Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
PROBLEM1&2:
1. There is a potential conflict of interest between shareholders and managers which give
risetowhatareknownas'agencyproblems'
(a)
Giveexamplesofsomeofthe'agencyproblems'thatcanariseasaresultofthis
potentialconflictofinterest.
(b)
Intheory,shareholdersareexpectedtoexercisecontrolovermanagersthroughthe
annualmeetingortheboardofdirectors.
Inpractice,whymightthesedisciplinarymechanismsnotwork?
Whatothermechanismsareusedinordertoreducepotentialagencyproblems?
2.Therearesomecorporatestrategistswhohavesuggestedthatfirmsfocuson
maximizingmarketshare/earningpershareratherthanmarketvalue.Whatisyourviewof
suchasuggestion?
SOLUTION1&2:
Seetextbookandlecturenotes.
PROBLEM3:
Presentvalues,annuitiesandperpetuities
(a) Whatisthepresentvalueof10,000arisingin1year'stime,assuminga
discountrateof12%?
(b) Whatisthepresentvalueofanannuityofastreamof10annualcashflowsof
10,000each,assumingadiscountrateof12%,withthefirstcashflow
arisingin1year'stime?
(c) Whatisthepresentvalueofanannuityofastreamof10annualcashflowsof
10,000each,assumingadiscountrateof12%,withthefirstcashflow
arisingin2years'time?
1
Page
(d) Whatisthepresentvalueofanannuityofastreamof10annualcashflowsof
10,000each,assumingadiscountrateof12%,withthefirstcashflow
arisingtoday?
(e) Whatisthepresentvalueofperpetuityof10.000perannum,assuminga
discountrateof12%,withthefirstcashflowarisingin1year'stime?
(f) Whatisthepresentvalueofperpetuityof10,000perannum,assuminga
discountrateof12%,withthefirstcashflowarisingin2year'stime?
(g) Whatisthepresentvalueofperpetuityof10.000perannum,assuminga
discountrateof12%,withthefirstcashflowarisingtoday?
SOLUTION3:
(a)
PV=10,000/1.12=8,929
(b)
PV=10,000x5.650=56,500
(c)
PV=56,500/1.12=50,446
This is a 10year annuity but starting 1 yearlate. Therefore,thevalueoftheannuityisas
atYear1andweneedtodiscountbacktogivethePV.
(d) PV=10,000+(10,000x5.328)=63,280
This iseffectively a 9year annuity of 10,000 plus 10,000 today (ie already in PV
terms),
(e)
PV=10,000/0.12=83,333
(f)
PV=83,333/1.12=74,405
(g)
PV=10,000+83,333=93,333
2
Page
GROUP2EXERCISES
PROBLEM1:
A company has 100m of debentures with a 10% coupon rate, which are redeemable at a
10%premiumin5year'stime.Therateofcorporationtaxis30%.
Required
Calculate the market value of these debentures assuming debenture holders require a rate
ofreturnof8%perannumbeforetax.
SOLUTION1:
Market value of debt is found usingthedividendvaluationmodel:futurecashreceiptsfor
the debenture holders arediscountedatthedebentureholders'requiredrateofreturn.(The
rate of corporation tax is irrelevant). Theamountofinterestperannumis10%x100m=
10m. There is alsoaredemptionpremiumof10%(i.e.10%100m=10m)in 5 years'
time.Thereforethetotalcashreceivedbydebentureholdersinyear5is120m.
Cashflow
Discount
factor
PV
TotalPV
1
10m
0.926
9.26
114.84
2
10m
0.857
8.57
3
10m
0.794
7.94
4
10m
0.735
7.35
5
120m
0.681
81.72
Thereforemarketvalue=114.84m
PROBLEM2:
ABC plc is a mediumsizedcompanythatislisted on thestockmarket.Thecompanyhasa
yearend of 31st December. The company's earnings per share (EPS) and dividends per
share(DPS)forthelast5yearsareasfollows:
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
3
Page
EPS(p)
DPS(p)
140
82
136
81
131
79
127
78
122
77
Dividends are paid on 31st December each year. If the current dividend policy is
maintained, the directors estimate that annual growth in earningsanddividendswillbeno
betterthantheaveragecompoundgrowthinearningsoverthepast5years.
ABC plc is reluctant to take on debt at the present time to finance further growth. The
company is therefore contemplating a change in its dividend policy and total investment
plans to allow for 50% of its earnings to be retained for identified capital expenditure
projects, which are estimated to have a posttax return of 15%. The cost of equity for the
companyis12%.
