
"""trioty
your life
oriorotio, it would be evil for a doctor to demandthat you hand over
,""t"gr uJtneprice of an injection or die.On the other hand, mostpeoplethink
doctors should be rewardedand rewariledwell for treating the sick' Socialists
themselvesoften campaign- sometimessincerel$more often cynically'for
n.tt puy and conditions for all medical (and other) workers. Surely this
"
meansthat they are in somemeasurein favour of protit?
Major Dougtas,thefoundingfatherof social creditwrote that "Ithas never
to
5"en ilear to-me why any man in any position of tife should be expected
p""to"- *Vactionwlateverwhich u'asn otin somesenseof thewordprolitable
io him..." (jZ) O" tn. other hand, Leon thotsky, the doyenof the intemationa-
iirt I"ft, ,*, iotally against the very conceptof profit and the profit motive.
He wrote: "In a country where the sole employer is the state, opposition
meansdeathby slowstarvation. The old principle: who doesnot work shall not
(23)
eaf has beenreplacedby a nervons who'doesnot obeyshall not eaL"
ile doesn't teU us whom we are to obey,but it doesn't take much effort to
people would rather work to eat than be subjected to
work that one out. Most
thewhims of a monsterlike Tbotslry.
t3
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
ChapterThree:Socialism,Minorities
AndWorthyCauses
14
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
15
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
sumersby raising prices higber and higher to provide both higbervages and
higher profrts." (13)
Most interestingly, Qniglsy sopments that "Sincethe Marxist ideologr and
the Manist war cries weremore easily observedthan the social realities they
servedto conceal,especiallywhenlabor leaders sought all publicity for what
they saiil and profound secrecyfor what they did' many capitalists, some
workers, and almost all outsiders missed the new d.evelopmentscompletely
and continuedtobelievethataworkers'revolutionuiias justaroundthecomer.n
(r4')
While there can be no doubt that many hard core socialists continue to
profess sincerely in the class struggle,there can be no doubt either that many
of them have long been aware of this reality, and, as we shall seein Chapter
Eight, there has been a carefully concealedworking alliance betweenradical
socialists and monopoly capitalists throughout history.
Another point made by Professor Qurgleyis the rise of the technocrat and
the separation of the oumershipof capital from the managementof capital'
which "must lead" in the long run, to a decreasingdemandfor hand labor and
an increasing demandfor highly traineil technicianswho anemanagersrather
than laborers. And, in the longer run, this process would give rise to a
productive systemof such a high level of technical complexitythat it couldno
longer be run by the olurers but would have to be run by technically trained
managers.Moreover, the use of the corporate form of industrial organization
as a means for bringing the savings of the many into the control of a few by
sales of securities to wider and wider groups of investors (including both
managerial and laboring groups) would lead to a separation of management
from ownership and to a great incrcasein the number of onmers."(15)
All this and more refutes the nonsenseof Manism and the class struggle'
but hard core socialists are not interested in such nicetiesas truth, exceptthe
highertruth of Mamist rhetoric. It should neverbe forgotten that socialists are
fighting the classwar. In this connectionone should neverbut neverforget the
fme honoured dictum of United StatesSenatorHiram Johnson,tlat The first
casualtywhenwarcomesis truth." (1O
All the available evidencesuggeststhat hard core socialists are among the
most prolific, brazen and shamelessliars in history. Socialism is in fact an
antinomian philosophy,onewhich maintains that its practitioners may say or
do anything on the grounds thatthe means,howeverterrible, will alwaysiusti$
16
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
the end, that of a better world. (17) \{hen we cover the history of Bolshevism
the reader will seefor himself just how temible both the meansand the ends
of socialism are. Like any otler fom of dictatorship, including fascism,which
is literally demonisedby socialists,under socialism,the statecontrols all the
media, at least all those media outlets that matter. This means that the
socialiststatehas,can,does,and will, propagatewhateverlies it likes. It is not
evennecessaryfor censorshipto be applied rigorously under socialism,fhe
simple fact is that under a socialist dictatorship only those peoplewho have
been thoroughly iniloctrinated in the party line are permitted accessto the
media.Self-censorshipdoesthe rest.
SocialismAnd Minorities
Sincethe endof the SecondWorldWar,and indeedbeforethat, socialismhas
made much of the so-called struggle of minorities for emancipationand
equality. This does not relate solely to ethnic minorities - in practice, all
non-whites,whether they are in a minority or not - but has beenexpandedin
recent years to cover all manner of,minoities, some of them very creative
indeed. The original impetus for the concer:nwith minorities was the Nazi
persecution of the Jews. However,there is a big difference betweenending
persecution of minorities, ending state enforced discrimination against them
and striving for equality of opportunity for all on the one hand, and on the
other hand, gving certain minorities special privileges backedup by the full
coerciveforce ofthe state. And there is an evenbigger differencebetweentle
elimination of oflicially sanctioned discrimination and the violation of
property rights.
17
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
18
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
becauseit entailed state control over the market and the fixing of differential
wagerates betweenraces.(21) Other countrieswhich haveenforceddiscrimi-
natory practices in varying degrees- Malaysia, for example- have also been
anythingbut fascist
Ifsocialists wersincerein their desireto build a societybasedon equality
of opportunity, they would opposeall state interference in race relations and
call for ttre abolition of the race industry. (22) Instead, many of them have
carved out careers for themselvesmeddling in the economy,calling for the
imposition of racial quotas,and pushing multi-racialism (a euphemismfor
enforced race-mixi.g). There is no single reason for this, but again, the Nazi
persecution of the Jewsusually comesinto the equation somewhere.Certain
Jewish and Zionist organisations havealso entered the fray, and their incess-
ant meddling and duplicity has donefar more to ferment anti-Semitism than
to combat it. The unconditional hatred for Westem society,Western demo-
cratic traditions and indeed Westem Man himself, which is espousedby
certainelenentsof the socialistpopular front needsno doc 'mentinghere,but
it will suflice to say that many peoplewho meddle in race relations - be they
socialistsor otherwise- do sofrom tle most ignobleof motives.Wewill discuss
the thonryissue of racein more detail in Chapter Tivelve.
SocialismAnd "Gay"Rights
A special mention should be given here to one supposedlye4ploitedand
oppressedminority. The homosexualminority is undoubtedlythe most crea-
tive of all minorities which the SocialistIntemational haschanpioned.But it
wasn't alwaysthatnay. In Weimar Germany,Marxists attackedhomosexuality
as a fascist perversion [It may have been this opprobrium for homosexual
perversion that led Hitler to purge the homosexualEmst Roehmin the 1934
T.{ight of the Long Knives"l. (23)
A standard work on homosexuality tells us that "As early as the 1920s
leaders of Westem Communist parties beganto float the idea that...homosex-
ual activity...resulted from the decadenceof capitalism in its death throes.
t9
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
SocialismAndQuotas
The doctrine of oppressionwhich socialists have foisted on societyhas been
extendedfrom racial minorities to deviant minorities, specifrcallyhomosex-
uals. The semanticsof "oppressionn,which havebeenacceptedalmost uncriti-
cally by academia,the media, politicians, and social policy makers, are both
deceptiveand duplicitous, as well as demonstrably false. Briefly, smialists
believe- or professto believe- that certain desipated minorities: (27) blacks,
(2E)homosexuals,(29) and others, are historically oppressed"discriminated
against and disadvantaged,and that becauseof this, positive discrirninaion
nust be effected,backed up by tle full coercivepower of the state, to ensure
racial and other quotas in such areas as the professions,housing,various
20
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
2T
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
22
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
Movement
SocialismAndThe"Peace"
One field in ntich socialists and fellow travellers have long been active'
though onentich has faded into the backgrounil somewhatwith the collapse
of the Soviet Union, is that of unilateral nuclear disarmament, the so'called
peace movement.TVhilethe role of the former SovietUnion in promoting this
ldeologr has, undoubterlly,beengreatly exaggeratedby right wing ideologues
and others, it remainsa truism that the Sovietswerenationalists at homeand
communistsabroarl Furthermore, the Sovietshaveneverbelievedin disarma'
ment. Lenin believedthat until socialism was establishedeveryrvhereit was
nrevolutions could not be made by
false to advocate disarmament because
unamed men'. (38) He wrote this in December1916,but it remained a part of
soviet ideologr right up until the collapse.In otherwords, the propagation of
nuclear disamament by the Eastem Bloc served the express purpose of
undermining the West,and was not, and is not, based.on sincere ideologf or
deeplyheld political convictions.
23
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
SocialismAndTheRuleOf Law
One of the most absurd beliefs ever to be expoundedby the socialists, or
indeed by anyone,is that socialism will lead, somehowand inevitably, to the
regenerationof man. When the workers'paradise linally arrives, there will be
no need for policemen, prisons or any related institutions; not only will
governmenf as far as it exists, be purely administrative, dealing with the
ofderly running of society,but nobodywill break the law or evenrnantto break
the law.Ihis is not so much a political conceptas a religious one. (1) I*aving
asidethe inconvenientfact that there has neverbeenthe slightest eviilencethat
anything like this will ever come about it is exhaordinarily naive, and is
conparable to the pie-in-the-slrynonsensethat most religions sell their adher-
ents in retun lsr lgading vfutuous lives on Earth. (And paying their tithes).
Ihere is though a far more sinister side to socialism, and onerfrich always
nthe
comesbeforc the promised Paradiseon Earth. Ienin definedMarxism as
doctrine ofclass warfare plus the dictatorship of the proletariat'. (2) And he
definedthe dictatorship of the proletariat as "therule - unrestrictedby law'and
basedonforce-of theproletaiatoverthebourgeoisie, aruleenioyingtherympathy
and support of the labouing and qloited masses." (3)
It is not easyto define preciselywhat is meant by the rule of laq but one
prcrequisite is that the law must befairly abstract, that it must apply, orwould
appty,equatty,to everybodyin the same circumstances.Ihere can be special
laws goveming blind persons and women, for example, but these are not
abrog"ationsof the rule of law. (4) For example,in Britain' and in many other
countries, the law recognisesthat sometimesa woman who has recently given
birthwill, becauseof a hormone inbalance or somesuchphysiologicallybased
mental problem, harn or evenkill her baby.Thus the law provides for the
offenceof infanticide if it can be proved that this urasindeed the case. (5)
Children aad fseHs-mindedpersonsmay be subject to different laws,primar'
24
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ily to protect them from exploitation, and so on. These are very proper
exceptions,as far as they can be calledexceptions.
The chief safeguardfor all of us is, in the words of F.A.Haye\ that "the rules
must apply to thosewho lay them downand thosewho apply them - that is, to
the govemment as nrell as the governed- and that nobody has the power to
grant exceptions.'(O
the socialist idea, tlat the governmentis unrestricted by law,meansexactly
that, laws do not apply to the government,only to the regulation of the people
under the control of the communists/socialists. Itwas GeorgeVlrashingtonwho
saiil that government, like fire, is a dangerousser:yantand a fearful master.
(f Like all the Founding Fathers,Washingtonrecognisedthat the lirst act of
governmentmust be to limit its ownpower;this is the purpose of a constitution,
to limit the power of the govemment. A leading anli-Communist, Dr fhed
Schnan, rccognisesthis also. Schwarzsays of knin's dictum, that the gov-
emment is unrestricted by law that " [t] his is a very sinister and seriousfeature
of the Communist system...because the history of civilisation is the restmint
of goverrrmentby law. Govemment unrestrained by law is naked f5ranny." (8)
In Britain, in recent years we have been unfortunate enough to wihess a
n'mber of monshous injustices: the Birmingham Six, Guildford Four and
similar casesospring to mind. Thesecasesand many others, have resulted in
peoplechallengingtheir convictions through the courts. kople who havebeen
urongly convicted, sentencedand sened time in prison can be arryarded
monetary compensation,although most peoplewould turn doun any amount
of moneyrather than spend the bestyears of their lives in prison. Sometimes
too the police overstepthe mark, and again, there havebeena number - a large
number-of successfulactionsagainstthepoliceinrccentyearsforfalsearrest,
and other improprieties. Usually in suchcasesthe police nght dl the waythen
settle at the court door insisfing that they have arlmitteil no liability. Rarely
are olfending police ollicers evendisciplineil in any meaningful senseof the
word, nuch less subjectedto criminal prosecution. (9)
In reality, evenin a so-calleddemocraticcountrylike Britain, the police and
otler authorities can often do more or less what they damn well like, and in
tle event of a complaint or investigation, the entire bureaucratic machinery
closesranks in what many people often interyrret as a megalithic conspiracy.
(10) [The cunent writer has personal erperienceof tbis]. Police officers who
investigate other policp oflicers are the least respecteil by their colleagues.
25
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
26
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
38) 'No bailiff shall in future put anyone to trial upon his own bare word,
without reliablewitnesses produced for this purpose,"
Theseare frne principles which the passageof time should not be allowed to
erode.(14) Tlmes maychange,technologr does,but Man's nature remains the
same,whatever the socialists would have us believe. Clause 40 is a vitatty
important one;although a rich man can afford expensivelanyers (1O and the
privilegeswealth brings, it is a point hardlyworth arguing that, in the criminal
courts at least the capitalist statehas dispenseda far superior brand ofjustice
to the comnon man than SovietRussiaand Communist China. It is though
n
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
not only the individual citizen who may be taken to court under our bourgeois
systemofjustice; the govemmentcan be taken to court if it breaks the law.
In April 1763,the MP andjournalist JohnWilkes (1725-97),the prime mover
behind a scunilous magazinecalled The North Biton, insulted the King's
mother and accusedthe Monarch himself of lying. Although TheNorth Biton
uas published anonSmously,the identity of the people behind it nas no great
secret,and a generalwarrantwas drawn up to arrest "the authors, printers,
and publishers of a seditious and treasonablepaper entitled TheNorth Biton,
No. 45'. (1O The word "heasonable"u'as addeil to deny Wilkes the right to
pleadRarliamentaryprivitege.Inthree days49peoplewerearrested, including
many totally innocent persons.(17) [It is worth mentioning here that accord-
ing to a standard biography of Wilkes, there appears to have been a large
elementof role playing in this affair. Wlkes was sent to the Tower of London,
in somestyle, (18) and although prior to his arrest he wasrunning around like
a blue-arsedfly, he never seemsto havebeenin any danger of having his ears
loppeil off, as diil William Prlmne. (19) Nevertheless,none of this should
distract the readerfrom the seriousnessofthe principle at issuel.
In the end" it n'as ruled not only that the general warrant was illegal, but
that a writ of habeascorpushad beeninfringed and Parliament violated. (20)
Foltowing this, Wilkes won an action for trespassagainst the Under-Secretary
of State and f1,000 danages for carrying out the instructions of the general
warranl (21)
A more prosaic exampleof the govemment being found in breach of the law
is the SecondGreenbackcaseof 1870inwhich the Americanjudge Salnon P
Chaseruled that greenbackswereunconstituti onal. Q2) As he had beenin the
Iheasury at the time, and urasthereforc responsible for the 1862Legal Tbnder
Act, he convictedhimselfl (23)
Ihere have been othe6 contemporary, instances of the government being
prosecuted successfullybecauseof the separation of the Executive am of
govemmentfrom the Legislativeand the Judiciary. Again, this is by no means
per{ect,and judgesare all the time subjectedto polifical and other pressures.
But under socialism the Executiveis also both the Legislative and the Judi-
ciary. Q4) This principle is what socialists refer to as Denocratic Centralisn.
A betier phrase is naked granny. Later, Ilitler copied this structure in Nazi
Germanywith the kadership Principle.
28
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
SocialismAnd ReligiousFreedom
It is well lmorm tlat Karl Mam refened to religion as the opiateof the people.
(1) Foltowing their antinomian dictum that anything that forwards the class
struggleis goodandanythingthathindersitis evil,theatheisticsocialistshave
at times supported religious freedom in exactly the same uay these great
intemationalists have supported nationalist movementsand movementsof
so<alled national liberation, particularly in the so-called Third World" the
backrnarilnessof which is aluays blamed on Imperialism nhich is somehow
said to have drained the wealth out of thesecountries. (2)
Once the dictatorship of the proletariat has been established' religious
freedom like all other freedoms are abolished. Like their crusades against
racismrsacism, andeveryotherlin, the socialists'supportofreligiousfieedom
is simply a meansto an end.
29
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
news,and so on. For oncethey are not wrong.Who couldn't find, researchand
urite better stories in a mor.eprofessional manner?
At the time of rvriti.g - Summer 1995(4) - two femaleauthors of doubtfrtl
titerary talents - Martina Navratilova and Naoni Campbell - are riding high
with gbost'written novels.Ihere can beno doubt whatsoeverthat whateverthe
merits of their respectivebooks, both theseladies havegot into print solelyon
account of being who they are. (5) Navratilova is of coursethe grrcatesttennis
player of all time, while Campbell is a leading fashion model, perhaps rlze
leading black fashion model in the world. (6) An unsuccessfulhack might look
with enviouseyeson Navratilova and Campbell, ask himself (or herselD why
tten rather than me?and reply becausecapitalism sucks.As indeed it does.
(7) But at least under capitalism it is possible for a woman to become
fabulously wealthy and a published novelist by ptaying tennis in Martina's
case,(8) or simply by looking good in Canpbell's. (9)
Publishing isn't quite a closedshop,but rn'ritingbookshas beenmore or less
seemup byjournatists, academicsand a fewothers. It goeswithout sayingthat
not all of theseauthors have much merit, or indeedany at all. (10)
Artgular conespondent of mine - and fellowlibertarian - SeanGabb' editor
of FreeLife - is in much the sameposition as me and countlessothers. He is
not only at least as gooda writer as myselfbut is an extremelyerudite qualifietl
lanyer and historian. Awhile agoa mutual friend commentingon his work saiil
that hewasforrver writing excellentarticles and sendingthem offto magazines
such as t}reSpectatorrandnever,or hardly ever,getting anything in prinL Sean
Gabbanil I are farfrom alone,indeed"the number of talentedwriters who have
never,andwill never,getanyrvhere,is dwarfedbythe n 'mber of firstrate actors
and other per{onners'composers,(1L)talentedfine artists, and so on.
All the abovepeople have the dubious pleasure everyday of their lives, of
seeingfar lesstalented peoplethan themselvesreaping rich renrardsunder the
capitatist system.At times they seepeoplewho are liffle better than imbeciles
having fame and fortune thrust upon them while somewhereout there is
another Beethoven,another Shakespeare,another Rembrandt, the worldwill
never eyenhear of, much less appreciate. There are peoplewho have rritten
novel after novelwho have neverevenhad so much as the offer of a publishing
contrac! much lessgot into print. Any one of theseunpublishedauthors could
be another Charles Dickens.
30
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
31
SOCIALISM?
UNDER
FREEDOM
32
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ChapterSix Academia,Education,
HealthAnd Medicine
AcademicFreedomUnder Socialism
Ihere are few areas of human activity where freedom of inquiry is more
inportant than academia;this applies to the social sciencesas much as to the
hard sciences.Without freedom of inquiry progressis impossible in any field.
Harilly a day passeswhen someacademicor other doesn'tvoice a supposedly
controversial opinion in the popular prressor other mainstream media. Just
becausean opinion, idea, theory or whatever is controversial, doesn't mean
that it has any merit at all. There is still a Flat Earth Societyin existenceto
this day; the idea that the Earth is flat is quaint if nothing else,but of course,
it has no merit at all. In Galileo's ilay though the idea that the Earth was
spherical was extremely controversial, and ifyou had voiced such ideas in
certain circles, 1;ks Qalilse himself you would have found yourself in deep
waten Or evenon a bonfrre!
In spite of their commifinent to the scientific method, and their (supposed)
willingnessto tlrow out any hlpothesis,theory or law that is patenflyurong,
scientists are tardigrade beasts.Virtually everynew idea in sciencehas been
ridiculed and scorned by scientists before it has been acceptedas the new
wisdom.Itwas thegreat GermanphysicistMax Planckwhosaidthat "Ihe new
scientifrctruth doesnot triumph byconvincingits opponentsandmakingthem
see the light, but rather becauseits opponents eventually die, and a new
generationgrows up that is familiarwitl it " (1)
Long after scientists have acceptedthe value of a newhgrothesis or theory
or have ftamed a new law, the general public and the media continue to give
spurious credenceto proven nonsense.(2) The best ercamplesof this arc the
controversies surrounding astrolory, the Loch Ness Monster, flying saucers,
spirit medinmship, psychic nspoon-bending", and other such nonsense.(3)
Anyonewho has studied the scientific literature of thesesubjectswill realise
that such controversiesexist only in the media.
aa
JJ
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
34
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
35
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
36
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
38
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
ChapterSeven:A CloserlookAt
TodavtsSocialists
PayingTheirDues
The lhotskyite Socialist Workers Party publishes a weeklynerrspapenThere
are many otler well-establisheilsocialist publications, T\e Moming Star is
published daily. By contrast, the declared arch-enemies of socialism, the
so-calledfascistspublish monthlyjournals and broadsheets.Although in the
United States,the far right is generally far better funded' there can be little
doubt that for all its professedshare-the-wealthdogma,the far left in Britain
is extremelywealthy.This wealth comes not only from its patrons, from the
capitalist foundationsand trusts it professesto despise'from Ieftwing coun'
cils, (1) and from its business fronts, (2) but from ordinary rank and lile
members.
In the Spring of 1995,a small right wing journal published a contribution
schedule(Regishation form) for the SocialistWorkers Partywhich showshow
much members are expectedto pay each month. For a single person the
subscription ranges from unemployedat S4per month to f5 for students to
f24 for someoneearning $500 per month to a staggering Sa00a month for
someoneeaming 92,000a naonth. (3) This is a political party that doesn't
contest elections and which is forever denouncing the rich as parasites. AI'
thougb one can only admire the dedication (or gullibitif) of the SWP'sgrass
roots membership,no organisation which demands20Voof its members' net
earningshas the right to denouncethe rich or anyoneelseas parasitic. Under
an SWP-stylesocialist govemment everybodywould be expectedto pay even
heavier dues,not to t,heparty, but to the state. Remember,under capitalisn'
man works for profit; under socialism, he works for the cornrnon goodriefor
the state.
39
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
A CloserLook At Today'sSocialists:The
SWPandtheCPGB
Ihe time has comenorvto take a closer look at the rhetoric of contempomry
socialists. We shall do this by examining a short book by leading Socialist
Workerand.jounalist PaulFoot and a pamphlet by the Socialist Party of Great
Britain.
The SocialistWorlsersParty is without doubt the leading thotskyite organi-
sation in Britain.In July 1990'it publishetl THE CASE FOR SOCIALISM:
WIAT I:HE SOCULIST WORKERSPARTY STANDSFOR' which uas urit-
tcn by-Paul-Eootrone ofjlsmore high profiIe members.
nrealsocialisd. The (former) Soviet
Apparently what the SIYPstanils for is
Bloc and everybody else who professed to practise socialism werrereally
capitalists rvhowere simply pretending. This is not simply dead urong but a
total andwilful distortion of the true nature of Malxism-Leninism. Ihe usual
SWPtraddle - as you'll realise if youte everarguedwith one of its members'
is that the former SovietUnion practised, not socialism' but State Capitalism.
Ihe Revolution rftrs both glorious and successful,but nas usurped by Stalin.
Ihe huth is that it nrasthe great Lenin himself who introduced State Capital'
ism. According to Marxist-Ieninist theory Imperialism is the highest stageof
capitalism, (4) capitalism itself being the highest stageof human development
to dztn,and onewhich will be succeeded- inevitably ' by socialism. According
to Lenin, State Capitalism wasintroduced asa transitional stage' (O in reatif
he introduced it becauseit soon became obvious that total socialism (ie
absolute collectivisn) doesn't work (Q Just how ludicrous is socialism in
practice can be seenfrom the chaosthat resulted from the short lived rEgime
of B6la Kun in Hungary.
40
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
41
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
A CloserLookAt Today'sSocialists:
The SWP- continued
Returning to Foot, wilh de rigueur socialist disrespect for truth, the aufhor
whiteuashesSoviet Russia and blamesits subsequentplunge into tganny on
Stalin. On pages14-5he givesthe impressionthat Karl Marxwas sone kind
of 'anti-racist". The reality is that Marx wasboth a vicious anti'black bigot and
a gutter anti-Semite, the latter notwithstanding his own Jewish origins.
The American Jewish author Nathaniel Weyl has uritten that "...thebelief
that some races aneinnately more able, nore vigorous, and morc intelligent
than others...uasthe consensusopinion of educatedmen in Marx's tine. It
was a view held by Thomas Jefferson,JamesMadison, Abraham Lincoln, and
other American statesmen.Philosophers like Daviil Hume and Montesquieu
concurred in it.' (9)
This is indeed true, and although the racism of Thomas Jefferson and
Abraham Lincoln (the Great Emancipator) have likewise beenwritten out of
the history books, it is common knowledgein certain circles that they were
anything but egalitarians. (10) However,the racism of Karl Marx and his
mentor Engelswent far beyonda belief that blacks, and others,weregenetically
inferior. According to Weyl "Strangelyenough,the so'called secltt conversa'
tions of Adolf Hitlerare lesssuffusedwithhatredand destructionthan Marx's
contributions to the Marx-Engelscorrespondence."(11) Yet in spite of this'
"Publicly and for political reasons,both Marx and Engelsposed as friends of
the Negro. In private, theywere antiblack racists of the most odious sort." (12)
Atthougb they may not be infusedwith eitler an intensehatreil of the Negro
or an overtly patronising attitude, there is little reason to believethat today's
leading (white) socialists are any less cynical about non-whitesthan they are
about the workers they profess loud and long to support. Certainly they
rutllessly exploit both in the furtherance of their ideologr of anti'capitalist
hatred. (13)
Returning to Foot's book, the reader is toltl that "Man argueil that all
human historywas dominated by a tussle for the wealth betweenclasses,one
of which took the wealth, and usedit to exploit tle others'" (14)Wehavealready
42
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
disposedof this nonsense;Marri and Foot and his ilk would haveus believe
that the likes of capitalists such as BilI Gates and Riclard Branson, and
corporations like Marla & Spencerare simply expropriators of wealth rather
than creators of it. While it is probably a little unfair to take Marx to task for
promulgating this view, Foot, who lives more than a centurXrlater' has no
excuses.Furthermore, he bas seenthe evil effects of the philosophyMan did
so much to crrcate,so if Marx can be dismissed as a well-meaningcrackpot'
Foot can only be denouncedas a mischief'maker.
Foot tells us that workers haveto seizethe wealth of their so'called exploi-
ters: (15) Exploiters nto amassedtheir power and wealth by robbing workers
were not sentimental or namby-pambyabout iL They would hold on to their
wealth and power,if they had to, by force. They would neYersturender that
power and wealth, howeverintellectually or morally unjustifiable it was.' (16)
One can argue of coursethat men should not havepolYerover other men, and
that the powerof the stateshouldbedispersed.Footand companydonotwant
to disperseor deshoy suchpowerthough, rather theywant to bring it all under
their control. His claim or inferencethat peopleshould surender their wealth
becauseit is immoral for them to bewealthy is totally fallacious.
l{e have refuted this fallacy already (that of the redistribution of wealth)'
along with that of tle classshuggle, but we reiterate, if it were left to the likes
of Foot to decide how muei personal wealth we should be pemitted to
accumulate,and if wewereleft to obeythe likes of Foot (and his idol lhotsky)
in order to eat, wewoulil all be in serious trouble.
Foot continues:The newmillionaireswho emergedin the 1980sralmost to
a man, are people without any noticeable skill, intellect or ability. They are
expert only at playng the stock market or sackingworkers - the two activities
most likely to make a f35t millien.' (17) While there is, unfortunately, more
than a grain of truth in this claim, it is not the remorselessquest for profit
that makes workers redundant but nervtechnologr. However,until such time
as the capitalist systemcan be reformed, (L8) wewill all of us haveto live with
its evil That being said" capitalists who do not invest their
"oosequ"oces.
capital soon becomeex-capitalists' so rnoney saved by sacking one set of
workers will usually be rcinvestedelsewher.e.
Foot is on evenweakergrounds whenhe claims that the rich are rich because
they have robbed other people's labour. (19) Again' while there are such
creatures as the idle rich, the likes of Bill Gates, Richard Branson, Anita
43
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
44
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
45
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
paying them well, actually widens the franchise, particnlarly to people from
working classbackgrounds.Ihe reasonjudges are (apparently) so highly paiil
might also havesomethingto do with making bribes lessattractive. (26) Under
socialism thougb, there will be no need to worry about that. Not onlywill no
onebe rich enoughto ofrer judges bribes, but judges wiII be academicanryay.
If they exist at all, their function will be simply to rubber stamp Executive
policy. Including in criminal frials. Q7)
Page70: The socialist argument is that peopleare far morr likely to do what
they uant to do, and what they are best able to do, if the reward for everything
is roughly the same...o
Ihe onlythingunongwithFoot'slogic is everything.Whileit is certainlytrue
tlat manywealthypeople,peopleof independentmeans,retired pebple,etc,do
workatwhat theychoose,including voluntarywor\ tlere is a vast gulf between
the voluntary worker and active pensioner,and a world in n&ich everybody
doeswhat theywant and what they are bestat. (28)According to Foot, a doctor
who has to train for sevenyears will receivethe sameremuneration as a car
park attendant A senior factory manager with thirty years enperienceand a
great deal of responsibilitywill receivethe sameremuneration as the man who
mops the floor. And of cource,they will all be blissfully happy with tlis state
of alfairs. We have though, omitted a minor - or perhaps not so minor -
qualification. What Foot actually saysis that"most peoplewill get the same.n
@mphasis added). It doesn't take too much imagination to rcalise that Foot
and his chums in the SWP - who will be telling everybodyelsewhat to do - are
notmostpeople.(29)
On page71,f,'ootrefers to public ownershipof the meansof production and
stats or implies that tlis will not include cons'mer goods. Bear in mind
though dear reader,that it is not nerely the ghosts of Ienin and thotslry that
will haunt this nightmaneworld, but the ghostof B6laKun. Will your batlroom,
your motor car (if the state givesyou a permit for one), or evenyour bed"be
countedas consumeror as capital goods?
Still on page7lz "...thewhole point of tle public ownership of the meansof
production is that more is produced and shared out, not less."
The proof of that pudding is the collapseof Communism.Professor Quigley
relates that after the SecondWorld War, Russian soldiers were amazedthat
"erploited" Geman workers onmedwristwatches;their standard of livinguas
that mucl higher. (30) Such startling revelationsare not difficult to find. The
46
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ANobleException
Atthough PauI Foot is living in cloud cuckooland, the de rigueur claims of
socialiststhat the profit motivecan be doneawaywithis not a total nonsense,
but this requirts a re+valuation of the meaningof the word profit. Ihe most
obvious examplesare the fields of creativiff (eg the arts, including literature
and music) anil the voluntary sector.Many are the poets who have nevergot
into print; thecumentwriter hascorrespondedwithtwonovelists,oneofwhom
had at the time - several years ago - written five novels without having one
published. At one time I lnew personally an extremelytalented composerand
perfonner - primarily a classical guitarist - who had composed,according to
his ownreckoning,twothousandor morepiecesof music;hehashadverylittle
published. Ihe world is full of such people, doubtlessyou, dear rrcader:, know
of somesuch person, or several of them. You may evenbe one!
Similarly, there are many millions of people throughout the world whose
voluntarywork earns them no frnancial reward, sometimesleavesthem out of
pocket,despisedby certain sectionsofthe public, or evenendangerstheir lives.
(31) However,whatever drives such people - creativity, a senseof duty' or
perhaps evensomebasemotive - it is a total fantasy eYento suggestthat tle
world can be run along such lines. There is a vast chasm betweenwriting a
novel, performing a song, or manning a lifeboat on an ad hoc basis, and
sweepingthe streets Iive days a weekfor thirty years. Or training for several
yearr as a doctor or an architect and then working at somebodyelse'swhim
for as long as that person pleases,whether or not that person is Leon llotslcy'
Paul Foot, or someother collectivist.
47
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
A CloserLookAt Today'sSocialists:
The SPGB
If you haven't heard of the Sociatist Party of Great Britain that is hardly
surarising, it is diminutive and devoteshalf its time to promoting socialism
aud the other half to attacking an organisation it refers to as "Ihe Socialist
Farty of Clapham".According to its literature the SPGBuas reconstituted in
June 1991,(32) and has since then beenat war with a rival of the samename.
