FRAMEWORK QSS

QSS Ruling
Minimum Standards for Education
and Training (MSET)
Assessment system
Friday, November 25, 2016

Assessment
of
MET Institutes
Penilaian lembaga diklat
(QSS Framework ANNEX A / Part 2)
November 25,

Assessment System

WHY AN ASSESSMENT
SYSTEM ?
Because part of STCW 95 regulations :
One aspect of the STCW-treaty regards a
QSS : a Quality Standard System.
One aspect of the QSS requires a tool to
monitor training, assessment of
competence, certification, endorsement and
revalidation activities.
November 25,

Assessment System

QSS must cover :

1. Certification system
2. All training courses and programmes
3. Examinations and assessments
4. Qualifications and experience of
instructors and assessors
5. Internal quality assurance reviews
November 25,

Assessment System

Assessment must also cover :

1. Certification system
2. All training courses and programmes
3. Examinations and assessments
4. Qualifications and experience of
instructors and assessors
5. Internal quality assurance reviews

November 25,

Assessment System

How ?
By carrying out an assessment the required
level can be ascertained.
With QSS, a minimum defined level of
training, assessment and certification must
be guarantied.

November 25,

Assessment System

Note :
A Quality Management System (QMS) is
not the same as a QSS, but
a Quality Management System is part of the
QSS.

November 25,

Assessment System

Conclusion :
An assessment instrument to audit the
maritime institutions in Indonesia in order
to:
control the minimum required standard of
STCW 95
increase the credibility of the Indonesian
maritime sector
keep Indonesia on the IMO white list
November 25,

Assessment System

What items are assessed ?

ANNEX A - Part 1 / Minimum Standards

Organizational and managerial aspects

Infrastructure
Competence education and training (E & T)
Equipment and material required for competence
E&T

So the hardware and software !

November 25,

Assessment System

Organizational and managerial aspects

Infrastructure
= HARDWARE &
ORGANISATION

= SOFTWARE

Competence education and training (E & T)

Equipment and material for competence E & T

November 25,

Assessment System

10

So :
Annex A Part 1\ATT ANT III\EQ ATT
III.doc
Annex A Part 1\ATT ANT III\MSET III.doc
Annex A Part 1\ATT ANT III\SCO ATT
III.doc
Annex A Part 1\ATT ANT III\EQ ANT
III.doc

November 25,

Assessment System

11

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

1. ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

2. INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

3. NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

4. CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

5. CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE FOR PERSONS ON

BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

6. EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE

TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

SUB TOTALS

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
Date
Function
Signature

:
:
:
:

November 25,

Assessment System

12

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

1. ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

2. INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

3. NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

4. CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

5. CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE FOR PERSONS ON

BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

6. EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE

TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

SUB TOTALS

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
Date
Function
Signature

:
:
:
:

November 25,

Assessment System

13

EQ A-II/1
File code
A-II/1-1

Equipment MET for officer in charge of a navigational watch

Function
1

Equipment Cluster

Abbreviation

Navigation equipment

EQ-Na

Electronic navigation equipment

EQ-El

Collision regulations equipment

EQ-Co

Meteorology equipment

EQ-Me

Emergency procedures equipment

EQ-Em

Visual signalling equipment

EQ-Vs

Manoeuvring equipment

EQ-Ma

English language equipment

EQ-En

Radar navigation laboratory

EQ-Ra

A-II/1-2

Cargo handling and stowage

EQ-Ca

A-II/1-3

Controlling equipment

EQ-Cn

A-II/1-C

COM

Computer room

EQ-Cr

November 25,

Library
Assessment
System

EQ-Li

14

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :
F1
EQ-Na

OFFICER IN CHARGE OF A NAVIGATIONAL WATCH

NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

File Code

Navigation Equipment

column 1

no.

