Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
An Examination of Sources as
they Pertain to Domenico Gabrielli's
First Ricercar for Violoncello Solo
by Brian Carter
Brian Carter Performing Gabrielli's First Ricercar
Domenico Gabrielli (1651-1690) was a member of the group of elite cellists that operated in
Bologna, Italy in the seventeenth century. Along with his teachers, Petronio Francheschini and
Giovanni Battista Vitali, Gabrielli was one of the pioneers of baroque cello playing.1 Gabrielli's
Seven Ricercare for Violoncello Solo represent the first works to be published for a lone cello.
Gabrielli was a busy cellist and composer, maintaining employment in Bologna's two premier
instrumental groups: the Accademia Filarmonica, and the orchestra of the Basilica San Petronio.2
The Orchestra at San Petronio was Bologna's most important musical group. This orchestra attracted
famous composers, performers, and conductors, and helped to set the stage for young composers like
Gabrielli and later, Torelli. Its chief architect, Andrea Manfredi, designed the basilica at San Petronio
to be "the largest church in Christendom."3 This massive structure was completed in the fifteenth
century, and by the mid-1600's, there was already a small orchestra in place, numbering between ten
and twenty musicians, depending on the occasion.4
Bologna was also home to an innovation that would forever alter the course of string playing, and
therefore the writing of music for stringed instruments. In the 1660's (a clear date is not readily
available), Bolognese string makers developed the wire-wound strings to be used for the cello's C
and G-strings.5 These new strings afforded the cello with a clearer tone, and allowed for a smaller
instrument to be used without sacrificing the tonal benefits of the larger cellos that were sometimes
used for continuo playing. Anne Schnoebelen's article points out that some of the manuscripts left by
San Petronio composers called for violoncello continuo and violoncello spezzato. She notes that the
continuo instrument was likely a larger-sized cello, or the older violone, while the spezzato
instrument was more likely a smaller instrument, capable of handling more soloistic material.6 These
new wire-wound gut strings would have solved this issue. By allowing for a quicker response, the
smaller cellos (now strung with these new strings) would have been able to handle both roles. As this
study moves to a direct look at Gabrielli's composition, we will see just how important these strings
must have been for him.
Gabrielli's Ricercari are fairly free in terms of compositional structure. Rather than falling into the
category of the structured, fugal ricercari of G.B. Antonii, or those of his teacher G.B. Vitali,
Gabrielli's compositions can be grouped into three structural types. The first is the 'ritornello type.'
This style contains some elemental subject that returns in a regular manner, thus affording a real
sense of organization. The second type is the 'through-composed' style. In these ricercari, Gabrielli
utilizes an almost improvisatory style. The musical ideas seem to naturally arise out of the preceding
material, and there is little melodic repetition. In this style, rhythmic ideas and cadential formulas are
the main connective tissue. The final formal type used is that of the 'canzona-type.' In this style,
Gabrielli moves through larger sections, using tempo and meter changes to indicate demarcate
sections. This third style is surely a precursor to the method he employed in his continuo sonatas,
which are very sectional.7
1 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
It is the through-composed style that is of greatest concern here, as that is the category that best
describes the first ricercar. The opening statement of the first five measures comprises the closest
Gabrielli comes to providing a theme.
2 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
Another aspect in this work (and really all of the ricercare), is the constant use of the lower two
strings, often times with rapid notes. These pieces were written about thirty years after the
introduction of the Bolognese wire-wound gut strings. While Gabrielli certainly makes use of the
upper strings, and even requires the cellist to utilize a great deal of shifting on those upper strings, he
just cannot seem to resist the draw of the lower strings.12 This dramatic use of the lower strings
would not have been possible on the bare gut lower strings, and Gabrielli's ricercare would have
been unplayable on the larger, continuo cellos. Given the extensive demands on the left hand which
included rapid passage-work, a great deal of position shifting, and double-stopping, the new strings
in combination with a slightly smaller cello would have been absolute necessities for the
performance of these works.
