Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
AIAA 20020000
A Discrete Dynamical System
Subgrid-Scale Model of Turbulent
Convection
J. M. McDonough
Departments of Mechanical Engineering and
Mathematics
D. L. Joyce
Department of Mechanical Engineering
University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 40506-0108
)
$+
*-,/.
+01( 2"
!"#$%&'(
* 546 78 *
9;:=<>:=<?A@BDCEBDFEGIHKJ
L0MON;PIQSRUT7MWVKRYX0Z\[^]_Ma`ab;PIVKcd`ePIfhgiVjIcYVkMaMWQScYVjlPIV=mn]PIRobKMWTpPIRqcd`aX
@0:Krs:=9IBut?Av
L MON;PIQSRqT7MWVKRwZ\[]>Ma`ab;PIVKcd`ePIfhgiVjIcYVkMaMWQScYVj
0
xyVKcYzIMWQ{XWcYRU|}Z\[^~#MWVKRq`a|usyMDcYVjIR\ZV;~_kIeI
OSWWAW\wqUUuAWOWoYdeqOAaaiSuyuOhwuda
WqWoSKOAyOA{AOA{ahiueOiA{Aadiu{OSuudSSOA
SKOAWeAdW;A{dShSUW\euUu{8D;uODkAqSdWAUWA
dO^d
AS{SeOuA^A{
SAudeoeSiOSqeShu{_W0A{sdWo
SuO{OSWudA\dhA{=e{OAWuWS=eSSeUd;ydAS
SUSdudduSaude{SeuuKAAOA{kOWWd{USUsOAO{
SdWUedDWOAkOAaaOiSI(hudqeS;Od{AW{dUudWuq\d\dhuAW
\WqAoUe-OddeqAAUaUiWWO\SWOhAWOeOSd
yO#={A{y0eieSUWk{UkWpWpAWU{OWaWdeieSweiodd{UeI
hA{AdiWWOeOWSO^OUe^deUudySd\SUeUdAeA{Ae
{AudhSdsSUOWwdSoAASW
huIo=
y=eAup'uqUaUe
U>lSuWd#WwSUaU dWda
U Ad
ad U=UWd\d
S S
du WSU D d A
WwU uUW
!
#"
W% $&')(Yu* (U +,W}\Uu
S S huqUaUeU d- wd ' .
UWsWU/
1
024352'6&798;:<8>=&3?8A@swuu WUC
Bk UUD
8 d EuSUW8Wia d W- WeOUWF HG<UU
wWd E\W/
ddU C
I ' SUWi\WddJ u
U a IddeK
0.8;62@43:<L 7M246&8A@NOF=&8;79L P
OQN.3?8AR.:9S
T dU
qe
VdJ +WySX
WKSqUdUWZ Y
A [ \dT
eodSdU F]J^}w ewJ
wuu ` _ }u 8W^U/
a
U8S
Tbdc
"
W U#d e
U
g fWqWQ h
Wi
U SWd#/
qS }Uw
WT
S
WUSsW\4 dS ie qiUU eUU
U
jlk Y n
mo
UX
Gdd p' Ul
jlkshdS
I
Id qGWdsW- WeOUWH
jlkUdw
U SU W =U0S eWqwlq/
WwUdeS
T
r
AUU os
W7Wa
U* t2duvuxw ++
2'3yNOQu z.&B{uU|
SUWW=W 5jlkiW\
\W- Od
kW
AUU } u4 W dX
WSu - Id ~l
U EuwSU l
o ASUdySdhsU U
U
U UaUSq
U} x2uvuq"
W
g d&Uat
qhIdU We* Ek=UdSwydw
y24.:ROQ0=&PN..246JN4v2%0||N.d8A2'6&Z35R}2&=y
T< UAWe
WkW \eUq wW WU
ds Ww
%`?&J?`&g`{`*;
d dq
q<2duv}uwW}WZ4&SWsW;U SUW
q/ 1I du a ddWo WqUSWAUWJ
WdyyS w du\e drJW?^Sd
SE S W yUdw W- WeOdC
U
UWUSd
w ` >UWd
Aq &
k
Ueq u
da\W/
U
4
W
<
UWW
S\ udW W Ut
UwkU uUWWsdWwJ e&
U 2WZ W\U dW w F( UwK WUd a
SudkWO;UaEqUU Q dUW WeS( (o-
d UeUu W J U \w
d U} {USE/
WU Kq} I
W\eJ wu'
W } wAd{
#Wud W WUUw
aS W UUW/
udS Sd 4
W ;wIpd\W +e8WwWdUW
[
WeSIUS
WI y ID h=S SwAd UWU
\A4 fh ddSdwW. d adSU
Wd d H
X<w C
UC
G +W% 4'C( s9
qSAEUsdWWQ +=daKdU\iSIUeq
dW w
WdS UUe0#aJ U
S WAU* Kq/
D
hZ U uU1
hdq SU wSdQ aadU!
