Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
P.1
P.3
LAB 3: MEMBRANES
P.11
P.19
P.31
LAB 6: FERMENTATION
P.39
P.53
LAB 8: DNA
P.61
P.69
P.75
P.87
APPENDICES
LAB NOTEBOOK GUIDELINES
P.97
P.101
P.105
P.111
Pre-lab Reading
Experimental Design
After you have decided on an experiment to perform, record the following in your lab
notebook: Objective, Variables, Hypotheses, Prediction, Control and Treatment groups, and
Procedure. Refer to the lab notebook guidelines (pages 97 99).
Fig. 1. Diagrammatic planting methodology for Plant Growth experiment. Use coffee filters
in place of fabric. Nutrient addition is only required if preparing a pot for the treatment
group.
Fig. 2. Example of a plant label. Your plant label should include your lab section (circled please),
treatment (phosphorous addition in example), and your last name.
Table 1. Schedule for Plant Growth Experiment and Lab Report Preparation.
Week
12 16 Sep
19 23 Sep
26 30 Sep
3 7 Oct
10 14 Oct
17 21 Oct
HW 3: Scientific Literature
HW 4: Introduction
HW 5: Data Analysis & Results
31 Oct 4 Nov
HW 6: Discussion
14 18 Nov
HW 8: Peer Review
28 Nov 2 Dec
2. Once youve cancelled units you should be left with only the desired unit(s), in this case
seconds:
Conversions factors work because you are simply multiplying your starting quantity by one,
without actually changing the quantity. For example, the conversion factor
is equivalent to 1:
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
Make sure your plants are well-labeled and placed in the tray for your lab section.
Return any items at your table to their place on the lab benches.
Wipe down tables and benches as necessary to remove sand and soil.
Acknowledgments
This lab was designed by Trace Martyn and Chris North. Tim Aston and other graduate teaching
assistants have provided expertise and suggestions.
10
LAB 3: MEMBRANES
Learning Objectives
1. Compare and contrast the processes of diffusion and osmosis.
2. Design an experiment to test the effects of solute concentration and other variables on
osmosis across a model membrane.
3. Understand and apply the terms for osmotic concentration.
4. Consider the utility of models in science.
Pre-lab Reading
12
13
Methodology
1. Soften the dialysis tubing by soaking the pieces in a 400 mL beaker of distilled water for
about 5 minutes
2. Fold one end over about 1/2 and cinch with a piece of floss. Tie a square knot tightly, so
that the bag will not leak (see Fig. 1). This will be the bottom of each bag.
3. Number the six 250 mL beakers: #1, #2, #3, #4, #5, #6 with lab tape and a sharpie. Do
not forget to include at least one control. Also place a small numbered tape flag on the
top tie of each bag which corresponds to the beaker (sample) number.
4. Carefully pipet 5 mL of solution into each dialysis bag, filling each bag approximately 1/2
full. Fold over the top of each bag, and tie the bag shut tightly with floss. The bags should
be limp and filled with about equal amounts of liquid.
5. Record the initial mass of the bag on the balance. Record the initial masses in a wellorganized table with space to record masses for each bag every 15 minutes
6. Wait to place your bags in the beakers until the rest of the class is ready. When the
class is ready, place bags in beakers, thus starting the experiment.
7. Mass each bag every 15 minutes. Before massing the bag, blot it gently with a Kimwipe.
8. By reading and recording the mass of each bag at specific intervals, you can determine the
rate of diffusion for each treatment.
9. After the last mass data are recorded, analyze and graph your data.
First, calculate the percent mass change for each dialysis bag over time. To do this,
subtract the initial mass of each dialysis bag (mass @ time = 0 minutes) from the mass for
the same dialysis bag at times = 15, 30, 45, and 60 minutes, and divide these values by the
initial mass of the dialysis bag. To make this a percentage, multiply by 100
14
15
C1 V1 = C2 V2
where C1 is the concentration of the initial solution, V1 is the volume of initial solution, C2 is the
concentration of the final solution, and V2 is the volume of the final solution. Concentration may be
expressed in various units, including g/L, %, and molarity (M). Volumes can also be in a variety of
units. The important things is to use the same units for both concentration variables, and the same
units for both volume variables. The variables for concentration and volume do not have to match
we can use mg/L for concentration and mL volume without converting mL to L, as in the example
below.
Example: To calculate the amount of 150 mg/L starch solution needed to make 5 mL of a 30
mg/L starch standard, we would do the following:
1. Figure out which variable (C1, C2, V1, or V2) you are solving for and reorganize the equation
to isolate that variable. Here, we want to know how much initial solution is needed (V1):
V1 = C2 V2 / C1
2. Next, replace all the known quantities with their values. We know the concentration of the
stock solution (150 mg/L), how much standard we want to make (5 mL), and what standard
concentration we want (30 mg/L):
V1 = (30 * 5 / 150) mL
V1 = 1 mL
4. To actually create the standard we would dilute the calculated initial volume to the final
volume by adding solvent. In this case, we would add 4 mL of deionized water (our solvent)
to 1 mL of 150 mg/L starch solution to produce 5 mL of 30 mg/L starch solution.
16
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
Dialysis bags can be disposed of in the trash.
Rinse all glassware three times. Return all items to the tray on your table.
Make sure you clean your table before you leave. Wipe down as necessary.
Acknowledgements
This lab was written by Diane Gorski and modified by Chris North
.
17
Learn to use compound and dissecting microscopes correctly, and name and explain the
functions of the parts of these microscopes
Calculate magnification properly
Estimate the size of objects viewed under the microscope
Prepare wet mount slides of living cells to view with the compound microscope
Compare and contrast prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells.
Compare and contrast plant and animal cells.
Pre-lab Reading
20
21
22
5.
CAUTION: Many microscopes have parfocal lenses, which means that as you
switch from one lens to another very little focusing is required after the new lens is in
place. If a microscope is not parfocal, as you move from one lens to another the new
lens may not have enough room above the specimen and may crash into the
specimen as the lens is moved into place, damaging the lens and/or specimen.
When working with a microscope that is not parfocal it is important to lower the
stage slightly before moving from a lower to a higher magnification and watch
carefully from the side as you move the higher magnification lens into place. Raise
the lens further, if necessary, to allow the lens to swing into place without contacting
the specimen.
6.
23
12.
13.
14.
24
Table 1. The approximate diameter of field for the general biology microscopes with different
objective lenses.