STUDY-LINE ANT III

A-II/1.1
column 2

column 3

column 4

Description items per subject and quantity

Available
quantity suitability
in %

Comments

EQ-Na

column 5

Points
max

actual

Navigation Equipment

1.1 Magnetic compass, incl. binnacle + manual

25

1.2 Deviation curve or table

1.3 Binocular

1.4 Bearing equipment

1.5 Chronometer

1.6 Sextant

>5

10

1.7 Stopwatch

etc.

etc.

30

10

1
134

0
0

etc.

etc.

etc.

Calculator, with trigonometric functions and

memory capacity
1.14 Mock / model ships chart table
1.13

1.15 Chart tables for exercises

November 25,

Assessment System

Subtotals

15

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :
A II-1

EQ

Equipment

STUDY-LINE ANT III

EQUIPMENT REQUIREMENTS FOR MET / ANT III

Points

Description

File Code

A-II/1 Com
A-II/1- EQ-Cr
A-II/1- EQ-Li
A-II/1- EQ-Tb
A-II/1- EQ-Vc
A-II/1 EQ 1
A-II/1- EQ-Na
A-II/1- EQ-El
A-II/1- EQ-Co
A-II/1- EQA-II/1- EQA-II/1- EQ-Vs
A-II/1- EQA-II/1- EQ-En
A-II/1- EQ-Ra
A-II/1 EQ 2
A-II/1- EQ-Ca

OPERATIONAL LEVEL
Computer room
LIBRARY
Textbooks
Video cassettes and VCD
NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL
Navigation Equipment
Electronic Navigation Equipment
Collision Regulations Equipment
Meteorology Equipment
Emergency procedures Equipment
Visual signalling Equipment
Manoeuvring Equipment
English language Equipment
Radar navigation laboratory
CARGOHANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL
Cargo handling and stowage
CONTROLLING SHIP'S OPERATIONS AND CARE FOR PERSONS
A-II/1 EQ 3
ON BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL
A-II/1- EQ-Cn Controlling equipment
Subtotals

max

actual

304

295
225

0
0

134
110
10
30
5
10
15
70
280

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

40

40
1568
(a)

0
0
(b)

ASSESSMENT SCORE BLOCK EQ = (b : a) x 10

November 25,

Assessment System

16

Name Institute :
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

1. ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

2. INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

3. FUNCTION 1 - NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

4. FUNCTION 2 - CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE

OPERATIONAL LEVEL
5. FUNCTION 3 - CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE
FOR PERSONS ON BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL
6. EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

SUB TOTALS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
:
Date
:
Function :
November
Signature
:

25,

Assessment System

17

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

1. ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

2. INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

3. NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

4. CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

5. CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE FOR PERSONS ON

BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

6. EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

SUB TOTALS

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
Date
Function
Signature

:
:
:
:

November 25,

Assessment System

18

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :
ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES - OS

STUDY-LINE ANT III

COM Organizational and managerial structures

Subjects
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19

Mission Statement / objectives

Education and training strategies
Organization
Instructor requirements
Development program requirements
Instructors teaching load
Faculty requirements
Instructor Student Ratio
Curriculum
Administrative documentation
Students admission, selection and
retention
School Tests and Examination system
Shipboard Training and Field Trips
Feedback from students and industry
Research and Development Program
Quality Management System
Campus/Building/Public spaces/Offices
General teaching means
Library and Internet facilities

Available Suitability
yes no
in %

Comments

Particulars are described

in the Minimum standards
(Annex A Part 1)

November
25, ASSESSMENT
Assessment
System
TOTAL
SCORE BLOCK
OS

File Code
COM
OS
Points
max
actual
10
70
50
50
30
70
70
30
90
50

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

50

80
60
40
30
30
50
70
70
Totals 1000 (a)

= (b : a) x 10

19

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 (b)

Organization and Staff resources

Source : Minimum Standards for Education
and Training / MSET = Annex A part 1
Annex A Part 1\ANT-ATT IV\MSET IV.doc

