Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Real Estate
Benchmarking
White Paper
October, 2010
Published by
Executive Summary
How others are preparing for the changes to the lease accounting
standards
Page 2
The intensifying focus real estate will receive from the C-Suite as a
result of the FAS13 changes coming into effect in January, 2012
that will capitalize future rent obligations bringing millions/
billions of dollars onto the balance sheet;
Each of these elements on their own offers unique challenges but, the
combination of them is creating a sense of urgency CRE departments
will be forced to embrace or they will lose opportunities to contribute
meaningful value to the organizations they support.
Portfolio Owned v
0 - 1,000,000
17%
Owned
68%
1,000,001 - 5,000,000
20%
Leased
32%
10,000,001 - 25,000,000
10%
25,000,001 - 75,000,000
22%
5,000,001 - 10,000,000
15%
75000000+
14%
Property Types
Geography of Portfolio
Office 100%
Warehouse/Distribution
57%
Europe
57%
Data Center
42%
Asia
43%
R&D
42%
South America
35%
Retail
39%
Other
Manufacturing
35%
Vacant Land
28%
Other
9%
8%
Page 3
have more profound impact on the overall organization than just about
every other department.
But, when the CRE professional gets to the table they better bring along
solid actionable business intelligence about occupancy costs, space
utilization/optimization, facility benchmarks, environmental impact and
financial terms which may allow for dispositions or acquisitions to grow
or contract in support of the direction of the company.
The departmental composition of those who participated in the survey
included:
Roles/Responsibilities
Real Estate
92%
Facilities
73%
Maintenance/Operations
28%
Finance
12%
Other
9%
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
97%
Portfolio Management
89%
Facility Management
77%
Space Management
71%
Reservations/Hoteling
33%
Maintenance
29%
26%
23%
Other
7%
Outsourced Providers
Page 6
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Energy Management/Procurement
Page 7
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
28%
24%
16%
12%
Other
9%
Colliers International
8%
Property/Facility Management
Page 8
Johnson Controls
21%
EMCOR
17%
CB Richard Ellis
12%
12%
Self Manage
10%
9%
8%
Sodexo
7%
Other
4%
Colliers International
2%
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Include optional renewal periods that are more likely than not
expected to be exercised and include contingent amounts for
percentage rent or CPI increases
The implications will place real estate front and center in the CFO/
Controllers cross hair when the cost and value of these leases are
realized. It is likely that many functions now being managed in the RE/
FM Department will be assumed by the Finance Department. And,
rightfully so given the amount of risk exposure a large leased portfolio
has to an organization. The new standard will have a greater impact on
retailers and banks that rely heavily on leased facilities to support their
operations but it will affect all leased facilities.
Page 9
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Page 10
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Information Systems to
Support Corporate
Real Estate Strategy
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
The challenge is on how they will fill their CRE information gap. Many are
in search of the holy grail solution in collecting information within their
organization to collect comprehensive financial performance information in
order to calculate true total cost of occupancy that will fundamentally
change the way they manage their companys CRE holdings.
Participants in our study cited the use of:
Page 12
82%
Argus
78%
Maximo
68%
Lease Harbor
38%
TRIRIGA
34%
ARCHIBUS
23%
ManagePath
17%
Accruent
14%
Manhattan Centerstone
14%
FAMIS
11%
PLANON
4%
3%
FM Interact
3%
Siterra
2%
Enableon
1%
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
43%
ORACLE
35%
PeopleSoft
12%
Proprietary System
7%
Other
2%
Page 13
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
As importantly, these solutions will help them answer the Top Five
questions that are being asked by senior management of the
participants in our study include:
Page 14
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Page 15
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Develop a plan to get clean, reliable and consistent data across the
entire portfolio (dont underestimate how hard this one will be)
Our industry has never been challenged as much for information than now.
The back of napkins and shoebox records wont work anymore.
Management will demand a higher level of sophisticated reporting that
weve never seen. The time for action is NOWAre you ready?
Page 16
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Page 17
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Sustainability
In developing a sustainability strategy
plan for your portfolio the blue print
starts with determining the overall
sustainability goals of the organization
and identify initiatives are already in place to address sustainability.
A contributing factor to companys overall corporate social
responsibility strategy is for the CRE professional would be to bring the
real estate perspective by:
Page 18
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Move forward sustainability initiatives that support the business objectives. Energy Management Systems employed at all
locations. Recycling efforts deployed. Re-lamping of facilities
to reduce energy employed. Focus more on Energy Star than
LEED.
Preparation of a plan for upper management to approve committee in place to form teams for each unit leaders appointed
to enforce initiative budget transformation over a realistic
time frame
Increased recycling including composting food waste and
collection of over 20 types of recycled products (plastic, batteries, binders, etc) Additional renewable energy projects...solar arrays on rooftops and one wind project Carbon
tracking across the entire company
Green to Gold treasure hunts, up grade lighting, building
temp adjustment earlier in day, increased recycling initiatives
Page 19
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Conclusion
The survey participants provided some great insight about how they are
managed their corporate real estate portfolios and offered some
benchmarking information many organizations could use for
comparison.
Benchmarking is a critical step toward achieving departmental objectives
of achieving a desired future state but once youve benchmarked your
portfolio, the CRE department will need to put together a strategic plan.
Through facilitated sessions with internal constituents and outside
consultants the process will help to develop a plan that will get the
organization to crawl, walk and then run.
Along with a consultant CRE departments will co-develop a strategic and
tactical solution unique to the organization might utilize a process
driven approach that will challenge the internal team to:
THINK: What is the real estate portfolios current and desired
future state?
BUILD: What are the specific initiatives to be implemented across
the real estate/facilities department(s) and portfolio that bring
about the desired efficiency, economic and environmental
sustainability results?
OPERATE: How/who will implement the plan, what will become the
KPIs to measure progress and define success, and how will the
momentum be maintained until the desired future state is
reached?
Some steps you might consider to help you get started could be:
Page 20
Document Title
CRE3 Consulting - Corporate Real Estate Benchmarking White Paper
Develop a concise listing and source of the data of your top ten
occupancy cost categories (rent, utilities, taxes, insurance, churn,
maintenance/cleaning, TI, management fees, etc.), create/
benchmark key performance indicators, set goals for cost
reduction improvements and implement initiatives to achieve them
Page 21
Document Title
About CRE3 Consulting
Page 22
Document Title
APPENDIX
Page 23
CRE3 Consulting
42 South Kingman Street
Lakeville Massachusetts 02347
Phone 617-529-1970
www.CRE3.net
2010 CRE3 Consulting - All Rights Reserved - The survey results contained in this white paper have been exclusively researched and written by CRE3 Consulting. The information may
not be modified, copied, distributed, transmitted, displayed, reproduced, published, licensed,
transferred, or sold, without the prior written permission of CRE3 Consulting.
For information, send an e-mail info@CRE3.net.