ho
udWShU9
dUAl
IUqJ u
N008;38;.2n02%@%R.79P
R.=&8;38AR:=Sdd adWDwWUWIi
Aw Wa
2'3lN.OQu %?$`iw !
Bk ad' $J$?$`,'
U\WAd' EW
BU4 d adg yBk0 M
"S
S\ W
WdC
q l2uvu{w
Sd
"Se
$ Y d
o uUw W^ d > Q SUeq8w\U4
4 W W\J Q lU dUA#dWdW +ad
U
A J A J g
[
d A J hWUd WU'hdU We-YU SU
(YZ*qd S^S/ uW\UdQdW
wWWU.
U S UF2duvu \`--& WSUSdU}A
\Ud\UWpW/u d d!=4@NOQ24P=%8;798;OQN6&8;3
- WU
U/ aWuSw X7
w
US2'3
N.OQu$& W U!U] qUuodt{ WU S d
c UaAUd
wdJ U J W
HI< \J SUW
\S SU
ud{ SUW#SwUu0S 4 aUW8S W W
\W/ ddU /I W#} 0n\`k
d; WW
W\eW-W eOUW`( {
B e q8U y
k
d adSd#u\dd od
s
d
a
`
Am}
xU5x
2dU\UW hqS dUAUW.d.
UW^daSdd8U} 8Wi qJ u}7
_ d
SUU Ud ady\/ UeUU I
WuU{hB } dq
duE SUW
dsUhSw W
WSJ W-W eOUWFY( qe\WJ U\UW Q
wd
A
C du\e dddUuod' Q
Us dWu\S e\`<[ SudWUS
/ aWewWkUdWkSdso u}8
^ U
d.A uUWwiW/ WU qSKd S dU
Wd
+ d adKqW W Uq}S U
w dUWwS w<
n-Z.-* Z
( eWU
e%W
eUasUe[Y W. d SUW
SW-W eOdQ eakUSqWI'E ddqeUD
wU dkWd
A}
AWZ
l
j k
A
jSk tjl k ,
~X k
A<
(YUUd }aUW=J d\dQ uhWUySUU uDdAdD
ad ddJ eO(dyUw WUhJ ad \duSU
&KS
sd WWg H"C
W uo0\9
I
AS -h I^d e Ud\U\SW uo
SW u /
! " hX
hEue WUd $x
# uSU
d IUU \/
Ud SU uU e\eUdSd
UdSSU}qde4a Wdaq/ sdk
wdQ aad\UudW
"Q dW\' d\Wudi
IdwkdU.
*A} =UUUuodWSUdSwU \U
U1
dd dduAUUdW
A TAWg ' "
i\w
W\U \
nW8F[ 246JN 6R]4\ 2%@'3?8AR.:Z
aUad UdadwAdSd|
t d ad|
q
2uvu^hoSAU1
oGW W ,p &_^h9
WOsJ IWUWKU
V.XS
UwdsWAd UeddSUWA
SUdU^
qUwe U} u
dAS}WI Sd}ddw S
WUUWd o0U WU8WdS 0U9
#U^Uuod
S;WuSdwDdAU d adl
?V=% =U ?a
dW WU UidWdt
n
d U}
"
G Ud4 UeqadwS :7S
Wl
' E ddqe* Ue I\U W } W
uU eUkd/IaJU u'hW
' ('
')'
*'
'
(
'
&% $
,
q
I
W
"
Bh} dq <U EuaUWWI- W}
WeU
eWiUd WqKUU>WUdWA SU uS
<A
1{
0 6k Ut
WUW- Id
243 * '5# Y
%
6 ,
SH
y2k d Id
#
% 6
(Y}UU4E-UeUU 3 d YuUeOUWW/IW
SUWad W\ adWeOdWd 2 U\
'\A8Sdd W w\dU #4 E-SUgiW 6
a`
jSk
a`
`
Xcb
Xih
Xcj
X edfXg!
