Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
The Trust for Public Land creates parks and protects land for people, ensuring healthy,
livable communities for generations to come.
Our Center for City Park Excellence helps make cities more successful through the
renewal and creation of parks for their social, ecological, and economic benefits to
residents and visitors alike.
Special acknowledgment
This report could not have been produced without the editorial and administrative leadership
of Adrian Benepe, Senior Vice President for City Park Development, The Trust for Public Land.
Table of contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................................5
What is a City Park Conservancy? ........................................................................................6
Founding Models: New York and San Francisco .........................................................7
What Makes a Park Conservancy Successful? ..................................................................13
Formal Agreement with the City ..................................................................................15
A Role for Public Officials .............................................................................................20
Master Planning and Project Prioritization..................................................................20
A Strong and Effective Board of Directors .................................................................21
Robust Fundraising is Mandatory ................................................................................26
Getting Recognition Right ............................................................................................26
Concessions and Earned Income ................................................................................29
Cordoned-Off Events ....................................................................................................31
What About Maintenance?...........................................................................................35
That Other PartnerThe City ........................................................................................36
Who Really Owns the Park? ..........................................................................................40
Combatting Fearfulness................................................................................................41
Conclusion ............................................................................................................................47
Tables
Selected Urban Conservancies and their Parks ...........................................................4
The Experience So Far ..................................................................................................14
Annual Revenue .............................................................................................................27
Annual Spending ...........................................................................................................28
Annual Earned Revenue ...............................................................................................30
Case Studies
Forest Park Forever, St. Louis ........................................................................................10
Piedmont Park Conservancy, Atlanta ..........................................................................16
Prospect Park Alliance, New York ................................................................................22
Civic Center Conservancy, Denver ..............................................................................32
Olmsted Parks Conservancy, Louisville.......................................................................37
Overton Park Conservancy, Memphis .........................................................................44
S E L E C T E D U R B A N PA R K C O N S E R V A N C I E S A N D T H E I R PA R K S
conservancy
city
park
acres
Atlanta
Chastain Park
268
Atlanta
Grant Park
132
Atlanta
Oakland Cemetery
Atlanta
Piedmont Park
Baltimore
Birmingham
Railroad Park
Boston
5 parks
835
Boston
3 parks
82
Boston
5 parks
Buffalo
Dallas
Fair Park
Dallas
Denver
Civic Center
Detroit
4 parks
Detroit
12 parks
Hartford
Bushnell Park
37
Houston
Buffalo Bayou
45
Houston
Discovery Green
Houston
Hermann Park
445
Houston
Memorial Park
1,431
Louisville
2,087
Memphis
Overton Park
Memphis
New York
New York
Central Park
843
New York
550
New York
High Line
New York
New York
Prospect Park
585
New York
433
New York
Riverside Park
New York
10 parks
New York
The Battery
25
Oklahoma City
17
Philadelphia
353 parks
Pittsburgh
8 parks
1,700
Portland
Forest Park
5,171
San Antonio
Brackenridge Park
246
San Jose
240
St. Louis
Forest Park
Washington, D.C.
48
185
6
19
15
1,200
277
5
12
8
117
12
184
3,200
65
330
1,792
10,550
1,293
146
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
Introduction
H\YfYkUgUh]aYk\YbifVUbdUf_gkYfYfa`mWcbg]XYfYXh\Ydf]XY ^cmUbX
fYgdcbg]V]`]hmcZhUldUmYfg"CbWYUdUf_kUg]bh\YdiV`]WXcaU]b U``U[fYYXh\Uh]hgkY][\h
kUghcVYWUff]YXcbh\Yg\ci`XYfgcZW]hm[cjYfbaYbh"
Bc`cb[Yf"K\]`YaUbmd`UWYggh]``\Ykhch\YhfUX]h]cbU`acXY` U[fck]b[biaVYfcZ
W]h]Ygbckih]`]nYdf]jUhYXcbUh]cbghcfYVi]`X fYZifV]g\ UbXYjYbaU]bhU]bgcaYcZh\Y]f
acgh]Wcb]WdUf_g"
HcXUmgZUjcfYXfYj]hU`]nUh]cbghfiWhifY]gh\YWcbgYfjUbWm"BYkMcf_U`cbY\UgbYUf`mhkc
XcnYbgiW\df]jUhYcf[Ub]nUh]cbgdfcj]X]b[bUbW]U`giddcfhZcfUdUf_ UbXh\Ub_ghc
gcaY\][\!dfc`YgiWWYggYg h\]gbYkUddfcUW\]gYaYf[]b[UgUg][b]WUbhdUf_aUbU[Y!
aYbhacXY`]bh\Yf][\hW]fWiaghUbWYg"
H\YWcbWYdhghc_YgVch\\cdYUbXZYUf"AUbmUbY`YWhYXcZW]U`UbXaUbmUdf]jUhY
Xcbcfhfighh\UhUWcbgYfjUbWmWUb]adfcjYdUf_giWWYggk\]`Y\c`X]b[XckbhUldUmYf
YldYbgY"Ch\YfgUfYg_Ydh]WU` kcffm]b[h\UhUbUffck[fcidcZfYg]XYbhga][\hUggiaY
Wcbhfc`cZUdiV`]WfYgcifWYk]h\h\YVYghcZ]bhYbh]cbgVihk]h\cihdc`]h]WU`UWWcibhUV]`]hm
cfUbibXYfghUbX]b[cZh\YVfcUXYfbYYXgcZh\YW]h]nYbfm"
flickr/ronald woan
H\]gghiXmYld`cfYgW]hmdUf_WcbgYfjUbW]YgZfcaU``g]XYg ig]b[fYU`!`]ZYbX]b[gUbX
YldYf]YbWYgZfca(%cf[Ub]nUh]cbgh\Uh\UjYUWc``YWh]jYYldYf]YbWYfYWcfXcZbYUf`m
+)$mYUfg"
Schenley Plaza, a key entranceway to Pittsburghs central Schenley Park, is an emblem of the
power and promise of conservancies. The neglected plaza, which had devolved into a parking lot
for 60 years, was redesigned and reconstructed by the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy and is now
the social and environmental centerpiece of its neighborhood.
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
flickr/detroit riverfront
7cbgYfjUbW]Yg[YbYfU``m\UjY`Uf[YVcUfXgUbXgaU``ghUZZg"6cUfXg]nYfYYWhgh\YX]jYfg]hm
cZdUf_Wcbgh]hiYbW]YgUgkY``Ugh\YbYYXZcfVfcUXbUbW]U`fYUW\"GhUZZ[YbYfU``mZcWigYgcb
cihfYUW\ ZibXfU]g]b[ UbXWcbhfUWhcfaUbU[YaYbh k]h\cb`mh\YjYfm`Uf[YghWcbgYfjUbW]Yg
\]f]b[g][b]WUbhbiaVYfgcZaU]bhYbUbWYUbXdfc[fUakcf_Yfg"
Rivard Plaza, a notable stimulus to the revitalization of downtown Detroit, is operated and
supported by the Detroit Riverfront Conservancy, one of two private institutions partnering with
the government to support parks in the city.
6
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
Friends of the Park groups. These generally all-volunteer groups focus on hands-on
cleanup and grassroots advocacy. Depending on the circumstance, a friends
organization may lobby in favor of a park department or criticize it. Either way, the
focus is on improved government services, not private philanthropy. In a few cities,
these individual park groups are so numerous they have spawned an umbrella organization, with paid staff, that works on park issues citywide. Such advocacy groups may
also go by other names, for example New Yorkers for Parks, the Philadelphia Park
Alliance, the San Francisco Park Alliance, and Park Pride, in Atlanta.
Business Improvement Districts (BIDs). These support organizations for core commercial districts are multiplying quickly, to well over 1,000 nationwide. Funded through
a small surtax assessment on district property owners, BIDs typically manage sidewalk
cleanliness, help visitors and enforce orderliness. Only a few districts have thus far
taken on park issues and improvements within their boundaries. Unlike conservancies,
BIDs generally do not solicit or receive philanthropic donations.
Most Conservancies in California. Confusingly, the state of California uses the word
Conservancy to designate a certain type of state agency. These include the Santa
Monica Mountains Conservancy, the Tahoe Conservancy, the California Coastal
Conservancy, and others. Generally, these agencies work within their landscapes to
meet environmental and other goals. However, the word is also used in California to
refer to a few private nonprofit organizations similar to those discussed in this booklet
for example, the Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy.
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
`cVVm]b[k]h\cihUjU]`"Ch\YfgdfcdcgYXdf]jUhYZibXfU]g]b["=b%-+, bYk`m!Y`YWhYXAUmcf
9X?cW\UbXdUf_gWcaa]gg]cbYf;cfXcb8Uj]gWfYUhYXh\Ydcg]h]cbcZ7YbhfU`DUf_
UXa]b]ghfUhcf W\Uf[YXk]h\gidYfj]g]b[bchcb`mdUf_cdYfUh]cbgUbXaU]bhYbUbWYVihU`gc
Wcaaib]hmYb[U[YaYbhUbXdUf_fYghcfUh]cb]bWc``UVcfUh]cbk]h\h\Ydf]jUhYgYWhcf"6Yhgm
6Uf`ckFc[Yfg UW]hmd`UbbYfUbXC`aghYXgW\c`Uf [chh\Y^cVUbXkUggccbkYUf]b[hkc
\Uhg.7YbhfU`DUf_UXa]b]ghfUhcfUbX7YbhfU`DUf_7cbgYfjUbWmdfYg]XYbh"H\]gibdfYW!
YXYbhYXgc`ih]cb`UibW\YXFc[Yfg]bhcibW\UfhYXkUhYfg"5gUXa]b]ghfUhcf g\YkUgUW]j]`
gYfjUbhk\caUbU[YXh\YdUf_ cjYfgUkib]cb]nYXW]hmkcf_Yfg gYhUbXWUff]YXcihdc`]W]Yg
UbXfYdcfhYXhch\YDUf_g7caa]gg]cbYfUbXi`h]aUhY`mh\YaUmcf"5gWcbgYfjUbWm
dfYg]XYbh g\YX]fYWhYXgdYW]U`!dfc^YWhZibXfU]g]b[ `YXUdiV`]W]hmUbXcihfYUW\WUadU][b
cjYfgUkbcbib]cbYad`cmYYg UbXfYdcfhYXhch\Y[fcidgW\U]faUbUbXi`h]aUhY`m]hg
VcUfX"K\]`Yh\Yhkcfc`YgkYfYgdY``YXcih]bkf]h]b[ h\Y^cVXYaUbXYX\][\`YjY`g
cZUXUdhUV]`]hm dc`]h]WU`gYbg]h]j]hm UbXdYfgcbU`Wcaaib]WUh]cbg_]``gfUh\Yfh\UbU
Vm!h\Y!Vcc_VifYUiWfUh]WUddfcUW\"
Fc[YfgghUfhYXVmfYbcjUh]b[h\Y%,+$8U]fmWchhU[Y]bhcUj]g]hcfWYbhYf UfY`Uh]jY`mgaU``
dfc^YWhhchYghUbXXYacbghfUhYWUdUV]`]h]YgUbXVi]`Xhfigh"5hfgh h\YdUf_gXYdUfhaYbh
gidd`]YXhkc!h\]fXgcZh\YZibX]b[UbXacghcZh\YghUZZ VihUghf]b[cZgiWWYggZi`fYghcfUh]cbg
`YXhcU[fck]b[fcghYfcZdf]jUhYXcbUh]cbgUbXYjYf!V][[Yfdfc^YWhg"6m%--, h\YWcbgYf!
jUbWm\UXfU]gYXacfYh\Ub%$$a]``]cb]bXcbUh]cbg/]hkUgZibX]b[hkc!h\]fXgcZh\YdUf_g
ViX[YhUbX+$dYfWYbhcZ]hgghUZZ"H\UhmYUf ]hbY[ch]UhYXU`cb[!hYfaWcbhfUWhk]h\h\YW]hm
hcaUbU[Yh\YdUf_"G]bWYh\Yb h\YZibX]b[VU`UbWY\Ugg\]ZhYXYjYbZifh\Yf k]h\h\YWcbgYf!
jUbWmYad`cm]b[-)dYfWYbhcZh\YdUf_gaU]bhYbUbWYghUZZUbXWcjYf]b[+)dYfWYbhcZ]hg
ViX[Yh"H\YW]hmWcbh]biYghcckbh\Y`UbX dfcj]XYU``h\YgYWif]hm]bW`iX]b[U%$$!dYfgcb
Dc`]WY8YdUfhaYbhdfYW]bWh ZibXh\Y7YbhfU`DUf_NccUbXU``h\Y`][\h]b[UbXdckYf
dfcj]XYdc`]WmcjYfg][\h UbXdUfhbYf]bd`Ubb]b[XYW]g]cbg Vihh\YWcbgYfjUbWm\Ugh\Ydf]aY
fc`Y]bdUf_aUbU[YaYbh j]g]hcfdfc[fUa]b[ UbXd`Ubb]b["
6mh\Y`UhY,$g h\Y7YbhfU`DUf_7cbgYfjUbWmggiWWYggYg\UX]bgd]fYXUg]a]`UfYZZcfh]b
6fcc_`mbgDfcgdYWhDUf_ Ubch\YfC`aghYXUbXJUil[Yah\Uh\UXWcaYW`cgYhc\]hh]b[fcW_
Vchhca"K]h\]bhkcXYWUXYg h\YWcbWYdhkUgUXcdhYXZcfacfYh\UbUXcnYbdUf_g
]bh\Y6][5dd`Y"AcfYgch\Ub]bUbmch\YfW]hm BYkMcf_\Ugih]`]nYXWcbgYfjUbW]YgUgU
ghUbXUfXZcf`Uf[Ycf\][\!dfc`YdUf_g"H\Y]adfcjYaYbhcZh\cgYdUf_g\UgdUfU``Y`YXUbX
gcaYkci`XgUm \Y`dYXgdUf_BYkMcf_gfYgif[YbWY"
6YWUigYcZBYkMcf_gWi`hifU`UbXaYX]Udfca]bYbWYUbXh\YZUWhh\Uh7YbhfU`DUf_fYWY]jYg
hYbgcZa]``]cbgcZj]g]hcfgUmYUf bYkgcZh\YWcbgYfjUbWmUddfcUW\gdfYUX"Acgh`YUXYfg
Zfcach\YfW]h]YgfYWc[b]nYXh\Uhh\YgWU`YcZh\Y7YbhfU`DUf_7cbgYfjUbWmkUgbchdcgg]V`Y
hcYai`UhY VihaUbmkYfYWUdh]jUhYXVmh\YWcbWYdhUbXghUfhYXhch\]b_UVcihhfm]b[gcaY!
