Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
(overview)
Research
Clarification
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY I
PRESCRIPTIVE STUDY
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY II
Lucienne Blessing
3TU PhD Event
June 2010
Lucienne Blessing
Lucienne Blessing
Lucienne Blessing
Lucienne Blessing
Lucienne Blessing
Lucienne Blessing
Lucienne Blessing
Lucienne Blessing
Understanding
organisation
micro-economy
process
Support
macro-economy
people
Lucienne Blessing
10
Lucienne Blessing
11
Problem
Generalization
Hypotheses
Theory
Research design
Data analysis
Data collection
3TU PhD Event June 2010
Measurement
Lucienne Blessing
12
Lucienne Blessing
13
Challenge:
Lucienne Blessing
14
Stages
Literature &
Analysis
Research
Clarification
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY I
Assumption &
Experience &
Synthesis
PRESCRIPTIVE STUDY
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY II
Lucienne Blessing
Results
Goals
Understanding
Support
Evaluation
15
Example project
Goal:
Improve the reliability of products to improve product
performance (increase sales).
Assumptions:
Improved reliability improves product performance
Improved product performance increases sales
Timely assessment of reliability increases the changes of
improving product reliability
Available support is ineffective
Research questions:
Are the assumptions correct?
How to improve?
Lucienne Blessing
16
to identify the goals the research is expected to realise; the focus; the
main research problems, questions and hypotheses; the relevant
disciplines and areas to be reviewed and those to contribute:
to develop an initial representation of the existing and of the desired
situation, the Initial Reference and Impact Models
Determine
the initial set of influencing factors thought to be relevant
those factors that may be suitable success criteria;
the believed links between the factors in the existing as well as
the desired situation, in particular those linked to the success
criteria;
Lucienne Blessing
17
Market share
_
+ [A]
Maintenance
cost
[A]
_
+
_ [A]
_
Company
image
Amount of
profit
Market share
_ + [A]
[A]
+
Product
reliability
[A]
+ + [A]+
Support
Company
image
Maintenance
cost
[A]
Product
reliability
18
to identify the goals the research is expected to realise; the focus; the
main research problems, questions and hypotheses; the relevant
disciplines and areas to be reviewed and those to contribute:
to develop Initial Reference and Impact Models, i.e., an initial picture of
the existing and of the desired situation;
to provide a focus for the DS-I stage in finding the factors that
contribute to, hinder or prohibit success;
Lucienne Blessing
19
Stages
Literature &
Analysis
Research
Clarification
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY I
Assumption &
Experience &
Synthesis
PRESCRIPTIVE STUDY
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY II
Lucienne Blessing
Results
Goals
Understanding
Support
Evaluation
20
Methods:
Lucienne Blessing
21
Reading literature
Lucienne Blessing
22
Empirical studies
Some essentials:
the aim,
the research questions and/or hypotheses,
the type of data collected,
the way it is collected, processed and analysed,
the interpretations and conclusions
all match.
Get advice and try out
Focus, focus, focus
Lucienne Blessing
23
Lucienne Blessing
24
Reference Model
Success Criterion
_
Market share
Other factors
Measurable
Criterion
Quality of
production
[1]
Price
+
0
[2]+ [A]_
[1]
+
Customer
satisfaction
_
_ [1]
+
[4]
+
Warranty
cost
[3,4]
[1]
+
Product
reliability
+
Operating
cost
+
+ [3]
+
Maintenance
cost
Quality of
product
+
[5]
[3]
_
Key Factor
Other factors
_
Productspecificity of
DfR- methods
3TU PhD Event June 2010
[A]
0[E]
+ +
Use of
DfR-methods
Lucienne Blessing
% of
project time left
to improve
25
Lucienne Blessing
26
Stages
Literature &
Analysis
Research
Clarification
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY I
Assumption &
Experience &
Synthesis
PRESCRIPTIVE STUDY
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY II
Lucienne Blessing
Results
Goals
Understanding
Support
Evaluation
27
Prescriptive Study
The role of the Prescriptive Study stage is:
Lucienne Blessing
28
Impact Model
preliminary
Success
Factor
market share
price
+[2]
+
other factors
customer
satisfaction
warranty
cost
[1]
++
product
reliability
other factors
use of
DfR methods
3TU PhD Event June 2010
_
_
maintenance
cost
quality of
product
quality of
production
operating
cost
_
_
+
+
preliminary Measurable
Succsss Factor
_
_
preliminary
Key Factor
+
% of
project time left
to improve
Lucienne Blessing
assess
reliability
in early design
stages
29
Prescriptive Study
The role of the Prescriptive Study stage is:
Lucienne Blessing
30
functionality of
Actual Support
core
contribution
functionality of
Intended Support
Lucienne Blessing
31
Prescriptive Study
The role of the Prescriptive Study stage is:
Lucienne Blessing
32
Stages
Literature &
Analysis
Research
Clarification
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY I
Assumption &
Experience &
Synthesis
PRESCRIPTIVE STUDY
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY II
Lucienne Blessing
Results
Goals
Understanding
Support
Evaluation
33
Descriptive Study II
The role of Descriptive Study II is to identify:
Application Evaluation
Success Evaluation
(Model evaluations)
Lucienne Blessing
34
Evaluation
preliminary
Success
Factor
market share
price
+[2]
+
other factors
customer
satisfaction
warranty
cost
product
reliability
other factors
use of
DfR methods
3TU PhD Event June 2010
Application evaluation
[1]
++
Success evaluation
_
_
maintenance
cost
quality of
product
quality of
production
operating
cost
_
_
+
+
preliminary Measurable
Succsss Factor
_
_
preliminary
Key Factor
Support evaluation
+
% of
project time left
to improve
Lucienne Blessing
assess
reliability
in early design
stages
35
Keypoints
DRM emphasises
Lucienne Blessing
36
Stages
Literature &
Analysis
Research
Clarification
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY I
Assumption &
Experience &
Synthesis
PRESCRIPTIVE STUDY
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY II
Lucienne Blessing
Results
Results
Goals
Understanding
Support
Evaluation
37
As to DRM:
Lucienne Blessing
38