FgW}
X dX*! "
FgSZ
X d X "
FgW
(Y
dUwSUWCk $ , ell sH[. WWeOU
dsWUW/ AdSnmpoIqorma^
W / aW
U SyWdSUWdiWU \UW
Uu SUsdaU{uDSwWqUU u d
U dUAdSUW( U} W W Uw qd
dSUWd/ WUQ+ U
qZ; ue dUC AUU
uRIU\edW/I WWsV.X Q UdS Q
S(d6WkUSdU SkU\/ 4
E 'E I Wd
wWd. d U#U
d#UeI \UuDdAdSUWgK
\d'E Q Wd wu'uE sEuWk
{WdS SWWUl WqdW>\WddJ u
4 OdW4 SJ e\Qh SaUW S d. ue
Uwu adU
y adSU
Uu dWU oW
odu UA g! gk
Ad
4gAW -u <& SU\|
u dX Uu Od U0eW8S=d\} AdS
hU V.Xu
" 0Ue SiU 4
SU^/ aU
WUUWd oW\/ W\=< qq dI UUSIU
WU Od4h
id^ 0quqUWl
V =iW
UG d\'
S;UU u dd4 dUAaUW
! g&f
k
, X
t XX ` $ u w , u w x uyw X {z
l
j
k b
b
b b
h b
uHv w
a}
t X ` u w u w x uyw X
$
,
~Xk #
% ;
d ; UU UQo
"=U KWK/ aUWuS
4}(Sd
wqddSUWwD EueW- WeOUWC
I SU-
SdyU\ W{
IUWdquSU d\/
Sd
dS=} l
wuu Wh Wd d X
IZO .
UWpU^qeSd^S0d#W- WeOUWF ^
qwWUsdaWW/
\Ui
*d S} -
SdSd Ix
dd\ded\9
Uy Aqe
dW y
ghUWwsuwW=<?>1\@ ,Z
ACB ED FHG .Id =DKgJ MLFGNMOPHJ4Qd L
(Y8U J UOd } u wUuU aadda
\ UdyU9
SUU uRIUAU ad9
AW==% |
AdS WdWUuodday x
d' 4 a
ad* n"M
d U 8UWWI
ud\deudW ` [Wd|
t d ad4
q Wd4 IS udW 4 Q /
q +
UdSUwAsShUUdw U SUWg 8W
Sg U A IsW WskdWd T
Ueqad/
u
Ue W# UeWulI
qe\` T[W
w&
WH
TSIW- , Y &
^8IWd wda Q u4 IuAT
aWU S
Wd4 dUAUe
G UqU \8Au;2u(USdia
eWqkF ,F
< &qGWU/
o s Ud UUSU
WU KqUWV.X
Y UwWqU \UWSIUeqyUde A`
qeUU=U Q |
U} qde4 f8 CUZV.X
Y \/
U
S d dSUUH
8;8 U V.Xu=WUWUUWd S
W\9
WOJ IWU (WK
8;8;8 iUw AdShUeq
WU |
\UW/
aWen
onW/
IWd4 d'
qAdad(WUu WU;U F^8dS
ydaSUeq
uQv w
b h
k
,
z l
j k
tX ` $ u w
j
b j
uQv w
h h
X
{Z
S
j
k
,j
h
k
,
, h u j w x uyw X z l
j k jX
a
X |
nm~o $ , om
yU}+dx uyw X Sd J
dU dO4
d u d w d X dweS}Ud d\oSAdUUu\ aUe
dpU +SUWgESp- wd J d\du duSU
$ , l
4OdW#\/Ad!2duvu
Q `$ l Q ) l Q Q o< l qWd
b
h
j
dSaUWS WW}=UwUaySE
g}W!o&
( y WUU sSU I Wd\q uU AuUD
eSwSUXa WU S^UX Ue\eu
SUWUY( \`u[ y yU ^USyWU $ S ,
Sdd adUwd I
j
k
,
qd[
q {a z jl
U [
k
Sq ^W ^WUpuUaadW8U
^ WU
4OdWk0a Uq $ , {8
U o[=Ua
l
j
k
1
m
Q wdW
W}
$ Q q e) $ Q
Q `$ a
b
b
b h
SZ
Q $` a , \ Q ) , Q Q
h
h
h
b h
(Y
`[ UU SUWSdU U'Eu W
UU9I W } ##Unt dad4
S UU- /I UWwdJ ]J WSg /
A U}W
e adg coY( # X UeqqJ u ddwU
qe\WdUs SUW
k{ ,
qm}
l % zX
~ k
"-4 l wW~Xk mq
^ S qUdW qWd
USk l \dWUy 9h
2 I\w=U 'AUDO=W
W \UWWUsue\dqe*u W U l uq Q
"{WU D Q \WddJ dWW;SDUyW '
uolW eOdWWd=d/I aJ U}
" SIq
hoqJ UDOhS(uRIUdSUWUsAUdu \
UG U; \ W W \U(\W/I WAdq $ S ,
#Zq 8UUWAdWnW u\oW
U/I.
