Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Fernanda Rochoel La Rosa1; Ellen Cristine Giese2; Robert Frans Huibert Dekker3;
Jacinta Snchez Pelayo4; Aneli de Melo Barbosa5*
Abstract
A paint company in the state of Paran in Brazil had several batches of water-based acrylic paints
contaminated with microorganisms. Three fungi and one bacterium were isolated. The bacterium was
identified as Stenotrophomonas maltophilia. Three commercial fungicides (Fungicide I, II and III) and
three bactericides (Bactericide I, II and III) were evaluated in attempts to prevent microbial growth.
Fungicide II (1 g/L) was the most efficient fungicide of fungal isolates A and B, while Fungicide I
was a better inhibitor of isolate C at the lowest concentrations studied. Bactericide II and III inhibited
bacterial isolate at a concentration of 1 g/L, while 2 g/L of Bactericide I did not inhibited its growth.
Inhibition tests were standardized and used to quantitatively evaluate the bactericides demonstrating
that Bactericide III (2 g/L) inhibited 80 % of bacterial isolate.
Key words: Paint. Microbial contaminants. Bactericides. Fungicides. Stenotrophomonas maltophilia.
Resumo
Uma indstria de tintas do Estado do Paran (Brasil) teve vrios lotes de tintas acrlicas base dgua
contaminadas por microrganismos. Trs fungos e uma bactria foram isolados. A bactria foi identificada
como Stenotrophomonas maltophilia. Trs fungicidas comerciais (Fungicida I, II e III) e trs bactericidas
(Bactericida I, II e III) foram avaliados quanto ao potencial de inibio do crescimento microbiano. O
Fungicida II (1 g/L) foi o mais eficiente para os isolados fngicos A e B, enquanto que o Fungicida I
inibiu melhor o isolado C nas menores concentraes estudadas. Os Bactericidas II e III inibiram o
isolado de bactria quando na concentrao de 1 g/L, enquanto que o Bactericida I (2 g/L) no inibiu o
crescimento desta. Os testes de inibio foram padronizados e utilizados para avaliar quantitativamente
os bactericidas, e demonstraram que o Bactericida III (2 g/L) inibiu 80 % o isolado de bactria.
Palavras-chave: Tinta. Contaminantes microbianos. Bactericidas. Fungicidas. Stenotrophomonas
maltophilia.
1
Especialista em Bioqumica Aplicada, Universidade Estadual de Londrina, DBBTEc, Londrina-PR, Brasil, larosa@hotmail.
com.
2
Doutora em Engenharia e Cincias de Alimentos, Universidade Estadual Paulista, DQCA, S. J. Rio Preto-SP, Brasil, ellengiese@
gmail.com.
3
Professor Visitante, Universidade Estadual de Londrina, DBBTEc, Londrina-PR, Brasil. xylanase@gmail.com.
4
Professor Adjunto D, Universidade Estadual de Londrina, DM, Londrina-PR, Brasil, jspelayo@sercomtel.com.br.
5
Professora Associado C, Universidade Estadual de Londrina, DBBTEc, Londrina-PR, Brasil. E-mail: aneli@uel.br.
85
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008
La Rosa, F. R. et al.
Microbial contamination of paint can occur and described for degrading and modifying the
during its manufacture, with the majority of the characteristics of paints (FAZENDA, 1995).
contaminants being present in the source of water,
Biocides constitute a heterogeneous group
in the raw materials and also in equipment vessels
of chemical agents with diverse mechanisms of
and plumbing lines (tanks and pipes) (FAZENDA,
antimicrobial action; microbiostatic (inhibiting
1995). Certain microorganisms produce biofilms
microbial growth) and microbiocidal (causing
that can adhere to the surfaces of plumbing systems
irreversible or irreparable damage to the microbial
containing water, processing tanks and other
cell) effects (DENYER, 1990; EUCHI, 2002). The
environments at the factory, and these in general,
biocides generally act during the vegetative stage
are very resistant to the treatment with biocides and
of growth of the microbial cell, as the resistance to
deodorants (WINKOWSKI, 1999).