h\]b[g]a]`Uf"6mh\YYUf`m&$%$g dUf_giddcfhYfg]bacfYh\UbUgWcfYcZI"G"W]h]Yg\UX
`UibW\YXWcbgYfjUbW]YgUbXkYfYVig]`mfU]g]b[UbXgdYbX]b[acbYm"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
5hUVcihh\YgUaYh]aYUgh\Y`UibW\]b[cZh\Y7YbhfU`DUf_7cbgYfjUbWm UdUfU``Y`YZZcfh
kUg[Yhh]b[ibXYfkUmcbh\YkYghWcUgh"9ghUV`]g\YX]b%-,% h\Y;c`XYb;UhYBUh]cbU`DUf_
5ggcW]Uh]cb]hW\Ub[YXhcWcbgYfjUbWm]b&$$'kUgZcfaYXhcdfchYWhh\YifVUbUbX
giVifVUbdUf_`UbXgh\UhWcadf]gYh\Y;c`XYb;UhYBUh]cbU`FYWfYUh]cb5fYU"=bh\YmYUfg
g]bWY ]h\UgZibXYXWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhgUbXfYbcjUh]cbgUh'+g]hYg]bGUb:fUbW]gWcUbXhkc
UX^UWYbhWcibh]Yg"H\Yacghdfca]bYbhcZh\YgY]g7f]ggm:]Y`X UZcfaYfU]fY`Xcbh\YGUb
:fUbW]gWckUhYfZfcbhh\UhcdYbYXUgU'(")!a]``]cb %$$!UWfYdiV`]WdUf_]b&$$%"
=bUXX]h]cbhcWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhg h\Y;c`XYb;UhYBUh]cbU`DUf_7cbgYfjUbWmVi]`XgWcfY
[fcidgcZjc`ibhYYfghYkUfXg fYghcfYgYWc`c[]WU``mgYbg]h]jY\UV]hUhg dfcdU[UhYgd`UbhgZcf
\UV]hUhfYghcfUh]cb UbXacb]hcfgk]`X`]ZY"=b&$%' ') $$$WcbgYfjUbWmjc`ibhYYfgXcbUhYX
acfYh\Ub)$$ $$$\cifgcZgYfj]WY"H\YWcbgYfjUbWmU`gcVi]`XghfU]`g cdYfUhYgVcc_ghcfYg
fibghcifg WfYUhYgg][bU[Y UbXUXjcWUhYgZcfbUh]cbU`dUf_ZibX]b["<ckYjYf g]bWYZYkW]h]Yg
\UjY`Uf[YbUhifU`bUh]cbU`dUf_g]bg]XYh\Y]fVcfXYfg h\]gacXY`]g`YgghfUbgZYfUV`Yhcch\Yf
ifVUb`cWUh]cbg"Cb`mU\UbXZi`cZW]h]YgWUbdchYbh]U``mVYbYhZfcaUg]a]`Uf_]bXcZWcbgYf!
jUbWmZcfh\Y]fZYXYfU`dUf_`UbX":cfh\YfYgh h\YacfYfY`YjUbhacXY`WcaYgZfcaBYkMcf_"
This figure does not include San Franciscos $33-million-per-year Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy because the vast
bulk of that park is located outside of the city limits.
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
ca s e st u dy
flickr/gobucks2
8Ygd]hYU[fcibXgkY``cZgiddcfhZcfh\YbUgWYbhWcbgYfjUbWm ]hgdUh\kUgbch
YghUV`]g\YXYUg]`m":cfYghDUf_kUg`cjYXVmU``VihbchU`kUmgZcfh\YgUaYfYUgcbg gUmg
ZcfaYf:cfYghDUf_:cfYjYfdfYg]XYbh>]aAUbb"GcaYkcfg\]ddYXh\YdUf_UgUbUhifU`
gUbWhiUfm gcaYZcf]hgUWh]jYfYWfYUh]cbcddcfhib]h]Yg UbXgcaYZcf]hgUVibXUbhWi`hifU`
cZZYf]b[g"GcaY[fcidgkUbhYXacfYZUW]`]h]Yg ch\YfgkUbhYXVi]`X]b[gXYac`]g\YX"5g
Zcfh\YWUfdfcV`Ya h\YfYkUgYfWYkfUb[`]b[cjYfk\Yh\Yfh\YdUf_g\ci`XcZZYf
acfYdUf_]b[ cf`Ygg"K\]`Ydf]jUhYXcbcfgkUbhYXhc\Y`d acghZY`hh\Uhh\YW]hmbYYXYX
hcVYUfUdcfh]cbcZh\YVifXYb"6ihW]hmhUldUmYfg\UXghiVVcfb`mhifbYXXckbYjYfm
dfcdcgYXWUd]hU`VcbX]b]h]Uh]jYZcfdUf_gg]bWY%-),"
10
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
IbXYfh\YghfU]bcZeiUffY`]b[igYf[fcidg h\YUhhYadhhcXYjY`cdUaUghYfd`UbZcf
:cfYghDUf_ZU]`YX UbXZcfh\YgYjYbmYUfgZc``ck]b[h\YWcbgYfjUbWmgZcibX]b[cb`m
YaYf[YbWmfYdU]fg\Y`Xh\YdUf_hc[Yh\Yf":]bU``m]b%--' ibXYfh\YdfcXX]b[cZbYk`m
Y`YWhYXAUmcf:fYYaUb6cg`Ym >f" Gh"@ci]gjchYfgdUggYXU\U`Z!WYbhgU`YghUlhcbUbWY
W]hm!k]XYWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhg cZk\]W\dUf_gkYfYU``chhYX%+a]``]cb"=hkUgbhaiW\
acbYm Vih:cfYghDUf_:cfYjYfgiWWYggZi``migYX]hhcg][bU`h\YdiV`]WgWcaa]haYbhhc
h\YVig]bYggYghUV`]g\aYbh"
6i]`X]b[cbh\YacaYbhia AUmcf6cg`YmWU``YXZcfUbU[fYYaYbhcbUbYk:cfYghDUf_
aUghYfd`Ub UbXdU]bghU_]b[bY[ch]Uh]cbgbU``mib]YXh\YkUff]b[ZUWh]cbg"H\Y_Ym
VfYU_h\fci[\kUgWcbWiffYbWYcbUdc`]WmcZbcbYh`cggcZdUf_`UbXhcUihcacV]`Ygcf
Vi]`X]b[g.UbmbYk]adYfaYUV`YgifZUWYkci`X\UjYhcVYWcadYbgUhYXVmUbYei]jU`Ybh
UfYUcZXY!dUj]b[Y`gYk\YfY"
5ggccbUgh\YaUghYfd`UbkUgUddfcjYX]b%--) :cfYghDUf_:cfYjYfUbXh\YW]hm
`UibW\YXUbUaV]h]cigWUadU][bh\YmWU``YXFYghcf]b[h\Y;`cfm"H\YW]hmWcaa]hhYX
('a]``]cbcZdiV`]WZibXg k\]W\:D:d`YX[YXhcaUhW\]bdf]jUhY[]Zhg"H\YhUf[Yh
XUhYhcWcad`YhYh\YfYghcfUh]cbkUggYhZcf&$$( h\Y\ibXfYXh\Ubb]jYfgUfmcZh\Y
AYYhAY]bGh"@ci]gKcf`Xg:U]fUbXh\Y&$$h\Ubb]jYfgUfmcZh\Y@ci]gUbX7`Uf_
YldYX]h]cb"HcUW\]YjYh\Y[cU` h\YW]hmYbUWhYXUcbY!Y][\h\!WYbhgU`YghUl]bWfYUgY
UbX:cfYghDUf_:cfYjYf`UibW\YXUai`h]!`YjY`df]jUhYWUadU][bh\UhVfci[\h]b
XcbUh]cbgZfca& $$(dYbb]YgZfca[fUXYgW\cc`W`UggYgidhc&"$$(!a]``]cb[]ZhgZfca
WcfdcfUh]cbgUbXZcibXUh]cbg"CbYZibXfU]g]b[gh]ai`igkUgUd`YX[YVmh\Y8UbZcfh\
:cibXUh]cbhcaUhW\U``Wcbhf]Vih]cbgaUXYVmaYX]ia!g]nYXVig]bYggYg"H\Y
WUadU][b\Ugg]bWYZUfgifdUggYX]hg[cU`"
H\YaUghYfd`Ub]gcjYfgYYbVmU&)!aYaVYf:cfYghDUf_5Xj]gcfm6cUfX Uddc]bhYX
Vmh\YaUmcf k\]W\fYdcfhghch\YX]fYWhcfcZh\Y8YdUfhaYbhcZDUf_g FYWfYUh]cb
UbX:cfYghfm"H\YW]hmfYhU]bgi`h]aUhYUih\cf]hmcjYfh\YdUf_ VihfYgdcbg]V]`]h]Yg\UjY
[fUXiU``mckYXhch\YWcbgYfjUbWm"IbXYfh\Y%--+U[fYYaYbh h\YW]hmkUghccjYfgYY
WUd]hU`dfc^YWhgk\]`Y:cfYghDUf_:cfYjYfkUghcfU]gYh\YacbYmZcfh\Ya"<ckYjYf
fYbcjUh]cbgZY``VY\]bXgW\YXi`Y UbX]b&$$&h\YWcbgYfjUbWmkUgUih\cf]nYXhcaUbU[Y
WcbghfiWh]cb"DUf_aU]bhYbUbWYZc``ckYXUg]a]`UfdUh\ UbX:cfYghDUf_:cfYjYf]gbck
]bWfYUg]b[`m]bjc`jYX]bXUm!hc!XUmcdYfUh]cbg"
DUm]b[ZcfaU]bhYbUbWY]gUbcb[c]b[W\U``Yb[Y gc]b&$%&h\YdUfhbYfg`UibW\YXU
%'$!a]``]cb^c]bh]b]h]Uh]jYhcYldUbXh\Y:cfYghDUf_:cfYjYfYbXckaYbh k]h\'$
a]``]cbZfcabYkW]hmVcbXgUbX%$$a]``]cbZfcadf]jUhYacbYm"H\YVcbXfYWY]dhg
UfYX]fYWhYX]bhcUbUWWcibhh\UhWUbVYigYXcb`mk]h\h\YUddfcjU`cZVch\:cfYghDUf_
:cfYjYfUbXh\YW]hm"H\Y]b]h]Uh]jYgUfYdfc^YWhYXhc]bWfYUgYUbbiU`dUf_ZibX]b[Zfca
%$a]``]cbhc%)a]``]cbk]h\]bUXYWUXY"H\YdUfhbYfg\]dk]h\h\YW]hmU`gc]bW`iXYg
U'$!mYUfU[fYYaYbhhcg\UfYXYW]g]cb!aU_]b["H\YW]hm]gbckfYgdcbg]V`YZcfgbck
fYacjU` hfUg\Wc``YWh]cb UbXVi]`X]b[UbXg]XYkU`_fYdU]f k\]`Y:D:\UbX`Ygack]b[
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
11
375
1876
Park created
1986
Conservancy founded
$3,926,486
$12,998,911
92%
Expenditures*
Revenue*
Contributions and grants as portion of total revenue*
1%
51
Employees
1,100
Volunteers
38
5 officers, 12-member
executive committee,
18 general directors,
10 ex-officio**
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
12
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
13
T H E E X P E R I E N C E S O FA R
w h e n pa r ks a nd th e ir support orga ni zati ons w e re founde d
City
Conservancy
Park Created
Conservancy
Founded
Atlanta
1850
1984
Atlanta
1887
1989
Atlanta
1883
1999
Atlanta
1938
2004
Baltimore
1829
2008
Birmingham
2010
2008
Boston
1879
1997
Boston
1634
2000*
Boston
2007
2004
Buffalo
1870
1995
Dallas
1886
1986
Dallas
2012
2004
Denver
1894
2004
Detroit
1847
2001
Detroit
1975
2002
Hartford
1854
1981
Houston
1899
1986
Houston
1925
2000
Houston
2008
2004
Houston
1914
2004*
Louisville
1880
1989
Memphis
1975
2007
Memphis
1901
2011
New York
1858
1980
New York
1872
1986
New York
1868
1987
New York
1984
1987
New York
1933
1992
New York
1823
1994
New York
2003
1999
New York
2009
2000
New York
1847
2002
New York
2010
2005*
Oklahoma City
1981
2011*
Philadelphia
1855
2001
Pittsburgh
1889
1996
Portland
1947
1989
San Antonio
1899
2008
San Jose
1990
1995
St. Louis
1876
1986
Washington, D.C.
