Sei sulla pagina 1di 18

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering

Industrial Engineering
Volume 13 Issue 4 Version 1.0 Year 2013
Type: Double Blind Peer Reviewed International Research Journal
Publisher: Global Journals Inc. (USA)
Online ISSN: 2249-4596 Print ISSN:0975-5861

Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in


Practice: A Review
By Rakesh Kumar & Dalgobind Mahto
Himachal Pradesh Technical University, India
Abstract - With the present changing and uncertain economic and marketing scenario the
available resources must be utilised by the most optimum way, so that the predetermined goal is
achieved. There are number of tools and techniques that are used directly and as support
system in the business for success. Forecasting is also a powerful tool and technique which is
used as support system to the industrial environment so that future of the business can be
predicted accurately. It provides the basis to plan the future requirements for men, machine and
materials, time, money etc. so that the wastage will be least.This paper presents the reviews of
different works in the area of industrial forecasting support systems and tries to find out latest
developments and technologies available in industries and show how they are beneficial to
achieve an accurate forecasting.
Keywords : forecasting, support systems, techniques
GJRE-G Classification : FOR Code: 290502

Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice A Review

Strictly as per the compliance and regulations of :

© 2013. Rakesh Kumar & Dalgobind Mahto. This is a research/review paper, distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License http://creativecommons. org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/), permitting all non
commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and
Technologies in Practice: A Review
Rakesh Kumar α & Dalgobind Mahtoσ

Abstract - With the present changing and uncertain economic of change, if any in characteristic economic phenomena
and marketing scenario the available resources must be
which may affect one’s business plans. Prediction is an
utilised by the most optimum way, so that the predetermined

Year 2013
goal is achieved. There are number of tools and techniques estimate of future event through subjective
that are used directly and as support system in the business considerations other than just the past data. For
for success. Forecasting is also a powerful tool and technique prediction good subjective estimation is based on
which is used as support system to the industrial environment managers’ skill, experience and judgement. There is an
so that future of the business can be predicted accurately. It influence of one’s own perception and bias in prediction.
provides the basis to plan the future requirements for men, So it is less accurate and has low reliability. Forecasts 17
machine and materials, time, money etc. so that the wastage have great importance now days because:

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


will be least.This paper presents the reviews of different works
in the area of industrial forecasting support systems and tries • The forecasts are very important for organizations to
to find out latest developments and technologies available in help to meet the upcoming needs of their
industries and show how they are beneficial to achieve an customers.
accurate forecasting. • Majority of the activities of the industries depends
Keywords : forecasting, support systems, techniques. upon the future sales.
I. Introduction • Projected demand for the future assists in decision
making with respect to investment in plant and

W
ith the changing of the structure of business, machinery, market planning and programmes.
reliable prediction of sales is of immense • To schedule the production department activity for
benefit to a business because it can improve effective utilisation of the plant capacity.
the quality of the business strategy and decrease costs • To prepare material, tool and spare part planning so
due to waste, thereby increasing profit. To improve an that it will be available at right place, at right quantity
enterprise’s competitiveness, we must make correct

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


and at right place when desired.
decisions using the available information. This • It provides information about the demand of the
“Forecasting” is viewed as an important part of decision different products in order to obtain a balanced
making. It is defined as the estimation of future activities production in terms of quantity required of different
like the estimation of type, quantity and quality of future product as a function of time.
work. These estimates provide the basis to plan the • To provide a future trend,this is very much essential
future requirements for men, machine and materials, for product design and development.
time, money etc. Forecasts are predictions or estimation

MARKET & CATEGORY FORCAST


ACTIONS OF OUTSIDES (e.g. ACTIONS OF INSIDES (e.g. MARKETING
COMPETITORS, GOVERNMENT) MIX)

MARKET SHARE

DEMAND

Figure 1 : Forecasting need and their relationships


Author α : M. Tech. Student. E-mail : dmz.rakesh@gmail.com
Author σ : Professor Green Hills Engineering College, Solan, India.

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

Thus, in this changing and uncertain economic a) Qualitative Forecasting Techniques


and marketing scenario forecasting helps to predict the Qualitative forecasting techniques are
future with accuracy. Sometimes it is appropriate to subjective, based on the opinion and judgment of
forecast demand directly. When direct prediction is not consumers, experts; appropriate when past data is not
feasible, or where uncertainty and changes are available. Qualitative forecasting analyses can be used
expected to be substantial, marketing managers may to formulate forecasts for new products for which there
need to forecast the size of a market or product are no historical data; to devise or adjust mid- or long-
category. Also, they would need to forecast the actions range forecasts for corporate planning. There are three
and reactions of key decision makers such as situations in which qualitative methods are preferable to
competitors, suppliers, distributors, collaborators, quantitative ones. These are when: 1) Data are
governments, and themselves, especially when strategic insufficient or are known to be unreliable. 2) It is not
Year 2013

issues are involved. These actions can help to forecast possible to construct a suitable numerical model. 3).
market share. Time is insufficient to initiate and operate a quantitative
There are numerous ways to forecast, ranging analysis.
from the simple, unsophisticated methods of intuition to
complex approaches such as econometric models.
18
However, the forecasting techniques can be divided into
two types, namely:
v vIV Version I

Table 1 : Different Qualitative Forecasting Techniques


S.No. Techniques Description
This method is based on judgment of the executives about the future.
Expert evaluations use the experience of people, such as executives, sales
D ) Volume XIII Issue

Jury / Expert Evaluation people, marketing people, distributors, or outside experts, who are familiar
1. with a product line or a group of products and estimates for future. The
Techniques
executives exercise their judgment and give their opinions. By rough
averaging of these opinions, the final forecast is made.

In the jury method opinions of executives gives rise to forecast. In survey


of Experts Opinion method, experts in the concerned field inside or
2. Survey of Experts Opinion
outside the organization are approached for making estimates. The
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

opinions of outside expertise may include opinions given in newspapers,


trade journals, Opinions of wholesalers and distributors, agencies etc.
In this method the sales forecasting is done by the sales force. Each
salesman develops the forecast for his respective territory, the territory-
3. Sales Force Composite
wise forecasts are consolidated at each branch area level and the
Method aggregate of all these forecast is taken as the corporate forecast. It is a
grass root method.
Consumers Opinion Method In this method, actual users of the product are directly contacted by the
4. investigators and their preferences and attitude towards the product as
well as future requirements are ascertained.
The market share of the firm may also serve as a guide to sales
forecasting. The firms first work out the industry forecast, apply the market
Market Share Method share factor to estimate the company’s sales forecast. The market share
5.
factor is developed based on past trend, company’s present competitive
position, brand preference etc.
Each member of the panel of experts who is chosen to participate writes
an answer to the question being investigated and all the reasoning behind
6. Delphi Method this forecast. The answers of the panel are summarized and returned to
the members of the panel, but without the identification of which expert
came up with each forecast

b) Quantitative Forecasting Techniques endogenous quantitative forecasting technique,


Quantitative forecasting models are used to there is an implicit assumption that there will be no
estimate future demands as a function of past systematic changes or departures from previously
data; appropriate when past data are available. occurring patterns. If there is reason to believe this
The method is usually applied to short-intermediate assumption is no longer valid, qualitative
range decisions. When a forecaster uses an techniques provide the means to adjust the

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

forecasts by tapping the experience and judgment forecast. In other words, one could say that
of people knowledgeable about the product being qualitative forecasting emphasizes predicting the
forecast and the environment affecting the future, rather than explaining the past.
Table 2 : Different Quantitative Forecasting Techniques

S.NO. TECHNIQUES DESCRIPTION


In this method the firm uses its own record of past several years’ sales to estimate the
Sales Trend future sales. It involves the plotting of the sales figures for the past several years and
1.
Analysis stretching of the line or the curve as the case may be. The extrapolation will give the
figures for the coming years.
This method tries to identify the factors which cause variation in the demand. There
Casual Method

Year 2013
2. analyst tries to find out the method that best explain the level of sales of the product.
This process called econometric forecasting.
The variable to be forecast has behaved according to a specific pattern in the past and
that this pattern will continue in the future. D = F(t)Where, D is the variable to be
3. Time series forecast and f(t) is a function whose exact form can be estimated from the past data
available on the variable. The value of the variable for the future as a function of its 19
values in the past Dt+1 = f (Dt, Dt-1, Dt-2 ...)

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


A moving average may be defined as an average of some fixed or predetermined
4. Moving Average number of observations in a time series which moves through the series by dropping
Method the top item of the previous averaged group and adding the next item below in each
successive average. The calculation depends upon the period to be odd or even.
It is similar to moving average method and used fairly extensively. In fact it is an
improvement over moving average method. It tries to overcome the limitations of
5. Exponential
moving average method and eliminates the necessity of keeping extensive records of
Method
past data. The fundamental concept of Exponential method is that new estimate=odd
estimate of latest actual demand +α (latest demand-odd estimate of latest actual
demand)
Least Square Under this method a mathematical relationship is established between the time factor x
6. and the variable y. Let y denote demand and x the period of a certain product. Then
Method
relationship is given by y = a + bx.Where, a and b are constants.

