Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/49846016
CITATIONS READS
27 262
3 authors:
Veronica Wiley
Children's Hospital at Westmead
54 PUBLICATIONS 1,936 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Sunita Bijarnia-Mahay on 12 December 2016.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
J Inherit Metab Dis
DOI 10.1007/s10545-011-9286-8
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Screening Protocol
Sample Collection
Day 3
- TSH Assayed
Fig. 1 The screening protocol followed in the New South Wales further testing, TFT thyroid function tests, T3 triiodothyronine, T4
Newborn Screening Programme. TSH Thyroid stimulating hormone, thyroxine, + result above reference range, result below reference
mIU/L milli-international units per litre, WB whole blood, NFT no range, scan isotope scan, CH congenital hypothyroidism
from 2,275 babies, and a second card at about 1 month of The initial sample was drawn within the first 7 days of
age was received from 2,117. Birth weight was used as an life in all babies included in the study, with a median of
indirect measure of gestational age because information on 3 days. The timing of the second sample was variable with
gestational age was missing (for 116 samples) on NBS a median of 31 days (92% babies were re-sampled before
cards or thought to be inaccurate. The lowest gestational 2 months of age).
age with provision of a sample was 20 weeks. The
gestational age distribution is shown in Table 1. The mean TSH results
and median gestational age in the cohort was 28 weeks.
Of the 3,193 VLBW babies (1,699 males), 1,506 were Most VLBW babies had a normal TSH level in the initial
below 1,000 g, 477 of these being below 500 g. There were sample. Five had a high TSH (20 mIU/LWB or more)
814 VLBW babies from multiple births, including two sets and had immediate further investigation. In two the
of quadruplets and 34 sets of triplets. elevated TSH was persistent (Table 2). Of the 2,117
babies who underwent a second screen, 37 had an
abnormal result, with TSH levels 7 mIU/LWB (age
Table 1 Gestational age distribution appropriate cut-off for full-term babies). Eighteen of them
(1:116 of those from whom we received samples, 1:128 of
Gestational age (weeks) Number of babies all survivors) were classified as having persistent elevation
<24 528
of TSH after further investigations. These babies were
24 to <26 350
started on treatment with thyroxine soon after diagnosis
26 to <28 510
and 16 still remained on thyroxine supplementation at ages
2455 months (Table 2). Two babies (twins) were lost to
28 to <30 659
follow-up after 4 months of treatment. Plasma TSH
30 to <31 519
measurements at 1 month were 46 and 135 mIU/L. Not
31 511
all children have yet had a trial withdrawal of treatment.
Gestation unknown 116
Six babies had undoubted permanent hypothyroidism,
Total 3,193
with an increase in TSH developing after trial treatment
J Inherit Metab Dis
Case Sex B Wt (g) TSH 1st test TSH 2nd test Age 2nd Plasma TSH Plasma Isotope Current Comment
(mIU/LWB) (mIU/LWB) test (days) (mIU/L) FT4 scan result duration of Rx
(months)
B Wt Birth weight, TSH thyroid stimulating hormone, WB whole blood (to convert whole blood to plasma equivalent assuming a haematocrit of
50%, multiply result by 2), FT4 free thyroxine, Rx treatment, N normal, dyshorm dyshormonogenesis
Superscripts identify twin pairs
cessation at 23 years. Permanent hypothyroidism has still formal thyroid function test at 2 weeks and a newborn
not been definitively ruled out in the remainder. They screening blood spot at 1 month of age. Among them was
include three with dysgenesistwo hemiagenesis and one one baby (included in the 18 positive cases) who required
with apparent athyreosisone with a large thyroid with treatment beyond 2 months of age. An additional 24 babies
increased uptake on scan, one with Down syndrome and had a high TSH with either normal or low free T4, three of
two who had had TSH levels in excess of 100 mIU/L at whom were treated with thyroxine for only 2 weeks. All the
1 month (see Table 2). 24 babies were categorised as having transient hypothy-
Nineteen babies with a second TSH7 mIU/LWB had roidism secondary to exposure to povidone-iodine. Thus in
transient hypothyroidism. Thyroid function was normal total there were 43 babies with transient hypothyroidism
when formal thyroid function tests were undertaken usually which normalised by 1 month of age with no or only brief
a few days later without any treatment or in one baby, treatment.
whose mother was on antithyroid medication, after only a
1 week treatment. A third category of babies came from one Other disorders
centre where there is a protocol for testing with thyroid
function tests at 2 weeks of age as iodine was used The repeat samples were tested for the whole range of
routinely as an antiseptic on newborn skins. Of the 385 newborn screening disorders, and there were no other
babies born at this centre 382 had retesting, most having a abnormal findings.