Objective lens
4X
10X
40X
100X
Leitz
4800 m
1920 m
480 m
190 m
25
Olympus
4500 m
1800 m
450 m
180 m
27
Prepare wet mounts from the sample water(s). Your instructor may offer hints for finding
organisms within each sample. Many of the organisms are visible swimming about in the water.
Other good places for finding a diversity of organisms is near any plant material in the sample or
along any bottom material in the sample. If you dont find much on your first attempt, try making
another slide, but sample from a different part of the jar.
You should use both the compound and the dissection microscopes to examine the water sample
organisms. Wet mounts with coverslips must be used for samples examined under the compound
microscope, but you may use wet mounts, depression slides or culture dishes for examining
specimens under the dissecting microscope. As the specimens in this exercise are not stained,
different methods for improving contrast in the specimen will be employed. Experiment with
adjusting the light passing through the specimen by slowly closing down the iris or adjusting the
rheostat.
Focus on low power and examine the organisms. Move up to higher power objectives if you wish.
If the organisms are moving too quickly, move to a clean slide and add a drop of Proto-slo to slow
them down.
As directed by your instructor, sketch some of the organisms. With your sketches, include the
magnification of your image and any additional notes on movement, color, shape, structures,
interesting features and identification of your organism(s).
28
Clean-Up
Before you leave lab:
Make sure you clean your table before you leave.
Remove any slides from the stage. Return depression slides, and prepared Nostoc and letter e
slides, to where they came from.
Place used coverslips and any broken microscope slides in the Glass Disposal or Sharps
Disposal containers do NOT place these items in the trash cans.
Wash and rinse the microscope slides you used for wet mounts. These can be reused.
Put the lowest power objective lens in place on your compound microscope, turn the
rheostat to its lowest setting, and turn off the light.
Acknowledgements
This lab was written by Diane Gorski and modified by Chris North.
29
Pre-lab Reading
Fig. 2. Standard curve for starch concentration. Absorbance was measured at 580 nm after 2 drops
of Lugols solution were added to starch standards.
To estimate the concentration of starch in a solution by measuring the absorbance of light with
the spectrophotometer, we must first create a standard curve (Fig. 2). A standard curve is created
by measuring the absorbance of standards, which are solutions of known concentration. We can
compare absorbance values measured from unknown solutions to the standard curve to get an
estimate of the concentration of the unknown solution.
During this lab, you will use a standard curve and the spectrophotometer to estimate the starch
concentration of three unknown solutions. Then you will design and conduct an experiment to
assess the effects of some treatment on the activity of amylase. You will also practice dilution
calculations.
Pre-lab Questions
You should read and consider the questions below before lab so you are better prepared.
1. What enzyme will we be working with today, and what is its function?
2. How do enzymes work to speed up chemical reactions?
3. What factors might affect enzyme activity and the rate of chemical reactions?
4. Do you understand the difference between transmission, reflection, and absorbance of light?
5. Can you differentiate between qualitative and quantitative methods?
6. Given an absorbance value, for example 1.002, can you estimate the starch concentration by
using the standard curve represented by Fig.2?
33
34
35
Fig. 3. Diagrammatic representation of an enzyme time series. Amylase is added to start the
reaction, then 2 drops of I2KI are added to end the reaction. However, for the 0 s time, I2KI should
be added first, so that amylase cannot react with the starch. Blank tubes have purposely been left
empty what should be included in blanks for each series?
36
37
Clean-Up
Before you leave lab:
Turn of the spectrophotometer. Make sure you have not left a sample in the
spectrophotometer.
Empty your test tubes, triple rinse them, and return them to your test tube rack upside down
so they can dry. Place a paper towel under the tube rack.
Dispose of used pipet tips in the glass waste bin.
Clean the whiteboard if you used one.
Tidy up anything else at your table as necessary.
Acknowledgements
This lab was adapted from a series of labs presented in:
Jordan, C.N., and C.A. North. 2014. Life 1010 General Biology Lab Manual. Hayden-McNeil,
Plymouth, MI.
38
LAB 6: FERMENTATION
Learning Objectives
1. Understand the process of fermentation.
2. Design and conduct an experiment to test how some factor may affect the rate of
fermentation by yeast.
3. Evaluate and interpret data collected from a single treatment experiment with a t-test.
Pre-lab Reading
39
Experiment 2
Control Treatment
4.6
7.7
4.4
7.9
9.5
8.5
2.9
4.3
4.3
10.2
If we calculate the average for each group, we find that in both experiments plants in the
treatment group are taller than plants in the control group (treatment average = 7.7, control average
= 5.1 cm). Therefore, at first glance we might conclude that our treatments resulted in taller plants
in both experiments. However, we must remember that we have only sampled a handful of plants (n
=5), and random factors may have contributed to these differences - for example, maybe the
controls were planted poorly, or we happened to choose better seeds for our treatment groups.
Another way to compare data is to look at the variability in the data. Standard deviation is one
measure we can use to look at variability. Standard deviation essentially measures the dispersion of
data around the average in other words, how close are data points to the average? If standard
deviation is low then data points are close to the average, and random factors probably had less of
an effect. If standard deviation is large then data points are further from the average, and random
factors probably had a greater impact. If we calculate the standard deviation for each group in our
hypothetical experiments (Table 1), we discover that data from Experiment 2 is more variable (Table
2).
40
Figure 1. Averages and standard deviations (n= 5) for control and treatment groups from two
different hypothetical experiments (experiments 1 and 2).
Remember, standard deviations are a measure of variance around the average. To compare
standard deviations between groups visually, we often add error bars to that represent the average
standard deviation. For experiment 1, the standard deviations for the control and treatment groups
do not overlap, so we might conclude that the difference in averages is a result of our treatment (Fig.
1). For experiment 2, the standard deviations do overlap, which suggests that the difference in
averages are more likely a result of random factors (Fig. 1).
41
42
43
Methodology
10. Obtain approximately 100 mL of prepared yeast solution from your lab instructor. Add 25
mL of yeast solution to each tube.
11. Add substrate to the centrifuge tubes as required for your experiment.
12. Screw on a lid without a Luer lock and syringe to each tube and vortex until well-mixed.
13. Carefully remove the first lid (some pressure will have formed) and clean the lip of the tube
with a Kimwipe so the tube will form a tight seal with the second lid with a syringe attached.
14. Before screwing on the lid with the syringe, pull out the syringe slightly so that it is set at 1
mL. This will allow the piston to move more easily as gas is produced.