Aims and Objectives

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


II. • To effectively correlate deliveries of materials and
supplies with production schedules.
Organizations use forecasting methods of
• To plan about the potential demands with the level
production and operations management to implement
of investment in plant, equipment and inventory to
production strategies. Forecasting involves using several
be created to manage the business.
different methods of estimating to determine possible
future outcomes for the business. Planning for these
possible outcomes is the job of operations
III. Literature Review
management. Additionally, operations management The literature surveys have been done
involves the managing of the processes required to considering support systems and techniques prevalent
manufacture and distribute products. Important aspects in industries. The works of various authors from diverse
of operations management include creating, developing, fields have been referred from 1992 onwards. Some of
producing and distributing products for the organization. the most important and relevant findings have been
The aims and objectives of the present study are as presented.
follows: Mahmoud et al. (1992) [1] argue about the gap
• To provide the business with valuable information between forecasting theorists and practitioners and
that the business can use to make decisions about suggested the answers for the question for the
the future of the organization. successful implementation of forecasting in the
organizations, which is hampered by gaps in
• To improve the accuracy and quality of the
communication and understanding between forecast
production forecast.
preparers and forecast users. Two approaches of
• To encourage and achieve a greater level of Rogers's and Bass models were compared by Wright
engagement in the production forecast process, by and Charlett (1995) [2] and found that bass model is
using data, where available and appropriate, as more successful forecasting tool than Rogers's
input to the forecast system. approach. Similarly, Winklhoferet al. (1996) [3] worked
• To plan production to meet customer requirements. on Forecasting practice and studiedvarious forecasting

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

application in industrial area and identified their major overtime and inventory holding costs based on a fixed
methodological characteristics. workforce level and an available overtime and the total
Korpcla and Tuominen (1996) [4] worked costs could be reduced by 13.2%.
onanalytic hierarchy process-based approach to A new systematic approach was presented by
demand forecasting and proposed decision support Svetinovic and Godfrey (2001)[11] based on the use of
system which offers many improvements compared to functional and quality attributes to recover, document,
traditional methods. Fleischmann et al. (1997) [5] and apply knowledge about how and why software
surveyed the recently emerged field of reverse logistics. systems evolve. In this discussion was done on how the
The management of return flows induced by the various study of software evolution in terms of attributes makes it
forms of reuse of products and materials in industrial possible to draw parallels between software evolution
production processes has received growing attention and other types of evolution This help us to analyze their
Year 2013

throughout this decade. They subdivided the field into similarities and to map their results and methodologies
three main areas: distribution planning, inventory control, from these other fields to software evolution and how the
and production planning, and discussed the use of attributes can make knowledge about how a
implications of the emerging reuse efforts, review the system has evolved more easily applicable to other
20 mathematical models proposed in the literature, and attribute-based techniques of software engineering.
point out the areas in need of further research. A comparison of the focus forecasting and
A work was presented by Diebold (1998)[6] on exponential smoothing was done by Gardner et al.
v Version I

the macroeconomic forecasting, the Non-structural (2001) [12] and found that Exponential smoothing is
forecasting based largely on reduced-form correlations substantially more accurate than Demand Solutions.
and Structural forecasting spects, which aligns itself with Forecasting rules are arbitrary, with no statistical
v IV

economic theory, and theirimpact on the product rationale therefore, users of Focus Forecasting have
forecasting. Focussing on the inter department co– much to gain by adopting statistical forecasting
D ) Volume XIII Issue

ordination of an organisation Celikbaset al. (1999)[7] methods. A work was presented by Smaros (2001)[13]
considered two possible organizational structures on the support for Collaborative Planning, Forecasting
centralized and decentralized. In the decentralized and Replenishment offered by electronic marketplaces
system, the marketing department provides a forecast to as well as distributed, peer-to-peer, information systems.
manufacturing. Whereas in the centralized system, When comparing the centralized market place model to
marketing and manufacturing jointly decide on the the decentralized peer-to-peer model, it becomes clear
production quantity. They showed that it is possible to that the market places are not the solution to CPFR. If
set penalties so that a coordinated decentralized system the standardization considered, it appears that
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

outperforms a centralized system when there are no companies would be better off choosing a peer-to-peer
tangible costs to the firm for the efforts expended by the solution for CPFR rather than relying on electronic
marketing department. marketplaces to provide the necessary support for their
The various characteristics and effectiveness of collaboration efforts.
the Delphi technique reviewed by Rowe and Wright A work was presented by Charles N.
(1999) [8]. They concluded that Delphi technique Smart(2002) [14] highlighting the importance of
sometimes performs better than statistical groups and accurate demand forecasting for inventory planning to
standard interacting groups. But, the technique has optimize stocking levels to ensure that the right service
shown no clear advantages over other structured part or product is available at the right place at the right
procedures. Sutanto (2000) [9] studied the role of time, in the right quantity. Accurate demand forecasting
Human resource management in supporting the results in the improved customer service and
production plan to achieve the target. The main task of satisfaction. Out of stock and not having the right part in
human resource management is to support other stock at the right time, can be costly, especially when
departments to have the best people. Therefore, the customers are an infrequent purchaser and thus
Forecasting helps to have the best people in the right accurate forecasting needed to control business.
place at the right time so that production does not suffer Smaros (2002) [15] focussed on the Collaborative
at any time. Planning Forecasting and Replenishment (CPFR)
By using winter’s decomposition and Auto- process. In their study, more emphasis is given to
Regressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA) exchange ideas among the different people to get a
forecasting models, Yenradeea et al. (2001)[10] good forecast and finally the product life-cycle model
discussed the demand forecasting and production can be used to select and combine the most suitable
planning for Highly Seasonal Demand Situations. It was approach to collaboration in different market situations.
found that the decomposition and ARIMA models Choudhury et al.(2002)[16] worked on
provide lower forecast errors. The forecasted demand Forecasting of engineering manpower through fuzzy
and safety stock were subsequently used as input to associative memory neural network with ARIMA: a
determine the production plan that minimize the total comparative study, focussed on the requirement of
© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)
Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

technical man power for the plant in next five years by A work was presented by G. Peter Zhang (2003)
using ARIMA and FAM Method. Karel van Donselaar [22] on Time series forecasting using a hybrid ARIMA
(2002)[17] studied the Winters’ method for forecasting and neural network model, focussed on combined effect
of seasonal demand and found that the quality of the of ARIMA and ANN model and a model proposed to
forecasts deteriorates, if the relative demand uncertainty take advantage of the unique strength of ARIMA and
increases or if the amount of historical demand data ANN models in linear and nonlinear modelling.
decreases. Mathematical modelling as well as Timmermann and Granger (2004) [23] worked on
simulation was used to assess the added value of Efficient market hypothesis and forecasting concluded
product-aggregation. It turns out that impressive that Forecasters constantly search for predictable
improvements can be achieved, especially in case patterns and affect prices when they attempt to exploit
demand uncertainty is high. trading opportunities therefore stable forecasting
A work was presented by Winklhofer and patterns unlikely to persist for long periods of time and

Year 2013
Diamantopoulos (2002)[18] on A Multiple Indicators and will self-destruct when discovered by a large number of
Multiple Causes (MIMIC) model in which managerial investors this gives rise to non stationarities in the time
evaluations of forecasting effectiveness are modelled as series of financial returns and complicates both formal
a function of different forecast performance criteria, tests of market efficiency and the search for successful
namely, accuracy, bias, timeliness and cost. The data forecasting approaches.
A new approach presented by Smaros and 21
from a survey of export sales forecasting practices and
several hypotheses linking the aforementioned criteria Hellstrom (2004) [24]to reduce significantly time spent

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


on effectiveness are tested and indicate that evaluations on forecasting by working with an entire assortment at a
of forecasting effectiveness are equally influenced by time instead of producing a forecast for each product
short-term accuracy and absence of overestimating individually. The implementation of a less time-
bias, while timely delivery of the forecast to management consuming forecasting method has enabled the
is somewhat less important, while in Long-term company to involve its salespeople in forecasting and in
accuracy, underestimation and timing of production of this way gain access to their product and market
the forecast are not found to impact on effectiveness. knowledge. Its forecasting accuracy and time spent on
The performance of a vendor managed forecasting before and after the implementation are
inventory (VMI) supply chain with a traditional ‘‘serially measured. The results demonstrate a remarkable
linked’’ supply chain was compared by Disney and increase in forecasting efficiency as well as improved
Towill (2003) [19]. They found that vendor managed communication. HuiZou, Yuhong Yang (2004) [25]
inventory responds significantly better at responding to worked on combining time series models for forecasting
volatile changes in demand caused due to discounted used an algorithm with ARIMA Model to improve

