Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Power
Power converters
converters
Definitions
Definitions and
and classifications
classifications
Converter
Converter topologies
topologies
Frdrick BORDRY
CERN
12-18th May 2004
Power Converters
for particle accelerators
Warrington, UK
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Power
Power converters
converters :: Definitions
Definitions
The
Thesource
sourceof
ofthe
thebeam
beamblow-up
blow-upwhen
whenwe
wecould
couldnot
not
prove
(Control
proveititwas
wasthe
theRF
RF
(Controlroom
roomoperator)
operator)
AApowerful
powerfulsmall
smallblack
blackbox
boxable
ableto
toconvert
convertMAD
MADfiles
files
into
intocurrents
currents (Accelerator
(AcceleratorPhysics
Physicsgroup
groupmember)
member)
An
Anequipment
equipmentwith
withthree
threestates,
states,ON,
ON,OFF
OFFand
andFAULT
FAULT
(Another
(Another operator)
operator)
Is
Isititthe
thesame
samething
thingas
asaapower
powersupply?
supply?
(Person
(Personfrom
fromanother
anotherphysics
physicslab)
lab)
AAbig
bigbox
boxwith
withwires
wiresand
andpipes
pipeseverywhere
everywhereand
and
blinking
blinkinglamps.
lamps.Occasionally
Occasionallyititgoes
goesBANGG!
BANGG!
(Group
(Groupsecretary
secretaryview)
view)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Power
Power converters
converters :: Definitions
Definitions (contd)
(contd)
That
Thatwhich
whichfeeds
feedsthe
themagnets
magnets
(a
(avisitor)
visitor)
AAstupid
stupidinstallation
installationtaking
takingaanon-sinusoidal
non-sinusoidalcurrent
current
at
atpoor
poorpower
powerfactor
factor (power
(powerdistribution
distributionengineer)
engineer)
AAstandard
standardpiece
pieceof
ofequipment
equipmentavailable
availablefrom
from
industry
industryoff-the-shelf
off-the-shelf
(a
(ahigher
highermanagement
managementperson,
person,not
notin
inin
inthis
thisroom
room!)!)
Something
Somethingwhich
whichconverts
convertsyour
yourtime
timein
inmoney.
money.
Efficiency
(my
Efficiency???
???Especially
Especiallylast
lastweek-ends
week-ends!!!...
!!!...
(mywife)
wife)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Traction
and auxiliary
Domestic Appliance
Medical applications
50 or 60 Hz ; AC
DC current
Control
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
AB/PO
In the beginning
AB/PO
By courtesy: I. Marneris
CERN - PS
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
AB/PO
Control
Ii
Io
Power Converter
Source
Vi
Topologies
Vo
Source
Power Converter
--performance
performance
--efficiency
efficiency
--reliability,
reliability,repairability,
repairability,availability
availability
--low
lowcost
cost
--effect
effecton
onenvironment
environment(RFI,
(RFI,noise,...)
noise,...)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Inductances
and
capacitors
Connection
rules
Switches
Power Converter
Topologies
Sources
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Source
Source definition
definition
Source definition: any element able to impose a voltage or a
current, independently of, respectively, the current flowing
through, or the voltage imposed at its terminals.
A source could be a generator or a receptor.
Two
Twotypes
typesof
ofsources:
sources:
Voltage
Voltagesource
source
which
which imposes
imposes aa voltage
voltage independently
independently of
of the
the current
current flowing
flowing
through
through it.
it. This
This implies
implies that
that the
the series
series impedance
impedance of
of the
the
source
source is
is zero
zero (or
(or negligible
negligible in
in comparison
comparison with
with the
the load
load
impedance)
impedance)
Current
Currentsource
source
which
which imposes
imposes aa current
current independently
independently of
of the
the voltage
voltage at
at its
its
terminals.
terminals.
This
Thisimplies
impliesthat
thatthe
theseries
seriesimpedance
impedanceof
ofthe
thesource
sourceis
isinfinite
infinite
(or
(orvery
verylarge
largein
incomparison
comparisonwith
withthe
theload
loadimpedance)
impedance)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Source
Source definition
definition
The principle of operation of a converter is based on the
switch mode action of its switches. Commutations of
these switches generate very fast current and/or voltage
transients so that the transient behaviour of the sources
is fundamental.