15. When you screw on the lid with the syringe, be careful to handle only the lid and not the
syringe so as to not break the epoxy seal. You also should not overtighten the lid. This
begins the experimental times.
16. Record the volume of gas in the syringe every 5 minutes.
17. Repeat as necessary to produce enough replicates. Rinse tubes thoroughly between
replicates.
44
45
This exercise explains how to perform a t-test in Excel and provides some example exercises. You
may use your own laptop or one of the lab laptops to complete this exercise in pairs.
How to calculate averages and standard deviation, and performs a t-test, with Excel
1. Enter your data into two different columns, one for your control and the other for your
treatment. For this example well use the data from our 1st hypothetical plant experiment
(Table 1). Add labels to identify where averages and standard deviations will be calculated,
and where you will perform a t-test (calculate a p-value).
2. In the cell next to the label Average, type =AVERAGE(. The equal sign tells Excel that you
want it to perform a calculation (use a function). Next, highlight the first column, then close
the ). Excel will return the average.
46
3. To perform a t-test, well use the function =TTEST().Anytime you start typing a function,
Excel will show you what the required fields are. For a TTEST, you need to identify array1
and array2 (which are the two groups you wish to compare), define the number of tails, and
the type of t-test. To fill the array fields, highlight the data you wish to use as before. Type a
comma after selecting the first array, and before selecting the second array. For our
purposes, use a 2-tailed t-test (so, enter 2 for the tails field), and enter 3 for the type.*
* t-tests may be one-tailed or two-tailed, and refer to the extremes of a normal (bell curve) distribution. One-tailed tests
are used when we consider differences between groups only possible in one direction (group A must be greater than
group B), whereas two-tailed tests are used when either direction is possible (A may be larger or smaller than B).
Excel can perform three different types of t-tests: paired (type 1), equal variance (type 2), and unequal variance (type 3).
Paired t-tests are used with experimental designs that include paired sampling, such as when an individual is measured
before and after some treatment. To determine if variance is equal or not additional statistical tests are required. Without
performing these tests it is safer to assume that variances are unequal because the type 3 test is more conservative (less
likely to produce false significant results). Similarly, two-tailed tests are more conservative than one-tailed tests.
Feel free to adjust the tails and type to see how this affects the p-value.
47
Practice Problems
Use Excel to calculate averages and standard deviations, and perform t-tests. Record answers to
the questions below in your lab notebook.
1. Perform a t-test for Experiment 2 (Table 1). What is the p-value you get? How would you
interpret this result?
2. In fall 2012, students in lab section 21 had an average height of 66.6 inches, while the
average height in lab section 17 was 64.6 inches. Here are the data:
Student Height (inches)
Section 21: 69, 70, 66, 63, 68, 70, 69, 67, 62, 63, 76, 59, 62, 62, 75, 62, 72, 63
Section 17: 68, 62, 67, 68, 69, 67, 61, 59, 62, 61, 69, 66, 62, 62, 61, 70
* Example adapted from the Handbook of Biological Statistics
a.
b.
What are the null and alternative hypotheses for this comparison?
Perform a t-test on this data. Are the average heights of the two sections
significantly different? Explain.
48
What are the dependent and independent variables for this experiment?
What are the null and alternative hypotheses for this experiment?
What is the average and standard deviation for each group?
Perform a t-test on this data. Based on the outcome of your t-test, and the values you
calculated for c, what is your interpretation of the results of this experiment?
4. Once you have completed your fermentation experiment, calculate averages and standard
deviations, and perform a t-test to compare the amount of CO2 produced in control tubes
and treatment tubes if you have multiple treatments, use only one for this comparison.
Once you have done calculations and performed a t-test, fill in the blanks in the paragraph
on the next page, which demonstrates how a results section might be written.
49
A figure representing
fermentation data
50
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
1. Wash centrifuge tubes and any glassware you dirtied (e.g. graduated cylinders). Dry and
return tubes to your table and glassware to wherever you got it.
2. Return syringes to the side shelf unless they have been dirtied. Dirty syringes can be
discarded.
3. Wipe up any spilled yeast solution with a sponge or wet paper towel.
Acknowledgements
This lab was written by Chris North.
51
Pre-Lab Reading
Wavelength (nm)
380-450
450-495
495-570
570-590
590-620
620-750
In this lab you will use the spectrophotometer to gather absorbance data on plant pigments across
a series of wavelengths to produce an absorbance spectrum for three different samples (Table 2).
First you will need to extract the pigment from your sample. The solvent used to extract pigment
will depend on the pigment of interest (Table 2).
Table 2. Extracted sample used in the Photosynthesis and Plant Pigments lab, solvent for
extracted sample, and wavelength for initial dilution check. If absorbance is above 2.0 for
check, sample must be diluted.
Pigments to be extracted
Chlorophylls
(green and greenish-yellow)
Anthocyanins
(red, purple, blue)
Carotenoids
(red, orange, and yellow)
Solvent
Acetone
Dilution Check
440 nm
Water
380 nm
Ethanol
400 nm
Pre-lab Questions
You should read and consider the questions below before lab so you are better prepared. You do
not need to record your answers in your lab notebook, but you may find it useful.
1. What are the reactants and products of photosynthesis? What is the purpose of
photosynthesis?
2. What are the two main sets of reactions that occur during photosynthesis? How are they
linked?
3. What are some of the various ways that organisms use pigments?
4. If an object appears to be red, what wavelengths are being reflected? Which are likely being
absorbed? How about an object that appears green?
5. If you are extracting red pigments from a flower, what solvent should you use? At what
wavelength should you do a dilution check? See Table 2.
54
Reactant
Molecules
Product
Molecules
Summary of
Stage
Light
Independent
Reactions
(Calvin Cycle)
3. Explain what is accomplished by photosynthesis.
4. Draw a diagram that illustrates the processes of photosynthesis (i.e. a road map of
photosynthesis).
55
56
57
58
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
1. Return the spinach extract and acetone blank to your lab instructor if you havent yet.
2. Ground produce and flowers can be discard in waste bins. Water and ethanol-based extracts
and blanks can be dumped in the sink.
3. Rinse any glassware you used thrice (e.g. mortar and pestle, beakers, tubes, etc). Dry and
return to your table. Remove any labels.
4. Make sure spectrophotometers are turned off.
5. Do any additional cleaning that is necessary.
Acknowledgements
This lab was designed by Diane Gorski and modified by Chris North. Exercise A was adapted
from a study sheet produced by Pearson Education.