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


ordering or price variations. A work was presented by prediction accuracy when there is much uncertainty in
Hsu et al. (2003) [20] on Litterman Bayesian vector auto finding.
regression (LBVAR) model for production prediction The performance of Artificial Neural Networks
based on the interaction of industrial clusters. The (ANN) and ARIMA models in forecasting of seasonal
LBVAR model possesses the superiority of Bayesian Time series compared by Kihoro et al.(2004)[26].The
statistics in small sample forecasting and holds the results showed that the ANN is relatively better than
dynamic property of the vector auto regression (VAR) ARIMA models in forecasting ability but the nature of the
model. Result showed, the LBVAR model was found to data may influence the results. The main problem with
be capable of providing outstanding predictions for ANN is the lack of explanation capabilities and of a
these two technology industries in comparison to the proper building methodology to define the network
auto regression (AR) model and VAR model. architecture. Most of the ANN modelling process is
Siliverstovs and Dijk (2003)[21] compared the basically empirical and proposed an easier ARD rule,
forecasting performance of linear autoregressive which seems to be working well empirically. This rule
models, autoregressive models with structural breaks, may be investigated further and perhaps a theory
self-exciting threshold autoregressive models and developed to be included in Time Series modelling
Markov switching autoregressive models in terms of methodology for Artificial Neural Networks.
point, interval and density. The results of point forecast Onkal and Bolger (2004) [27] examined the
evaluation tests support the established notion in the potential differences in perceived usefulness of various
forecasting literature on the favourable performance of forecasting formats from the perspectives of providers
the linear AR model. The Markov switching models give and users of predictions. Experimental procedure
more accurate interval and density forecasts than the consists of asking participants to assume the role of
other models, including the linear AR model. Thus the forecast providers and to construct forecasts using
non-linear models may outperform linear competitors in different formats, followed by requesting usefulness
terms of describing the uncertainty around future ratings for these formats. 95% prediction intervals were
realizations of a time series. considered to be the most useful format, followed by

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

directional predictions, 50% interval forecasts, and lastly, adopted and was unusual when compared to other
point forecasts. journals. There were little cross-fertilisation between
A work on the effects of judges' forecasting on journals. Organisational issues and the effects of
their later combination of forecasts for the same forecast error have been ignored. These two issues
outcomes was published by Harvey and Harries (2004) directly impact the gap between theoretical contributions
[28]. The judges' ability to combine forecasts that they and forecasting practice, a gap that remains unbridged.
receive from more knowledgeable advisors is impaired Michael Lawrence et al. (2006) [34] reviewed the past 25
when they have previously made their own forecasts for years has seen phenomenal growth of interest in
the same outcomes. Also, People responsible for judgemental approaches to forecasting and a significant
integrating forecasts from more knowledgeable advisors change of attitude on the part of researchers to the role
should not explicitly include their own forecasts among of judgement. Judgement is recognised as an
Year 2013

those that they combine and should consider avoiding indispensable component of forecasting and much
making their own forecasts altogether, the cognitive research attention has been directed at understanding
mechanisms responsible for these effects. and improving its use. Human judgement can be
A work was presented by Marcellinoet demonstrated to provide a significant benefit to
al.(2005)[29] on the “Iterated” multi period-ahead time forecasting accuracy but it can also be subject to many
22
series forecast and compared the empirical iterated and biases. Syntetosa and Boylan (2006) [35] presented
direct forecasts from linear uni-variate and bi-variate
D) Volume XIII Issuev vIV Version I

work on the stock control performance of intermittent


models by applying simulated out-of-sample methods. demand estimators. The nature of the empirical demand
Iterated forecasts was more efficient if the one-period data set evaluated and the stock control model specified
ahead model is correctly specified, but direct forecasts for experimentation purposes. The performance of the
are more robust to model misspecification. Wilson and new intermittent demand forecasting method was found
Gilbert (2005) [30] in their paper great emphasis were better than the other forecasting methods.
given to the emotional, psychological effect on the future
A work on the long term forecasting was
events. One cause of the impact bias was focalism, the
presented by Granger and Jeon (2007) [36]. Long-term
tendency to underestimate the extent to which other
forecasting is likely to be dominated by trend curves,
events will influence our thoughts and feelings. Another
particularly the simple linear and exponential trends.
was people’s failure to anticipate how quickly they will
However, the forecasts will be unsatisfactory with breaks
make sense of things that happen to them in a way that
in their parameter values at some unknown points. They
speeds emotional recovery. Affective forecasts were
investigate whether or not simple methods of long-run
important because people use many decisions on them.
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

forecasting can ever be successful, after one takes into


It may be overestimating the impact of negative events
account the uncertainty level associated with the
creates unnecessary dread and anxiety about the future
forecasts.
and results in costs to affective forecasting errors.
Chandra and Grabis (2005) [31] focussed on A comparison of support vector regression
the bullwhip effect. The results obtained do not provide (SVR) with the existing neural-network approaches and
evidence that magnitude of the bullwhip effect is larger the autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA)
for higher order autoregressive processes, but the model were done by Kuan-Yu Chen (2007) [37]to find
magnitude of the bullwhip effect is similar for the first out the feasibility of SVR and find out that SVR performs
order and the seasonal autoregressive demand better than the ARIMA models. Similarly, A work was
processes. A new methodology was presented by Horet presented by Nikolopoulos et al.(2007) [38] on
al. (2006)[32] using Auto Regressive Integrated Moving Forecasting with cue information: A comparison of
Average (ARIMA) model to predict daily load pattern. multiple regression with alternative forecasting
The work served as an initial step to investigate the approaches done on Multiple linear regression (MLR)
impacts of climate change and weather extremes on method and which was less accurate than a other
electricity demand patterns and the electricity network. methods when deals with the complex non-linearity’s
The forecasted load will be used as input to data.
transmission network model to study security and grid Bianco et al. (2007) [39] used Ensemble
reinforcement of the power network as the result of Kalman Filter to calibrate porosity fields used in a model
climate change. The model has fitted to an in sample for oil reservoir production. The dependence of
training data and the results were then verified with Ensemble Kalman Filter effectiveness on the number of
actual electricity data. The mean absolute percentage fields included in the statistical ensembles was
error (MAPE) for each month generally lies within 1-3%. performed by using three ensembles of 50, 100 and 135
Robert Fildes(2006) [33] analysed the different members and investigated the connection between
journals and showed that the comparative approach to Ensemble Kalman Filter effectiveness and the size of the
establishing improved forecasting methods through ensemble for a real problem. The limited number of
examining multiple hypotheses has been successfully ensembles considered did not give the chance to lead

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

to some ultimate conclusion on key points like the Hamzacebi et.al (2009) [47] focussed on the
number of fields required from a practical viewpoint. two methods, first was iterative method, in which
Two time series forecasting techniques neural- subsequent period information was predicted through
network & fuzzy compared by Pandey et al. (2008) [40] past observations and then the estimated value was
for wheat production forecastingand proposed a model. used as an input for the prediction of the next period.
By comparing the results it was found that proposed The process was carried out until the end of the forecast
model yields better results than the other method. Guoet horizon in multi-periodic time series forecasting. In the
al. (2008) [41] studied the characteristic of the pre- second, direct forecast method, successive periods
processing of sample data using wavelet transformation predicted all at once and yield better results as only
for forecast. The experimental results suggested that the observed data was utilized in order to predict future
proposed hybrid method is typically a reliable periods.
forecasting tool for time series technique superior to A work was presented by Goldstein and

Year 2013
standard SVM model. Two automatic forecasting Gigerenzer (2009)[48] on forecasting rules and shown
algorithms were described by Hyndman and Khandakar that simple statistical forecasting rules make better
(2008) [42].The first was based on innovations state predictions than more complex rules, especially when
space models that underly exponential smoothing the future values of a criterion is highly uncertain. They
methods and second is a step-wise algorithm for provide evidence that some of the fast and frugal 23
forecasting with ARIMA models. These algorithms are heuristics that people use intuitively are able to make

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


applicable to both seasonal and non-seasonal data, and forecasts that are better than those of knowledge-
compared using four real time series. intensive procedures. Petervon Stackelberg (2009)[49]
Datta et al. (2008)[43] focussed on the studied Timelines when used to lay out historical data
forecasting and risk analysis in supply chain. Advanced and cycles, and found that waves pattern along a
forecasting tools were applied for decision support in common temporal scaleprovide a far deeper, more
supply chain management and results suggest that nuanced understanding of the dynamics of change.
advanced methods may be useful to predict oscillated Timelines patterns can be used in a "hypothesis-to-
demand but their performance may be constrained by forecast" process to identify potential long-term patterns
current structural and operating policies as well as of change and make long-range forecasts whereas,
limited availability of data. Improvements to reduce Traditional forecasts are well suited for relatively short-
demand amplification may decrease the risk of out of term futures but, exploratory forecasts are better suited
stock but increase operating cost or risk of excess to forecasting longer-term futures.
inventory. A work was presented by Jushan and Serena A work on forecasting aggregate demand was