A source is a voltage source if the voltage across its
terminals cant undergo a discontinuity due to the
external circuit variation.
A source is a current source if the current flowing
through it cant undergo a discontinuity due to the
external circuit variation.
A square wave voltage (current) generator is indeed a voltage (current)
source, since the discontinuity are not caused by the external circuit.
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Source
Source definition
definition
Instantaneous impedance :
the limit of the impedance Z(s) when the Laplace
operator s tends towards infinity.
New definitions:
AB/PO
Source
Source examples
examples
L
1
E = LI 2
L 2
I state variable
dI/dt
Current source
V state variable
1
E = CV 2
c 2
dV/dt
Voltage source
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Source
Source examples
examples
K1
K1
K2
K2
Voltage source
between A and B :
ZAB = 0
Current source
between A and B :
ZAB =
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Source
Source nature
nature imposition
imposition
Plant
Plant
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Modification
Modification of
of source
source nature
nature
Cables
L
Battery
U
Voltage
Source
Current
Source
Voltage
Source
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Duality
+
Unidirectional
Unidirectionalsource
source
voltage
voltage : :ififthe
thevoltage,
voltage,across
acrossits
itsterminal,
terminal,cant
cantchange
changesign
sign
current
:
if
the
current,
flowing
through
it,
cant
reverse
current : if the current, flowing through it, cant reverse
Bidirectional
Bidirectional(reversible)
(reversible)source
source: :
voltage
voltage: :ififthe
thevoltage,
voltage,across
acrossits
itsterminal,
terminal,can
canchange
changesign
sign
current
:
if
the
current,
flowing
through
it,
can
reverse
current : if the current, flowing through it, can reverse
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Introductive example
Io
Uo
Ui
Converter
Ii
Io
Ii
Io
Ra
Ui
Rb
Resistive solution
Uo
Uo
Ui
Linear solution
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Introductive example:
Transfer of energy between
- DC voltage source Ui
- DC source (nature is not defined) : Uo, Io
Ii
Io
Ra
Ui
Rb
Uo
optimum Rb =
Ui
Ui==24V
24V; ;Uo
Uo==10
10VVand
andIoIo==600A
600A =>
=> efficiency
efficiency <<42
42%%
Ui
Ui==24V
24V; ;Uo
Uo== 55VVand
andIoIo==600A
600A =>
=> efficiency
efficiency <<21
21%%
Ui
Ui==48V
48V; ;Uo
Uo==10V
10Vand
andIoIo==600A
600A =>
=> efficiency
efficiency <<21
21%%
AB/PO
Ii
Ui
Io
T
Uo
Po = Uo . Io = 10 . 600 = 6000 W
PT (power dissipated by the switch) = UT. IT = (Ui Uo) . Io = (24 10) . 600 = 8400 W
Converter efficiency = Po / (PT + Po) = 42 % !!!!!
Furthermore, itll be difficult to find a component (semiconductor) able to dissipate 8400 W .
Then impossible for medium and high power conversion
Commutation
- UT = 0 if IT 0
- IT = 0 if UT 0
Linear mode
PT = 0
switch mode
(saturated-blocked)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Commutation
Active
Activecomponents
componentsused
usedas
asswitches
switchesto
tocreate
createaa
succession
successionof
oflink
linkand
andno
nolink
linkbetween
betweensources
sourcesto
to
assure
assurean
anenergy
energytransfer
transferbetween
betweenthese
thesesources
sources
with
withhigh
highefficiency.
efficiency.