Required
(a) Using the dividend valuation model, calculate the share price which might be
expectedbythemarket:
(i)ifthecompanydoesnotannounceachangeindividendpolicy.
(ii)ifthecompanydoesannounceachangeindividendpolicy.
(Note: For both parts (i) and (ii), you should assume that dividends will grow from their
currentlevelof82ppershare).
(b)
Commentonthelimitationsofthemodelsyouhaveusedinpart(a).
(c) Discussthereasonswhythesharepricemightreactdifferentlyfromthemarket's
expectations.
SOLUTION2:
ABCplc
(a)
(i)Currentdividendpolicy
Averagecompoundgrowthrateofdividendsoverpast5years=
g=(4throotof140/122)1=3.5%
Shareprice(at1stJanuary2006)=Dividend2006
Keg
=(82x1.035)/(0.120.035)
=998.5p
4
Page
(ii)Newdividendpolicy
growthrate=returnonequityx'plowback'rate
g=15%x50%=7.5%
Shareprice(at1stJanuary2006) =Dividend2006
Keg
=(82x1.075)/(0.120.075)
=l,958.9p
PROBLEM:
5
Page
Year
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
EPS
42
46
51
55
62
DPS
17
18
20
22
25
Investment analysts have reevaluated the company's prospects and estimate the
company's earnings and dividends will grow at 25% for the next 2 years. Thereafter,
earnings are likely to increase at a lower annual rateof10%.Ifthisreductioninearnings
growth occurs, the analysts consider it likely that the dividend payout ratio will be
increasedto50%.
Thecompany'scostofequityis18%.
Required
Using the dividend valuation model, calculate the estimated share price which the
analystsnowexpectforPAplc.
6
Page
SOLUTION3:
PAplc
2005
do
2006
d1
2007
d2
2008
D3
DPS
25
31.25
39.06
EPS
62
77.5
96.88
Growth
25%
25%
rate%
NBdiscountrate=costofequity=18%
53.28
106.56
10%
200
9
d4
58.61
117.22
10%
PVofDividend2006
PVofDividend2007
=31.25x0.847=26.47
Valueofdividendsfrom2008toinfinity
=Dividend2008
Keg
20
10
d5
64.47
128.94
10%
=39.06x0.718=28.05
=53.28.
(0.180.1)
=666p
Thisisthevalueasat31sDecember2007
Therefore,needtodiscountatyear2discountfactorforcostofequityof18%:
Valueat1stJanuary2006
=666x0.718
=478.19
TotalPVoffuturedividends=26.47+28.05+478.19=532.70
7
Page
GROUP3EXERCISES
PROBLEM1:
HickLimitedisconsideringinvestinginanewproject,forwhichthefollowing
informationisavailable:
000
Initialinvestment
Lifeofproject
Estimatedannualcashflows:
Year1
Year2
Year3
Year4
450
Residualvalue
30
4years
150
300
100
100
Therateofcorporationtaxis30%.
Required:
Evaluatethefinancialviabilityoftheaboveprojectusingthefollowingtechniques:
i)
payback
ii)
theaccountingrateofreturn
iii)
netpresentvalue(assumingacostofcapital10%)
iv)
internalrateofreturn
Clearlystatetheassumptionsmade.
SOLUTION1:
a.
Timevalueofmoneyrelatestotheideathat1todayisnotequalinvalueto1inthe
future
Timevalueofmoneyissaidtohavethreecomponents
oTheimpatiencetoconsumeorpuretimevalueofmoney
oInflation
oRisk
8
Page
Thereforeitisnotappropriatetosimplyaddorcomparesfromdifferenttimeperiods
Futuresarethereforetranslatedintopresentvalue
b.
(i)
Cashflow
Investment
=(450,000)
Year1
=150,000
Year2
=300,000
Thereforepaybackequals2years
Cumulative
(450,000)
(300,000)
0
(ii)
ARRisbasedonprofitswhich=cashflowdepreciation
Straightlinedepreciation=(450,00030,000)/4=105,000p.a.