In searching for primary source material dealing with the violoncello in the seventeenth century,
there is very little to choose from. Owing to the fact that treatises were generally used as a teaching
tool for amateurs, the violoncello receives very few mentions, due to its status as a professional's
instrument. As such, it was taught through the guild system, and was not meant for amateurs. In fact,
the first known Italian cello methods did not appear until midway through the Eighteenth century!
The first, penned by Francesco Scipriani was published ca. 1753, followed by Salvatore Lanzetti's
1756 method.13 That said, there are a few relevant sources that do discuss violin playing, and they
are able to serve as a sufficient starting point for this project.
Bartolomeo Bismantova's 1677 treatise, Compendio Musicale, covers many topics, ranging from
basic theoretical discussions to the techniques of playing stringed, keyboard, and wind instruments.
There is precious little information available concerning Bismantova's life, but he did seem to be
well educated, and his treatise contains some of the earliest available fingering tables for the
recorder, flageolet, and the cornett.14
For my purposes, Bismantova's work contained some excellent examples of how one should bow
different musical examples. He laid out short musical excerpts in a variety of different time
signatures in order to show how different rhythmic groupings might alter one's bowing choices. In
these excerpts, Bismantova uses a system of dots to indicate bow direction: a dot above the note
indicates up-bow, while a dot below the note indicates a down-bow. In the following examples, I
have only included the ones in triple meter, as they are the most relevant to my study, since the first
ricercar is in 3/4 time. The main aspect to be noted from Bismantova's examples is the strict
adherence to the so-called "rule of the down-bow." This rule, largely associated with French and
German schools of playing, states that when using an overhand bow-grip, all important notes and
downbeats are to be played down-bow. Bismantova's use of this rule is curious, to say the least, but it
offers some insight into how string players in the seventeenth century were using the bow.
It is important to note that Bismantova felt it was worth mentioning that bowing rules are "the same
for the cello as for the violin."15 This distinction allows me to state with some confidence that
Bismantova's bowing rules are directly applicable to Gabrielli's ricercar.
3 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
4 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
5 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
but at least I will be approaching the embellishments from an earlier perspective, as opposed to
attempting to add later eighteenth century trills and exaggerations.
In conclusion, this project has provided me with many challenges in terms of locating relevant
source material to guide my performance choices. At the very least, we know both what type of
strings Gabrielli was using, and that he was performing on a smaller-size instrument similar to what
we currently use. With the help of Corrette, making a decision on how to hold the bow was made
easier with his distinction of the Italian-style of bow hold. I feel that the most important discovery I
have made in this project has been Bismantova's very clear bowing examples. I feel the most
confident about the bowing choices that I have made thanks to Bismantova's very clear and orderly
approach to laying out the rules of bowing. It must have been right at the end of the down-bow
tradition in Italy when Gabrielli wrote these pieces, as the style obviously changed soon thereafter to
Geminiani's ideal of bowing as the notes come.
December 7, 2008
ENDNOTES
1. Anne Schnoebelen, "Performance Practices at San Petronio," Acta Musicologica 41 (June
1969): 46.
2. Gordon Kinney, The Musical Literature for Violoncello (Ph.D. diss, FSU, 1962): 229-230.
3. Eugene Enrico. The Orchestra at San Petronio (Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press,
1976): 4.
4. Ibid.: 31.
5. Stephan Bonta, "From Violone to Violoncello" Journal of the American Musical Instrument
Society 3, 1977: 98.
6. Schnoebelen: 47.
7. Ibid.: 234.
8. Kinney, Vol. 3: 40.
9. Ibid., Vol. 3: 40.
10. Ibid.: 245.
11. Ibid, Vol. 3: 40.
12. Brent Wissick, "The Cello Music of Bononcini" Journal of Seventeenth Century Music
12/1: 3.4.
13. Brent Wissick, "The Cello Music of Bononcini" Journal of Seventeenth Century Music
12/1: 3.4.
14. Jutta Lambrecht, "Bismantova, Bartolomeo," Grove Music Online, ed. Laura Macy.
http://www.grovemusic.com (accessed [05 December 2008]).