The reader may frnd this amusing, but it is by no meansunusual. Inileed, the
nastiest hate literature produced by socialists and communists is directed
trailitionally not at either their capitalist oppressonor the mythical fascist
menacebut at other socialists. (33)
In its 1995pamphletSOCIALIST STWIES NO. L6,the SPGBkicks offwith
a swipeat the establishmentwhich createsa public n&ich is "docile'nwallowing
in "political ignorance, general indifference, apathy and prejudice against
Socialism". (34)
On the very samepageit refers to "the so-calledcommunists of Russia"and
on the next pagemakes the stock charge that "Socialismhasneverbeentried'.
lTheir italics.] Obviouslyl-enin,lbotslry, Stalin, and perhaps most of all' Bla
Kun, would turn in their gpavesifthey realised that not only had they never
tried socialism but had never even been conmitted to it. I*nin's collected
works run to 56volumes, (35) most ofwhich are devotedto espousingthe cause
48
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
49
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
ChapterEighfiA StraightLookAt
BolshevismIn Practice
TheRevolutionBeforeAnd After:
A PottedHistory Of Bolshevism
The foltowing account - which is largely non'contentious ' has beenincluded
to showwhat sort of men the Bolsheviks were,and the result in practice, of
the adoption of hard line socialist policies. Ihe word that best sums up the
Bolsheviksis scnm.For that is preciselywhatthesemenwere.Scum.Iheywere
scum after they seizedpower,and they were scum beforethey seizedpower.
Although communist theory goesback to Karl Marx and indeedway back
before him, the history of Bolshevism begins with Lenin. On May 8, 1887'
Lenin's elder brotheq Alexander Ulyanov,uas hangedalong with four other
conspirators for plotting to assassinatethe Tsar. According to at least one
source,he seemstohavebeentotallyunrepentant,andtherecanbelittle doubt
that this had a profound effecton the young Lenin. (1) Lenin took an interest
in radical politics himself, andwas active in the Social Democratic Party (the
RussianSocial DemocraticLabour Party).Ihe SecondCongressof this party
washeldin Brusselsandlondon fromJuly30,1903'anditwas atthis congress
that the split occurred betweenthe Bolsheviks and the Mensheviks. \{hile
Leninleilthe Bolshevikfaction,JuliusMartovledthe Mensheviks.Atthistime
the Bolshevikswerein the majorify, (2) but by 1908all the leailing Bolsheviks
bar Zinoviev and Kamanev had desertedLenin. Both men were executedby
stalin in 1936,(3) as, incidentally, was the aforementionedMarxist-I-eninist
lunatic Bla lhrn. This was Kun's reward for his fanatical devotion to both
Lenin and Communism. (4)
In spite of their professedideal of sharing the wealth, the main priority of
the Bolsheviksnas to raise moneyto maintain their organisationand to sprcad
their ideologr. We should not deride them for this; evenorganisations which
seekto restrdcture capitalist societyon a not-for-profit basis haveno altema-
50
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
tive but towork - for the present - within the confines of the capitalist system.
However,as Lenin's biographer points out "The Bolshevik Centre had to be
maintained at all eosts- and moneyhad to be raised by any possible means.n
(5) [Emphasis addedJ lhese means included political maniages, forgrng
cumency,donations from wealthy sympathisersand, not the least" robbery' in
one case with appalling Ioss of life. One wealthy s;mpatliser, the Moscow
mi[isnsirc Sava Morozov, subsidised the Bolsheviks to the tune of 12'fi)0
rubles a year. (O As with our latter day socialist millionaires, the poor fellow
obviously didn't realisejust how much the recipients of his largesshated him
for the crime of being rich, nor what sort of fate they had in storc for him.
Morozov didn't live long enoughto frnil ou$ he sqmmitted suicide in 1905.IIe
was said to have left a large legacyfor the promotion of Bolshevism;he and
many other bourgeoissupported the Bolshevik cause,with lenin's full knowl-
edge. (7) this is the equivalent of German Jews frnancing Hitler in the fuIl
linowledgeof the Nazis'programme of exclusionand expulsion. (8)
Ihe Bolsheviks' criminal methods of raising moneywere called'acpropria'
tions;I*nin's biographer refers to thosewho objectedto expropriation squads
- in particular Plekhanovand Martov'as squeamish.(9) Ienin spent most of
his life exiled abroad.Anothsl lea.ling Bolshevikwho spenta great dealof time
in (internal) exilewas Stalin. On one occasionStalin defendeda man who had
robbed a peasant before an ad hoc court of political exiles. The thief is a
product of capitalist societyr,he argueil' "Instead of condemninghim for his
ac! he should berecruited, becausemen of this type arrenecessaryforthe fight
to destroy the capitalist order." (10) For a man tike Stalin it was but a short
step from condoning an act of theft from a poor man for an obviously selfish
purpose to the justification of nurder for a higher purPose. It was he who
organised the greatest Bolshevik expropriationof all, the Tlflis post office
robbery ofJune 1907.
the sum expropriated here was estimated from 250,0fi) to 341'{X}0rubles.
This rms not so much a robbery as an act of mass murder which involved the
killing and maiming of literally sconesof peoplewhen the Bolsheviks opened
up on a post oflice convoy with guns and bombs. (11) Most of the people
murdered during the courseof this robberywould havebeenordinaryworking
people.This terrible act shorw the Bolsheviksin their true colours.
To be scrupulously fair to the Bolsheviks,theywere neither the first nor the
last idealists to resort to criminal activity in order to finance theft higfier
51
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
52
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
53
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
54
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
55
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
56
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
57
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
LeonThotslqy:
An Amu singAnecdote
Orlko
Wehaveseenthe sort of peoplewhomakeup the socialisteliterandthereader
will, doubfless,recall FauIFoot'scommentthat under socialism'most people
will get the samen.Just as Paul Foot is not most people, neither rvas Ieon
lbotslry, for while he nas living in exile in New York, tlis champion of the
doumtroddenand the oppressedappearsto havedoneverywell for himself. In
his autobiography which waspublished in 1930,thotslryurote that all manner
'My only profession in New York
of rumours were circulated about him, but
vas that of a revolutionary socialist." (47) In practise this meant u'riting for
the small circulation emigr6 press and gving a few lectures. Ihe income he
would have derived from this does not taily with his lifestyle at that time;
Antony Sutton finds lhotstcy'sexplanation unconvincing; (48) another author
believesthat lbotsky may havedabbled in the frlm industry. (49)
I{hefher or not 1trisshsmpion of the working classuas indeed bankrolled
by American bankers - Jewishor otherwise- orwhether he was at one time an
aspiring Kirk Douglas (or more likely Charlie Chaplin), he certainly appears
to havelived well in capitalist America. Ihe thotskies rented a houseand were
a IiffIe disappointed when their Negro janitor abscondedwith the rent (50)
Howeve.4their faith in human naturewas revivedwhen theyfound both their
rent and their propertywhich at first they thought had disappeared.lbotslqy
urote that The janitor had taken the noney of the tenants who had already
received their receipts; he ditl not mind robbing the landlord, but he was
considerate enough not to rob the tenants." He and his wife were deeply
touched: nit seemedas if a coruer of the veil that concealedthe black problem
in the United States had lifted.' He called the janitor "A delicate fello#. (51)
Doubtless the landlord had harsher words for him.
One reasontle lbotskies lived so well in the United StatesurasbecauseLev
Davidovich spent a lot of his time poncing off socialism's staunchest suppor-
ters. In L930,henrote "In the United Statesthere is a large classofsuccessful
and semi-successfuldoctors, Ianyers, dentists, engineers,and the like who
divide their precious hours ofrest betweenconcerts by European celebrities
58
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
and the American Socialist part5r."(52) It is people like this who have always
beenthe backbone of the socialist movement.And people like this who have
alwaysbeenthe first to go up againstthewall comethe rcvolution. Incidentally'
throughout his lifer lhotslry seens to have had no or little trouble moving
aboutf how manyrrorkerf at that time could afford to move from the Soviet
Union to the United Statesand back? How many of tlem could haveafforded
to travel to spain, and to Mexico, and to take their families with them?
totslrywas far from the only such "revolutionary" who flitted from country
to countrywith apparent easeand little or no declaredincomel asstateq Lnin
spent much of his life in exite. Other socialists have devotedenormous time
uid to stirring up trouble, and organising expensiveconferencesand
"fo"t
demonstrations: (53) where did the money come from? where does it come
from?
Returning to Lev Davidovich,oneof the peoplewho entertainedthe thotskies
*, u Dr M. Mrs lbotslcy and her sonsweretaken out for jaunts bythe
"""tuio
good doctorts wife, and on one occasionwhen the happy party visited a tea
'\ilhy doesn't the chaulfeur comein?" (54)
ioom the boys asked their mother:
How could anyonehave evergiven theserevolutionaies the time of day?
Not that it was all play and no work for everybody'sfavourite working class
hero. totslry studied the economichistory of the United Statesand found that
e:rports grew during the war. The growth urasso great that it astoundeil him.
ftir r""-r to have led him to the belief tlat capitalism wants wan (5O Of
course,capitalists often do profit from war, but beforethey can so profrt from
a war, ihere has to be somebodyto start one. Certainly socialism has started
morc than its fair share of wars this century.Andwe should never forget that
the likes of lhotsky and Lenin are at war with us all of the time; whether you
realise it or not, whether you want to confront tlem or nof they are frghting
you unrrcmittingly in the classwar.
Interestingly,lbotslry gfossesover Kronstadt in his autobiography; there is
no mention here of the rebellion proper. And certainly no mention of shooting
workers tike ducks in a pond, probably becausesuch "untypical" socialist'in'
spired brutalify would not have gone doum too well with his concert'going
doctor friends in the American Socialist Party.
Sevenyearslater, Thotskypublisheda damning indictment of socialismrThe
Rwolution Betrayed..(5O In the first chapter he asks what has beenachieved,
and concludesnot a lot "In thebestmetal foundry,accordingto the acknow'
59
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
ledgment of its director, the output of iron and steel per individual worker is
a tlird as nuch as the averageoutput of American foundries.n (57) He refers
to the dying awayof the stateasa "sociologicaltheorem"; (58) and statesbaldly
that nln a communist sociefi the stateand moneywill disappeanlheirgradual
dying avay orrghtconsequentlyto begin under socialism." (59) It is now mone
than half a centura since totslry's assassination, and three quarters of a
century since the glorious rcvolution he and his kind foisted onto tfie Russian
people,and to someextent onto the rest of mankind. Thewithering arvayof the
state is no neaner than it ever was, but still lhotslry's acolytes continue to
proclaim that it is just around the corner and that when it doesanive all will
bemitkand honey.\ilhichis surelyproofenoughthat socialismis lessa science
than a religion.
60
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
ChapterNine:More AboutTheMedia
Who ControlsThePastControlsThe
Future - TheMedia Under Socialism' 1
A chargeoften madeby the far left is that the Westem media is controlled by
a handful of super-rich corporations hellbent on serving the interests of the
rich. Fhequently,onehears expressionslike "the Tory press".This is a serious
criticism and one the cument uriter will not attempt to gloss over. Unfortu-
nately,the inevitable outcomeof uncontrolledlaissezfaireis that somecor?or-
a6ons and inilivirluats will becomenot only incredibly wealthy but incredibly
power{ulrandthattheywillattempttoexertthispower,sometimessuccessfully'
in wayswhich are detrimental to the interests of the majority. If nothing else,
such power allows them to buy favourable publicity, or, as is morrcoften the
case,to suppressne$4sworthy stories becausetheywould embanass ' or indict
- the powerful. Also, in most if not all Westerncountries - and many others '
the mainstream media has long since becomepart of the establishment. This
is a defacto politicat reality which is not worth seriously debating.
Accepting this, the socialists' cure is, as ever'worse than the disease.Their
argument is that the media is controlled by a few vested interests, so power
shouldbe takenout ofthe handsofthe fewand placedin the handsofthe one'
(ie the state).Whenthe state controls all outlets of information, it is able to
exert a terri$ing and literally malevolentinfluence over not only all communi-
cation, but over the minds of its subjects.Ilere is what actually happened in
the SovietUnion.
In May 1920,a famous photograph wastaken of Lenin adilressing a crowd
of troops. (1) In this photograph, thotslry and Kamanev apPearin the back'
ground. Thesetwo were later painted out. (2) One of the gfeatest atrocities of
the second\ilorld war was the Katp Forest massacreof some14,500Polish
officers andintellectuals. (3) The remains of only4l53 ofthe nenwere actually
found, (a) but there can be no doubt whatsoeverthat theywere all murdered
by the communists. At the kangaroo court that was Nuremberg, the soviets
6t
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
Krushchevon Stalin
Krushchev's address was actually made on February 24, L956 in a closed
sessionofthe 1lventiethCongress.Ihe first newsofthe addressand an outline
nas publisheil in the New York Times,March 15, 1956.(8) The full text of the
speechwas published by the U.S. State Department on June 4, andan edited
version of the text appearedin the Na,vYorkTime.rthe following day.The actual
addressran to more than fiftypages. Dr FbedSchwarzsaid this was perhaps
the most remarkable speechever made. (9)
Among other things, Krushchev revealedthat Stalin planned to "do away
with" (10) Molotov and Mikoyan, andwould have done if he hailn't died. He
62
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
Who ControlsThePastControlsThe
Future - The Media Under Socialism- 2
One commentatorhas written that "Thefalsification of photographscones
easily to those govemmentsand elites that seekto be the sole interpreters of
history and have a monopoly on the information media." (14) This is un-
63
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
doubtedlytrue, but the claim by author Alain Jaubert that this sort ofthing
can't happen in a denocracy outside of war (L5) becauseof "pluralify of
information, freedomof accessto sources,freedomof expression..." is simply
not true, (16) as anyonewho has studiedthe continuedfaking, dissemination
and endorsementof Holocaustpropagandawill surely realise.(17)
Ironically, the latest battle for state control (or regulation) of the media, is
taking place largely in that great bastion of capitalism, the United States.The
adventof the Intemet hasenabledpeopleto communicatecheaplyand instan-
taneouslywithpeopleon the other sideof theworld. This meansflat, in theory
at least,it will beimpossiblein the future for anygovernmentto hushup major
embarrassingincidents such as the March 1993siegeat Waco,Tbxas,(18)
which resulted in such appalling loss of life, and is widely perceivedby even
the less conspiratorially-minded of Americans as an act of state-sponsored
massmurder. (19)
In the past year or so (20)atl mannerofnonsensehas beencirculatedabout
bomb manuals beingmadeavailable through the Internet; (21) an anti-Semitic
hategamecalled.ConcentrationCampManagerQ2) in which you win by gassing
[sic] the most Jewsin the most economicalmethod;child pornography,(23)
and much more. It is difticult to believethat all this nonsensehas beenthe
result of sensationalisttabloid or simply irresponsiblejour:nalism.It is quite
likely that many such scare stories are started wilfully as part of the Marxist
Hegelian dialectic of crisis management.(24)
.I/ the numerous conpanies which sell Intemet services can light off the
attempts at regulation by all manner of collectivists and hatemongers,then
censorshipof the Internet in any meaningful sense(if not of anything else)may
eventuallycometo an end. Needlessto say,sucha scenariois overly optimistic.
Under socialism,any Internet providersnas far as they existed,would betotally
under state control, and free communication would go right out of the window
along with all our other freedoms.
Another, pleasing offspin of the Internet - for budding authors - is that it is
nowpossibleforanyonewhocanafford a computeranda modem,andthevery
reasonableconnectioncharges,to linkup. Which meansthat anyonecan now
becomea published poet, writer, or 'zine editor. There is no guarantee that
anyonewill read your outpourings, much less pay for themnbut this fairty
recent exponential leap in household technologr has d.onemore to level the
playrngfield for the buddingartiste tlan socialismhas everdone.
64
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
65
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
ThePowerOfAdvertising
Much is madeby socialistsof the rampant consumerismwhich existsunder
capitalism, and the supposedlymanipulative advertising that goes hand in
hand with it. Again, unlike somecapitalist apologists, the cunent writer does
not dispute that such things exist.
That notwith5141ding,the power ofadvertising, if not the powerofthe media
in general, has beengreatly exaggerated.The truth is that tho'lgh the public
can at times be extremelyfickle, it can also be taken for a ride, as can all of us.
Just as astrologersrecord only their successes, so do the detractorsofadver-
tising record only its successes. The successof marketingis duein large part
not so much to advertising as to market research. Mega<orporations spend
enormoussums of moneyon market research,so onewould expectthem to
make the right marketing decision occasionally.(28) Even so, the failurrcsare
many: there are companiesthat specialisein remaindered books; few and far
betweenarc the fiIm mega-starswho do not make at least one film that sinks
like a lead balloon, or the rock band that doesn't make an album that flops
badly.Evenscandaldoesn'taln'ayssell, as the rock star Michael Jacksonfound
out when he nas accusedof indecently assaulting young boys. Although no
chargesweneeyer frIed against him, his sponsorship deals dried up virtually
overnighL
Likewise,products frequently flop; the current writer has personal experi-
enceof this. A fewyears ago I was an extra in a TV commercial for a chocolate
bar. Ihe company- Cadbury's, I think - hired a WestEnd theatre for two days
and literally hundreds of extras [incluiling myselfl. (29) I receivedabout f,70
for twelvehotrswork (although I was there for far less than that). On top of
that everyonereceivedf4 lunch allowanceand a free breakfast. (Nice work if
you can get it). Tiofilm this commercial - about 30 secondsworth of film - and
to screenit, must havecost tle advertiserliterally hundredsof thousandsof
pounds.As far as I recall, I sawit onceon Tf, then it sankwithout trace. I can't
evenrecall the name of the chocolatebar itwas madeto advertise.The reader
can argue that this evidenceis merely anecdotal,but if he looks around hewill
frnd many similar examplesof commercialflops.
66
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
67
SOCIALISM?
UNDER
FREEDOM
ChapterTen:Monopoly,Marketing
AndEmployment
OnMonopolies
Aswehavealreadypointedout,tle inevitableoutcomeof uncontrolledlaissez
faire is that somecorporations becomeboth incredibly wealthy anil increrlibly
powerful.In somecasesthis canleadto monopoly,or more usuallyduopolyor
otigopoly,inwhich the market is dominated by one,two, or a few such giants.
(1) It is a widelyheld beliefthat oncemonopolystatusor somethingapproach'
ing it has been achieved,the monopolist can exploit his consumerswith
impunity. Socialists believethat this is a powerful argument for state owner-
ship of major industries.Like manywidelyhelil beliefs,this is urong, as is the
belief of socialiststhat the state canrun suchindustries better,more efficiently
and more fairly (whateverthat means)than private enterlrise.
The word monopoly has connotations of power, but a monopoly is not
everythingit is crackedup to be, (asI toowfrom personalexperience).Many
publishershavemonopolyrights on certainnagazinesand books;this doesn't
gUaranteethat theywill be successfu[magazinesgo to the wall everyyear and,
likewise,books are remaindered. (2) In the mid'7Os,a man named Rubik
invented an amusing toy, the Rubik cube,which caught on like wildlire for a
few months and madehim a wealthy man. Although, he ownedthe patent, the
Rubik cube was manufactured by many sompanies.But of course' if he had
decirledto manufacture it himself and the public couldn't seethe novelty, he
could havehad all the Rubik cubesin the world and they wouldn't have done
either him the slightest good or the public the slightest harm.
If onecompanyhad a monopoly of an essentialptoduct, bread for example,
yet sold loavesof suchpoor quality or at such exorbitant prices, it wouldn't be
long before the pubtic realised that bread isn't quite the staple food that it is
meant to be,and would abandonit in favour of somethingelse.cake perhaps!
The increaseddemandfor cakewould meanthat, through the familial 6a1'ftsf
mechanismits price would rise, and this would stimulate both production and
68
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
69
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
Ihe bigest rip-offs of all are the tariffs which countries impose on cheap
imports.Wein Britain are toldthatwe must beprotectedfrom wickedJapanese
businessmenwhoare plotting to destroyour industriesby sellingus cheapTV
sets,video recorders and other merchandisewhich we as consumershave no
altemative but to buy. (8) Thriffs are imposed on Japaneseand other goodsto
protect the home market, to protect iobs and for other fanciful reasons.I)oes
the consu'ner really needprotecting against a companythat will sell him a
better product at a cheaper price? Of course not! But the govemment likes
tarilfs, they raise money,in the short telm at any rate; tley createmake-work
jobs: extra posts for customsofricers,product inspectorsand the like. And
theysavejobs,wearetoldrwhichiswhyorganisedlabourlikesthem.Thereality
though is that tariffs may savejobs in the short term, but it is the consumer
who suffers ultimately. If consumerswant to buyforeign-madegoodstheyhave
to pay the tariff (ie a tax) to the government,which is money they might well
have spent on something else. Or they might have invested it. The money
consumerswould have spent or invested elsewherewould have benelited the
local economyin other ways. (9)
Ihe Japanesein particular have long beencriticised for their efficiencyas
manufacturens.Yes,for their efficiency!And for a smiety that makes so much
noise about the evils of racism, hostility to Japanese manufacturing and
commercial efliciency manifests itself in a curiously xenophobic manner. In
1983,oneauthor, a certain Malvin Wolf, claimedin a paranoid book that Japan
wasout to dominatetheworldwith itseconomicnationalism.ThethemeofThe
fapaneseConspiracy(which might more accuratelyhavebeentitledThe Proto-
colsoftheLeamedEldersof Nippon),is thata sinisterentitycalledtheMinistry
of International Thadeand Inilustry (MITI) had hatched a plot to dominate
worliltrade bytheevenmoresinisterpracticeof subsidisingtheirexportswhile
protectingtheir home markets from cheap imports. (L0)
Maflin Wolfs ravings were nothing new though, a full half century before
his nonsenseappeartd in print, Australian manufacturers were complaining
that Japan was dumping cheapgoods in Australia, and calling for a tariffto
protect Australian industry against this outrageouspractice. (11) DidAustra-
lian manufacturer really want to protect Australian industry or their own
profits?
By making a foreign produced product more expensive,the tariff also makes
the same home produced product cheaper,but only in relative tems, not in
70
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
71
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
72
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
nreason-
Parkerruled tlat the contract,which Michaelhad siped in 1988'was
able and fair'. (18)
It is all too easyfor musicians and others to portray sucha battle as a replay
of David and Goliath, to whit, an enotmouscorporation riding roughshodover
its artists. Granted that Michael was (and remains) a big name and that he
sincerelybelievedhe had fua oppressed,itisan undisputedfact that he was
able to afford to bring, and lose, suchan action. How many of us havesomuch
moneythatwe canafford to tlrow awaynearlythree million pounds to preserve
our artistic fircedom?How many rock musicians and bands who were not
making GeorgeMichael's mega-buckswould havehappily traded placeswith
him and allowed the companyto dictate its ouarterms?
The judge said that Michael had beenpoorly advised by his team. Pundit
Jonathan King (himself a fonner perfomer) said Michael had sold his soul
to the Devil. Hewould havebeena Greekwaiter otherwise.(19)
Then there are the innumerable disputes betweenboxing promoters/mana-
gers and professional tighters. Whilst it is undoubtedly true that sharks can
be found in all professions,is it reatly true that there are more to the square
mile in boxing? Surely a promoter who invests in a frghter, payrng for his
haining his board, his fares, and paying the fighter as well, is entifled to an
aboveaveragereturr?
I,et us brieflyreview both fields: boxing and music. Apromoter or manager
may invest heavily in a fighter, whosecareer could be endedat any time if he
sulfers an iqiury. (20) A rccord companymay spendenormous sums of money
financing and promoting a band. There is no guarantee that any particular
frghter will becomea world champion, or any sort of champion; similarly there
is no guaranteethat any particular bandwill becomea mega'success'or break
even. Becausethe failures are many, the investor must recoup his losses
through his successesas well as reaping his rewards through tlem.
Ihe most notorious boxing promoter in the world is Don King' he of the
electric haircut. (21) King has beeninvestigatedby the authorities more than
oncefor his altegedsharp practices. Evenso,there are somePeoplewhospeak
very highly of Don King. One such person is the British fight manager and
promoter FhankWamen,u&o in November1989,was gunneddonmin an East
London strcet.Yearslater he tolil a British boxingmaga"ine that the veryfirst
phone call he had taken after the assassinafion attempt had been from a
concemedDsn King. Wamencommentedthatyou rememberthings like that.
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
SocialismAnd Unemployment
Oneof the recurrentcises of capitalismhas beenso-calledunemplolment.I
say so-calledbecauseit is taken for granted by alk economists,politicians,
labour leaders...thatfull emplolment is desirable,and that this should be the
frrst priority of any govemment,along with keepinginflation down.We cannot
discussthe SocialCredit theoriesof Major Douglasherefor want of space;it
will sufrice to saythat emplo;m.entfor employment'ssakeis as undesirable as
itis unnecessary.Ihedesiretoeffectfull employmentstemsfromthefallacious
betiefthat the purposeofthe financial systemis to act as a systemofpnnisfu-
ment and reuard.We havealreadydiscussedat somelengththe failings of the
socialisVcommunistsystembecauseof its erosionof incentivesas much as its
74
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
l5
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
job, faiting which their benelits will be cut off. The culrent uriter does not
approve of this and indeed opposesit vigorously.But the socialist altemative
of work for all is no altemative at all.
RememberThotsky'smaxim that under socialism who doesnot work shall
not eat becomeswho doesnot obeyshall not eat? lbrrible as the future is for
the unemployableunder capitalism in the 21st Century it will be far more
terible under socialism.Becauseunder socialism,it is not simply the socially
inadequate, the unkempt, the recidivist, the wino...who are unemployable.
Under socialism, anyonervho doesnot obeyis unemployable.Living proof of
this are the sundry hate canpaigns that havebeenmounteil against so'called
racistsby'anti-racisf" socialistfanaticsandtheir fellowtravellers,(seenote14).
As with any and everyother freld of human activity, peoplecan and should work
to reform the system, to repeal repressive laws, to improve the lot of the
workers, of women, of children, and of the old and infim, etc. But whatever
approach is ailopted towards the so'called problem of unemploSmenf social'
ism is not the answer.
76
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
the time of writing a minimum wageof around f,3 to S4per hour is beingmooted
bytheLabourFart;l,andeventhatisn'tmuch.Ina free- orlargelyfree-market,
r;vagerates arc determined by market forces. A minimum wagecan be either
greater than or Iessthan or the sameas the rate determinedby the markel If
the minimrn wageset by the govemment (or the relevant quango)is equal to
or less than the rate determined by the market there is no point setting it. If
for argument's sakethe govemmentwere to set an absurdly Iow rate, say 50p
per hour, for which no one in his right mind would worl and which no one
could possibly exist on, then there wouldn't be any point at all in setting one.
In practice, the only purpose of bringing in and enforcing a minimum wage
;. 16ssmpel employersto pay abovethe market rate. Again, this soundsgood
for peoplein extremelypoorly paid jobs, but if the employercan't alford to pay
such a rate then these peoplewill be thrown out of work If that is not clear,
imaginentat would happenin the governmentdeclaredthat cateringworkers
had to be paid a minim 'rn wageof f,100per hour and that any employerwho
didn't pay sucha rate would be thrown into gaol. Is there any caf6,restaurant
or five star hotel that coulil pay any of its workers sucha wage?Obviously not,
becausebusinessesgenerateincome by selling goods and services,and the
going rate for a bacon sandwichat the present time is about a pound" t&ich
meansthat no catering establishmentin the countrywould be ableto pay such
absurdly high uages.
VVith a more realistic minimum wage the problem would still exis* if
employers couldn't afford to pay the going rate they would either have to a)
employ people clandestinely at belowthe market rate or b) not employ them
at all. In short minim ur wagesdestroyjobs rather than either createthem or
protect oppressedworkers. (27)
Allied to minimum wagesare price controls. Like ninimum uagesthey don't
worlq and they have the added drawback, that, running contrary to human
nature, tley encourageblack market activity and thereby criminalise a large
sectionofthe population. Price controls (and rationing) don'twork because
whercverthere is a demand,there are peoplewho are willing to supply it, and
again it is ttre market that is the principal deterninant of price. (28) If
producersare precludeilbylawfrom sellingbelowacertainpricetheywillsoon
be undercut by their lessscrupulous competitors. If on the other hand they are
not permitted to sell abovea certain price theywill either not sell at all or cone
to someother arrangementwitl their customers,egperhapstheywilltake part
77
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
of the palment in cash offthe books.Again, all that happensis that business
is hamperedand otherwiseindustrious peopleare criminalised.
A brief mention here of rationing. It is well documentedthat the in the former
soviet union comtption was endemic and that anyonewho wanted to obtain
goods or servicespromptly (or of a quatity the state could not supply) had to
greasea few palns. An extremeexampleof the ill effects of rationing uas the
oil crisis in the 70s. shortages of oil in the united states werc not causedby
the Arab producer states rrestricting supply, or bumping up prices, theywere
caused by the us govemment's affempts to respond to the cnsisby imposing
domestic controls. The best nay to react to such a cnss is to ipore it, for if
certain overseasproducers of oil - or of any other commodify - decide to
increase their prices way abovethe market rate, the relative cost of domestic
production falls and this stimulates investment. Likewise, other overseas
competitors soon decide that they can increase their share of the market by
lowering their prices. In practice, the onlyway a cartel can ever be preserved
is by legislation, othenrise somebodyalwaysgets greedyand breaksit up.
78
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
AntinomianCommunism:
GuiltyByDint OfBirth
We have mentioned atready the antinomian aspectsof communism/social-
ism. Now let's hear it straight from the horse's mouth. Here is Lenin himself
speaking: "A Communist must be prepared to make every sacrifice and" if
neeessa(y,even resort to all sorts of schemesand stratagems,employ iilt-
inate methods, concealthe truth, in order to get into the trades unions, stay
there,and conductthe revolutionaryworkwithin..." (1)
I-enin's biographer David Shub wrote that Lenin was scornful of trades
unions but sought to control them. (2) Indeed, in this rrcspecthis successors
have been spectacularly successftrlin most Westem nations bar the United
States; the trades union movement has becomeall but synonlmous with
socialism, although most workers wouldri't be too keen on socialism if they
realised exactlywhat the comradeshavein store for them whenthe revolution
comes.
Herc is another Lenin quotefrom the samework,and this oneis a lollapa-
looza: "!Ye repudiate all such morality that is taken outside of human class
concepts.We saythat this is tleception,a fraud, which clogsthe brains of the
workers and peasantsin the interest of the landlords and capitalists.We say
that our morality is entirely subordinatetl to the interest of the slass strrrggls
of the proletariat. Our morality is derived from the interests of the class
struggle ofthe proletarial' (3)
In otherwords, anything that furthers the class struggle is good,including
mass murder, evenif such mass murder includes the workers who are being
liberatedby the socialists.It is a staple of socialist propagandathat peopleare
guilty by dint of their birth; (4) the fact that Lenin and most of the othel lsa.ling
socialists were of bourgeois extraction never enters the equation; when the
79
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
80
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
One author has nritten tha* "Facedwith a clash betweentheir ideas and the
evidence,scientists will change their ideas. The special pleaders, like social
scientists, prefer to change the evidence,and show why normal judgments
cannotbemadein their particular case.Veryoften it is the supremeimportance
of the causewhich is called upon to justify the specialstandards." (8) This may
or may not be true of all social scientists, but it is certainly true of "socialist
scientistsn,and indeedof socialistsgenerally.
81
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
Up
TheComradesWake
Ihe death of the leader of the Labour Pu"ty, Joho Smith, in 1994 at the
relativelyyoungage of55, brought the electionofthe youthful Tony Blair as
head ofthe Opposition. Blair has set about the deconstruction ofthat party's
socialist machinery and has attempted, for the most part successfully,to
inftoduceseriousreforms toits economicpolicy.Thisis notsonethingentirely
new,and indeedBlair has for the most part simply continued the processthat
John Snittr introduced after Labour had suffered its fourth consecutive
82
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
General Election defeat.The last defeatwas all the more difftcult to swallow
not becauseit uas the fourth in a row but becauseLabour had expected
confidently to win. The biggest changein Labour Party policy has been the
scrappingof ClauseFour,an antiquatedpieceofnonsensedatingfrom ante-
diluvian times which committed the party to the state control of major indus-
hies. (16)
Labour is far from the only "socialist"partywhich haswokenup to the reality
of the unworkability of socialism; the Revolutionary Communist Party pub-
lishes a magazine called,Living M amismwhich is lessManist than Libertarian;
on occasionthe RCP have evenoffered to debatewith "fascists".(17) But the
most telling indication that the boobs have iinally woken up came' for the
current writer, whenhevisited the oflices of theMoming Star newspaperin 1992
as part of his ongoing researchesinto far left ideologr. Though tbe Moming
,Sfar(which was founded in 1930as tbleDaily Worker)was oncea signifrcant
Communist Party newspaperyits circulation has dwintlletl significantly over
the yrcars.(18)
Ihe person who assisted me with my researchesat the lmper was Don
Cuckson,a time servingcommunistwhowasthe Archivist/Librarian.If I recall
he was long retired, had white hair and worked for the paper part time. At the
time of myvisit, radical changesweregoing on behind the former Iron Curtain;
I asked Don Cucksonwhat he thought about all this. In reply he took out a
piece of paper which he said concerned the Nomenklaturain Poland. It was a
lengthy list of the faithful. Every important office of every organisation had
beencontrolled by a party official from, not just national and local government
butright iloumtothelocal chessclub.Don Cucksonlookeda sadoldmanwhen
he told me that this wasn'twhat he meantby socialism.By socialismhe meant
freedom,and this wasn't it. I found this both very moving and very saQ if Don
Cuckson,who nnasobviouslyadecenthuman being' unlike someof the scum
one finds in the SWP - if he, and people like him' had laboured under the
illusion for so long that they had beenfighting for freedom, peoplewho had
devotedtheir entire working lives to the "struggle", then somethingmust be
tenibly wrorg with, not only the socialist system,but with people'scritical
faculties also.
