Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Energy
rirM.WardumVIAUniversityHorsens
2010
Dissertation
7.Semester
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Preface
This dissertation is a part of my curriculum for the 7th semester B.sc in Architecture
Technology and construction management. To make this report I have read many
articles and books on this subject and I also visited a real geothermal energy power
plant and got a private tour in it.
The reason for my choosing this subject was that I am from Iceland and it has always
been around me, but I have never really put much thought in it until I moved to
Denmark. Thats when I really realised how lucky we are to have so much access to
geothermal energy. Its cost also intrigued me when I got my electricity and heat bill
when I was living in Denmark.
This dissertation is built up into 9 chapters to make it easier to read. I built up my report
basically from what areas you can find it and all the way to technical data about
harnessing it. In the conclusion I will clarify all my research questions which I asked
myself in the problem statement.
Abstract
My research focus in this report is geothermal energy, which such questions as What is
geothermal energy and where does it come from. I have used various research
methods, such as books, articles and study guides, to find the information I needed to
answer these questions, as well as the others I have asked myself in the problem
statement. My findings have shown that it comes from deep in the earth, and in specific
areas around the globe, where the conditions are right. In my conclusion I state that
geothermal energy is a very good contender for replacing coal and oil power plants, but
in order for this, it is necessary to reform the way governments handle energy supplies
by taxation and other methods.
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Table of Contents
Preface.........................................................................................................................................................2
Abstract........................................................................................................................................................2
Table of Figures..........................................................................................................................................5
Introduction..................................................................................................................................................5
1. Problem Formulation.............................................................................................................................6
2. Geothermal Energy what is it, and where does it come from?.....................................................7
2.1 Where do you find geothermal energy ................................................................................ 7
2.2 Tectonic plates .................................................................................................................... 8
2.3 Divergent boundaries .......................................................................................................... 8
2.4 Convergent boundaries ....................................................................................................... 8
2.4.1 Oceanic Continental Convergence........................................................................................9
2.4.2 Oceanic-Oceanic Convergence.............................................................................................9
2.4.3 Continental-Continental Convergence..................................................................................9
2.5 Transform Fault Boundaries ................................................................................................ 9
2.6 Countries using geothermal energy to produce electricity ................................................ 10
2.7 The depth of geothermal energy ....................................................................................... 11
2.8 The temperature of geothermal energy ............................................................................. 11
2.8.1 Low heat zones.......................................................................................................................11
2.8.2 High heat zones......................................................................................................................12
2.9 Harnessing geothermal energy ......................................................................................... 12
2.9.1 Dry Steam................................................................................................................................12
2.9.2 Flash steam.............................................................................................................................13
2.9.3 Binary steam...........................................................................................................................13
3. Research and exploration methods..................................................................................................14
3.1 Schlumberger method ....................................................................................................... 14
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Table of Figures
Figure1:Theearthlayers.............................................................................................................................7
Figure2.Theplateboundariesintheworld................................................................................................8
Figure3.MidAtlanticridgedivergent.........................................................................................................8
Figure4.Temperaturesatdepthof6kmintheUSA.................................................................................11
Figure5.HeatzonesinIceland...................................................................................................................12
Figure6:DrySteamplant...........................................................................................................................12
Figure7:Flashsteamplant.........................................................................................................................13
Figure8:Binarycycleplant.........................................................................................................................13
Figure9:Schlumbergermethod................................................................................................................14
Figure10:A2DdatareceivedfromSchlumbergermeasuring..................................................................15
Figure11:TEMMethod.............................................................................................................................15
Figure12:A3DdatareceivedfromTEMmeasuring..................................................................................16
Figure13:Themostcommondrillhead.....................................................................................................18
Introduction
In this report I wanted to investigate what geothermal energy is, and where it comes
from. The report is divided up into eight separate chapters, excluding the literature list,
which enables me to start from the basics of what geothermal energy is, to where you
can find it, and at what depth. The following chapters after that are about the more
technical aspects of geothermal energy, followed by information about some of the
largest geothermal power plants in Iceland.
What I hope to achieve in writing a report about this subject, is a broader knowledge in
this field, which I possibly could use after I am finished with the 7th semester. I have
developed a strong interest into the techniques and developments of this field, and am
avidly following the progress of the local power stations. At the moment in Iceland,
these geothermal power plants are under a lot of media coverage because the
government in power have halted much of the progress going on, by the wishes of the
5
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
1. Problem Formulation
What is geothermal energy?