59
LAB 8: DNA
Learning Objectives
1. Understand how polymerase chain reaction is used to amplify DNA
2. Learn how gel electrophoresis is used to analyze DNA samples
3. Use DNA gel electrophoresis to solve a murder mystery
Pre-Lab Reading
Restriction Enzymes
Restriction enzymes were discovered by Werner Arber, Hamilton Smith and Daniel Nathans in
the mid- 1970s. Their discovery revolutionized biochemistry and molecular biology. Most
prokaryotes possess protective enzymes that chop the DNA of invading viruses into fragments.
The cells own DNA is not cut by its restriction enzymes because the cell protects the recognition
sites on its DNA by camouflaging them with methyl groups. The restriction enzymes therefore do
not recognize these sites on the host cells DNA. However, foreign DNA lacks the protective
methyl groups on the recognition sites, and thus the bacterias restriction enzymes can cut the
foreign DNA.
Restriction enzymes are highly specific specialized molecular scissors they cut DNA very
precisely at sites with specific base pair arrangements (Fig. 1). Molecular biologists take advantage of
these enzymes to cut DNA at specific locations for a variety of purposes. For example, scientists can
take a piece of DNA from one organism and insert it into the DNA of another organism using
restriction enzymes and ligases to cut and paste, respectively.
When DNA is digested (cut into pieces) by one or more restriction enzymes, scientists can use
information gathered about the sizes of the different pieces to learn about the original piece of
DNA. Sometimes the information confirms that a recombinant molecule has been correctly
constructed, other times the sizes of DNA fragments from different sources are used to determine if
these sources are similar or related.
62
63
64
65
TAGCATACACGTCCCAGCTAAACGCATTGCAACGTCAACGTCAAACTGCTCAT
3
5
2. Write the 5 to 3 sequence for both of the primers which would be required to amplify this gene
via PCR.
3. Compared to the DNA replication process within a cell, the denaturation step achieves the
activity of which enzyme(s)?
4. Compared to the DNA replication process within a cell, the primer annealing step achieves the
activity of which enzyme(s)?
66
6. Diagram 3 cycles of PCR amplification for the gene shown above using the selected primers:
67
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
1. Dispose of any practice gels at your table in the waste container at the back sink.
2. Discard your gloves in the indicate waster container.
3. Wash your hands before leaving the lab.
TA clean-up:
1. Dispose of ethidium bromide gels in the container in the hood
2. Return the spatula and gel transport trays to the viewing stations
3. Wipe down viewers and leave open to dry
Acknowledgments
This lab was written by Diane Gorski and modified by Chris North. The PCR group activity
(Exercise C) was contributed by John Willford.
68
Pre-Lab Reading
Cell Division
One of the tenets of cell theory is that all cells come from pre-existing cells. How does this occur?
In all organisms, cells are produced by cell division, during which a parent cell divides into two or
more daughter cells. Cell division is the final step of what is known as the cell cycle, essentially the
lifetime of a cell. During the cell cycle, cells grow and accumulate resources during a series of gap
phases (G1 and G2). Cells also duplicate their DNA during the synthesis phase (S) in preparation
for cell division when all of their resources, including genetic information, will be divided among
daughter cells.
In prokaryotes, cell division is accomplished by binary fission, which produces two identical cells.
Because prokaryotes usually only have a single, circular chromosome, during binary fission the cell
simply pulls one copy of the chromosome (which was replicated during S phase) to either side of the
cell before splitting. Cell division in eukaryotes is more complicated because genetic material
contained in DNA is packaged into a number of chromosomes (for example, your cells each contain
46 chromosomes), which must be carefully sorted and divided. Depending on the function of cell
division, eukaryotic cells divide either by the process of mitosis or by the process of meiosis.
Mitosis and Meiosis
Eukaryotes produce new cells through two types of cell division: mitosis and meiosis. Mitosis
produces two genetically identical daughter cells, while meiosis produces four genetically different
daughter cells. Mitosis produces diploid cells, like most of the cells in your body, which contain two
sets (2n) of homologous chromosomes. A pair of homologous chromosomes each has the same
set of genes, although they may have different variants of these genes, and one homolog is inherited
from each of your parents. On the other hand, meiosis produces haploid cells, which contain only
one set (n) of chromosomes. In humans, diploid somatic cells contain 46 chromosomes, while
haploid gamete cells contain 23 chromosomes. Before cell division occurs, chromosomes are
replicated during the S phase to produce two identical sister chromatids which are separated during
division.
Diploid somatic (body) cells are created by mitosis. Through the production of somatic cells by
mitosis, organisms can grow, heal wounds, or replace old cells. In single-celled eukaryotes, mitosis
can also be used for asexual reproduction to make exact copies, or clones, of parent cells. Haploid
cells produced by meiosis are the sex cells, called gametes or germ cells. In animals, gametes are
eggs and sperm. When two gamete cells fuse during fertilization, they produce a new diploid cell.
69
70
71
72
Meiosis
73
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
1. Make sure all of the materials from Exercise A have been returned to their container.
2. Return slides to their place, lower the stage of your microscope, set it to the low power
objective, and turn off the light after turning down the rheostat.
Acknowledgments
This lab was written by Diane Gorski and modified by Chris North. Exercise A is based on an
exercise developed by Larry Flammer, who created the mitosis, meiosis, and summary sheets.
74
Pre-Lab Reading
Chapter 14
Bring your textbook to lab this week, you will find it helpful.
Genetics
Genetics is a rapidly growing and changing scientific field. The information that previously filled
the genetics chapters of biology texts is now a mere scratch on the surface. In this lab you will
explore fundamental concepts of Mendelian inheritance.
In the nineteenth century, Gregor Mendel established the foundation of genetics with his historic
experiments on garden peas. He studied characteristics that varied among individual plants that he
carefully bred and followed through many successive generations. Mendel examined characteristics
that clearly differed between plants for example, he looked at purple vs. white flower color, round
vs. wrinkled seed coats, and yellow vs. green pods. He also used true breeding individuals that
is, his plants with purple flowers had come from plants with a history of purple flowers. Mendels
studies led him and others to recognize the following:
1. A characteristic or trait, such as flower color, is a heritable feature. (We now call this a
gene.)
2. Variations of characteristics occur, for example, purple vs. white flowers. (These
variations are now known as alleles.)