1791
2002
14
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
WcbgYfjUbW]YgUbXW]h]YgWUbVc`ghYfYUW\ch\Yf dfcach]b[UbYei]`]Vf]iah\UhYjYbgcihh\Y
dYU_gUbXjU``YmgcZVch\[cjYfbaYbhUbXdf]jUhYgYWhcfjUf]UV]`]hm"
H\ig hc\Y`dWcbgYfjUbW]YgVYUggiWWYggZi`Ugdcgg]V`Y UbXhcUjc]XWf]h]WU`d]hZU``g kY\UjY
W`cgY`mghiX]YXk\UhaU_Ygh\YagiWWYYXcfZU]`"H\]gVcc_`YhX]gh]``gUgYhcZ`YggcbgUbXVYgh
dfUWh]WYgZcfh\YY`X"
15
ca se study
flickr/clinton steeds
6ih]hkUgbhYbci[\ gc]b%-,(U[fcidcZA]XhckbW]h]nYbgZcfaYX:f]YbXgcZ
D]YXacbhDUf_hcdfcachYgaU``!gWU`Yjc`ibhYYfUbXUXjcWUWmYZZcfhg"CjYfjYmYUfg
16
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
h\YZf]YbXg[fcidUXXYXVig]bYggUbXWcaaib]hm`YUXYfghc]hgaYaVYfg\]dUbX
fYcf[Ub]nYXUgh\YD]YXacbhDUf_7cbgYfjUbWm"H\YfYcf[Ub]nUh]cbkUg]bhYbXYXhc
id[fUXYUacXYghg\U_Yf]bhcUaU^cfacjYf VihaihiU`X]ghfighk]h\h\YW]hm\UadYfYX
h\UhYjc`ih]cb UbXh\YWcbgYfjUbWmghfi[[`YXhc[YhUZcch\c`X
KYXYVUhYXk]h\h\YW]hmk\Yh\YfkYWci`XYl]gh k\Yh\YfkYWci`XhU_Yh\YdUf_cjYf
UbXk\UhkYX\UjYhcXcZcfh\YW]hm]bcfXYfhcfibUbXfYbcjUhYh\YdUf_cbcifckb
gUmgA]_YGYafUi h\YWcbgYfjUbWmgZcibX]b[VcUfXW\U]f"H\YfYZc``ckYXgYjYfU`mYUfg
cZbY[ch]Uh]cbVYZcfYUbU[fYYaYbhkUgbU``mfYUW\YX]b%--&"9jYbh\Yb g_Ydh]W]gacZ
h\YbYkcf[Ub]nUh]cbfUb\][\ ]bdUfhVYWUigYh\YWcaaib]hmkUggh]``V]hhYfh\UhYUf`]Yf
aUghYfd`Ubg\UXWU``YXZcffYdifdcg]b[dUf_`UbXZcfch\YfigYg"9Uf`maYYh]b[gfY[i`Uf`m
Wc``UdgYX]bhcgWfYUa]b[aUhW\Yg"
KYbYYXYXhccjYfWcaY[fYUhX]ghfighVYWUigYZc`_g]bh\YbY][\Vcf\ccXUggcW]UhYX
igk]h\YUf`]Yfh\fYUhghch\YdUf_ fYWU``YX8YVV]YAW7ckb UbYUf`mdfYg]XYbhcZ
h\YWcbgYfjUbWm"HcVi]`XfUddcfh h\YWcbgYfjUbWmWfYUhYXU)$!aYaVYfWcaaib]hm
UXj]gcfmVcUfXhcjYhdfc^YWhgUbXUXXfYggdUf_igYfgWcbWYfbg"5hh\YgUaYh]aY \Uj]b[
Yl!cZW]cVcUfXaYaVYfgZUW]`]hUhYXVYhhYfWcaaib]WUh]cbk]h\h\YaUmcf W]hmWcibW]`
UbXdUf_gXYdUfhaYbh":]bU``m]b%--)g]lmYUfgUZhYfh\YWcbgYfjUbWmg]bWcfdcfUh]cb
h\YdUfhbYfgUddfcjYXUbYkD]YXacbhDUf_AUghYfD`Ub W`YUf]b[h\YkUmZcfgYf]cig
ZibXfU]g]b["
H\YD]YXacbhDUf_7cbgYfjUbWmg]b]h]U`%")a]``]cbWUd]hU`WUadU][bZcWigYXcb
h\YacfY\YUj]`mj]g]hYXgcih\YbXcZh\YdUf_]adfcjYaYbhghcdiV`]WgUZYhm h\Y
fYghcfUh]cbcZ`UkbgUbXgaU``\]ghcf]WY`YaYbhg UXc[dUf_ UbXbYkdfc[fUaa]b["
GiWWYgg]jYWUadU][bg[fYkXfUaUh]WU``m]bg]nYhc*a]``]cb h\Yb&)a]``]cbUbX
ZibXYXUbXaUbU[YXYlhYbg]jYfYghcfUh]cbcZ\]ghcf]WVi]`X]b[gUVcUh\cigY UaYYh]b[
\U``UbXUbYk]ff][Uh]cbgmghYa"H\YWcbgYfjUbWmU`gcXYg][bYXUbXVi]`hUbYk
Wcaaib]hmWYbhYf"AcghWcbhfcjYfg]U` dfcadh]b[dfchfUWhYXXYVUhY kUgUbYk\]``g]XY
UihcacV]`Y[UfU[YZcfh\Y5h`UbhU6chUb]WU`;UfXYbVU`UbWYXVmh\YWcbWca]hUbh
W`cg]b[cZUgifZUWYdUf_]b[`ch]bh\YWYbhYfcZh\YdUf_"H\YWcbgYfjUbWmghYYfYXh\Y
WcbjYfgUh]cbcbh\Uhdfc^YWhhcUddfcjU`UbXh\YbaUbU[YXWcbghfiWh]cb"
G]bWY%--)h\YD]YXacbhDUf_7cbgYfjUbWm\UgVYWcaYU`Yj]Uh\Ub"=h]ad`YaYbhgh\Y
dUf_gaUghYfd`Ub cjYfgYYgU``UgdYWhgcZWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhg UbXZibXgUbXYlYWihYg
UVcih,)dYfWYbhcZXU]`maU]bhYbUbWY"CZD]YXacbhDUf_gUddfcl]aUhY`m'!a]``]cb
UbbiU`cdYfUh]b[ViX[Yh h\YW]hmcZ5h`UbhUWiffYbh`mWcbhf]VihYgcb`m%+) $$$ Xckb
ZfcaUVcih($$ $$$]b%--&"H\Ycf[Ub]nUh]cbfibgcbUa]lcZfYjYbiY fci[\`m($
dYfWYbhYUfbYXUbX*$dYfWYbhXcbUhYX"H\YWcbgYfjUbWm\UgjYZUW]`]hmaUbU[YaYbh
U[fYYaYbhgk]h\dfchg[c]b[hckUfXdUf_aU]bhYbUbWY"
K\YbmcihU_YcbUaUghYfd`Ubh\Uh[fckgh\YdUf_ mci\UjYhc[ifYcihbYkkUmghc
aUbU[Yid_YYd ZcfaYfWcbgYfjUbWm79CMjYhhY6ckXYbhc`X7]hmDUf_g6`c[]b&$%'"
=bh\]gYWcbcam mci\UjYhcVYb]aV`Yk]h\mcifVig]bYggacXY` aU_]b[gifYmciWUb
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
17
hU_YWUfYcZYjYfmh\]b[mcicdYb"DUfhcZcifWcaa]haYbhhccifXcbcfg giddcfhYfg
UbXaYaVYfg]gh\UhkYfYbch[c]b[hchU_YcifYmYgcZZh\YaU]bhYbUbWYZUWhcf"
Acj]b[[fUXiU``mbcfh\h\fci[\h\YdUf_k]h\]hgfYbcjUh]cbg h\YD]YXacbhDUf_
7cbgYfjUbWm]gbckhUW_`]b[]hgV][[YghW\U``Yb[YXYg][b]b[Zcfh\YjYfmfghh]aY
)'UWfYgcZib_YadhkccX`UbXh\Uh\UXgUh][bcfYXZcfUWYbhifm"D\UgY= k\]W\Wcgh
('")a]``]cbUbXcdYbYX]b&$%' WcjYfYX(%UWfYgUbXUXXYXa]`YgcZhfU]`ghch\Y
dUf_ WcbjYfhYXU[fYYbkUghYXiad]bhcbYkVU``Y`Xg Zcf[YXUdUf_WcbbYWh]cb
hch\Y5h`UbhU6Y`h@]bY fYacjYX]bjUg]jYd`UbhgZfcaUh\fYY!UWfY\UfXkccXZcfYgh
UbXd`UbhYX% $$$hfYYg"D\UgY==k]``fYkcf_h\YfYaU]b]b[%&")UWfYg]bhcUkUhYf!
fYhYbh]cbUfYU Wcaaib]hm[UfXYb cihXccfW`Uggfcca UbXbYkd`Um[fcibX"
8Ygd]hY]hgaUbmgiWWYggYg h\YWcbgYfjUbWm]gbchWcad`YhY`mZfYYcZW\U``Yb[Yg"DiV`]W
gUZYhm h\ci[\jUgh`m]adfcjYX fYaU]bgUWcbWYfb UbXfYg]XYbhgkYfYfUhh`YX]b&$$-
VmUZUhU`ghUVV]b[bYUf@U_Y7`UfUAYYf"H\YW]hmUbXh\YWcbgYfjUbWm\UjYghYddYX
iddUhfc`g ]bghU``YXgYWif]hmWUaYfUg UbXfYj]g]hYXghfUhY[]Yghcgh]ai`UhYUWh]j]hm"BYk
WcbgYfjUbWm!ZibXYXgYWif]hmcZWYfgYbZcfWYh\Y%%d"a"*U"a"W`cgifY k\]W\\Ug
[fYUh`mfYXiWYXXfi[XYU`]b[ Wfi]g]b[ UbXg`YYd]b[cih]bh\YdUf_"
Pi e dm ont Pa rk Conse rva nc y
185 acres
Park size
1887
Park created
1989
Conservancy founded
$11,608,365
$6,678,384
88%
Expenditures*
Revenue*
Contributions and grants as portion of total revenue*
6%
51
Employees
2,924
Volunteers
48
9 officers, 6 at-large,
28 general directors,
5 ex-officio**
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
18
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
H\YACI]gigiU``m_YmhcUWcbgYfjUbWmgUV]`]hmhcfU]gYZibXg"8cbcfgaighVYWcbj]bWYX
h\Uhh\Y]f]bjYghaYbh]bh\YW]hmgdfcdYfhmk]``VYdfchYWhYX h\Uhh\Ydfc^YWhk]``VYYZZYWh]jY`m
aUbU[YX UbXh\Uh[cjYfbaYbhk]``bchkU`_UkUmZfca]hgfYgdcbg]V]`]h]YgUZhYfh\Ydfc^YWh]g
Wcad`YhYX":cfh\YdiV`]WdUfhbYf h\YU[fYYaYbhUggifYg]hgfc`Y]bd`Ubb]b[UbXdc`]WmcjYf!
g][\hcb\][\!j]g]V]`]hm]ggiYgZfcabUa]b[dfchcWc`ghcWcbWYgg]cbghcdf]jUhYYjYbhg"H\YW]hm
aigh\UjYi`h]aUhYUih\cf]hmUbXaighVYfYgdYWhYXZcfh\UhUih\cf]hm gUmg6YhgmGa]h\"Mci
WUbh\UjYUWcbgYfjUbWm[fcidh\UhXcYgbhkUbhUbmh\]b[hcXck]h\h\YW]hm"
H\YgYUfYbchgaU``]ggiYg YgdYW]U``m]Z`Uf[YY[cgUfY]bjc`jYX"=baUbmWUgYg [Yhh]b[U
g][bYXaYacfUbXia\UghU_YbUmYUfcfacfY/]bcbYWUgY]hhcc_gYjYbmYUfgUbXUW\Ub[Y
cZUXa]b]ghfUh]cb]bh\YaUmcfgcZWY"
H\YYX[`]b[WcbgYfjUbWmaUmVYhYadhYXhcUjc]Xdc`]h]WU`ghf]ZYVmdihh]b[cZZZcfaU`
bY[ch]Uh]cbgk]h\]hgdiV`]WdUfhbYf"6iha]bcfX]gdihYg]bh\YfY`Uh]jYdYUWYcZh\YWcbZYfYbWY
fccaWUbhifb]bhcaU^cfcVghUW`Yg]ZUdfc^YWhacjYgZcfkUfXk]h\cihUbU[fYYaYbh"<Uj]b[
UbUWWcfX]bd`UWYViZZYfgh\YdUfhbYfg\]dZfcadfYggifYg[YbYfUhYXVmUbUbW]U`Xckbhifb
cfUWcbhYbh]cigaib]W]dU`Y`YWh]cb"H\YacfYghU_Y\c`XYfgUdUf_\UgWi`hifU`]bgh]hih]cbg
UXjcWUWm[fcidg bY][\Vcf\ccXUggcW]Uh]cbgh\YacfY]adcfhUbhUg][bYXU[fYYaYbh]g"
AcfYcjYf h\UhcjYfUfW\]b[U[fYYaYbh]gbchYei]jU`YbhhcUgYf]YgcZdfc^YWh!Vm!dfc^YWh
WcbhfUWhg"BccbYg]bW\Uf[YUbXYjYfmcbYg]bW\Uf[Y bcVcXmckbgh\YdUf_UbXYjYfmVcXm
ckbgh\YdUf_ gUmgcbYcVgYfjYfUVcihUdUfhbYfg\]dh\Uh\UgfY`]YXcb]bhYf]aU[fYYaYbhg"
=bh\Uh]bghUbWY dc`]h]WU`[f]X`cW_\UgZfighfUhYXh\YWcbgYfjUbWmgUhhYadhghcg][bUVfcUX
ACI UbXUkYU_VcUfXcZX]fYWhcfg\Ug`UW_YXh\YW`cihhcZcfWYUfYgc`ih]cb"H\YWcbgYf!
jUbWm k\]W\kUbhghcgYfjYUgUbiaVfY``Ucf[Ub]nUh]cbZcfh\YdUf_fUh\Yfh\UbUgUbch\Yf
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
19
]bhYfYgh[fcid^cW_Ym]b[Zcfdcg]h]cb ]gUbl]cighchU_Ycb[fUXiU``macfYWcad`YlWUd]hU`
dfc^YWhg"6ihUZhYfmYUfgcZkcf_ ]h\UgVYYbibUV`Yhc[YhUbU[fYYaYbhibXYfk\]W\]hWUb
cZZYfib]YXcjYfg][\h"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
H\Yhkcacgh]adcfhUbheiYgh]cbgUaUghYfd`UbUXXfYggYgUfY.k\Uhg\ci`XVYXcbY UbX
k\Yb"=ZUdUf_bYYXgUhhYbh]cbUWfcggaUbmUfYUg ]h]gYggYbh]U`h\Uhgc`ih]cbgVYdf]cf]!