83
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
84
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
I I
Recall Initiative
rl Referendum
Suffrage
tl
tl
Legis1ature JudiciarY Executive Civil CensorshiP
Service
Examinations
85
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
Only a fool would deny the fact that, although we have the right of suffrage -
every live years or so - the people do not, by and large, have the power of
initiative, Q2) nor of recall, and only very rarely have we seen referenda
an;'rrherein the Westernworld. The other tendencyis for the various anns of
governmentto be either concentratedinto the Executiveor to be subvertedby
all manner of special interest groups. The theme of Frederick HayelCs19214
bookThe RoadTb Serfdomis that all governments,the then Nazi goYemment
of Germany,that of the (much more recently defunct) Soviet Union, and the
so-calleddemocraciesof the West,were,and are, travelling the sameroad.
Indeed,as long agoas 1936,a respectedAmerican politician, Alfred E. Smith
of New Yorl made precisely the same claim: "Just get the platform of the
Democraticparty andgetthe platform ofthe Socialistpartyandlaythem doum
onyour dining-roomtable,sideby side,and geta heavyleadpencilandscratch
out the word 'Democratict and scratch out the word 'Socialist,' and let the two
platforms lay there, and then study the record.of the presentadministration
up to date.' (23)
He was referring here to the New Deal administration of Flanklin Delano
Roosevelt,in particular to its collectivisation ofresourcesand their redistribu-
tion "not by any processof law, but by the whims of a bureaucratic autocracy.n
Q4)
Then Smith madethis stark challenge:"After you havedonethat makeyour
mind up to pick up the platfom that more nearly squareswith the record, and
you will haveyour hand on the Socialistplatform...it is not the first time in
recordedhistory that a group ofmen havestolenthe livery ofthe churchto do
the work of the devil." (25)
Another extremelywellinformed indivitlual writing on this samesubjecthas
observedthatkars bringcontrols and...somepeople in high placesaresofond
of contrsls that a war may appear a desirable means16r s5ta[lishing them.'
(20
kst the reader think this is idle rhetnric, let me quote someonewho
endorsedthis idea. In March 1933,the LondonDaily kpress reported that:
86
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
87
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
makesthem look more important and givesthem more power,it also makes
their ownjobs more secure,for when the axe is wielded,it is inevitably the
junior and'less important" poststhat are lost. It is not necessarytopostulate
any sort of conspiracytheoryto explainsuchempire-building,it is sinply how
human natureworks.
It is this phenomenonmorr than any other that e4plains the grorvth of
bureaucracythroughout the capitalist world" and to a great extent the strang-
ling of industry by red tape. Peoplewho work in certain agenciesare forever
drrcamingup newways to justify their own existence,and to push their own
agendas.In order to do this they will stoop to the basestof tricks, including
outright lying and often naked tyranny. An excellent example of this is the
anti-smoking industry.
In Chapter Six we mentioned the Harry Elphick casel other dirty tricks of
the anti-smoking lobby include the manufactured controversy over passive
smoking,the useofchildren to entrap tobacconists,and the abuse,doctoring,
and even outright faking of mortality statistics. In the United Statesnthe
Environmental Protection Agencyhas used its Draconian powers to virtually
strangle industry, and has manufactured one environmental scare after an-
other. (30)
B8
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ChapterTlvelve:Race,Socialist
MendacityAndTheAppealOf Fascism
Anti-SemitismAndTheRiseOfThe
PopularFront
Ihe current uriter has demonstratedclearly here, as have many beforehimt
that the main appeal of socialism has alwaysbeento intellectuals, and that
genuineworkers in the movementhave beenfew and far between.That being
said, there havealuays beenmore waysthan one to skin a cat, and the more
dedicated members of the Socialist International have long resorted both to
the infiItration of bona fide movementsfor social reform and to the creation
ofpopular fronts in order to further tleir long term goal, the subjugation of
all nankind. (1)
A popular front is exacflythat [ie an organisationwhich supports a popular
causebutwhich is in reality (or also) a front for other activitiesl. It is usually
a campaigning organisation created by communistsand/or socialists with the
ostensiblepurposeofbringing about desirablesocialchange.Ihis can be any
number of things, but the two most important fields in which the far left has
campaigned since the end of tle SecondWorld War are (against) nuclear
proliferation - specilicallythrough CND - and assortedraceissues.
Theearlyl920ssawtheriseof Italian FascismundertheleadershipofBenito
Mussolini. At the time, Fascismwas an entirely non'racial philosophy. (We
touched on this brielly in Chapter Three). Ilowever, in Gemany' National
Socialism which (all but purists like Colin Jordan will concede)is a form of
fascism, took on a distinctly anti-Semitic flavour. Again' we must stress that
anti-Semitism is not a necessaryingredient of fascist or even of National
Socialist ideology.It is not widely known that the Dutch Nazi Farty' founded in
1931under the leadership of Anton Adriaan Mussert, was totally non-anti'
Semitic. (2)
89
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
90
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
91
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
92
SOCIALISM?
UNDER
FREEDOM
SixMitlion ReasonsToHate
TheWhite Race
The SecondWorld War endedwith perhaps fifty million dead,and atrocities
committed on both sides, for such is the nature of war. Allied atrocities
included such acts of insanity as Hiroshima, Nagasaki,the fire-bombing of
Tolryo and the destruction of Dresden. However,at the end of the war, the
victors hit on the novel ideaof putting the vanquishedon trial, mosfly Germans
but also many Japanese,and collaboratorssuch as the Iilorld War One hero
and leader of vichy Flance, Marshal P6tain. The focus of the spurious war
crimes trials was, and remains, the Nazi death camps, including the allegetl
extemination camps of Auschwitzand others in the East.
The British, who liberated Belsen,found somethirteen thousandcol?ses
lying arounil the camp, which was disease-ridden,particularly with typhus'
and, on account of severelogistical and other problems, a sceneof mass
starvation and utter homor. Simitar sceneswere found at other liberateil
camps,including Dachau,althoughbynomeansall the liberatedinmateswere
infected with typhus, or starving. Someof those liberated at Dachau were fit
enoughto abusetheir forner captors. (18)
altuay of the true nature of the Nazi camps is beyond the scope of the
currentwork,itwill sufriceto sayherethatall the camps,andtheNazi ideologr
which is saiil to have created them, have,by clever propagandaand manipu-
lation of the media, becomeassociatedpermanently in the public mind with
racial hahed and genocide.Although it has never beenclaimed - exceptby the
sensationalist prtss and the ignorant ' that Belsenwas any sort of extermina'
tion canp, (19) the public perception of the Holocaust has alwaysbeen,in the
93
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
94
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
pean powerscertainly did exploit the peoplesof Africa and India. But overall,
tle Imperialists bestowedfar more benefitson their subjectsthan misery.
The distinguishedliberal historian ProfessorQuigley has written that:
"British rule in the periotl 1858-1947tied Intlia togetherby railroads, roads,
and telegraphlines.It broughtthe countryinto contactwiththeWesternworld,
and especiallywithworlil markets, by establishinga uniform systemof money'
steamboatconnectionswith Europe by the Suez Canal, cable connections
tlroughout the world, and the use of English as the languageof government
and administration, Best of all, Britain establishedthe rule of laq equali8
beforethe law,and a tradition ofjudicial fairness to replacethe older practice
of inequality and arbitrary violence." (22)
This was far from the only contribution of the wicked Imperialists to the
Indian sub-continent.The ResearchBulletins of the Agricultural Research
Institute at Pusa for 1911-12report on flax experiments,wheat cultivation'
rrcsearchinto horsediseases,rice diseases,bee-keeping, and much more. (23)
Other, equally impressivecontributions to the welfare of Indians and other
colonial peoplesweremadein many other fields.
Nowherewasthe impact of colonialism greater than in Africa. Contrary to
the fantasies of the Boas school of cultural anthropologf' there was never any
civilisation in Black Africa in any meaningful senseof the word. The first
pnerequisitefor civilisation is a written language,and it is a fact that the Negro
has oever developedanyuritten langUage.Thus, evenslaveryhas not been
entirely without benefit to the Negfo, albeit to later generations rather than
thosewho sufferedunder it and died in their millions while being transferred
to the NewWorld in the most brutal and inhuman of conditions.
Becauseofthe hysteria oYerracisrnwhich has beengeneratedby the scenes
found at Belsenand elsewhere,and ofthe allegedNazi genocideofthe Jews,
any suggestion that different races have different (ie inferior) potential to
contribute towards the advanceof civilisation has becometaboo throughout
academiaaswell asthroughout the media.Theword racivn (24) has beenused
as a catch-all deviceto blame the White Man for all the sins of the world and
to excuseall black shortcomings. Whites have been portrayed as inherently
evil; blacksas oppressed.Thewordracism is usedto desipate not only a belief
in innate racial differences(its original meaning) but hostility to racial inte-
gration - including forced integration - hostility to miscegenationand the
95
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
96
L6
'ru6pl.roXl puotas eqf aJoJag'quu{ eqfJoro sard,(d a .Ilnupqp aqlJo (09)
'xnuwpbsg pe{teu-iloqs aql Jo 'asaugq3Jluqlo Jo 'aldoadetlqraJo etue5ge
eq1.{uap,tpreq uuJ euo lpar sgpuu slsFe eJsU 'JapJolsJg aqf Jo esnesuou
q s$[l'auo pcfololq s ueql raqler ldaruor lultos e q l luql lspra ,tlear
luseop eter IBIII sga111sa8E;q puu lsrg aq;,'sytrl W1nop o1Eulqlauos e Bq
,{gensns,nalpawuwnwuolgu xlspue uaquoqc m3'u.reEg'sag ffiI4no pue
'sqrpq ,tgp yo.rauuuu ,(q ,{larJosrIJe$alI uo pasodu;
IlsurIJBIq 1euopoua 1e
ueeqsuq ldecuor sn8oqqryauo lspr.rstrtre q usllDrlo ldaeuoc,iral aq1'rp
'arJpnfard',(.r1oftqppu.rgo atuelsgeeql,tuapo1qqlooJ eqppo r lI q8noqfry
rusIJBu6rusrcug6msleug
:f,ro1sl11fuareg
q sepIIBeUIuIrsU
'puplrrBrtr uInJ
Jo lBnlueaeaql of pBaIII]$ oq,[ suoJoluIIBqI
JaqpJ splolluu sglgpuu ',{.rnlueCqpltue {I eqlJo sJelseslp1uluautror! uaprIB
sa;pa8e.q usunq eqlJo IIe lsortrleroJalqpuodsaruaaqa^sqoqrasuoJou ueqf
Jeqlar splolluu 'asel fue q 'q lI ',tuuu.r,$pue uogede1s luslnsal aql pue
'usprgrellooyouo;1dopueql fq raEgauols aIOof {tsq sdeq.radfassalfa.r pue
Lra,nodyo uolsnllIp puu ,(uouora pusuap u :ua1s,ts1sJp11dere ,(q pacuequa
aq ru$,i{Iqu 1uq1'uopeslllalr B ulqulsltr pue p[nq o1aoe.r.,(ue;o ,{1gquaq3
Ja alcqlrpuy'qq3 pa,ro.rda^BqsaFtrouoca ;q1e11deJ Jleql paulqar e^Eqtuql
selJlunoJusrFJV AreJasoql !uo1s.ra,r,qns ls1unurtrol JollnseJ aql ,t1afue1san 1g
aleuu! s.uetrAl
1eq1s; ,(4pa.r aql !,{1pro;.ra3ul {c"Ig aql Jo llnser elg q slsapoq1
go uopqgodsap luelFser aql feql antuu fuu6 IBuolf"N qspprg eqf Jo so[I
eql'asJnotJo ailqDEulz ,rlou6qsapoqgu1pauadduq1uq,n,t1aspa.rd s1s;ry
aql srra4pt1.reqlerlaldoadeql Jo IIpr
(69) ,,-'aldoadaql go11p$
aqt 1ragarlou saop.{.r1unot lslunwtuo3 B uI luau[ra,rot aryuollstpnurrtrot
',tged
Jo suBeruraqlo pue ssa.rdaq1Jo loJluot pprls Sqqqupu {q puu
prllqod auoInq ge Eulssa.rddns fq auop sl IEILI'luauora,roE eql puu aldoed
aql uaeqeq d;qsuopela.lsnogour.req,{1.rpy e daa>1o1 aSuueu,taql osly
HrGNn
ensnvrcos rvocsluJ
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
98
66
pafFII eql ol ssorJBdoq,(ptrerba{ pus luauitoldEaun ou ,tIIBqr.r^ resns trsl
auoJu! ou ,tsd tpelq ere uoqaJo sprlql onl sepnrurag3oaldoadaqg 'plJoraaql
u;Eupr;1goprupusls lsaq8g qgg aql seq'puusnoqlflx.rseJartru sl uopupdod
esoqa apnurag yo asype.rudpuqq aqf, 'uopeu agq,r,{uu qlln ,t1qe.rno,le3
,{aua.4xa sa.reduoortrrFpruolfeu rpu1q,(pueu.ruopa.rdauo ueaa s! eraql
'spJo,raJoJpmsqe ool q ',f:o1sgo pua salfqa-uou
ssatddosallrlA leqf BapI aql 'qgsg uo ,{.rlunor,trare ,t1png.r,rq punoJ eq
rret suolfBlol stq8g uutunq pus sesnqus1q31.r g4c Sqlpdde pue uorcsatddo
'acpsnfu; 'anouraq;.rng:rurll plroll puoras eql uI poJesns uedug uollsfse ap
aqf sJeplsuot auo uaqlr eIqEDIJBuareJoruaqf ils sl sFtrI '6u.r,r,91 go sprepusls
q8gq,fta,l.{o[ueruaqfJo IJpJo lsoru pue,(lprpuouoJelnJssaJcns ,{gepeepads
ueeqsuq 6uedeg,(qpal'suopeu lseg rud Jo f,olq lsJpgdee ary '6uo.rnu-re1d
aseJ,tuu ug s1,(lgenbapue acpsnf .ro;,(lssapualarapEn.gs suolleu ellqa-Eou
aql l"ql uoprasseaq1'arsrcot{o s7ooglalqdued snouosgodaq1o16u.ru.mlaa
'uopnlos
eql fou sl ,3uslmJ-lpteuprru 'sseprapun aql JoJ ualqo.rd eqf lou sl utspoy
'sserJns pl.rneua.rda.rluapuauouaqd J.reql
roJ sImoJJ",{pu.rud osIB qJlq,rr
ts,ten.raqlou.Iqs!truelJ,ira,r.are,{aq1puu 'anu.r,(p,u-;ep.r s! aJroqp 'salguey
pepuaryea,ruqp.raua8q suegsy6aprs aqlJo pua Jarlp aql IV'einJoarD s uuql
Jeqlou peFrstuun us ualJo a.rou 'aleuay auol e,{q papaaqeru 'selu1spelgn
aq1q ,(leJeadsa6sploqasnoq pBIq Joa8eluae.rad q8q .fn r y ',(Jpeq,Cra,r,t1guu;
Jselrnu eql q1;a pador aaeq sl1relq lsql psJ aldu;s aql q srpulq lsSuouu
,tga,rod a llBIaJ Jo eler q4q aql JoJ uoseer euo 'su"r.rreuy 1nq seo.6ap
,t1uo1oua.replJo r eql rrJsJexoq;qfta,n&reaqdo1aq1p {11un1.r!e11qa,'u.r4;.rg
u! se.r4snpq lrsJnslsa.r pue Sugapr aql Jo a8eluauad aleuoprodordqp
u dn aluu $arsap uellsll Jo suos.rad:salduuxaeleredsJponl1snfaqq o1
'setEr luaraglp
uae qaq suogunpn1; snorrrJouaaqt pue spua4 lalJos qf,ns .ro3alqpuodsa.r
a.ruqrfq,$ aJBr saplseqsJolruJ snoJarunueJeaJerf,L'sanaqdsIB-rJospue JJuo
-uoea,{usu u! sallq r uuql ra$eq,{lapuop.rodord op 'quap.re ep1 8uJpn1eu1
'sa11prou-nu eruos pu" ',$.ra.rod q 8u1,r11oqu sallqrr r{uertrere araq,1'rualqo.rd
',(ga,rod q 3u!4I pue arege r uo s{t"Iq
{relq B ,(le,qsnpxa ,{p.ruq sI sFIl
a.rou,{1a1uuop.rodo.rd,(1a1Fgap lsou anuaraql q8noq;p 1nq'ssulcrapun{rslq
6upno$ pue a6.re1u sI aJaql salqs pafg1 aql q ferll anq,{p.regar q ;1
gg)'a,r;ssardul
,{lunba areft srllsguls J$trouoteJeqfo 's1epgo Euuruer-q8fq,{qperratoro
u30NnNoc=l:lHl
al/usllvrcos
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
(3o Another
states on shoppingtrips. crime is all but unknownon theisland.
non-white which eqioys an extremely high standard of living is the
"utio" As with Bermuda, one does not have to look far to seethe
island of Brunei.
reasons for Brunei's high standartl of living. These two island paradises are
but they indicate that there are many causes of poverty'
totally atypical,
backrvardiess and oppressionbesidesthe universally proclaimed nonsenseof
racismand Imperiafiim. (37)And, incidentally,of the far right's much trum'
petea geoeti" iiot""io"ity of blacks. (38) Which brings us to so'called racially
motivated violence.
Fbequently,much is made of this by the media and by "anti-raclif" organisa-
tions, and atsurrl figures for racial incidents (meaning white on non-white)
including murders are bandied about from time to time. Yet consider the
followintstatistics. Between1969and 1987,2,618peoplewerekilled and more
nan ssrdooinjured in the TioublesinNorthern Ireland. (39)Northem lreland
nur u popot.tion of lessthan 1.6million. (40) The majority of thesethousands
of innocent people were murdered simply becausethey were Protestants or
Catholics. This is what white peopledo to each other; why should they behave
u"i or.*"uv toward.snon-whites? If there had been proportionately that
many racially motivated murders in Britain, we would be talking about a
virtual g"o*id". Then there is the well-documentedcaseof the misreporting
anA cf'nicat exploitation of so-called racial attacks' (41)
Nor does the story end there. In the United States the most serious crime
which the current writer has often seen
^bandiedis black on bhck A statistic
problem
about - one that is truly horriffing - is that onebtackAmerican male
(42) Predictably the
io zr mt eventuallybe murdered, mostly by other blacks.
socialists and their fellow travellers evenblame t|olis onracism.l\e dispropor-
prison (a {igure which is not so much
tionate number of young black males in
result of oppressrue policing, ethnic bias
,no"f.i"g or scandalousj,is seenas the
The fact that moreyou-rg blacls may
in senteicing,and other suchnonsense.
be inherently dishonest,thuggish orwhatever, is dismissed asracist rhetoric'
(43)
'
in the wake of the genocidein Rwanda,the Socialist Workers Party crowed
that "The roots of Rwanda'scivil war lie in the divisions causedby decadesof
world
colonial rule bywestern powersand the deeppoverty that the capitalist
systemhas brought to Africa.
100
IOI
(09) 'se^Blrue{tBIq raqfo
ro uaIJsH u! a il ol sao.r8apseJJoJauoou,{peguls lsap.runruruoa 1;q fpq8p
'11uus u1 e^Il ol aseulqJ arll seJJoJ euo oN'suoqte.I|lB lslJnot euoJeq rmql
'uaroleulqJ su,(1pro1u,$oml,tlensn
Jo ertrospuz'sogaq8eseulqJ eJBaseql
ars qrlq,$ eseulqJ rluqla Jo sa^?Icuafieus punoJ eq usJ pFo1|Aeqf ssoJrB
sag;c.rofeu,(rrerrr r{'sa1;qn o1,{elospeuuuot lrusl fI q8noryp'1q69 a4qngo
uouaruouaqdpa$e$e 11e,$ aql q s$[l (6t) ''tc]rls1p o.r6ap1p us q {teq uoos
s; ,tgtnu; slrtrfpus 'vro11o5sao.r8alq;o,{uo1oeu 'ppqslp IEIluepIsaJal!qa{I"
,tlsnopra.rduolulsa,rom.{[rtrEJpaJoIoJ Euaql{furp^roqssuraguduopu.6g4J"
'ssaulsnqII,r[0
.r;aq18u1pqru arnp eruesaql lu a11q,lr slps.rnd Jaqlo puu sfsaralu!rslcupsug
u,raoJleql ^roIIoJ,{aq1uaqn sJalErIpuu slo8gqpepu"rq tugaq luesa.r ,(1pr
-geqdmapou,{aq1 puu 'aq11ppoqs,{aq1uoq,$ ',(o1dua1snu,{aq;ruoq,lrpue
'aluposse lsnw ,taq1uoqa rllpr p1o1Sugaqfuasar ,(aq1lpapu,ru1,tcu,r;.rd4aq1
8q,req luasal a1doa6(97) ,,'sa11q,n;o ,{oe,r;:d IelJos aql epu uI q ldwape uu
fnoqu se lo^eJrtlunpe 1nqo.6ap aq1.ro3lueltrarusapBJlurouoraJoJealJp3 sB
JIa$I pazl4lqnd seq luetneaotr^J EqBIUU J eql. :suolsueltluqfaJo,(1.r.rofuu
'q8noql 6sen11
$a^ eql JoJsuosuoJIBaJeql palmodugdoq,nua8galgluqy
(1,7)'s:noqq81au4aq1,(q uaql uodn pasodu.req pFoqs
rtrslleluolot Jo rrrroJ,$euB lerll pa1sa38nsaq ,(1qpe.rru!erotn ua.rg (9r7)'p;es
aq 5,,se,r1esuaq1 SuguraaoS;oalquderul a.ran',tguepqla papp1p'oq,n aldoed
paqg,r;eun,tueuga1,tery,,;upua.ra;ar SuIpIoqfnoqll,raEaql uo aruapuadapuJ
6up.rog.ro;seFolocJeuroJJleql,(q panseq pFoqs sranodpgoloc,tuetn 1eq1
paqqt psq puoldlp uur1rry us leql pagoda.rt66I reqotco vl sawll uopuorl
eqlq eplpu ug'11EupopueqeroJlnq6maqluo usgpFadul Eqsodul.roglou
srepr JerrrJoJJleql euelq slsgJel usc.HJVeuos 6usl1uJ.radu1 ;o IIBJuaopeql
lnoqe 8q.rq ol.ramods1;u-r8qqg.re,ro p[p luuollurl.reftrI lslIBIroS eqf a1;q,lrJoJ
'19pa puu arlsr rpqf a Eq ol fua r oq^rartrosere araql'q8noql flqpamul
$y)
'spJo,ra JoJprnsqe oo; s1,l4unor oql ilaI a,ruq.taql.rages.rea,(,{ueru appoua8
.royalqgsuodsa.r Eu;aqyo sellq,lrerg esntte o;. 'snoradso.rdpue alqqs ,{1a,rpqar
se,n1gs.ranod leluolot eq1,tq pa1n.rsearet.rJry {tsltr appr fBW sJrgn.r1aql
(tt) ,,'qrFreql puu sdoo.rldra.rog aql lsupEe
alFn ol spuno.64req Jluqp IIUJo su"pueArg.roys11no,{e,n8upse1,t1uoary
'"r.up pa8elgda Bq qJlqa ser.ro;aq1{1aspa.rd
luasa.rda.r
,(arysuogep palpn eq1,:o sdoo.qqtua.{!I rtro{ uo.qnlosou aq 11I,raraql
HscNn
er\lsrlvlcos ruooSSuJ
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
ThePoisonSpreads
In addition to the decolonialisation of African and other nations, a new
phenomenonhas comeabout the processhas beenreversed.Non-whites from
virtually every country on Earth have flooded into the white nations for a
multitude of rcasons.A very tiny minority are bona fide refugeesfleeing from
political and other persecution.Sone, in particular' Indians, are businessmen
- the newmerchantclass-nhoare expandingtheirsmpires.Agreat manywere
actually encouragedto immigrate to Westernnations. After the SecondWorld
War therrewas a so-called labour shortage in Britain, and the government
thought the bestrvayto solve this problem was to recruit cheap labour in the
West Indies. It may have beencheapat the time, but we have all of us paid a
hearyprice eversince.
In a frrcemarket therc are no labour shortages,when labour is scarce,the
price oflabour (wages)rises, and the vacanciesare soonfilled. (52) Organised
labourwashostileto immigration, andnot simplyout of so'calledxenophobia.
As state( whenthere is a labour shortagethe tendencyis for the eost of labour
to rise, which improvesthe lot of the working people.Thus' the best reason for
organisedlabour to opposeimmigration wasa purely selfish one:competition
from non-whitesin the home labour market would.depresswages.Ihe Com-
munist Party though saw things difrerently. As early as 1955 it publisheil a
pamphlet calleil No Colour Bar for Bitain. This pamphlet argued speciously
that "British public opinion in generalis firmly against a colour bar, as anyone
who reads the newspaperswill see",and that any sort of colour bar was the
desire of "a prejudiced minsrity". (53) The idea that the newspapers (ie the
L02
EOI
:{1a;oos u.ra1sa111noqEno.rq1 ooqelfl1enpp euoJeqaou seq 'sansslprFololq
aq1,(1p;eadsa pue 6sansslJapI,$aq1'arur Jo uolssnJslplBuo!|"r,{uu 1eq1,{us
o1uope.ra8fl?xaou q U (99) 'uolluuuep puu arUIIaqJo lrarql eql a{H uoIlBI
-ndod uoxeg-opug aq;go speaqalg Je^opaple!^rq euueJ6oJd uollelrllrrJa$a
'1no palulod eouopoo/rueg pJBqtIU sV 'eJeq uosaroqula
;zep paFalp aq;
ou spaaude4dup snopads sql uI lJuu{Jelq leuollotue Jo luatuelaaq,[
'[duuo uoll"u1ruJegaue ssranuqruq l"rn'suugolqq ,{q -
,,a1qe1radsa.r,,
a1e.r,tue l" ^rou- peu!"IJ lou s! lI lerg lno 1u.rodo1q;1 ppoit I 1nqdaspr.raqlo
Jo lsluolslley ',[ro1sq uo eslleaJl e lou s! slql ssa4s I 'u;eEV] ,,'Z96Tul
pasodruglsJg a.re,lrsloJluot uollu.r8ruug uaqaruil1el su r neqtsq qsggg ot
puo.raql uo daNlsJg et1l 'sduuuruogeulrrrJages(ralllllyo seq;1odaq1'nuqeeq "
pue 4! rqJsnv Jo srllllod aq1a.reuogepledar go srpgod aq1.,1816pelqs
sl lI II a8edu6'lsqt ples,{genlcedAtS eql'saa inuqouq ol peor aql uo dals
1sJgaql epilf suor - a.ru.{aql sexBI- uplrr{ ur eJJoJu; rtpea.rluqo4uoo uopu.6
-IEul aqf 'srpeue; a1.lQs1o41 asaql ol 8u1p:orry (99)'s1oauo3uotto8nuutl
tsutoSv asoJ atu palpr lelqdued tuqs B u! p1p r(ge4 s.rergorll lsllsltos
eql g1,6Iq 1nq's,na1'eqlJo aplroua8pup paEalp aql Jo uopuaruou se{Brtr
roqfne qql la.req,nauosuopunba aql Jeluo ,(gunsnilaqunq) so8'uyefry
euoililu palpunq e'uog1Lru
ua15uo.r11gu s :ulallJf, Jelueol pa$Fu,radaq o1a.re,{.4unoe,(uu tuo.r;eldoad.ro
sallqa-uou,tueu,no11'r(r;1oduope.r8luug us eluq lsnu,iqunor ,{ra,ra'apgsu
egqoqdouax puc utsrcot'1eq1 s1lreg a1du1sary r(reunl sno! qo sI sFLl'slo4uor
uopan8puu; IIB ol pue rre JoJ puy ieJuaso puad u 'saa u'acuegopuad e
apeu aqol uopeulugJslp pgce.r.,{uy,, JoJSIIBJJa oslog.roqlne'11a8edu6
'tro!f
-e11o$xalq1epradu1yo,{squeyaqlgo ryed q qql'qeEy u-'usg1q;derqspFfl
Jo lgeuaq eql roJ rueqlJo lno pe{tns Sqaq s1Wlsa,trJpql esne agr :seluolot
Jeqfo prru salpul lsel\ eql q peq os iuaar suolllpuoc ,(qm,(1pexasupldxe
aq g eEeduO (tS) iuarlf roJ alqlssodu; ag1Eulquu alnr qsplrfl go s.rra,(
00su,rru;ellJfl o1q uo;lu.r8grurul uelpul lse t JoJuosser aqf l"rp.,{lsnogcads
erortrueaepanfue puq eq ta;peg'c1a'sp.ropuel ,tq saeuyJlaql u! peruuels
s:oop 8u1,ruq'a !I ol eJeqaeuos Supug punoJ ueilo sallrlra-rrou,{tFogJIp
aql palular roqlnu eql areqa a8ed snopra.rdaql uo u!"p aql .tq peplpu.rluoe
asec,{uuu! sl req rnolor e ol pasoddose,nuopldo cqqnd tsql lqult sgltr
'lsua1eq1,(usol '1aa.r1s
eql u! us[u aql;o uo;u1doeql peueJ (ssa.rd,{.ro1
la^ous1
ufcNnuroct3Sul
et/\snvtcos
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
104
s0r
slalupog ulotu.rTrapBal uuJlrerrv ary (79)'ue$Btn uo uopspr sJq
IZBN IB.rJer
passassodlou e^Bqs.r1aq pnlugds sgq6,{laleungoJun 'uolsnpp u
lnq pe.r1eqJo
,(qdosogqdz,t1uo1ouse IFad ^ro1a aql paqu8orer ranlHJlopy.goqs u1
'araqBur-upldxa
ou peau lurp suo$ar .roy,fto1sq go Ino ueg!.ftr ,tpa;nb treeqscq ,(qdosoJlqd
s,ral{H JIopVJo loadsu srql 'rrutr41lrtr)I Jo rusp$ras-pus plqer eqf ilIIT
(9) earplqaot uops4ll p
aq1;o pno.rdeq ol lq8lr arll e^Bqan se 1sn[lsud ".8uoleq
,r-raqlgo pno.rdaq ot lqAF
aq1a,req,taryu ro rno o1eopadnsq.trolqq lsed 4aq11eq;,(leerJllupeI pu
rsuopzzJlpr.rcluapue o1Euolaq,{aq;, 'saalesrnool ro.r.ra;q6ugaq suasauudelaql
Jo eseutq3 aq1pap.ru8a.r JaaauaaeqIu :pIEsaq.(le.raua8sJqua.uo Jo eI$L!\
(29),,'salJlunot
oerl rno allun qtlqia spuoq eql fttq8g eJortr,taerpo1 sn aEannoJue IJSAIfI ra e
rreql alortr.raqlcadsa.rpue alegra.rddu o1 sn rpuat JI1AI JEtrsFII TuagJ B ptru
,tgu ue ulBrtri'.rs,(aqe gn uudel"sn .rogu:snql arlodsJerqq{ aq1raup eq1;o
epue8udo.rduetgeruv eql uo Suguauuoc nTye'9p61'91,ftun.rqeguO 'qrns
su l! petunouep peepq pue 'pa.r1eqyo ,t8oloap;uE sE f! paqu8oce.rnq IFeiI
^AolJaIaq1paleafa.r,(1uo;ou tftolsq vt lslJDtsno.rJoloulsou aql ,(lpasoddns
'rap ylopy',{lprporJ 'pe.rpq
II allrad ^roile1 aql ul Jallaq aqt sl esle;ut1,taroJ
5o ,{Eo1oop1 uu Eugu8udo.rdse,lt eq ';g eqpa.r &uplp preppolg qSnoqly
'acBJot urual
lsnru,tlpgradsa
UBWatIrLlI eql leql .t1.tpa.raeu eql q sgl pue 'uetrgallrl!\ eql Jo asoql op sB
uaqf JoJqrnru sE lunoo saldoadraqlo IIBJo pue'asauudel'eq1gosuopu.r.rdsu
aql nq 'erBJ rr,noslq JoJSupluads,t1sno;,rqo su,r.rossa;o.rdary (19) ,'gan
sB seJBJJerllo aql JoJInq 'sare.relgqn aql JoJapeu lou serd,plJo/rraq,L!:snql
uedul';o ;uEepo.r4n(g rossaJordsalonbeq {ooq slq trJ 'uolsnlap sI sFll
"
a41!.ruppo15',(1a1eu
1Fed/noIIaA"lnqrorrqf,pag u,tpo1oupe8esprua's.raq1o
-qJoJ-ql e0Z6IsBo8e3uo1su ue$lr,lr ueeqa^eq.{1pe.rsp.ronaseqfplnoJ
(09) ,,'ru,|A
ss?Ir ol ss llearse IEpUJol lueE
-ellJu! qsmaq s.wslaaqslog JoJIenJ sg'uogeugu.r.rJsIp IuIJos,tra,ra
6acue,a!6
pq111od,fta,ra'uo.r1e.4dse lslpuopeu,&ra,r,g'atua,ra.r pue peJFqJo1adso3.r1eq1
uerupeJoIoJpelueluoJslpJo s.reaeq1q radsJpl s-rolqpe {.r^aqslog'salqs
palpn eql pue 'eopauy u.qe1 'erg;y 'elsv uI 'aqo18aq1;o .ra1.runb,iram
u!$ :aouslsr! lsJU aql u! uo$seJr sl! roJ pue rualqo.rdqq1 go aruafuaue aq1
.ro3- uopJdo s.JalFArltreJJnreql u! uosua.r;uugodul lsow aql - suosua.r erilJo
auose,nsB'alBJnJrEsen ualqord aou.rEu$.rauauu;o,(seqdo.rds,p.ruppolg
H=GNn
ev\lst]vrcos Noo3ful
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
106
FREEDOMUNDEHSOCIALISM?
race riots we have experiencedin Britain are a fantasy; inileed they have
certainly beenplayed down by the media at the behestof the governmentand
under pressurefrom the raceindustry and other vestedinterests.