Research questions:
1. Where do you find geothermal energy?
2. How deep do you need to drill for it?
3. How hot is the water or the steam?
4. How do you harness it?
5. Can you use it to make electricity?
6. What are the advantages and disadvantages of geothermal energy?
7. What is the future of geothermal energy?
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure1: Theearthlayers
http://www.cangea.ca/whatisgeothermal/
http://www.myclimatechange.net/default.aspx?cat=3&sub=&SubjectId=41&Rate=5
3
http://www.myclimatechange.net/default.aspx?cat=3&sub=&SubjectId=41&Rate=5
4
http://www.cangea.ca/whatisgeothermal/
5
http://www.universetoday.com/31139/ringoffirevolcanoes/
Figure1:http://www.myclimatechange.net/default.aspx?cat=3&sub=&SubjectId=41&Rate=5
2
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure2: Theplateboundariesintheworld
Figure3: MidAtlanticridgedivergent
http://www.platetectonics.com/book/page_5.asp
Figure2:http://academic.evergreen.edu/g/grossmaz/heidtken.html
7
http://www.platetectonics.com/book/page_5.asp
Figure3:Personalphoto
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
http://www.platetectonics.com/book/page_5.asp
http://www.platetectonics.com/book/page_5.asp
10
http://www.ust.is/surtsey/fridlandid/
11
http://www.platetectonics.com/book/page_5.asp
9
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
You can also find geothermal areas in rifts on the plates and the most famous one is the
Rio Grande rift that made the national Yellowstone park in Colorado. It goes all the way
from Colorado (USA) down to Mexico12.
2.6 Countries using geothermal energy to produce electricity
From a report from the International Geothermal Association done in 2007 it says that
24 countries are using geothermal energy for direct electricity production but 72
countries use it for both district heating and electricity13.
List of top 10 countries that use geothermal energy for producing electricity14:
1. USA - 2248 MW
2. Philippines 1909 MW
3. Mexico 953 MW
4. Italy 791 MW
5. Indonesia 589.5 MW
6. Iceland - 575 MW15
7. Japan 534.3 MW
8. New Zealand 437 MW
9. El Salvador 161 MW
10. Costa Rica 142.5 MW
12
http://cires.colorado.edu/science/groups/sheehan/projects/riogrande/faq/
http://www.geoenergy.org/currentUse.aspx
14
http://www.http://balisos.com/Energy/ReFocusReportGeoThermalEnergyIndonesia.html
15
http://os.is/jardhiti/jardvarmanotkun/raforkunotkun/
13
10
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure4: Temperaturesatdepthof6kmintheUSA
16
http://www.jardboranir.is/?PageID=688
http://www.geysers.com/geothermal.htm
Figure4:http://personaldividends.com/lifestyle/briskycapital/cangeothermalbeamajorpartofourenergyplan
18
http://www.fsu.is/~ornosk/liffraedi/erlend/joha/jarisl.htm
19
http://www.myclimatechange.net/default.aspx?cat=3&sub=&SubjectId=41&Rate=5
17
11
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure5: HeatzonesinIceland
21
in Iceland .
20
http://os.is/jardhiti/jardhitasvaediaislandi/laghitasvaedi/
http://visindavefur.hi.is/svar.php?id=2687
Figure5:http://os.is/jardhiti/jardhitasvaediaislandi/hahitasvaedi/
22
http://www.myclimatechange.net/default.aspx?cat=3&sub=&SubjectId=41&Rate=5
Figure6:http://www.agreenamerica.org/geothermal.htm
Figure7:http://www.agreenamerica.org/geothermal.htm
Figure8:http://www.agreenamerica.org/geothermal.htm
21
12
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure8:Binarycycleplant
13
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure9:Schlumbergermethod
23
GeothermalEnergySystems,ErnstHuenges,page37
Jarhitabk,GumundurPlsson,page107108
25
Jarhitabk,GumundurPlsson,page111122
Figure9:http://www.arcticgeophysics.com/methods_resistivity_1D.html
24
14
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure10:A 2DdatareceivedfromSchlumbergermeasuring
Figure11:TEMMethod
placed in the middle reads and measures the electricity coming up and changes it into
data26.