Ii
Is
Ii
Is
Us
Ui
Direct Link
Ii
Is
Us
Inverse Link
Us
Open Link
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Ii
Io
Switch-mode converter
Ui
Linear
conversion
Ik1
Vk1
Uo
Ik2
Vk2
- Active filter
- 4-quadrant converters (see Mr. Thurels presentation)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
The problem :
switch characteristics
Power
Powerconverter
convertertopologies
topologies
Ik
Ik
Vk
Vk
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switch
Switch characteristics
characteristics
Switch :
ON state
Ik
Ik
Vk
Vk
OFF state
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switches
Switches :: two
two segments
segments
Power Converters for Particle Accelerators Warrington 12-18 May 2004
Static
Staticcharacteristics
characteristics
Ik
Vk
Ik
Ik
Vk
Type D
Vk
Type T
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switches
Switches::three
threesegments
segments
Static
Staticcharacteristics
characteristics
Ik
Vk
Ik
Vk
Ik
Vk
D and T
in parallel
D and T in series
D
T
D
T
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switches
Switches::four
foursegments
segments
Static
Staticcharacteristics
characteristics
Ik
Ik
Vk
Vk
or
D
T
D
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switches
Switches
Dynamic
Dynamic characteristics
characteristics
ON state
OFF state
Ik
spontaneous commutation
no losses
change of quadrant
Vk
controlled commutation
Ik
losses
no change of quadrant
(controlled turn-on ; controlled turn-off)
Vk
gate
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switches
Switches :: two
two segments
segments
Power Converters for Particle Accelerators Warrington 12-18 May 2004
Dynamic
Dynamiccharacteristics
characteristics
Ik
Vk
Ik
Ik
Vk
Type D
Vk
Type T
ON
OFF
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switches
Switches::three
threesegments
segments
Dynamic
Dynamiccharacteristics
characteristics
Ik
Vk
Ik
Ik
Vk
Vk
OFF
OFF
ON
T
ON
OFF
Vk
Vk
ON
D
Ik
Ik
OFF
ON
T
D
AB/PO
DUAL
DUALTHYRISTOR
THYRISTOR
Ik
OFF
Vk
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Switches
Switches::four
foursegments
segments
Dynamic
Dynamiccharacteristics
characteristics
Ik
Ik
Vk
Vk
or
Three
Threesegments
segmentssynthesis
synthesis=>
=>66types
typesof
ofswitches
switches
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Control
Ii
Io
Power Converter
Source
Vi
Vo
Source
Power Converter
--performance
performance
--efficiency
efficiency
--reliability,
reliability,repairability,
repairability,availability
availability
--low
lowcost
cost
--effect
effecton
onenvironment
environment(RFI,
(RFI,noise,...)
noise,...)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Commutation
Commutation rules
rules
electronic switches modify the interconnection of impeding circuits
V1
V2
Turn On impossible
I1
I2
AB/PO
V1
I1
C1
V2
I2
L1
C2
L2
AB/PO
Converter topology
Sources have different natures:
Direct link configuration
Sources have same natures:
Indirect link configuration :
need to had intermediate element
- modification of source nature
- use of two direct link structures
- indirect structure
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Connexion
Disconnexion
U
K2
K1
K3
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
K1
K4
D
K2
K3
K2
B
K4
K3
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect Conversion
- Two sources have the same natures => need to had intermediate element
I
I
I
Input
V
Output
Input
Output
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect Conversion
- Two sources have the same natures => need to had intermediate element
V
Inductance buffer
I
V
I
Capacitor buffer
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect Conversion
Voltage-Voltage Indirect Converters
Power Converters for Particle Accelerators Warrington 12-18 May 2004
Vi
Vi
Vo
Vo
Vo
OR
Vi
First sequence
K1
Second sequence
K1
K2
V0
K5
L
K3
K4
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect Conversion
Voltage-Voltage Indirect Converters
Power Converters for Particle Accelerators Warrington 12-18 May 2004
Vi
Vi
Vo
Vo
Vo
OR
Vi
First sequence
Second sequence
K1
K2
V0
K5
L
K3
K4
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect Conversion
- Two sources have the same natures => indirect converters
C
Io
Ii
Io
Ii
OR
C
Io
Ii
First sequence
Second sequence
K2
K1
I0
K5
K1
K3
K4
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect Conversion
- Two sources have the same natures => indirect converters
C
Io
Ii
Io
Ii
OR
C
Io
Ii
First sequence
Second sequence
K2
i
I0
K5
K1
K3
K4
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
K1
Vi
(Vo)
Three basic
converters
structures
Io
(Ii)
K2
K4
K3
K1
K2
Vi
V0
L
K3
K2
Ii
K5
K4
I0
K5
K1
K3
K4
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Direct
Converters
Current-Current
Indirect Converters
Voltage-Voltage
Indirect Converters
Output
Input
e
ev
R
e
bl
i
s
ve
n
co
er
rt
b
si
r
ve
e
R
le
rs
e
t
er
v
n
co
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
co verters
connve
l
a
u
D
rte
rs
Du
al
+
+
+
+
4
+
+
+
-
Output
Dual
Input
2
D
5
6
7
8
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
K1
AC
Vi
K2
K1
Vi
K2
K4
Io
AC
K4
K3
Vi
K3
K1
K4
K2
K3
Io
AB/PO
DC-AC
converter
AC-DC
converter
AC link
(HF)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Voltage
Current
Voltage
Current
Voltage
Voltage
Current
Current
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
DC 1
Chopper
DC 2
Inverter
AC 1
f1 = f2
AC controller
(transformer)
f1 = f2
frequency direct
converter
(cycloconverter)
Rectifier
AC 2
Converter classification
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Commutation
Operation of a static converter can be split into a sequence of elementary modes. Each
elementary mode is characterized by an electrical network different to the previous one and
derived by interconnection modifications of the active branches.