ThJ current uriter has long been in touch with people in both far right
movementsand in the media who have confirmed the truth of this. Racial
violenceis not a fantasy,and it maywell be that most racial violencein the (still
but rapidly diminishing) predominantly white world is directed againstwhite
peopleratler than by them. The Black Plagueis a fantasy becausethe picture
it puiotr is inherently flawed: the world is not made up as the so'called
"aiti+acist" lobbywould haveus believeof whites and non-whites.(66)Wehave
already mentioned the reality of black on black crime.Ihis, and most of all the
history of modem decolonisedAfrica, is surely proof enoughthat blacks are
bit ur *pable of brutalising andmurdering eachotherastheyarewhites,
""".y
orwhites them.
Ihis scenariois repeatedacrossthe world, as is inter-ethnicviolence.Some
of the worst racial violencein Britain has not beenso'calledNazi and skinhead
gangsattacking non-whitesbut the violencebetweenvarious walring clans of
Liuor in areai like Southall,WestLondon. And we havealreadymentioned
Northem Ireland. Inciilentally, during the LA riots, Korean shopkeeperswere
targetedalongwithwhites,andit is insufficientto saythattheyweresotargeted
simpty by freebootersl there has been much genuine resentmentagainst
troreans in the Uniteil Statesthe samenaythere has beenagainst Asians here.
Theyare both enviedand resentedfor their commercialsuccessby the indigen'
ous population who wonder why these Johnny Come Latelies can enter the
country and in a fewyearsowntheir ownbusinesses,eventlough many of them
can't even speak good English, when they, the natives, are stuck in menial,
low-paid jobs, or living off welfare. This is not so much racial hatred as
ignoranceof economics.(67)
It is easyfor most peopleto seesuchdelusionsas the Black Plagueand the
Yellow Peril nowadays,but the biggest delusion of all is racism. Earlier we
touched on theProtocols Of Zion; this and other conspiracy literature port'
rayed the rising Jewish merchant class of the late Nineteenth and early
Iiventieth Centuries as part and parcel of an all-encompassingmegalithic
conspiracy.
-as The bogus theory of racism is yet another conspiracy theory for
just
-economy, the Jews were saiil by the peddlers of the Protocols to control the
the banks, the governmentand virtually everythingelse,soracisz is
107
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
TheFearOfABlackPlanet-
And RacialDeath
The non-white exodusinto the white nations, and all the other trappings of
governmentallyforcedrace-mixing,(72) socialist-inspiredbullying and indoc-
108
60r
'Euallluues qcnsploq
oqrl salqlr fpo lou q t! '(pro,tara$eq e aq ppoAr esuitslp sduq.rad)walqotd
eil{,ta s ,fia.rnd sE e paIFJ-os qq1 ,tu.r1.rodol auFlturu eleq ls11sltoseql
II
'U^a q uopuuaSacqruo1,{11g1soq 1aql ,{lprauai
Jo sgoge lsaq erlt Jo a11dsu1
arou sduqrad .ro tpa sI IB ! rns allqil feql JeIIeqeql ss peugep eq lseq uet
's,{epelrou 1e8ur-ueau,{uuseq usnDJpJo,raeql sBJBJsV 'uarpgqepuar8
11 1u
-1ua.r8.r1eq1 ol pue 'ue.rpgqrpue.r8 4aqt puu ueJpl-rqtJleql of saua8.r1aq1 uo
ssudo16s111.ram;eqn'aEelFeII rleql aa.rasa.rdo1saldoedleJo lqEF eql q 11
@4)ldualuor pue pe.r1eltr olul rslnrgJed uguof;1et qspof aql8u$uprq
pue rrrsp.rues-lfus Jo serg aql Sulgany,(qa.raql'pa.r1eq1elJu.tlrJttoJlaqt JoJ
aldoad qs!$af erllue eql leoSadecsol erull eruuseql ls pue sepua8e1uep11od
nraoJlaqf JeqlmJ ot alq" a.ru,taq1,te,raqq1 uI Gr) 'sad,(1oanals cplwas-puu
s,1qE!.rrsJ oql o1 dn ,te1d ot lseq Jlaqf op uaryo pue 'segoaql ,(ru.rldsuor
qcns a8ulnotslp of Eu.rqlouro epn op suopusJuufuoFlrsuJ-puu pel1ut-os
pue 1quog2'qslaaf,{uuu 1ua:Ee 1eq1pIBsaqof suq;r'a.rouraq}md 'pa lolq
a.rusuopesguefuopue slunp!4pul qspref qr1rac pq1.{1uoa alleq pus s,rrefJo
paJlurtrluuos.radou a,req,taqlse qtnusut4 selluas-nuu lou eJBueqlyo,{uuw
peepq puu'a.rarugs,(ilelot are,{.roaq1 ,{ce.qdsuors1q;ep8edo.rdoqn aldoad
eqlJo lsotrJ'aspJ,{1qe.r1suouap s111 's1.rogalsaq rleqlJo agds q 1nq(vL)'?/Jo
poddns u1sluaunfue Euo.rls,fta,l1noapurua,r,uqaldoad1uaftqalq r(1q8qauos
'paapq !ggo acel eql uo spunosl! ss pmsqu su fou s!JeIIeqqqtr'fae.4dsuoe
qslaef IsuollerrJaluJ ellsu.r.rad-1peql Jo lar.rud puu ged q uopeue8arqru
lurg JeIIeq eqt of eruapert 8ul,rf fq8lr JsJ eql uo aldoad ,{ueu o1 pal s"q
rrrsllEtroll"ral$pr pu? ssausnolJsuotIslcsJalFlnso uroJ i{uulo sdno.6aseql
,{q uopelcosselualqsrad eql r"Inrlgud ug'sdno$ eseql11u,tq(gf) a8el;.req
uoxeg-opuy ellqaJnoJouopu.fruap aq1'goddns qqlraf Euo.rlspa41s qtlqia
suopuquefuo 1spya1,{uuu pue 6suo,r1uque3.ro lsluolz puB qsl,$af-opnasd
'qs!,r,rafuluueJ Jo asoql aJ? ereq {Jo r l3 sepuaEuelEIInIoJIIn lsoltr aql
'sepue8erLlrorlaql JarIUnJol JepJou16s1qppos,(1du1s 1ou
'sdno.6.tueu,{qpa.rnpnuq luqlpa,r;sqppu.ru'aldu.rspuea.rndpe.qerlIBltBr
q ErlL zirolsgqgo le11oteql uaroppaqsng q - 11a ,tpua.raqul'asrc ,tuu ug 'sg
qr.rqlr-arerellqaaqlJ! re$Brtrl.usaopll oroJereqfletp puu lspeluseop ll tsql
'1sgel,useopatur luql u1ult ol JFoleqJlsIIsIJos
1nqta1;utul.useopl! 1eql1ou
pJepu"ls sg;; 'qefu'appouaE yo !.roqs u1 'uollcuuxa JulcarJo ',t1a1annrru
a.rorn'ro laue1d {tBIq BJo JBOJeqf :JaeJIE J ,f,ra,re - eldoed algqm,tuuu ,fta,r
.ro;-puu taqlouu 1;qprlq8no.rq seq'r1a'sdpdmer aleqalpl.n-puu6uopeuprl
H30Nn
ey{snvr3os v{oo33uJ
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
110
III
aJar anbJquuzotr{ rtroJJstue.6tuu! IBBaIUlsql pqJoder oEuarSord s,$eu
{1011606 sdJ, f,gg ?eqsHqnd se]|[elrlus sarull w eql eroJeq{aea eq,l
OB) ipaggpale arueJaql6uneqgo {Iu1 ue^ese,mereqf,1no s,enblquuzo141
daarlol lnq'q s{illq s,E .rrry qlnog daarlol loN'anb;quuzotrq8ulrnoqqS.rau
pu? q$os ueeqeq errreJraproq eql pueue ol paplrep puq qepuBtr^T
apBJEoJ
"JFJV fuarnu.ra,lo8lsltal-llue,taql
Jo u feql perunouuu - uopuol u; paqsgqnd
.radudsrauuurI.UVq1nose - saull ZS' eql ueqil auur IIBJo{Joqs paEil1qaqtr
'acuaeqro1,{gaqq ua4el
$g)
-slu p"q,{aq1 uaql Eu11a1 s.ragoddnsIerlpur arou slq peploJsaq uo!s6)ro
auo uO 'srretrrry qtnos IIE roJ ernlnJ re$aq B pllnq o1 slsqq;dur rrBrFJV
qnos qlpr{ro rol papele suq elapuetr{'ec.uy qlnosJo {ro^rouw;lqp11dee
aql apueuslp ueql rerller .roytrud per aql u1 s.ra4o[eql eq ol Ino paurnf
q8noql aaeq fueurrrJaro8Xtr1y lspnrurtror pallur-os ,r{euslq pue Blepuetr^J
',ftlunoc lue.6 leqt u! trolluslll4r roJ
IIoDI q1rap oql eq ol sql Supcadxa
'paueo.r8 lqlr rEJ aq1 'panore
ilaI rBJ eql ep-Wlt'ur!.{w {nos 1upur-plnu
^naueqlJo Suaplsardeql se Blepuetr^l uosleN,,Jeuosprd u.ra18uo1puu
1ecpr1od,,
lsForrel rerruoJaqlJouolpele aqllr qlur lq8no.rqppqgudygolleleql'utstzor
pa[uc-os $oqu q;n4 aql Jo pue 'ale.r go pafqns .tu.roq1eql uo ,tq.rcod,tqpuu
sprupue;s alqnoprleql Jo uaa$ aqppoqs aldruexe.req1m;auo.neqruq ot peor
eql lnoqu EpueEudo.rd Jlaqf pue spua!.{IJa{Jol[ lsIIBIroS.rnool Equrnpg
(t8) ',,sarBrroIJeJuIuJlaql e sq osIBs{Jelq leql pare^oJslp
oqraBlqlEuN ug ,ftuuogssptruptnreg erg Jo asBt eW pe*r,(puaqe a uq e/n
',(t1uul.{(g) X.ua.rarili{aq111ag aqs,t1rea1a!*aldmuxauB 1asol pepadxa a.rea,{a
c;1qndaq1u1aldoed 1re1g,, lerll p;us raluasa.rd qcelq etrO'ul"psp r$!rr uog
rg,
-eua8aequ,tl.rrqeleo pallec-os^ri,IAruauon:1au1q,t1ppadsa 's{rulq
InJssamns
,(uuu 1eq1palee^ar 5qarey41 u1sau11topung aqf u.rpeqsilqndalepru ug
?661
'ernfrnrls,{guuy elg1,rreql puu
{rBIq aq1qloq 8up{o.r1sap
eft pul{ Jeq puu arls ernlJn4s ,tguey {rBIq aqf 8ulFeuup,(p.rarn rtro{ JEJ
puu'lre1.raqfiqu a4o:qr(lupger u?ruo r sFlI (ZB),,lre1raqEJq auos 8upparq
'pLrqcr1ce1qaqlJo speauaq1Eu.r.rou8J;o'am1cn.r1s,{1r-uuy
Jo pus 4cqq aql Eu;
-Beruep,go pupl Jaqpuu Jaqpasnrr" oq/rauertro,${Julqfnq s11"reuoqdaagsnqe
qf!$ raq pafepunq oqrl.stspDt (aflq,$) IHtoI f.use,$lI leql pasr.rdrnssutaptrz
aEe.r.r.ruu lultuJ-ralulJo pafqns eql uo radedsaauIeJoIs,tq pa,na;,r"ra1u! sBAr
uurtr )pulq B ol pt!ilsrtr se/raoq r qfuoeg 'e$e.u"W u! ueruoa aIWA V (Ig)
's{Jelq uo.q,t6reprp.rud
'1sa1ordsnoraJlro^o1 papa[qns ssra sea.rs
lellueplser uleu eql ap.r8alu;
HfoNny\oc33ur
al/\|snvrcos
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
TheDoctrineOf *Racism":
SictqEvil, Manipulative
The most sickeningthing about the doctrine of racism as perpetuated by the
socialist left is the way it smearsall whites as bigots if they reject any degree
of forced rass-pi*ing or if they express the slightest antipathy towards the
genocidethesemonsters haveplanned for them' And for all mankind-
In September1991,the boxerMichael Watsoncollapsedin the 12th round
of his super-midtlleweightworld title challengeagainst Chris Eubank (88) As
a result ofwhat for all boxers is an occupational hazaril, he nearly died. (89)
Michael Watson is blaclg of course. Boxersare not usually renownedfor their
innate modesty,but Watson, although alwaysquietly confident, was never tte
sort of personto shoot his mouth off outsidethe ring. Evenafter he defeated
his arch-rival Nigel Benn in six thrilling rounds in May 1989he remained the
quiet, personableyoung man he hail alwaysbeen.Although lacking the char-
isma of the likes of the flamboyant Benn or the anogant (and at times offensive
miscegenist)EubanlglVatsonwon much public support.
After the fight had beenstopped,it wasevidentimmediatelythat the26year
oldWatson wasin grave,and almost certainlylife-threatening, trouble. In the
wake of the fight the hospital switchboard was delugedwith calls ftom frght
fans. (90) IVereall thosefans black? Wereall the peoplewho later raised funds
for MichaelW'atsonblack? (91)
Likewise,wereand are all the peoplewho have donated countless millions
of pounds, francs, Deutschmarks, dollars and shekels to African'oriented
charities black? Are all thesepeople nascentNazis or foaming-at-the-mouth
anti-blackracrfs becausetheyare opposedto unrestricted non-white immigra'
t12
etr
eql SupfluJad u1'papgurtrot suq lI uls InJlaeeql JoJuolIBII .rno uop.rudlpr
pog 1eq1fu.rd'f,.r1unoe sIIIJo pue!{ rlrse lel1, :snql srepears;; o1quaddu pue
'lolsprg yo au,{6 '^eU eqf ,tq
T ,,palsall? ,t1p;,,eq ol p;es sl NIVJ1Y) TnfI)
-VgWNn uo lo opto tq ryoae ol paffio1gsDlvrol{/kl'o8a1t1apuag o {o nptnTal
gHJ IO JNnOJJvNV.epeJl a BIsaqt lsqu8e paddu uupslrqJ u paqqlqnd
.(lapogpeqtr snoF;pg aq166991 seo8eSuolsV 'etglns 1;lr saldruuxa;oaldnoe
6sele:Jeqlo suls aql ,{q paqrluru$ull 1ueru
V'uF{ rr,lro.4aq1lsqeEe ua1;o Jo
,(aq1'salgqn-uou;sugu6e aJer eflqlr aql Jo sqs eql Je elBIIArtanornraqpmg
:(uuw.{l lsIIBItos ol pasoddoa.ruoqn gu,{q
palJn4suoJep,tlpnlua.ralnqpapafa.r,{11e1o1,(po lou eqlsnrull uossiu sFIfJoJ
'IIe ',(1go[uu
puu 'pa.r1aqIeIJBJJo uIJoJalsurllln eql sl ,LlusrtoJ-rlrre,, Jo 1so141
a1;q,naq18qspuu.r,t1 pue Supqnd;ueru qloq Jo suuartre pue rs.ra11a.le.rl ^roIIeJ
rleql prresls11sltosaql JoJluauaslpue.f8e-y1as gopoqfau u ',t8oloapg pllelros
(,,utsrzoJ-nuq,;o
roJ alrlqel B ueql ssalSugqlous! qtlqa ldacuoeaq1aptno.rd
ol lnq',tlapos uupr41p8aeJoruuaae.ro!sn[ a.rou telpg u alouold ol lou
s1asod.rndesoqlrauo puu ldaruor prp;1od u f1a.r11ue sg's.ra11a,ranlaoIIeJ4eql
pus l'al IsIIElros aq1,(qpqquurtr Jo lsal aql oluo pa$IoJ se'tusttot lnq '$Fe
s6ulqt esarf,L'ItreqfauopuoJ.ra,rau.tlupget ppo,lr 1 puu 'pa.r;eq1e!t"J ua a
.ro'frlo8gq'ecJpnfe.rd IsIJeJJoeouafsfeaql elndqp o1,{en,{ueq qsFAlotrop J
6up6y'lrou,(qepuu ueeqaaeqpFoqslulod aq11nq'uga,t qqlu; uo oEplnor I
'asuadxa
;ellq,$ eq ol uaJpllqtpue.f.r;aq11uu,t,teq1asnetaq.ro
s.uuu {JsIq aq11uarlofpuolsetJo uu rpe.rof,aq1asneeeq,(1du;s tol ,tp4.q,{eq1
ate to'pnoJoloH urou eql JoJuope.ruda.rdu1.rarlunqEuryeX1s.,{gu; IeuolfuN
qsplJg eqlu! sraquloqcn33uyp11nq ,rrouue,ra,taqleJVAslzBNluarseu',{upo1
aldoeda1;q,ngo ,{1l.rofeu aq1a.repue 'plagsuury pJol seXlilalqEnep qq ,{.r.ruu
pFortrso.6ap e 1eq1uopsaSSns ereu eql uolsgr er lsouln eq1qgnpap.re8a.r
aauqlou plnofi arl tuql Jo 'auoq slq o1- o.6atr1,(ue- o"6atr1e pa1;,ru!e^uqplnoi$
'ueruqqlEug ssup .raddn.{ue .ro neq
tp 1e ueuqsil8ug ,tue Jo ILLT uI luql
itrstcot fex fue uI lou se,na8pnf aues sgp tpql a alJeqo1palredxa e,r eJV
(96) ',,aq1ua.rq o1a,le1s^{uu.roga.rndool q puepug
Jo rlB eqJ4 esnEceqInJr$sluneq ol uopuelap sFI parsltsp plausuBtrJ pJorl
'?rl?uuf JoJpunoq seruBrtrIaql u16u;,(1d;qs u p.ruoquo suo4 q ppq sanroq,rr
a {rslq EJo ewalar eql parepJoa8pnfqq18ug,ve lLLl su oEeEuol sy
"Is (26)'f,up1noar uoqlJo;sou,{1a.rnssy ;,{guey rlaql olu! Jo
'auoq .rgaq1 olul {JBIq e auoJla,rrlou ppo,n,{aq1asnsteqJO 'a.ruuaqlgo ,tuuu
,tlpalqnopunsV esel4unot qq,!r,(pueuluopa.rd .raq1oro ululFg olq uoll
utoNnu\oo3f
el/tsnvrcos uJ
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
1L4
9II
'd;qs.ro1u1cgp61roqs ':a,nod;ouollssllu4lral tqf uo pasuq
u1 luernrr.leao8;o
'slrefqns
ua1s,{se ,{g.rerupds11.t',(reualdns elFl^rlou s! ltrslzuN IBlEoIocJlaqt
Xsup8u qqp;.redu1 uuedo.rng eql ,(q paqlce.rd se,laqr.Iqa,{ceua.rdns aryqn
eql ol pepnile osp a^uqaX1',tqdoso1.rqd ppe.r e,{g.ressarau ueaeJo,(gruu;.td
lou q usIJsBJIBIII ,tpra.rp poluJlsuouop a Bq oX1'a6u1gaq1epar s.euoJo
uopu,rresardaql puo,taq.reg o61eq1sacuanbesuot e sq rnslJseJJoSIIIJoJ Jeqlo
'auo
pue us;zsN 'asuc,tuu uI 'petrretuoJ sI a.rnfsrruertrnqa.raqn,(lu1cadsa
pe.r.rocaq1 S,{anqBlous!uopnlossno!qoeq1're,ranog'ua1qo.rdppu.rsno!qo
',tqi[o
uB ol uopnlos snolaqoeql suees,tqdosogqdlepe.rV'Esp?N lroqs q
-sogqdp.rcuru .uopnloseql a,req,(aq1 am11eq's.rossetcns puu sapru.rodueluoc
rlaq; 'uup.rof uIIoJ '1aru1coaulotu.Irl sB qtns aldoadpap;nis;u auog
(691) ;Pe,uasaril
'e8q;.reqlBql s! aoq s!
aq q'.raq;o,{us.ro a8el;.raquoxuS-o18uyellqa E 1; aq
uopsanbElq eq;'1u llJns ellqArJouollou.rqndodun leqaauos eql tulpnlcu;
.e8e1!.reqrlern eAreserd o1 saldoadpgo lq8p eqt q lI'q8noql paluxssv (80I)
'ueq{ufistr s.tno13uu1s1 Jo uollsN aql Jo repsel pap;nEqut31tpeuslrsqr eqf
Eulpnpq'c.rryuag-pue se peJBaEspuu slsltseJ sBpe{tellu eJBsts.tt"rellq,rt
'.{1sno.r.rna
yo suol1u.r;dsueql eJuqsoqlr srIJsIq ua,r'g(41) 'eflues'lftrB uu se
'uaryo pue 'ls1rsey'\s1cote sE pa.reeluseq ru,r f1;gqe-r1saps11uopsanb puu
'up6g
arsr slq Jo qlBepfEellluu1 aql 1o,{g1EeJeql etal Plno^roq^|ellq,la,{ue
(9g1)'sa;quq(a1;q,n,tJpleadsa) 1oJaprnu sseu peqpEal aql pue puslmp
uo uo-rgoqe;o quauodo.rdc;lsqsnqlue osp a.ru [a1s] uo;1e1s@1 eluq-$uu
e,rpsa.rda.reJortrpus aJoItrpuutuap,tpuulsuoooqa rsrs!tr.r'$us!pe$IuuoJ
ertrsseqf 3o ,{uuu os 1eql peapu! rluorl s! lI (90I) u'suo11u.raua8 rnoJ rtlJu
sepers eJolnou aq 11liaaloql 6uoosaluJ ltr4q reqEq E e Bq uepeas u! ualtroar
eqf ssepn luql pelcullse uaaqseq lL leql eloJ r.rau8Jeduur uolgoqu-lluu
uu 6uoprypa.rd SuplcoqssFg rege s.rua,(,$.to; eratnV (791)'ucgauy E! Itu!$a
u30Nnl/\|oc33ul
e]/lsnvrcos
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
FascismAnd Socialism:SiameseT\vins
116
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
Communism Constitutional
Socialism Republic
Fascism Limited Government
Nazism
Figure 3: Ihe reader will seethat there is nothing here about race at all, and
at the riskof boringhim Iwill repeatthe factthatno form offascism(induding
Nazism) has to be anti-Semitic, anti-black or anti any particular efhnic group.
Ib paraphrase GeorgeOnrell, if a boot is stamping on your face, the ethnic
origins or political afriliations of the owner of the boot make little difference.
Ihe appeal of fascism,and nore parochially, of Nazism, can besumned up
in the phrase 'AIl within the state, none against the state'. In reality, fascism
adoptsa similar power structure to that of socialism,oneknonmbythe curious
oxJimoronof I)emocratic Centralism. (112) Before returning to the racial
ideolog of Nazism, let us take a closer look at the power structure and briefly
reviewthe history of Nazism from llitler's rise to power.
r17
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
Nazism:TheBenignFaceOf
Authoritarianism
A stock chargeagainst Hitler is that he wasa dictatory a stock chargeagainst
the Nazisis that theyweretotalitarians. The lirst of theseassertionsis partly
true; the secondis demonstrablyfalse.ProfessorQuigleytells us that the Nazi
rgime was not totalitarian in either theory or practice but authoritarian,
becausetwo membersof the Quartet were not coordinated, and although the
economicsystemwas not ruled by the state it was subjectto'self-rule'. (113)
IntheWeimar Republicrthequartet of powerwasArmy,Bureaucracy,Industry
and Landlords.Under the Nazisthis becamea quinteh Nazi leadersrlndustry,
Army,Bureaucracyand Landlords, (114)thoughit doesn'ttake much imagin-
ation to fathom who had the final say.
In Hitler's Germany,the landlords gained economically;prices fixed by the
Nazis werenot high but were adequate."Pa5mentsfor interest and taxeswerrc
both reduced...' (115) There is, by the way,someevidencethat the Nazis hied
to reform the comupt, debt-basedmoneysystem.Or at least, sone of tlem did.
The author of the NSDAP's programme was not Adolf Hitler but Gottfried
Feder,who espousedsimilar ideasto Major Dougfas.Breakingthe thraldom
of interest was a major plank of this programme. Howeve4in 1934,Federwas
purged,(116)and by and largeit wasbusinessas usualfor the moneycreators.
According to Professor Quigley, the Nazis rejected totalitarianisnl those
who wanted a "secondrevolution" were purged in June 1934.The reader may
find the following difricult to believe,but it is true neverthelessthat "Many of
the economicactivities which had come under state control wererepivatiznd.
The United SteelWorks, which the govemmenthad purchasedfrom Ferdinand
Flick in 1932,aswell as three of the largest banks in Germany,which had been
taken over during the crisis of 1931,were restored to private oumershipat a
lossto the govemmenl" (117)
Nazism had other things going for it aswell. Although today praising Hitler
is likely to haveone denouncedas a fascist, an anti-Semite, a crank or simply
mad, tlis wasn't ahnaysthe case.In 1936,after the passageof the Nuremberg
Laws,the formerBritish prime ministerLloydGeoryepraisedhim as perhaps
118
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
LLg
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
120
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
t2r
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
L22
EZT
uespg eql 'slsrJols-r^eulsn"JoloH fuBEJo suoluessu eql ol ftB4uoJ (8tI)
'4lnqrsnv lB lueprBrtrrtroJ B uaeq osle p?q JeltrB.rxlrorll?J)tr 'ueEaf,
Jesof
Jo luupuBurtro3 lsq eql fq pepeerlJJslsdruucuopu.quecuoralg-,(;.roJJoIslrt
eql su,raslql 'Iu!.{Lurslaf, eql sun s1epl.ro[uuaqlgoauo 'ppq eJa,n,,sleulrtrF
rua\ Jo s1q.r1,(ueu '.ru11pgo11 puotes eqtJo pue eql rel;ry 'Eupnoqoyeql Eo.II
paEne8aquzr slzeNeqfreptrnsassetueqlJouolleulJttopqeqtJo fuega aql
'pefseJJeq eulqJBltrJepJnu usIJRlFo{$B
aql sesmxarou tlm8 puos.red s6JaBTIIsuassal,te,trou u-r'spugu;.rc Jslee.6
ua.roanan'qa,rasoog,(1a:g1 a1;nbpue gge.rnq3 tulpls lsqt pBJarp puy '.fto1qq
u.rsluulrtr.rJclsalear8 aql Jo euo osIB su { eq gt6l ,(q uaql ',f.ro1s5quI sJepsal
1safaa.6aqlJo euo selr raIlIH 66I ,tq J! :sa^Iasuaql -ro3rleads speJ aql puu
'tq8pr u a{stn JaaeusSuo.uron1lng 'slzeN aql uuql sa.4po4e as.ro,r,(1quqo.rd
ssappo4e papFrrtror pus saFlunot lB4neu pep" u! osIBse![V eqf JBI\ plrol[
puoJesaq13u.unp;eq1',tpra.r.ror'1no;ugod slsfolodu s.JenlH',tc11od dproJ
'a,qssa.rffluqq
;sguogsuudxa o1 p.re8a.rqlpr {JeE aq1 paddalsra,ro eq $rB
'p1.ronaql .ranbuooo1petuea erllBrll su.rup pmsqs
lqnop ou equsc ereqf (1p1)
eql paquq pue aFopqr 'upuuEedo.rd'saq se ssJuslp uur euo {8noqryu puu
'ruug eql .rogpue (9tI) '[ssnlqesug aq1]e;.4snyJo
nuolsuaur,,slq JoJua,rflrol
eq uE aq q8noqqe !,tr;1odufta.rogsgapgl,{lptlflrt aquexa osIB1snlr etrO
(971),'uspnururoJ lsqeEu epssnm;zep aqlyo ged
ss Janlg rtro.r;sJepJossardxeuo uilpuepun,{.r;1od e1uraq11ep B ueeqe Bq ol
suees rnsgo.r.rafJo ufteduec qql lroddns 1utlfuuuJItuJ u! pue tps"lsnqlue
o1u;-'aufe.r snoJaprnu s.u{sls .ro3aldoeduBIssnUaq1go,(1go[eu fsua eql
,(q 11eypa4uq pu" reeJaql pau.ro;sue.r1,{aqlsqfuou aeJB u.rlsrtrflreJ eql tuo.g
pa8pnfaquur It6I ul Blssn1paralua.{aq1uaq,n sdoo.quum.regerlfJo pnpuot
eqJ.,,l"ql ,(1a,rgqrqalora a1ee1luereglp.{1a.rgua se/n$eg eqf q rrolseau!
aql Inq (p1) ',{.ro1s;q u.ruopedneropes!1;p lsou eqf sdeq.radsB,$aJuaUJo
uopudnmoslzsN eqf,'saluenbasuotIBTBJ W!11'elssrry)psflu ol - uqq eroJeq
uoe1odetr1q{- peplrap relryH !eu; do.rlueqq51-^otoptr Jaq16ugd;s regry
(gp1)',ft1sacueqs!ftaf srtrIIBfSpeJerf e^Eqol paut.ulcslzep aql ten eqf u! refsl
paepq pue'u.6po qsF$efJo aq ol pe^elJeq,(Fppt{ seaJlesurq qplg 'aup aq1
lv'ulssnu pello4uor-qspref (.{pesoddns)1ooqtuoq p8eqqlsls q|;n ped u
ped;s .rap1g's,na1'aq1 1eSulIlBr slq ge .rog'Eqpap alqnoppue,tmalslsuocu-r
',(strcod,(qrrarojslz"N aqt puu s.JagIH qfoq a^oquarll il" of ppe lsntn ano
(Af) ,{flpe.r Eup$;rra1s artrofirqsuq se ll rno Jo
padsu,{.ra,raefeltfppus lo4uot o16.rapea1 us;.rsilIelolJo uu1rul.rJollfne,(uBro
noG3SHl
uScNn
av{snvrcos
nzT
efgud aql $uIE8" ,(upnu - rarq4d aq1qlpa Eqae.GesJp
ol eraql uo{t fI sl rBJ ,noII '1qEF s,tarlu s! rarq4d aql :sseH qdlopnX yo
sproa eql IIErar 6q1eap,(q alquqspnd Eulaq.gted aq13sup8e,{urrnu o1sy .acan
efglraeqf Jo trollsuluue1xeeq1.rog,(gs1oupu" pnol 'Euo1os pedJudwec a,ruq
aldoad esaqf uosaal a$ eq ga,rl,(eu qr$[&t 'aseaslp,trq;pareq we se tuslmt
p.re8a.roqn 6uoJsens.rad 1spya1 sJo qaq1e's,tuparoueldoadatuosiu" ore'rr.