h]nYX"AYad\]ggCjYfhcbDUf_7cbgYfjUbWmX]gWcjYfYXh\]g]b&$%%k\Ybh\Ymcib[[fcid
Ybh\ig]Ugh]WU``mXcjY]bhcUgYhcZdfc^YWhgVUgYXcbh\YdUf_gc`XaUghYfd`Ub"6ihibh]`]h
ghfUhY[]WU``mdf]cf]h]nYX]hghc!Xc`]gh h\YbYk[fcidggWUhhYfYXUaV]h]cbg`YZh]hibZcWigYX
UbXghfYhW\YXh\]b WcbghUbh`mgWfUaV`]b[hcZi```h\Yk]g\YgcZ]bX]j]XiU`VcUfXaYaVYfg"
5kY``!aUXYd`UbWUbU`gcZcfYghU``Wcb]WhgVYhkYYbh\YjYfmghU_Y\c`XYfgk\cZcf[YXh\Y
WcbgYfjUbWm]bh\Yfghd`UWY"H\YgY]bgh][UhcfgaUmVYUgX]jYfgYUgWcbgYfjUh]cb]ghg Wi`hifU`
`YUXYfg \]ghcf]WdfYgYfjUh]cb]ghg Xc[ckbYfg d`Um[fcibXUXjcWUhYg UbXbY][\Vcf\ccX
gdc_YgdYcd`YYUW\k]h\\]gcf\YfckbgYhcZdf]cf]h]Yg"FYWcbW]`]b[h\cgY]bhYfYghgXif]b[
h\Yd`Ubb]b[dfcWYggWUbVYUfXicigVihU`gcYadckYf]b[ gUmg>]aAUbb ZcfaYfX]fYWhcf
cZ:cfYghDUf_:cfYjYf h\YWcbgYfjUbWmZcfGh"@ci]gg:cfYghDUf_"BccbYkUbhYXhc[c
h\fci[\h\UhU[U]b \YgU]X gcYjYfmcbYWcaa]hhYXhch\YcjYfU``[cU`"
5aUghYfd`Ub]gU`gcUb]ffYd`UWYUV`Yhcc`k\Ybkcf_]b[k]h\Xcbcfg gUmg8cfYYbGhc``Yf
X]fYWhcfcZ<cighcbg<YfaUbbDUf_7cbgYfjUbWm"K\YbUfYeiYghWcaYgid h\Yd`UbcZZYfg
[i]XUbWYKYkcbhUWWYdh[]Zhgh\UhXcbhh]bhch\YaUghYfd`Ub g\YgU]X UbXkYXcbh`Yh
XcbcfgX]WhUhYh\Y`cc_UbXh\YZYY`cZh\YdUf_"
K\]`Y\Uj]b[UXmbUa]WW\]YZYlYWih]jY]gU[fYUhVYbYh ]h]gh\YWcbgYfjUbWmgVcUfXcZ
X]fYWhcfgh\Uh]gigiU``mh\YaU_Y!cf!VfYU_ZUWhcf]bgiWWYgg"6cUfXaYaVYfgaigh\Y`dk]h\
ZibXfU]g]b[ ghfUhY[]W[i]XUbWY UXjcWUWm dc`]h]WU`WcbbYWh]cbg UbXch\Yf_YmfYgcifWYg"
K\]`YUdUgg]cbUhYWcaa]haYbhhch\YdUf_]gU[]jYb ]h]gbhYbci[\"KYU`h\\Y`dg U`h\ci[\
Birminghams Railroad Park, the citys newest and most ambitious park, would not have come into
existence without a public-private partnership. The Railroad Park Foundation, which raised millions
in private donations, now manages the city-owned facility.
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
21
ca se study
5`h\ci[\h\YfYbYkU`cZ7YbhfU`DUf_\UgWUdhifYXacghcZh\Y`]aY`][\h DfcgdYWh
DUf_gfYV]fh\kUg]baUbmkUmgUbYeiU`giWWYggg]bWYh\YbY][\Vcf\ccX\Ug\UXZUf
ZYkYffYgcifWYghckcf_k]h\"
22
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
H\caUgg]b]h]U`W\U``Yb[YkUghcXfUkj]g]hcfghcUdUf_k]XY`mj]YkYXUgXUb[Yfcig"
CbYcZ\Yffghdfc^YWhgkUgfYZifV]g\]b[h\YWUfcigY`UbXXf]j]b[cih]hgfYg]XYbhXfi[
XYU`Yfg"H\Y5``]UbWYU`gccf[Ub]nYXgW]Ybh]WY`Xhf]dgZcfgW\cc`W\]`XfYbgcaYh]aYg
YgWcfhYXVmdc`]WYcZWYfgUhUhYUW\YfgfYeiYgh Ubh]W]dUh]b[h\UhghiXYbhgkci`X
fYhifbhch\YdUf_k]h\h\Y]fZUa]`]Yg]bhck"H\YghfUhY[mkcf_YX UbXZUa]`]Ygg`ck`m
VihgifY`mjYbhifYXVUW_]bhcDfcgdYWhDUf_"
:fcah\YghUfh h\YDfcgdYWhDUf_5``]UbWYkUgUV]hX]ZZYfYbhZfcach\YfWcbgYfjUbW]Yg
Ui[aYbh]b[ghUbXUfXZibXfU]g]b[k]h\Ug\chcZX]fYWhUXjcWUWm"5ZhYfh\Ycf[Ub]nUh]cb
gifjYmYXdUf_j]g]hcfghcbXcihk\YfY]b6fcc_`mbh\Ym`]jYX ]hh\YbigYXh\YXYhU]`g
hchUf[YhY`YWhYXcZW]U`gZfcah\YZUfWcfbYfgcZh\YVcfci[\aUbmcZk\ca\UXbh
fYU`]nYX\ckZUfh\Y]fWcbgh]hiYbhghfUjY`YXZcfUaU^cfdUf_YldYf]YbWY"
H\caUggYbhfYdfYbYif]U`UddfcUW\g\UdYXh\YU[fYYaYbhgh\Uhgh]``[i]XYh\Y
5``]UbWY"6iW_]b[h\YbcfaUacb[WcbgYfjUbW]Yg g\Y_Ydhh\]b[gbYVi`cig YjYb
fYg]gh]b[UZcfaU`aYacfUbXiacZibXYfghUbX]b[ZcfmYUfg"GiVgYeiYbhU[fYYaYbhg
cbWcbWYgg]cbg `]WYbg]b[ UbXgdYW]WWUd]hU`dfc^YWhg\UjYVYYbg][bYXcb`mUgbYYXYX"
<ckYjYf g]bWYH\caUggfYh]fYaYbh]b&$%% h\UhaUmVYW\Ub[]b[/bYkX]fYWhcfGiY
8cbc[\iYgUmgh\Ycf[Ub]nUh]cb]gfYYjU`iUh]b[h\Ya]lcZU[fYYaYbhghcWcbg]XYfU
acfYWcadfY\Ybg]jYXcWiaYbhh\UhfYYWhgh\Ygd]f]hcZh\YdUfhbYfg\]d"
5gZcfh\YaUghYfd`Ub UaUn]b[`m DfcgdYWhDUf_fY`]Ygcbh\Ycf][]bU`%,*$gXYg][b
dfcXiWYXVmC`aghYXUbXJUil"H\Uhj]g]cbkUggcghfcb[h\Uhh\Y5``]UbWYgdYf]cX]W
ghfUhY[]Wd`Ubg\UjYVYYbZcfai`UhYXaYfY`mhc]ad`YaYbh]hUbXhcibXcgcaYcZh\Y
XYg][bXUaU[YaUXYcjYfh\Y]bhYfjYb]b[mYUfg"AcghfYWYbh`m ]b&$%' h\Y5``]UbWY
fYd`UWYXUbc`Xg_Uh]b[f]b_k]h\h\YbYk@U_Yg]XY7YbhYf k\]W\cZZYfgk]bhYf]WY
g_Uh]b[ giaaYffc``Yfg_Uh]b[ UWUZ UbXfYghfccag"6Yg]XYgh\YbYkVi]`X]b[ h\Y
+*!a]``]cbdfc^YWhfYZifV]g\YX&*UWfYgcZh\YdUf_g`UbXgWUdY]bW`iX]b[fYVi]`h
hfU]`gUbXbYkdYXYghf]UbUWWYggdc]bhgUbXfYghcfYXC`aghYXUbXJUilgcf][]bU`
Aig]W=g`UbXUbXh\YbUhifU`g\cfY`]bYcZh\YdUf_g`U_Y"
CjYfh\YmYUfg DfcgdYWhDUf_5``]UbWY\Ugg\]ZhYX]hgdf]jUhYgdYbX]b[ZfcaWUd]hU`
dfc^YWhghcYjYfmXUmdUf_aU]bhYbUbWY"K]h\h\YW]hmgh]``UaU^cfZibX]b[gcifWYbck
cbh\YWUd]hU`g]XYfUh\Yfh\UbcdYfUh]b[g]XYh\Y5``]UbWYgViX[Yh\Ug[fckbZfca
&$$ $$$]b%-,+hccjYf%&a]``]cbhcXUm":ibX]b[]gdUfh`mh\fci[\d\]`Ubh\fcdm
dUfh`mZfca[cjYfbaYbhgcifWYg UbXdUfh`mh\fci[\fYjYbiYZfcaUWUfcigY` UdUXX`Y
VcUhWcbWYgg]cb h\Y\]ghcf]W@YZZYfhg<cigY UhYbb]gWYbhYf UbXgdcfhgY`Xgcbh\Y
dUfUXY[fcibX"
5acb[h\Ycb[c]b[W\U``Yb[YgZcfh\Y5``]UbWY\UgVYYb_YYd]b[idk]h\6fcc_`mbg
W\Ub[]b[XYac[fUd\]Wg"BY][\Vcf\ccXggiffcibX]b[h\YdUf_UfY\caYhcfYg]XYbhg
cZX]jYfgYYh\b]W[fcidg ]bWcaY`YjY`g UbXdfYZYffYXdUf_`UbXigYg"5`h\ci[\h\Y
dUf_gk]XY`mYai`UhYX7caaib]hm7caa]hhYY\Ug\Y`dYXbY[ch]UhYh\YgYWcb]Wh]b[
]bhYfYghg h\Y5``]UbWYaighdYf]cX]WU``mfYVU`UbWYh\YWcaa]hhYYhcYbgifYh\Uh]hgh]``
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
23
hU_Ygh\Ydi`gYcZgiffcibX]b[dcdi`Uh]cbg"5W\]Yj]b[X]jYfg]hmcbh\Y5``]UbWYgVcUfXcZ
X]fYWhcfg]gU`gc]adcfhUbh bchYg7\U]fkcaUb=f]gKY]bg\U``"H\YbY][\Vcf\ccXg\UjY
W\Ub[YXUbXh\YWUhW\aYbhUfYUZcfh\YdUf_\UgW\Ub[YX gckYbYYXhcaU_Yh\YVcUfX
acfYmcib[ j]VfUbh UbXfYYWh]jYcZcifWcaaib]hm"
Prospect Park A l l i a nc e
585 acres
Park size
1868
Park created
1987
Conservancy founded
$11,698,228
$9,996,987
Expenditures*
Revenue*
60%
40%
308
Employees
3,400
Volunteers
34
4-member executive
committee, 29 directors,
3 ex-officio**
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
24
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
UWh]j]ghgcZacXYghaYUbgaUmU`gcaU_YYlWY``YbhVcUfXaYaVYfg"9UW\cbYbYYXgU`gchc
Wcaa]hhcfYU`dfcV`Ya!gc`j]b[cZcbYgcfhcfUbch\Yfh\fci[\bUbW]U`[YbYfcg]hm hYW\b]WU`
YldYfh]gY Wcaaib]WUh]cbUV]`]hm Wcbgh]hiYbWmach]jUh]cb cfch\Yfg_]``g"G]bWYgcaYVcUfX
gYUhgUfYWcaacb`m``YXVmSf]TQW]aYaVYfgdUf_U[YbWmUbX[cjYfbaYbhfYdfYgYbhU!