November 25,

Assessment System

20

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :
ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES - OS

STUDY-LINE ANT III

COM Organizational and managerial structures

Subjects
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19

Mission Statement / objectives

Education and training strategies
Organization
Instructor requirements
Development program requirements
Instructors teaching load
Faculty requirements
Instructor Student Ratio
Curriculum
Administrative documentation
Students admission, selection and
retention
School Tests and Examination system
Shipboard Training and Field Trips
Feedback from students and industry
Research and Development Program
Quality Management System
Campus/Building/Public spaces/Offices
General teaching means
Library and Internet facilities

Available Suitability
yes no
in %

Comments

Particulars are described

in the Minimum standards
(Annex A Part 1)

November
25, ASSESSMENT
Assessment
System
TOTAL
SCORE BLOCK
OS

File Code
COM
OS
Points
max
actual
10
70
50
50
30
70
70
30
90
50

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

50

80
60
40
30
30
50
70
70
Totals 1000 (a)

= (b : a) x 10

21

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 (b)

Name Institute :
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

1. ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

2. INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

3. FUNCTION 1 - NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

4. FUNCTION 2 - CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE

OPERATIONAL LEVEL
5. FUNCTION 3 - CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE
FOR PERSONS ON BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL
6. EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

SUB TOTALS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
:
Date
:
Function :
November
Signature
:

SIMILAR ASSESSMENT
PROCEDURE AS FOR
ORGANIZATION & STAFF
RESOURCES

25,

Assessment System

22

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

FUNCTION 1 - NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

FUNCTION 2 - CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

FUNCTION 3 - CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE FOR

PERSONS ON BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

SUB TOTALS

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
Date
Function
Signature

:
:
:
:

November 25,

Assessment System

23

STCW : 6 Functions :
Nautical :
Navigation 8 competences
Cargo handling and stowage 2 competences

Technical :
Marine engineering 7 competences
Electrical, electronic and control engineering 1 comp.
Maintenance and repair 1 competences

Nautical and Technical :

Controlling the operation of the ship and care for
persons on board 6 competences.
November 25,

Assessment System

24

STCW : 6 functions :
Nautical :
Navigation 8 competences
Cargo handling and stowage 2 comp.

ANT III
ANT IV

Technical :
Marine engineering 7 comp.
Electrical, electronic and control engineering 1 comp.
Maintenance and repair 1 comp.

Nautical and Technical :

Controlling the operation of the ship and care for
persons on board 6 competences
November 25,

Assessment System

25

STCW : 6 functions :
Nautical :
Navigation 8 competences
Cargo handling and stowage 2 competences

Technical :

ATT III
ATT IV

Marine engineering 7 comp.

Electrical, electronic and control engineering 1
comp.
Maintenance and repair 1 comp.

Nautical and Technical :

Controlling the operation of the ship and care for
persons on board 6 comp
November 25,

Assessment System

26

Function Competence :
Every function contains one or more
competences, e.g. :
Function : Navigation
Competence : Maintain a safe navigational
watch
Or :
Function : Marine engineering
Competence : Operate pumping system and
associated control systems
November 25,

Assessment System

27

Competence Subject :
Comp : Maintain a safe navigational watch
Every competence contains one or more
subjects, e.g. :
1 : Knowledge of the ColRegs
2 : Principles in keeping a navigational
watch
3 : The use of routeing
November 25,

Assessment System

28

Function

Competence

NAVIGATION

Maintain a safe navigational watch

Subject

Knowledge of the ColRegs

related activities
for professional
discipline

KUPS

training
outcome

November 25,

Assessment System

29

Subject Topic :
Every subject contains one or more topics,
e.g. :
Subject : Knowledge of the ColRegs
Topic : Content, application and intent of
the Collision Regulations
Annex A Part 1\ANT-ATT III\SCO ANT
III.doc
November 25,