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


(2008) [44] on forecasting economic time series using published by Widiarta et al. (2009) [50]. The aggregate
targeted predictors studied two refinements to the demand series composed of several correlated sub
method of factor forecasting by applying the method of aggregate components, each of which was assumed to
principal components to `targeted predictors' selected follow a stationary time series process, which was
using hard and soft thresh holding rules. They correlated over time. They analytically showed that there
considered the methodof quadratic principal is no difference in the relative performance of TD and BU
components that allow the link function between the forecasting strategies when the time series for all of the
predictors and the factors to be non-linear. Second, the sub aggregate components follow a first-order univariate
factors used in the forecasting equation were estimated. moving average process with identical coefficients of the
A work on the long-term forecasting and trend serial correlation term.
forecasting was published by Dong and Pedrycz (2008) Sanders et al. (2009) [51] investigate forecast
[45]. Technique based on the fuzzy clustering was used smoothing in the USDA’s cotton production forecasts
to construct information granules on a basis of available and demonstrated how forecasting practitioners and
numeric data present in the original time series. A farm managers should correct the forecasts. Forecasts
forecasting model developed which captures the provide an important and cost effective source of public
essential relationships between such information forecast information, a graphical technique used for
granules and in this manner constructs a fundamental identifying and analyzing smoothing in forecast
forecasting mechanism and yield better results when revisions. Simple scatter plots in Excel provide a test for
processing a large number of data. Eric Sucky (2009) the existence of smoothing, and the corresponding
[46] presented a work on the bullwhip effect in supply regression line provides the corrective adjustments
chains. The variability of orders increases as they move needed to remove the impact of smoothing so that
up the supply chain from retailers to wholesalers to producers frequently can use agency forecasts to aid in
manufacturers to suppliers. They showed that while planning and decision making.
analyzing the bullwhip effect in supply chains, the A work was presented by Borade and Bansod
influence of risk pooling has to be considered, (2009)[52] on the supply chain management practices
Otherwise bullwhip effect will overestimated. for improving business or supply chain performance.

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

They discussed vendor managed forecasting with the system quality and access and a dependent variable
help of case study. They showed how a small enterprise measuring forecast performance. Forecasting
improves supply chain performance by using demand practitioners confirms a positive relationship between
related information obtained from retailer. The results specific forecasting support system characteristics and
obtained in the study shows that vendor managed the system user’s perceptions of system quality and
forecasting in supply chain reduces the demand access.
variation and improves inventory management A new approach named cycle forecasting
significantly. EWMA (CF-EWMA) was published by Bing Ai et al.
Concentrated on the forecasting approach of (2010) [59]. The new approach deal with the problem of
foreign trade unit value indices Lutero and Marini (2010) large deviations in the first few runs of each cycle. In
[53] presented their work.In their work the automatic case of mixed-product drifted process, they
Year 2013

selection strategy of TRAMO evaluated in comparison concentrated on the time lost on irregular break down
with a standard ARIMA model and then, a direct during the production time, these uneven breakdowns
forecasting approach experimented. They show that the deviate the results from the target value which will lead
automatic selection process of the ARIMA model carried to a possible high rework rate and lots of waste wafers.
out by TRAMO provides acceptable forecasts, on A work on the trend and seasonality patterns of
24
average better than those from the classical Airline a selected product in a retail trading chain was
model. . presented by Hasinet al. (2011) [60]using traditional
v vIV Version I

Berlec(2010) [54] presented a procedure for Holt-Winter’s model, artificial neural network (ANN) with
forecasting the lead times of production orders on the fuzzy uncertainty and then the errors, measured in terms
basis of past actual lead time data. The proposed of MAPE. The error level in Holt-Winter’s approach was
procedure for forecasting lead times was an empirical higher than those obtained through fuzzy ANN approach
distribution of possible lead times for a production order. because of influence of several factors on demand
D ) Volume XIII Issue

On the basis of this distribution, the probable lead time function in retail trading system. It was also observed
of a production order was forecast, taking into account a that as forecasting period becomes smaller, the ANN
confidence interval. Subsornet al. (2010) [55] approach provides more accuracy in forecast.
investigated the best-fitting forecasting model for A work was presented by Theodosiou (2011)
national rubber production forecasting.The methods [61] on hybrid forecasting method based on the
used in their study was based on non-neural network disaggregation of time series components. The
training and neural network training techniques and prediction of each component were done individually
compared with the actual rubber production data for the and the reassembling of the extrapolations to obtain
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

best-fitting forecasting model. estimation for the data. Generalized Regression Neural
A new version of support vector machine (SVM) Networks (GRNN) used to perform out-of sample
was presented by Qi Wu(2010) [56] named v –SVM. The extrapolations of the seasonal and residual components
new proposed model construct the nonlinear system of and shown good results. Leitner and Leopold (2011)
product demand series by combining the chaos theory, [62] reviewed several literatures and found that in most
evaluated and the simulation results demonstrated that experiments the forecasting abilities of individuals were
Cv-SVM is effective in dealing with multi-dimension data compared to rational forecasts or forecasts of statistical
and finite samples. Also, Cv-SVM has better MAE, MAPE models. In such a way results were very poor and the
and MSE than ARMA, GA v-SVM and ECGA v-SVM. inability to incorporate supportive information was the
Syntetos et al. (2010) [57] studied that the efficiency of main cause of forecasting inefficiency.
inventory systems does not relate directly to demand Similarly, Polerand Mula(2011) [63] presented a
forecasting performance, as measured by standard new automatic selection procedure of time series
forecasting accuracy measures. It should always be forecasting model proposed and the selection criterion
evaluated with respect to its consequences for stock has been tested using the set of monthly time series of
control through accuracy implications metrics, in the M3 Competition and two basic forecasting models.
addition to its performance on the standard accuracy Cardin and Castagna (2011) [64] presented a new
measures. They addressed the issue of judgementally application of discrete-event simulation as a forecasting
adjusting statistical forecasts for ‘fast’ demand items, tool for the decision support of the production activity
and the implications of such interventions in terms of control of a complex manufacturing system. The
both forecast accuracy and stock control. specificity of such an application of simulation is the
A work was presented by Smith and Mentzer short term of the forecast. This specificity implies that the
(2010) [58] on the relationship between forecasting initial state of the simulation takes into account the
support system, the procedures that guide forecast actual state of the system. The development on a real-
creation, and their fit with the capabilities of the size flexible manufacturing system shows the technical
forecasting support system user. The results showed a feasibility of the developed concepts and the potential
positive relationship between the user’s assessment of benefits on the productivity of a single example.

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

A work was presented by Miranda and Lima window and continuously updating scheme and
(2011) [65] on the forecasting of the challenging world methods that use less information appear to perform
future scenarios discussed the behaviour of the supply better than methods using all the sample information
and consumption of energy and food, two of the main about the covariance structure of the available forecasts.
commodities that drive the world system. They suggest Lee and Tong (2011) [72] worked on
that unless the currently prevailing focus on economic Forecasting time series using a methodology based on
growth is changed into that of sustainable prosperity, autoregressive integrated moving average and genetic
human society may run into a period of serious programming. They proposed a hybrid forecasting
economic and social struggles with unpredictable model for nonlinear time series by combining ARIMA
political consequences. with genetic programming (GP) to improve upon both
A new methodology was presented by Rossi the ANN and the ARIMA forecasting models. Finally,
and Sekhposyan (2011) [66] to identify the sources of some real data sets are adopted to demonstrate the

Year 2013
models’ forecasting performance. The methodology effectiveness of the proposed forecasting model.
decomposed the models’ forecasting performance into Xiang et al. (2011) [73] presented work on
asymptotically uncorrelated components that measure Multiagent Bayesian forecasting of structural time-
instabilities in the forecasting performance, predictive invariant dynamic systems with graphical models. They
content, and over-fitting. The results showed the new proposed a model called dynamic multiply sectioned
25
methodology is useful for understanding the causes of Bayesian network and showed that as long as the
the poor forecasting ability of economic models for DMSBN is structural time-invariant (possibly parametric

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


exchange rate determination. time-variant), the forecast is exact and its time
A new hybrid SARIMA wavelet transform method complexity is exponentially more efficient than using
for sales forecasting was presented by Choi et al. dynamic Bayesian networks (DBNs). Cheikhrouhou et al.
(2011) [67] combined the classic SARIMA method and (2011) [74] presented a judgemental collaborative
wavelet transform (SW). Experiments were conducted by approach for demand forecasting in which the
using real sales data, hypothetical data, and publicly mathematical forecasts, considered as the basis, were
available data sets and the time series features which adjusted by the structured and combined knowledge
influence the forecasting accuracy and new method from different forecasters. Factors corresponding to
shown good results. Petrie and Bannister (2011) [68] these events were evaluated through a fuzzy inference
presented a method for merging flow-dependentfore system to ensure the coherence of the results. They
cast error statistics from an ensemble with static show that by structuring and combining the judgements
statistics for use in high resolution variational data of different forecasters to identify and assess future
assimilation. In their study EnRRKF the forecast error events, companies can experience a high improvement