h]jYgh\YfYaU]b]b[d`UWYgaighVY``YXghfUhY[]WU``m"
Aib]W]dU`cZW]U`gXcbch\UjYjch]b[dckYfcbacghWcbgYfjUbWmVcUfXgVihh\YmfYhU]b
i`h]aUhYckbYfg\]dUbXUih\cf]hmcjYfh\YdUf_"=bdfUWh]WY h\]gaYUbgh\Uhh\YW]hmaighg][b
cZZcbh\YUWh]j]h]YgcZh\YWcbgYfjUbWm"=bh\YWUgYcZ:cfYghDUf_]bGh"@ci]g U&)!aYaVYf
:cfYghDUf_5Xj]gcfm6cUfX Uddc]bhYXVmh\YaUmcfUbXgYdUfUhYZfcah\YWcbgYfjUbWm
VcUfX cjYfgYYgdUf_dc`]W]YgUbX]ad`YaYbhUh]cbcZh\YaUghYfd`Ub"
K\YbUWcbgYfjUbWmdi``gcZZUgYYa]b[`m]adcgg]V`YZYUh`UbX]b[Ua]``]cb!Xc``UfW\YW_
[Yhh]b[UaU^cfUddfcdf]Uh]cbZfcaKUg\]b[hcbcfh\YghUhYWUd]hU` gWcf]b[df]aY!h]aY
WcjYfU[YcbbUh]cbU`HJ VY]b[bUaYXUdUfhbYfVmU[]UbhWcfdcfUh]cb]hgigiU``mUVcUfX
aYaVYfk\caU_Yg]h\UddYb"5g8YVV]YAW7ckb ZcfaYfX]fYWhcfcZh\YD]YXacbhDUf_
7cbgYfjUbWm bchYX.=WUbhd]W_idh\Yd\cbYUbX[Yhhch\YaUmcf VihamVcUfXaYaVYfg
WUbUbXXc"
5W\]Yj]b[h\YdYfZYWhVcUfX]gbhYUgm"Ig]b[cb`mh\YGcW]U`FY[]ghYfhcVi]`XUVcUfXWcifhg
X]ghfigh ]Zbch\cgh]`]hm Zfcah\cgYk\cVY`]YjYh\Y]fVY`cjYXdUf_k]``VYhU_YbUkUmZfca
h\Ya cbYZUbWmkYXX]b[fYWYdh]cbcfYlW`ig]jYdUfhmUhUh]aY"Cbh\Ych\Yf\UbX UVcUfX
dcdi`UhYXgc`Y`mk]h\h]aY!hYghYXUWh]j]ghgUbXUXjcWUhYgacfYWcaacb]ZUWcbgYfjUbWm\Ug
[fckbZfcaUZf]YbXg!cZ!h\Y!dUf_cf[Ub]nUh]cbaUmbch\UjYU``h\YfYgcifWYg g_]``g UbX
WcbbYWh]cbghcVYYZZYWh]jY"H\YdifdcgYcZUWcbgYfjUbWm]ghcXcgcaYh\]b[h\UhUZf]YbXg
[fcidWUbh.fU]gYYbci[\df]jUhYacbYmhcaU_Yg][b]WUbhWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhg"H\YVYgh
VcUfXg]bW`iXYd`YbhmcZaYaVYfgk]h\kYU`h\UbXWcbbYWh]cbgVihU`gcUZYkfYWc[b]nYX
dUf_W\Uad]cbgk]h\ghfcb[WfYX]V]`]hm _bck`YX[Y UbX\]ghcfmk]h\h\YdUf_"=XYU``m UdUf_
g\ci`X\UjYh\YgiddcfhcZVch\UZf]YbXg[fcidUbXUWcbgYfjUbWm YUW\k]h\UVcUfXgi]hYX
hc]hg[cU`gUbXaYh\cXg"
AcfYh\UbcbYWcbgYfjUbWm\UgVYYbZcfWYXhcfYWc[b]nY]hg`UW_cZVcUfXWcbbYWh]cbgUbX
ZibXfU]g]b[dfckYgg"AcghcZhYb h\]gWcaYgbchUgU\][\!dfc`YWc``UdgYVihUgU[fUXiU`
ghfUb[i`Uh]cbh\YWcbgYfjUbWmg]ad`mWUbbchfU]gYYbci[\acbYmhcaU_YUX]ZZYfYbWY"Cif
cf[Ub]nUh]cb]g[c]b[h\fci[\[fYUh[fckh\ cbYWcbgYfjUbWmX]fYWhcfgU]X Vihh\YdYcd`Y
]bjc`jYX]b]hgZcibX]b[ h\cgYk\cfc``YXidh\Y]fg`YYjYgUbXaUXY]h[YhghUfhYX UfYbhh\Y
cbYghchU_Y]hhch\YbYlh`YjY`"=\cdYkYWUbaU_Yh\YhfUbg]h]cbgYUa`Ygg`m k]h\h\YVcUfX
ibXYfghUbX]b[h\Uh]hbYYXghccdYbgdUWYgZcfch\Yfg"
5bch\YfWcbgYfjUbWmX]fYWhcfU[fYYX"H\YYUf`m[fUggfcchgUXjcWUhYgUddc]bhYXh\YagY`jYg
hccifVcUfXk]h\h\YVYgh]bhYbh]cbgVihVUXWcbgYeiYbWYg"Cifkcf_]gbckU``UVcihh\Y
fYgcifWYg h\YWcbbYWh]cbg UbXh\YZibXfU]gYfg UbXkYfY]bUb]bhYfYgh]b[UbXcZhYbX]ZWi`h
hfUbg]h]cbhcUacfYdckYfZi`VcUfX"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
25
City
Annual Revenue
New York
$38,912,440
New York
$23,550,671
Detroit
$13,999,813
St. Louis
$12,998,911
New York
$9,996,987
Memphis
$9,040,279
Dallas
$8,599,294
Houston
$6,873,615
Houston
$6,699,486
Atlanta
$6,678,384
New York
$6,170,925
Pittsburgh
$4,807,576
Houston
$3,927,356
Buffalo
$3,415,794
New York
$3,345,021
Boston
$3,034,730
Oklahoma City
$2,840,753
Birmingham
$2,773,465
New York
$2,472,244
Memphis
$2,456,492
Washington
$2,220,063
Boston
$1,977,304
Louisville
$1,782,767
Philadelphia
$1,743,632
New York
$1,574,183
Detroit
$1,394,878
Boston
$1,300,425
Houston
$1,274,455
New York
$1,199,471
Atlanta
$1,097,644
New York
$884,966
Denver
$637,387
Atlanta
$557,473
San Jose
$494,722
Dallas
$444,700
Portland
$413,907
New York
$402,265
Baltimore
$378,297
Hartford
$133,522
Atlanta
$116,013
San Antonio
$113,045
*2012 only
26
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
CbYkUmUWcbgYfjUbWmWUbVfcUXYbVcUfXWUdUW]hmk\]`YfYhU]b]b[ZcibX]b[UXjcWUhYg]ghc
WfYUhYUgYWcbXVcXm cZhYbWU``YXUbUXj]gcfmVcUfX UbX``]hk]h\_YmdUf_UbXfYWfYUh]cb
YldYfhg ]ggiYUXjcWUhYg UbXWcaaib]hm`YUXYfg"H\YgYdYcd`YaUm\UjY^ighUgaiW\cf
acfYk]gXcaUbXUWh]j]gahccZZYfUgVcUfXaYaVYfg"K\]`Yh\YmaUmbchVY]bUdcg]!
h]cbhcVf]b[]b\][\!Xc``UfXcbUh]cbg Ybh\ig]Ugh]WUbXWUdUV`YUXj]gcfmVcUfXaYaVYfgWUb
[UfbYfg[fUggfcchgdc`]h]WU`giddcfhUbXcZZYfYldYfh]gYcbaU]bhYbUbWYUbXigYfg\]d]ggiYg"
K\]`YUVcUfXcZX]fYWhcfgZcWigYgcbZibXfU]g]b[UbXcjYfgYYg`cb[!hYfad`Ubb]b[ h\YUXj]!
gcfmVcUfXaUmkY][\]bcbh\YdfUWh]WU`]ggiYgg\ci`XXc[gVYU``ckYXcZZ!`YUg\ WUbdUf_
fcUXgVYW`cgYXhcWUfg \ckaiW\WcbWYfhdfcachYfgaighdUmhcfYghcfY`Ukbg UbXacfY"
7cbjYfgY`m gcaYWcbgYfjUbW]Yg\UjYWfYUhYX\cbcfUfmhfighYYg dYcd`YgckY``!_bckbUbXgc
Vigmk]h\ch\YfaUhhYfgh\Uhh\YmWUbbchWcaa]hYbci[\h]aYhcVYVcUfXaYaVYfgVihWUb
gh]``dfcj]XY_YmWcbbYWh]cbgUbXj]g]V]`]hmcbUbUg!bYYXYXVUg]g"
27
Annual Spending
New York
$11,928,415
$1,772,424
New York
$3,092,202
$498,742
Houston
$4,751,895
$395,991
Dallas
$1,344,733
$258,602
Boston
$3,849,152
$256,610
Detroit
$1,554,426
$200,313
Birmingham
$3,446,114
$181,374
Oklahoma City
$1,881,606
$110,683
New York
$1,751,335
$70,053
Atlanta
$11,608,365
$62,748
Detroit
$7,242,497
$61,902
Denver
$541,715
$45,143
New York
$37,227,935
$44,161
Houston
$1,683,192
$37,404
Washington, D.C.
$4,779,953
$32,661
Baltimore
$185,345
$29,420
New York
$11,698,228
$19,997
Atlanta
$842,622
$17,665
New York
$1,045,982
$16,092
Boston
$1,255,495
$15,333
New York
$6,214,614
$14,352
St. Louis
$3,926,486
$10,471
Houston
$3,486,526
$7,835
Memphis
$1,210,906
$6,653
New York
$1,681,304
$5,095
Pittsburgh
$5,347,882
$3,146
Hartford
$110,560
$2,988
Buffalo
$3,503,314
$2,919
Philadelphia
$2,146,947
$2,359**
Memphis
$6,550,650
$2,047
Dallas
$519,666
$1,876
San Jose
$444,816
$1,853
Atlanta
$453,747
$1,693
New York
$894,714
$1,627
Boston
$1,171,475
$1,403
Atlanta
$124,481
$947
Louisville
$1,953,275
$936
Houston
$1,100,350
$769
San Antonio
$92,281
$375
New York
$446,567
$249
Portland
$433,255
$84
*2012 only
28
City
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
29
E A R N E D R E V E N U E A S P E R C E N T O F T O TA L R E V E N U E
2009-2012 ave rage
Conservancy
City
Earned Percent
Oklahoma City
61.9%
New York
53.9%
New York
53.8%
New York
40.1%
Houston
33.8%
New York
23.4%
Detroit
17.2%
New York
17.1%
Buffalo
16.4%
Atlanta
16.0%
Houston
13.0%
New York
11.9%
Memphis
11.0%
Atlanta
9.8%
San Jose
7.8%
Denver
6.8%
Birmingham
6.4%
Atlanta
6.1%
Houston
5.8%
Portland
4.0%
Atlanta
3.6%
Dallas
2.9%
New York
1.7%
Philadelphia
1.5%
St. Louis
1.4%
New York
1.4%
Boston
1.2%
Dallas
1.1%
New York
1.1%
New York
1.0%
Louisville
0.5%
San Antonio
0.4%
Boston
0.3%
Houston
0.2%
Hartford
0%
Detroit
0%
Baltimore
0%
Memphis
0%
Pittsburgh
0%
Boston
0%
Washington, D.C.
0%
*2012 only
30
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
Cordoned-off Events
DYf\Udgh\Yf]g_]YghkUmZcfUWcbgYfjUbWmhcfU]gYfYjYbiY]ghcfY[i`Uf`mcZZYfUdcfh]cbcZh\Y
dUf_Zcfdf]jUhYYjYbhgkYXX]b[g fYib]cbg Vig]bYggdUfh]YgUbXh\YbWcfXcb]hcZZZfca
ch\YfigYg"Bchcb`mXcYgh\]gfYacjYUgWYb]WgdchZfcadiV`]WYb^cmaYbh VihYWcbca]W
fYU`]h]YgcZhYbX]WhUhYfYbhU`ZYYgUVcjYk\UhaUbmdYcd`YWUbUZZcfX `YUX]b[Wf]h]WghcWfmh\Uh
h\YdUf_]gVY]b[df]jUh]nYX"
H\Yfghdf]cf]hmcZUWcbWYgg]cbg\ci`XVYgYfj]b[h\YdiV`]W gUmg6YhgmGa]h\"7cbWYg!
g]cbgg\ci`XbhVYk]bXZU``g"MciXcbhkUbhWcbgYfjUbW]YgfY`m]b[cbWcbWYgg]cbg VYWUigYmci
XcbhkUbhh\Yahc[YhhccYlW]hYXUVcihWcaaYfW]U`UWh]j]hm]bh\YdUf_"
:cfacghWcbgYfjUbW]Yg BYkMcf_WcXYdfYjYbhgh\YhYadhUh]cbVmfYei]f]b[U``WcbWYgg]cb
fYjYbiYghcVYfYhifbYXhch\YW]hmg[YbYfU`ZibX"5`h\ci[\h\Uhdc`]WmdfYXUhYXWcbgYfjUb!
W]Yg ]hgUfYa]bXYfh\Uhh\YmaighgYY_cihd\]`Ubh\fcdm gUmgGa]h\"=bUZYkWUgYgk\YfY
UWcbgYfjUbWmZibXgh\Y`]cbgg\UfYcZUdUf_gXU]`mid_YYdgiW\Ugh\Y<][\@]bYUbX
FUbXU``g=g`UbXh\YW]hmU``ckgh\YWcbgYfjUbWmhc_YYdfYjYbiYgUgUWcbhf]Vih]cbhcdUf_
aU]bhYbUbWY"H\cgYgdYW]U`U[fYYaYbhggYhU\][\h\fYg\c`XZcfUWcbgYfjUbWmgdf]jUhYWcbhf]!