The network branches connected to this static devices must fulfil the connection rules of the
sources:
- each switch is connected to a voltage source (otherwise opening a switch would result in
open-circuiting a current source)
- the node at the centre of the star is connected to a current source since a voltage source
can be connected only to a current source through a controlled switch.
- at a given time one an only one switch must be ON to avoid connecting two voltages
sources and open-circuiting the current source.
Each commutation only involves two switches.
A1
V1
Star-connected
electronic switches.
V2
A2
I
C
A3
V3
A4
V4
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Elementary
Elementary Commutation
Commutation cell
cell
K1 and K2 are complementary switches
A1
Ik1
V1
Vk1
V
Ik2
Vk2
VVk1
k1++V
Vk2
k2 == V
V
IIK1
K1--IIK2
K2 == II
A2
V2
V = V1 V2
The
Thereversibilities
reversibilitiesof
ofthe
thevoltage
voltageand
andcurrent
currentsources
sources
determine
determinethe
thestatic
staticcharacteristics
characteristicsof
ofthe
theswitches.
switches.
The
Theswitches
switchesneed
needto
tohave
havestatic
staticcharacteristics
characteristicswith
with
the
thesame
samenumber
numberof
ofcurrent
currentand
andvoltage
voltagesegments.
segments.
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
ON
OFF
ON
OFF
ON
OFF
Chopper-type cell
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
on
off
on
off
Duality
on
off
on
off
AB/PO
AB/PO
Ui
K1
Io
K4
K2
Uo
K3
K1
Ui
K4
K2
Ui
Io
K3
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
I
i = I C dv/dt
i
v = V L di/dt
C
Example of commutation cell with inductive voltage source
L1
A1
Ik1
V1
Vk1
On command : OK
Off command : overvoltage
V
Ik2
L2
Vk2
A2
V2
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
K1 Turn on
K1 Turn on
L1
iK1
Ik1
V1
Vk1
V
Ik2
L2
Commutation
duration
defined by L1
and L2
(new phase)
- iK2
Vk2
L1
V2
Vk1 = V
Vk2 = 0
V1
; Ik1 = 0
; Ik2 = - I
i1
Ik1
I
Vk1
M
Ik2
Vk2
L2
L1
V2
Ik1
V1
Vk1
V
Ik2
L2
Vk2
+
i2
V1 L1 di1/dt V2 L2 di2/dt = 0
Ik1 Ik2 = I
dIk1/dt = di1/dt and dIk2/dt = di1/dt
dik1/dt = diK2/dt = (V1-V2) / (L1 + L2)
V2
Vk1 = 0 ; Ik1 = I
Vk2 = V ; Ik2 = 0
VM = (V1 + V2) / 2
Soft commutation (natural commutation) with overlapping
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
K2 Turn OFF
L1
Ik1
V1
Vk1
V
over voltage on K2
Ik2
L2
Vk2
L1
V2
Vk1 = V
Vk2 = 0
V1
; Ik1 = 0
; Ik2 = - I
i1
Ik1
I
Vk1
M
Ik2
Vk2
L2
L1
V2
Ik1
V1
Vk1
+
i2
V
Ik2
L2
Vk2
V2
Solution:
-Decoupling of the commutation cell
-Forced commutation.
Vk1 = 0 ; Ik1 = I
Vk2 = V ; Ik2 = 0
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Ik1
V1
Vk1
Cd
Ik2
L2
Vk2
V2
For example.
