Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CITATIONS
READS
41
3 authors:
Pieter J Carpentier
Philip Asherson
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
Ulrich Mller
University of Cambridge
166 PUBLICATIONS 5,036 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Online Survey on Mind Wandering, Creativity, Education, and Occupation View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Pieter J Carpentier on 05 November 2016.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
30
ADHD: Pathways into Addiction,
Diagnosis and Pharmacotherapy
P i e t e r - J a n C a r p e n t i e r, P h i l i p A s h e r s o n
and Ulrich Mller
Introduction
The diagnosis of ADHD in adult patients
with substance use disorders (SUDs) is a
relatively new concept. Although the first
reports of an association between ADHD and
addiction date from around 1970, only in the
last two decades has the high prevalence of
ADHD in SUDs patients been more systematically evaluated.
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 491
In view of the high prevalence of this hitherto unrecognised disorder and the possible
lack of specificity of some of its symptoms,
a central issue has been the validity of the
diagnosis, although this has now been substantially addressed by several authors and
guideline groups (Faraone, 2005; National
Collaborating Centre for Mental Health,
2009). The first descriptions in children are
now a century old. Nevertheless, the ADHD
diagnosis in adults is still relatively new and
unknown, despite the first clear descriptions
by Wender, Wood and other authors in the
mid-1970s (Wood etal, 1976). In part this is
due to the decrease of motor hyperactivity
with age, which is one of the more overt and
eye-catching characteristics of the disorder
in childhood. In adulthood, ADHD symptoms are often less noticed, because adults
have learned to compensate and to adapt to a
certain extent. While motor hyperactivity
may have decreased or disappeared, the
bothersome inner restlessness is hardly
9/22/2016 12:01:10 PM
492
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 492
9/22/2016 12:01:11 PM
493
* Age criterion: Six or more symptoms of inattention/hyperactivity and impulsivity for children up to age 16, or five or more
for adolescents 17 and older and adults.
Duration: symptoms have been present for at least 6 months, and are inappropriate for developmental level.
(and even in old age). The problem of underdiagnosis of ADHD in adults has long been
overlooked, and has only come to the attention of professionals and general public in
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 493
the past two decades. In adults, the worldwide prevalence has now been estimated to
be around 2.54.3% (Kessler et al, 2006;
Fayyad et al, 2007; Simon et al, 2009).
9/22/2016 12:01:11 PM
494
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 494
Neurobiology of ADHD
ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder
with genetic, environmental and biological
aetiologies. Genetic influences are established with high heritability estimated to be
in the range of 7080% in children, adolescents and adults (Faraone etal, 2005; Chang
etal, 2013; Larsson etal, 2013). Until now,
molecular genetic studies have only revealed
a limited number of candidate genes associated with ADHD, each of which making no
more than a small contribution to the development of the disorder. A number of these
genes are involved in dopamine and serotonin neurotransmission (Faraone etal, 2005).
Recent genome wide-scan research has also
identified genes that are involved in neural
cell growth and metabolism (Lasky-Su etal,
2008; Poelmans etal, 2011). Presently, little
9/22/2016 12:01:11 PM
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 495
495
9/22/2016 12:01:11 PM
496
Medication
Standard adult
daily dosage
Efficacy in RCTs
Methylphenidate
30 80 mg
Dexamphetamine
15 40 mg
Atomoxetine
40 100 mg
Bupropion
300 450 mg
Desipramine
(tricyclic
antidepressant)
100 200 mg
Venlafaxine
75 225 mg
Guanfacine
1 4 mg
no RCTs
Clonidine
0.1 0.4 mg
no RCTs
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 496
Remarks
Abuse potential of short-acting
formulations
Abuse potential of short-acting
formulations
Not a stimulant, no abuse
potential, continuous
efficacy
No abuse potential
More effective for hyperactivity/
impulsivity than for
concentration problems; side
effects limit use
Positive findings in open studies
(Findling etal, 1996;
Upadhyaya etal, 2001)
Effective in children and
adolescents, not well studied
in adult ADHD
Effective in children and
adolescents, not well studied
in adult ADHD.