Assessment System

30

Function

Competence

NAVIGATION

Maintain a safe navigational watch

Subject

Knowledge of the ColRegs

Topic

Content, application and intent

of the Collision Regulations

November 25,

Assessment System

related activities
for professional
discipline

KUPS

training
outcome

area of
performance

31

Function

Competence

Subject

Topic

MARINE ENGINEERING

Use appropriate tools for

fabrication and repair operations

Materials for construction and

repair

Mechanical properties and uses

November 25,

Assessment System

related activities
for professional
discipline

KUPS

training
outcome

area of
performance

32

STCW : 6 functions :
Nautical :
Navigation 8 competences
Cargo handling and stowage 2 competences

Technical :
Marine engineering 7 competences
Electrical, electronic and control engineering 1 comp.
Maintenance and repair 1 comp.

Nautical and Technical :

Controlling the operation of the ship and care for
persons on board 6 competences
November 25,

Assessment System

33

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

FUNCTION 1 - NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

FUNCTION 2 - CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

FUNCTION 3 - CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE FOR

PERSONS ON BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

SUB TOTALS

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
Date
Function
Signature

:
:
:
:

November 25,

Assessment System

34

Example

Function 1 Navigation
8 competences (C 1.1 up to C 1.8)
C 1.1
C 1.2
C 1.3
C 1.4
C 1.5
C 1.6
C 1.7
C 1.8

=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=

Plan and conduct a passage and determine position

Maintain a safe navigational watch
Use of radar and ARPA to maintain safety of navigation
Responds to emergencies
Respond to a distress signal at sea
English language
Transmit and receive information by visual signalling
Manoeuvre the ship

November 25,

Assessment System

35

C 1.1 = Plan and conduct a passage and determine

position
7 Subjects (S 1.1.1 up to S 1.1.7)
S 1.1.1 = Celestial navigation (11 topics)
S 1.1.2 = Terrestrial and coastal navigation
S 1.1.3 = Electronic systems of position fixing and
navigation
S 1.1.4 = Echo-sounders and speed measurement
S 1.1.5 = Compass - magnetic and gyro
S 1.1.6 = Steering control systems
S 1.1.7 = Meteorology
November 25,
Assessment System
36

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :
F: 1
C: 1.1
S: 1.1.1

OFFICER IN CHARGE OF A NAVIGATIONAL WATCH

NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

Plan and conduct a coastal passage and determine position

Celestial navigation

column 1

no.

1
2
3

STUDY-LINE ANT III

File Code

A-II/1

column 2

column 3

column 4

column 5

column 6

Examination
method
(use legend 1)

Item properly examined

if no, indicate
yes
no
(use legend 2)

Points

Description topics per subject

Actually instructed
% covered
yes
no
(par 5.1.4 d)

Solar system

max

Celestial sphere and equinoctial system of coordinates

Hour angle

6
6

5
6

Amplitude

Time and equation of time

Nautical Almanac

10

Latitude by meridian altitude

10

Pole Star observation

11

Position fixing

54

12
13
14
15
16
17
18

November 25,

actual

Daily motion and horizontal system of coordinates

Sextant and altitude correction

ED 1.1

12
10

Assessment System

37
128

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :
F: 1
C: 1.1

OFFICER IN CHARGE OF A NAVIGATIONAL WATCH

NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

Plan and conduct a passage and determine position

File Code
A-II/1

maximum
points

actual
points

S: 1.1.1 Celestial navigation

128

S: 1.1.2 Terrestrial and coastal navigation

218

S: 1.1.3 Electronic systems of position fixing and navigation:

34

S: 1.1.4 Echo-sounders and speed measurement:

17

S: 1.1.5 Compass magnetic and gyro

62

79

544
(a)

0
(b)

S: 1.1.6 Steering control systems

S: 1.1.7 Meteorology
Subtotals

Actual Points Obtained

Maximum Obtainable Points

STUDY-LINE ANT III

0
544

ED 1.1

Assessment Score C 1.1 =

(b : a) x 10

Assessor 1
Name:
Function:

Date:

Signature:

Date:

Signature:

Assessor 2
Name:
Function:

November 25,

Assessment System

38

Name Institute:
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

ED 1

A-II/1

OFFICER IN CHARGE OF A NAVIGATIONAL WATCH

NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

File Code

A-II/1
A-II/1
A-II/1
A-II/1
A-II/1
A-II/1
A-II/1
A-II/1

C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C

Points

Description

1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8

Plan and conduct a passage and determine position

Maintain a safe navigational watch
Use of radar and ARPA to maintain safety of navigation
Responds to emergencies
Respond to a distress signal at sea
English language See IMO Model Course under development
Transmit and receive information by visual signalling
Manoeuvre the ship

Subtotals

max
544
122
66
34
2
60
59
15

actual

902

Actual Points Obtained

Maximum Obtainable Points

ASSESSMENT SCORE BLOCK FUNCTION 1

November 25,

Assessment System

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

0
902

0.0

39

Name Institute :
Address
:
Date of audit :

STUDY-LINE ANT III

OVERALL ASSESSMENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING

SCORE PER
BLOCK

WEIGHING
FACTOR

CORRECTED
SCORE

1. ORGANIZATION AND STAFF RESOURCES

2. INFRA-PROVISIONS TEACHING FACILITIES

3. NAVIGATION AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

4. CARGO HANDLING AND STOWAGE AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

5. CONTROLLING THE OPERATION OF THE SHIP AND CARE FOR PERSONS

ON BOARD AT THE OPERATIONAL LEVEL

6. EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR COMPETENCE TRAINING (BLOCKS 3, 4, 5)

24
(a)

0
(b)

BLOCKS

SUB TOTALS

OVERALL SCORE (b : a)

REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:

Name
:
Date
:
Function :
November
Signature
:

As the whole system is based on Minimum Standards,

the Overall Assessment Score should be a ten (10) in
order to comply fully with STCW 95 requirements

25,

Assessment System

40

Actual assessment forms :

QSS\Annex A Part 2\ANT III\Chapter 3 Ass.sheets OS\Ass. sheet OS.xls
QSS\Annex A Part 2\ATT III\Chapter 4 - Ass.
sheets ITF\Ass. sheet
ITF.xls
QSS\Annex A Part 2\ANT III\Chapter 5 - As
s. sheets ED\
Ass.sheet ED 1.xls
QSS\Annex A Part 2\ATT III\Chapter 6 - Ass
. sheets EQ\Ass. sheet EQ 1.xls
November 25,

Assessment System

41

Assessment by audit teams :

During such an assessment (audit) it is thus
ascertained that the level of education, the
structure of the organisation, the equipment
and the infrastructure of the MET institute
( the school) matches the minimum
requirements as acquired by the Minimum
Standards of Education and Training
(MSET)- program and thus by STCW 95.
November 25,

Assessment System

42

PROBLEMS
Management level

Required
minimum
STCW level of
knowledge,
understanding
and proficiency

Operational level
National curriculum
Actual assessed school
level ??

Additional national
requirements

November 25,

25 STCW competences
(minimum requirements)
within 6 functions

Assessment System

43

PROBLEMS SOLVED !!!

Management level

Required
minimum
STCW level of
knowledge,
understanding
and proficiency

Operational level
National curriculum
Actual assessed school
level ??

Additional national
requirements

November 25,

25 STCW competences
(minimum requirements)
within 6 functions

Assessment System

44

FRAMEWORK QSS

QSS Ruling
ANNEX A - Part 1 / Minimum Standards
ANNEX A - Part 2 / Assessment Forms
Completed !

November 25,

Assessment System

45

FRAMEWORK QSS
PBSI 1
2002

THE END

Presentation
Friday 25 November 2016

QUESTIONS ?

November 25,

Assessment System

47