J Inherit Metab Dis
a baby with Down syndrome who was treated. There is In conclusion, our study confirms that a delayed rise in TSH
evidence that most babies with Down syndrome have is a distinct entity amongst infants with VLBW, with cases of
slightly abnormal thyroid function and may benefit from permanent and transient hypothyroidism being missed unless a
treatment with thyroxine (van Trotsenburg 2006). The second screening protocol is used. Almost 1% of VLBW
second issue is that we know of only two VLBW babies babies were deemed by paediatric endocrinologists to need
(twins with ectopic thyroid glands) with permanent hypo- treatment with thyroxine for a substantial period if not
thyroidism missed by our screening programme over a permanently. A strategy involving a second screen needs to
period of 22 years. VLBW babies are under considerable be pursued if all VLBW babies currently deemed to need
clinical scrutiny during their first years of life, so that treatment for a period are to be detected. This of course begs
hypothyroidism would be likely to be diagnosed readily the question of whether some of the treatment was unneces-
and would be likely to be reported to the programme. This sary, but as the long-treated babies remained euthyroid on
accords with experience elsewhere (Rapaport 2000; Vincent usual replacement doses of thyroxine, this seems unlikely. Our
et al. 2002). Thus it is most puzzling that such a large group study is one of the few that has follow-up data relating to trial
of VLBW babies needed treatment. All the babies still able of withdrawal of treatment. Routine second screening of all
to be followed have been deemed by paediatric endocrinol- infants, not just VLBW babies, does detect extra cases of
ogists to need treatment for at least 2 years. Do these babies hypothyroidism, and there is an urgent need for studies that
represent those who without re-screening would later be will guide us on the benefit or otherwise of treating mild cases.
found to have juvenile hypothyroidism? It seems unlikely At present treatment is directed to numbers, without clear
that such a problem for VLBW babies would have gone evidence of benefit (Krude and Blankenstein 2011).
unnoticed for such a long period. Alternatively most might
have had mild subclinical hypothyroidism, uncovered only Acknowledgements We are very grateful to the paediatric endo-
crinologists who kindly supplied us with follow-up data, and to the
by the repeat testing. This scenario was found (but not in staff of the NSW Newborn Screening Programme who of course did
VLBW babies however) in the interesting retrospective most of the work.
study in Sweden (Alm et al. 1984).
In our study, there were only 2,117 repeat samples from
2,275 babies, and thus there is a possibility that some cases References
were missed. However, even in this small cohort 16 of 18
positive cases showed a delayed rise in TSH. Among the 16 Alm J, Hagenfeldt L, Larsson A, Lundberg K (1984) Incidence of
babies, 13 had TSH below 6 on initial testing and would congenital hypothyroidism: retrospective study of neonatal
still have been missed using a lower threshold. By reducing laboratory screening versus clinical symptoms as indicators
leading to diagnosis. BMJ (Clin Res Ed) 289(6453):11711175
the threshold TSH level on retesting to 6 mIU/L as Australasian Paediatric Endocrine Group (2010) Guidelines for
recommended (Korada et al. 2008) the false positive rate management of congenital hypothyroidism. http://www.apeg.