J dyduAW\UW
" eq| W 4 \UWW/I W
SdySUWdI dwUS
A
wUd Uu \dU d
d\'
\Ax $%K x ,J%2435@u( Wh
UA}' S
Sd qd A 0\Wi Un- wU UwqU
SSwUUK Uu \ $ :
:
l S1 l W
4
.IW&^8dWJ
t qsdUeaUe
848 %L 6J@%N.3?8AR.: N6JN.7M2'35246%
= S=U\
UeI Wu
l eWud d
W @%Rd0.8;7M2':<=&8AR.:'
S0WUdu
W Uu \W/ \dwuu
t q8Ul9 al'E I dw SdpU}u\ddw
Ud Uepd
V pUSdwW*= U u
, Q Q 2 l Q q }
Q $` , Q
h
h
h
b h
j
U uQIeOsShUaS\ddW8UUWA
SUsSAWZ&
^8 U. u
U^u\S e0UdSUwAS
A &i"M
hoqU 0dAdUu - wd d'
Wadn
Uu\e dWd d }aUWF {( WUS
Wd d wuu d\d'EW{(YiuUWg
uq AUJd\ad
ShUU ud\/AdW
o
DdW'dakS}
4o&\(Y!odW}d4
UeqAd
4 JI S
I< <
WUW S
dW5
q da y
So dW 'I dJI OdQ I \WddJ
U <
I< U9I a da adkW4 {
0d#
S0ISUUnK W8W0UWqdWHE SkU
UUwAq- g k
B {W\WAddody
W W
UeWuaUe*s
a SdW e W U UeqA
U + e<;
U/ d I< \J SUWb =Sh dy j W uo
\9I WAdkSU/ dSJ d dJ eOUW }A SyU
uaUW
J WS^WUwda W Sd
\UdJ udwUsdU W e-Y U {
dwqUg
ESdiM- WUd Y 4 wy Sq Ed
Eu SUhWU A Ueq SUWS S Ueq
U Uy\W/ WU UW UA go %f
Uwd\SUW='E Idw a
wuu W
odJ OUWF eUUAU s4;iUS<o
J d \ywuu Y( d dJ dWaUU/u dUiu'
UUwkUeqyd UySUSaKddWq&
WI ^=S243{NOQu ,J
" dh I \SZo dD dat qI=WUe
} \ dI U adSD
w 0{
d suUUed UA9Y( 1 W
U ' Sd
4E eOdasdiX
wuu dJ d
q !I< \J SUSIu d u pJ \W0Uwd
Ueq -Y d U/I a U}
" - y
s]JG d\'/
\A
c \UdJ udUU #IWue#d
o d%8
^ ^ \ Q \id^ adiS} 9 U} Aqe
l^
W
$ Q Q
o
Q $` a $ Q q Q i
b
$ e
$
W
$ !
(
ogW
ogSZ
o gW
h
^}a 7W#d\d\dASw UuodHkUeq
SUW'EuISdUw WUUUZ (SDd
UH{4o4-&BhWUU\W SUWF AUUd( eS
\} I\ U/dSJ dS
W u\o WISU
\S Wu UU adg B{uWW7Ueqad
<h U SddehWUS
}dUQ hWuRIU\e4
W } I 4 FqHg uSd\SU/
[Y2SJ dSKD
UU/
W uoWUid/
IaJ U|
h K
WS=U
UeWUWUpSd\ddQ +puu WadwJ d
\ \UWZ 'yUl\WAS7 pdU ad
.