Side effects limit use
9/22/2016 12:01:11 PM
Clinical characteristics
In the majority of addicted patients currently
identified with ADHD, the diagnosis of
ADHD has never been made previously and
they have never received treatment for the
condition as children. Contrary to what has
often been assumed, and in line with the
prevalence studies, SUD patients with ADHD
do not seem to have a selective preference for
stimulant psycho-active drugs, such as cocaine
or amphetamines; rather they tend to use sedative medications, most commonly cannabis
and alcohol and sometimes heroin (Clure etal,
1999). It is quite common to encounter polydrug abuse among addiction patients with
ADHD. Some patients report paradoxical
effects of stimulants such as amphetamines
and cocaine. They can become calm and
focused, instead of driven and agitated. Such
experiences are strongly suggestive of ADHD,
but do not form firm proof of the diagnosis.
Furthermore, not all patients with ADHD will
react positively to psychostimulants in this
way particularly if they use higher dosages
and intravenous or intranasal routes of administration. Adults with ADHD may also describe
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 497
497
9/22/2016 12:01:12 PM
498
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 498
9/22/2016 12:01:12 PM
Prognosis
The course of an addiction seems to be more
protracted, and treatment more difficult, in
SUD patients with untreated ADHD than in
SUD patients without ADHD. Patients with
ADHD seem to derive less benefit from treatment for SUDs, show poorer treatment compliance and have greater difficulty with
achieving and maintaining abstinence
(Wilens etal, 1998; Levin etal, 2004). It is
likely that core symptoms of ADHD (e.g.
disorganisation, impulsiveness, restless agitation) and associated features (e.g. emotional instability) contribute to earlier
substance use relapse. In addition, ADHD
cannot be treated adequately until the addiction has been stabilised. Therefore, the two
disorders need to be treated together, preferably in an integrated approach.
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 499
499
Treatment
Treatment planning
In adult as well as in childhood ADHD, psychiatric comorbidity can have a major impact
9/22/2016 12:01:12 PM
500
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 500
Pharmacological treatment
There are still no widely accepted guidelines
for the appropriate pharmacological treatment of ADHD in the presence of SUDs
(Perez de Los Cobos etal, 2012). In principle, the same medication is prescribed as
that for ADHD adults without SUDs (Mariani
& Levin, 2007). Mainly for practical reasons, the lack of acute effects, the slow and
9/22/2016 12:01:12 PM
501
Table 30.3Randomised controlled trials of ADHD medication in adolescent (in italics) and
adult SUD patients
Study, year
Schubiner, 2002
Riggs, 2004
(adolescents)
Carpentier, 2005
Levin, 2006
Levin, 2007
Wilens, 2008
Thurstone, 2010
(adolescents)
Konstenius, 2010
McRae-Clark, 2010
Riggs etal, 2011
(adolescents)
Konstenius, 2013
Levin, 2015
Sample
size
SUD Type
Effect on
ADHD*
Effect on
SUD*
48
69
Cocaine
Various
Methylphenidate IR 3 30 mg
Pemolide, 75112.5 mg
+
+
0
0
25
98
Various
Opioid (MMT**)
0
0
0
++
0
0 (+)
+
0
106
80
70
Cocaine
Alcohol
Various
Methylphenidate IR, 3 15 mg
Methylphenidate SR, 2 2040 mg
Bupropion, 400 mg
Methylphenidate SR, 40 + 20 mg
Atomoxetine, 25100 mg
Atomoxetine, 25100 mg
24
38
303
Amphetamine
Cannabis
Various
Methylphenidate (OROS), 72 mg
Atomoxetine
Methylphenidate (OROS), 72 mg
0
+
(+)
0
0
(+)
54
126
Amphetamine
Cocaine
++
++
+
++
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 501
9/22/2016 12:01:12 PM
502
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 502
9/22/2016 12:01:13 PM
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 503
503
long-acting formulations are clearly indicated in this patient group. As these extended
release preparations or atomoxetine are not
available or reimbursed in all countries, it
may still be necessary to prescribe traditional immediate-release psychostimulants.