biocides develops during the period of sporulation
Biodeterioration of paints by fungal and (RUSSELL, 1990).
bacterial agents present in the packaged product and
Changes in the active toxicity principle of
after painting has been described in the literature
biocides have seen the substitution of highly toxic
(ARQUIAGA; CANTER; ROBERTSON, 1995;
compounds (pentachlorophenol and mercury
BJURMAN, 1999; DORNIEDEN; GORBUSHINA;
used during the 1960s and 1970s, and organic
KRUMBEIN, 2000). The peculiar chemical
composites such as formaldehydes and phenols in
characteristics of paints themselves (presence of
the 1980s) for more favourable compounds such as
polyamides, epoxy resins, chlorides and even some
isothiazolinones that are less toxic and aggressive in
organic solvents and water) can serve as sources
the environment, (MATTEUCCI, 1989). However,
of nutrients for the contaminating microorganisms
these biocides still do not offer the same efficacy as
(STRANGER-JOHANNESSEN; NORGAARD,
mercuric compounds in the adequate preservation
1991). Among the bacteria associated with the
of paints and paintings (LEITE; MURRO, 1999).
deterioration of paints present in the packaged
Microbial resistance to the action of these biocides
product, species of Pseudomonas, Flavobacterium,
has been related to the resistance to antibiotics
Escherichia and Bacillus have been identified
(RUSSELL, 1990), and this is related to the
86
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008
Microbiological contamination of water-based paints from an industry in the state of Paran, Brazil
production of -lactamases capable of hydrolyzing PDA plates and left to grow at 28 C, and colonies
the -lactams commonly present in antimicrobial isolated and subcultured until pure as observed by
agents including antibiotics (KATAOKA, 2003). homogeneous growth. The purified isolates were
maintained at 4 C on PDA slants, and subcultured
The objective of the work presented herein was
at intervals of 3 months.
to isolate and characterize the microorganisms
from different batches of water-based paints from For identification of bacteria, the samples were
a paint company in the state of Paran (Brazil), transferred to blood agar (BA) plates to allow
and to determine the potential biocide efficacy of development of microbial colonies. Then, the
some commercial bactericides6 (Bactericide I, a colonies were submitted to the Gram stain, and
composite of hemiacetals and isothiazolinones; it was observed that all the colonies were Gram-
Bactericide II, a mixture of 5-chloro-2-methyl-4- negative. These colonies were next transferred to
isothiazolin-3-one and 2-methyl-4-isothiazolin- MacConkey agar (MC), and those that grew were
3-one; Bactericide III, a mixture of dimethylurea, then submitted to the following biochemical tests:
5-chloro-2-methyl-4-isothiazolin-3-one and oxidase, motility and oxidation-fermentation (OF).
2-methyl-4-isothiazolin-3-one) and fungicides As all of the bacteria tested were oxidative, these
(Fungicide I, a composite of heterocyclic compounds, were then identified by the API 20 NE system
isothiazolinones and benzimidazol; Fungicide (bioMrieux, Marcy-L Etoile, France).
II, 2-N-octyl-4-isothiazolin-3-one; Fungicide III,
2-methoxycarbamoylbenzimidazole;), and their
use during the manufacturing process of paint in Evaluation of commercial biocides by the pour-
attempts to control microbiological contamination plate method
and activity. Inoculum was prepared by growing the isolated
microbial strains on PDA at 28 C for 5 days,
and using agar-plugs of 5 mm diameter colonized
Material and methods with cells. Four plugs were transferred to assay
Microbial isolation techniques tubes containing 10 mL isotonic saline solution (9
g/L). The tests were carried out in triplicate, and
Paint samples were obtained in triplicate
samples containing fungal mycelium, fungal spores
from some identified phases of the industrial
or bacterial cells from each purified isolate, were
process considered as critical points of microbial
mixed in PDA before the agar solidified. Inhibition
contamination: reservoirs, pipes and tubing, tanks
tests were carried using sterilized filter paper discs
and also some raw materials, such as antifoam,
of 5 mm diameter placed within the centre of
thickeners, dispersants and emulsions, as well
each PDA plate. To each disc, 8 l of an aqueous
as water, and paints of contaminated batches.