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


statistics in a subspace defined by an ensemble of in demand forecast accuracy.
states forecast by the dynamic model and then merged A methodology was proposed by Chang et al.
in a formal way with the static statistics and then used in (2012) [75] to evaluate individual and alternative mean
a variational data assimilation setting. forecasts using efficient estimation methods, and
Mukhopadhyay et al. (2011) [69] presented compared individual replicable forecasts with alternative
aStackelberg model of pricing of complementary goods mean forecasts. The empirical analysis showed that
under information asymmetry. They show that replicable and non-replicable forecasts could be
information sharing benefit the leader firm but hurt the distinctly different from each other, that efficient and
follower firm as well as the total system if the follower inefficient estimation methods, as well as consistent and
firm shares information unconditionally. They then devise inconsistent covariance matrix estimates, could lead to
a simple scheme which was beneficial for both the significantly different outcomes, alternative mean
system. Babai et al. (2011) [70] analysed a single forecasts could yield different forecasts from their
echelon single item inventory system. Where Demand individual components, and the relative importance of
was modelled as a compound Poisson process and the econometric model versus intuition could be evaluated
stock was controlled according to a continuous time in terms of forecasting performance.
order-up-to (OUT) level policy. They proposed a method A work was presented by Xu Yaboaet al. (2012)
for determining the optimal OUT level for cost oriented [76] on the safety in combination with production.
inventory systems and results showed that there was a Combination forecasting model can be used to the
significant difference in accuracy for slow moving items. actual forecast, in order to achieve the prior risk
Hsiao and Wan (2011) [71] suggested two modified forecasting of production safety trends and has shown
simple averaging forecast combination methods—a the good results. Obahet al.(2012)[77] working on
mean corrected and a mean and scale corrected Simplified Models for Forecasting Oil Production: Niger
method. They concluded that due to the fact that real Delta Oil Rim Reservoirs Case, studied Many factors
data was usually subjected to structural breaks, rolling affect both the reliability and accuracy of production
forecasting scheme has a better performance than fixed forecasts; the static or geological uncertainties, the

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

dynamic uncertainties and operational uncertainties. In work, Interorganizational Relationships and Unified
their study a generic dynamic simulation study was Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology was
carried out to generate oil production profiles from oil rim proposed and empirically validated. Matteo
reservoirs in the Niger Delta. Kalchschmidt (2012) [83] compared the different
Donate et al. (2012) [78] in this paper an novel perspectives by designing and testing different sets of
Evolutionary Artificial Neural Networks (EANNs) propositions that underline the aforementioned
approach used to build an ensemble of neural networks, perspectives. More than 500 companies collecting data
under four different combination methods: mean, was analyzed via the 4th edition of the Global
median, softmax and rank-based. Based on the Manufacturing Research Group (GMRG IV)
experimental results they suggested that the fitness questionnaire and the results demonstrated that each
weighted n-fold ensemble improves the accuracy of the perspective has some empirical support.Qin and
Year 2013

forecasts, outperforming both then no weight n-fold Nembhard (2012) [84] worked on the stochastic
ensemble and the simpler hold out validation(0-fold) diffusion of a product in the market as a geometric
EANN. Also, advised the use of a 4-fold ANN ensemble Brownian motion (GBM) process that has a time-varying
that evolved using weighted cross- validation and that drift rate. The model calibrated so that it was able to
uses a rank-based combination method to build the final feature different product types and diffusion conditions.
26
forecasts. The model demonstrated robust performance over a
Lehneret al. (2012) [79] presented a method, wide range of conditions despite model uncertainty and
v Version I

the inferred probability method, for quantitatively gave both qualitative and quantitative information for
measuring the accuracy of forecasts in documents that manufacturers and service providers to design
use imprecise language to describe both forecast strategies for stochastic PLC conditions as well as
events and forecast certainties. They applied the inferred dynamic production planning.
v IV

probability method to 14 documents that examine A work on Multi-objective integrated production


D ) Volume XIII Issue

significant and complex political events which were and distribution planning of perishable products was
considered the premier analysis product. Test focused presented by Amorim et al. (2012) [85]. They integrated
on three things: first, whether the inferred probability production and distribution planning approaches at
method yielded accuracy results that are in the same operational level and formulate a model for the case
range as more traditional forecasting studies in the where perishable goods have a fixed and a loose shelf-
same general topic area. Second, whether the accuracy life. The results showed that the economic benefits
results were biased by a readers’ knowledge of the topic derived from using an integrated approach were much
area, and third whether the accuracy results were dependent on the freshness level of products
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

sensitive to errors in assigning ground truth. delivered.Xu et al.(2012) [86]developed a product


Subramanian and Ramanathan (2012) [80] modularization model based on real options theory to
reviewed the applications of Analytic Hierarchy Process determine the optimal modular production strategies
in operations management. AHP has been largely under market uncertainty. They showed that when the
applied to macro and people oriented problems, the market is more volatile, it is optimal for a firm to
most addressed decision themes were product and postpone modularization, and when a firm’s investment
process design and, managing the supply chain. They efficiency at the preparation stage is higher, the firm can
presented a comprehensive listing of AHP applications start modular production earlier with relatively low
in operations management and develop a framework for product modularity. An increase in market uncertainty
identifying the decision areas that have better research will stimulate the firm to improve its product modularity.
gaps to be studied by future researchers. A two-step Beutel and Minner (2012) [87] presented two
forecasting method separately updates the average data-driven frameworks to set safety stock levels when
number of parts needed per repair and the number of demand depends on several exogenous variables. The
repairs for each type of component was proposed by first approach used regression models to forecast
Romeijnders et al.(2012) [81].The method was tested in demand and the second approach used Linear
an empirical, comparative study for a service provider in Programming. Both the methods exercised to a
the aviation industry. They showed that proposed common problem and results were compared. They
method performs considerably better than Croston’s showed a considerable improvement of the overly
method and forecasts errors cab be reduced up to 20% simplifying method of moments is possible and the
by planned maintenance and repair operations. ordinary least squares approach yields a better
Chan et al. (2012) [82] studied the factors that performance than the LP-method. But, the LP approach
influence the diffusion of e-collaboration in SCM among provides more robust inventory levels, if some of the
the SMEs. They proposed a research model to examine standard assumptions of ordinary least squares
a stage-based e-collaboration diffusion process in regression are violated. Money et al. (2012) [88]
SMEs. An integration technology adoption model based developed a baseline probabilistic model FINE
on Technological- Organizational - Environmental frame- (Forecasting the Impacts of Nanomaterials in the

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

Environment), was developed using expert elicitation A work was presented by Douglas et al. (2013)
techniques.a case of silver nano particles (Ag NPs) in [94] on Forecasting Innovation Pathways (FIP) for new
aquatic environments studied. They showed that and emerging science and technologies, offer a
Bayesian networks provide a robust method for formally framework to analyze NESTs to help ascertain likely
incorporating expert judgments into a probabilistic innovation pathways. They devised a 10-step framework
measure of exposure and risk to nanoparticles, based on extensive Future-oriented Technology
particularly when other knowledge bases may be Analyses (“FTA”) experience, and describing the
lacking, and Within the bounds of uncertainty as nanobiosensor experience in contrasted with that of
currently quantified, nanosilver may pose the greatest deep brain stimulation in relative quantitative and
potential risk as these particles accumulate in aquatic qualitative emphases analytically in two case studies.
sediments. The paper reflects on the systematic FTA framework for
A work on Demand Forecasting of Supply Chain emerging science and technologies, for its intended
Based on Support Vector Regression Method was goal, that is to support decision making.

Year 2013
presented by WANG Guanghui (2012) [89]. They Ubilavaand Helmers (2013) [95] examined the
introduced the basic theory and computing process of benefits of nonlinear time series modelling to improve
time series forecasting based on Support Vector forecast accuracy of the El Nino Southern Oscillation
Regression (SVR), optimizing the parameters of SVR by (ENSO) phenomenon. A smooth transition
Genetic Algorithm (GA) and then Applied SVR to autoregressive (STAR) modelling framework was 27
forecast the demand and finally, compared to the RBF adoptedto assess the potentially smooth regime-

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


neural network method.. They showed that SVR is dependent dynamics of the sea surface temperature
superior to RBF in prediction performance and the anomaly. They showedthat the superiority of forecast
suitable and effective method for demand forecasting of performance of STAR over the linear autoregressive
supply chain. models, especially apparent in short- and intermediate-
Xu and Ouenniche (2012) [90] proposed a term forecasts. Fye et al. (2013) [96] evaluated
Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) based technological forecasts to determine how forecast
framework to address the problem of relative methodology and eight other attributes influence
performance evaluation of competing forecasting accuracy, also evaluated the degree of interpretation
models. They show that the multidimensional framework required to extract measurable data from forecasts. They
provides a valuable tool to apprehend the true nature of found that quantitative forecast methods were more
the relative performance of competing forecasting accurate than forecasts using qualitative methods, and
models and the ranking of the best and the worst forecasts predicting shorter time horizons were more
performing models do not seem to be sensitive to the accurate than predicting for longer time horizons.