Vih]cbg gUmgGa]h\ VYWUigYh\YWcbWYgg]cbVig]bYggWUbbchYlYadhUWcbgYfjUbWmZfca
aU_]b[df]jUhYd\]`Ubh\fcdmU_YmdUfhcZh\Ydinn`Y"
>]a;f]Zb X]fYWhcfcZh\YD]hhgVif[\DUf_g8]j]g]cbUbXZcfaYfZUW]`]h]YgX]fYWhcfUhh\Y
D]hhgVif[\DUf_g7cbgYfjUbWm \UgUg]a]`Ufd\]`cgcd\m"GdYU_]b[hch\YBUh]cbU`FYWfYUh]cb
UbXDUf_5ggcW]Uh]cb \YgU]X Mci\UjYhcgh]W_hck\Uhmci_bckUVcihh\YW\UfUWhYfcZh\Y
dUf_"8cbh[]jYidh\YWi`hifYcZh\YgdUWYhcaU_YUViW_"=ZmcihfmUbYjYbhUbX]hZYY`g
kfcb[ aU_Y]hUcbY!h]aYa]ghU_YUbXacjYcb"
CbYcZh\Yacghdfca]bYbhYlUad`YgcZUb]``!ghUffYXdf]jUhYYjYbhkUgh\Y;fYUh
;cc[UAcc[UZccXUbXaig]WZYgh]jU` k\]W\hcc_cjYfDfcgdYWhDUf_gBYh\YfaYUXZcf
h\fYYXUmg]b&$%&"H\Yaig]WkUgZfYYVihZccXjYbXcfg``YXh\YaYUXckk]h\WcaaYfW]U`
cdYfUh]cbg"GcaYdUfhgcZh\YdUf_kYfYZYbWYXcZZZcfYlW`ig]jYigYcZh\cgY\c`X]b[&)$
J=DdUggYg"H\YDfcgdYWhDUf_5``]UbWYfYWY]jYXU+) $$$igU[YZYYZfcacf[Ub]nYfg gcaY
cZk\]W\kYbhhcfYgYYX]b[h\YXUaU[YXdcfh]cbgcZh\YaYUXck Vihh\YfYkUggh]``UdiV`]W
cihWfm"H\Y&$%';fYUh;cc[UAcc[UZYUhifYXUbYk`Umcihh\UhVYhhYfdfchYWhYXh\YdUf_
UbX_YdhacfYcZ]hcdYbhch\YdiV`]WVih]hU[U]bXfYk`ciXWcad`U]bhg":]bU``m ]b&$%( h\Y
dUf_gXYdUfhaYbhUbXh\Y5``]UbWYXYW]XYXh\UhDfcgdYWhDUf_kUgUb]bUddfcdf]UhYjYbiY
UbXYbXYXh\Yfib"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
31
ca se study
32
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
H\YWcbgYfjUbWmg`UVcfg\UjYm]Y`XYXZcifV][Zfi]hg.UbUbbiU`=bXYdYbXYbWY9jY
WY`YVfUh]cbZYUhif]b[UZfYYWcbWYfh fYkcf_g UbXU`][\hX]gd`Um/UV]_Y!]bgiaaYf
acj]YgYf]Yg/ZfYYkUfa!kYUh\YfhbYggW`UggYg UbX7]j]W7YbhYf9Uhg Uhk]WY!kYY_`m
`ibW\h]aY[Uh\Yf]b[cZZccXhfiW_gk]h\`]jYaig]W U`gc]bh\YgiaaYf"H\YdUf_bck
UhhfUWhgUVcihUa]``]cbj]g]hcfgUmYUfVihgiWWYggkUgbhYUgm"
H\YWcbgYfjUbWmVY[Ub`]ZYk]h\Uhci[\`Yggcb"=h\]fYXZUacigUfW\]hYWh8Ub]Y`
@]VYg_]bXXYg][bYfcZdUf_bY][\Vcfh\Y8YbjYf5fhAigYiahcWfYUhYWcbWYdhiU`
fYbXYf]b[g"6ihh\YUfh]gh]WU``mk]`XWcbWYdh]cbgWUigYXUdiV`]WZifcf"H\YWcbgYfjUbWm
kUgUWWigYXcZhfm]b[hc]ad`YaYbhUib]`UhYfU`j]g]cbZcfh\YgdUWY h\Ydfc^YWhkUg
g\Y`jYX UbXh\Y8YbjYfdUf_gX]fYWhcfi`h]aUhY`m`cgh\Yf^cVcjYfh\YWcbhfcjYfgm"@Ybh
Uhhf]VihYgh\YV`ck!idhcdccfWcaaib]hmcihfYUW\"=hg]adcfhUbhhcXYbYUj]g]cb
UbXa]gg]cbVch\]bhYfbU``mUbXYlhYfbU``m gUmg@Ybh YgdYW]U``m]bUd`UWY`]_Y8YbjYf
k\YfYh\YWcbgYfjUbWmacXY`\UXVYYbibZUa]`]Uf"
5ZhYfh\YgYhVUW_ h\YWcbgYfjUbWmfYYjU`iUhYX]hgd`Ub"Dcghdcb]b[h\Y`UibW\cZUaU^cf
WUd]hU`dfc^YWh ]hZcWigYX]bghYUXcb]bWfYUg]b[Wcaaib]hmhfighh\fci[\]bWfYaYbhU`
giWWYggYg]bdfc[fUaa]b[UbXUXjcWUWm"=hgacXYghUbbiU`ViX[YhcZ+$$ $$$U`gc
ZcfWYXUgWU`Y!VUW_cZ]hgd`UbhchU_YcjYfdUf_aU]bhYbUbWYfYgdcbg]V]`]h]YgZfcah\Y
8YbjYfDUf_gUbXFYWfYUh]cb8YdUfhaYbh"
H\YWcbgYfjUbWmg`Uf[YghgcifWYcZ]bWcaYWcaYgZfcaWcfdcfUhYgdcbgcfg\]dgUbX
d\]`Ubh\fcd]W[fUbhg k]h\U[fck]b[dYfWYbhU[YZfcaZccXhfiW_WcbWYgg]cbgUbX
]bX]j]XiU`XcbUh]cbg"5`h\ci[\cf[Ub]nYfgcZ`Uf[YYjYbhg]b7]j]W7YbhYfDUf_aigh
dUmUdYfa]hh]b[ZYY h\YfYjYbiY[cYghch\YW]hmg[YbYfU`ZibXfUh\Yfh\Ubhch\Y
WcbgYfjUbWm"
=fcb]WU``m XYgd]hYh\YdUf_gVi``g!YmYg]hY h\Yd\mg]WU``cWUh]cbUWhiU``m\UadYfgh\Y
WcbgYfjUbWmgUV]`]hmhcfU]gYacfYacbYm"GiffcibXYXVm[cjYfbaYbhVi]`X]b[gUbX
bcbdfchYbh]h]Ygh\Y8YbjYf5fhAigYia 7c`cfUXc9XiWUh]cb5ggcW]Uh]cb UbX
h\Y6Ug]`]WUcZh\Y=aaUWi`UhY7cbWYdh]cbh\YdUf_`UW_gUbUhifU`Wcbgh]hiYbWmcZ
bYUfVmdf]jUhY!gYWhcfWcadUb]YgcfkY``!\YY`YXfYg]XYbhg]bh\Ydcg]h]cbhcaU_Y`Uf[Y
XcbUh]cbgcfh\fckh\YagY`jYg]bhcaU^cfZibXfU]g]b[WUadU][bg"
FYgcifWYga][\hVYYUg]YfhcWcaYVm]Zh\YdUf_kYfY`cWUhYXk]h\]b8YbjYfg\][\!
dckYfYX %&$!V`cW_8ckbhckb8YbjYfDUfhbYfg\]d UVig]bYgg]adfcjYaYbhX]ghf]Wh
6=8h\UhfYWY]jYghUlgifW\Uf[YdUmaYbhgZfca`UbX`cfXgUbXVig]bYggckbYfg"
<ckYjYf ]h]gbh"H\YVcibXUfmkUgXfUkbhcUjc]Xh\YdUf_UbXgiffcibX]b[UfYUg]bWY
[cjYfbaYbhVi]`X]b[gUbXbcbdfchgkci`XbhWcbhf]VihYhch\Y6=8Y]h\Yf"
H\YWcbgYfjUbWmX]Xd]cbYYfUfY`Uh]cbg\]dk]h\h\Y6=8 WcbhfUWh]b[k]h\]hhcd]W_
id`]hhYf fYacjY[fUZh] UbXdfYggifYkUg\dUjYaYbh]bh\YdUf_"7U``YX7]j]W7YbhYf
GdUf_`Yg h\YgiaaYf!cb`mdfc[fUaWcgh%$+ )$$cjYfh\fYYmYUfg UbYldYbgYgd`]h
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
33
YjYb`mVYhkYYbh\Yhkccf[Ub]nUh]cbg"IbZcfhibUhY`m ZibX]b[fUbcihUbXh\Ydfc[fUa
kUgX]gWcbh]biYXUZhYf&$%%"
GUZYhm\UgU`gcVYYbUb]ggiY]bh\YdUf_ k\]W\]gW`cgYhcXckbhckbhfUbg]h\iVg UbX
k\YfY\]ghcf]WghfiWhifYgUbX`UbXgWUd]b[dfcj]XYg\UXckm\]X]b[d`UWYgZcfjU[fUbhg
UbXXfi[XYU`Yfg"5&$%'g\cch]b[]bh\YdUf_dihcZZXcbcfgUbXgcaYj]g]hcfg Vih]h
[U`jUb]nYXdc`]h]WU`giddcfhZcfh\YWcbgYfjUbWm @YbhgUmg"H\YaYX]UUhhYbh]cbWfYX]hYX
h\YW]hmZcfYZZcfhgh\YmkYfYibXYfhU_]b[OhcUXXfYggWf]aYQUbXYbWcifU[YXh\Yahc
Wcbh]biY"5hh\YgUaYh]aY @YbhgUmg YjYfmVcXmhcihYXh\YWcbgYfjUbWmgdfc[fUaa]b[
UgUgc`ih]cbhcfYXiW]b[Wf]aY"H\YaUmcfU``cWUhYXacfYacbYmZcfdc`]W]b[UbX
gYWif]hm UbXh\YdUf_gXYdUfhaYbhghYddYXidgiaaYfh]aYdfc[fUaa]b["
H\YWcbgYfjUbWm]gbckW]fW`]b[VUW_hcUXXfYggWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhg UgWU``YXZcf]b
h\Y&$$)7]j]W7YbhYfDUf_AUghYfD`Ub"<Uj]b[giWWYggZi``mUXjcWUhYXZcfh\YdUf_g
]bW`ig]cb]bh\Y&$$+6YhhYf8YbjYfVcbX]b]h]Uh]jY k\]W\[iUfUbhYYg-")a]``]cb]b
diV`]WacbYmhcUhhfUWhUbX`YjYfU[Ydf]jUhY`mfU]gYXZibXg h\YWcbgYfjUbWm]gd`Ubb]b[U
&)!a]``]cb7YbhYbb]U`7UadU][b"=hg[cU`g]bW`iXYh\YfYghcfUh]cbcZh\Y\]ghcf]W;fYY_
H\YUhYfUbX7UfbY[]Y@]VfUfm/UbYbXckaYbhZcfdfc[fUaa]b[UbXaU]bhYbUbWY/UbX
h\YXYg][bUbXWcbghfiWh]cbcZU`cb[d`UbbYXVihbYjYfVi]`hWYbhfU`ZYUhifYZcfh\YdUf_"
7]j]W7YbhYfDUf_gW\U``Yb[YgUfYfYU` VihWUbVYcjYfWcaY @YbhgUmg"KYfY\YfYhc
aU_Yh\YWUgYh\Uhh\]g]gUgdUWYkcfh\[\h]b[Zcf"
C i v i c Ce nte r Conse rva nc y
12 acres
Park size
1894
Park created
2004
Conservancy founded
$541,715
Expenditures*
$637,387
Revenue*
93%
7%
Employees
45
Volunteers
13
6-member executive
committee, 9 directors,
2 ex-officio**
Some
Board structure
Conservancy manages operations/maintenance?