solution of each fungicide (Fungicide I, Fungicide
The samples were transferred to potato-dextrose
II and Fungicide III) or bactericide (Bactericide
agar (PDA) plates to allow development of
I, Bactericide II and Bactericide III) was added
microbial colonies. Samples collected in-situ in the
at a concentration of 1 g/L (recommended by the
contaminated places were carried out using the swab
manufacturer); 2 g/L (as used by the industry) and
technique (GUGLIELMINETTI et al., 1994). In the
8 g/L (chosen experimentally as excess of biocide).
laboratory, the collected material was transferred to
The plates were incubated at 28 C for 7 days and
6
As we didnt have permission to divulge the names of the the halo of inhibition observed at intervals of 24 h.
commercial biocides used in this study, we adopted the Radial growth was measured as colony diameters
acronyms Bactericides I, II and III, and Fungicides I, II, and
(cm) at 4-equidistant points taken from the centre
III to refer to these biocides.
87
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008
La Rosa, F. R. et al.
of the growing fungal colony, and the average value sterile water (1:10) and scanned within the spectral
taken. All experiments were carried out in triplicate range of 400 to 800 nm to monitor the absorbance to
and the reported data represents average values develop the inhibition tests.
SD.
Table 2. Nature of the microbial contaminants isolated from industry water samples.
Microorganisms Characteristics
Fungal isolate A filamentous white fungus
Fungal isolate B filamentous green fungus
Fungal isolate C filamentous light-yellow fungus
Bacterial isolate Stenotrophomonas maltophilia
The microbial contamination of paints containing chain and the production of metabolic energy
fungicides in their formulation is not uncommon, (DENYER, 1990).
and has been described (GUGLIELMINETTI et al.,
The commercial fungicides evaluated in the
1994; BJURMAN, 1999). Inoue and Koyano (1991)
inhibition tests included Fungicide I, Fungicide II
isolated different fungal species from oil paints
and Fungicide III, separately, at concentrations of
containing biocides based on pentachlorophenol and
1, 2 and 8 g/L (Figs 1A and B). Fungicide II (1 g/L)
benzimidazol components, which included genera
inhibited fungal isolates A and B more efficiently
of the following fungi: Cladosporium, Trichoderma,
than Fungicides I and III at 48 h. After this period,
Rhizopus, Aspergillus, Alternaria, Penicillium and
the inhibition halo observed in the presence of
Fusarium, as well as a several bacterial species. The
Fungicides I and III with fungal isolate B decreased
isothiazolinone compounds, present in the majority
suggesting that by then the microorganism had
of commercial fungicides currently used in paints,
acquired resistance to these biocides.
have been described as inhibiting the respiratory
88
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008
Microbiological contamination of water-based paints from an industry in the state of Paran, Brazil
3.5
3.0 high cost and also the risk of inducing resistance to
2.5
2.0
microorganisms.
1.5
1.0 Shirakawa et al. (2002) verified that use of paints
0.5
0.0
containing dimethylurea and carbamate as biocides
did not hinder the growth of some fungal species
24 48 72 96 120 144 168
Tim e (h) such as Alternaria, Epicoccum, Pestalotia and
Aureobasidium. These fungi have been described
4.0 Isolate C
as producing exopolysaccharides (GOATLEY,
Inhibition diameter (cm)
3.5
3.0
2.5
1968; SCHIMID et al., 2001; MISAKI et al., 1984;
2.0 GIBBS; SERVIOUR, 1992), which participate in the
1.5
1.0 process of microbial deterioration. The occurrence
0.5
0.0
of biofilms in domestic and industrial water piping
can result in loss of water quality, corrosion of the
24 48 72 96 120 144 168
Tim e (h) pipes and contamination of industrial processes
and products, some with pathogens (MORTON;
SURMAN, 1994).