26
Jarhitabk,GumundurPlsson,page113114
Figure10:http://water.usgs.gov/ogw/bgas/publications/wri994211/wri994211.html
Figure11:http://www.enex.is/?PageID=201
Figure12:http://www.isgs.illinois.edu/aboutisgs/monthlyrepts/apr2009/actsall.shtml
15
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Figure12:A3DdatareceivedfromTEMmeasuring
3.3 MT-measurement
MT-measurement (Magnetotellurics) is a technique based on using natural fluctuations
in the earths magnetic field. By measuring these magnetic fluctuations you can make
pretty thorough readings of the layout of the underground layers, up to even 30km
down. It has mainly been used to measure the earths crust or to survey a very large
area.
16
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
17
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
27
Jarhitabk,GumundurPlsson,page122
Figure13:http://www.ecplaza.net/tradeleads/seller/3402014/steel_tooth_tricone_bit.html
18
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
When the 10m bar has been drilled down you detach the drill motor and screw a new
10m steel bar on it and drill it down again. You repeat this process and you put on as
many steel bars as you need to reach down to the depth you need. The drill head has
three drill heads on it, and it turns as soon as the steel bars start turning, turning around
60-90 times a minute, which breaks and crushes the earths rock into as fine sand as
found on a beach. But how many times you must replace the drill head depends on how
hard the ground layers are, and that takes a long time depending on how deep you are
down. You need to unscrew all steel bars off until you reach the drill head and then redo
everything again until you reach the bottom of the hole and continue drilling28.
The deepest drill hole in the world is in Kola, Russia. It started in 1970 and it was being
drilled on an off till it stopped in 1994. It was part of a program to drill many holes
reaching 10-15km depth during the time of the Soviet Union to research the earths
crust, pressure and research the techniques and technology for deep drilling for oil and
gas at the depth of up to 15km.29 They reached a temperature of 180C in the bottom of
the hole and this was not a geothermal area so the possibilities are every were if there
is a will to reach heat from the ground.
28
29
Jarhitabk,GumundurPlsson,page124126
http://www.episodes.org/backissues/54/ARTICLES9.pdf
19
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
5.1 Reykjanesvirkjun
Reykjanesvirkjun is a geothermal power plant in Iceland and is owned by HS Orka hf.
And the plant is located in an area called Reykjanes in Iceland. They also have other
geothermal power plants in another area called Svartsengi.
I visited and got a private tour around the power plant. Reykjanesvirkjun produces 100
MW of electricity (only electricity) and its a very unique geothermal power plant and
actually only one of its kinds in the world. This is due to the hot water it uses is almost
pure sea water. It also uses sea water to cool down the steam and water after it has
gone through the generators. It is located on the coast so it has easy access to cold sea
water, which is one of the main problems with establishing a geothermal power plant
around the world, as not all cities are located in coastal areas.
It gets water and steam from 16 drill holes reaching depths of 2-3 km deep, and in the
total of 35km deep. Most the holes reach heat from 290-310C but there is one that
reaches 316C. The pressures in the holes are from 25-50 bars.
The water goes from the holes to a separation station through pipelines and there it is
separated and changed into steam. Each separation tank can take water from 6 holes
and after that process the pressure goes down to 18 bars. Then it goes through 1220m
of pipelines to a moisture separation tank. There always slips some water through the
separation station and in such long pipe lines, moisture is just unavoidable. Thats why it
goes into a moisture separation tank and there all moisture is filtered out and the steam
is dried. It is very important to dry the steam before it goes into the turbine generators.
From the moisture tanks it goes into the generators (turbines) and it is let into the
generator on each side to balance the steam or energy coming in. The turbine is the
20
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
machine that generates electricity, the steam comes into the generators and goes
through the turbines making them turn as the steam goes through them and that
generates electricity, and in Reykjanesvirkjun there are two generators. The turbine
rotates 3000 rpm as the steam goes through them so you can see why it is important to
dry the steam so the moisture or water doesnt go through. But there is always some
moisture and thats why Reykjanesvirkjun has double flow generators to minimize
erosion and damage. The wind flow in the generators is 1000 kph so you can imagine
the stress and pressure the generators are put through, and there is about 17% of
moisture in the steam when it enters the generators. That means there is about 14kg
per sec. In 1000 keep going through the generators and thats why they use double flow
generators to ease the immense pressure on the generators. There are two generators
in Reykjanesvirkjun and each produces 50 MW, a total of 100 MW, which goes to a high
voltage station next to the plant, and then to its destination.