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


choice of importance weights or outranking methods. A Forecasts about computers and autonomous or robotic
review of literature on Sustainable business technologies were more accurate than those about other
development (SBD) in manufacturing and services was technologies, and of the nine attributes, only
done Gunasekar an and Spalanzani (2012) [91]. The methodology and time horizon had a statistically
papers on Sustainable business development were significant influence on accuracy. Gorr and Schneider
critically examined including tools, techniques and (2013) [97] applied receiver operating characteristic
strategies that would be helpful for SBD in future.A work analysis to micro-level, monthly time series from the M3-
on Singular spectrum analysis (SSA) was presented by Competition. Forecasts from competing methods were
Claudio (2013) [92] to decompose and forecast failure used in binary decision rules to forecast exceptionally
behaviours, using time series related to time-to-failure large declines in demand. Using the partial area under
data. Results were compared with previous approaches the ROC curve (PAUC) criterion, they found that
and show that SSA is a promising approach for data complex univariate methods (including Flores-Pearce 2,
analysis and for forecasting failure time series. Forecast PRO, Automat ANN, Theta, and Smart (FCS)
Bao et al. (2013) [93] studied the forecasting perform best for this purpose. Thedecision-rule
and optimization decisions in an experimental cobweb combination forecasts using three top methods
economy. They performed experimental study on the generally perform better than the component methods.
basis of: (1) subjects form forecasts only, (2) subjects From the evidence M3-Competition suggests that
determine quantity only, (3) they do both and (4) they practitioners should use complex univariate forecast
are paired in teams and one member was assigned the methods for operations-level forecasting, for both
forecasting role while the other was assigned the ordinary and large-change forecasts. A work was
optimization task. They showed that the performance presented by Heinecke et al. (2013) [98] on the
was the best in treatment 1 and the worst in Treatment 3. categorisation of stock keeping units (SKUs) and apply
Given a price forecast, subjects were less likely to make the most appropriate methods in each category. A bias
conditionally optimal production decisions in adjusted modification to CRO (Syntetos–Boylan
Treatment 3. Approximation, SBA) has been shown in a number of

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

empirical studies to perform very well and be associated records of forecasts and to use them appropriately
with a very ‘robust’ behaviour. The solutions were to obtain feedback.
compared by means of experimentation on more than • Forecast can be improved by reducing bias and
10,000 SKUs from three different industries. The results inconsistency in human judgement. Principles that
enable insights to be gained into the comparative have been formulated for doing this generally derive
benefits of these approaches. from research in cognitive psychology and allied
Asimakopoulos and Dix (2013) [99] examined subjects but have been validated within specific
the critical factors for the effective adoption and use of forecasting contexts.
forecasting support systems (FSS) in product • There are several other factors that affect the
forecasting. Using the technologies-in-practice model coordination including manufacturing capacity,
based on evidence from professional designers, users information systems capabilities and organizational
Year 2013

and organizational documents, found that FSS adoption issues like single period analysis which is suitable
and use depend on certain situational factors, such as for products with a very short life cycle.
organizational protocols, communication among • In case of Moving Average forecasting method, the
stakeholders, and product knowledge availability and more demandin formation is used to construct the
their outputs can be used as springboard for forecast to keep the smaller the increase in
28
organizational actions. A work on forecast accuracy was variability. Similarly, in case of Exponential
presented by Davyden koand Fildes (2013) [100]. They forecasting method, negatively correlated demands
v Version I

showed that many existing error measures are generally can lead to a larger increase in variability than
not suited to the task, due to specific features of the positively correlated demands. The more weight the
demand data. A metric based on aggregating forecast places on a single observation, the larger
performance ratios across time series using the the increase in variability.
v IV

weighted geometric mean yield better results and has • The ARIMA model provides more reliable demand
D ) Volume XIII Issue

the advantage of treating over- and under-forecasting forecasts but it is more complicated to apply than
even-handedly, has a more symmetric distribution. the decomposition model. Therefore the ARIMA
model should be used only when the decomposition
IV. Discussion model is inadequate.
From the review of literatures it is found that the • The bullwhip effect is due to the retailer's need to
main purpose of forecasting is to estimate the upcoming forecast. It is clearly seen that the increase in
demand in order for the organizations to make plan to variability will be greater for longer lead times.
create the products. The goal is to create as accurate However, the size of the impact does depend on the
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

forecasts as possible since accurate forecasts can be forecasting methods. The bullwhip effect is larger in
very profitable as forecasts help companies to meet the case of Exponential forecasting method than
upcoming demand. If forecasts are too low, profits are Moving Average with the same average data age
most likely lower due to lost sales. Forecasts which are and for certain demand processes.
too high will create excess inventory which will increase • The experimental results show that the forecasting
the inventory carrying costs and products might have to errors made by various neural-networks models
be sold at a discount and discarded as obsolescence. used only data-driven methods without model
From the literature surveys following points are identity, and that any prior assumptions about the
considered: properties of the data would be much smaller than
• Traditional forecasting methods include a few that of traditional ARIMA model.
explanatory variables, most of which can easily be • The neural network method is objective as
expressed in quantitative terms. compared to subjective fuzzy time series methods,
since in case of neural network interpretation is done
• Classical forecasting methods are both deterministic by only designed artificial neural network model. It
and structurally stable leading to error in forecasting can easily handle the inaccuracy and any degree of
because of constant change which is selectively nonlinearity in the data.
studied, and interpreted from a special view point. • Hybrid method is typically a reliable forecasting tool
• Traditional forecasting methods do not take into for application within the forecasting fields of time
account the development of new relationships series from social system, while the one without
among variables and possible changes in trends. wavelet analysis evaluated showed poor ability in
• Management information system should be forecast.
engineered to ensure that records of previous
V. Conclusion
forecasts should be kept with outcome data so that
people can easily compare the effectiveness of From the study of literature survey it has been
different types of forecast. It is important to keep observed that in order to reduce equipment costs, cycle

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

time, the correlation between task times and flexibility 10. Pisal Yenradeea, Anulark Pinnoi and Amnaj
ratio needs a great attention on accurate forecasting. Charoenthavornying (2001) “Demand Forecasting
Forecast of manufacturing is a very complex problem, and Production Planning for Highly Seasonal
which is influenced by many factors. How to identify the Demand Situations: Case Study of a Pressure
factors such as technology, labour and investment, etc., Container Factory” Science Asia 27, pp 271-278.
and considers them into the forecast model is the 11. Davor Svetinovic and Michael Godfrey (2001)
problems which will be researched in the future. “Attribute Based Software Evolution: Patterns and
Success or failure of the project greatly depends upon Product Line Forecasting” ICSE ’02 Buenos Aires,
the accurate forecasting; therefore method adopted Argentina.
must be perfect and best suited according to the 12. Everette S. Gardner Jr., Elizabeth A. Anderson-
circumstances. Because a wrong forecast may results in Fletcher, Angela M. Wicks (2001) “Further results on
the total wastage of money, power and time.The inability focus forecasting vs. exponential smoothing”

Year 2013
to incorporate supportive information is the main cause International Journal of Forecasting, Volume 17,
of forecasting inefficiency and remains a clear challenge Issue 2, Pages 287-293.
for all those engaged in the design of forecast support 13. Johanna Smaros (2001) “Peer-to-Peer Information
systems. Quantitative method produce better results Systems - An Enabler of Collaborative Planning,
than the Qualitative methods when rich historic data is Forecasting and Replenishment” The Logistics 29
available, simple, and accurate and less time Research Network 2001 Conference,

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


consuming. Edinburgh, UK.
14. Charles N. Smart (2002) “Accurate Intermittent
References Références Referencias Demand Forecasting for Inventory Planning New
1. Essam Mahmoud, Richard DeRoeck, Robert Brown, Technologies and Dramatic Results” APICS 2002
Gillian Rice (1992) “Bridging the gap between theory International Conference.
and practice in forecasting” International Journal of 15. Johanna Smaros (2002) “Collaborative Forecasting
forecasting, Volume 8, Issue 2, Pages 251-267. in Practice” the Logistics Research Network 2002
2. Malcolm Wright and Don Charlett (1995) “New Conference, Birmingham, UK..
Product Diffusion Models in Marketing: An 16. J. Paul Choudhury, BijanSarkar, S.K. Mukherjee
Assessment of Two Approaches” Marketing Bulletin (2002) “Forecasting of engineering manpower
6, pp 32-4. through fuzzy associative memory neural network
3. Heidi Winklhofer, Adamantios Diamantopoulos, with ARIMA: a comparative study” Neurocomputing
Stephen F. Witt (1996) “Forecasting practice: a 47, pp 241–257.