Yes
Yes
Yes
34
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
35
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
ca se study
Kcf_]b[]bdUfhbYfg\]dk]h\@ci]gj]``YAYhfcDUf_g h\Y7cbgYfjUbWm\Ug\UXaUbm
giWWYggYg ZfcafYghcfUh]cbcZh\Y;fYUh@Ukb]bG\UkbYYDUf_hcfYWcbghfiWh]cbcZh\Y
XfU]bU[YibXYfGiaa]h:]Y`X]b=fceic]gDUf_ ZfcafYVi]`X]b[cZh\Y=fceic]gDUf_
5ad\]h\YUhfYUbX]bghU``Uh]cbcZUaU^cfghcfakUhYf\UbX`]b[gmghYaUfcibX]hg
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
37
dUf_]b[`chghcfYghcfUh]cbcZh\Y6Uff]b[Yf<]``j]ghU]b7\Yfc_YYDUf_UbXfYacjU`cZ
`Uf[YhfUWhgcZ]bjUg]jYVig\\cbYmgiW_`Yh\fci[\cihh\YgmghYa"MYh &$mYUfgUZhYfh\Y
aUghYfd`UbkUgdiV`]g\YX cb`mUVcih&)a]``]cb\UgVYYbfU]gYXUVcihcbY!h\]fX
cZh\YZibX]b[[cU`"AU^cfdfc^YWhgfYaU]b]b[hcVYWcad`YhYX]bW`iXYG\UkbYYDUf_g
Aig]W7cbWcifgY[UfXYbg h\YBcfh\YfbCjYf`cc_]b=fceic]gDUf_ UbXh\Y<c[Ubg
:cibhU]bj]ghU]b7\Yfc_YYDUf_"K\m3
H\YUbgkYf]gWcad`Yl":cfcbYh\]b[ h\YZi``gmghYacZ%,dUf_g ]bW`iX]b[h\fYY
dUf_kUmg hchU`g& $,+UWfYgUacb[h\Y`Uf[YghUWfYU[YgiddcfhYXVmUW]hmdUf_
WcbgYfjUbWm"AcghWcbgYfjUbW]YgUXcdhcb`mUg]b[`YdUf_/giddcfh]b[ai`h]d`YdUf_gUbX
`Uf[YUWfYU[Y]gUbYlhfUcfX]bUf]`mX]ZWi`hW\U``Yb[Y":cfUbch\Yf acghcZh\YkYU`h\]Yf
XYb]nYbgcZaYhfc@ci]gj]``Y\UjYacjYXhch\Ycihg_]fhgcZh\YW]hmUbX\UjYU`Ygg
]bh]aUhYXUm!hc!XUmWcbbYWh]cbk]h\h\YWYbhfU`!W]hmC`aghYXdUf_g"@Ugh`m ]b&$$)
U`Uf[YUbXYlW]h]b[YZZcfhhcWfYUhYh\cigUbXgcZUWfYgcZbYkdUf_`UbX&%gh7Ybhifm
DUf_ggdfUb[idcbh\Ych\Yfg]XYcZ@ci]gj]``YZfcah\YC`aghYXdUf_g"=bgd]fYX
]fcb]WU``m VmUgdYYW\[]jYbVmh\Yh\Yb!W\U]fcZh\YC`aghYXDUf_g7cbgYfjUbWm h\Y
bYkWcbgYfjUbWm\UgfU]gYX%&$a]``]cbUbXgYfjYXUgUbibk]hh]b[WcadYh]hcfZcf
d\]`Ubh\fcd]WgiddcfhZfcadUf_!a]bXYXXcbcfg"
=bUb]XYU`kcf`X gUmgC`aghYXDUf_g7cbgYfjUbWm79CA]a]N]bb]Y` \Yf
cf[Ub]nUh]cbkci`XhU_YW\Uf[YcZcb[c]b[aU]bhYbUbWY]bh\YC`aghYXdUf_g
VihWiffYbhZibX]b[WUbbchgiddcfhh\Uh`YjY`cZkcf_"K]h\UghUZZcZcb`mhYb
h\Y7cbgYfjUbWmgWfUaV`YghcfU]gYYbci[\acbYm^ighhcghUmU\YUXcZh\YbcfaU`
XYhYf]cfUh]cbcZh\Y\i[YUWfYU[Y]h\UgW`U]aYXUg]hgVU]`]k]W_"H\]gG]gmd\YUbhUg_
XcYgbh`YUjYaiW\acbYmZcfV][WUd]hU`dfc^YWhg U`h\ci[\fYWYbhacXYghgiWWYggYg
\UjY]bW`iXYXh\YfYghcfUh]cbcZ\]ghcf]Wd]Wb]WdUj]`]cbg WcbghfiWh]cbcZbYkfYghfccag
UbXgd`Ug\ncbYghcUhhfUWhZUa]`]Yg UbXh\YfYacjU`cZ]bjUg]jYgdYW]YgVmjc`ibhYYfg"
H\Ycf[Ub]nUh]cbU`gcdUmgU``Y[]UbWYhc]hgUXjcWUWmfcchgdfYgg]b[ZcfacfYdiV`]W
dUf_gdYbX]b[ dfcach]b[C`aghYXgj]g]cbZcfh\YdUf_g UbXgdYU_]b[cihU[U]bgh
WcaaYfW]U`YbWfcUW\aYbhU`cb[h\YC`aghYXdUf_kUmg"=baUbmW]h]Yg ZibXfU]g]b[
UbXUXjcWUWmUfY\UbX`YXVmX]ZZYfYbhcf[Ub]nUh]cbg"
H\Y7cbgYfjUbWmgdYbXg%")&")a]``]cbUbbiU``m fU]gYXYbh]fY`mZfcadf]jUhY
XcbUh]cbgUbXZcibXUh]cb[fUbhg"IbXYfW]hm`Uk UbmdUf_![YbYfUhYXfYjYbiY giW\Ug
d]Wb]WdUj]`]cbfYbhU`ZYYg aigh[chcAYhfcDUf_gfUh\Yfh\Ubhch\YWcbgYfjUbWm"H\Y
cb[c]b[gYUfW\ZcfZibX]b[ gUmgN]bb]Y` fYaU]bgh\YWcbgYfjUbWmg[fYUhYghW\U``Yb[Y"
DYcd`Y`cjYk\UhmciXc h\]b_]hg[fYUh h\Ybk\YbmciUg_h\YaZcfacbYmh\Ym
XYW`]bYVYWUigYh\YmgUmh\YmU`fYUXmdUmhUlYg"H\Ycf[Ub]nUh]cb]gdfYdUf]b[hc`UibW\
UbYkWUd]hU`WUadU][b"
=bgcaYkUmg h\Y@ci]gj]``YC`aghYXDUf_g7cbgYfjUbWm]gh\Y]XYU`acXY`ZcfU
dUf_!giddcfhcf[Ub]nUh]cb]h\UgUVfcUXj]YkcZdUf_bYYXgUbXWc``UVcfUhYgW`cgY`m
k]h\@ci]gj]``YAYhfcDUf_gcbd`Ubb]b[UbXXUm!hc!XUmkcf_"=bUbch\YfkUm h\Y
WcbgYfjUbWmgYYaghc\UjYdcg]h]cbYX]hgY`Z]bUbibgUh]gZUWhcfmd`UWY"=h\UgUWWYdhYX
38
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
fYgdcbg]V]`]hmZcfh\cigUbXgcZUWfYgcZdfYW]cigUbX\]ghcf]WdUf_`UbXgk]h\cihYbci[\
acbYmhcXcU``h\Ykcf_ fYacj]b[h\UhVifXYbZfcaAYhfcDUf_g"H\YViX[Yh
biaVYfgWcbfah\]g"AYhfcDUf_ggdYbX]b[dYffYg]XYbh]gUddfcl]aUhY`mY][\h
dYfWYbhVY`ckh\YUjYfU[YZcfV][!W]hmdUf_gmghYagbUh]cbk]XY k]h\h\YWcbgYfjUbWmg
gdYbX]b[acgh`mWcjYf]b[h\Uh[Ud"=Zh\YW]hmgaU]bhYbUbWYgdYbX]b[kYfY\][\Yf h\Y
WcbgYfjUbWmWci`X]bjYgh]b`Uf[Yf!gWU`YWUd]hU`dfc^YWhg"K\]`Yh\YfYacjU`cZ]bjUg]jY
gdYW]Yg]gUjU`iUV`YgYfj]WY h\YZcWigcbgiW\dfc^YWhg\Ug`YZhgcaYcVgYfjYfgZYY`]b[Ug
h\ci[\h\YWcbgYfjUbWm]gg]ad`mhfYUX]b[kUhYf"
O l mste d Pa rks Conse rva nc y
Park size
1880
Park created
1989
Conservancy founded
$1,953,275
Expenditures*
$1,782,767
Revenue*
99%
2%
21
Employees
5,000
Volunteers
36
6-member executive
committee, 30 general
directors, 6 ex-officio**
Yes
Yes
No
No
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
39
X]fYWhcfacbh\`m UbXcifa]X!`YjY`ghUZZYfgX]Xgchkccfh\fYYh]aYgUgcZhYb"5bX=U`kUmg
aUXYgifYhcg\ckidUhWcbgYfjUbWmVcUfXaYYh]b[gh\YfY]gbcVYhhYfkUmhcghUjYcZZ
a]gibXYfghUbX]b[gcfZU`gYfiacfgUbXb]ddfcV`Yag]bh\YViX"
CZU``h\Y]bbcjUh]cbgWca]b[cihcZBYkMcf_gYUf`mYldYf]YbWYk]h\WcbgYfjUbW]Yg bcbY
kUgacfYXUf]b[h\UbWcaV]b]b[h\Ydcg]h]cbgcZdUf_UXa]b]ghfUhcfUbXWcbgYfjUbWmdfYg]!
XYbh]b6Yhgm6Uf`ckFc[YfgZcf7YbhfU`DUf_ ]b%-,$ UbXHiddYfH\caUgZcfDfcgdYWh
DUf_ ]b%-,+"=bYUW\WUgY h\Y`YUXYfggU`UfmWUaY\U`ZZfcah\YW]hm \U`ZZfcah\YWcbgYf!
jUbWm"5bXYUW\fYdcfhYXhchkcVcggYgh\YdUf_Wcaa]gg]cbYfUbXh\YW\U]faUbcZh\Y
WcbgYfjUbWmVcUfX"=hkUgUb]bbcjUh]jYUbXf]g_mUddfcUW\"6ihh\YUXa]b]ghfUhcfgg\ckYX
h\Uh]hkUgdcgg]V`Yhch\fYUXh\Y]fkUmh\fci[\dc`]h]WU`a]bYY`Xg VU`UbWYh\Y]bhYfYghgcZ
h\YW]hmUbXh\Ydf]jUhYgYWhcf UbXghUmcbh\Y[ccXg]XYcZh\YaUmcf dUf_gWcaa]gg]cbYf
UbXU\UfX!W\Uf[]b[VcUfXcZX]fYWhcfg"H\YUffUb[YaYbhfYei]fYgh\Yf][\ha]lcZdYfgcbU`]!
h]Yg UbXhYbg]cbg\UjYcWWUg]cbU``mUf]gYbk\Ybh\YhkcVcggYgX]XbhgYYYmY!hc!YmY"8Ygd]hY
h\UhcWWUg]cbU`Zf]Wh]cb h\]gXiU`UXa]b]ghfUh]jYghfiWhifY\UgVYWcaYghUbXUfXZcfBYkMcf_
7]hmdUf_WcbgYfjUbW]YgU`h\ci[\ XiYhc]hgibWcbjYbh]cbU`]hm ]h\UgbchVYYbUXcdhYXVm
ch\YfW]h]Yg"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
Combatting Fearfulness
=baUbmWUgYg ZYUf]gh\YibXYf`m]b[fYUgcbZcfghUfh]b[UWcbgYfjUbWmh\YdiV`]WgZYUfcZh\Y
dUf_"FibXckbUbXbY[`YWhYXdUf_gWUb[]jYh\YZYY`]b[h\UhbccbY]g]bWcbhfc` UhhfUWh]b[
Ubh]!gcW]U`UbXYjYbWf]a]bU`UWh]j]hm"H\]gUhacgd\YfYdig\YgZUa]`]YgcihcZh\YdUf_
aU_]b[]hX]ZWi`hhcVi]`XidUWUXfYcZXcbcfgUbXUWh]j]ghgk]h\Uj]g]cbhc]adfcjYUbX
fYghcfYh\YZUW]`]hm"
H\ig UbYUf`mhUg_ZcfaUbmWcbgYfjUbW]Yg]gYghUV`]g\]b[dUhfc`g ]ad`YaYbh]b[jUf]YXUbX
ZfYeiYbhdfc[fUaghc``h\YdUf_k]h\UWh]j]hm UbXh\YYbZcfW]b[fi`Ygh\UhaUm\UjY`cb[
VYYb][bcfYX"
G]ad`m[Yhh]b[dYcd`YVUW_]bhcUb]adfcj]b[dUf_\Y`dgdiV`]W]nYUbXVi]`XcbUWcbgYf!
jUbWmggiWWYggYg gcUai`h]d`]W]hmcZjc`ibhYYfcddcfhib]h]Yg]gdUfh]Wi`Uf`m]adcfhUbh"6Ygh
]gWcbbYWh]b[k]h\Yl]gh]b[bYhkcf_gh\fci[\Wcb[fY[Uh]cbg Vig]bYggYg UggcW]Uh]cbg cfch\Yf
gdYW]WigYf[fcidggch\Uh]bX]j]XiU`jc`ibhYYfgU`fYUXm\UjYh\YgiddcfhcZZf]YbXg"9jYfm
WcbgYfjUbWmg\ci`X\UjYUbYbYf[Yh]W Ybh\ig]Ugh]W UbXkY`Wca]b[WccfX]bUhcfcZjc`ibhYYfg"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
41
Flashpoints
As with their urban park department partners, conservancies inevitably face issues that
can cause discord. Solving them will not only improve the park experience for all users,
it will go a long way toward building a conservancys reputation for thoughtfulness,
commitment, and fairness. Among common challenges are:
Dogs. Most conservancies establish one or more off-leash dog areas and then strive
to be strict about enforcing leash laws in the rest of the park. Dogs are heavy users
of parks, and they provide many enjoyable moments (even for non-owners), but they
also present problems, including waste, smell, noise, and fear. Best is to have an active
canine committee (including at least one non-dog owner) to handle day-to-day conflicts.
That way, the conservancy board (and the city) need only deal with matters that rise to
the level of a major policy consideration.
Music. For some people, nothing is nicer than a concert in a park; for others, loud music
fractures nature. Obviously, its best to provide both ambiances, either by geography (in
large parks) or by time (in plazas and squares). Even personal boom boxes can be disruptive and might need to be banned in certain locations or perhaps regulated by time
of day. For conservancies that host weddings and parties in their park, noise conflicts
can be even more significant since these are emotional and costly gatherings. Clear
policies and appropriate signage are necessary.
Cars. Many older parks have been damaged over the years by the addition of roadways
and parking, and a conservancy may be called upon to figure out a rebalance. Those
that have instituted auto restrictions (by location or time) have invariably gained total
users through an increase in walkers, runners, cyclists, skaters, and families. But they
have also been excoriated by drivers. In recompense, some conservancies have sought
to establish transit connections or have set up shuttles. Some have resorted to building structured garages or charging for parking. The issue of autos is too fraught to be
decided solely by the conservancy; it requires a full-fledged policy decision by the city
itself. However, the conservancy is often called upon to raise enough money to pay for
whatever solutions are devised.
Bicycles. Most people consider bicycles benign, but, like cars, they can also reach
speeds and density levels that diminish the park experience for pedestrians, seniors,
small children, and people pushing strollers. In Central Park, with 40 million annual visitors, cyclists are permitted on all the original roadways but have been banned from foot
trails and paths. Other heavily used parks are following similar rules. As cycling continues to increase in urban America, more focused attention is needed on park regulations
governing bike speed, parking, and etiquetteand conservancies are likely to be taking
the lead.
42
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
Giving the Grass a Rest. No lawn can withstand millions of users without an occasional
breather, and conservancies must decide between protecting plantings and allowing
unfettered human access. (For most cities this is a new situation, since most municipal
agencies without conservancies lack the manpower to fence lawns and enforce their
closure.) Scheduling the level of lawn use and enforcing closures through explanatory
signageand, in some instances, public service announcementsis one of the tougher
jobs that a conservancy must face.