UsingannualbasisofARR
Year1=(45/450)x100% =10%
Year2=(195/345)x100% =56.5%
Year3=(5/240)x100% =2%
Year4=(5/135)x100% =3.7%
UsingtotalinvestmentbasisofARR
{[(45+19555)/4]/450}xl00%=57.5/450=12.8%
UsingaverageinvestmentbasisofARR
{57.5/[(450+30)/2]}=24%
(iii)
Year
0
1
2
3
4
NPV
Cashflow
Discount
factor
1
0.909
0.826
0.751
0.683
(450)
150
300
100
130
PV
450.00
136.35
247.80
75.10
88.79
98.04
9
Page
(iv)
Trydiscountrateof25%
Year
Cashflow
0
1
2
3
4
NPV
(450)
150
300
100
130
Discount
factor
1
0.800
0.640
0.512
0.410
PV
(450.0)
120.0
192.0
51.2
53.3
(33.5)
Usinglinearinterpolation(orgraphicalmethod)IRRcanbeestimated:
98.04+33.5 =98.04
0.250.1
(x0.1)
Rearranginggives:
(x0.1)
=98.04x0.15
98.04+33.5
Thereforex=0.11+0.1=21%approx.
c.Seetextbookandlecturenotes.
10
Page
PROBLEM2:
A project requires an initial investment of 120,000 and is expected to produce the
followingnetcashinflows:
Year1
50,000
Year2
25,000
Year3
25,000
Year4
25,000
Year5
30,000
Thediscountrateis8%
Required
Evaluatethefinancialviabilityofthisprojectusingthefollowingmethods:
a)
payback
b)
accountingrateofreturn
c)
netpresentvalue
d)
internalrateofreturn
SOLUTION2:
a.
(i)
Cashflow
Cumulative
Investment
=(120,000)
(120,000)
Year1
=50,000
(70,000)
Year2
=25,000
(45,000)
Year3
=25,000
(20,000)
Year4
=25,000
5,000payback
Thereforepayback=3.8years(3years+20,000/25,000)
(ii)
ARRisbasedonprofitswhich=cashflowdepreciation
Straightlinedepreciation=(120,000)/5=24,000p.a.
UsingannualbasisofARR
Year1=(26/120)x100%=21.7%
Year2=(1/96)x100%=1.0%
Year3=(1/72)x100%=1.4%
Year4=(1/48)x100%=2.1%
Year5=(6/24)x100%=25.0%
UsingtotalinvestmentbasisofARR
{[(26+1+1+1+6)/5]/120}X100%=7/120=5.8%
11
Page
UsingaverageinvestmentbasisofARR
{7/[(120)/2]}=11.7%
(iii)
Year
Cashflow
0
1
2
3
4
5
NPV
(120)
50
25
25
25
30
Discount
factor
1
0.926
0.857
0,794
0.735
0.681
PV
120.0
46.3
21.4
19.8
18.4
20.4
6.3
(iv)
Trydiscountrateof15%
Year
Cashflow
0
1
2
3
4
5
NPV
(120)
50
25
25
25
30
Discount
factor
1
0.870
0.756
0.658
0.572
0.497
PV
120.0
43.5
18.9
16.4
14.3
14.9
12.0
Usinglinearinterpolation(orgraphicalmethod)IRRcanbeestimated:
6.3+12.0=6.3
0.150.08(x0.08)
Rearranginggives:
(x0.08)=6.3x0.07
6.3+12.0
Thereforex=0.08+0.024=10.4%approx.
12
Page
GROUP4EXERCISES
PROBLEM1:
ProjectPoldavia
Abuildingmaterialscompanyhasidentifiedanopportunitytoinvestinanewcement
plantinPoldavia,detailsofwhichareprovidedbelow:
Initialinvestmentrequired
NetsalesexpectedinYear1
Salesgrowthrate
Operatingprofitmargin
Taxrate
Workingcapitalinvestment
Costofcapital
40m(tobedepreciatedover20years)
100m
5%perannumforthefirst5years/zerogrowth
thereafter
10%forthefirst3yearsand12%thereafter
(excludingdepreciation)
30%.
10%ofthefollowingyear'sNetSales(required
atthestartofeachyear)
8.5%
13
Page
SOLUTION1:
ProjectPoldavia
NetPresentValueAnalysis
Allamountsin'000
Year0
Year1
Year2
Year3
Year4
Year5
Stabilised
NetSales
Salesgrowth%
100,000
105,000
5%
110,250
5%
115,763
5%
121,551
5%
121,551
OperatingProfit(OP)before
depreciationOPmargin(ex
depn)%
10,000
10%
10,500
10%
11,025
10%
13,892
12%
14,586
12%
14,586
12%
LostContribution
(8,000)
(8,000)
(3,000)
Depreciation
(2,000)
(2,000)
(2,000)
(2,000)
(2,000)
(2,000)
OperatingProfitBeforeTax
500
6,025
11,892
12,586
12,586
Tax(30%)
(150)
(1,808)
(3,568)
(3,776)
(3,776)
NOPAT
350
4,217
8,324
8,810
8,810
2,000
2,000
2,000
2,000
2,000
(2,000)
(2,000)
(2,000)
(2,000)
(2,000)
(525)
(551)
(579)
8,810
Initialinvestment
Adddepreciation
Lesssustainingcapex,
Workingcapitalchange
(working1)
Freecashflow
Terminalvalue(working2)
(40,000)
2,000
(2,000)
(10,000) (500)
(50,000) (500)..