(fSf) 'qtuap,(q
alquqsJundsar,$.ru; eql Jo uouesrueEroue .ro,tlproqpe ,$.ru4pu-ru8eltq1nu
:,(puerg;d.rs 1sou luy (gg1) Emofuapunuos.radaq;;o uogsqurad
"1uaqea4
erp lnoqtla' aldoad asoql ez.q.uafs o; .ra,nodseq luaurrJeaog eqL :essaslp
.&rugparaqa Bq oq { ewor ol suoganaua8go uopeep.rd eql roJ ,rI g6I .tI
,{1nf aqf repufl 'argns il}n IBp11raslefl eqf uo.{ sapnb goeldnoc rerpouy
ia 7dnuy4 dnlaapo?7 slqgldaruoc
rarqld slr$ s-r.{qog.ragn leq&\ areqtouu Jo lurTf ol rurr sq lrefqns ,(t6qrur
uos.radEuqu.rql1q8lr,(uu saoq ls8qql 1sorufnoqu Suo.r,nuaaqs"q pu.Dlrruu
Jo lsou I"FoEaEuI eug eJu.rsuaq,r bspuaqlo Jo Isrp11od.ra11eu.{.ra,ra
poqu 1@.u aq s,tu,qe uec srapealgo dno.6,tuu.ro.rapea1,{uupq1 aaaqaq.tper
auo{uu saop 'apgse 1eq1 8u.r,rea1 1nq'sp.roll u,nos.sseHol ell aql sa,rp puupocg
of f1g alpq lnq JIoJaq luanbasqns sg1 .sapnb qrns Jaqlo,tuurn a.reanary
(ZST) roqrrrupeqs aqt segpuurrntrorsIttrJolno Eu]Crrec
"'us11eposleuopsNJo
fp11alq eqt q 'eroJeraqa3o uopsanb eqf eslu.rlou seop qrg/n puertrttrot
sFI ol aoue[DeqoIsJpgrun eql u! lqt;r aq 11urs(enp eq 1uql pue fq8pr
s,{urquq aq luqt arou{ prre IaeJI1ee,sluqf lJuJeqf Eo{ ses!.rsleql pue t rarqgg
e$ sI lEqL'rusr.rll;.r eaoqursJ uerrrrag euo s! anaql1uq1{es a,r apprd q;p1"
:snql ssnll qdlopng papnb eqlxaN (ISI) ,'rapJoeql 1noSur,tr.reouos.rd aq1
Jo 1.rd aql uo lmJt pus eruemeqoqrndu! :s8uJq;or$ papuuuep EslIElroS
IsuollBI\L lEql prJ?slasunoSs.rauarx 6eaua;ep aq1.roJqcaadsEquado qq u1
(0sr)
'seeeld u1palplds almb sararuaJep aql pue (6tI) .ppr; noqs B
lou sBraIB!{f,
erusnv|cos
u3cNnytoc=t3ul
9Zr
qs$Ftr erearsreqtuou rapunoJ sl! Jo fuutu 'uogalsaq3 'X'V eW 'qEnoq1e
':peqru.rp snolras euo aaeq q8noql p;p lI 'rglea/$uormrroJeql
Jo sJeqrmu
el$ltr aql $!r{ srtu{ Euo.rp qqquu ol pue 'a.raq,(puaqu saflqlr-uou esoql
ep;.qede.ro16u;u1ugo1q sallq r-uouJoxnlJu! eqf lsquEu padpdursr 11:elFln
ul"llr{ ileaq ol fg.ruu1.rd papunol sa r tuo.U IEuoIIBNarll 'sruflI ppoll qloq
ug1qEno;oqlr 1s1leuolluupu" lolrlud tuaf e 6uogalsaq31y'y,{q papunoysun
lI 'ului4rg q peu.roJse,ra luo.U IBuollBNaql pallsr,qrud papJloil e'Lg6lul
IB^I^rnSefFl&Irod alEEnrlseql puv
'fuo.14 eql
IBUoIIBNeqtrJg,tpe8u.trf,
'luu trc argl no,t qsnJt '.{11qft1s
ueaeJo
lllia aq-luqys.ra,uodaq1
saao.rdduslp efqs aql 1uq1fen.{uuur,{1puuos.rad.rno,( ssandxeno,{se uoosse
6aug,tgedaqlgo ap;qno dals
tselo.rd pepu 11aqp'auoa:1uuno,t sa uoos se
euo a{sl no,(se uoos ss fnff 'eug 'anbpr Eu1p.raql ,(q pesnodsa,trgod.raq1o
,(ue.ro 'apgd puo;1uu 'leapr.rnsa;rq,r'scpeEne esJoplleno,(g o5 !'elsls eqt
'a3e6 aql u1q1!,n
6upEe auou 11V.ue6o1saq1uJdn peuuns aq ust usltsBd/Es!
-Islros IBuogEN Jo loorueqt
'ule8v 'alBI oot q ll
ISun altloed1somot snopqo
l.usg11lnq6snopqo eqpForls sFItr'uurtrrtollals.auosp.ranrol,tpuaeap8u;.ruqaq
;o 3dacuoa,{.ruu1p.ro eql rtro.r;,{u,nEuol e sg,t1npJo sap! $! Scefiot sFlL
'at8J Jo/puBelEls eql ol
,{lnp q lI Espultos IBuoIl"N tapan lua4tou eql o1,{1nps! l! tnsll"loos repun
'sue1s,(suslrerllslol pue uslrslFoqtne IIBJo padde pdJcuprdaq1sg1eq;'6u1
-Buopqlo asuass1q1'uope1uau18ar sgql',,,{4pn1cund. qq1 qtnoqt slll',{fUent
-aund uuql ag1u.rsEqql 1uq.rodu1 erortr aJEeJeln lsqt mpseJ aqf etrrlalrot
pFoqs seJBIdalqa.r;sapunJarllo puszlpNltsnyof ueJsu!?.qesoqfJoartrosessJ
Ja$BI eql q lsql lrsJ eq1!aru;1uo unJ suru4 aql epsu sFpN eqt ptrB sfspsed
trElsll aq1 'uaes aaeq e,lnsV ee;1rusltsuJ go peddu eql seop treql eJeql\
ruslrsBf,Jolueddvaql
U:lONnIIIOOS3HI
efUSnV|cOS
9Zr
Julnrp:ed u-r's.raquau 1uo.rgEu1pua1;o sluapecoluBIUBNaql uo pazlessJe{BrII
-Jer-qJsIulsJuo-rzAslnaf palossB pue s.raSuoua;EqlsllBftosJo luo.rg.repdod
eql lnq (691) 's.raquau qspaaf lorue ol qdualp rlpouseds epuu peepu!
puu (6SI) .dgqs.raquausgls8uoruurer! 8pelseoq$o4geql0r6l seelel sV
',tged aq1.ra,roatuengu.r8upuanru.ruu
pegaxa'ralsqal\ wuutr4l lulxasouoq aql SuJpnpul luauap pulq at111ulll ltuJ
eql Sqpuepqlpafotr leql pu" .a.rn1onr1s Jpernuep,tpSnoloql B pBIl luo.qil
IEuopENaql
6anou.raql.rng'po81eq1.roy dpduur o1.roos,(uso1pleqe pu s""n
pue lu^!i"ms al$pr u! pe e{aq,{du1s eH :re eleqia -Ilrre Jo uqsy-guu trelq
-puu su?eru auo pJoA{snonrB^ larn,tq {l $tmr B uolalsaq3 s8 r JeqlleN
',tlneg pespu8 rO',{qqol IsJP11odeps.rcse;'.tsunbssalqlru
,(1p1o1puepg.ranodfstllJo sus-rqqJt efeup$al qBE ol pr-arysJeaaussrr eq
q8noqlp'1uo.{{ IeuopsN eqt papunoJaq a.ro;aqEuoIusplues-gus petunoller
,{praauls p"q (ggl) 'pasropua aq selJoaql ,(ee.qdsuoere^efeqlr puu s rep
.re,n-andsFI Jeaelsq,ra'uo1ra1saq3 luql Ja eoquqarlqnop ou eq ust eJe'rr.
',(upluasard aql of u,taop996I ul asaarlplourvJo rpsap aqf etuls Ppq s"q
eq apuloJte ue 6pe1iEqpeal s,ule1.rr{auoreq ol uo luea lreprof UIIoJ GgI)
',(grepuuoldgp 11lnd.raqrreaser auose'uogsan$ qspref aql uo
"actre8.rstrequlr
.ro; uopuquefuo sgg uo.g usprof u!Io3 ulegar u papadxaaq tS6I uI pue
's3s1p,{o1 andug yo an8erl aql Jo JapunoJeql osp sulauo1.r4seq3'X'V
' uspluas-puy
tg,tpaBn4 atlJ pellr,r \ooq 3 elgra ol qrlatJql qdasol'.re1pn
qslaef xopor$Jg aW qf.r,$dn paweal eq 8t6I u! pus 'uaespeq aq lq8noql .ro
',nuseq leqniQ pag;.r.roqsuareq 6pnrro1o11aql puu sdust uose4uatuot eql
lnoqe epue8eito.rdpaq1y,{q q uaqq tam aql relry'slzuN aql Suuq8g lnoqe
sulunb ou peq uogepaqJ $lg1) ,,ssaulsnqs.u!q!rg pqu* ol paluar,{e1so141
a1.nl,ltGgI) 'ailrnas-guu fuellu.raBoslu surd.uoilelsaq3 6,(a1so141 a4rp11',ta1so141
q1.r,n lgtts .rap1lnq .raqde.6og sla1soy41 osp suraaq '4n1st1m7g eql.radedstrau
6araquoga;saq3
f,nf, arpJo roflpa eql serauogefsaqJ lsgeu:nof',tgapq lnq
'uopes1mfuO lqEllprses aq1dn
T'yJo.{qdafo.rq e gu.rad lou saoparedS
ar1euleql srellaas4 raogaldoSpues,na1'-o1d,irc pa[g-elsqJo enbgaleus ;eq1
.repag.red u.rSupnpul 'ga1 Ssltot-grlre!pallslos aqf ,(q Eql Jo ap"u sI qJnu
puu ls;csug JarrrJoJE searJIasuIq uolafseqJ ?uernele $r-ua4xe .ro aEu.u;
Jguunl 11artrsu pe.4lu of lou uope-'f,1uur lsqe8e padpduuc qtlq r uoll"s
-;uufrro .ro ,tped,tue .royelqu4atuoJtrr aq plnoir lI ryaleedxaaq of serasFLlr
'sIzBN (.reurog-os-1ou aruospuu) .rau.rol;o anb.tle3 peululuot
oqu 1glno :ad;alo; aql daa:1o1.t4unor qql .ro11q6noJpeq oq,trueruetlaras'xa
ulcNnv{oo3lHJ
av\lstlvrcos
LZI
,(1a.rpuaeq louueJ luo4g eql 'up8g 'eJoJ aql o1 ,(Jp1du auua 6uogalsaq3
.(q qceqeq pleq uaeq peq qtr,qarluo.\iJ eql Jo Eslllues'$ue 1uo1e1 ,(peerlu
eq,I (?9I) 'dpduur 1uo.rg-puualgo.rdqftq s,an8ra-1-tzep-$uyaql uo{ seqes
-ueql af,uslslpol asoqt,taql suosuarJeqlo puB lutllt"l.rog q6noql1e'qq8.u
pc.q.r1odapup.rHal slgluo.rg aq1,{uapo1dpduec elg Jo luo{eroJ eql u.rarea
,Cu{eflsJuol2 paquufug Jo sreltraqrsu"me elqouni eq;, 'us$Iues'Puu sua
rualqo.rd.reqloug
farue1q,{gelgud aq,tpo ueJ llro.\[ eql tplq,rr roJ euopue
(991)'slstrcot
pue slslrseJpaflat-os Jo sffi;.r aql aquSocar.ra8uolou ppo,n l! 3eltrfsepJeqn
II IJ roJ IIrunoS lBtrolluN eql,(q uolfsrslrap aqf sarl qSnoE 4psu eEp'I[e
aq1,t1qeqo.r6 lI dop o18qq1oupyp,(1p.raua8 1q3lr ruJ eql pue ftro.U 1euopuN
aq1aErq puu ,tq pue 'ursrtotlo aluuortrpe;q1,tu eqt luqruot ol JapJotr! aBI Jo
ap.r aq1q8noJql erpe/$sBlnc ol ale,r{slts eJaJareuo lL 'eruot 01serrasroi[ JBJ
'saqr.ruu pue stqlaau ploq of IqBIJ sr.[NeqlJo uolssa.rddnseqf sG$ss p"{
'aueH
eql {oof lBrtrftuo.u aql sar I s,(e,rqe puu 'pasodu-ra.Ieiasusqle{uElg 'JapJosJp
c;gnd Jo perql aql ,(q ,fiilu1s &FptB lslptrogeu aggs ol lJel rrf,ltorplrB!
paususlrtr eql pa aolle dN aql snryuopdnrslp roJ ,fialepauq papfue1
ara,$qrlqa s8upeau cgqnd algo.rdq8g pue serpJcrtr (acunouueuqJo arortr
.ro) ploq q tu.rnupuoc,tqlnq'rgqnd q pe eqeq 11a,lr pue {6rap.rolrud lsou
eql JoJera r oqm's.raquarnu,rtosg ttrl!,$loN 'uopeltro.{uoc 1ueloll Eu.Garnocua
'slrnor aq1q8no.rqlseFlreuesfl8upq8g
Jo daq eqt olq I1aJluo.U 1euopeNaq1
',{ged aql peal ol ues.rrpeq ppu,fi,
JopselsuJ'(g16l ul pafp uogelsaq3 a:y)
uqof eup sgl ,(g ?aresroa elrals,tq aq1passa.ford selfraaoseq sy 'paquu8
-Jo eJe{ slsa1o.rd-.ra1unot lualo!^ 'qLrutu u aslueEro ol paFl tuo.tr{ luuo.Il
-EN ern eu$,tuy'sIzBN lsquEy stog uerc 'slzeN lsuFEV spltllooqrs 'speN
fsqe8y sJaqJeqtr Inq (991)antuq IzsN-puVeqt,(po;ou puq an uoos,f,ral
'uollcugxe uls1.roJ- ilH st1oo1 erup luasard
eql lE lurtra- rro{I atar eryq,lteql aaesof pIrBeqq,nupllrg deerlo1pad;eduer
pq1 uo;1uquu8.ro,(ue lsup8s Inq luo.lil aq1,(1uolou lsup8u pelunou sura
d.reduue - pcgapr(q saug luJ! - IsJlpoq1atuu puu'paqguerm eJer IIIJoJIUn
's1offletnse saitf ol
.rzBNu!,t1p;radse ppu,fi uqof Jo sqde$oloq; (191)
pepnIIBJEsqail\ puu 11upu,fi{foq qqq,rruI sapxls,{pra aql uo.g dn 8np aran
salonbSugssu.r.requa'sauppeaq eql olq f,uiasll {tp[ of p;us su,$dN eqtr
'ftrorJ aq1lsup8e uEpduee.rraus snolJIAB peqtlmq'sserd
(puu 'relsqeXl u$rsnt pue ppu,(tr uqol
eql u1 spmFJ rleql qlp$ Uatuot u.r
UscNn WOCS3UI
cYlSl-lVlCOS
FHEEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
blamedfor this; it is not simply a caseof giving a dog a bad name,the fact is
that it is often the activities of certain Jewish (more often Zionist) organisa-
tions and individuals that are the root causeof anti-Semitismas muchas the
craziesand the outright bigoterl.
The net result of all this has beenthe associatingof any form of n&ite racial
consciousnessin Britain with a particularly bizame fom of sexshop Nazism,
and six million uterninated Jews.We have already coveredthis ground in a
moregeneralsense;this is of coursea pattern that has beenrrepeatedthe length
and breadth of the white world, what remains of it. The driving force behind
the Anti-Nazi Letgue (henceforthANAL) wasnot OrganisedZionist Jewrybut
the Socialist Workers Party, which in spite of its pathological opposition to
Zionism (165)has neverbeenshyabout soliciting funds from Jewishbusiness-
men to combat (ostensibly) the mutual enemy.
It is theworlds worst kept secretthat the SocialistWorkersPartyanilANAL
are the same organisation in all but name; (16O from the latterrs inception
many ANAL oflice holders weneprominent members of the SWP; many still
are at tle time of uriting. (167) When they cry racism, racism, racisn the
popular front puts forviard its own solutionzsocialism, socialism, socialism.
this pattem is repeated tlroughout the white world, what is left of iL In the
nanti-racist"organisations is
Uniterl States, one of the leading the so-called
Center for Democratic Renewal.This started life as the National Anti-Klan
Networlg (168) its so-called Research Director is a man named Leonard
Zeskindowho is a former organiser of the Marxist-Ieninist Sojourner thuth
Organization. (169) Zeskind is the US conespondent for the Jewish-ormed,
anti-white race-hatemagazine'Searchlightrand,for the record, hewas present
with that organisation's head honcho, GerrryGable,and another Jew,Stephen
Silver, when the current rvriter served a libel writ on Gable at the House of
Commonson Wednesday,December8, 1993.(170)
In Fbance,one of the leading "anti-raclsf"organisations,MRAf, tle so-called
"MoyementAgainst Racismand for Amity 4rnongPeoples',is a Comnunist
PartyFlont. (171)Another "anti-racist"organisation,SOSRacisme,has been
partly funded by that country's socialist government.(L72)
There is though nothing new under the sun. The reader should recall the
wordsofLothrop Stoddard from 1,920:"in everyquarter ofthe globe,in Asia,
Africa, Latin America, and the United States, Bolshevik agitators whisper in
r28
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
129
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
130
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
131
-
\
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM? i
\
132
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ChapterThirteen:TheFight Against
Socialism,National SuicideAnd
RacialDeath:TheWayForward
Up until fairly recently in its history certain Southern States of the US
enforcedanti-miscegenationlaws.(1) The abolition of anti-miscegenationlaws
was seenas a great triumph by the Socialist Intemational and their fellorv
travellers, not becauseanti-miscegenationlaws are any sort of insult to man-
kind, (2) but becauseby abolishing them the leftists are not simply abotishing
discimination bnt are taken one step closer to abolishing tlat most hated of
institutions, the nhite race.
Naturally, National Socialists and others would like to see not just the
reinstatement of anti-miscegenationlaws but the death penalty for thosewho
practice it anil indeed for those who promote it. Many people - of all races -
feel uactly the same rvay about hard drugs, and indeed, some countries,
Malaysia for example,actually executemajor drug smugglers. Such policies
are basedon the nistaken notion fhat just becausesomethingis badonot only
ougbtn't peopleto do it, but that they should be prohibited by law from doing
so. Ihis is not opposition to socialism,rather it is a different kind of socialism.
As stated,the cor:rectwaytoconbatmiscegenationand other sym.ptoms of
the multi-racial madnessis through the restoration of individual rights and
the scaling doumof state intervention and meddling in all aspectsof people's
personal and economiclives. To this end white racists should forn alliances
with Black Separatists and like-minded racial nationalists. But they should
nof support any form of state coercion.
Ihe race industry the world over is fundeil largely by public money,that
meanstaxpayers'and ratepayers'noney. In other words, your money.Without
state sponsorship, this poison would long since have dried up, as would the
gay "rights" lobby and most of the other socialist-inspired crypto-ideologies.
National Socialists and others must lear:r to accept the reality, that some
membersof the white race will fall by the nayside, and concentrate on tlose
who can be saved.
133
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
134
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
that the members of everyrace and culture have the right - or eventhe duty -
to preservetheir inheritance for posterity, and let it go at that.
Oneleading Libertarian - whom I will not namefor the obviousreason- told
me that he personallyfinds blacks physically repulsive but that he doesn'tcarc
if whites and anyoneelsepractise miscegenation.My views are diametrically
opposedto his; there are many people I find physically repulsive - including
practisingmiscegenists, peoplewithfacial tattoos,peoplewhodon'twashrand,
most of all, homosexuals. Blacks- or personsof other races- do not enterfall
into my categoryofpersonal dislikes,but personallikes and dislikesare not
the sameas ideologr,and tr accept,and so should you, that peoplemay find
other people repulsive or hateful ' including you! - for no better reason than
that tley exist.
Notwithstanding that people can be indoctrinated and that therrcare ac-
quired tastes, and so on, finding someone- or somegpoup (4) - physically
repulsivemay be sadbut is nomorewrongthan linding sone objectrepulsive,
becausethis sort of thing is largely a subjectivejudgmenl One mightJust as
well argue that it is wrongto find the taste of strawbemiesrepulsive. I have
often heard it said that many homosexualsfind the thought of normal sex
repulsive, and that many lesbians find the thought of men touching them
repulsive. (5) In the frnal analysis, no one has the right to demanil that
homosexualsshould not n'allowin their perversion any more than "anti-racists"
have the right to demandthat certain whites should not lind blacks physically
repulsive. In a truly free - ie non-socialist - society, both racists (6) and
homosexualswould havethe inalienable right not only to indulge in their pet
hates and perversions, but to attempt to win converts. (7) But they would not
havetheright to do so usingpublic money.(8)
Retuning now to the main subject matter of this chapter, the proposed
strategr for combating socialism (ie the restoration of indivirlual rights), this
is also the corr.ect strategr for opposing quasi-socialist mendacity in every
other field of human activi$ besides the race indusfi. The increasingll'
interventionist style of governmentthroughout the West has not only eroded
freedom but destroyed prosperity, or even the prospect of prosperity, for
countlessmillions of people.
In ChapterThreewediscussedthe caseof JohnsonConhols, the American
companythat was draggedinto court becauseit operated a foetal protection
po[cy. We commentedat the time that such state intervention and regulation
135
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
136
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
Epilogus TomCaldwell
Ibm Caldwell was found dead in his home on Christuas Eve, 1994,atthe
youngageoffrfty. His deathcameasa shockbothtomyselfandto manypeople
rdo had lqonar him, becaussalfftsrrgh he had been desperatelyill up until
quite recently,all his friends andcolleaguesbelievedhewasoyer theworst of
iL Certainly he had put on weight - thanks largely to steroid treafnent - and
although he had long quit his post in the voluntary sectorin Lewisham,heuas
still beaveringawayon a number of projects.
Itho was Tbm Caldwell?As I said, he was a voluntany sectorworke6 I first
met him, around the Summer of 1987- datesare not my strong point - and he
was yery helpful to me at a time in my life when I neededhelp. He was Yery
helpful to a lot of other peopletoo, including thosewho didn't deserveany help
at all. Tomworked at a centre for the unemployed;Lewishamhas a high rate
of unemplo5mentrandthecentredid,and continuesto do,sterlingwork Ithas
to be said though tlat somepeople are not simply unemployedbut virtually
unemployable,as is the character I am nowabout to introduce. At onetime the
cenht nhere Tomworked wasplaguedby a seriesofthefts. It was evenburgled
at one poinl liom knewwho was responsiblefor most of the thieving and one
day,aftcr a portable IV set had gonemissing, he threw him out"
r37
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
I thought this guy was gone for good, but a short time later he was back
cadgng cigarrcttesand the like offTom. I asked Tbm why he kept letting him
in and he replied simply that there was no curing somepeople and that one
just had to do one's best for them. I've no doubt that Tom was 1611lstrding (ie
gving) this guy moneyout of his orm pocket, for his bus fare home, knowing
full well that itwould be spent in the pub.
At lbm's funeral early in the NewYea4literally hundreds of 1rcoplefrom all
backgrounds turned out, including a lot of people I wouldn't invite into my
home- and that's sayingsomething!Ibm wasa veranuch loved aad respected
man, by his co-workers,by the peoplewho usedthe centre,and by many people
who, Iike the petfy thief mentioned above,had beenthe recipient of his help,
his largess,and his humanity over the years.
The point of this belatedobituaryis that Tomwas,or considerc{ himsslf fe
be, a committed socialist and "anti-raclJt".He told me on one occasionthat he
consideredfascismto bea dangerousphilosophythat neededto be supprcssed.
He had also been,at one time, a member of the Socialist Workers Party. (14)
He hated all foms of bigofi and the Tory govemnent in equal measure.
Unlike most so-calledsocialists though, there was nothing doctrinaire about
Tom'sbeliefs.He had read quite a lot of political theory but his political beliefs
sprung not from Marxism but from a belief in people,that they mattered, and
that human nature uas inhertntly good.Eventhough hehad theoretically given
up full time workohis life revolvedaround wor\ none of ntich uas for his own
benefiL He was heavily involved with a music project in a neighbouring
borough right up until the end. It is no exaggerationto say that Tom was the
most selflessprson I haveever me! me and a lot of other people.
The other thing I rcmember about Tom was that he was a strong man. Not
physically, certainly not after suffering for years from the appallipg illness
which led to the removal of his spleen,amongother things. (15) RecaI though
the thief at the centre; Ibm liurervthat these sort of peoplewere weak in t,he
spirit and that horvevermuch kindness or humanity he,or anyoneelse,showed
them, theywould continue to steal, continue to take advantage.
What Tom didn't realiseis that most socialists- certainly thosewho rise to
the top of the pile - were not motivated by his iilealism. Tom was an altruist;
altruism is a belief that it is the highest good to work for otlers. As indeetl it
is. But socialistsare not altruists. Lenin, Stalin,Thotslcyaniltheir successors
weremotivated neither by altruism nor by idealism. The man who suppressed
138
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
139
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
SelectedBibliography
140
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
1,41
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
ChicagoDefendernewspaper(selectedissuesfor 1936).
Chirimuuta, Richard & Chirimuuta, Rosalind: AIDS, AFfuICA AND
RACISM, New and revised edition, published by Free AssociationBooks,
London, (1989).
Cole,G.D.H:A HI STORY OF THE IllB OUR PARW FROM 1914, publisheil
byLondon, Routledge& KeganPaul, (1948).
Collier, DrJoe TheHealth Conspiracy: How Doctorc,TheDrugIndustryAnd
The GovemmentUndermineOur Health, published by Century Hutchinson,
London, (1989).
Cox,EarnestSevien.L/NCOIN'SNEGRO PoucY,published bytie Noon'
tide Press,Los Angeles,(1968).
Cross, ColinzTHE E4.SCISTSIN BRITAIN, published by Barrie and Rock'
lifi,Iondon, (1961).
Daily Express,London, (selectedissues).
Daily Sketchnewspaper,Lnndon, (selectedissues).
Delmer, Sefton:Black BoornerangAN AWOBIOGRAPI:N, (Volume Tivo)'
published by Secker& Warburg, London, (1962).
I)elmer, Sefton: Tiail Sinister:AN AWOBIOGRAPHY (Volume One)' Pub'
lisheil by Secker& Warburg, London, (1961).
Delph, Ed\naril William: The Silent Community: Public Homosanal En-
countersrpublishedby SagePublications,London, (197E).
Denning Right Honourable Sir Alfred Qater Lord): FREEDOM UNDER
THE L/lw,published by Stevens& Sons,London, (1949).
Donovan,Patrictr, (seeentry for Bates, Stephen).
Douglas, C.H: Social Credit,publisheil bythe Institute of Economic Democ-
racy, (DouglasCentenaryEdition),publishedby Bloomfield Books'Sudbury
Suffoilq $nD.
Douglas, C.Hz THE MONOPOLY OF CREDIT,Introduction by Geoffrey
Dobbs,published by Bloomfield Boolis, Sudbury,Suffo[q (1979).
Dynes,WayneR.: (Editor): Encyclopediaof Homosextalrry,published by St
JamesPress,London, (1990).
\\e Economisf,fondon, (selected. issues).
Enqclop aedia Bitannica, Macrop ae dia and.Micropaedia, variots editions.
Encyclopedia Atnericana International Edition, published by Americana Cor-
poration, Washington,D.C.,(L977r.30volumes.
EveningStondardnewspaper,London, (selectedissues).
142
FBEEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
143
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
144
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
L45
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
146
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
r47
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
148
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
149
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
NotesAnd References
ChapterOne:WhatAre WeTalkingAbout?
(1) For the record, in generalI spell socialism (and socialist) with a small s
and communism (and communist)with a small c. GenerallyI spell fascism
(anil fascist) with a small f. However,when I am referring to the terms
specificallyrather than generically,I capitalise. The words Nazi and Nazism I
alwaysspell with capital letters becausethey are alwaysproper nouns.
(2) Throughout this work I haveused the words comm'nist and socialist
moneor less interchangeably.This is a point that is hardly worth debating.
lbue, there are niid socialists - David hving oncereferred to himself as a mild
fascist- when I refer to socialists I mean,gen'erally,peoplewho accept all the
major tenets of socialist philosophy,in particular the total state control and
ownership of the means of production, and the concepts of class urar and
proletarian dictatorshiP.
(3) The following information on Tbotslry,which is non-contentious, was
culled from the EncyctopediaAmeicana Intemational Edition, 1;977 . The entry
TROTSItr, can be found in Volume27,pages157-8.
(a) Seepages58-9.
(5) You Can Trust The Communists,by Dr Fred Schwarz, published by
Prentice-Hall, EnglewoodCliffs, NJ. SecondPrinting, (October 1960),page
43. According to schwan, thotslty was not a Menshevik either, and hovered
somewherebetweenthe two factions. For tle record" Schwau analysesof the
intellectual perversion known as Mamism are amongstthe linest everwritteu.
(A LEON TROTSItr CURSEDBY FATHER Tiail of Tbroist, by Bemard
O'Donnell,publishedinthe EmpireNews,SundayAugust25,1940'page5.
(7) Pollittwas the sonof a boilershopworker.seefor example2BITUARIES
FROM THE TIMES 1951-1960, published by NewspaperArchive Develop-
ments,Reading, (1979)'Page 579.
150
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
1-51
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
152
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ChapterThreq Socialism,Minorities
AndWorthyCauses
(Ll l{arl Mam Racist,byNathaniel Weyl,published by Arlington House,New
Yorlg (199), pagel26.
(2) There are variations on this,
Q) Weyl,Karl Marx: Racist,page126,(op cit). Weyl gives this as \ilorkers of
theworld unite!Youhavenothingto losebut your chainsand a world to gain!"
(4) TRAGEDY AND HOPE: A History of THE WORLD in Our Time,by
Carroll Quigley,SecondPrinting,AngriffPress,Los Angeles,(1974)rpage37S.
(O Quigley,Ti,agedy And Hope, page376, (ibid).
(O Quigley,Tiagedy And Hope,page380,(ibid).
(7) Michael Marks was a Jewish refugee who, fleeing from pogroms in
Russian Poland,adopted this name on his arrival in England. His real name
153
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
t54
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
155
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
156
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
tally, Lenin was the founder of the CommunistFarty of Great Britainl. How-
ever,it appearsto havelost somethingin translation as I havebeenunableto
Iocatethis actual quoteeither in the aboveor in anyof [,enin'sturgid prose.It
is though a faithful definition, and if Lenin himsetf atidn,tuse tlese exact
word.s,he would certainly haveendorsedthem,and indeedhe put them into
practice,as weshall seein due course.
(4) The Constitutionof Liberty,by F.A. Haye\ published by the University of
ChicagoPress,London, (1960),page154.
(5) The following is exfracted,from Blacl<stone's
Statuteson CNMINAL LAW
199+5,4th Edition, by P.RGlazebrook,publishedby Blackstonepress, Lon-
don, (1994),page11:"INFANTICIDE ACT 1938{ilhere a womanby anywilful
act or omissioncausesthe death of her child being a child under the ageof
twelvemonths,but at the time of the act or omissionthe balanceof her mind
was disturbed...'",etc.
(6) Ilayeb The ConstinttionOf Libeny, page 155, (op cit). In practice it is a
lot more complicated t,han ttrat becauseif the state were to prosecute every
alleged breach of every law the courts would be swamped.The facts that the
police will sometimescaution rather than prosecutetrivial offencesand that
the croum Prosecution service will sometimes decide not to proceed with
prosecutionswhich they believehavelittle chancesg 5rrsesding doesno! in
either case,constitutea breachofthe rule oflaw.
(7) This quote is verywell-known:
Thken here from the inside dust cover of THE FEARFW MASTER: A
SECOND LOOKAT THE UMTED NATIONS, by G. Edward Gritfin, pub-
lished by \TesternIslands,Belmont,Massachusetts,(1964).
(E)schwarz, wat Is communism.Thereare actually three tapesin this series
under the generictitfewat Is comntunism?Theyare wat Is communism?,
communist Dialectic and.communist Recruitrnent.Dottbtlessthey are, or lyere
157
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
158
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
159
09r
'[961 aiurl ,(Sg6I) .p.roJxo.ssa.rg,{1;sra.rg61 proJXO,{qpaqsgqnd,ape1l
seloqt.rNT puorg uegg,g,tq .acuatcgu! IaJaO puDpnDq :IlIl1VJ gHJ lO
SVgAVVJggI i.raqqlqnd pq8go aq1.asno11uopusgEqpnleul ! papop"r
'sesnoq Sqqqlqnd .rofeur y1 o1 .plsqsoy
11V ,{z.raffq rsda4g.laloutu.ruupr,
pJE ry{oog IBUoIIEN uJo ldursnuem pad,tp.r pallguqns
u Jelljl$.acuelae{V
:goda.r iq,uolloJ aql ruo{ trees eq trH) - rus!