L1
Cd
Cd
+
E
L2
Output of LC filter
(with electrochemical capacitor)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Ik1
- C
Vk1
+
Power Converters for Particle Accelerators Warrington 12-18 May 2004
K3
Ik2
Vk2
L2
+- C
Vk1
-+
Vk1
-V
K3
L2
Ik1
++ C
Ik1
K3
Ik2
Vk2
L2
Ik2
Vk2
AB/PO
On
Off
On
Off
Vk
Ik
Vk
Ik
On
Off
Vk
AB/PO
Aided commutation
Hard Commutation
Commutation
Turn On
Commutation
Turn On
Off
On
Switching losses
Off
On
Conduction losses
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
High
Highinductance
inductance
can
canbe
beadded
addedto
to
reduce
reduce the
theturn
turn
ON
ONlosses
losses
On
Ik
On
Vk
Ik
IL
On
Thyristor
Turn On control
Off
Vk
Off : no control;
by the circuit topology
IL = 0
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
High
Highcapacitance
capacitance
can
canbe
beadded
addedto
to
reduce
reduce the
theturn
turn
OFF
OFFlosses
losses
Off
VC
Off
Ik
Vk
Ik
Dual Thyristor
Turn Off control
On : no control;
by the circuit topology
VC = 0
On
Off
Vk
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Conditions of soft-commutation:
- Switches with three-segments characteristic.
- This characteristic is entirely described at each period
- The converter must include reversible source(s) able to
provoke the conditions of the spontaneous commutation
of the switches at the right instant
- Lossless circuit can be added to the switch to limit the
losses due to the controlled commutation
(aided-commutation circuit)
Soft-commutation is not a slow commutation !!!!
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
a) Determine the natures of input and output sources => basic configuration
b) From the specification, deduce the voltage and current reversibilities of the input
and output sources (one configuration of general table)
c) From the basic configuration, identify the different phases of operation according
to the reversibilities and the energy transfer control. If necessary, simplify the
configuration (short-circuit or open switches)
d) For the various phases, check the sign of the current through the ON switches
and the sign of the voltage across the OFF switches
=> Ik(Vk) static characteristics of each switches
e) From the specification (desired output current and/or voltage functions), deduce
the sequence of the different phases. For every commutation, represent the
working point of each switches before and after the commutation.
f)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
First Example
Io
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Chopper:
Output
Input
K3
K2
Vi
K4
K1
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Vi
K1
K2
Io
K4
Vi
K3
K1
K2
Io
K4
K3
1
IK1
IK4
1
1
2
VK1
2
VK4
On
IK2
IK3
Vi
T
K1
Io
K4
Off
D
K2
K3
2
1
VK2
VK3
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Second Example
Io
K4
+
-
Reversible in current
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
Chopper:
Output
Input
K3
1
K2
Vi
K1
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Vi
K1
K2
Io
K4
Vi
K3
Energy: Output
Input =>=>
Output
Input
Brake
See previous
phase example
K1
K2
Io
K4
K3
1
IK4
IK1
2
2
VK4
VK1
D
K1
Io
K4
Vi
On
Off
T
K2
K3
IK2
2
VK3
VK2
IK3
1
2
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Brake phase
Active phase
On
Vi
Io
Io
Vi
Off
On
Off
Io
On
Vi
Off
On
Off
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
K1
K4
Third Example
K3
Io
Vi
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Voltage Inverter
Output
Input
K2
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Vi = E
Io K1 +
+
K2
Ik
K4
K3
Vk
Static
characteristics of
the switches
+
Vi = E
K1 +
Io
K4
K3
K2
Vi = E
K1 - Io +
K4
K2
K3
2
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Third example :
Voltage inverter
I
t0
t2
t1
t3
+E
t4
-E
1
+
Vi = E
K1 +
K1
and
K3
Io
K3
K1 +
Io
2
1b
2a
2b
K4
K2
+
Vi = E
1a
K4
1a
1b
2a
2b
Vi = E
Vi = E
K3
K2
Ik
1b
1a
2a
2b V
Lag between
voltage and current
>0
Dynamic characteristics
of the switches
K1 -
K2
K1 -
K2
K2
and
K4
Io
K4
K3
Io
K4
K3
Ik
2b
2a
1a
1b V
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
T1
D1
Io
Off
Off
Vi
T4
T2
D2
D3
1b
1bto
to2a