Efforts should be made to ensure that a
range of formulations and medications are
available to avoid this situation as far as is
possible. In the meantime, a safe strategy is
to prescribe these short-acting medications
under strict conditions only, and to discontinue prescription when these conditions are
not met. The central issue in this strategy is
a reliable working alliance with the patient.
The patient must be informed about the risks
of the medication and must agree to the conditions of its use. Continued prescription of
the medication should only take place after
a trial period demonstrating convincing
effectiveness of the medication. Especially
in the beginning medication should be dispensed in small quantities. An interesting
option is to involve a person close to the
patient, supervising the correct and regular
intake of the medication. Abstinence (or in
some cases agreed controlled maintenance)
during treatment is not only a precondition
for optimal effectiveness, but also an indication of the commitment of the patient to
the therapy. The same applies to meeting
appointments and participating in treatment.
Under these strict circumstances, psychostimulants can be used sufficiently safely
by this patient group. Moreover, the abovementioned controlled studies have demonstrated that psychostimulant use does not
lead to an increase in substance use (Wilens
etal, 2005b).
However, it is also important to be aware
of the poor therapy compliance associated
with multiple dosages per day to be taken
at fixed times (Swanson, 2003). Medication
adherence is always a concern in pharmacotherapy, but even more of an issue in this
patient group. The strict and repetitive dosage of short-acting psychostimulants is particularly difficult for people with ADHD, and
9/22/2016 12:01:13 PM
504
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 504
9/22/2016 12:01:13 PM
Psychosocial treatment
Besides medication treatment, further psychotherapy and psychosocial support are
certainly indicated in patients with ADHD
and SUDs to preserve the prospect of stabilising the two disorders (Mariani & Levin,
2007). Appropriate treatment of the addiction, such as relapse prevention, is necessary
to maintain abstinence. In many patients,
ADHD will be diagnosed for the first time
during their addiction treatment: psychoeducation and cognitive therapy for ADHD will
help them to accept the diagnosis, improving
their adaption to their limitations (Safren
et al, 2005; Solanto et al, 2010; Emilsson
etal, 2011). The cognitive therapies have not
yet been systematically evaluated in SUD
patients (Magon & Mueller, 2012). However,
in several medication randomised controlled
trials (RCTs), concurrent treatment of the
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 505
505
9/22/2016 12:01:13 PM
506
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 506
Prevention
ADHD in children has been identified as a
risk factor for addiction in later life.
Longitudinal studies of ADHD children followed into early adulthood have clearly indicated the increased risk for SUDs in ADHD
(Molina & Pelham, Jr., 2003; Molina et al,
2007; Charach etal, 2011; Klein etal, 2012).
In all these studies, participants, identified
with ADHD in childhood and followed up
into early adulthood show higher rates of
various SUDs, compared to normal controls.
These observations make for an excellent
target for preventive efforts. The problem
(addiction) is quite relevant, the risk group
(children with ADHD) is readily identifiable,
and an effective therapy is available.
However, the question whether effective
treatment of ADHD in childhood can
decrease this risk of SUDs, can only be
answered conclusively by long-term studies
which are hard to organise and take time.
Until recently, the consensus was that
a preventive effect of ADHD treatment in
childhood on the development of addiction
remained to be demonstrated (Molina et al,
2013; Goldstein, 2013; Humphreys et al,
2013). However recent studies suggest there
may indeed be a protective effect (Chang
et al, 2014). Using Swedish national registers, the authors studied all individuals born
between 1960 and 1998 and diagnosed with
ADHD (26,249 men and 12,504 women).