Figure 1. Evaluation of growth inhibition of fungal
isolates A, B and C by commercial fungicides: Fungicide Some bacterial species such as Pseudomonas,
I (), Fungicide II () and Fungicide III () at 1 g/L; Klebsiella, Enterobacter, Bacillus and Alcaligenes
and Fungicide I (), Fungicide II () and Fungicide III have also been described in the biodegradation of
() at 2 g/L.
paints and result from water sources (ARQUIAGA;
CANTER; ROBERTSON, 1995). The bacterial
When the fungicides were evaluated at a isolate of the present work was identified as
concentration of 2 g/L, an inhibition halo was Stenotrophomonas maltophilia (bacterial isolate).
observed in I68 h with Fungicides I, II and III, which This Gram-negative bacterium was originally
corresponded to halo diameters of 3.33, 2.37 and identified as belonging to the Pseudomonas species
1.50 cm, respectively, for fungal isolate A, and 2.95; and later reclassified as Xanthomonas maltophilia.
2.83 and 1.25 cm, respectively, for fungal isolate B. S. maltophilia has been found in water, soil, plants
However, for fungal isolate C (Fig 1C), Fungicide (BROOKS et al., 2004) but rarely in humans and
I was the most efficient fungicide evaluated at animals (DALAMAGA et al., 2003). Through the
concentrations of 1 and 2 g/L. In the case of use of molecular biology techniques other species
biocide Fungicide III, the inhibition halo decreased of Stenotrophomonas have been described recently
after 48 h, suggesting that the microorganism had as S. african, S. nitritireducens, S. acidaminiphila
and S. rhizophila (COENYE et al., 2004).
89
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008
La Rosa, F. R. et al.
0.600
0.450
0.300
0.150
1.5 0.000
Inhibition diameter (cm)
0.5
Figure 3. Absorption spectra of culture medium: control
flasks (), bacterial isolate (), Bactericide I (),
0.0
Bactericide II () and Bactericide III ().
24 48 72 96 120 144 168
Time (h)
Among the Gram-negative bacteria strains
Figure 2. Evaluation of growth inhibition of bacterial studied by Andrzejewska et al. (2004), S. maltophilia
isolate by commercial bactericides: Bactericide I (), and Bordetella bronchiseptica were inhibited by
Bactericide II () and Bactericide III () at 1 g/L; and high concentrations of benzimidazoles compounds
Bactericide I (), Bactericide II () and Bactericide III
() at 2 g/L.
(100 g/mL), which is the active principle used in
90
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008
Microbiological contamination of water-based paints from an industry in the state of Paran, Brazil
the composition of certain biocides. S. maltophilia pseudo outbreak related to bronchoscope reprocessing
has also been described for its capacity to degrade procedures. American Journal of Infection Control, Saint
Louis, v. 32, n. 3, p. E60-E64, May. 2004.
lactams and atrazine, besides presenting resistance to
a diversity of antibiotics and xenobiotic composites COENYE, T., VANLAERE, E., LIPUMA, J. J.,
VANDAMME, P. Identification of genomic groups
(ROUSSEAUX; HARTMANN; SOULAS, 2001). in the genus Stenotrophomonas using gyrB RFLP
The effect on the biodeterioration of paints through analysis. FEMS Immunology and Medical Microbiology,
fungi and bacteria presents characteristics such as Amsterdam, v. 40, n. 3, p. 181-185, 2004.
changes in viscosity, discoloration, appearance, COLLINS, C. H.; LYENE P. M. Metodos microbiologicos.
development of gas and foul odour (DEY et al., Zaragoza: Acribia, 1989.