would increase from 0.1 to 2.8% of the population, but org.au/Portals/0/documents/guidelines%20for%20management%
would still miss most cases showing a delayed rise in TSH. 20of%20congenital%20hypothyroidism.pdf. 05/11/2010
Calaciura F, Mendorla G, Distefano M et al (1995) Childhood IQ
Our initial testing was done earlier than in the UK babies of measurements in infants with transient congenital hypothyroid-
Koradas study and this may have influenced results. ism. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf) 43:473477
Forty-three babies in our study had transient hypothyroid- Chung HR, Shin CH, Yang SW et al (2009) High incidence of thyroid
ism, with thyroid function which normalised before 2 months dysfunction in preterm infants. J Korean Med Sci 24:627631
CSLI (Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute) (2009) Newborn
of age, and most of these were not treated at all. This number screening for preterm, low birth weight and sick newborns:
suggests that transient hyperthyrotropinaemia may be more approved guideline. CLSI document I/LA31-A. CLSI, Wayne, PA
common in infants with VLBW, and it is not known how this Filippi L, Pezzati M, Cecchi A, Poggi C (2006) Dopamine infusion: a
might affect developmental outcome. Pollitt suggests that possible cause of undiagnosed congenital hypothyroidism in
preterm infants. Pediatr Crit Care Med 7:249251
additional cases of hypothyroidism are being found because Fisher DA (1998) Thyroid function in premature infants. The
of better analytical performance in screening laboratories, and hypothyroxinemia of prematurity. Clin Perinatol 25:9991014
that identifying and treating either mild or transient hypothy- Grueiro-Papendieck L, Chiesa A, Mendez V et al (2005) Efficacy of
roidism does not accord with currently accepted criteria for congenital hypothyroidism neonatal screening in preterms less
than 32 weeks of gestational age: more evidence. J Pediatr
screening (Pollitt and Wales 2010). Long-term neurodeve- Endocrinol Metab 18:373377
lopmental studies in a large number of infants and children Korada M, Pearce M, Ward-Platt M et al (2008) Repeat testing for
are needed to evaluate the effects of subtle thyroid function congenital hypothyroidism in preterm infants: unnecessary with
abnormalities in neonates (Rapaport 2000), and this might an appropriate TSH threshold. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed
93:F286F288
need to be a retrospective study similar to the instructive Krude H, Blankenstein O (2011) Treating patients not numbers: the
study of Alm and colleagues (Alm et al. 1984) as suggested benefit and burden of lowering TSH newborn screening cut-offs.
(Pollitt and Wales 2010). Arch Dis Childh 96:121122
J Inherit Metab Dis
Lafranchi SH (2010) Newborn screening strategies for congenital Rapaport R (2002) Thyroid function in the very low birth weight
hypothyroidism: an update. J Inherit Metab Dis 33(Suppl 2): newborn: rescreen or reevaluate? J Pediatr 140:287289
S225S233 Silva SA, Chagas AJ, Goulart EM et al (2010) Screening for
Larson C, Hermos R, Delaney A, Daley D, Mitchell M (2003) Risk hypothyroidism in extreme premature and/or very-low-
factors associated with delayed thyrotropin elevations in congenital birthweight newborns: the importance of a specific protocol. J
hypothyroidism. J Pediatr 143:587591 Pediatr Endocrinol Metab 23:4552
Mandel SJ, Hermos RJ, Larson CA, Prigozhin AB, Rogas DA, Tylek-Lemaska D, Kumorowicz-Kopiec M, Starzyk J (2005)
Mitchell ML (2000) Atypical hypothyroidism and the very low Screening for congenital hypothyroidism: the value of retesting
birth weight infant. Thyroid 10:693695 after four weeks in neonates with low and very low birth weight.
Mikosch P, Gallowitsch HJ, Kresnik E, Molnar M, Gomez I, Lind P J Med Screen 12:166169
(1999) Thyroid hemiagenesis in an endemic goiter area diagnosed van Trotsenburg AS, Kempers MJ, Endert E, Tijssen JG, de Vijlder JJ,
by ultrasonography: report of sixteen patients. Thyroid 9:1075 Vulsma T (2006) Trisomy 21 causes persistent congenital hypothy-
1084 roidism presumably of thyroidal origin. Thyroid 16:671680
Mitchell ML, Walraven C, Rojas DA, McIntosh KF, Hermos RJ van Wassenaer AG, Kok JH, Dekker FW, de Vijlder JJ (1997) Thyroid
(1994) Screening very-low-birthweight infants for congenital function in very preterm infants: influences of gestational age and
hypothyroidism. Lancet 343:6061 disease. Pediatr Res 42:604609
Pollitt RJ, Wales JK (2010) Newborn screening for congenital Vincent MA, Rodd C, Dussault JH, Van Vliet G (2002) Very low birth
hypothyroidism: improved assay performance has created an weight newborns do not need repeat screening for congenital
evidence gap. J Inherit Metab Dis 33(suppl 2):S201S203 hypothyroidism. J Pediatr 140:311314
Rapaport R (2000) Congenital hypothyroidism: expanding the Wilcken B, Wiley V (2008) Newborn screening. Pathology 40:104
spectrum. J Pediatr 136:1012 115