(175)
3,666
7,745
8,810
103,647
Totalamounttodiscount
(50,000)
(500)
(175)
3,666
7,745
112,457
Discountrate
0.922
0.849
0.783
0.722
0.665
Presentvalue
(50,000)
(461)
(149)
2,870
5,592
74,784
14
Page
NetPresentValue
32,636
15
Page
Workings:
1.Changeinworkingcapital
NetSales
Workingcapitalrequired
Changeinworkingcapital
Year0
Year1
Year2
Year3
Year4
Year5
100,000
105,00
0
110,250
115,763
121,55
1
10,000
10,500
11,025
11,576
12,155
12,155
10,000
500
525
551
579
2.Terminalvalue
Terminalvalue=stabilizedcashflowx(1+growthrate)/(discountrategrowthrate)
Inthiscase,perpetuitygrowthrate=0
Therefore:
Terminalvalue=8,810/0.085=103,647
PROBLEM2:
Emperor'sClothesFashions(ECF)
ECFcaninvest5millioninanewplantforproducinginvisiblemakeup.Theplanthasan
expectedlifeof5years,andexpectedsalesare6millionjarsofmakeupayear.Fixedcosts
are2millionayear,andvariablecostsare1perjar.Theproductwillbepriceat2per
jar.Theplantwillbedepreciatedstraightlineover5yearstoasalvagevalueofzero.The
opportunitycostofcapitalis10%,andthetaxrateis40%.
a. WhatisprojectNPVunderthesebasecaseassumptions?
b. WhatisNPVifvariablecoststurnouttobe1.20perjar?
c. WhatisNPViffixedcoststurnouttobe1.5millionperyear?
d. AtwhatpriceperjarwouldprojectNPVequalzero?
SOLUTION2:
ECF
16
Page
Revenue=Pricexquantity=26million=12million
Totalcosts=Variablecost+fixedcost=(16million)+2million=8million
Depreciationexpense=5million/5years=1millionperyear
Therefore,profitperannumbeforetax=12m8m1m=3m
Therefore,taxchargeperannum=3mx40%=1.2m
Profitaftertax=3m1.2m=1.8m
Aftertaxcashflow=profitaftertax+depreciation=1.8m+1m=2.8m
a.NPV=5million+[2.8millionxannuityfactor(10%,5years)]
=5+(2.83.791)=5.6million
b.Ifvariablecost=1.20,thentotalcostsincreaseto:
(1.206million)+2million=9.2million
Profitbeforetaxperannum=12m9.2m1m=1.8m
Profitaftertax=60%x1.8m=1.08million
Aftertaxcashflow=1.08m+1m=2.08m
NPV=5million+[2.08millionx3.791]=2.9million
c.
Iffixedcosts=1.5million,totalcostsfallto:
(16million)+1.5million=7.5million
Profitbeforetaxperannum=12m7.5m1m=3.5m
Profitaftertax=60%x3.5m=2.1m
Cashflow=2.1m+1m=3.1m
NPV=5million+[3.1millionx3.791]=6.8million
d.
CallPthepriceperjar.Then:
Revenue=P6million
Expense=(1x6million)+2million=8million
Givendepreciationistaxdeductible,theseresultsinataxsavingof1mx40%=
0.4m
Therefore,cashflowaftertaxperannumcanbeexpressedasfollows:
Cashflow=[(60%x(6P8)]+(0.4)=3.6P4.4
NPV=5+[(3.6P4.4)xannuityfactor(10%,5years)]
=5+[(3.6P4.4)x3.791]=21.680+13.648P
Therefore,NPV=0whenP=1.59perjar
17
Page
PROBLEM3:
DiamondLtd
DiamondLtdhas1mtoinvestandhaveidentifiedthefollowingfourprojects:
Project
A
B
C
D
InvestmentOutlay
400,000
600,000
300,000
250,000
NetPresentValue
+100,000
+125,000
+90,000
+40,000
Required
Assuming each project is infinitely divisible and the projects are not mutually
exclusive,inwhichprojectsshouldDiamondLtdinvest?