3. In individual organisms, alleles occur in pairs; one member of each pair has been inherited
from each parent.
75
Fig. 1. A pair of homologous chromosomes with alleles for genes P, G, R and T shown.
4. Gene P, which is homozygous dominant, codes for flower color and results in purple flowers.
Gene G, which is homozygous recessive, codes for pea color. Green is dominant, yellow is
recessive. What color are the peas that grow on the plant from which this cell came?
5. Gene R codes for pea shape, which can be either round or wrinkled. Gene T codes for plant
height, which can be tall (dominant) or dwarf (recessive). What shape are the peas from our example
plant? Is our pea plant tall or dwarf?
6. Peas contain seeds. Seeds are produced when a sperm cell (male gamete) and an egg (female
gamete) merge during fertilization. Which type of cell division produces gametes?
76
77
78
B. Eye Color
Blue eye color was long believed to be a simple recessive trait controlled by a single gene that is,
an individual with blue eyes must have received a recessive allele from each parent. As a result it was
inferred that a child whose parents are both blue-eyed must also have blue eyes. This occasionally
led to the erroneous claim that a child with brown or green eyes born to a couple with blue eyes
must indicate adultery.
We now know that although blue eyes are commonly passed down and all people with blue eyes
probably share a common ancestor (Eiberg et al. 2008), eye color is controlled by at least 15
different genes. As a result of this complexity, almost any eye color may result from a pairing of two
blue-eyed individuals.
Many, probably most, traits are polygenic (controlled by multiple genes) like eye color. Here, for
simplicitys sake, we will consider two important genes leading to blue eyes, the B locus and T
locus. Dominance at either locus will result in blue eyes. However, individuals that are homozygous
recessive for both genes display brown eyes.
79
C. Hair Type
Jane is the only person in her immediate family with curly hair. Her parents both have wavy hair,
while her two brothers have straight hair. Jane has heard that hair type (curly, wavy, or straight) is
inherited and cant figure out how her type fits in with the rest of her family. Janes friend Tori, also
has curly hair, but this isnt surprising because her mother does too. Toris father and brother both
have wavy hair. Tori has heard that hair type genetics are a bit unusual and display something called
incomplete dominance, but neither her nor Jane know exactly what this means.
1. What is incomplete dominance? See page 272 of Freeman et al. (2014).
2. Draw two Punnett squares that show how hair type is inherited in each family (Janes and
Toris)
3. Explain why Jane has curly hair when nobody else in her family does.
D. Blood type I
Blood types (A, B, & O) in humans are determined by a set of three different alleles of one
gene; one individual can have only two of the three possibilities. Two of the alleles are
codominant.
The codominant alleles are IA, which is responsible for the production of an A antigen, and IB,
which is responsible for the production of a B antigen. These antigens are carbohydrates that are
found on the surfaces of red blood cells. The third allele is recessive to both IA and IB and
consequently it is designed with a lower case i. The red blood cells of individuals with two i alleles
have no antigens on their red blood cells and have type O blood. The phenotypes and genotypes of
the four human blood types are summarized below.
Type A
IAIA or IAi
Type B
IBIB or IBi
Type AB
IAIB
Type O
ii
1. What does this mean, to say that two alleles are codominant?
2. Susie, who has type A blood, and whose biological mother has type B blood, plans to marry
Frank, who has type O blood. Give the phenotype and genotype of Frank, Susie, Susies
mother, and possible offspring of Susie and Frank. What can you determine about the blood
type of Susies biological father? Explain your inferences using Punnett squares.
80
F. Sickle-cell disease
Sickle cell disease (SCD, sometimes called sickle cell anemia) exemplifies two genetic concepts:
pleiotrophy and heterozygous advantage.
Sickle cell disease occurs in people that are homozygous recessive for a gene that produces the
blood protein -hemoglobin. This causes red blood cells, which carry oxygen to different parts of
the body, to become misshapen (sickle-shaped rather than disc-shaped as normal blood cells) when
oxygen concentrations are low. This shape-change, caused by a single gene, can affect many
different traits. The ability of a gene to affect several traits is called pleiotropy. Persons with SCD
may suffer any number of chronic or acute conditions, including those that lead to kidney, bone and
heart damage, as well as sudden death from various causes.
Sickle-cell disease is highly deleterious that is, it often kills people suffering from it at young ages
and should be heavily selected against. However, the allele which causes SCD is more common in
areas where malaria occurs, and in people whose ancestors came from these places, than might be
expected given the severity of SCD. Malaria is caused by a protozoan parasite transmitted by
mosquitoes, and killed more than 650,000 people worldwide in 2010. As it turns out, people who are
heterozygous for SCD are more resistant to malaria than either otherwise healthy homozygous
dominant individuals or homozygous recessive individuals, who suffer from SCD. This condition,
where heterozygous individuals have higher fitness than those with either homozygous phenotype, is
called heterozygous advantage.
1. Draw a Punnett square that shows how a single-gene for -hemoglobin can cause sickle-cell
disease (an example of pleiotropy) and confer heterozygous advantage. Use this drawing
to explain the two bold terms.
81
82
Ears
Hair
Length
Coat
Color
Floppy, or
upright
Short, or long
Black, red,
brown, or yellow
F
L
D, E
Tail
Long, or short
Eye
Color
Pale, grey, or
dark
D_E_ = black
ddE_ = red
D_ee = brown
ddee = yellow
An underscore indicates that either allele may be
present.
Long tails (TT or Tt) are dominant over short tails
(tt).