After the steam has produced electricity in the generators it goes into a condenser to
cool it down. From there the steam is cooled down into water inside a big tank. It works
like a double radiator that runs together side by side until it cools down from the cold
sea water, not unlike a closed radiator system in a house where you heat up the hot
water again in a circular closed heating system. The seawater is pumped up from
twelve 60m deep drill holes 200m at a rate of 4000 l per sec. from the coastline, to avoid
getting sea life and seaweed into the condenser. The earth layer is so open under all
that area and the seawater just runs through the ground. So after the steam has been
cooled down it is 45C and it is pumped back into the ocean. It has to be cooled down to
45C to not affect the sea life in the area.
Thats what makes Reykjanesvirkjun so unique compared to others, because its the
only one in the world that uses seawater to cool down the steam. But the sad part about
the steam that comes out of the generators is that it is still usable and would produce
50MW extra, but the tour guide from HS Orka told me that they are not allowed to use it
21
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
because of some rules and legislation around the geothermal energy and they even
have the third generator just lying on the floor unused30.
5.2 Svartsengi
Svartsengi is HS Orkass second area of geothermal power plants and also where they
started out producing electricity and also hot and cold water for homes and business in
the area.
The first hole to be drilled in the area by HS Orka was in 1971 and it was 262m deep
but it turned out to be useless. The second one was drilled the year after and it was
239m deep but it turned out to be useless too. But later that year they drilled the third
one and which was 402m deep and it was a success, and they used it until 1981. There
have been drilled 22 holes total in the area. This power plant very unique also, mainly
because it delivers preheated cold water to the hot water supply to homes and it was
one of the first ones in the world to pump the water back down into the ground, and
actually 60% of the water that is pumped up is pumped back down. The landscape is
also very open with centuries of old hardened lava rocks and that lets the rain water
easily pass down to the ground layers. So while it rains and they pump the water back
down, there is an endless supply of geothermal energy.
30
BrochurefromHSOrkahf.
22
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
31
http://www.myclimatechange.net/default.aspx?cat=3&sub=&SubjectId=41&Rate=5
23
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
32
33
http://www.hsorka.is/kynningarefni/KynningvigslaOV6.pdf
http://www.geysers.com/history.htm
24
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
power plant has only grown since, and it is the worlds biggest geothermal power plant.
It supplies the state of California with 25% of all renewable energy and it produces 40%
of all electricity made with geothermal energy in the US. The Geysers power plant
consists of 23 power plants, 350 steam wells and 58 injection wells producing over 2000
MW of electricity. Its a dry steam power plant and it pumps down water through the
injection wells to produce steam to power the turbines to make electricity. They get their
water from recycled wastewater from the state of California through some of the 80
miles of pipelines going in and out of the power plant34.
34
http://www.geysers.com/docs/Repowering_The_Geysers_May_2007.pdf
25
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
35
36
http://www.cleanenergyideas.com/articles/advantages_of_geothermal_energy.html
http://www.cleanenergyideas.com/articles/disadvantages_of_geothermal_energy.html
26
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
It is a huge task to provide 12 billion people enough energy and even more to provide
them with clean energy. It is hoped that energy consumption will improve in this century
like in the last years there has been made drastic changes for the good in air pollution
from some energy resources like coal or oil. But it is still clear that it will be hard to
reduce the pollution or even reducing that kind of energy production.
Greenhouse gases and air pollution is substantially less with using renewable energy
resources than using oil or gas. Thats why it is becoming the main focus in most
countries around the world today to use renewable energy. It is still going at turtle pace,
and it will probably continue to do so in the next two decades or so. The renewable
energy resources are much bigger than even todays energy consumption is in the
world, but it is met with a lot of resentment from todays leading energy companies,
mainly because of financial factors. They dont really want to stop selling oil and gas,
there is just too much at stake for them and that is the main reason. They control the
energy market. But to increase interest in renewable energy there has to be some
technological advancement in renewable energy production and mainly in cost. Or put
more taxes on fossil fuels to make renewable energy a better investment.