2004; TAN et al., 2008). DALAMAGA, M.; KARMANIOLAS , K.;
CHAVELAS, C.; LIATIS, S.; MATEKOVITS, H.;
Isolation of microorganisms from critical points MIGDALIS, I. Stenotrophomonas maltophilia: a serious
in the manufacturing process of paints at the factory and rare complication in patients suffering from burns.
and the evaluation of potential biocides of some Burns, Oxford, v. 29, n. 7, p. 711-713, 2003.
commercial biocides has allowed the location of the DENYER, S. P. Mechanisms of action of biocides.
origin and source of microbial contamination of the International Biodeterioration, Slough, v. 26, n. 2-4, p.
water-based paints, and to resolve this problem. It 89-100, 1990.
was observed that the biodeterioration of paint in DEY, B. K.; HASHIM, M. A.; HASAN, S.; GUPT, B. S.
Microfiltration of water-based paint effluents. Advances
the packaged product occurred due to contaminated
in Environmental Research, New York, v. 8, n. 3-4, p.
water used as solvent, as the industry did not pretreat 455-466, 2004.
water sourced from artesian wells, and used in the
DORNIEDEN, T.; GORBUSHINA, A. A.; KRUMBEIN,
process to make soluble resins. After the execution of W. E. Biodecay of cultural heritage as a space/time-
this research work, the industry treated its reservoirs related ecological situation an evaluation of a series of
and equipment, and initiated a procedure of water studies. International Biodeterioration Biodegradation,
Barking, v. 46, n. 4, p. 261-270, 2000.
treatment to be used in its process.
EUCHI, S. Abrindo a caixa preta dos revestimentos. Mais
arquitetura, So Paulo, v. 4, n., p. 54-56, 2002.
References FAZENDA, J. M. R. Tintas e vernizes: cincia e
tecnologia. 2. ed. So Paulo: ABRAFATI, 1995.
ANDRZEJEWSKA, M.; YEPEZ-MULIA, L.; TAPIA, A.;
CEDILLO-RIVERA, R.; LAUDY, A. E.; STAROSCIAK, GIBBS, P. A.; SEVIOUR, R. J. Influence of bioreactor
B. J.; KAZIMIERCZUK, Z. Synthesis, and antiprotozoal design on exopolysaccharide production by Aureobasidium
and antibacterial activities of S-substituted 4,6-dibromo- pullulans. Biotechnology Letters, Dordrecht, v. 14, n. 6,
and 4,6-dichloro-2-mercapto-benzimidazoles. European p. 491-494, 1992.
Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Amsterdam, v. 21,
GOATLEY, J. L. Production of exocellular polysaccharides
n. 2-3, p. 323-329, 2004.
by Alternaria solani. Canadian Journal of Microbiology,
ARQUIAGA, M. C.; CANTER, L. W.; ROBERTSON, v. 14, p. 1063-1068, 1968.
J. M. Microbiological characterization of the biological
GUGLIELMINETTI, M.; MORGHEN, C. G.;
treatment of aircraft paint stripping wastewater.
RADAELLI, A.; BISTONI, F.; CARRUBA, G.; SPERA,
Environmental Pollution, Barking, v. 89, n. 2, p. 189-
G.; CARETTA, G. Mycological and ultra structural
195, 1995.
studies to evaluate biodeterioration of mural paintings.
BJURMAN, J. Fungal and microbial activity in external Detection of fungi and mites in frescos of the monastery
wooden panels as determined by finish, exposure, and of St Damian in Assisi. International Biodeterioration
construction techniques. International Biodeterioration Biodegradation, Barking, v. 33, n. 3, p. 269-283, 1994.
Biodegradation, Barking, v. 43, n. 1, p. 1-5, 1999.
INOUE, M.; KOYANO, M. Fungal contamination of
BROOKS, K.; DAUENHAUER, S.; MILLIGAN, oil paintings in Japan. International Biodeterioration,
S.; WASHBURN, R. Stenotrophomonas maltophilia Slough, v. 28, n. 1-4, p. 23-35, 1991.
91
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008
La Rosa, F. R. et al.
92
Semina: Cincias Exatas e da Terra, Londrina, v. 29, n. 1, p. 85-92, jan./jun. 2008