-p1-rduc.rapun spleureqlo ,tueu pue - SuJqsqqndq snogr;.rdee aoq $nf (r)
'JIo sarpolrraq qlpr pooSsu
1sn[ qool puu.rnouep saoposIEgaqdua3 @)
.Unor sluuel aql uo ssa,no.rd Jeq qrfuu Jeaeu11prs;uopl
,&ura1g.raq1eq1,tes ol lpsur ou s.l! Inq se,roglanrepsI JoqlneuBpoo8laoqpnf
seprou aaeq 1.n661.u-ruolq8no15ry .reppog,{qpaqsqqndpue sapclN zr.rleuo
qlp{ m$IJAr-orse,n.auo7 7o1o1 aq1.1atoas.e oInBraBN?BeJpeq B IIu lB lorr
pua {ron ruAo:aq,(1afue1 aq ol p;us sr.unug.letou s,paqdue3 .r;ugeq o1 $)
'
lVuau8pa1uou4)V*sl 6sqluou arnosJo pogad u
raaoua$1r,lrsea{ooq qq1la8essud.relnr.rl.rud sql Bq;;.r,nyoaru;l aql ry (t)
'qfeel Jleql q8no.rqlEu.rr(1 ,{1dqs .ropgo,n,{sulrreJB uI
6upg .raql.raa.resJoqfnu aseqfJo fuuu ,noqglasmo,trlse puu .seruaq;pelsla.r
puu egqc,tsduo sellll aql Jo auos l" {ool e ilIsl .doqsqooq s ofu! rpe,n no,t
aup Uer'ralanoq ep!s?luqf 8q,rea1.qs,(puu l?ntxal s;,t1.Ip;eedsXf,t (g)
'E
FJV {rslg t4looJ Fs uBtr\J
al!e[eql eJoJeq,rrroll?srlralr,, {cBIqJo lurye aql su,n,epuu8edo.rd 1slpgcoso1
,fte.4uoc'u-ru8e.qr1q,nspq pnu aql q aA;1ol s,(epurou .ragand suer.r4ry.{eJos
t"qt usJ eql q sFItJoJoo.rdary .uaq1 lq8no.rquu4 etFL!\ orll puu uqplldee
6usJpgadrnlslgeuaqaq1{q.roypalesuaduorueql erorr
se,nspafqnslsluolo,
4at11Jo s.ra,nodlsJp;.radu1 aql ,{q uopel;o1dxaaq1 ,upue6udo.rdlqp;cos o1
,fte4uo3 'uolgolslp sso.6 e,(lqegae q fI lnq f,su1uu;Irlol Blou sI slql (Z)
'[0r-69r
sa8ed r(9961) u.rqq1qn6 BpuuurC/ulpsl"d ,tq paqsqqnd ,.raupg Ff,luore1
yJvD suoqnlonQ
? ryrv tq1rvo nrtgswa gHJ oJ cIT/009 p)yotslH
lo ,ttouog4q yl ptall yo anbpJ.rre o1acegandu q sFD elo.&rrretr J,,.agoJd
aq1;oun;do aql q .pry;.r;dsun
lI ars qrlqa suo$[puorJo 1.r.4dsaq1ptrBplroin
ssepreequgo s8ugaayaq1.a.rnlua.rc
passe.rddoaqlgo q6Jsaql s; uo!Hl1q1'(1)
Blpentrpuv slrv 6uopl1eg:e^If,reldBqJ
avrsr-rvrcos
H3cNn
u\oo3lul
T9T
's8uluoegoqs s,tus11u4deo .ro; alqlsuodsa.rs;
',trn1ua3qpgua4f,
Wlqra4otza,ssr4 trEql rerller rnsluopua refq sqt s1g pue
aql Jo asJnot aql Jaao lsr-uoguarJeful,{16u.rseanqauotaq aasq sellnouoJe
rrrelsal\ fuql ltuJ pr;4dua ue q8noql s; q 'a.raqrl(uu pa5pe .ri,rau suq
usl1elros lurll EI"Ir oq,rrs1slppos erot p.reqa4g uo ilrue ol8u-to81outu.1(61)
'a1oq,{.rouau
aq1ol padlsuor ueaq a,req !5pa.r3 1eltos go quauodo.rd raqlo pIIB uosl[Il
Jnq1.ry'sq8noq .rofe1,qyo s8upg,n lBqruas eqf a[qra'sasg;41uo,r 3;,npn1 3o
pJmq a Bq saltqt JlluouoJepue ue-usueqlrlJo eppmo aldoedrra;,{.ra,r'pueq
raqto eql uO ra^o plro,raeq1safloeu Eq11$Pue s.rolegullo,txepE u pau,neds
e Bq sr1.ror slq puu loq1ne 6q11as1saqsnornnqSod B altroreq aruls 6uo1
suqeq',$.r.rnesqo 1ulol sselro erortrq pa1px.re1qq8noqqurof,'usF.rutr trJo'
suilel Isltuuug,(1a.rndu! - ssattns aql q s$gJo alduuxa ogo.4 poru aqtr (31)
',{lpaarasapun,qplot 'esecs,x.re141 uI OI)
'(plql) '9g1a8ed'puog utytg uolssDJaqJ ruapuatg (91)
'O!qD '911a8ed'puog uf,Vl6 uolsvrJ aqJ 'uapuerg (91)
.(plql) ,91y aEed,puoy ^yl1 uolssD{aqJ 'uepuang(y1)
6uopuol'ua11y
41 aEuil'(nC)
'911.{q paqsgqnd5uapuergu.ruq.rug,(q'QNW N V trO NOI SSYJ gHJ G1.)
'ua,ta1g.ra1duq3
ees 'tusl1epos pus rrslunuruoJ ;o a4ods aqs sB ldualuor aues eqf qlpl[
uaql;o arlodsilesraq pus5 'slenpaflalr1pa1$s are aldoadasaql'1sealry (71)
'1elrelurtrrlrlo
4aql ellJlr oq,nsrau.ro;"rad
6suupgsnru
IIs pue {JoJ Jo ,t1profeu aqf apnlJu-rf .iro8apc sqf uI (II)
',tlapungogun'1ou 1ng
ialpur,teu 1 .rono,{auo aq1
'paqqlqnd lou are peapq s{ooq eug,tra,rauos 1eq3,(usof lou s! slql (0I)
'fuaqar;.rafue1
qrnu ,iral e yo dp aql ,{p.rau a.res,qaqdueJ ilII salJofs sseJtns aq3fi.ron
alnrasu!pu"SuJpuumap,{.re,r qpq 5quaryo,f,ra,rpue
aq uer tu11apotr41'1e.rauaE
u; uogssagold3u111apou aq1.rogaqdue3 reqlla epl11aq ol Sulirl fou EB I (6)
a.IaarsJJaq uI
uo,(1.reapa;ep ol lou uesorlJaqspuq paIrJBeea"q e^o$luJ sN u"roq-qJaz3aql
ppo r tnlelrce pus aungoJ'auegqtnm,toqJlesulq {sE plnoqs JapEJ eqt lnq
'lla,uuauomsgodspuu uausgods.rlaql pap.re,nars,{u,rapeauqqalaoS er1;.(g)
u30Nnu\ocl33Hl
al/\|sl]vt3os
Z9I
?ueppn"{ lqEprulop uaryo,ira,rpue'eue4xe
eqf q )1ee,rr'peqs! aruaplaaaq1loo8 q,f,roaq1aql q8noq1pfeql q ualqo.rd
,{1uoarylou {ulql I alqfu ueql relseJ qcntu la^url uet qclqn gercaauds
rgsgn1nJ q ,{ge1n6a.rrIUBg eql llsp qrlq r pue srno uuql petrre^pu a.roru
s.rea{;osuo;1llu er" leql suollsslll lJ Jo uopusl.r,rrpe q anqt lno a.raq,rraruos
lsql alquqordu; os l! sI'pp s.rea,t;osuolruq s! asre lun aql'11sraryy 'poo8
spunosweql Jo ,f,roaq1 aql {u;qf ru$ I peepurpuu 6s.racnes 6up{g uI Ja aleq
lnoaapa aluo sB rrellrar lueJJnJa r. 'freJ q s;suqr(uB eaBquusurouaqdasaqlJo
,tue1uq1e e{eq ol astrasuouq l lurll uuerul.uop 1 asuesuou,tesI uee11(g)
'luaueternorua,{uu;1 epl{ paeueldoaderuosleql rrluilat su ;snf
s11161ra.6,tre,r,(1u.rq.ralsI g e[q^r lI.rerleenba8Vua71pureaouaps-opnesd;o
uopouo.rd aql u! alor s.BIpatuaq1,(ypuenbo11dua11e of e{11luppo,u I (g)
' eEed'(OOOt)'uopuol
19
'ua11y'11X1,tq paqqlqnd tcuas^{gsue11,{q'asnD7 V qt!il p qay ugpalonS (1)
aulrlperupuvqtlBeH
6uoglucnpg'ugurepuJv
:4S relduqJ
'ule rEIIrtrIs
u uI alpra oqr[ sJoqlns fsonr ar" su 6q1eduapre8 eq1dn sJepsar.r;aq18ugpuel
Iprap a.respual4 sH pue aqpuu 'qqqqn.r prps,(u a-re,(aq1 puq Beq
1nq6pea.r
,{l.uussamu 1.uppo,r,{aq1sle ou sBuelllJ r aJa*rfaq111'ptoug qruauasatlJprlre
$luaqilvq)olg otlJ epnlru! s{ooq sH lraqqlqnd Euarlsuprtr u,(q dn ua4el
raeq ^rou seq aH 's6961Xgeaaq1u.rSuqs;1qnd-glesJJopegels su;1loJ ireJpuv
petu"u uerrr V 'paaJlns oq/n saseJfqgo,n aq1 s,{eaqelou q tI u;uEV (gZ)
'pussnoqf,{gg su,{la,rgaaga
f sor ss lsoulu sad4,tgg arluu uuc no.(1"ql q umIpeu qq13o,$nueqxq6LeT,')
'alqep.roge,tlaueqxe
saqze8uupuu s;alqdruud's1ooq;osun.rlurr{ Ioqs ilIEu salqd.rade; (17)
'dgqs.ro1e1c;pJo
srrrJoJIIBJapun1nquslplros Japrm
,(1dut-ts1ou sa;1ddeqq1 ',{1pluapyru1'asod.rnd.r;aq1pa Jes a,ruqr(aq1uaqa Jo
's.ra1Jale.4,noJIeJ
Jo slsilsrJospa$luuor se{asuaql 1oua.ru.taq;uaqtr4(gg)
a|/\sr]vr3os y{oo33Hr
H30Nn
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
163
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
164
99r
pesn su,n pue sls! pte ,Js!mr-We,, (pa1pc-os),{q ,{1;aqqndsnouroua ua,rp
su,nuugsy8uno,tqq1yo.rap.rnu9661,tp1 aryptrlnq 4qog ,(oqlooqcsdnep;5
p1o.rea.t9I Jo Jepmu aql sB t sptrfJo alduexa Sqruaqelsg luelleJxe uV (fi)
. (plqD
\7 afied.,tslcoy xtoytl ytrS7.ga6 (71)
'(1;r do) 'yg a8ud'ls1cogxtoytl ya2'$a6fi1)
'(SgOf)'sa1aEuy so1 'ssa.r6appuooNeq1,{qpeqsgqndto3
.re! eS fserrreg Aq'7'3.7IOJ OVggN S,N1O)NI7 ol peueJar s! rapuer eql
'o.6a11aq1o1epn1glus.uJocug olu-rlqSgsuguu.rog'Eup1eru-JegpsJtn pue esuas
-uou ssegse pasodxauaaq3uo1aleq s8ugurraH,tl1esperueussa.6ap WI,la
semluaapElEnK|s puq aq fBql sulup aq1:Jau,noeaBlse sB,ltuosra$ef"(0f)
' (1;e do)' xto14J
77 ateil' qs1cog 1toy'$aps(6)
' (pKD' gy61'o4utmrygolpaodo1ctcug (g)
'1,-919satud 'g1awin1oS'V-7ggi\rDf 'uop.rpegt6l eql u;,{.4u4 aql Eo.q ua{sl
q,f.ruurnns EqrraottoJ aql 'uoglpa $elBI erp q,ft1ua,tug e,{go suq uql (1,)
.'qlIBarIJFtrorroJes.slssng6u.uo1sar.ro3 alqusuadqpulsB,haPB4
alu,rprdleql pe$1upe aq ^roN'eltreqleue se asgd.raluaapa.r.rdpaplu8ar puq
mue'I816I u1"'roqlnu slql ot Eulp.roray'(plqD '11y a8ud'u1ua7'qnqs 0)
'(;p tlo) '719efled'4ua7'qnqg (g)
'(696I) 'uopuol'1.reqslAl aauarmul,tqpe
T
-qqlqnd'uqosppua141'16utuur1'9,(q pa11p g.'WSITruI{YJ iO 4DVIS JS4H
-gIH 'WSIT7T{41WI a! 'app fuqf E elora ueaeulue.I (t)
flHJ $}n {ooq
'9 aEerl'4anssg 'satug tqBNaqJ
1g')
9661.rdy4eq
'sse4roJ
B ery l11nqq ueq8uppN u! sasluerd sll leqt Jailra luerrnt eql plol eunos
pau.roJuluv'ulu1pfl q .ra1u.ud .reg.rofeu aql q peTuIrI ssar6lassrX (7)
rya1
'uns aql raprm (aq,*raq1opuu
4uqla) [1uou1ut
,irela pue rusFouel Jeqlo pue VUI Jo s.ragoddns 'luaue,lou lelrxesoruoq
pasguflro aqlpapnleq ssefuBlsllJo qualdpaX'uopuequ,(u8qlpr sasnst1sRIaI
o1,tauou 1nope11opqJlttrtrJTO peluau"Iun pue pagudap 6uo1aql se^resuas
pue ,s.ra,(edan pseg (I)
-uou Jo Uos sFIt Jo ,{ep,{aqary r(auou ,s.ra,{udxu1
slsllslros s5fBpol
fv{ool resolJ v :ueaasrefduqc
H3oNnt/loc=r3Hr
al/\srlvrcos
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
166
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
Q3) MPs to quiz gas chief overpay, by Patrick Donovan and Stephen Bates,
publishedin the Guardian,December16,lgg{rpage 1.
(24) According to Whitakers'Almanack, 1995, a Circuit Judge receives
f,69,497; a SeniorCircuitJfiSeES2$41;whileRecordersarepaid f,332perday.
(2t AII fhis and moreis discussedby Quigleyin TiagedyAndHope, (op cit),
seein particular Chapter X.
(2Q It is, or should be,commonknowledge,that most judges actually take a
pay cut when they arrccalled to the bench.A good QC doesnot relish the pay
cut such a promotion brings. It is said to be virtually impossible to bribe a
British judge.
(27) SeeChapter Four under SocralismAnd TheRule Of Law.
(28) A note here on the wealthy.In past centuries, scienffic research uas
caried out largely bywealthyanateurs. Eventoday there are still someof them
aboul For example, Edward Goldsmith, founder and former editor of The
Ecologistmagazine,has spent the greater part of his life working to conserve
the environment- I have met Goldsmith a few times, and his is obviously a
labour of love; just as obviously his work has been heavily subsidised out of
his oumpockel It goeswithout sayng that in FauI Foot's cloud cuckooland
paradise nobodywill have the meansto carry out such work, aad aslhingwill
be subsidisedwhich the statedoesnot approveof. (Seealso pages10-1).
(29) One is rcminded here of the oldjoke about Leonid Brezhnev.His mother
visits him in the Kremlin and he showsher round his automobile collection:
This is myRolls; this is myMercedes;this is myCadillac",hesays.Shereplies,
This is all very nice my son, but what will happen to you if the Commrrnists
get in?"
(30) Quigley,TiagedyAnd.Hope,page 889,(op cit).
(31) It is, I thint fair to say that special constables are often despiseil by
cerntainsectionsofthe public, and evenby certain sectionsofthe police force.
Lifeboahen and mountain rrcscuevolunteers perform at times thankless and
dangeroustasks.
(32) Seefor exampleSOCIALIST STUDIES NO. 16, (undated but published
early 1995),page15.
(33) A particular nasty domes1l"sxample of this is the monthly magazine
Labour Left Biefing * which calls itself "the voice of Labourrs inrlependent
unrepentantleft'. lbny Blair certainly has no friends here.
167
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ChapterEighfiA StraightLookAt
BolshevismIn Practice
(1) ShubrZenlz, (op cit), pages16-7.According to Shub,Lenin sworehewould
makeihem pay for this.
(2) Theword Bolshevik actually meansmqiority; Menshevik meansminsff5r.
Q) Shub,knin, pagelii1, (op cit).
(4) Kun ras actually executedin 1937,as a thotslcyite.According to his entry
in the EncyclopediaArnericana, he was later rehabilitated. The idea that
someonecan be rehabilitated posthumously is novel to say the least It is
doubtful if Commrrnismeyerhad a more faithful servantthan B6la Kun; if this
is the nay the Redstreat their most devotedproselytes,you can imagine how
they treat the corlmon people.
(g Shub,Lenin,pagel22, (op cit). [I haverelied largely on David Shub's
biographybecause,although it showsLenin and his fellow enemiesof humanity
in an ertrenely bad light, it is far from hostile. Shub took part in the 1905
Revolution,andrvas exiled to Siberia. He lnewlenin personallyl.
(O Shub,Ienin,page U2, (ibid).
(7) Shub,Ienin, page 115, (ibiil).
168
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
(E) there is evidencethat some wealthy Jews did finance Hitler, though
obviously for their orm nefarious pur?oses rather than out of misplaced
idealism as with the likes of Morozov And, the protestations of Organised
Jewry and their fellow travellers aside, the Zionist movementdid cooperate
(and indeed collaborate) with the National Socialists. Ihis is thoroughly
documentedbut will not be discussedhere.
(9) Shub,Iez in, paget22, (op cit).
(10) Shub,tenin,page 179,(ibid).
(11) Shub,leninrpage I23, (ibid).
(12) I hope this doesn'tsound unduly apologetic,but the point should be
taken.
(13) Shub,Zeninrpage126,(op cit).
(14) Shub,Z enin, page61, (ibid).
(1O Re the alleged Jewishnessof Stalin, sefor exampleFRAWWENT
CONVERSIOM The Myh Of Moscow's ChangeOf Heatt, by Colin Jordan,
published by the Britons, London, (1955),page25.Ihe Nazisalso suspected
&at Stalin was Jovish at one time.
Ihe allegedJewishnessof l*nin may not be anti-Semitic propaganda,but
a gen 'ine nistalre; he had a speechdefectwhich uas somewhatrcminiscent of
a Jewish accent in Russian, lWorld lewry: THE REVIEW OF THE WORLD
IEWISH CONGRESS,Maylfl2,Yolume Xf, Number2, page101.
(1O Lilce a plague bacillus, as Churchill put it.
(17) The actual quote is "It is hue that liberty is precious - so precious that
it must be rationed.' fThe PenguinDictionary of Twmtieth-centuryQuotations,
byJM. and MJ. Cohen,publishedbyViking London,Revisedand expanded
edition, (1993),page2291.
(18) Shub,Z enin, page!77 , (op cit).
(19) Shub,I enin, page310,(ibid).
(20) Af the trial of the staff of Belsen camp, one of the claims made by the
defencenas that Regulation 18b under which fascists and other opponentsof
the war had beenintenred, violatnd.habeascoryus.
(21) Shub,Ienin,page 414,(op cit).
(22) Shub,I enin, page312,(ibid).
(23) Shub,Zenin,page3l3,(ibid). [Eventuallyof courseSovietComnunism
collapsed"literally, but Shub's claim - made in the 1966edition of his Lenin
biography- held right up until the era ofGlasnost and Perestroikal.
169
FREEDOM
UNDERSOCIALISM?
170
FREEDOMUNDERSOCIALISM?
171
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
ChapterNine:More AboutTheMedia
(1) There are actually two photographs ofthis scene,taken a few seconds
aparL
Q) MAKING PEOPLE DlMPPEllRenamazing Otronicle of Photographic
Deception,by Alain Jaubert, published by Pergamon-Brassey'sIntemational
D,efensePublishers, Inc, Mcl-ean, Virginia, (1989)'pages30-1.
This bookwas first published as Ie commissariatanx atchives:Les photos
ry.i fatsifient I'histoire, by Editions Bemard Barrault, Paris' (1986).Although
theyare not widelypublicised, therc are a fewsuchstudiesof fake photographs;
this one is trulyexcellenl
(3) The definitive work on the subj ectis Katyn,by Louis FitzGibbon' publish'
erl by the NoontidePress,Ibmance,California, $nr.It is subtifled.ACime
Without Parallel.
(4) FitzcibbonrKntyn, (ibid)' seethe frontispiece.
(5) Jaubert, Making PeopleDisappear,page E9, (op cit). Briefly, the Katp
massacrewasuncoveredby the German authorities' who published a 330page
rcport on itin 1943:Thefficial StatementConcerningthe MassMurdcratKatyn.
Ituas proved conclusivelythat tie menweremurdered betweenApril 1940and
September1941.That notwithstanding, the Americans, including Roosevelf
covered up for the Soviets at Nuremberg who tried to pin the blame on
Hemann Goering. In September1976a pslrrrmspf vas errcctedin London to
the victims. For the full, grisly story the reader is referred to FitzGibbon's
boolgl{ntyn, (op cit).
(O One can add to this the compliance,venality,spinelessnessand outright
comuption of Westein governments,but again, this is an argument for the
diffusion of power - ie the limifing of the power of govemment in the lielil of
communications- rather than the opposite.
Q) laufurL, Making PeopleDisappeor,page96' (op cit).
(8) KRUSHCHET/ruLK CITED SruLIN PLOT AGATNST MOLOTOI4
U.S.HAS THE TEXE.., published in theNeH/YorkTirnes,LATE CITY EDI-
TION, Monday, June 4, 1956, page 1; the article continues on page 3 as
KRUSHCHEV ALK CITED SruLIN PLO T.
(9) Schuarz, Wa Is Communism?,(op cit).
172
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
173
NLI
'l! ul pereedde,tgenlce {u$ll l6uopI hI uo Ua ps aqf rausI
I
qEnoq1ppuu ',{cuaEu uu q8no:q; !.ro,n s,,tepauo1oE,{FoI pJoJereqf Jod (62)
'a1doad,(ueu 1ra.6 u;o spooqla^Il
aql of selnq.r.quoe pue 61.ro,lryo pap 1ua.r8e salu.rauaE,(1sno! qo ums sno .-oue
ue qens8ulpuads'e4euro1sadoq,(ueduocaq1,tauou aqt tno.gUudy '(1ry1aq1
q roHIlE 6Z:fEupnleur) ep! rplJo,rauolruru gg1;f01sun.ruu.t6o.rd.96 smopulryl
areusfl qtunel ol lJosorc!trJ,tq paleeole ptpnq 3u-rq1.ra,rpe eql lertrl peu1elt
su,n1; '9661 'gg lsn8ny uo Joqfne aqf ,tq prueq Fsrpsorq olpe.r B uI (82)
'(1;r do) '619a8ed'4ua7iqnqg (77)
'palaauorun aql Jo e;paruaq1Eqssa.rpppuaq r plpusJ prlt
aq ol lou qtnoua eslr trs slsllepos lsou q8noqlp taplnu Eupnpul (99)
'lr unJ lsntuluarnrue,ro8aq1
leguasse
sI aJli-rasE asnBreqlern anJl 1ou,(1du;ss! lI'suolleuop ap,rgd,tq,{la,rgsnpxa
papnnJs7g'saguot1c:eq1o,tueu qlpn 'puu ',{1peqae tnq atlaras a3u,q:d
u,{1uolou s! uopn1psuJluoqeJlrlluuolluN pr(oa aql latr'erlares luoqaJ;1eql
tsa,q1 ,tueur sa.res .rua,t,ira e qJIq euo sI eJI Jasplpr,{1aue.rga .reqlouy GZ)
',iqsnpu1 etsJ pel"uluop-f spru?Weq1,tqpa,toldua,(la,rpcaga
$ou ueeqq8norp ssq11's1spcre61,{q ,(1du;s1oupue 'uge8earn$ pus eull pasn
esuesuouJo 1.rosslql ueesa^Eq a,11'uogsse.rdxa ee{ of 7q611t notEu;,(o.rlsap
,tqeJ'rga'ua.rpgqr'sap!.rouluJluqp t aro.rdqpasneq Upr qJIqAruo;1e1s@1 o1
snladu; a,rp pE" slJefs.tqdn d;pr o1palua,r,ug s1'nrnasneupe'sEulr agqdopoed
'segce.rldsuor '1euJelEJeql uollul
!z"N - lsxa lusaop qr$Ur - uelqo.rd aqtr, Jo
-n8a.r11o.r1uor epls s! - wle pansapeql sI teql - uopnlos eql 'ua1qo.rdaq1efBi].D
p.rg no,{'uopnloseq1ag6a8ureqt,Qossacaulnoqe Eqr.rqol rapro u!',tUa.r.rg(lZ)
uerpllqt ["erJo
sqdu.foloqd auarsqoa{Bl ol peuIIJuIsselaq ru$,taqf sql op uee sa1;qdopaed
'1uaudo1a,rap B qJns aruoJlea plnoqs ,t1p;radsaec11odaq1 1uq1
J! esnereq
'salsufusJ{r1s.r;aqlatppq {qaraql pue
4ro1gdsq1 ol Jnmol.uprp f,lquqord11
ueruo^rJoselpoqeql tro rrarpMrJo seceJeql asodugadnsppoa sagqdopeed
',fflo1ouqra1u.repou qtlapq1 '.rarg;oaeglode,{qlsau.reeu.rpJB,n roJlnd leql sun
u.rod.ralnduoc;o dgqs.rosuar aql JoJsluaun8 re prnsqu lsoru aql Jo auo (gZ)
]/IooSSHJ
ansnvtcosHsctNn
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
ChapterTen:Monopoly,Marketing
AndEmployment
(1) There is also such a thing as monopsony,wherethe market is dominated
by onebuyar,usuallytte govemment.
(2) Seepage66.
(3) Qutgley,Tiagedyand Hope, page 452,(op cit).
(4) ManufacturersforceAsdatoend discountson S0vitantrls,, byNeil Buckley,
published in the Financial Times,October 26, 1995,page20.
(O Seefor examplethe excellent study TheHealth Conspiraqt:How Doctors,
TheDruglndustryAndTheGovemmentUndermineOurHealth,bythe london
pharmacistDrJoe Collier,publishedby CenturyHutchinson,London, (1989).
(Q \\e Financial Tirnesar1,icle(referred to in this paragraph) also mentions
the Sainsburysupermarketchain,which had also beendiscountingvitamins.
(7) Re Qurgley,seenote 3 above.In his 1.776classic, The WealthOf Nations,
the great free market economist Adam Smith wrote that "Peopleof the same
trade seldommeettogether,evenfor merriment and diversion, but the conver-
sation endsin a conspiracyagainst the public, or in somecontrivanceto raise
prices.n
(8) One of the expressionswe often hear in this connectionis tle "balanceof
trade"; Britain is said to have an unfavourable balance of trade with Japan,
whateverthat means.In reality, the moreweexport, the harderwe havetowork,
and the more we import, the more foreigp.ersdo the work for us. The Japanese
have long imposed heavy tariffs of their own while continuing to export
massively.Ihis is portrayeil by the media as somesort of nefarious Oriental
schemeto undernine the West; the reality is that we benefit from this at the
cost ofJapaneseworkers,who are subsidisingour cheapelectronicimports.
(9) On tariffs, the reader is referred to Protectionismand the Destructionof
Prospuity,by Murray N. Rothbard, in THE FREE MARKET READER Essays
in the Econonricsof Liberty, Edited by Ltewellyn H. Roclnrell, Jr, published by
The Ludwigvon Mises Institute, Burlingame,Califomia, (1988).
175
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
176
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
177
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
T7B
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
179
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
(30) For an excellentintroduction to the nonsenseof the EPA and the way it
has misused its Draconian powersunder the guise of protecting the environ-
men! the reader is referred to the briefing paper "/IDy'K SCIENCE' IN
ACTION: CNNCAL NOTESON THE EI,TWRONMEI{TALPROTECNON
AGENtr (EPA), by Chris R.Ibme, publisherl by FORESI London, (June
$n).
ChapterTkelve:Race,Socialist
MendacityAndTheAppealOf Fascism
(1) If this sounds unnecessarilyparanoid the reader should remind hinself
that the goal of many other ideologies and indeed of most religions is to
subjugnte all mankind. Therc is nothing eitler esotericor sinister about this'
indeed,any ideologr that is capableof persuadingpeopleto espouseit by
representing itself honestly,desenesto win converts.
(2) According to an article in thelewish Chronicle, Decemberl7 , llRT , pages
27-8,Mussert's party had about fifty Jervishmembers.An article published in
TheBarnesReviewforJune 1995reported that by the time a ban was imposed
in October 1938,the party had around a hundred and lifty Jewishmembers.
(3) And remains one! TheProtocolsis still in print, and has inspired a great
deal of subsequentanti-Semitic literature.
(4) In August 193E,Ford was awarded a Nazi nedal to celebrate his 75th
birthday, the first American to receivesuch an award. The reader is referred
to the excellent studies WHO FINANCED HITLER: The SecretFunding of
Hitlels Riseto Power 1919-1933, by James Pool and SuzannePool, and to
Antony Sutton's WriIIStreetand the Nse of Hitler, both of which cover Fords
involvementwiththe Nazis.Ihere are a number of biographiesof HenryFord
which also coverhis obsessionwith the JewishQuestion,the most sipilicant
being the 1980study byAlbert L'ee,HenryFordAnd Thelews.
(5) MSCISM IN BNruIN A History 191&1985, by Richard Thurloq pub'
lished by Basil Blackrvell,Orford, (1987),page 52.
180
I8I
sB?q8F1nopeuuapuor [aru] pue 6pgdnlspus pilItp\, arearXIfg aqf pilIrslle
oqlr sAef luqt paurs r 'g a8ud 'gg6l 'g pnSny Jo plto/fl tlsturalat1;. (71)
'[71e8ed,'Z6I '0 raqualdag 'a7c1uott73 qsr*a[eW q paqs[
-qnd'AOITOJ ,SJSDSV1 gO NOIN1 HSImIg :us!fiuas-uav puo ta1soyry
plD'$so ll.sl u'sn uo{ l33p a.renbSe eaeqs,(arquIIFI seFreueqI uBql JeqfuJ
.f4unoc slql e,ues oq,trpue upllJfl Jo suaz$IJ p,(o1 a.ruoqitr s {af 's,naf eJs
,(aq1asnecaqsaef {Jqle Ja^eua111',ftlunorslqf uilI"ttrs ,tpuaoa.re qtlq,n
asoql sBqrns suollJusuerlIsJJueugleuollsuJalq u! pa8u8uaa.re,{aq1 "q oaqrr
,(gunbam ,{gu; 1s;unuruoJ aqf Jo uopterlp eql sEqJns seg! Ilte a lsraaqns
ug pa8etue a.re faql 31 saef {rsDB e,1l 'stspsud JO uolufl qsllFfl eqf Jo
,b;1odaqlgo ged ou'a.roga.raq1 5s.r
puu'uqcseg;o ensq ou s! usplues-lluyx
'mg aCf
4uertrelels Eqrno11oleqf penssl ,{a1so1,q ;o 8ugpunogslq uO (II)
'rruoJer
lelJuBuuJo alsJoapB
,(gua puu Joilreaul tauno,{.rope; e'uoslgy JnIIFV sulltsuolrrfl eql of ulq
pernpo4ul oq,$usw eql '1g1noEqqsgqndrp;uag-llus 1epuangug lnq 'puus u
'suo1.r.rg
aq; o13uop uaqq selr eq uaqar auueaq,(1pnpu asarl (91)
,,es.r,rr-aafu
'rZ6I raque oN pewrguoJ '1,761.reqo1r6 pessud
,Z
z7761qBugee4 IBJauae.{.reu1p.roe.qxg uu 1upes;rgBuv searertrBuaqtr,(6)
l,tep s,ueu.rg
-ruolulT ssgt apeu,tlpalqnopun qcJqn'a1nps fsIrsBJaql ua,rp puq EuDt
eqt 1eql paloda.r ansq SZ6I'qlfl pn8ny aq1!ue.6a1a1,tupq4q ,{ddequ 8u.ry
aql lues peq qJuerq spunupg 'lS,ftng aql leql enssl 9Z6I 'q1tr9aunl s1.tu;
pryodar slspsagqsaug aqtlo uo&tgQuoaq1 :Nng77l7g JSD SVf gHJ 8)
'S6I s! e g erllsnf
NIff 6g padu4s sg1; launl q4,ptry
JW eroJaqJapJoaql'9g6l ',(eWqfSZparepsguopgad aql ro1rDerJu'uoqp11
acn.rg.raqdotslJqJ.irua11youoprlad aql uo 'uogsplq ,trarueq3 'gnof, qBlH
aq1ugdn puno^rse,ttpalFtrlrJstslrsedqsppg aq,I '(,$eX'acWOprottg tnqnd
eql ls ppq a.ruqe;q,n)s.radedJg Jeuralq palpn5 ssq rellrar lrrar.rnt eu.r.