SOLUTION3:
DiamondLtd
RankprojectsonbasisofNPVperofinvestmentrequired
Project
A
B
C
D
InvestmentOutlay NetPresent
Value
400,000
+100,000
600,000
+125,000
300,000
+90,000
250,000
+40,000
NPVper
Ranking
0,25
0.208
0.3
0.16
2
3
1
4
Allocateavailablefundsaccordingly
Project
C
A
Fundsused
300,000
400,000
NPV
90,000
100,000
18
Page
300,000(balance)
1,000,000
62,500(=125,000)
252,500
19
Page
GROUP5EXERCISES
Problem1:
Consider the following data for the returns on shares of the swimming pool owned by
SplashplcandthatoftheIceCreamManufacturingCompany(ICMC):
Event
probability
Splashsharereturn
Hotweather
Modestlywarm
Coldweather
0.2
0.6
0.2
1.0
5
15
20
ICMC
return
30
15
2
share
Required:
a.
Whatistheexpectedreturnofeachofthetwoshares?
b.
Whatisthestandarddeviationofthereturnsofeachofthetwoshares?
c.
Calculate the expected returns and standard deviation of the following
portfolios.
Portfolio
Proportion of funds
investedinICMC
A
B
C
0.80
0.50
0.25
Proportion of
funds invested
inSplash
0.20
0.50
0.75
d. Draw a riskreturn line using the data you have generated from a, b and c. (In
addition, you may also assume that the minimum standard deviation possible from a
portfolioofSplashandICMCsharesis0.62,whichgivesanexpectedreturnof14.5%).
SOLUTION1:
a.
Ri(%)
Rs(%)
piorps
RiPi
Rsps
30
5
0.2'
6.0
1.0
20
Page
15
2
15
20
b.
(RiE(Ri))2pi
42.63
0.10
35.91
2=78.64
=8.87%
0.6
0.2
Expected
return
9.0
9.0
0.4
4.0
E(Ri)=15.4% E(RS)=14.0%
(RsE(RS))2ps
16.2
0.6
7.2
=24.0
=4.9%
c.
[RiE(Ri)][RsE(RS)]pi
26.28
0.24
16.08
42.60
PortfolioA:
Expectedreturn:0.815.4+0.214=15.12%
Standarddeviation:
(0.8278.64+0.22x24+2x0.8x0.242.6)I/2=6.1%
PortfolioB:
Expectedreturn:0.515.4+0.514=14.7%
Standarddeviation:
(0.5278.64+0.52x24+2x0.50.542.6)=2.1%
PortfolioC:
Expectedreturn:0.2515.4+0.7514=14.35%
Standarddeviation:
(0.25278.64+0.75224+20.250.7542.60)=1.56%
21
Page
d.
22
Page
GROUP6EXERCISES
PROBLEM1:
Delawareplc
ExtractsfromDelawareplc'smostrecentbalancesheetareasfollows:
12%IrredeemableDebentures
OrdinaryShareCapital(1shares)
SharePremiumAccount
Reserves
000
4,000
8,000
2,000
6,000
16,000
An annual ordinary dividend of 20p per share has just been paid. In the past, ordinary
dividends have grown at a rate of 10% per annum and this rate of growth is expected to
continue. Annual interesthasrecentlybeenpaidonthedebentures.Theordinarysharesare
currently quoted at 2.75 and the debentures at 80 per cent (i.e. 80 per 100 nominal
value).
Therateofcorporationtaxis30%.
Required
CalculateDelaware'sWeightedAverageCostofCapital.
SOLUTION1:
Delawareplc
=18%
23
Page
=10.5%
WACC:
MarketValue
Equity
Debt
22m
3.2m
25.2m
87%
13%
CostofCapital
%
18
10.5
WACC=
WeightedCost
15.7
1.3
17.0%
PROBLEM2:
Herbertplc
YouhavebeencalledinasaconsultantforHerbertplc,asportinggoodsretailfirm,which
isexaminingitsdebtpolicy.Thefirmiscurrentlyhasabalancesheetasflows
Allamountsinm
Longtermbonds
Equity
Total
100
500
600
Fixedassets
Currentassets
Total
500
100
600
Thefirm'sincomestatementisgivenasfollows(allinm):
Revenues
Costofgoodssold
Depreciation
EBIT
Longterminterest
Earningbeforetax
Taxes
NetIncome
250
175
25
50
10
40
16
24
The firm currently has 100m shares outstanding, selling at a market price of 5 per share
and the bonds are selling at their book value. The firm's current beta is 1.12, the rate of
returnongovernmenttreasurybondsis7%andthemarketriskpremiumis5.5%.