2a: :T1
T1to
toD2
D2(T3
(T3to
toD4)
D4): :OFF
OFFcommand
command
2a
2ato
to2b
2b: :D2
D2to
toT2
T2(D4
(D4to
toT4)
T4): :ZVS
ZVS
2b
to
1a
:
T2
to
D1
(T4
to
D3)
:
OFF
2b to 1a : T2 to D1 (T4 to D3) : OFFcommand
command
Ik
1b
1a
2a
2b V
T3
Off
Off
K1
and
K3
D4
Dynamic
characteristics
of the switches
K2
and
K4
Ik
2b
2a
1a
1b V
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Third example :
Voltage inverter
I
t0
t3
t2
t1
+E
t4
-E
1
+
Vi = E
K1 +
K1
and
K3
Io
K3
K1 +
Io
2
1b
2a
2b
K4
K2
+
Vi = E
1a
K4
1a
1b
2a
2b
Vi = E
Vi = E
K3
K2
Ik
1a
1b
2b
2a V
Lag between
current and voltage
>0
Dynamic characteristics
of the switches
K1 -
K2
K1 -
K2
K2
and
K4
Io
K4
K3
Io
K4
K3
Ik
2a
2b
1b
1a V
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
T1
D1
Io
T4
On
On
Vi
T2
D2
D3
Ik
1a
1b
2b
2a V
T3
On
On
K1
and
K3
D4
Dynamic
characteristics
of the switches
K2
and
K4
Ik
2a
2b
1b
1a V
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Power
Power Converter
Converter for
for magnets
magnets
Control
IG
Gene
rator
Power Converter
VG
IL
VL
Load
Power Converter
--performance
performance
--efficiency
efficiency
--reliability,
reliability,repairability,
repairability,availability
availability
--low
lowcost
cost
--effect
effecton
onenvironment
environment(RFI,
(RFI,noise,...)
noise,...)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
IG
IL
Power Converter
AC
VG
Topologies
3 phase mains
(50 or 60 Hz)
Voltage
Voltage source
source
VL
Load
DC
magnet, solenoid,
Control
Current
Current source
source
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
IG
IL
Power Converter
Power Converters for Particle Accelerators Warrington 12-18 May 2004
VG
VL
AC
3 phase mains
(50 or 60 Hz)
- -low
lowmains
mainsharmonic
harmonicdistortion
distortion
- -power
factor
(closest
to
power factor (closest to1)1)
Load
DC
Control
magnet, solenoid,
klystron, vacuum pump
- -low
lowripple
ripple(current)
(current)
- -reproducibility
reproducibility(short
(shortand
andlong
longterm)
term)
- -rejection
of
mains
disturbance
rejection of mains disturbance
- -dynamic
dynamicresponse
response
COMPROMISE
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
1 Quadrant mode
Output
Source
+
-
2 Quadrants mode
V
+
-
4 Quadrants mode
Operating
Operating Modes
Modes
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
General
General power
power converter
converter topologies
topologies
1
2
3a
3b
Rectifier
CV1
AC Link
CV2
DC Link
CV1
CV2
CV1
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Power
Power converter
converter topologies
topologies :: DC
DC -- DC
DC
1
Buck
Forward
CV2
CV2a
CV2b
HF
Voltage AC link
Resonant
CV2a
CV2b
HF
Current AC link
DC
DC
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Direct
Direct Converters
Converters :: Rectifiers
Rectifiers
Ik
AC
Voltage
DC
Current
Vk
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
+ -
- +
Thyristors
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Direct
Direct Converters
Converters :: Rectifiers
Rectifiers
Ik
AC
Voltage
AC
Current
Vk
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
+ -
- +
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect
Indirect Converters
Converters :: AC
AC link
link
AC
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
DC
Application
Application: :- -very
veryhigh
highvoltages
voltageswith
withlow
lowcurrents
currents
- -very
high
currents
with
low
voltages
very high currents with low voltages
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect
Indirect Converters
Converters :: DC
DC link
link
Input Converter : AC / DC
CV2
+
-
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect
Indirect Converters
Converters :: DC
DC link
link
Input Converter : AC / DC
CV2
+
-
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect
Indirect Converters
Converters :: DC
DC link
link
Input Converter : AC / DC
CV2
+
-
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Indirect
Indirect Converters
Converters :: DC
DC link
link
Input Converter : AC / DC
PWM
CV2
+
-
F
i
l
t
e
r
s
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Power converter
Performance requirements
Iref
I
Imeas.