Substance abuse was found to be 31% lower
among those prescribed ADHD medication 3
years previously compared to those not prescribed medication. Similar risk reductions
were suggested among children. Overall their
data suggested a long-term protective effect
on substance abuse. There are more positive
reports: for example, earlier treatment seems
to offer more protective results (Mannuzza
et al, 2008; Dalsgaard et al, 2014). A more
recent well-executed longitudinal study demonstrated a protective effect of medication in
childhood (Groenman etal, 2013). A Danish
population study on the influence of ADHD
9/22/2016 12:01:13 PM
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 507
507
Future research
For research purposes, ADHD is an interesting model for the study of the development of
problematic substance use in patients with a
pre-existing psychiatric disorder (Wilens &
Biederman, 2006). In spite of clear evidence
of the aetiological role of ADHD in the development and persistence of problematic substance use, most interventions targeted at
ADHD have not shown the expected preventive or stabilising effect. All this points to the
fact that the relation between ADHD and
addiction is more complicated than expected,
and ADHD treatment is far less straightforward than in adult patients with ADHD but
without addiction. The complexity of the
combination of a heterogeneous disorder like
ADHD and a multi-causal disorder like addiction, in the dynamic context of the developing
brain during adolescence, the period of experimenting and drug use initiation, is certainly
part of the explanation. Both from a therapeutic and a preventive point of view, additional
research is needed to improve our understanding of this complex relation and improve
the efficacy of therapeutic options.
Increased knowledge of the aetiology of
ADHD and addiction, and their common and
separate contributing factors, will help to
identify targets for preventive and therapeutic
9/22/2016 12:01:13 PM
508
intervention. More detailed longitudinal studies starting in childhood can help to identify
prognostic factors, and also determine the
influence of timing of different interventions
in the eventual outcome. For ADHD adults
with addictions, a major challenge will be
improving the efficacy of ADHD treatment in
more complex patients. In addition to RCTs,
individualised pharmacotherapy studies can
be considered, in which several medications
(in sufficient dosages) are tried, according to
a protocol, again looking for (genetic) predictive factors. As discussed a specific cognitive
therapy for this dual diagnosis needs to be
developed and tested. As pharmacotherapy
in itself is insufficiently effective to stabilise
ADHD and SUD, a naturalistic study could
look at the effects of an integrated treatment
of this complex disorder.
Conclusion
In spite of the accomplishments discussed
above, ADHD in addiction remains a domain
full of clinical and research challenges.
Uncomplicated ADHD may be quite treatable in children and adults, but these same
interventions are simply not as effective in
addicted ADHD patients. Clinicians should
not be discouraged by these sobering results,
as we get more and more indications how to
do it right: individualising the treatment and
integrating pharmacotherapy with active psychosocial interventions.
ADHD is one of many aetiological factors in the development and persistence of
addiction. ADHD in itself may have limited influence in this process, but offers the
important advantage of preventive and therapeutic possibilities. In anticipation of further
research, more attention to this disorder in
clinical practice may provide indications for
improving treatment effectiveness, leading
to a clearer determination of the relevance
of ADHD in the diagnosis and treatment of
addicted patients.
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 508
References
Adler, L. & Cohen, J. (2004) Diagnosis and
evaluation of adults with attention-deficit/
hyperactivity disorder. Psychiatr. Clin. North
Am., 27, 187201.
Adler, L.A., Shaw, D.M., Kovacs, K., & Alperin,
S. (2015) Diagnosing ADHD in children and
adults. In: Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder in Adults and Children (ed. L. A. Adler,
T. J. Spencer, & T. E. Wilens), pp. 1623.
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Almeida Montes, L.G., Hernandez Garcia, A.O.,
& Ricardo-Garcell, J. (2007) ADHD prevalence in adult outpatients with nonpsychotic
psychiatric illnesses. J Atten. Disord., 11,
1506.
Arcos-Burgos, M., Velez, J.I., Solomon, B.D., &
Muenke, M. (2012) A common genetic network underlies substance use disorders and
disruptive or externalizing disorders. Hum.
Genet., 131, 91729.
Barkley, R.A. (2006a) A theory of ADHD. In:
Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: a
handbook for diagnosis and treatment (ed.
R. A. Barkley), pp. 297336. The Guilford
Press, New York.
Barkley, R.A. (2006b) Etiologies. In: AttentionDeficit Hyperactivity Disorder: a handbook
for diagnosis and treatment (ed. R. A.
Barkley), pp. 21947. The Guilford Press,
New York.
Biederman, J. (2011) The course and persistence of ADHD throughout the life-cycle. In:
ADHD in Adults: Characterization, diagnosis
and treatment (ed. J. K. Buitelaar, C. C. Kan,
& P. Asherson), pp. 18. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Biederman, J. & Faraone, S.V. (2005) Attentiondeficit hyperactivity disorder. Lancet, 366,
23748.