Incomplete dominance:
PP = pale
Pp = grey
pp = dark
83
84
Offspring 3
Offspring 2
Offspring 1
Father
Mother
Gen 2
Offspring 3
Offspring 2
Offspring 1
Father
Mother
Gen 1
Dog Name
Dog Name
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
Goal Dog:
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
Expression
N/A
Locus
A_bb = small
A_B_ = medium
aaB_ = large
Size
F
Ears
L
Hair
Length
D
Coat Color
T
Tail
P
Eye
Color
D_E_ = black
Floppy ears
ddE_ = red
Incomplete
Short hair
Long tails
(F) are
D_ee = brown
dominance:
(L) is
(T) are
Hemophilia is a
dominant
ddee = yellow
dominant
cominant
recessive Xover
PP = pale
An underscore indicates
over long
over short
linked trait,
upright
An underscore indicates
Pp = grey
that either allele may be
hair (l)
tails (t)
represented here
ears (f)
that either allele may be
pp = dark
present.
present
with X H or X h
XX = female
XY = male
Gender
Trait
85
Offspring 3
Offspring 2
Offspring 1
Father
Mother
Gen 4
Offspring 3
Offspring 2
Offspring 1
Father
Mother
Gen 3
Dog Name
Dog Name
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
phenotype
genotype
Expression
N/A
Locus
A_bb = small
A_B_ = medium
aaB_ = large
Size
F
Ears
L
Hair
Length
D
Coat Color
T
Tail
P
Eye
Color
D_E_ = black
Floppy ears
ddE_ = red
Incomplete
Short hair
Long tails
(F) are
D_ee = brown
dominance:
(L) is
(T) are
Hemophilia is a
dominant
ddee = yellow
dominant
cominant
recessive Xover
PP = pale
An underscore indicates
over long
over short
linked trait,
upright
An underscore indicates
Pp = grey
that either allele may be
hair (l)
tails (t)
represented here
ears (f)
that either allele may be
pp = dark
present.
present
with X H or X h
XX = female
XY = male
Gender
Trait
Exercise D: Pedigrees
With the information you recorded in Table 2, produce pedigrees for TWO of the target traits you
selected (see your answer to Exercise B, question 5). Include all of your dogs on each pedigree.
Represent males with squares, females with circles, and use shading to represent dogs that show the
trait in question. Make sure you indicate what trait you are diagramming in each pedigree, and
include names for each dog. See section 14.6 of Freeman et al. (2014) for example pedigrees. Write
a brief discussion of what each pedigree conveys about the trait it represents. Refer to figures
14.22 and 14.23 in Freeman.
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
1. Return dog cards and pennies to you lab instructor.
Acknowledgements
This lab was developed and written by Chris North.
86
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
Pre-lab Reading
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
gray, while only a few mice are very light or very dark. Different types of selection may change the
distribution of a trait within a population in different ways.
Fig. 1. The distribution of a trait, fur color, in a population of mice. Fur color follows a normal
distribution. The vertical line in the center indicates the mean value for the trait.
Three types of selection are directional selection, stabilizing selection, and disruptive selection.
When individuals with traits at one end of the distribution have the highest fitness, directional
selection may occur. When individuals with traits in the middle of the distribution have the highest
fitness, stabilizing selection may occur. When individuals at both ends of the distribution have
higher fitness than individuals in the middle, disruptive selection may occur.
Histograms
Histograms are figures that are used to illustrate distribution data (see example Fig. 2). Usually the
number of individuals, frequency, or percentage is plotted on the y-axis against some continuous
variable on the x-axis. Individual samples or measurements are counted and binned into groups. A
bin is a range of values. A well-designed histogram has bins that are (1) adjacent, (2) nonoverlapping, and (3) equal in size. The number of bins used can reveal different features of the data,
and is dependent on the number of data points (n). Although there is no set way to decide how
many bins to use, one method is square-root choice method in which the number of bins (k) is a
function of the sample size (n), where k = n. However, deciding how many bins to use may require
other considerations.
88
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
Consider the example data below for mouse fur color (Table 1). How would we select bins for this
data? If we use the square-root choice method we would make 7 bins (46 = 6.8), but because our
data has values between 1 and 16, 8 bins is a better choice (16 is not divisible by 7). Therefore, it is
important to consider the range and values of the data in addition to the number of data points
when selecting bin sizes. If we use 8 bins for the mouse fur color data, we end up with the
histogram shown in Fig. 2.
Table 1. Fur color of individual mice (n =46) collected from an abandoned farm field. Color values
are on a 16-bit grayscale, where 1 = white and 16 = black.
fur color
(16-bit grayscale)
11
4
7
12
5
6
10
12
8
10
11
11
10
9
16
3
10
15
8
5
8
2
8
6
5
3
13
9
9
13
6
5
7
9
4
4
12
8
14
14
7
9
10
9
8
7
89
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
Fig. 2. An example histogram that shows the distribution of fur color among mice (n =46). Color
values are on a 16-bit grayscale, where 1 = white and 16 = black. Notice that the histogram above
approximates a normal distribution, and that bins are adjacent, non-overlapping, and of equal size.
Isopods
This week in lab you will carry out a natural selection experiment with isopods. Animals that
belong to the Order Isopoda can live in aquatic and terrestrial environments, and may be better
known to you as roly-polies (also called wood lice and pill bugs). Terrestrial isopods are often found
under decomposing logs and leaves. Isopods belong to the Class Crustacea, and like their marine
relatives such as shrimp and crabs, isopods breathe through gills. As a result, they must live in humid
environments and do not tolerate desiccation (drying) well. When we work with the isopods in the
lab it will be important to keep them moist.
We will work with the species Armadillidium vulgare. In nature, A. vulgare play an important role as
detritivores - organisms that consume decomposing plants and animals. They are also prey for a
variety of predators, including spiders, birds, and frogs. You will investigate natural selection by
simulating predation of isopods and measuring and plotting the distribution of some trait before and
after predation.
Pre-lab Questions
You should read and consider the questions below before lab so you are better prepared. You do
not need to record your answers in your lab notebook, but you may find it useful.
1. How could you rewrite or paraphrase the requirements for natural selection to occur?
2. Can you draw how the distribution of fur color in mice might change from that shown in
Fig. 1 with directional, stabilizing, and disruptive selection? Section 26.3 of Freeman has
good examples of these three types of selection.
3. How are bins selected for a well-designed histogram?
90
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
91
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
Data Set 2
American robins (Turdus migratorius) often lay several broods of eggs a year, and each clutch may
consist of 2-6 eggs. A group of ornithologists (scientists who study birds) counted eggs in robin
nests on a small wooded property in Virginia over the course of several decades. During this time
the surrounding countryside was converted from forest to farmland. Table 3 contains clutch sizes
recorded in 1983, before agricultural conversion, and data from 2007 after most of the surrounding
land became kale farms.
Table 3. Clutch size of American robin nests in Floyd County, VA.
clutch size (# eggs)
1983
5
3
6
6
6
3
2
3
3
4
4
5
3
2
6
3
5
5
5
5
6
2
5
2
2
3
3
4
4
4
6
4
4
4
4
2
92
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
Data Set 3
Plants and pollinators often co-evolve (evolve together). Many moth pollinators use tongue-like
proboscises to access flower nectar, and in turn help plants reproduce by moving pollen (male
gametes) between flowers. The following data (Table 4) on the length of sphinx moth proboscises
were collected during two different years (2010 and 2014).