Water power and geothermal energy are competitive with fossil fuel regarding to cost,
biomass and wind power are not that far from it neither, but solar power has a long way
to go. International energy predictions assume that renewable energy will be 20-50% of
all energy consumption in the world in the latter part of the decade. And it is predicted
that sun power will be the far biggest renewable energy source and then biomass.
27
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
It is clear that not any other energy resource will replace fossil fuel as the world biggest
energy provider unless there are some changes made in the governing of energy in the
world. In the end you will need to use that energy resource that pollutes the least which
is available in your area or country37.
37
http://www.samorka.is/doc/1065
28
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
8. Conclusion
In this report I asked myself various question and the first of them was, what is
geothermal energy? Geo means earth and thermal means heat so thats were the word
geothermal comes from and geothermal energy comes from under the ground. It can be
in different depths depending on where you are in the world, or geothermal areas and
its energy or source goes as deep as the earths core which is 6000 Celsius. The
locations of most geothermal areas are where the Tectonic plates meet, thats also were
a lot volcanoes and earthquakes occur. The Tectonic plates are floating on one of the
earths layers called the mantle and they are constantly moving and are all in a chain of
action. No plate moves without another moving but when they collide there is a massive
release of energy like volcanoes and earthquakes. Toughs places are the most
common area where geothermal energy is. The depth of geothermal energy various
from where you are in the world for example in Iceland its from 50m to 4000m but in
Geyser California most of the holes are around 3000m. It can go as far as 10.000m but
you really just need to reach 180-190 steam to produce electricity. But before you can
drill anything there is a long time that goes into research and ground measuring before
you start drilling and there a many ways of measuring it, but the most common one is
the Schlumberger method, but with todays technological advantages its only going to
get better. The heat of the steam can go as low as 150 or even less, to over 300 and
is some cases you need to cool down the steam before letting it go through the
generators. To harness this energy and produce electricity there are mostly three kinds
of power plants in the world. The first one is a dry steam power plant and that one uses
the steam directly from under the ground with a temperature around 235. The second
one is called flash steam power plant and it pumps up water around 180 and when the
water condenses it uses the steam to power its generators. The water that is still left is
then pumped back down into the same well and is reused and this is the most common
geothermal power plant. The third one is called binary steam plant and it pumps up hot
water that is still not hot enough to condemns, but it is used to heat up other liquids
materials that have a much lower boiling point than ever water and when that liquid has
condemns it uses that steam to power the generators. The hot water is then pumped
back down like the flash one. This method is most likely to be the most common one
29
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
because it does not need as hot water to power the turbines. I also asked myself what
are the advantages and disadvantages of geothermal energy? The advantages are far
better than the disadvantages, mainly because it does not pollute the air at all or release
any greenhouse gases either. The space it needs is also significantly less than other
power plants, like oil or coal and it as also renewable energy unlike fossil fuel. The
disadvantages are not many but mostly it is location. It can be hard to build power
plants where these geothermal areas are, and to cool them down. Many geothermal
power plants need cold water to cool down the steam and that can be difficult to provide
because many geothermal areas are in remote places. Its other disadvantages is that it
can take a long time before ever drilling down, due to research work and it can take up
to 10 years from researching the area to producing electricity in a power plant. In the
end I asked myself what is the future of geothermal energy? It is clear that geothermal
energy will never be the only energy provider in the future but it will play a big role in it.
Fossil fuel will always be used until it is cheaper to use other energy resources like
geothermal energy. There are many things that need to changes in the worlds
governing like taxing fossil fuel to force cleaner and renewable energy resources. It is
predicted that geothermal energy will be around 3-4th biggest energy provider after solar
biomass and wind.
30
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
9.Literature list
Books:
Geothermal Energy Systems, Ernst Huenges, 2010
Jarhitabk. Eli og nnig jarhita, Gumundur Plsson, 2005
Web Pages:
Canadian Geothermal Energy Association
http://www.cangea.ca/what-is-geothermal/
31
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
rirM.WardumGeothermalEnergy
Clean Energy Ideas: web page with info and articles about renewable energy
http://www.clean-energy-ideas.com/articles/advantages_of_geothermal_energy.html
Clean Energy Ideas: web page with info and articles about renewable energy
http://www.clean-energy-ideas.com/articles/disadvantages_of_geothermal_energy.html
33