dWw\Ud ES0dWO \eOUW#WUeqU
I
uq nd UWw S|
qUWS
UU
ud {SUWs\` .[ &aSU W%
U{
WuadEW
eSdde=Sqww\UdWDU W od y
SW
U
t u SUW% h' EuU
4 gq4 -&
G; WUda
7 Y $kudQ wsu UUUyu
Sw quqU wuu WUWd +wd }aUWsWW
U EuwSUWWUx
WEWWMK7 iWUUkd ad4
" l
WdswqqJ e* SIq
u
odg SKS
u UuwUWdaddS
o} {(
U dUAd(UU/
q;4 EUqWWU WqU U
[S|
U W\}
# SUW
\WAS
U WqU w pdd wW U}0U\nd ad
7 Sd dquqU\AdSw 0 dad
SSwU ^^wAUWU S
pd^e q} =
WAWkdWdg wWAI\q uUeW0 dd.
U WU8
A o4 -&KB{ud =pOd nSw
UeWUWW d8/
anU W/
SUS#J U - YU
{
#wuu wUdSwdqwWWU7SI. WW
Uw(U +d ad4 IdU W X(YuUWg W
4 I0uqUaUedaU 8 s S iW
d \U dWWiSk dWU We
' E-
UwAdi \W- OdQ SddWoda
A go hds4 EAU\UWg
U y
, Q ) , Q Q 2 l Q
Q `$ a
h
h
h
b h
j o WZ
l Q
l Q Q o l
Q $` )
j
b
h
j
o j
d qyAUs ? Wd
h dd^Ueq -Y d
q UWjgTY( U| dUAqJ uU U/ WdqWe
|huE na
|
Lf .! d
M B Z- -* dA
" s(U
+ ad
o S
t ? (
I
o a Z
/t e (
o S
t
h
[ WdpU9
Ur dUAd SW -+ e2\`ll
qC AUU wuu SsaUwA dW-W eOUWFh S
USdSwWUAo wqJ ueS Q uS9
Uuod4Y( dU SUW U SUepd8U
W Su - i\
/ aW0y\`A[
WAUiS=wSdQa SUU< UAWdW
Ui dUA W
W WUSip4U[<U[ S
[m<Y( Wqd4 Sdy
duE SUWl9
aWg d pU uud\S*y
4 d
Q
dr dUA W
U8wuu0d\dWy\`
U
[ 8 ^I Dh 7d eo W}Y( }d ^Uq}
(U
+ wuu SWkI'E I OdUwW adh
FyoKJAT-Aq=
0d UOd0 WIn\W/
U00U { U
^
k
Uk dU\;USdUhd'
2 l
4 S (dU
Ueqdsdk' EKqeOUWF SSd
d wSd A4 Eu qU WqJ uS IdU dWWe=W
dad
WdWUd DWUwI W AUUe
. WDU SW
(d4 IWUU` [EWd{
[.
SUWwuu WWI#\W Od* MVTS
WA =Ut
Ueq=US
} aU WUeWUWW eUEWU
w dJ d
"' E UwAd a/
aWiUSdk' EUdw
Q
7Sp W7W Q 0Ue\odJ OUe
U U
I;l
Q |
Bkqg ,,M^8 uwW
oddSUiUS wuu d adM
o W
du \ Q
SU
SI WU qd
wW l}UUW
W u\odwUde 8US J
CG; d/
U. u
0Ue\odJ OUe7UuUW}S
G;< 0S\` [}[ S
G;Z X[dUAdd}\WddJ udJ U
w G;} dM
m#S
nJ {pWd uU.