Table 4. Proboscis lengths of sphinx moths collected in southwestern Colorado in late July 2010
and 2014.
proboscis length (mm)
2010
11
6
6
8
8
6
8
6
8
9
9
9
8
9
7
10
5
7
10
10
8
9
10
9
8
8
7
8
11
7
8
8
7
10
93
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
94
GENERAL BIOLOGY LAB MANUAL LAB 11: EVOLUTION & NATURAL SELECTION
9. Give the eaten and survivor culture dishes to your lab instructor. He or she will re-label
them.
10. Take measurement from both groups. After completing measurements, have your lab
instructor identify the two groups.
11. Create a histogram which compares the whole population of isopods (all 40 you started
with) to the survivor group.
Follow-up Questions
After producing histograms of your data, discuss the following questions with your group. Record
your answers in you lab notebook.
1. What type of selection, if any, did your observe in your experiment?
2. What is the relationship between variation and selection? For example, the number of dorsal
plates on isopods does not vary within species how do you predict selection might impact
this trait?
3. If predation and other selection pressures reduce variation, why does variation persist in
nature?
Clean-up
Before you leave lab:
4. Return isopods, soil, and paper towels to their container. Return containers to the back
bench.
5. Rinse and dry the large and small culture dishes.
6. Return rulers, paintbrushes and any other materials you used.
Acknowledgements
This lab was adapted by Chris North from a series of labs presented in Jordan & North (2014),
originally based on Berkelhamer (1998):
Jordan, C.N., and C.A. North. 2014. Life 1010 General Biology Lab Manual. Hayden-McNeil,
Plymouth, MI.
Berkelhamer, R. 1998. Variability and selection in natural populations of wood lice. Proceeding of
the Association for Biology Laboratory Education 19:245-254.
95
General Rules
1. On the front cover of your lab notebook include the following: your name, your lab
section, course and semester.
2. Dedicate the first page to a Table of Contents (see Organization and Contents below).
3. Because lab notebooks are permanent (and sometimes legal) records of work done, always
use a pen.
4. If you make a mistake, draw a thin line through the word or number. Do not obscure the
original entry. Sometimes these mistakes prove to be important.
5. Similarly, never remove a page from your notebook.
6. Write legibly!
7. Always include appropriate units with all data, and in all figures and tables.
97
Experimental Information
Objective
A brief (one or two sentence) explanation of the purpose of the experiment. What question do
you want to address?
For example, your objective might be to test the effectiveness of a new fertilizer on the production
of tomatoes by a tomato plant.
Variables
The independent variable is the variable you change or manipulate in an experiment. Groups
within the independent variable are referred to as treatments. The dependent variable is the effect
you measure. It is sometimes also called the response variable.
For example, you might want to measure the effect of fertilizer (independent variable) on the
tomato production (dependent variable). Your specific independent variables (or treatments) might
be the amount or type of fertilizer used, and you specific dependent variable might be number or
mass of tomatoes produced.
Include both the independent and dependent variables for each experiment.
Hypotheses
The null hypothesis is the hypothesis that the independent variable has no effect on the
dependent variable e.g. adding the new fertilizer does not affect tomato production.
The alternative hypothesis, on the other hand, is the hypothesis that the independent variable
has an effect on the dependent variable e.g. adding fertilizer affects tomato production. Note that
the alternative hypothesis does not speculate as to the nature of the effect this is the role of your
prediction.
Include both the null hypothesis and alternative hypothesis for each experiment.
Prediction
If there is an effect of your treatment (e.g. addition of the new fertilizer), what do you expect it to
be?
For the tomato example, you would probably predict that the addition of fertilizer will increase the
production of tomatoes. But you could also predict a decrease in the production of tomatoes.
98
99
You will produce an individual lab report based on an experiment you carry out as a class over
multiple weeks. Lab Reports mimic the style scientists use when publishing the results of their work
in peer-reviewed journals. We have you write a lab report to help you:
1. Develop a better understanding of the scientific process which is synthesized in scientific
articles.
2. Become acquainted with methods for analyzing and interpreting data
3. Become familiar with the style in which scientific findings are reported.
4. Improve your ability to write clearly and concisely
Below you will find helpful guidelines for preparing your lab report. You should also regularly
refer to the lab report rubric as you complete homework assignments and prepare your lab report.
An example lab report is also provided.
101
102
103
Citations
The primary literature used in scientific writing are peer-reviewed journal articles. For your lab
reports, you will be expected to find such articles to support statements you make in your
introduction and discussion, to compare with your findings, and to suggest further work. You may
also use books as references. With few exceptions, websites are not considered reputable sources for
scientific articles, and should not be used in lab reports. For this reason we have not provided
guidelines for citing internet sources.
In-text citations in scientific literature consists of the last name(s) of the author(s), and the year of
publication. Do not report page numbers. If citing multiple sources in-text to support a single
statement, list references in order by date.
Examples:
One author: (Jones 1999)
Two authors: (Jones & Smith 2008)
More than two authors: (Jones et al. 2011) et al. means and others
Multiple sources: (Jones 1999, Jones & Smith 2008)
Literature Cited sections should use the format shown below. List references alphabetically with
hanging indents. If citing multiple works by the same author, list these in order by date.
Journal article example, single author:
Alexander, R.D. 1974. The evolution of social behavior. Annual Review of Ecology
and Systematics 5:325383.
Journal article example, multiple authors:
Hanggi, P., P. Talkner, and M. Borkovec. 1990. Reaction-rate theory: fifty years
after Kramers. Reviews of Modern Physics 62:251341.
Book example:
Brooker, R., E. Widmaier, L. Graham, and P. Stiling. 2014. Biology, 3rd ed.
McGraw-Hill, New York, New York.
Book chapter example:
Sargent, J.R., and K.J. Whittle. 1981. Lipids and hydrocarbons in the marine food web.
Pages 491-533 in Analysis of Marine Ecosystems, A. Longhurst (editor). Academic Press,
London, UK.
104
Introduction
Many organisms can carry out fermentation, a process that allows cells to produce adenosine
triphosphate (ATP) even when they cannot perform cellular respiration due to lack of a final
electron receptor, such as oxygen (Freeman et al. 2014). Fermentation occurs in animal cells during
anaerobic exercise and is performed by many single-celled organisms in anaerobic environments
(Freeman et al. 2014). Like cellular respiration, fermentation produces carbon dioxide (CO2) as a
byproduct during the catabolic breakdown of glucose to release energy (Freeman et al. 2014).