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


review of the empirical literature and an agenda for 17. Karel van Donselaar (2002) “Forecasting seasonal
future research” International Journal of Forecasting demand: a serious limitation of winters’ forecasting
12, pp193-221. procedure and the added value of product-
4. JukkaKorpcla, MarkkuTuominen (1996) “Inventory aggregation”.
forecasting with a multiple criteria decision tool” 18. Heidi M. Winklhofer, Adamantios Diamantopoulos
International Journal of production economics, 45 (2002) “ Managerial evaluation of sales forecasting
pp 159-168. effectiveness: A MIMIC modeling approach”
5. Moritz Fleischmann, Jacqueline M. Bloemhof- International Journal of Research in Marketing,
Ruwaard, Rommert Dekker (1997) “Quantitative Volume 19, Issue 2, Pages 151-166.
models for reverse logistics: A review” European 19. S.M. Disney, D.R. Towill (2003) “The effect of vendor
Journal of Operational Rcsearch 103, 1-17. managed inventory (VMI) dynamics on the Bullwhip
6. Francis X. Diebold (1998) “The Past, Present and Effect in supply chains” International Journal of
Future of Macroeconomic Forecasting” Journal of Production Economics 85, 199–215.
Economic Perspectives, 12, pp 175-192. 20. Po-Hsuan Hsu, Chi-Hsiu Wang, Joseph Z. Shyu,
7. Muruvvetcelikbas, J George, Shanthikumar and Hsiao-Cheng Yu (2003)“ A Litterman BVAR
Jayashankar M. Swaminathan (1999) “ Coordinating approach for production forecasting of technology
production quantities and demand forecasts industries” Technological Forecasting and Social
through penalty schemes” IIE Transactions 31, pp Change, Volume 70, Issue 1, Pages 67-82
851-864. 21. Boriss Siliverstovs and Dickvan Dijk (2003)
8. Gene Rowea and George Wright (1999) “The Delphi “Forecasting Industrial Production with Linear,
technique as a forecasting tool: issues and analysis” Nonlinear, and Structural Change Models”
International Journal of Forecasting 15, pp 353–375. Econometric Institute Report EI 2003-16.
9. Eddy Madiono Sutanto (2000) “Forecasting: The 22. G. Peter Zhang (2003) “Time series forecasting
Key to Successful Human Resource Management” using a hybrid ARIMA and neural network model”
JurnalManajemen & Kewirausahaan Vol. 2, pp 1-8. Neurocomputing 50, pp 159 – 175.

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

23. Allan Timmermann, Clive W.J. Granger (2004) 36. Clive W.J. Granger, Yongil Jeon (2007) “Long-term
“Efficient market hypothesis and forecasting” forecasting and evaluation” International Journal of
International Journal of Forecasting 20, pp 15– 27. Forecasting, Volume 23, Issue 4, Pages 539-551.
24. Johanna Smaros and Markus Hellstrom (2004) 37. Kuan-Yu Chen (2007) “Forecasting systems
“Using the assortment forecasting method to enable reliability based on support vector regression with
sales force involvement in forecasting: A case genetic algorithms” Reliability Engineering and
study” International Journal of Physical Distribution System Safety 92, pp 423–432.
& Logistics Management Vol. 34 No. 2, pp. 140-157. 38. K. Nikolopoulos, P. Goodwin, A. Patelis, and V.
25. HuiZou, Yuhong Yang (2004) “Combining time Assimakopoulos (2007) “Forecasting with cue
series models for forecasting” International Journal information: A comparison of multiple regression
of Forecasting 20, pp 69– 84. with alternative forecasting approaches” European
Year 2013

26. Kihoro, J.M., Otieno, R.O., Wafula, C (2004) Journal of Operational Research 180, pp 354–368.
“Seasonal time series forecasting: a comparative 39. Bianco, A., Cominelli, A., Dovera, L, Naevdal, G.,
study of ARIMA and ANN models” African Journal of Valles, B. (2007) “History Matching and Production
Science and Technology (AJST) Science and Forecast Uncertainty by Means of the Ensemble
30 Engineering Series Vol. 5, No. 2, pp 41-49.. Kalman Filter a Real Field Application” presentation
27. Dilek Önkal, Fergus Bolger 2004 “Provider–user at the SPE Europec/EAGE Annual Conference and
differences in perceived usefulness of forecasting Exhibition held in London, United Kingdom.
v Version I

formats” Omega, Volume 32, Issue 1, Pages 31-39. 40. Adesh Kumar Pandey, A.K Sinha, and V.K
28. Nigel Harvey, Clare Harries (2004) “Effects of Srivastava (2008) “A Comparative Study of Neural-
judges' forecasting on their later combination of Network & Fuzzy Time Series” IJCSNS International
v IV

forecasts for the same outcomes” International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security,
Journal of Forecasting, Volume 20, Issue 3, Pages 382 VOL.8 No.9.
D ) Volume XIII Issue

391-409. 41. Xuesong Guo, Linyan Sun, Gang Li and Song Wang
29. Massimiliano Marcellinoa, James H. Stockb, Mark (2008) “A hybrid wavelet analysis and support vector
W. Watson (2005) “A comparison of direct and machines” Expert Systems with Applications 35, pp
iterated multistep AR methods for forecasting 415–422.
macroeconomic time series” Journal of 42. Rob J. Hyndman and Yeasmin Khandakar (2008)
Econometrics 135, pp 499–526. “Automatic Time Series Forecasting The forecast”
30. Timothy D.Wilson and Daniel T. Gilbert (2005) Journal of Statistical Software, Volume 27, Issue 3.
“Affective Forecasting: Knowing What to Want”
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

43. ShoumenDatta, Clive W. J. Granger, Don P.


American Psychological Society Volume
Graham, Nikhil Sagar, Pat Doody, Reuben Slone
14-Number 3.
and Olli‐PekkaHilmola (2008) “Forecasting and Risk
31. Charu Chandra, Janis Grabis (2005) “Application of
Analysis in Supply Chain Management”.
multi-steps forecasting for restraining the bullwhip
effect and improving inventory performance under 44. Jushan Bai, Serena Ng (2008) “Forecasting
autoregressive demand” European Journal of economic time series using targeted predictors”
Operational Research 166, pp 337–350. Journal of Econometrics 146 (2008) 304317.
32. Ching-Lai Hor, Simon J. Watson and Shanti Majithia 45. Ruijun Dong, Witold Pedrycz (2008) “A granular time
(2006) “Daily Load Forecasting and Maximum series approach to long-term forecasting and trend
Demand Estimation using ARIMA and GARCH” 9th forecasting” Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its
International Conference on Probabilistic Methods Applications, Volume 387, Issue 13, Pages
Applied to Power Systems KTH, Stockholm, 3253-3270.
Sweden. 46. Eric Sucky (2009) “The bullwhip effect in supply
33. Robert Fildes (2006) “The forecasting journals and chains—An over estimated problem?” Int. J.
their contribution to forecasting research: Citation Production Economics 118 (2009)311–322.
analysis and expert opinion” International Journal of 47. Coskun Hamzacebi, Diyar Akay and Fevzi Kutay
Forecasting, Volume 22, Issue 3, Pages 415-432. (2009) “Comparison of direct and iterative artificial
34. Michael Lawrence, Paul Goodwin, Marcus neural network forecast approaches” Expert
O'Connor, Dilek Önkal (2006) “Judgmental Systems with Applications 36, pp 3839–3844.
forecasting: A review of progress over the last 25 48. Daniel G. Goldstein, Gerd Gigerenzer (2009) “Fast
years” International Journal of Forecasting, Volume and Frugal Forecasting” International Journal of
22, Issue 3, Pages 493-518. Forecasting, 25, pp 760-772.
35. Aris A. Syntetosa, John E. Boylanb (2006) “On the 49. Petervon Stackelberg (2009) “Footprints of the
stock control performance of intermittent demand Future: Timelines and Exploratory Forecasts in
estimators” Int. J. Production Economics 103 (2006) Futures Research” Journal of Futures Studies, pp
36–47. 13 – 34.

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

50. Handik Widiarta, S. Viswanathan and Rajesh Piplani several sources of information – A review of the
(2009) “Forecasting aggregate demand Ananalytical literature” European Journal of Operational
evaluation of top-down” nt. J. Production Economics Research 213, pp 459–469.
118, pp 87–94. 63. Raul Poler and Josefa Mula (2011) “Forecasting
51. Dwight R. Sanders, Ira J. Altman, Mark R. Manfredo model selection through out-of-sample rolling
and Rachel Anderson (2009) “Using USDA horizon weighted errors” Expert Systems with
Production Forecasts Adjusting for Smoothing” Applications 38, pp 14778–14785.
Journalof the ASFMRA. 64. Olivier Cardin and Pierre Castagna (2011) “Proactive
52. Atul Borad, Satish Bansod (2009) “Vendor managed production activity control by online” Int. J.
forecasting: A case study of small enterprise” Simulation and Process Modelling, Vol. 6, No.
Journal of industrial Engineering and management, 3, 2011.
vol-2(1): pp 153-175. 65. Luiz C.M. Miranda, C.A.S. Lima 2011 “On the

Year 2013
53. Giancarlo Lutero and Marco Marini (2010) “Direct vs forecasting of the challenging world future
Indirect Forecasts of Foreign Trade Unit Value scenarios” Technological Forecasting and Social
Indices” Rivista Di StatisticaUfficiale N. 2-3/2010. Change, Volume 78, Issue 8, October 2011, Pages
54. T. Berlec, P. Potocnik, E. Govekar and M. Starbek 1445-1470.
(2010)” Forecasting lead times of production orders 66. Barbara Rossi, Tatevik Sekhposyan (2011) 31
in SME’S” Iranian Journal of Science & Technology, “Understanding models’ forecasting performance”