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
The apparent belief on one side that anything is possible and the
impression on the other side that the specification have been
chosen at random, sometimes leads to rather cynical feelings
such as
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Some
Some definitions
definitions
AB/PO
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Accuracy
Accuracy
*requires definition :
(e.g. Electrical distribution system
perturbation, temperature variation,)
IMeas.
Accuracyppm
*
INominal
INominal
The
Theaccuracy
accuracyisisdefined
definedby
bydefault
defaultfor
foraadefined
definedperiod
period(Ta)
(Ta)
one
year)
(e.g.
(e.g. one year)
The
.
Theaccuracy
accuracyisisexpressed
expressedin
inppm
ppmof
ofIINominal
Nominal .
IfIfthe
thedefined
definedperiod
period(Ta)
(Ta) isistoo
toolarge,
large,aacalibration
calibrationprocess
process
should
shouldbe
beexecuted
executedmore
moreoften
often(e.g
(e.gevery
everymonth)
month)
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Reproducibility
Reproducibility
Uncertainty
Uncertaintyin
inreturning
returningto
toaaset
set
of
ofprevious
previousworking
workingvalues
valuesfrom
from
cycle
cycleto
tocycle
cycleof
ofthe
themachine.
machine.
Cycle 1
IB1
Cycle 2
IB2
Cycle 3
IB3
T < TR
IB2 = IB1 (Reproducibility pmm . Inominal )
IB3 = IB2 (Reproducibility pmm . Inominal )
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
40 I = 16000 Amps
0
20
0
-20
-400
60
Time120
in Minutes
180
2
1
0
-1
240-2
Stability
Stability
Maximum
Maximumdeviation
deviationover
overaa
period
periodwith
withno
nochanges
changesin
in
operating
operatingconditions.
conditions.
Stabilityppm . INominal
TS
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Glossary
Accuracy
Accuracy
Long
Longterm
termsetting
settingor
ormeasuring
measuringuncertainty
uncertaintytaking
takinginto
intoconsideration
consideration
the
full
range
of
permissible
changes*
of
operating
and
the full range of permissible changes* of operating and
Accuracy
environmental
environmentalconditions.
conditions.
*
Precision
IMeas.
ppm
INominal
**requires
requiresdefinition
definition
Reproducibility
Reproducibility
INominal
Uncertainty
Uncertaintyininreturning
returningto
toaaset
setof
ofprevious
previousworking
workingvalues
valuesfrom
from
cycle
Cycle 2
Cycle 3
Cycle 1
cycleto
tocycle
cycleof
ofthe
themachine.
machine.
Stability
Stability
IB1
IB2
IB3
TR
Maximum
Maximumdeviation
deviationover
overaaperiod
periodwith
withno
nochanges
changesininoperating
operating
conditions.
conditions.
TS
Accuracy,
Accuracy,reproducibility
reproducibilityand
andstability
stabilityare
aredefined
definedfor
foraagiven
givenperiod
period
Precision is qualitative . Accuracy is quantitative.
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Resolution
Resolution
Smallest
Smallestincrement
incrementthat
thatcan
canbe
be
induced
inducedor
ordiscerned.
discerned.
I*ref I*ref
DAC
I*meas. I*
ADC
Imeas + I.