Fermentation also produces other byproducts, such as lactic acid in humans and ethanol in some
yeast (Freeman et al. 2014).
One species of yeast that can produce ethanol is bakers yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) (Legras et al.
2007, Hageman & Pikur 2015). Bakers yeast has been used by humans to produce ethanol for
consumption for millennia (Legras et al. 2007). More recently, people have explored the possibility
of using ethanol produced by fermentation as an alternative to fossil fuels. Such biofuels can be
produced from a variety of different materials or substrates, including cane sugar and corn (Groom
et al. 2008).
105
Methods
To estimate the rate of fermentation of cane sugar and corn by yeast, we measured CO2
production in fermentation apparatuses over 40 minutes. Fermentation apparatuses consisted of a
50 mL centrifuge tubes with a 20 mL syringe attached to the lid by a Luer lock. A yeast solution was
prepared by adding 35 g of dry bakers yeast and 1 g NaCl to 1 L of water at 40 C and agitating for
5 minutes. To each tube, we added 15 mL of the yeast solution and 1 g of substrate. We then
secured lids, with syringes fully depressed, to the tubes. Every 10 minutes for 40 minutes, we
recorded the displacement of the syringe which indicated how much gas had been produced in the
fermentation apparatus.
For the cane sugar treatment group we used Sugar in the Raw and for the corn treatment group
we used corn meal. In addition to our two treatment groups (cane sugar and corn), we also had a
negative control group to which no substrate was added and a positive control group to which we
added 1 g of glucose. We performed three replicates in each experimental group.
For each replicate, we calculated the rate of CO2 production over the 40 minute experiment.
Averages and standard deviations (SD) were calculated for CO2 produced and rate of CO2
production for each experimental group. The rate of CO2 production was compared between the
two treatment groups by a t-test performed with Microsoft Excel.
106
Results
Over 40 minutes, the positive control group produced the most CO2 (20.3 0.6 mL, n = 3), while
the negative control group produced the least (0.2 0.1 mL, n= 3) (Fig. 1). In the same amount of
time, the corn treatment group produced 4.9 0.3 mL CO2 (n = 3) while the cane sugar treatment
group produced 13.1 0.3 mL CO2 (n = 3)( Fig. 1). The rate of CO2 production in the cane sugar
treatment group (0.33 0.1 mL/min, n = 3) was significantly higher (t-test, p < 0.001) than the rate
of CO2 production in the corn treatment group (0.12 0.1 ml/min, n =3) (Fig. 2).
Fig. 1. CO2 production by yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) in fermentation apparatuses with different
substrates over 40 minutes. Each 50 mL apparatus received 15 mL of yeast solution and 1 g of
substrate. The negative control group received no substrate, while the positive control group
received glucose. Each point on the figure represents the average of three replicates.
107
Fig. 2. The average rate of CO2 production by yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) in fermentation
apparatuses when given cane sugar or corn as a substrate (n = 3). Each 50 mL apparatus received 15
mL of yeast solution and 1 g of substrate. The rate of CO2 for each replicate was calculated over 40
minutes. Carbon dioxide was produced at a significantly higher rate when cane sugar was the
substrate than when corn was used (t-test, p < 0.001).
Discussion
We found that S. cerevisiae produced CO2 at a higher rate when given cane sugar as a substrate than
when given corn (0.33 0.1 mL/min versus 0.12 0.1 ml/min, p < 0.001; Fig. 2). We also
observed that the production of CO2 was higher in the cane sugar treatment group over the entire
experimental period of 40 minutes (Fig. 1). These results support our alternative hypothesis that the
substrate used affects the rate of fermentation by yeast and allow us to reject the null hypothesis that
that the substrate used has no affect the rate of fermentation by yeast. Furthermore, our results
support our prediction that cane sugar would be fermented more quickly than corn. Our findings
108
109
Literature Cited
Freeman, S., K. Quillin, and L. Allison. 2014. Biological Science, 5th ed. Benjamin Cummings, San
Francisco, California.
Groom, M.J., E.M. Gray, and P.A. Townsend. 2008. Biofuels and biodiversity: principles for
creating better policies for biofuel production. Conservation Biology 22:602-609.
Hageman, A., and J. Pikur. 2015. A study of the fundamental mechanism and the
evolutionary driving forces behind aerobic fermentation in yeast. PLoS ONE
10: e0116942.
Legras, J.L., D. Merdinoglu, J.M. Cornuet, and F. Karst. 2007. Bread, beer and wine:
Saccharomyces cervisiae diversity reflects human history. Molecular Ecology 16:2019-2102.
Renouf, M.A., M.K. Wegener, and L.K. Nielsen. 2008. An environmental life cycle assessment
comparing Australian sugarcane with US corn and UK sugar beet as producers for
fermentation. Biomass and Bioenergy 32:1144-1155.
110
Total Score:
=
_____%
_____ / 50
Methods (20%)
____ (4) Methods are clear
____ (4) Methods are complete
____ (4) Methods provide enough detail that the study could be duplicated.
____ (4) Descriptions of controls, sample size, and replication are included.
____ (4) Written in past tense and in paragraph form.
____ (20) Total
Results (20%)
____ (6) All results are clearly described in writing.
____ (2) Any trends, outliers, or interesting relationships are identified
but not interpreted.
____ (2) Figures and/or tables are referred to in the text with figure/table
numbers.
____ (3) All figures and/or tables clearly and correctly represent data.
____ (3) Figure axes are correctly labeled and include proper units and/or
columns and rows in tables are clearly labeled with proper units.
____ (4) Each figure and/or table has a descriptive caption (called a figure or table
legend) that provides enough information for a reader to understand and
interpret the figure or table without referring to the written report. In other
words, figures and tables are standalone.
____ (20) Total
111
Discussion (20%)
____ (4) Results are summarized and interpreted in light of the original experimental question and
background information.
____ (4) Hypotheses (both null and experimental) are accepted or rejected with explanation.
____ (4) Literature is cited (at least two sources) to help explain data or conclusions, for
comparison, or to suggest At lemodifications.
____ (4) Potential sources of error or bias are identified and their impact on the results are
discussed.
____ (4) Relevant additional research questions arising from results are posed and further studies
suggested.
____ (20) Total
General Comments:
112