UW8WuS
dW} sw WddSwWU 9(Y
SUU ' W
G;< Fm U dM
I<\J SU
UU
W u\o hS
G;Z \
dU9
Ia de
I<OJ aUW4
"o- esS aUe8
G;Z KW U
Uuu Kt
SU
&";qdadq
dW(y
y
SUW udd9
q Iduu I AWu4 \U
/
G;Z u} Z &ASU E ; AiT
WU u%
U
0.02
0
(a)
0.02
0.02
-0.02
0.04
0.02
-0.04
(b)
0.02
0.02
-0.02
0.04
0.02
0
0.02
0.04
0.02
0
0.02
0.04
0.24
-0.04
(c)
u velocity (cm/s)
0.02
-0.02
-0.04
(d)
0.02
-0.02
-0.04
200
400
0.24
600
(e)
0.16
0.16
0.08
0.08
0
0
200
400
200
400
600
600
Time (s)
. 1Ir
QWMy5NWM{KN
KQN ERKQN Z=
yHN
n
KQN nyy
]4QI
j dJ d;iqdSUhUUw
]UqUdW ?Id cy
\b ` [}[ SS
US W Ul
q Iduu n
WwAd qeWdS
k I\U
dUAUe
\`[[
G; dM
[ gWqM
?d 'uwoddSUeda} su `
\d\duSw UqU-S
du sUwiUdeyS
W U eW_WdUlWU We2_d SIWaUU
' E IdwA4 ( /
IWUdSAwU8WU h 4 W Eda
Ueq WyIWdSewAwWW $ , uW
uadU/
h d U0Sdl
WdWw\Udd
W0d Q
a f l $ , x
l
l s S SBdd
uUeO\ \UW /
j j S9
jl kUUu\ ad U
uq Zo [KUd WwU b jlk,adsW
d &
(YHSUU ' SdUe Q daxj ~l Iq
b
j
jSk , ~ljlb k ,
dSJdXI<OJaUW4DdJeOUW }dwUW\|
u aUW qeiU n;G <
[ uWUJad
\UdJ u8'E UwAd dJ dn U. u7
\`l[[(
AddqUlU}WU#dad UU
W u\o8Uw^UdeWT;G Z\
m qw SiwWd Aq
Ueq sdi4E UwAd SdS
;
G Z UW
uU
Wd+ WA \9I WAyaiW\;
G <<[qB Uu Ud
S`.[}
[ I DIh u SUKdaUW weWJ Ue
SU qdWd+ WA W u\o\9I WAad<\
^
uWt dUA
S#4E- WadsUi W
Au d\d4 W\}
^hW/ WU UW7SU\W/ U7dw
qUsWiU u\o8W/ AS8U/I .
J d WWeoUSCW qd W uopWpU/I a U
SdUWw SwWdiqUdW ^WdU SU^dS
WdQ+ W
d u\oWsd/I aJ U}S Sd EUeWUWW KW
U\ \UWgy
4 d UUs WAy WUq
d/ dSJ dSHW UU W uoUqU
USkUQh W dEdWdU SUWgY( C Wqd4 W
h }[ W W x }[.._a dU
AqUwd 'E I \ U8dJ C
" WJI OW=dwuu
ek UUWU qUSUWg
(a)
1.0
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
14.04
14.06
14.08
(b)
1.0
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
Dimensionless Velocity, u
0.4
0.2
0.2
14.04
14.06
14.08
(c)
1.0
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
14.04
14.06
14.08
(d)
1.0
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
14.04
14.06
14.08
(e)
1.0
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
1.2
0.4
0.9
0.9
0.4
0.2
0.6
0.6
0.2
14.04
14.04
(a)
1.2
0.6
14.06
14.06
Scaled Time (Arbitray Units)
14.08
14.08
0.3
0.3
f 5MyN QWMysNWM{KN
s4NQI- Z Z F :
4HR
I/Z W
ysyCR
QNM- HZ 4Py4NQR
N{TZ WZ Q c&FNF
/Z
0.0
0
14.04
14.06
14.08
(b)
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
0.6
0.6
0.3
0.3
Dimensionless Velocity,
JUwdS\UdJIWu\wI\ dUw
hUe4 dW/
uddJ d|
o8KA U
qw UWg "dqydq/
fhUsdw
qUW/
G; #\UdJ Uo
]UW/
\d cW u\o
8Au;2uUU UeqAU SdW' Yd
hUUw Q YU
SUSK{ ue\9
IUUWg dWhddJ u `
{Wr
G;A4 g[^\SuWdaUW
Uaswq
Sd AdW 7 hdd iG Uuue5 _lU
\UdJ 0d0UJ Wd - d n
WqwSU
u'
\9
IUUWg " uRIU\8 i
SUU ' S l A u
WUeU
' E Idw S}W/
u.