a. Whatisthefirm'scurrentcostofequity?
b. Whatisthefirm'scurrentcostofdebt?(Youmayassumetherateof
24
Page
corporationtaxis40%).
c. Whatisthefirm'scurrentweightedaveragecostofcapital?
d. AssumethatmanagementofHerbertplcisconsideringdoingadebtequity
swap(i.e.,borrowingenoughmoneytobuyback70msharesofstockat5per
share).Itisbelievedthatthisswapwilllowerthefirm'sratingtoCandraise
theinterestrateonthecompany'sdebtto15%andthebetaofequityis
expectedtoincreaseto2.8.
Whatisthefirm'snewweightedaveragecostofcapital?
SOLUTION2:
Herbertplc
a. Currentcostofequity=7%+1.12(5.5%)=13.16%
b. Currentpretaxcostofdebt=InterestExpenses/Marketvalueofdebt=10/100
=10%
Theaftertaxcostofdebt=10%(10.4)=6%.
c.
Thefirmscurrentcostofcapital(WACC)=D/Vrdebt(1T)+E/Vrequity
Whererdebtisthepretaxcostofdebtandrdebt(1T)istheaftertaxcostofdebt.
ThusWACC=13.16%(500/600)+6%(100/600)=11.97%.
d. Ifthefirmborrows350millionandbuysbackshares
Newdebt=450m
Newequity=150m
Thecostofnewequity=7%+2.80(5.5%)=22.40%
Theaftertaxcostofdebt=15%(10.4)=9%
WACC=22.40%(150/600)+9%(450/600)=12.35%
25
Page
PROBLEM3:
WestLtd
WestLtdisanunquotedcompany.TherecentlyappointedFinanceDirectorhasaskedfor
yourassistanceinobtainingacostofcapitalthatWestLtdcanusetoappraiseits
longterminvestmentopportunities.
Youhavebeenprovidedwiththefollowinginformation:
2million25pordinarysharesvaluedat87p
Theannualdividendof180,000,whichrepresents70%oftheamountthatwasavailable
fordistribution,hasjustbeenpaid.Thecompanyexpectstoachievearateofreturnof
26%onitsretainedprofits.
1million9%preferencesharesofl0pvaluedat80,000cumdiv.
lm8%irredeemabledebentures.Debentureholdersrequirearateofreturnof10%.
Therateofcorporationtaxis30%.
Required
CalculateforWestLtdits
(a)
costofequity
(b)
costofpreferenceshares
(c)
marketvalueofdebentures
(d)
costofdebentures
(e)
weightedaveragecostofcapital
26
Page
SOLUTION3:
WestLtd
(a) Costofequity
g=rateofreturnonequityxplowbackratio
=26%30%=7.8%
=19.0%
(b) Costofpreferenceshare=Dividends
Marketvalue(ediv)
=12.7%
(c) Marketvalueofdebentures=Interest
Debentureholders'requiredrateofreturn
=0.8m,
(d) Costofdebentures=10%(1taxrate)=10%(10.3)
=7%
(e) WACC:
Equity
Prefshares
MarketValue
1.740m
0.07lm
66.67c
2.7%
CostofCapital
%
19
12.7
Weighted
Cost
12.7
0.4
27
Page
Debt
0.80m
2.611m
30.6%
7
WACC=
2.1
15.2%
28
Page
GROUP7EXERCISES
PROBLEM1:
ALtdwishestobuyBLtdforlm.Thecurrentbalancesheetpositionsofbothcompanies
areasfollows:
FixedAssets
Factory
Machinery
NetCurrentAssets
FinancedBy
ShareCapital
Reserves
ALtd
000
BLtd
000
450
250
700
750
1,450
400
400
600
1,000
150
1,300
1,450
100
900
1,000
A Ltd makes pretax profits of 200,00 per year. The owner of A Ltd has 150,000 of
cash, lives in a house worth 600,000 subject to a mortgage of 250,000, and has life
assurance policies and investments worth 180,000. After the takeover it isestimatedthat
the combined companies will produce a cash flow of 250,000 for the service of debt,
besidesprovidingtheownerwithasalaryanddividends.
Requirement
Recommendanappropriatefinancingpackage.