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


Transaction B: Engineering, Vol. 34, No. B5, pp 521- Journal of Econometrics, Volume 164, Issue 1, 1
538. September 2011, Pages 158-172.
55. Panida Subsorn, Dr.Jitian Xiao and Dr. Judy 67. Tsan-Ming Choi, Yong Yu, Kin-Fan Au (2011) “A
Clayden () “Forecasting Rubber Production using hybrid SARIMA wavelet transform method for sales
Intelligent Time Series Analysis to Support Decision forecasting” Decision Support Systems 51 (2011)
Makers” V ISBN 978-953-307-069-8, pp. 342, March 130–140.
2010, INTECH, Croatian, 68. R.E. Petrie, R.N. Bannister “A method for merging
56. Qi Wu (2010) “The hybrid forecasting model based flow-dependent forecast error statistics from an
on chaotic mapping, genetic algorithm and support ensemble with static statistics for use in high
vector machine” Expert Systems with Applications resolution variational data assimilation” Computers
37, pp 1776–1783. & Fluids 46 (2011) 387–391.
57. Aris A. Syntetos, Konstantinos Nikolopoulos, John 69. Samar K.Mukhopadhyay, Xiaohang Yue, Xiaowei
E. Boylan 2010 “Judging the judges through Zhu (2011) “A Stackelberg model of pricing of

Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G


accuracy-implication metrics: The case of inventory complementary goods under information
forecasting” International Journal of Forecasting, asymmetry” Int. J. Production Economics 134 (2011)
Volume 26, Issue 1, January–March 2010, Pages 424–433.
134-143. 70. M.Z. Babai, Z. Jemai, Y. Dallery (2011) “Analysis of
58. Carlo D. Smith, John T. Mentzer (2010) “Forecasting order-up-to-level inventory systems with compound
task-technology fit: The influence of individuals, Poisson demand” European Journal of Operational
systems and procedures on forecast performance” Research 210 (2011) 552–558.
International Journal of Forecasting, Volume 26, 71. Cheng Hsiao, Shui Ki Wan “Comparison of
Issue 1, January–March 2010, Pages 144-16. forecasting methods with an application to
59. Bing Ai, Ying Zheng, Yanwei Wang, Shi-Shang Jang, predicting excess equity premium” Mathematics
Tao Song (2010) “Cycle forecasting EWMA (CF- and Computers in Simulation 81 (2011) 1235–12.
EWMA) approach for drift and fault in mixed-product 72. Yi-Shian Lee, Lee-Ing Tong (2011) “Forecasting time
run-to-run process” Journal of Process Control 20 series using a methodology based on
(2010), pp 689–708. autoregressive integrated moving average and
60. M. Ahsan Akhtar Hasin, ShuvoGhosh, and Mahmud genetic programming” Knowledge-Based Systems
A. Shareef (2011) “An ANN Approach to Demand 24 (2011) 66–72.
Forecasting in Retail Trade in Bangladesh” 73. Yang Xiang, James Smith, Jeff Kroes (2011)
International Journal of Trade, Economics and “Multiagent Bayesian forecasting of structural time-
Finance, Vol. 2, No. 2, April 2011. invariant dynamic systems with graphical models”
61. Marina Theodosiou (2011) “Disaggregation & International Journal of Approximate Reasoning 52
aggregation of time series components: A hybrid (2011) 960–977.
forecasting approach using generalized regression 74. 7Naoufel Cheikhrouhou, François Marmier, Omar
neural networks and the theta method” Ayadi, Philippe Wieser (2011) “A collaborative
Neurocomputing 74, pp 896–905. demand forecasting process with event-based fuzzy
62. Johannes Leitner and Ulrike Leopold-Wildburger judgements” Computers & Industrial Engineering 61
(2011) “Experiments on forecasting behavior with (2011) 409–421.

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

75. Chia-Lin Chang, Philip Hans Franses, Michael 88. Eric S. Money, Kenneth H. Reckhow, Mark R.
Mcaleer (2012) “Evaluating individual and mean Wiesner (2012)” The use of Bayesian networks for
non-replicable forecasts” Romanian Journal of nanoparticle risk forecasting: Model formulation and
Economic Forecasting – 3/2012. baseline evaluation” Science of the Total
76. Xu Yabo, Wang Tong, Song Bingxue, XieYushu Environment 426 (2012) 436–445.
(2012) “Forecasting of Production Safety Situation 89. WANG Guanghui (2012)“Demand Forecasting of
by Combination Model” Procedia Engineering 43, Supply Chain Based on Support Vector Regression
pp 132 – 136. Method” Procedia Engineering 29 (2012) 280 – 284.
77. Boniface Obah, Aniefiok Livinus, and Chima M. 90. Bing Xu a, Jamal Ouenniche (2012) “Performance
Ezugwu (2012) “simplified Models for Forecasting evaluation of competing forecasting models: A
Oil Production: Niger Delta Oil Rim Reservoirs Case” multidimensional framework based on MCDA”
Year 2013

Petroleum Technology Development Journal (ISSN Expert Systems with Applications 39 (2012) 8312–
1595-9104): An International Journal; 2012 - Vol. 2. 8324.
78. Peralta Donate, Paulo Cortez, German Gutierrez 91. Angappa Gunasekaran, Alain Spalanzani (2012)
Sanchez, Araceli Sanchis de Miguel (2012) “Time “Sustainability of manufacturing and services:
32 series forecasting using a weighted cross-validation Investigations for research and applications” Int. J.
evolutionary artificial neural network ensemble” Production Economics 140 (2012) 35–47.
Neurocomputing 109, pp 27–32 92. Claudio M. Rocco S (2013) “Singular spectrum
v Version I

79. Paul Lehner, Avra Michelson Leonard Adelman analysis and forecasting of failure time series”
Anna Goodman (2012) “Using inferred probabilities Reliability Engineering and System Safety 114, pp
to measure the accuracy of imprecise” Judgment 126–136.
v IV

and Decision Making, Vol. 7, No. 6 2012, pp. 728– 93. TeBao, John Duffy, Cars Hommes (2013) “Learning,
740. forecasting and optimizing: An experimental study”
D ) Volume XIII Issue

80. Nachiappan Subramanian, Ramakrishnan European Economic Review, Volume 61, 2013,
Ramanathan (2012) “A review of applications of Pages 186-204.
Analytic Hierarchy Process in operations 94. Douglas K.R. Robinson, Lu Huang, Ying Guo, Alan
management” Int. J. Production Economics 138 L. Porter (2013) “Forecasting Innovation Pathways
(2012) 215–241. (FIP) for new and emerging science and
81. Ward Romeijnders, Ruud Teunter, Willem van technologies” Technological Forecasting and Social
Jaarsveld (2012) “A two-step method for forecasting Change, Volume 80, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 267-285.
spare parts demand using information on 95. David Ubilava, C. Gustav Helmers (2013)
Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

component repairs” European Journal of “Forecasting ENSO with a smooth transition


Operational Research 220 (2012) 386–393. autoregressive model” Environmental Modelling &
82. Felix T.S.Chan a, AlainYee-LoongChong a, LiZhou Software, Volume 40, February 2013, Pages 181-
(2012) “An empirical investigation of factors 190.
affecting e-collaboration diffusion in SMEs” Int. J. 96. Shannon R. Fye, Steven M. Charbonneau, Jason W.
Production Economics 138 (2012) 329–344. Hay, Carie A. Mullins (2013) “An examination of
83. Matteo Kalchschmidt (2012) “Best practices in factors affecting accuracy in technology forecasts”
demand forecasting: Tests of universalistic, Technological Forecasting and Social Change,
contingency and configurational theories” Int. J. Volume 80, Issue 6, 2013, Pages 1222-123.1
Production Economics 140 (2012) 782–793. 97. Wilpen L. Gorr, Matthew J. Schneider (2013) “Large-
84. Ruwen Qin, DavidA. Nembhard (2012) “Demand change forecast accuracy: Reanalysis of M3-
modeling of stochastic product diffusion over the life Competition data using receiver operating
cycle” Int. J. Production Economics 137 (2012) characteristic analysis” International Journal of
201–210. Forecasting, Volume 29, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 274-
85. P. Amorim, H.-O.Gunther, B. Almada-Lobo (2012) 281.
“Multi-objective integrated production and 98. G. Heinecke, A.A. Syntetos, W. Wang 2013 “
distribution planning of perishable products” Int. J. Forecasting-based SKU classification” International
Production Economics 138 (2012) 89–101. Journal of Production Economics, Volume 143,
86. Su XiuXu, Qiang Lu, Zhuoxin Li (2012) “Optimal Issue 2, June 2013,Pages 455-462.
modular production strategies under market 99. Stavros Asimakopoulos, Alan Dix (2013)
uncertainty: A real options perspective” Int. J. “Forecasting support systems technologies-in-
Production Economics 139 (2012) 266–274. practice: A model of adoption and use for product
87. Anna-Lena Beutel, Stefan Minner (2012) “Safety forecasting” International Journal of Forecasting,
stock planning under causal demand forecasting” Volume 29, Issue 2, April June 2013, Pages
Int. J. Production Economics 140 (2012) 637–645. 322- 336.

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)


Industrial Forecasting Support Systems and Technologies in Practice: A Review

100. Andrey Davydenko, Robert Fildes (2013)


“Measuring forecasting accuracy: The case of
judgmental adjustments to SKU-level demand
forecasts” International Journal of Forecasting,
Volume 29, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 510-522.

Year 2013
33

D ) Volume XIII Issue vIV Version I


Global Journal of Researches in Engineering ( G

© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US) 

Potrebbero piacerti anche