W
W/
UW I I\U
nU Wu}U &
"WUt
UuRIU
u\S d qw S
WdUq} UVwdWUS* = =U wy\`
[gda WWSUWSKW Ue Q +eaUW
SK
go4 A Z SdsS Ud4 Uu WU^UwqU
SC
I\UWW WdU
h ddW/
ddq
I ad< " C
Ue\ q a ' E eOdW+
Wd d huu S kI Wqw SEdJ d Q
udWpW\- W\U W^SwUSqd hJ e\Q h Q
e qd. Wd0 SUWw a
U}D
UeO ^Uswuu \odJ OUWF
G; d|
m
W
J {1
UU W u\o#S#U9
0.0
0
14.04
14.06
14.08
(c)
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
0.6
0.6
0.3
0.3
0.0
0
14.04
14.06
14.08
(d)
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
0.6
0.6
0.3
0.3
0.0
0
14.04
14.06
14.08
(e)
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
0.6
0.6
0.3
0.3
0.0
0
14.04
14.04
14.06
14.06
Scaled Time (Arbitray Units)
14.08
14.08
/
5M{yNHNWR"M{KN
] $y8$K
3.0
2.5
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.5
(a)
1.0
3.0
14.04
14.06
14.08
0.8
(a)
1.0
2.5
Velocity, u
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
(b)
3.0
14.04
14.06
0.6
0.4
0.6
0.2
0.4
0.2
14.08
14.04
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
14.06
1.0
2.5
14.08
(b)
0.8
Velocity,
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.5
0.6
0.4
0.2
1.0
(c)
3.0
14.04
14.06
14.04
14.08
2.5
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.5
14.5
13.00
13
14.04
14.04
(d)
14.06
14.08
2.5
2.5
2.0
1.5
(e)
14.04
14.06
14.06
Scaled Time (Arbitray Units)
14.08
14.08
.MI=yI4
Q M .yC.
4
14.06
14.08
14.08
1.5
1.0
Scaled Time14.06
(Arbitray Units)
14.04
13.0
13.75
13.75
12.25
3.0
14.08
(c)
14.50
12.25
1.0
14.04
14.06
15.25
15.25
Temperature
Dimensionless Temperature
1.5
0.8
; K
h*qTo=T
wAySq
Xw Wy ^8WUUSy'EUU
U/m.Y {WUqUSWAq S*W Q ISddeu
8 u dwqJ ue4 CG<UUUwWd{ISkAUUeo
UWUywuu yWd o- d\AU' EyWEd
Uw\dU S;Udw ?I< UqU4 Uq/
\o
/
eWUWd dWn
Wdo4 Eu' UWg W
Wq Q du\eUUW4
y =
"udW UU4E- UeUdWaUJusWyU
hW\ JI WU U. uyG\Vlu u
dW
GANg[.5d 4[
y (F
!#"%#$&%"('&`)+**,-.0/q+"1.
%2. `#3` 4
576898;:2<>=?A@#:CBD@FEG: FH>#IJKCL)MONFL+P#P}CL)QON)R!L)MId
S)T &?`#UWV(X
Y,Z.[.3&KP`F$3]\.)^_ 4` :#ab?c896G:
dYe)fc: FZH > +IJKgL)MQhK+P#P CL)hJiR!Lj#&L
k - ?0U)"(l##m K%" #T$ 7"1.n?. `?&gpo #m C,ZX `3i"( q"1.&
%7.0d/ ?`rs$ `?&#"(C/ &&l `` \(?. P 3t. `#`3 4 BD@FEG:
u]viw :gx v ?c?s: WH > #IyKCL)MON(IK+P#}P pN(QiRKN(dM
z .* ?030/g|q{ ~} u xCD|5g } @ v x v =We)E6[at:;_:;6
896 6On6 w Y]%" ?$#&l { ' `? .sx i+%" ?$K&l OpL)MMd
i d)l U)`U c bm m `F < T %" #$%/ "(c_-