'puesnoql nal usql arou uaaqaasqJaaauppor ll 1nq'szn
dr-qs.raquau1enpa eql lertrr Bep! " ou a^eq p; aao.rdol spJEJxepq eql pue
I
's.requaw
690'0Ztpeq eqseup eqf ls asnsJaqrurop ulq parrnf aasqol pIBssI
ssmre-urofun' (pslrsedqqlgg aq1,(1.rau.ro;) qslrsuJ qspFg aqlJore oelpl
eql roJ (fgfi ut) plq B apuu eacq ol pIBs sera,{e1sotr41 pls,rrso rls 'Sg6I 'BI
,irunuel.rog.radeds,naa ilatqaH uoJyaurveql ugpaqsllqndaIJpJBue FI G)
'gg a8ud'(tg6)'uopuol'$IHeoU
puu elr.lsg,(q paqqlqnd'sso.r3 u11o3,(q'Nyiltrg NI SJSI1SVI gHJ O)
uScNn
av\s|rvrcos v\oo33HJ
z8r
ueeqJaael! sBqJou uespfl
'a.Iar areql lBql peu-rEltr{1sno!.res
1esJaqueqr set ,tue .ra,raueJaaeJarIJ.'sJaqrn"qose8s.uaqag ol peJJeJarg66I
tZZ lsnftry rc1 topung uo guapuadapuT aq1'aldusxa JoJ lduee uolfEulur.re;xe
uB sE uaslagol saruirJaJer 1euolsurro spug ilps auo'Sulpuulsrnprfou1erf,L
'slqlgnbcu uealmoJpue serueluas
1oe6,{1ua4- (uaqag yo qr1;g eq1)asarg
unr{ pueJlesu.rqJauB{{ Eupnleu-r- suollntaxe ue^alaq palFsa.r 'zlpnqesng
pue uespg lB pa$Iuuoc,{1pa8a1pse$lro.quqf!,$parrJeruoJserrqtq,rr '1e!4
eql rarrreJy luuprrertrrtro3Supnpul 'sluepuagapSt q4,$ St6I'1,1 .raqualrlag
uo pauado 11',{ueu.rag 'iraqaunl lB JJE:lsueslag Jo pleq seraIsFf V (6I)
'[941 a8utl'(U6f)'uo$Ipg puoras 'xassng6uo1qft..rg
'ssan;,napr,ag pego1sy1,(qpaqsqqnd'drruua)qtaqua.4laq1lg mop a4Jl x
,-p.run8 pa.rnldece 8u1;unq neqrsq 1esreuosprd-xg,pauopdec
SI EJEH'SdhIV)
I! NOUWJN4)NO) IZVN TO NOAWaqIT gHJ ONV
SNnNgI4M:JyVgH S1ODA gHJ gAISNI,{pnrs Sg6l s,Enzqygaqoa;o
y6efleiluo s.reeddeosp (,tpua.ragp,(pqfl1s paueq) qde.doloqd euss e[.r.
'sse.r1sJpauos u1,{lsnoprqo
s! oq r prunt pepsrq ue Eqs 'ua1pgu JaaoEugpuelsselu&u! pa511an,{pua
-.reddeo^g sitaorls SS uB asnqe safuuu! nsqreq pelsJaqlrl pauopdue
qdu.foloqd y "p.run8
qtarJuatugaq1t6 nog arll
*'&ryua3 {ro,ralsluols! EI prspusfs
s5t1q 4nfl 'U'V ,tq ua,rp sJ slrlf Jo alduuxa 8u.q-r.r1s ,(pu1nc;gud V (BI)
'En0g/z.loagwalgerso prorru r[qnd
uI punoJ aq uue goda.r a8edaa.rq1s;q,L'8tZ['9 pafep s! pueJtrasu.rqelqqsuoJ
gaq3 aq|,{q pad;s sI stqt'861 ugurugAoN 9NftIr70 I'I4H sDNuEgw
JSIJSVT-NNV ANV JSDSVI f,O JUOJW H)NVAq TM)qJS (LD
'psror)
GI)
'erlgo auo11 '1,g, qgEtZ/Wl
Nnf rIfSZpedue1s s! 14'591.,6ELZ0S"HI
'saqtluJtozanaas
OH u! punoJ aq ust pu? a1gettgo proJau rllqnd s sI slql
-lJuV - uopuo7 'g u! saruoqrrust1 sauraqt'I to{
UD rycuno3 7ouo4o71(p1)
u'sealesuaqlslspsBtr
,{a1sotr41aqf
ers Eslrsul 1u}redu1aq11sup8e1q6g.rnougs.rapoddnspa1ea.6
'aup luasa.rdarp fV. :snq1'ueuraH 'V ',{feltos qs$af ,tflsra4un pJoJrO
"mo
eqlJo luaplsard eql papnb gg6l '67.raqrualdasrc! apluonD qsr^apq1 (El)
';ullossn4 rogp.rompoo8e
puq eJtlgp errreserII u'qlleJJnoJouatnlueJep1e ,{q's,tes,{1n4IUIH$IJ\rIfl
u30Nnl/roc3suj
eu\sr'lvrcos
E8T
.I6LI
a8ud'(1661)troa.nap'asno11 uopusy,,{q paqqlqntl'a1u3 spm3 .{q qrua.qg
eqf rtro{ patelsue-Il '1a.rags;o5ue.rg-ueef,(q 'uououuolu1to aty aqgu! IaraCI
3oo1
to 6tay aqt :HJntrJ WOV1 JHgI'1f, IHJI * ,'satottoua{ur.rpq1a,ruq
's{celq furg peJe orslp 1snfpeq ueu,f8.ra1o pauopuag!-Ilaras!q.f' :slueurtroa
'.ralq8nelJo sJBoJqlpr palaa.r8se,rrslqtr 'sEu.requurtrnq
1a,reg liJaqlo ,tue aqq
eJB suurulqJog eql - la8rog lou s.lql, pe{Jerua.ruorrrres e Squa,rqapuaqn
.qq;rnup taoqpuV[ ugueu.tEralc luelseford u"ur.reg V 'eloptaue Sqlroqoy
aqf sal"Iar p,rag qo5uu.14-umf* 'qtru1uo,tg tqBUtraqJ {ooq sH uI (92)
's.{u,nlsapouuro
rno q lI ol alnq!4uot olJoareql {tu1 .to ,{1;gqerlno rno Jo ssalp.re8e.r '1u sn o1
6uo1aqppoqs puu seoperue1lreqq qql'spnplAtpq pagS go:equnu IIBrtrsB
Jo sgoga aqf Jo {nsar aq1,{1.r.rerq.rda.ru-,fflo1ouqca1pue eJuelts r(pedpuFd -
uollusll!^lrJo sluaua alqrs eql ?TperJIElroSuo{ uil1uf t .-alBsl sltll GZ)
'punq
-goru ertroJeq 8uo1 suq sqf nq 'rusqDnol atuo ss { pJo^rpa.r.ra;e.rd eq1.(tZ)
'[m1uar cJlsrl JoJBJprrIu!
{Jo^r prupusfs B sBAIaruBJpadrunq-auoaq1
uo {ooq slH 'e4qsulotulT trI proJusls 1uar.rpwd e dn Supps puu puupug
o1 3uJu.m1a.r aloJaq sJIrW q pe Jas JaIBI pue 'ugpu1go lueurr.ra^o3 aql ol
lqppadg larue3palqodde senaq luogssayo.rd,(qp.r BsEAesairl'eseaT plou.ry
,In?r"il,l,ff
T;j?.lH:J;ff :;:;,!:;r:r.,[::]
"pserqsp$s"q,r"""ffi ' utsoor pelltFos ol lsnmopll
pallsFos eql Jo aJu"^eleJeql InoqB ue$Fra s! esuasuorJe$n lBq/h as![Ber
o16s,ne1'aq; aluuFrrJe$aol ldua11upaapu!p1psrzeNerll fuqt ',(pua.redde'saop
apal suldamu ol e sq lou seopeuo' [ (1p do)'91g eted.'tusyoqtog oJ axw^pv
'alea1l
,:raEuuppue alqno4 alntnJJoacJnosu qlpnSuguapJopoqlau lu.rn1eu
puB sno! qo eqf pareplsuoJsB r SIBAIJ sll ol lualuaauotuls?!nIB !,uns asoqra
.{;;.rou1u IBlJer E Jo uo$"ulrrrJe1xeeql serup luaIJuB trI 'etlpErd aapgu.uil
ol uolsJeaa.re ,tldurs ta,ranoq 'sen 11'spqu poz[! p o1 6q,$.u.roq suaas
.rtrelqordrlslnaf eql Jo uo$nlos IBuId6s.JalflHrl"ql ue$,r.I/n sBqel8ea(Iz)
'[(11edo) 'yg aBeil'&ryua3qtal]uanllaW '4ngl '
tO toop dootdse
punoJupa,reLr,tlyuuorsetro sarreJsqtns pug ilp$ no,{,(upo1uela pus 'suopeu
-g.rage yopotd epuetedo.rdsseu'a,lpeaga aql paln1ssuoes.{e,npsuq qolqir
uaqag 'a,raqaq1's911,, luql ueilFrassqzln{ JnqUVuErJolsIHtsluo1q,rqg(67)
u30Nnv!oc33HJ
el/\|srlvrcos
vgr
'pa,(oldEermlou s.eH'slreafual q s,(Ep
,,'ela.qsFBElerol aql s.aq
ual pa{ro r ttluo seq uulrueqeg auo,, us8aq qJlqlt' propuols Snuaag uopuorl
ew u.r ecgo ls!.rnotr surrruqe{ eql ,(q pacqd su,nluauas$Je,rpe aEed 1n;
e'1661'6 .raquacaquO 'seruuquflaql sI aslpe.rudpusls! qtns pJIrIl v Og)
'rteme:parq
o11ou.{pu.ruleqa.re o palo^ Bpnur.raggo aldoadeILf,'ulsl.ug uo.g acuapuad
-epu! JoJldo ot spnrrrJefl pa^ro[u a uq plno,rt qtlqa unpuereJeJ BJo eaeeql
uo se,nlroda.r s$11,'S66I'91 lsnEny '.roqpe aql,tq pmaq goda.r oJpsg O)
'(1;c do) '9-1,1,1sa8ed'aatg aqrlo aSopuog'ueBgals(Sg)
\L6tl'.r
paqqlqnd,tlpup;.ro sam,tessaeql:Z-I9Z sa8eduo.r; uilIBl sI alonb qry'(1p
do) (uonag arloA aqJ 'pueg u! ttlopaargpuo n&ung tessa aql uo-1E(yg)
lo
'(pHD'1 atud'utslcot slooy (gg)
to
.1aEut[,(33et)
'uopuol 'suopulag ersg 'uslcot p stooy
Jo elq.rpul aql ,(q paqslpnd @E)
;1spa .ra8uolou,{aq1a allaqol a/treJs
p,t'sc;.ra6,{q olul {,rl,slr2.l-!luerslroJql ,(epo; s.rnopo1ultuJJo uopuau,tuy
't9-S6 sa8ud'(4691)'uopuol'uanqla14i
,{qpaqqlqnd 'g'J'X 'uqsuqo1"11,tr.ru11.4g.{q 'IZgghItrZ gHJ gO
HJSON
g)NgN-If,NI HSUNq YqONN S7NOJNYTT gHJ TO NOUYOJ Y gO
JN1OJJV 1WOS glg9 OJ JJW4JJV IW :oc1{y 7o4ua2qsgygl n'uertro,n
u! ueql ueu uI .ra8uo.r1s,(ppgarsl Jnopo eql'uH qlla rtrooJpesolJB u-r
rr.rBrtral
o1a1q;ssoduJ q31uplr 1; Eugapuar'aa.fap Sqleddu uu ol aalsuago
saullauos sg1; o.6aupeqlop eql ul-'uog.rsoduocug,{1go aroru pue Japu.ruru
lueJeglp B Jo aq ol aru of .reedduppon qrFI.$ lnq '1Bansq1.rr pepunoJuoJ
fB
uego uoneJrasB sauql epnxaqc;qn'q;d-u.ru aql rapun spuep eqf W rr
papeuuoJaq o1.ruaddeplnoar laus o.r8aue^.rsuaJJo fsoru aq.r.'suuado.rngug
ueql .rafue1,tpplrar a.resa.rodaql pue',(1aa.g pue,fusuaa.r.rdsad[sao.6ap],
1uql aloJ^rtrolsuqof ,ftleg JlS JotsJlslulupu FIuoIor eq; ',ftquer aql Jo
IIJn1arll aloJaq,(ploqsue$F r Brl{V pailorfuot-qslllJg Inoqe{ooq u q (1g)
'pallut eq of ^rouare,taql se'4nu1 rO (0)
'Olql) '0S-6tI saBed.'uogo4gaz) snsraAragtlapual (69)
' (plqD' 7y1eBeil'uopmlpn3 snsraArg tlapua; (gg)
'gy1 aEed '(n11)'up.ro;ge3 'sala8ug so1 'ssan; eppuooNeql
,{q paqs;1qnd'O'qd'Ilapued reutfl fq' NOI;UZITil) SnSVgtl XSS (LZ)
HfoNnuIoctS3ul
awsFtvtcos
s8r
'ua{sl aq pFoqs lqod eql nq
6snoprqnlus anornaraq/rmuosol aaortrof lrala 1a,n,(eu,irago1 a1e1s aql sq,rroqa
o.6atr1E :iueq {Jora lB srofceJrltuouore-opos ,(ueu e.rea.raql,{lsnoprqo (0S)
'(plql)' gg7 eBeil,'aatgaq1 aSopuog'uaEgefs(6?)
lg
'(1;r do) '1-91,1saEed'aaq aq1lg aSopuog'wilgats (B?)
' afled' 3
71 ?66T'ZZlcqoltg saug aql u1peqsqqnd
',(a1ryuug fq'uautuoc 3u1pon! atncpyo4oc n!!o spnpallau! wt!4V (w)
lBql p.rBs
peq a lleAresuot eilq,lr s 3.r,(qqol Jsllal.lllrre,,eqryouol;cseJaql auFanl $p)
'sa ale.radsap su Inq '(ado.rng
lI JlaqlJo JaaJuI saa8ngar
q sallq r-uougo.$po[uu Supulaq,nralo aq1se) s1uu.r6;ru Jlrtrouoras" lou pag
puq,{aq1qe1q,nuoq,f.rlunot e ol {rsq paddqs puu saqJeoroluo pa,roqspnf
'staqutot1t suS lnoqe ser:a1s,(q ou'a.raq s1salo.rdanfer1 IZBNIIEV oN'{tgq luas
ptrB saqtuoJoluo pepaoJe,{1p.ra111 alan,tery'9651 lsn8ny u! arlBZJo fuetn
-rualo8 aq1,{q suupuuragJo uo.rlq.qedar aqf sE r $prf tJuo4 JergotrV (St)
. ..ot1to21 s
t o (W)
V661,EZfpr l llDu S
'arn|nJ alqsinseroJeql JoJ lou lssel
'uadduq lou 'asuesuourluepsJe-opnasd;oJarmertr pue
1e m,rrll os 1e tro,n
aeglod.re,roc.rapun 'suolsnc tupnpul 'unop u.ro1aq ppo,r{ sa.qdue lol e
Jo
'uaddeq ol ara,lrsIrpJI'lq8lrrJaao suospd eqt f,ldwe fgeng;,rppo,n sJrys8n rp
p.ruqSuJpnlruJ6sEn.rp aqpEal of aq p1nor aur.rrtu! sslq rluqfe pasoddns;o
ualqo.rd aq1ap1e4o1r(enlsaq aql os 'pa1u1a.r-Bn.rp q auln {rEIq Jofol V (gt)
'Sqpdde q eulrr lualo$ {tBIq uo rpqq,(lugegac
'a;annrce,(1quqo.rd q 11la.req/ruaqueuar luea 1q8noql oo11m..rd u-rlI uease Bq
l'pooH aqJ 71ztog w1gS aqt q treamsaql uo paqsegsE r rgsll"fs s$trtr(Zt)
'suos8arJo
JatrrrurtrIIBToJpeJnpuJnuertr1nqpalgoldxa,tpo 1ouare seurFoqrns ,lroqo;u!
1q6;sqegunp,te sa,rlFqegqn'ncuauVq samog auy) apg:i.IO/LlgNAV)
palpe,{pn1s enbgn u paqqlqnd ssq xorM\ pJ.r"rl rluepsru usrrrertrVeql
'(uaaag.raldeqJ ol gI alou aas)'aldwuxa .ro;
te8Enq lIqoUJo reprnu aqf, (It)
'lglla?;eil'966y
4muDu4v sla4oiltt/t/l'J'000'AS'I yo uopelndod 1elot e peq 't66t ul (01)
lI
'91 aEed'(tOOl)'uopuol'a1qe1suo3 paqsqqnd'ue11l A
dmqa [q't1ot7 ul utsuoaa! lo asn 4oc1t1pod aqJ :SVgJSVWJgJdnd (6;E)
'eraqlraEapuE selqs
pal;ug aq1'u1q;lg ug1qfti JUJf sl1euolfeua1;q,n aq1,tqpapdun.rl qrn4 (g)
av\ls
t']vtcosutoNnyIoc3SHl
98r
'88 afud '(CgeD'uopuol's{oofl uor1,(qpa
-qqlqnd tarlo1-ro^a.trI'U'9,(q uo;pnpo.r1u1'sualals'H'U1auo1o3,{q uuu.rag
aql uo{ pelulsue.Il'pnouag qo5uu.rgf,q palfpg \26y Tudy-ttoruqal ssau
-nroe uuDurog-raqlH aqt U7TJIH I'IOCM IO JNgh[VJSgJ gHJ Q9)
'(plqD '61aBed'n7o3 a{Z UBppolS (I9)
{g ap173uts1g
'(plqD 'g77a8eilJto7o3 apllSutsty a{/'przppofs (09)
tg
:rBl\ plrolll lsrld eql Jo {"arqfno aq1arogaq'y161
aunf u.rspJorl asaqf alo.r,n,tqenpu Joqlnu aq; 'p.rora.ratp Jod ir a8ed '(OZ6t)
ruopuol '11eHpus uuuduq3 ,{q paqqlqnd 6p.reppolgdo.rqlo1 tq'7')VW
-strdns-oTtro/tt sJIILTIJ sNMe v vo 7oJ t o s aLLot""
gjo g?]o
Suplgdslulod ou aasI os 1utguap!a.resapoloap!asaqlaldoadpou ro.{ (8S)
'salsls palgn aqf q se.rt[od uopru a,r4uurgyry(,9)
'(qsgod ul) uop;pee nrd auo;sue1
'saSun8uq,{uuu
1e- Jeqsllqndaq1,{q,(leuos.radpauroJu! se,nI - EuJpnpul
u! suoplpe snoJarrmuq8no.rql ueeqsertrfI 'punog puv tso'J uollqry 45 ap$ eqf
.rapun^Cpualsuu.q paqsllqnd oqu sel'rplO tiloay uonflW45 p16,'p.rora.raq1
rod 'suo.qIpere3ul Eo.r; pelalap sua alonb qq1 lla1qduud pgotutu! Arouslql Jo
Eupu.ud961 e mo.ry4onb s1q15ur-rp1 u" I '[1uuFFo ul ploff] ,,'uottdunsatdsttl
atuallsol 4lhlqzsnvpuo notlcnqlo a4tadsaq1pasnt lsqDuosruaulutotduoyat o
'saqcaads tpoa sy$o auout utDtlrgolu! uorlo8tuuttpatno4ot tqpasoduaBuopaql
ot uonuagoilorp naAoJ ttioug ua2l4-'se8v a1ppg{ eql u! sB r uogutruup pIrE
erUIIeqJolea.rrgaqf sc reqler jaeelndodaqfJospseqaql re o papleg q lI 'Jlesll
ersg aql Jo lua! rns aqf sueleaJql 1; 1nq 6ap!.rdleuolluu pue pooquopuu Jo
aldpuFd eql eulurapun o1pasn,{1uofou s! uolmp xIS eql-'r salF,npoorLreH
u6 (99)
'Jstruv HJnvJ gHJ i gla ITTvgu N)IZTIw ns oKI to za8ed
'816I ol atsp (sgoda.rslpau o1)lalqdued eql uI saJuereJerJo
fI raqumu
u fnq petspun s! uop"r.rlqnd qry '9 'ON JgTHdhMJ J4DOJ UtNOh
JSITilDOS - STOVJNO) NOIJW9IWWI JSNIV9V uSVJ gHJ GS)
' (plqD' afled.'uto1ugtot tog nop) o1g'raloqog (pg)
9
'91 a8ed'(SSet)'uopuol'ulsflJg lsarC
Jo,{1ruafsl
-ununnoJ aq1,tqpaqqlqnd'.raloslogd;gq6,tq'u1r7ugto! tog no7o3 o71(gg)
'rfre.rncreelq?uoseiu qf;.tr en4
sploqpueueppuu,{1ddnsloareleql lnq'dgqsuo.rlula.rpag.radu 1ouq sFlL (Zg)
'1gga8ed'aatgaql aSopuog'uaflgals(Ig)
1;cdo) to
H30Nn
awsnvrcos wooS]uJ
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
(63) Hitler, Tbstarnent,page 62, (ibid). I should point out here that since
completing the penultimate draft of this book I havefound a claim that these
quotesare - or rather the sourcefrom which they are taken is 'fraudulenl In
the 1991editi onofHITLER'S WAR(pageE)' DavirlIlvingreports that'Martin
Bormann'sallegednoteson Hitler's final bunker conversations'publishedby
Albrecht Knaus Verlag in German as Hitlers PolitischesTbstament:Die Bor-
rnannDildate (Hamburg,1981)are in my view quite spurious: a copy of the
partlyflped, partlyhandrvrittendocumentis in mypossession,andthis leaves
no doubt.'
As hving is not the sort of person to say anything detrimental about the
Fiihrer without good reason, this may well be true, but an examination of
Hitler's record makesit clear that hewasno more bigoted,and probably less
sorttant[e averagewhiteman ofhis era.Hedoesmakeanumberofrostensiblyt
anti-black remarks tn Mein fu^pf, but it is notable that when the American
athleteJesseOwensretumed to the United Stateshe reported (contrary to the
myth of Hitlet's snubbing of him) that he had beentneatedwell by both the
Germanpeopleand Adolf Hitler.Ironically' the leadingblacknewspaperthe
ChicagoDefenderreported (in its August29,l936 issue)that Owens'parents
had beenTim Crowed"when they had goneto meettheir son at the Hotel New
Yorker.Orvenshimself nas said to haveclaimed that Germanywasn't the only
placewhere race prcjudice was rampant.
(64)Apart from his nonsenseabout the JewishQuestion,ofcourse!
(65) WHITE POWER, by GeorgeLincoln Rockwell,pages2912. This quote
is takenfrom the SecondEdition, whichis datedSeptember,1977.No publish'
ing details are given,but the book is still in print and can be obtainedthrough
a n 'mber of far right distributors.
(66) Often referred to as whites and blacks or evenin the United States by
the sick euphemismof whitesand "peopleof color".
(67) The black economistlhomas Sowellhasuritten that "It is...acommon
pattem among immig'aa$ to eventually overtake native-born people of the
sameancestry.nThere can be all manner of reasonswhy foreign-bom Koreans
succeedin business morc rradily than native'born blacks; they might' for
example,havebeenprosperous in their own country.
(68) LIBYA: Ga.dhafrHurnan Nghts Award Given Tb the FightAgainstAIDS
in Africa, by Marcel Fakhry,pubtished in SpareNb July 1992' pages46'7.
187
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
188
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
189
UNDER
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
190
r6T
Jlesr.rq {sB plnoqs JepBeJaql Eopsanbeql - seuoerlEzlq auos ss llea sB- s^{r!
rplues-ptrB auos sploq uBq{8ilBJ lsql andslp luauoE euoroJl.uop I (g0I)
'@ret
'uopuol 's1dlrrsnuetr41
lsnfuV) $eIoJqI ,{q paqsglqnd .uo.reg ropEBxaIV
Aq.nual p ang raWO aqJ lo anbguc o qtry 11111 toy a1oya1 ,1t$17qaoas,, b
ttolg pasltluosu1'aru1aqJ:S4NOW4W OOO9 4AVH OJ JHgnO SVW.I
ol erusfsu! fsJg aql q pailaJeJ s! JapseJary .areqSupueumropou spinu acBJ
slqJo uopntas.radc.no1s1q eql JoJalqgsuodsa.rsploq eq,{1aposeql roJ,nef Jo
ad,ttulepac BJo peqeq leuolllpuortm aq1',t1sno;.mr os lou aq,(euJO G6I)
'sqlmp
915,ira,raroJ sq1.rg969,t1uoare r areql,tueu.rag q Vl,6l ul lutp pryoda.r
UeqEIIEJ q,nr1 .(q ssudq applns pmoqv plro/1 aIWU turoqssatt8lg tlurg
'arusgly ,pmt8w111ouolto1g
lBuolf"N (rngas-$ue) aq1,(qpaqqlqnd sgqer-qn
Jo enss!096I,(1nf aql q peqs[qnd se,nup,l s$g q app.ru 6up{g.r.r.roq v O0I)
'a,qpads.rad
lelre.r e uloq usqf JeqlBJ
rrupsFqJ Euo{I uailIrn sl c;ua1oduo;ryoqu-pusslqf, 1g1aEed.ft,g6l) .slu?H
'arlols8ugsug u.ua:1r;; peqsgqnd 6a1r-qr6 pru6eetr41 tq ^q,NOIJ
1eqs.retr4i,(q
-VOqVNOW HJNAI 4I-IJ :S'NIT'IDI JNTTIS NOITTIW O/UJ GOI)
.Jeqrless
rrrD1.reuyuB s? u4q ol parraJar611e8ud 'Sq6l'L.raque1da5 ro1 allluorqC
qstuualaqlroferres eqt pilIre$s osls srapq puu s1o61q se sal;q,n(qryra1-uou)
snolrsuot-eoe.rIIB aJunouep.ra,raro;oqn,t1.rJotr.ru etnosa.rp'aruesaqf t(Iqep;p
-erd'(036I) 'eF.roe9 tnp e( "11Sn ssard,trellrg IE .rrolslH,(q poqsqqnd
sun'(pq6go arp uo{ parnpo.rda.roloqd) uoJssardu;puoeasaq1!1u.udu.rnps
,(1un1cus! {ooq stql'NOLLWZITWDNON VO NOnWVdgS - 4JIOH)
ynOI nmL {ooq Eq ot g)Vggyd aqf q oqlrg g eropoaqf ropuas (tgl)
'(gc do) 699a8ud,Lg6T,6I.raqualdag.Tstrutouocg (gg1)
'(11cdo) 6711aBed'qtrul utotg lrt8ill aqt
leaqt (zor)
'uoprn.qsep
sserrrJo spoqpu aql ertroJaqalqFraf puu tuelrge eJour eql puu .sarua,rpe
,{Eolouqrala.rotnaql ertroJaqa^rpasgp.n erou arll luqt s! uollesllprpgo xopaned
1re.6eql loof se!4unor e11qnugpauadduqesrnorJoeaeqsrouoq qrns (I0I)
'srorloq usJ!{Iv
Jo [I"-pue
pue lls-aq eqf rtro{ reJ are eseqf puv'seleqepN 669'9arau s peIJ.DIaqu8nq
1.reqog'6an1uoc,(g ?snsrolog e alpb ss rleqf .uoglgu gI Inoqs sanzpueig
go uogepdod aq11uq1EulrapgsuoS'a.rngudep s.ugrw Bu.ulollogs.rea,(aarql
ansr]vrcosH30Nnhroo3Sul
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
192
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDEH
(122) lt may be argued that Shaw was simply visiting but on page 119
Hollander commentsthat for somepilgrins, eyenprolongedresidencein the
SovietUnion madelittle difference.
(123)Hollander,Political Pilgrirns,page 146,(op cit).
(nq b his 1991bookThe Flight From Tiuth' Jean-FrangoisRevel (already
cited) reports that 60,000peoplewere shot in the first three months after the
conquestof SouthVietnam by Hanoi; 20,000moneweneexecutedshortly after;
300,000died during the next few years on accountof the concenhation camPs
etc; yet Westem journalists and photographers scw none of this, nor of
rteducation camps.
I offer also tle following anecdotefrom personal experience.At the time of
the Sovietinvasion of Afghanistan I was living in Leeds,a city thatwas then a
hotbed of extrenist activity, (mostly of the far left but also of the far righO.
One day in the city centre I cameacross somecommunists sellingtbe Moming
At this time the entire Westernmedia seemedto befocusedon Afghanistan
^Star.
andnothing else.SoI askedthis communisthowhecouldpossiblydefendsuch
an outrageous act, which seemedlikely, in my misguideil opinion, to trigger
WorldWar III. He replieil that the Sovietshad not invadedAfghanistan'they
had beeninvited in!
(r2S) THE NEWUNHAPPYLORDS:AN EXPOSUREOF POItrERPOU-
T/CS, byA.K. Chesterton,published by Candour Publishing' London, (July
1965),page23.
(12O Fendetl,SacVenus Civilization,pages149'50,(op cit).
(127)The Australian-bom anti-Nazi propagandist SeftonDelmer stated this
in the tirst volume of his autobiography Tiail Sinister,lpublished by Secker&
Warburg,London, (1961)1.Delmer said he believedthe Reichstaglire wasthe
work of a lone individual, nthelunatic van der Lubbe",and that both the Nazis
and the communists exploited it for their own ends.Although Van der Lubbe
wasindeeda communisthe was not aligpetlwith Moscow.
(12E)I am not trying here to excuseHitler's anti-Jewish policy, but a pro-
tracted study of the"IewishChronicle for the Nazi era yields somesurprising
rcsults.I have summarisedthesein my 195 bookHOLOCAUST DENIAL:
NEWNAZI LIE or NEIA INQWSITION?, (seein particular pageslTQ?).
(129)T\elewish Chroniclefor October25' 1935'page18reported in an article
Five Yearsfor Blaclonailinga few rthat an ex-Stormtooper in Casselhad been
sentencedto sucha term for demandingmoneyfrom a Jewwho'dhad relations
193
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
194
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
195
SOCIALISM?
UNDER
FREEDOM
t96
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
r97
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
ChapterThirteen:TheFightfuainst
Socialism,NationalSuicideAnd
Racial Death:TheWayForward
(1) Anti-miscegenation laws were struck down as unconstitutional only in
1967;miscegenationremains a social taboo: not only on the white side and not
only betweenwhites and non-whites.
198
66r
Jo raded$mu,(1q1uou aq1\s11ouo1troN Llsltugp ansq S66I fpf aqf u1pagod
-eJ surf,slsrDosoJelaq3u1pn1cxaspnxesouoq go elduuxa luesal eJortry
'ueql slps lI ueq^rsa{asueql epulrtrLrtslp of SqnpInrag.rad
a.reslunxasouoq'uopuulu-rrtslp pue olqoqdoutoq lnoqe 8uJu1q,tpue 8q11e,n
rleql IJBroJ lsrg ue{q aqppoqs lugodaq1lnq 'uaasaq of su.ruruersapaaqEunp
uErrmqaseqfs" - sq1uq,(1pleadsa - sa.rllualrl?artresaql esnol luB,nplnoa eJ"J
^{ue;ouos.rad,(q1paq ,{uufqlq ',,slunxasouoqlog,{1uos! qpq aq11eq11qft.4no
epls IF$JaIqs"Jaql [sasecauos u! pus] -'sesgra.rdaql aleal ol raq Jo UFI{s?