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
I0 = 1019.9 Amps
60
40
20
1
Reference
Measured
0
80
Time in Seconds
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Tracking
Tracking
ss
Ability
Abilityof
ofthe
theconverter
converter to
to
follow
followthe
thereference
referencefunction
function
(static,
(static,dynamics)
dynamics)
I1
I2
I3
Iref
AB/PO
RIPPLE
RIPPLE
V
Power converter
Control
Circuit
H(s)
I
Magnet
F(s)
V = R . I + L . dI/dt
=> H(s) = 1/ (L/R . s + 1)
Voltage
Voltageripple
rippleisisdefined
definedby
bythe
thepower
powerconverter
converter
Current
Currentripple
ripple::load
loadtransfer
transferfunction
function
(cables,
(cables,magnet
magnetinductance,)
inductance,)
(good
(goodidentification
identificationisisrequired
requiredififthe
theload
loadisisaalong
longstring
stringof
ofmagnets
magnets))
AB/PO
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Power Part
(Voltage Source)
Topologies
Vref
Analogue and/or Digital
Iref
Control
Current
Transducers
Active
Devices
E. Carroll
Passive
Components
A. Rufer
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Power Part
(Voltage Source)
Topologies
Fast Pulsed
Vref
Converters
Analogue and/or Digital
P. Smith
Control
Iref
Converters
for cycling
machines
N. Marks
Rectifiers
R. Visintini
Current
Transducers
SMPC
1-quadrant
P. Barrade
SMPC
SMPC
4-quadrant
Y. Thurel
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Systematical
Analysis
C. De Almeida
L
I ld
C
L
iL
C
3
1
vC0 vC1
vC
E
5
7
E+
E
L
I ld
C
L
I ld
C
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Regulation
Theory
F. Bordry
Power Part
(Voltage Source)
DAC- ADC
J. Pickering
Topologies
Vref
Control
DAC
Analogue
and/or Digital
Iref
Control
A
D
C
Current
Transducers
High Precision
Measurements
G. Fernqvist
Control
and Interfaces
Q. King
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
AC
Mains Supply
Power Part
(Voltage Source)
Electrical Network
and
Power Converters
H.-U. Boksberger
Topologies
Vref
Control
Analogue and/or Digital
Iref
Control
Current
Transducers
Protection
Interlocks and
Diagnostics
S. Griffiths
ElectroMagnetic
Compatibility
EMC
A. Charroy
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Netlist
Schematic input
and/or
+
-
+
-
Simulation Program :
+
-
TRTOL
Simulations Tools
??
Post-Processor :
Scope look and feel
Wave form calculator
Nice plots and prints,...
Demo
P. Jenni
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
I had a dream
Ik
Vk
ON
Vk up to 10 kV
Ik up to 1kA
In a few ns
OFF
It became a nightmare
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Matrix converters Ideally an all silicon solution for power conversion ("no
need for reactive energy storage components" !!!!... )
Dream
n-phase
m-phase
n x m bi-directional switches arranged so that any of the output lines can be connected
to any of the input lines.
A line filter are necessary to circulate high frequency switching harmonics.
Switches are modulated in such a way as to generate the desired output waveform
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Most current Matrix Converter researches are focussed on 3-phase to 3phase converters: 9 bi-directional switches.
nightmare
AB/PO
Instead of
4-segments
switches
ON
OFF
ON or OFF
ON or OFF
ON or OFF
3-segments
switch
ON
OFF
ON or OFF
ON or OFF
ON or OFF
ON or OFF
ON or OFF
ON or OFF
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
K2
K2
V/2
V/2
K1
K1
K1
V/2
K1
V/2
VM = 0
VM = V
K2
K2
K2
V/2
I
K1
M
K1
V/2
VM = V/2
K2
AB/PO
AB/PO
Multicell concept
Main states of "2-cell" commutation cell
K2
K2
K1
V/2
K1
V/2
K1
K1
VM = 0
VM = V
K2
K2
K2
K1
V/2
K1
M
K1
V/2
M
K1
VM = V/2
K2
VM = V/2
K2
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Vn-1
Vn
Kn
Vn = V ;.
Vk-2
Vk-1
Vk
Kk
K1
Kk-1
Kk
Kn
V1
Kk-1
K1
Vk = k . V / n ; . ; V1 = V / n
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Kk
Kk-1
K1
Kp
Kk
Kk-1
K1
Vn = V ;.
Vk = k . V / n ; . ; V1 = V / n
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Standard Model
Voltage
source
Capacitor
Current
Source
Inductance
Type D
D
Type T
T
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Type D
Type T
OFF
OFF
T
OFF
ON
ON
T
ON
T
D
OFF
ON
T
D
Etc
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
Protons + Leptons
=
Atoms
K1
Vi
(Vo)
Io
(Ii)
K4
K2
K3
K1
K2
Cohesion laws:
Never short-circuit a voltage source
Never open a current source
Vi
V0
K5
L
K3
K2
Ii
K4
K5
I0
K1
K3
K4
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
+
Output
+
-
+
+
Input
36 8 = 28
+
-
Mendeleiev Table
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO
r
o
f
k
n
a
n
h
o
i
T
t
n
e
t
t
a
r
u
o
y
Regards
Regards for
for your
your participation
participation
Fk. Bordry
AB/PO