SOLUTION1:
ALTDBUYSBLTD
1misonlythebalancesheetvalueofBLtd.ItispossiblethatALtdmayneedto
paymorethanthistoacquireBLtd'sshares!
Wouldbeinterestingtoknowwhetherthereisanysurpluscashisinthebalance
sheetofALtd,andwhethertheworkingcapitalofALtdcanbe'squeezed'(eg
29
Page
throughbetterstockanddebtorsmanagement)tomakefundsavailablefor
financingthisacquisition
TheownerofALtdshouldonlyreallyconsiderusinghisownfundsandre
mortgaginghisownpropertyafterhehasexhaustedallopportunitiesforraising
financeviathecompany
ALtdcurrentlyhasnogearing,has700,000offixedassetstoofferassecurity
ondebt,andhascashflowsof250,000perannumtoservicethedebt.The
companythereforehastheabilitytoraiseasignificantamountofdebt.
Assuminglmrequired,thenapossiblefinancemixcouldbe250kofcash
(ideallyfromworkingcapitaloralternativelyfromtheownerofALtd'sown
fundsplusremortgageofhouse),then750kofdebtsecuredonassetsofALtd
andBLtdcombined
PROBLEM2:
A group intends to sell off a division. The division is run by two managers (one in
production and one in marketing) and has been breaking even. However, the managers
reckonthatitcouldproduce profitof100,000ayearifheadofficechargeswereremoved
they also foresee substantial growth. The group is prepared to sell the division for
400,000 to existing management. Net assets are 600,000 including a freehold factory
valued at 320.000. The managers can raise 100,000 through second mortgages and
savings.
Requirement
Recommendanappropriatefinancingpackage.
SOLUTION2:
MBO
Management Buy Out's (MBO's) generally involve a substantial amount of cash
injectionfromthemanagerstoshowcommitmentandobtainownership
Mayneedtoraisemorethan400,000tohelpfinancethefuturegrowth
There is a gap between what the managers can raise (100,000) and the minimum
amountrequired(400,000)
Managers may be reluctant tobringinnewequityasthiswilldilutetheircontrolof
thenewcompany
The freehold factory may provide security for senior debt.Thecompanyshouldbe
30
Page
able to raise around 80% of the market value of the factory's market value(80%x
320,000=256,000)
The profit forecasts suggest that the companywillgeneratesufficientcashflowsto
servicethedebtinterest
The managers may look to Venture Capital finance to help fill the financing gap
andstrengthenthemanagementteam.
Assuming 400,000 will be sufficient initially, suggestion is for the managers to
input 100,000,VC'stoinput50,000inexchangeforaplaceontheboard,andfor
seniordebtof250.000
PROBLEM3:
000
000
FixedAssets
3000
CurrentAssets
4,200
Creditors:amountsfallingduewithin1year
TradeCreditors
1,800
Overdraft
1,400
3,200
NetCurrentAssets
1,000
4,000
TermLoan
1,600
2,400
FinancedBy
ShareCapital
400
Reserves
2,000
2,400
Requirement
Recommendanappropriatefinancingpackage.
31
Page
SOLUTION3:
EXPANSION
PROBLEM4:
RightsIssue
RIplchas100millionsharesinissue.Itwishestoraise25mviarightsissue.Itsshares
arecurrentlytradingatapriceof120pinthestockmarket.
RIhasdecidedtoraisethe25mbyissuing25madditionalsharesatasubscriptionprice
of1pershare.
FredcurrentlyownslmsharesinRIplcandhaslmofcashinthebank.
Requirement
(a)
(b)
Calculatethetheoreticalexrightsshareprice.
ShowtheeffectonFred'swealthifhedecidesto:
i.Donothing
ii.Takeuptherights
iii.Selltherights
(c) Whateffect,ifany,doesthelevelofpricediscountdecisionhaveonthewealthof
32
Page
shareholders?(Forexample,woulditmakeanydifferenceif50mshareswere
soldatasubscriptionpriceof50p?).
SOLUTION4:
RIGHTSISSUE
(a)Given25msharestobeissuedrelativetothe100msharesalreadyinissue,thismeans
thiswillbea1for4rightsissue.
Theoreticalexrightsprice=MVbeforerights+cashraised
No.ofsharesaftertherights
=(1.20x100m)+25
125m
=1.16
This assumes the new funds raised by the company will be invested at zero Net Present
Value.