,0g% rs$ P `#$ `W. "K `l/Krs; #%" 0$`3 &W' 3. &1 )
^ ZZ%" #$F.0
{`\ d$ i S
4 <>=Oe)[6Ge06!fAe<>6) v f 6[ }+ ) v +?D 6G
*.03Z/ v ?&=O : $ Z T 3. ?X (. `|1D/Od `3 IhJK|mFP #&l `[r
HZ`0q"(l#+ `[ gYL)MyK!PKP gLjOyiR!L)QdJ
% d&'
!%" #$ TC | O! T aDfGZ?_576 G v f }+ )
% Z?`?)!]%" {$#&l tYL)MON(dI
v !e v sH
i 3i& l/g ,- ;O. ?3~V ?&S% ? `#`3
W$ 2]%" ?q$ & $ n;r ' `0"(&l )$Xb"d `RKmW?. &' `VD "1. &i 4
+?: ` :g fA< v e@#: u]v G: #ZH > +IIKYL)MMK!P#P +ION)RFd
.* [`U &l )C Y
D, T %" [&l 9V$#$K>m q"1. &gF c?. % [r
K3 `i%" [3Z/g H
4 } @ v 6 v ?feZ=baO!n6i=Oe@ v G~?s6 }+ ) v !e v
^i' ` v ?Y=:+ $ ZmFP ?K&l nrcZH [q"(l#(FX ^~Z &0'!KL)MyK(PKP (KLZRKN(dI
3i& l/g gDF^"1. `i g g%" K$~ cg 2 D?,
;O' `[. lO"1?. &T%mW. Z%" #&l .n. Z"(3?. &]%/ `&n%" #$m "(pmF3)"( b% [r
K3
4 ;7"(P `y(j(rZL)QON1j#+P `?`W. $"1. a abaFgc fA
E!=8fe)G[7B] =GZ89=WE!=89fAeiGt=!9xg=OG v G|576i): +4m iF^ %" ?)+-
_I(j1RFIyK2L)My(j
n 3i& l/g. c ; ;%" #$DW^"1?. `) ;
?, &|P+%" ?&% . `. "mW. Z%" #&l ].n?. 0"(3. &e- r
`&+"( T W3)"( W$ %K% ? `W.g.* ?`%" #$.* &[`3 )$ &O' )3r
.&g q4 m t
V 7"(P y(j(rcX
(%]rZL)QKWP ?`?`O?. $"1. ad+<&&f+? v
ab+ =Y< vZv ?cf #X ^- [ i%" di T +)&3 !MiR!Lj#gL)My(j
) 3i& l/g %" #$DW^"1. `i , T %" 0&l ;r [3i"( S`r
Q3. &_ F3)"(4 ?"( ;r [3)"( 730/+%" (?. 3 ? . &C. b [&l `?i "1?. &Y 4
a aa ` : #ZH > +I(j#YL)MyQK!P#P YL)MI(j1R!L)MhdJ
[S 3i& l/g7 g%" #$~DF^"1. `i C ,0% ? `O.9m r
.&g&%" &{ +"' 0"(&l $g b$#d$ ?. ' t`3 &|P &? . &S% 0&l `i
V "1. &g U4 26 86O }+ ) v +?pD 67GOOW F i^ 7 &nr
)d$ Z& m V7rs*VHZ> 1N(QK% m V)FX ^ &['pWL)MyMKP#}P (N)R!L)dI
nk %" ?&g D%" #$ % %" _,ZX &# )%" o"( `04' i.[/Kr
W$ i 4 d ab< ` :C 8 v ):gab!=O : FH > #IQKCL)MyMK+P#}P CLL)hMiR!LL)ON
z 3i& l/gp F%" Kl##{ !%" K$F gKV ! 2, F$ #l
.rs$ P K$ `W.. `W.b.\ i1
^ i' `_" +"(3Z'O^%" 0$F>r c"(`3 #yl [. Pd q"
"($#d$ ?. ' &. `W.$ `3 &|P &? . &%" K$3Z/+%" (. X
3 "(P ) /
4 Bn6
e v0v fA G6[fGZ?a_GZfA=5768b ?s=?cfA6!=D fA E!=89fAeiG576O+
%mF`3 `#`3 ;%" #$
v v !e v p v ?=:D )d$ ZCF &#l\ &#l{ ' `? .sl
% 3Z/ d l(WpF &#l|\ &#l#gL)MMK+P#P pN1jWN)RKN(dI
[ F gKFV K\ K%" #$ 3)& l/Y! g,/+%" (. 3tm "( rnmF3)"(
ZH F`3 .s* $ C%" ?&[P )3. ' W$ Q&C{ d?`? ' $_% ? `#`3
|%" $#$ . ' b)`3 &|P &? . &%p.0/ bXb"d `nRKmO?. &' `]VD "1. &i 4
+?: ` :g fA< v e@#: u]v G: #ZH > +IQKYL)MMMK!P#P +hMiRFQON
n mK"(lO" .)9
xg=O Ov OEdpf8 =?cfA66 !eZ68b! v G0GZfc v
D 67G YmFP #&l `[rcZH `0q"(l#K `0 gKIJJK&L