6 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
15. Bartolomeo Bismantova, Compendio Musicale (Firenze, Studio per edizioni scelte, 1977): 120.
As translated by Mark Vanscheeuwicjk in his article, "The Baroque Cello and Its Performance," in
the journal, Perfromance Practice Review Vol. 9 (1996): 87.
16. Ibid.: 112-114.
17. Francesco Geminiani, Art of Playing the Violin (London: Oxfrod University Press, 1951): 4.
18. Ibid.: 6.
19. Ibid.: 24.
20. Corrette, Mthode de violoncello (Geneva: Minkoff Reprints, 1972): 8.
21. Ibid.: 12. As translated by Valerie Walden in her book, One Hundred Years of Violoncello.
22. Domenico Gabrielli, The Complete Works for Violoncello, ed. Bettina Hoffmann (Kasel:
Hinnenthal-Verlag, 2001): VIII.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Primary Sources:
Bismantova, Bartolomeo. Compendio Musicale 1677. Firenze: Studio per edizioni scelte, 1978.
Corrette, Michel. Mthode Thorique et Pratique pour apprendre en peu de temps le Violoncelle dans
sa perfection 1741. Geneva: Minkoff Reprints, 1972.
Gabrielli, Domenico. "Ricercare Primo," score, 1689. Special Collections Luigi Silva Collection,
Jackson Library, The University of North Carolina at Greensboro.
Geminiani, Francesco. The Art of Playing on the Violin 1751. Edited by David D. Boyden. London;
New York: Oxford University Press, 1951.
Ortiz, Diego. Tratado de glosas sobre clusulas y otros gneros de puntos en la msica de violone
1554. Kassel: Brenreiter, 1961.
Secondary Sources
Berger, Jean. "Notes on Some 17th-Century Compositions for Trumpets and Strings in Bologna. The
Musical Quarterly, 37/3 (July 1951): 354-367.
Bonta, Stephan. "From Violone to Violoncello: A Question of Strings?" Journal of the American
Musical Instrument Society 3 (1977): 64-99.
Careri, Enrico. "Geminani, Francesco."Grove Music Online. http://www.grovemusic.com (accessed
[05 December 2008]).
Cowling, Elizabeth. The Cello. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1975.
7 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
Enrico, Eugene. The Orchestra at San Petronio in the Baroque Era. Washington: Smithsonian
Institution Press, 1976.
Gabrielli, Domenico. The Complete Works for Violoncello. Edited by Bettina Hoffmann. Translated
by J. Bradford Robinson. Kassel: Hinnenthal-Verlag, 2001.
Kinney, Gordon, Ph.D. "The Musical Literature for Unaccompanied Violoncello." , diss. Florida
State University, 1962.
Lambrecht, Jutta. "Bismantova, Bartolomeo" Grove Music Online, ed. Laura Macy.
http://www.grovemusic.com (accessed [05 December 2008]).
Paul Laird. The Baroque Cello Revival, An Oral History. Toronto; Oxford: The Scarecrow Press,
Inc., 2004.
Mishkin, Henry G. "The Solo Violin Sonata of the Bologna School." The Musical Quarterly 29/1
(January 1943): 92-112.
Schnoebelen, Anne. "Performance Practice at San Petronio in the Baroque Era." Acta Musicologica
41 (January-June 1969): 37-55.
Vanscheeuwijck, Marc. "The Baroque Cello and Its Performance." Performance Practice Review 9
(1996): 78-96.
Walden, Valerie. One Hundred Years of Violoncello: A History of Performance Practice, 1740-1840.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
Wasielewski, Wilhelm Joseph. The Violoncello and its History. Translated by Isobella Stigand. New
York: Da Capo Press: 1968.
Wissick, Brent. "The Cello Music of Antonio Bononcini: Violone, Violoncello da Spalla, and the
Cello "Schools" of Bologna and Rome." Journal of Seventeenth-Century Music 12 (2006):
http://sscm-jscm.press.uiuc.edu/v12/no1/wissick.html .
8 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
9 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM
http://www.cello.org/newsletter/articles/gabrielli/gabrielli.htm
10 of 10
11/5/16 2:42 PM