,t1du1s,{uu luarne8uueu Jo rulq eiJes o1asnya.r,{euJapuaueqaql'-a8euo.rled
,(ueuo.q pa8u.rnorslp,(lprgeualsfs aJu slunxesoJafaq 'auoJ1a,nun,{popp
'slenxasoruoqgo luawfofue alg JoJflssa.rdxa-'palu.rado pus pelr,troeru sqluq
,tu8pue s.rogud31dds.ruq,teg,, 'ilayuno)
;eq1 spJotar qdleg ue1g61 pre,npg
-ug lottx"soutoH )llqnJ :tyuruuruoS ruaIS aqJ qde.'?ouou g16l slq uI (6)
'uarnaolleJ.rgaq1,(q paqdsap,tpado
eq 11!$'uogsraLrad pue ,{oe.raue8ap 'pa.r1eq;oseqdosogqdalu6udo.rdoqrr Jo
rno.r Bqaqleltos-lluu q a8e8uaoq,naldoad 1eq1aEpaproq aql :lls Jo lulu4s
-uor 6a8Egqaq1 sdeq.radpue 'slqerlsuor 1e8a1 reqlo aq ppo,$ alary (g)
'(691 a8ud'sq1.rauggqqug
'op urernJo1soltr
JaIIJ ar$ uo {rsllu p;aeu.r8s.rpeqf of eruareJeraql osp aas)
',{11uappra'su - f,lga1sodrog uogsra,r:ad.r;aq; al"raserdof qsl,lr ,taql ;1 llnJJeJ
of e uq,(aq1paa.rqlouueJ slBnxesouoqasnuteqlBql pIEs uaeq sBqlI (,)
'stslcotellq^-gue pue elma{-uouSulpnpq (9)
;a.rlspdar,tpJu1ls.Ipuertr Buo{ a{uqspueq e uurgelsuolpegu a.rouEqq1{uu
pug I ?uulsrapun uec 16ulq1aruossI slql 'uegqsal-uouu su 6u;lpad5 $)
'dno.6 plee.r u,(g.russeJeu lotr'qu8y (y)
'epua8e uBIJBlIIslol .re1ne;gud.r-raql sasoddo oq,nauo,tuu'aI (g)
'uogggep fqpassatddo
eq lsnu g uopepdod :pe1q o/o001 e seq ,ir;unoc s J! leqf sa;1du; fI esnureq
pJnsq" as.r,t.ilH eJe tuo$oq eql uo s{Jelq eql aaeitl ,{1qe1;,rau1 puu s,{en1u
uogeta.fasgo sua1s,{spalJoJua,(lsno.ro8p qtns lBItrlsulelt aql's{mlq qlpr
elulJosseoXpa11pr'.rad lou aru selgltauollpgep fq uaql sellq r q1!^ elelJosse
ol pag;u.radlou aJus{t"lqJ! aruls 'dno.r6,(uuJoslq8g aqfJo uogulo!^JoUos
.tuealnlgsuor - p;aqgudy 8ulpnpu1 - uope8a.rEas .rousrauluolleuatarqu'pue
Jeqllau la,ranoq ,{l-rleeJuI 'etunouep ol lJlt{s sr(u,qe q ,(qqo1"tslcoJ'llrte,
aq1'uo11eEa.6as qtprt su 'qagq,neuo pue luamnfuu uoturtroJe s1qq1 (7)
l/IocSSHl
u3GNn
av\snvrcos
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
the British National Pa"ty; a public house in Liverpool was said to cater
exclusivelyfor honosexualslnormal peoplewereturned awayat the doon
(10) The AIDS industry is a tlinly disguisedfront for the organisedhomo-
sexualmovemenl krhaps the most insidious of thesefront organisationsis
the TbrrenceHigins Tbust. Ostensi.blyan AIDS charity, it is staffed largely by
militant homos and screaming queens,its educational literature is blatant,
pro-homosexualpropaganda,factually inaccurate and often obscene.
(11) The reader is rcferred to Chapter Nine, note 24 and,the technique of
bringrng about necessarychangeby first creating the problem then stepping
fonvard with the solution.
(12) This is perhaps the dirtiest trick of all, and is one favoured by the
anti-porn industry. Britain's leading Libertarian Chris Thme once said that
when they start talking about protecting your children what they are really
talking about is destroying your rights.
(13) ThomasJeffersonrletter to W.S.Smith, November13r1787,from page
IEZ of ifueBLOOMSBURYDICTIONARY OF QUOTATIONS,published by
BloomsburyLondon, (1987).
(14)Like nost membersof the SWI Tomwashighly educatedaswell as highly
intelligent and had completerlhis MA.
(15) Tomsufferedfrom a very rare illness which cameon suddenlyin mid-life.
A mutual friend told me that the doctors had usedhim as a guineapig to some
extent (they had no choice), so no one knew what would be the eventual
outcone. His death was as suddenas it was tragic.
NotesToBibliography
(1) The British Library Retrospective Catalogue contains six entries for
various editions of lenin's collectedworks including what appears to be a
completeset of his unabridgednritings in 46 volumes.This was publishedby
Martin Lawrence in 1927 and 1930;tlere two translations of Volume 13. I
believethe frrst tranche - which comprisesYolumes1 to 23 - is incomplete,but
I admit freelythat I did not, and haveno intention of, wading througb thewhole
lot.
200
r0z
'w6tpstw qqqq {apm6
s.npsarBs"q g !9761puu6til uea$feqpaqsgqndsu"negpaedop,trua
sFLI)
0,$fo33HJ
ansnv|eos:H3N
FREEDOM
UNDER
SOCIALISM?
AuthortsIndex
Like its compiler, this index is woefully inadequate,but it should be suffcient
for most rcaders. A number of authors havebeenindexed togetherwith their
books,althongh in somecasesthe booksalonehavebeenindexed.For a fuller
listing of authors and books,thereaderis refemedto the bibliographyon pages
140-9.
Abortion, 1l5,l48rt9l
Abzug,Robert, authorInside The WciousHeart...r1,40rl82
Affirmative action, t3 4, 1.86
Afghanistan,193
Africa, 18,35, 95,100-1,105,107,LIO-L,128,L42-5,t52, 155,160,164,
LE3-4,187
Africans,35rLllAr160
Afro-Americans, 108
Agriculture, 63,98, 173
ArDS, 20,22, 35,10E,136,140,142-3,155,164,187-8,200
Ali, Thriq,5,151
Allen, Gary conspiracytheorist and author, 52,140,L52,192rL96
Allies,80,E4,L2Lrl23
Altruism,138-9
America\American\Americans - throughout
AmericanCivilLiberties Union ( CLUI-,?2
American Civil IVar. 159
ArnericanHebrewnewspaper,140,159,I8l, 192
American Liberty kague, 179
American Relief Administration. 56
American Socialist Party,59
Anin, Presidentldi, 114,190-1
ANAL (Anti Nazi I*ague), 127-8, 185,197
ANC,111
Anglo-Saxon , L03-4,10E-9,115,188
202
g0z
97I' ETI'311'ue.rlquoqlnv
ETI'Irl5egpny
z 6 l ' 9 9 TM' ' 0L'u1p.4sny
s6r'98r'z8T'lil-' 9e-' Ecr'0r'96'zlprqtsnv
96I.'z8l' Ecr' E6'19'sappo-qy
561',{uouo.4sg
ISI'S?I
gg',t8o1o.t1sg
'slBltosv
t6I
gg1'Lg1''66'1"Z 'suugsy
'(qlleag pue Suploug uo uopey) g5g
ZgT'lI
gLI' 69'upqc p4rurnrednsY11SV
I71'sqEJV
, tlqury
86r'Ofl'8r'qerv
'91'p.taqgedy
661'T11'
'89'8up1ous-Puy
9gI
06I'gtl'p11',fta,re15'Puy
'us.q;ua5-11uy
'8fr 'rgr '0ll'8-gzr'60r's0r'v6'7'06'68'6-8r
v6T'z6T
utspoJ Jepuine6s-,,tslloJ-lluy,,\,,tzls1l2-guy,,
669'u.tod-puy
TVNV rapun aas- an6ea-1IzeNPrV
L6l' E6I"'8-Lzl' Tcl'-rzeN'!luv
'slslcssJ-lfuv
6I
z81-'6Lr' ffil' E'75'97'1s10se;';xuy
g71'8uuq1q-nuy
7g'uogeuguFrslp-$uv
ggT'gZ'ls.runurnoc-11uy
6uqunmruoJ-lfuy
19
gp lqp1;ilec-puy
0Zlr;qqteg-lluy
Lgr'9Tr' LU' Zll'Z? tcelq-puv
9ZI'uEsV-$uV
'SII 'uog.roqe-puy
16I
f 9T'6L' 6Z' 9I'uuluouguY
96',trlo1odoq1ug
'ssnlqesuy
961-'ETT
u30Nnv{ooSlHl
eylsrlvrcos
FREEDOM UNDER SOCIALISM?
Authoritarianism' 118
Axelrod,52
Bahamas,184
Bankers, 44r52,58
Banking,123,159
Banknotes,49
Banks,13,411107,118
Bantu,97
BBC,111
Beackon,Derel 198
Beethoven,30
Belsen,lB-s, 1234, 145,169,182'3,195'6
Benn,Nigel' 112
Bermuda,99,100' 184
1lit' 138,155
Bigotryn9L, 96.,!7,
Bilbo,141,191
Birdwoo{ Lady' 196
Birmingham Six,25' 158
Birthrate, 110,114
hirt, 91,t26, t{l, Ln
Blacles
Blair,Tony,44rE2r167
Bleackley,Horace, atthor Life of lohn Wkes, I41, 159
BNP - seeunder British National Party
Board of Deputiesof British Jews,92,L95,197
Boasschool'95
Bochimans,183
Bolshevih4,72,32,50'2,90,105,128,147,L68,171
Bolsheviki'139
Bolsheviks,2, 504156,63,65' 90
Bolshevism,17,50-tr 116,168
BondageOf TheFree,98,L47,156,1844
Bourgeois,15,28, 47,5L,79,lffi
Bourgeoisie,24, 53,L66
BoyzNtheHoodrlSS
Boxing, LL, 21,72-4, 91, 141,177, 189
Branson,Richard,10r43
204
902
z6r'ggr'6LT'6w'wr' olr' gg'Lz'errl\J
9'allqJ
6Lt'SVl'ap&ua44t13
6uopelsaq3
96r' E6l'Tvr' L-gcr'oe[ "x'y
ts's{aqJ
p151q1.req3
'6'9EFeqf,
ooz'vLt.
'p!,ru('panese3
t6f
v L1.'v;l'lzr'sg'fg'gE' Ll'dgqs.rosua3
'gg'sapprqala3
88I
gg1'se;1oq1e3
g41rwsp11oq1e3
r9l's'z 'o.r1se3
8L'69'7r'Irye3
ZSI' 1l'rrarpug'apau.re3
ggl'rrr' 6L' 6s' Eg'E'w'ygl'slsqegde3
I Ll' g-sgl' 0gr' vtr' 6Tr
'
tnl' yl L' L-gg'vg' 6s' L-gs'vs' lv' 0F 6E'zE-6z' 6l' gl'4'uq1e1.rdu3
saqzu8ernJnopuo7
961
I-09I'09luoep'qeqduu3
gg'e1poquu3
6-rgl'uotr tlampp3
slslrs"dJo uolun qs$Irg raprm eas- dlfg
0s'spssrug
961r;aun.rg
'u,no.rg
97'pg'tltpaa
,qsfo{, Jepunaas- p! EO'uplsuo.rg
IBI'69I',t1apog Eqqqlqn; suofFg
961'l9l' 97;'16'slspseg ;o uolulf qsplrg
002'g6r'6gr'r8r' gLl' g9l' vq.l'6cr' Elr' L6',tgu6puo;p1r,1 qs$Fg
t?'sBc rtrsllFg
'(dg.ro s$Irsed qsp;.r{)
IBI'S?I'11W'I-06 ltspsed qslllrfl
S'&red lsFmuuo3 qslfFg
B-Lgl'WI|8u{aug
,9I'p1uo{I hauqzarg
g6y'uu1-aq1-uo-nurmeJg
H30Nn
ewsnvrcos t/rool3ul
SOCIALISM?
UNDER
FREEDOM
Chinatown,10L
Chinese,85,Y7,101,105'110'155
Chirimuuta, Richard and Rosalind,
authorsI,IDE Afica And Racism,!42, L64
Christian, !13, 14S-6' 1554, L9l'2
Christianity, 90, 130
Christians,11,154
Churchill, Winston, 119,123'169
Clarrcndon,154
Clinton adminishati on, t37
cND 89
Collectivisation,86
Collectivism ,40r97
Collectivist,47,84,gfJ'125,l:29
Collins,Andreq 162
Colonialism,94{' 101'108
Commonwealth,125
Communism,3-4, 26, 4L,46,50,54-6,79, 81,84,tl6, 123,129,145'6,
150-1,155-7,161,168-9,172-3,t92
Communist,2, 5, 19,20,25,27,35, 41,50,56,60, 62'3,74, 79' E0'83, 92,
g6-7, 102,L1-l,t20, 122,128,l4l, 145-6, 150,t56-7, 170, L8,l,186,193
Communists,3, 5, 23,25,34, 41,4E,52'3, 56'7,61,63,89,96,120'L,143,
146,150,l:67,\7 A, 192-3,tm
Conspiracy,25, 52,70, 88,90,96,104,L07,L09,126'140,142'3,148,tn'
175-6,188,192,196
Coventry,121
Crime, 51,100,107,ll2, L43,148'172,185
Crimea,lM,t54
CryingWolf,l48,l85
Crypto-Jews,1116
Cuba,144,t70rl92
Cuckson,Don' 83
Currie, Edwina,87
Dachau,93,103,110-1,Ull' 182,\E6
Daily Worker(seealsoMoming Star),56,83,L79
Dallas,L41,179
206
Ljz
L6T'E'rgl''0sr'str' Tvr'v;t-'grr' grl't'rll'16-68's9'8t'6'91 lqrseg
r-o8r'tfl'osr
'
Lvl' 6' LEI'6Tl' srr' zz' 6Tr'L' grl' v 0r' z6'68'99'99'8' LT'7'uspseg
6911'qno1'ueqlerrug
Z6l' t61.
9II'u?IqBJ
E-Zgl'EVI' 0l1''W'79'suu11 teuas,(g
t1,'suopel.rilo.rtlxg
19
segsuueqlng
V6l'ZTl
'scJuaEng
SZI'0T1-
6g1-'ZT1,'sFrqJ tueqng
y115e1iloq1g
16'xnuupbsg
,{rua8y uogteloJd Islueuuorlaug Japun ees'Vdg
g8l'Ltl '88'(Vdg) ,{oua8yuolpelord 1uluetntror!rg
ISI'S noq3'n-ug
'rg 'zv'1137'qaiug
Brr
ZtI'yCI'gtytq1qoug
gLI' L'98'?L' 89'17'1uau,(o1dug
'Eu1p[ng-a.4dug
88'tg
gg'gg',f,r.re11 tclqdtg
9'sallg
9616gaq1yteplg
6lT'W'mspepregpEg
69',trlsqqztezg
99',t1odonq
SgI'9-g9I'fHoU'pfflnq
ggr' Igl' Egt'zll' 8ll' vL'$'ro lew'su16noq
,6I'PeIJMeol'se16noq
'v'EEr'll.l'
66r'sfl 9'E0l'z-02'8' Ll'z'lr'uopuulugcqq
5d;qs.rolqa;q
zgr' 091'zcr'yill-'zE' 6z'vz' Ll t1
z9'uollBslunqs-ec
061'ZVI'(pa.q1y.r;5,(garu.roy) p.ro1'6u1uuaq
Lll' 8Z'7'us;1ul1ual Dga.rtouaq
V't61,'ZVI'14'uoryag'.rauPq
z0I'uollBsllBluolocao
79'etn,e1'salau(
HfcNnl/\oo=l3HJ
aNsnvrcos
B0z
sr'slou-ea?H puE Se^oH
'aPnqqsull
V6T'glT
98I'8tI' EVI'E1l!.reqe;g'Poonru11
I0I'uaIrsII
69I'89I'g'97'sndtocsDaqDH
8SI'SZ'.rnogP.to;P1-tng
gg1 'eur1 sese.rg
97'sleequaarg
1g'Paqsunun1ea.rg
lnoqtno.rql - lueurrJeao3
6usa.rq1'ueu'rog
6 LT'SVI'991
,s'F[Jo9
6'fuug'.raPnPlog
191'p.renpg'q4usP1og
5uuuuta11r8ugeoe
ZLl' 08
69l'1sous0l9
i 6l' T6r' L$l' z8l' zrr' 6-8ll't0r' 16'68'98'08' z9'8z'6' 91
'tI 's1oiue.1g 'Pnouag
"(ueulag
98I
'60r'g0r 'r'00r '9'96 6aplcouag
TEI'cf,T
A6'uolz uo^ uastall DP asswulaAao
oflI'E1l' seg
S8I'Z8I'I'0I L6's-raquuqe
'oeIIIe9
LgT'EVT'1auo1o3'SBIIPU9
'0?I '94 ',t'r'rag'alquC
88I
'ure5 'qqeg
I-09'I
Ja$III Japun ees- Jerqnd
lnoq8no.rql - suoPaeq4\uopae.\f,
5nur1uu44
6Ll' gg!.reqllg
lE'aLlJ ?DaqulDryno[
zsr'Lvt'll ',tsguo.l
596',irua11'P.rog
0gI'ttl
ggl''Evl'$i'L'zv 'gY'9 tne6 61oog
'7-19'saplpd uo;pa1o.rd(ppo;) plag
9gI'Sfl .lslquag
o8r'9sr'str'8or
8II ?elr$rog taPag
g 6s1spsug
96l' z'l'8l' 6gt' z'Irvl' l'jl'' Lzl' szl''lzl' 9I'l.'z' 06'8' I L' 99'6
uScNnvuoclSSHJ
at/\lsnvlcos
602
tgI'wT'0II'86'stropBleu arsu Jo alnlpsul
gg 'zs 'sraprsul
LgI,pVappltwIul
'app;1ue;u1
Lgl'VZ
6pg'.(1;pnbarl
96
'suegpul
Z0l'96
g8I .56.ElPtrI
6sa,q1uaru1
01.T'tL
s9r'09r'wl.'l'001'16'01'67'uqppadul
' ggt' LvrIgzl' E'ztt' 0ll' v'z0l'uope.6gnu1
Lg1''Z'0ll's1ue.61uu1
1LT'Wl'99'sq8noq'aP,{g
',&e8un11
LLl'VL'1'1P
g6T'L6l' lgl' s gl' zsl' Lvr' zvl' q;l' 0z' 6r',(llunxasowo11
o0I'9'otqoqdoutoP
66I'86I
w' 8l'1snuro1o11
}vr' TEI'gzr'E'zzr'Ell' t-.E6'
6r'16r'8r'tr' 5poo,n(11o11
19
061'IVT'711'.rnq.rY'aBPog
3
V6I'E-Z81'1p1t tryua3 Waltua4laq1tg mog
^ro[e aql uo taplH
S0I'11.lad
ssluauncopuuzlllJofl-JanlH
9gl' Etl
lnoq6no.rql- JIoPV'laplH
LLI' q7l' 96'uu1qso.rlg
791'uro
r Pu6'6.rnquePu111
r6t\tt'feu'ntH
9I'Wn.r;reqElg
g-15'esodlndroqElg
'qdlopng 'ssa11
791
pg'suepqJpa.rag
',(WS's8upuua11
S9I
'I8 '79 'ueg1a8a11
8rI
09I'la8aH
49'a.rerq;pa11
96'ueupua11
gg .17 .97.rcqlnutc;rapa1{ !e,tz11
g6T,gLT, LSl,ESl,EVT,
g?I'quo {3H
ulcNnv\ool3uJ
erusnvrcos
FREEDOM SOCIALISM?
UNDER
2r0
TT7,
6xouua'I's!,na-I
II
Sfl'S$'suelqsr1
gg 6op.ruuorl
79'a4o1cguaal4u?7
Zg'gI6t uaau!u?7
(1qqur1-pprretr l puu usluluerl-uspilsntr osp ees)1noq8no.rql- quql
g7'tcynPual ToEaT
'qdasol'qr.uagr1
921
BI'IgI'gzl'16!pury'asae'1
(,ru1yoaInUJapunosp aas)'1noqEno.rq1 - nurl
I8'slsp{crB|ilql
gg'lspp.reme'1
susItIJJBEE-I
S-t
Tgtoreuel
I9I'6-89'19' 79'e4ot-zassP1
6'LLl' tgl' zll' E'z8'gL' 6v'.{rrua.rnoqef
&u{aug npuneas - &u{a1tgnoqD1
rpug'z1ma
86I'Z-IEI
oos'6v'gv'g'gv'I,v'6y'u1996uny
B9r's9r'9sr
79'qeo1-uqnY
ts's{u[nx
oBlI{INheqrqsn.rA
E-ZLt' E-Zg
'S-tS 'lpslsuor)N
6S
'ulluary
ELI'Lgl
g6l' Z8l' 9ll' f' ECf,taso1'6.rauu.rA
'T9I 'rnqf.rV'uoslga
IgI
gg1',(aupog'Euyy
1,'e!q"ry Jpnuggo3u1y
g1 'ueq1euo138u.ry
97'uqol Eu.ry
gLl'alEL'uoq'Eu.qtr
gg tapuuxaly',{rlsua.rey
7,Ll' EVI' 6Er' 7-19'rr&ql
19 !.rnoc oore8uuy
qLl'11g'69 r,rauewuy
'tuuJq3 ':Iaqs-1uy
971
ev\st-lvtcosHtcNnuroc3Sul
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
212
EIZ
06I'g-tgl'I Ll1'66'1g',(qEupoq lqElanirueq Jo aJu"uylrop'seo.r8alq
' ggl''zvl' }vr'v;Tr'r0r'86'9'96'89'7y'seo.6ag\o't8au
16I'salaqepN
sapreqn II4f, roJ lpuno] IuuopsNrepun aas'IJJN
poq8no.rql - rus;zeg\s1zuN\Iz"N
I-09I'0 tuP:etrq'eaol.IlsJ "N
EET'IZI' 97'sXs11uuo.t1u1r,1
6usguuoPulq
6Cl' 60T'01'8I'91
8- LE'L'aePr.rag $1eeH l"uolfsN
. '6'9g['fuo.U
L'96I'9LI 1utrollsN
6sag.raq.t1 roJ
L6l' Z6 t.I^!f, lltuno3 IEuoIluN
16I'eruul11vIBuol1eN
g71'uoaloduP
gI'III'egqgueP
g6'pleseteg
5p11ossn141
Z6l'Zgl'0Z1-' 6ll'68'8I'o1;uafl
69'ueelrPy troluv lressntr{
3(sua1so141.ro) stuqsn141
0I'99
'equtntr4
1161"'96'Ueqog
8Zrhvun
'anb;quezo14i
11y
g6l' z6T' z'r8l'' gcl' 16' uz'p1arsg .q5 6'ta1so141
0I'9'(su;1sntr41.ro) sua1so141
E6I-'691'gsl,' Lvl' wl' z9'19'nocso141
rerug',roso.rotr41
69I'IS
|
E6T'6 Ll' 8 69' Qa4,n21t1o q oslu eas);o15SuttuoYtl
gg'uufuotr41
gg'napbsa1uotr41
',tuosdouo141
941
g LT'Egl'E-zsl' zw' r L' 6-89'E'zg' 8E'gl' El',(1odo uo141
E;I'do.r1uaqqlg-^ololotrl
ZLT'Zgho1o1otr41
0t'Irlntr
'S$ 'gI '0gI 'III '60I '?0I 'S6'uogeua8ersg4l
86I
79'ue,{o4.rtr41
94'd;qa-o.rr541
woo3SHl
awsnv|cosH30Nn
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
Newton,Sir Isaac,85
NF - seeunder National trlont
No Colour Bar for Bitain, 103,L4l, t86
NomenHaturarS3
Non-anti-Semitic,89
Nuremberg,61r118rt72
Odour,184
Oligopoly,68
Owens,Jesse(J.C.),187
Ortrord-educated,45
Paedophiles,174
Falestinians,120
Pendell,Elme4 author SEX WRSUS CU4LIZATION, 96, 120,145,
tu,L93
Perestroika,169
P6tain,Marshal, 93
Plekhanov,51-2
Pogroms,153
Political Pilgrims (book and people), 1..l9,144,192-3
Pollitt,Harry,5,150
Pornography,Mrl52
Pravda,52
PregnancyD iscimin ation Act, 2l
Prohibition, 33, 164
Proletariat, 24,29,32, 41,53,79, 8L-2,L45,156
Propaganda,20,35, 57,64,79, 93,105,111,120,123,126,L29,t30,
L43,160,L69,173,183,L97,200
Protectionism,lTS
Protocolsof theLeamed Eldersof Nippon,10
Protocolsof theLeamedEldersof Zion,90, 107-8,l2lrt59rl80
Prynne,William, 28, 159
Quangoes,136
Quigtey,ProfessorCarroll, author TiagedyAnd Hope, 14-6,46, 54' 69,
95,110nl1.8,146,1534, 167,l7 0, L75 -6,183,188,192
Race-conscious, 191
Race-hate,128,188
2L4
9rz
tII'00I6ePuuna
0S'&JpdJnoqerlJllsJtoueq IEltoS uBIssnU
{976uelssna
ILT' 6'89l'EgI''ETI'86'09'zs'0s
selssng
sgl.'Ezr' 6T]"'86'08'r-99'vzi' 89'zv' 9' vE'lE'17'7
97'aPeu,tuuna
5'r"I
IET'Lzr'zcl' \cl' 96'*r(' zz Joerlu
s6r'06r'Lgr'Egl'6-99r'
LLT'VL'ZL'99'aqnas$Ipuu'ou.rg!1qna
16'pJoT'erauraqlo1
u,{V'pusg Jeptrneas- aJ![V'Enuqueso1
. V8l'Wl'6'96'utslcoglo sloog
Z,LI'ECI'99'ouelaquppeqtr !1a^esoog
7s'sAousuou
1,;ZT'
Z9'6I'lsu-rg'uqaoa
(
V-EV'
0l (doqs,{pogYo.rapunoS)'u1;EV lrfppo1
'SII '9'S0I 'uloeut5'11er{tog
9-L9T'W1
Z9l' qtT' ZS'0T'.ra1aga4coa
sulsePoqX
1,-96
g-74 5s1quo!s!sU
g'Z8I 'tgl '79 '1s;uo1q,reg
susguolsPreg
lgl
L6l'e6r'r'06r
'f,tl'9?I 'H6UJ WOVI IHDITE gHI $qlnie
's1oiuuq4'uuafla^sg
'uoPePledag
S8I'g0I
01pugrquru
'E4sqa;q1
E61,'0Zl
'Z0I'saaEn;q1
S8I
'S8'unPue.ra;ea
t8I
(gp'uoPnqFlsIPeU
99
g'ussauel'alu.6PeX
aeJu
L6l'vgr'6 LI''Tgr'Il9l'gvl'l?l' 6zl'86'?8'9s'r'9'u'tY'pusu
86r'06r'88T't'3r' DEl
vgl'zsl'vrl' zvl'gEl'zET'
'g'Lzl'vzr'll' L}l't'0r'00r',6'I 6'z'16'0L'zv'9'vE'67'8I''us-roug
IaslJoJ Jepurilees' utsllDl?oa
gE1-'1'Z '61 '7'suolluleJ eJsU
'8or 't6 '0z'6l '8ug1u'aoua
v91.'T[l
vIoGS3ul
HScNn
ev\lsnvrcos
UNDERSOCIALISM?
FREEDOM
Rwandans,101, 185
Saar,123
Salmonella,E7
Saudi,Arabia,37
Schiff,Jacob,52
Schwarz,Dr Fbed,anti-Communistand author' 25,62-3,t46r150,
156-7,170,1723,t92
Searchtight(magazineand Organisation),126,128,140'1,\46, 163,
179,188,190-1
Self-censorship, 17
Selfgoveming,96
Self-publishing,\62
Self-rule,l1E
Self-sacrifrce,139
Self-seekers,1M
Separatists,133,192
Serajevo,148rL77
Shakespearer 30
Shaw, George Bemard, ll9 r 193
Shub,Davi4 authorLenin, 534, 79, 146,156'165'1"68-70'174, L77'8
Siberia,168
Skeggs,Malcolm,176
Smith,Adam, 69,146,175
Smit}, (Alfrcrl E), Al, 86,179
SocialCredit, 13, 48,74, 142,L6l, 164,166,183
Socialism\Socialist\Socialists- throughout
Socialist-indoctrination,36
Socialist-oriented,136
Socia[st Farty of Great Britain, 48-9' 168
SocialistWorkers Party,39, 40,42, 46,49'83,103,128,194,Lyl, 200
Sociologr,102
5ony,72,74
SOSRacisme,1jl8
Sout} African Labour Party' 155
Soviet\Soviets- throughout
SovietUnion, Westernaid to, 56'7,147, L70
2L6
LIZ
'I?I '711.u1ogo;,
06I
67'sa;.ro;,
86I'tlotoJ
6'o,qotr
tz'saqlll
( tng Joqlne'Iaqosg'apqtr
Vgl' LII suossa'7
6tr'ss'rg'slulf,
'arunbg ueruueuell
691
0gl' LjT'.roqlne'p.reqr1g'lrognry
'1sa.re1uguopleJqlr
911 Jo
.u.rnq.rory
IZ'JJIIJ
1,1,1'uu.raqq1
6LT' ZSI'VEI'6p'uopuxql
S'repd'11aq4q1-
?6'Blusus-qf
'r-0''s$Fqf,
6LI-'g-SLr
,tge6 sm4.roXllsllultos repun eas- dAfS
VTI'ZgluugazlprS
911'uapen5
08I'I'0rI' LVI'g'Lg'79',{uo1uy'uopn5
5L'salppqng
l-yL'6
'88I'nuar.gg
'6I
'sngnf '.raqep45
161
98r
' L4'g7l'g-pg1'to1o3{O apUSutgyaq1roqlns'dorqtof {p.ruppo15
9-?gI'9SI' LV1'Z-T0T'96'aatgarglO aSopuog toqlnuolue)I'uaigqS
,8'usllels
59'uqugulg
LLt' EL' 69t' 6st' 991'Egt'Ltl
'gtr'Ezl.'6rr '08'L9'E'zg'Lg'g'vs'z'09'Bv'zl'0t'gr'Tf,'t 'z 'ullels
z8r'ss
ulslFg leer3Jo,(gq4lqppos repun aes- gCdS
gg'to1o1cadg
L6l' 96T'881' Ll1''g1y'poaqtoads
69'uJudg
LgI' Lll'roqlne'seuroql'IIearoS
t/\ocf3HJ
H30Nn
ar{srlvrcos
8TT,
g01-,L6.arququlz
gp(ergu.ey
g8I'er-rBz
,-t6I'IFaiI rm11atr
6LI' 5;g7l'Sg'uns .rg'uas-1q1
'sa{MA
6ST'l?T'gZ'uqof
911',(aeuardnsef$L&t
I6T'qVI toqlnu laruflretr4i .16'alle11
'q.rnq-u.ra1sar11
1,9
'6I'.reu;aa1
8If
'
L-961'6gf, L-gTl' ug.le141'ra1sqe11
61auqeg41'uo qeXl
6gl' ZIT
.ua.uur11
LLT,t- EL tuu.q
lnoqEno.rql-.ru6
6.roq3ne'op61',{puepXl
t LT' gl1-
'orBll
ELt'W
'g'p1'ueu;ap1
E6l'tg1
gl1-'wI !.reqalX'1p.r.rer1
yg 5uopu41uu.ra1
g9l'Zl',tms1
lnoqino.rql - selels pegun
uFe/I osIBaas-.roua,{61
0S'(qua.I Jo .reqlo.rq)raptrExeryhoue,t61
uluerl Japrmaes- l|'ousJlll
161'upue61
g6'snqddl
6uqo1'
L6r'g6T'6ct' L{t \1epudtr
lglrSrZroe6.Surg-as;
96'79'1q.rus1
g.uslrBsJ.
g9I 'g0I '0V'6E'a1.r,t4s1o.q,
LLt'T-oLr'tr ggr'o9r'gvr'svl-'gtl
6'Lg's'lg'zs't'gl' El'E'q' 6'g'l' g'uoa"l',$tqo.u
' T;t'9L' Lg'T'09'
g'suotutuoS aWto tpa8o.+I
'uslu"F"lflstol
8II
'911'ueprel;p10;
661'LEI'gTl' E{f,
u30Nnu\|oo33uj
er{srlvrcos
g8r'69r'Ew'wt'tgr'0gr*,grttc6TT*,'*llTt?lil
?61'tTt'131'us-ruog
91,1'gg'laPoq2
uloo33uJ
ansnv|cosH30Nn
FREEDOM UNDER SOCIALISM?
Ihb ioril socialism has pleasingconnotations,many peoplein all walks of
lifi ar6 prqud tgcall themselvessopialists.Socialismwill, many of them say,
equitablewodd.When the economy,or evensociety
' - ! , . 1 " : . -
- '
PublishedbyInfoTextManuscripts'
g3cVennerRoad,
Sydenham,
London SE26sHU.
England.
ISBNr87r473837