(b)EffectonFred'swealthif:
(i) Doesnothing
Shares(lm1.2)
Cash
Before
1.2m
1.0m
2.2m
(lm1.16)
Cash
After
1.16m
1.00m
2.16m
Fredwouldthereforebe40,000worseoff.
(ii) Takesuprights
Before
1.2m
(l.25m1.16)
1.0m
Cash(10.25)
2.2m
TherewouldthereforebenoeffectonFred'swealth.
(iii) Selltherights
Shares(lm1.2)
Cash
Shares(lm1.2)
Cash
Before
1.2m
1.0m
2.2m
After
1.45m
0.75m
2.20m
After
(lm1.16)
1.16m
Cash(1+(0.2516p*) 1.04m
2.20m
33
Page
TherewouldthereforebenoeffectonFred'swealth.
*Valueoftherights=Exrightspricesubscriptionprice=1.161.00=16ppershare
(c) There will be no effect on shareholders' wealth if a different combination of price and
number of shares is issued to raise the required 25m. (This can be proved byreworking
(b)abovefora50mshareissueatasubscriptionpriceof50p).
Thepricediscountisonlyrelevantwherethereisconcernthataftertherightsissueis
announcedbutbeforeittakesplace,thesharepricemightfallbeneaththesubscription
price.Insuchcircumstances,therightsissuewouldfailasnoonewouldtakeuptherights
offer
34
Page
GROUP8EXERCISES
PROBLEM1:
MSPLTD
MSP is a private limited company with intentions of obtaining a stock marketlistingin
the near future. The company is wholly equity financed at present but the directors are
consideringanewcapitalstructurepriortoitbecomingalistedcompany.
MSP operates in an industry where the average asset beta is 1.2 (i.e. beta with zero
gearing). The company's business risk is estimatedtobesimilartothatoftheindustryasa
whole. The current level of earnings before interest and tax is 400,000. This earnings
levelisexpectedtobemaintainedfortheforeseeablefuture.
The rate of return on risk less assets is at present 10% and the return on the market
portfolio is 15%. These rates are posttax and are expected to remain constant for the
foreseeablefuture.
MSP is considering introducing debt into its capital structure by one of the following
methods:
(1)
(2)
500,00010%debenturesatpar,securedonthecompany'slandandbuildings
1,000,00012%unsecuredloanstockatpar
The rate of corporation tax is expected to remain at 33% and interest on debt is tax
deductible.
Required
(a) Calculateforeachofthetwooptions:
(i)valuesofequityandthetotalmarketvalueofthefirm
(ii)debt/equityratios
(iii)thecostofequity
(b) Listthemainproblemsandcostswhichmightariseforacompanyexperiencinga
periodofseverefinancialdifficulties.
35
Page
SOLUTION1:
(a)
WewilluseVg=Vu+DT
Firstly,calculatetheungearedvalueofthebusiness,Vu
Estimatedcashflowaftertax(toperpetuity)=400,000x(10.33)=268,000
DiscountrateusingCAPM=10%+1.2(15%10%)=16%
Vu=268,000/0.16=1,675,000
500,000debenture
(i) Vg=1,675,000+500,000x0.33=1,840,000,thereforeequityvalueis
1,840,000500,000=1,340,000
(ii) Gearing=500,000/1,340,000=0.37
(iii) Ke=d/P0
Dividend=(400,00050,000)x0.67=234,500
Thereforeke=234,500/1,340,000=17.5%
1,000,000debenture
(i) Vg=1,675,000+1,000,000x0.33=2,005,000,thereforeequityvalueis
2,005,0001,000,000=1,005,000
(ii) Gearing=1,000,000/1,005,000=0.99
(iii) Ke=d/PO
Dividend=(400,000120,000)0.67=187,600
Thereforeke=187,600/1,005,000=18.7%
Answerstopart(b)arewellcoveredinthetextbookandlecturenotes.
36
Page
PROBLEM2:
CapitalStructure
"Capitalstructurecanhavenoinfluenceonthevalueofthefirm'.
Discussthisstatementandcommentbrieflyonthepracticalfactorswhichacompany
mighttakeintoaccountwhendeterminingitscapitalstructure.
PROBLEM3:
DividendPolicy
'Dividendpolicycanhavenoinfluenceonthevalueofthefirm'.
Discussthisstatementandcommentbrieflyonthepracticalfactorswhichacompany
mighttakeintoaccountwhendeterminingitsdividendpolicy.
SOLUTION2&3:
Answerstoproblem2and3arewellcoveredinthetextbookandlecturenotes.
37
Page