Biederman, J., Monuteaux, M.C., Spencer, T.,
Wilens, T.E., Macpherson, H.A., & Faraone,
S.V. (2008a) Stimulant therapy and risk for
subsequent substance use disorders in male
adults with ADHD: a naturalistic controlled
10-year follow-up study. Am. J. Psychiatry,
165, 597603.
Biederman, J., Petty, C.R., Wilens, T.E., Fraire,
M.G., Purcell, C.A., Mick, E., Monuteaux,
M.C., & Faraone, S.V. (2008b) Familial risk
analyses of attention deficit hyperactivity
9/22/2016 12:01:14 PM
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 509
509
9/22/2016 12:01:14 PM
510
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 510
9/22/2016 12:01:14 PM
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 511
511
9/22/2016 12:01:15 PM
512
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 512
9/22/2016 12:01:15 PM
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 513
513
9/22/2016 12:01:15 PM
514
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 514
9/22/2016 12:01:15 PM
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 515
515
delay aversion in attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: nosologic and diagnostic implications. Child Adolesc. Psychiatr. Clin. N. Am,
17, 36784, ix.
Spencer, T., Biederman, J., Wilens, T.E., & Faraone, S.V. (1998) Adults with attention-
deficit/hyperactivity disorder: a controversial
diagnosis. J. Clin. Psychiatry, 59 Suppl 7,
5968.
Spencer, T., Wilens, T., Biederman, J., Faraone,
S.V., Ablon, J.S., & Lapey, K. (1995) A double-blind, crossover comparison of methylphenidate and placebo in adults with
childhood-onset attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry, 52,
43443.
Steinhausen, H.C. & Bisgaard, C. (2014) Substance use disorders in association with
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, comorbid mental disorders, and medication in
a nationwide sample. Eur. Neuropsychopharmacol., 24, 23241.
Stovner, A.M., Wyller, T.B., Skulberg, A., Os, L.,
& Korsmo, G. (1996) [Treatment of hyperactivity and attention deficit with amphetamine. Experience with five adult prisoners].
Tidsskr. Nor Laegeforen., 116, 20025.
Swanson, J. (2003) Compliance with stimulants
for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder:
issues and approaches for improvement.
CNS Drugs, 17, 11731.
Tamm, L., Trello-Rishel, K., Riggs, P., Nakonezny, P.A., Acosta, M., Bailey, G., & Winhusen, T. (2013) Predictors of treatment
response in adolescents with comorbid substance use disorder and attention-deficit/
hyperactivity disorder. J. Subst. Abuse Treat.,
44, 22430.
Teter, C.J., McCabe, S.E., LaGrange, K., Cranford, J.A., & Boyd, C.J. (2006) Illicit use of
specific prescription stimulants among college students: prevalence, motives, and
routes of administration. Pharmacotherapy,
26, 150110.
Thomas, M.J., Kalivas, P.W., & Shaham, Y.
(2008) Neuroplasticity in the mesolimbic
dopamine system and cocaine addiction. Br.
J. Pharmacol., 154, 32742.
Thurstone, C., Riggs, P.D., Salomonsen-Sautel,
S., & Mikulich-Gilbertson, S.K. (2010) Randomized, controlled trial of atomoxetine for
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in
9/22/2016 12:01:15 PM
516
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 516
9/22/2016 12:01:15 PM
(2005a) Characteristics of adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder plus substance use disorder: the role of psychiatric
comorbidity. Am. J. Addict., 14, 31927.
Wilens, T.E., Monuteaux, M.C., Snyder, L.E.,
Moore, H., Whitley, J., & Gignac, M. (2005b)
The clinical dilemma of using medications in
substance-abusing adolescents and adults
with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder:
what does the literature tell us? J. Child Adolesc. Psychopharmacol., 15, 78798.
Willcutt, E.G. (2012) The prevalence of DSM-IV
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: a
SAGE-WOLFF_ET_AL.indb 517
517
9/22/2016 12:01:15 PM