H\YZYUfZi`bYggdfcV`Ya]gacfYUWihY]b`ck!]bWcaYbY][\Vcf\ccXg"MYh `]_Yhfm]b[hcghUfh
UWUadfYk]h\bcUjU]`UV`YkccX ]hgU`acgh]adcgg]V`YhcYghUV`]g\UWcbgYfjUbWmZcfUdUf_
giffcibXYXVmdcjYfhm"HcXYU`k]h\h\]gW\U``Yb[Y kYU`h\]YfWcbgYfjUbW]Yg]bgYjYfU`W]h]Yg
UfYghYdd]b[idVmg\Uf]b[fYgcifWYgk]h\`YggZcfhibUhYbY][\Vcf\ccXg"AcghbchUV`Y]gh\Y
D]hhgVif[\DUf_g7cbgYfjUbWm"Cf][]bU``mdfcdcgYXUgUWcbgYfjUbWmZcfcb`mGW\Yb`YmDUf_
h\Y]bgh]hih]cbVfcUXYbYX]hgaUbXUhYhcU``ZcifcZh\YW]hmgfY[]cbU`dUf_gibXYfh\Ygi[[Yg!
h]cbUbXdfcXX]b[cZh\Yb!aUmcfHcaAifd\m"G]bWYh\Ybh\Ycf[Ub]nUh]cb\UggWfidi`cig`m
fchUhYXWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhgUacb[h\YZcifdUf_gUbX\UgfYWYbh`mYldUbXYXgiddcfhhc
gcaYgaU``YfbY][\Vcf\ccXdUf_g hcc"
D\]`UXY`d\]Ug:U]facbhDUf_7cbgYfjUbWmU`gcWcbgW]cig`mfYUW\YXcihVYmcbXh\YW]hmg
g][bUhifY[fYYbgdUWY h\fck]b[]hgY`Z]bhcfYj]hU`]n]b[,+!UWfY<ibh]b[DUf_]b\UfX!\]h
Bcfh\D\]`UXY`d\]U"=bBYkMcf_ h\Y7YbhfU`DUf_7cbgYfjUbWm\UgYghUV`]g\YXcihfYUW\
UbXhfU]b]b[dfc[fUagZcf[fcidgUgg]gh]b[dUf_g]b<Uf`YaUbXch\Yf`YggUZiYbhbcfh\Yfb
AUb\UhhUbbY][\Vcf\ccXg"=b5h`UbhU 8YVV]YAW7ckbcZD]YXacbhDUf_7cbgYfjUbWm\Ug
aYbhcfYXgYjYfU`YX[`]b[WcbgYfjUbW]Yg \Y`d]b[k]h\aUbU[YaYbhUbX[cjYfbUbWY]ggiYg"
H\Ybh\YfY]gh\Y6fcblF]jYf5``]UbWY"K\]`YbchfYU``mUWcbgYfjUbWm^S`aS h\YU``]UbWY
ZcibXYX]b&$$% Vf]b[gai`h]d`YfYgcifWYghcdiV`]W[fYYbgdUWY]b`ck!]bWcaYUbX]aa]!
[fUbhbY][\Vcf\ccXg]bBYkMcf_7]hm UbX]hgacXY`Wci`XVYWcaY]biYbh]U`"=bUXX]h]cb
hc]adfcj]b[dUf_gUbXkcf_]b[hcWcbbYWhh\Yah\fci[\U[fYYbkUm h\Y5``]UbWYgVfcUX
a]gg]cb]bW`iXYgYbj]fcbaYbhU`YXiWUh]cbUbXh\Y]adfcjYaYbhcZkUhYfeiU`]hmUbXk]`X`]ZY
\UV]hUhU`cb[h\Y&'!a]`Y!`cb[6fcblF]jYf"
K]h\UbUbbiU`cdYfUh]b[ViX[YhcZ%"%a]``]cb h\Y5``]UbWY\Y`dgBYkMcf_7]hmgdUf_g
XYdUfhaYbhWUfYZcf%&dUf_ghchU`]b[UVcih()$UWfYg"H\Y5``]UbWYgYlYWih]jYX]fYWhcfU`gc
gYfjYgUgh\YW]hmg6fcblF]jYf5Xa]b]ghfUhcfUbXfYdcfhghcVch\h\YbcbdfchgVcUfXUbX
h\YW]hmdUf_gWcaa]gg]cbYf"5gcZ&$%( h\Y5``]UbWY\UXfU]gYXUbXgdYbhacfYh\Ub%($
a]``]cbhcWfYUhYUbXfYghcfYdUf_gUbXhfU]`gbYUf`mU``cZ]hZfca[cjYfbaYbhUbXZcibXU!
h]cb[fUbhgfUh\Yfh\UbZfcaWcfdcfUhYcf]bX]j]XiU`Xcbcfg"6YWUigYaiW\cZ]hgcdYfUh]b[
fYjYbiYWcaYgZfcah\YdUf_gXYdUfhaYbh h\Y5``]UbWY]gacfY`]_YUbUhifY!cf]YbhYX
Wcaaib]hmXYjY`cdaYbhcf[Ub]nUh]cbh\UbUhfUX]h]cbU`WcbgYfjUbWm"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
43
ca se study
H\YgYh\fYUhggYfjYXhcYbYf[]nYdUf_UXjcWUhYg k\c\Y`dYXhifbVUW_Vch\dfcdcgU`g"
44
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
GiXXYb`m bYUfVmfYg]XYbhgZY`hh\Yh]aY\UXWcaYZcfUbYk]bgh]hih]cbhcgiddcfhh\Y
dUf_"GdYUf\YUX]b[h\Ydig\kYfYhkc_Ym`cWU``YUXYfgUbXigYfgcZh\YdUf_g[c`Z
WcifgY;UfmG\cfV 79CcZAYh\cX]gh@Y6cb\Yif<YU`h\WUfYUbX;Ycf[Y7UhYg
UfYU`YghUhYYlYWih]jYUbXd\]`Ubh\fcd]gh"H]bUGi``]jUb k\ckci`XVYWcaYYlYWih]jY
X]fYWhcfcZh\YbYkCjYfhcbDUf_7cbgYfjUbWmCD7 WU``gh\YYZZcfhUVi]`XidcZ
bYYXUbXkUbhU``X]fYWhYXUhcbY\U`ZgeiUfYa]`YcZAYad\]g"
@]_YaUbmch\YfWYbhfU`dUf_g CjYfhcbDUf_]g\caYhcUWc``YWh]cbcZaU^cf
]bgh]hih]cbg ]bW`iX]b[h\Yncc h\Y[c`ZWcifgY UbXgYjYfU`]bgh]hih]cbgcZ`YUfb]b["
Gcfh]b[cihh\Yfc`Ygh\YgY]bgh]hih]cbga][\hd`Um]bUbYkWcbgYfjUbWmhcc_gcaYh]aY
UbXh\YbcbdfchkUgbh`UibW\YXibh]``UhY&$%%"IbXYf]hg%$!mYUfU[fYYaYbhk]h\h\Y
W]hm h\YWcbgYfjUbWmcjYfgYYgXU]`mcdYfUh]cbgUbXWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhgcb%,(UWfYg cf
^ighcjYf\U`Zh\YdUf_"
6YZcfYVf]b[]b[h\Y]XYUhch\YdiV`]W 7UhYg G\cfVUbXch\YfdUf_W\Uad]cbggWcihYX
Yl]gh]b[WcbgYfjUbW]Yg gc`]W]hYXUXj]WYZfca`cWU`ZcibXUh]cbg UbX\cbYXh\Y]f
Yld`UbUhcfmd]hW\Yg"H\Ub_ghch\UhbYhkcf_]b[ h\YfYWfi]haYbhcZUdckYf\cigYVcUfX
W\U]fYXVm7UhYg UbXei]YhVihYZZYWh]jYZibXfU]g]b[ h\YWcbgYfjUbWm`UibW\YXcbU
ghfcb[bchYk]h\acfYh\Ub*a]``]cb]bgYYXacbYm"KYkYfYUh][\hcf[Ub]nUh]cb
VYZcfYkYYjYbZcfaYX gUmgGi``]jUb"
H\Ymcib[WcbgYfjUbWmei]W_`mgWcfYXhkc[fYUhgiWWYggYg WfYUh]b[CjYfhcb6Uf_ U
`Uf[YUbXdcdi`UfcZZ!`YUg\Xc[UfYU UbXfYjUad]b[h\YFU]bVck@U_YD`Um[fcibX Ub
UXjYbhifYgdUWYZcfmcib[W\]`XfYb"6ihh\YZcibXYfggccbX]gWcjYfYXh\Uhh\Ym\UX
bY[`YWhYXhcZcfai`UhYUdf]cf]h]nYX`]ghcZ]adfcjYaYbhg"Gi``]jUbgUmgh\Uhk\Ybg\Y
hcc_h\Y\Y`ajYacbh\gUZhYfh\YWcbgYfjUbWmgZcibX]b[g\Y]b\Yf]hYXUdfc[fUah\Uh
acfYW`cgY`mfYgYaV`YXh\YVcUfXaYaVYfgk]g\`]ghh\UbgcaYh\]b[VUgYXcbUaUghYf
d`Ub"H\fYYdfc^YWhgkYfY]bh\YXYg][bd\UgYk]h\cih\Uj]b[[cbYVYZcfYh\YdiV`]WZcf
WcaaYbhUbXk]h\cihUbmbUbW]U`cfghU[]b[[i]XUbWY"9jYfmh\]b[kUggYYbUgacgh
]adcfhUbh gUmgGi``]jUb"CbYcZh\Yfghh\]b[g=\UXhcXckUgYghUV`]g\U\]YfUfW\mcZ
bYYX"
K\]`Yh\YWcbgYfjUbWmVi]`hUghfcb[kUfW\YghZcf]hgfghWUd]hU`dfc^YWhg ]hZUWYgU
`cca]b[W\U``Yb[Y]bXYjY`cd]b[UgighU]bUV`YZibX]b[ghfYUa]bUW]hmk]h\cihU`ch
cZdf]jUhYkYU`h\":cfcbYh\]b[ h\YfY]gUbch\YfaU^cfdUf_WcbgYfjUbWm]bAYad\]g
h\YcbYZcfG\Y`Vm:UfagDUf_ cbh\YW]hmgkYU`h\]YfYUghg]XY"7cadcibX]b[h\]g
W\U``Yb[Y CjYfhcbDUf_7cbgYfjUbWm\UgU[fYYXhchU_YcbU\YUjmdfcdcfh]cbcZ
dUf_aUbU[YaYbh"IbXYf]hgacghfYWYbhU[fYYaYbhk]h\h\YW]hm g][bYX]b&$%& h\Y
WcbgYfjUbWmdUmgZcfj]fhiU``mU``cZh\YdUf_gWcghg ]bW`iX]b[ih]`]h]YgUbX]bgifUbWY
VYmcbXh\YW]hmgUbbiU`Wcbhf]Vih]cbcZcb`m%)$ $$$hckUfXcdYfUh]cbgUbX%) $$$
hckUfXih]`]h]Yg"H\YW]hmU`gcU[fYYXhcdfcj]XYUddfcl]aUhY`m%$$ $$$dYfmYUf
hckUfXgWUd]hU`]adfcjYaYbhg Vihcb`mh\fci[\&$%*"H\YfYZcfY h\YWcbgYfjUbWm]g
ZcWigYXcbZifh\YfXYjY`cd]b[]hgVcUfX YldUbX]b[ZibXfU]g]b[YjYbhg UbX]bWfYUg]b[
cddcfhib]h]YgZcfWcfdcfUhY[]j]b["
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
45
5gUbUXX]h]cbU`hf]U`h\YWcbgYfjUbWmaighVU`UbWYh\YWcadYh]b[]bhYfYghgcZh\YdUf_g
igYfgUbX]hgWi`hifU`]bgh]hih]cbg"H\YAYad\]gNcc AYad\]g6fcc_gAigYiacZ5fh
UbXAYad\]g7c``Y[YcZ5fh[YbYfUhY\YUjmWUfhfUZW k]h\h\YnccU`cbYZfYeiYbh`m
W`U]a]b[Zi``mcbY!h\]fXcZh\YWYbhfU`;fYYbgkUfXZcfcjYfckdUf_]b[":ibX]b[ZcfU
aiW\!bYYXYXnccdUf_]b[[UfU[Y\UgdfcjYbY`ig]jY k\]`Y7]h]nYbghcDfchYWhCjYfhcb
DUf_\Ug]bWfYUgYXh\YWcibhYfjU]`]b[dfYggifYVm`UibW\]b[UWUadU][bWU``YX;YhCZZ
Cif@Ukb
K]h\UbibXYfZibXYXW]hmdUf_gmghYaUbXUXfUaUh]WYld`cg]cbcZdf]jUhY!gYWhcf
Ybh\ig]UgaZcfdUf_g AYad\]g]gW`YUf`mUW]hmhckUhW\"Cb`mh]aYk]``hY``]Z]hg
WcbgYfjUbW]YgWUb`YUXUdUf_fYbU]ggUbWYh\Uh\UgY`iXYXh\YdiV`]WgYWhcf]bfYWYbh
XYWUXYg"
O v erton Pa rk Conse rva nc y
184
1901
Park created
2011
Conservancy founded
$1,210,906
Expenditures*
$2,456,492
Revenue*
100%
0%
Employees
33
Volunteers
38
29 general directors,
9 ex officio**
Some
Board structure
Conservancy manages operations/maintenance?
Yes
Yes
No
*Annual, 2012
**Ex-officio: Parks Director, Zoo, College of Art, Museum of Art, Levitt Shell, Rhodes College, Lick Creek Stormwater
Coalition, Citizens to Protect Overton Park, Evergreen Historic District Association, and Park Friends.
46
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
Conclusion
H\fci[\cihaiW\cZh\YWcibhfm h\]g]gU[c`XYbU[YZcfg][bUhifYifVUbdUf_g":fca
6cghcbhc<cighcb BYkMcf_hcGUb:fUbW]gWc 5h`UbhUhcD]hhgVif[\hcGh"@ci]ghc
8Yhfc]h VYUih]Zi`c`XXYgh]bUh]cbdUf_gUfYVY]b[fYbYkYX UbXgcaY[fYUhbYkcbYgUfYVY]b[
WfYUhYX"
=bUbU[YcZUVibXUbhdf]jUhYkYU`h\UbXUWcbghfU]bYXdiV`]WgYWhcf dUf_ggYYa`]_YU`c[]WU`
UfYUcZh\YdiV`]WfYU`ahcVYbYhZfcadf]jUhYgiddcfhacfYW]fWiagWf]VYXUbXYUg]Yfhc
aUbU[Yh\Ubdfc[fUaghcgc`jY\caY`YggbYggUbXdcjYfhm cf]adfcjYYXiWUh]cb"=g]hUbm
kcbXYfh\UhUdUf_WcbgYfjUbWmgYYag`]_YU[ccX]XYUhcd\]`Ubh\fcd]ghgUbXaUmcfgU`]_Y3
5gZcfh\Y[YbYfU`diV`]W k\ckci`XbhkUbhhcVY[]jYbk\UhgcibXg`]_YUZfYYdUf_3
CZWcifgY Uggiadh]cbgUfYbhU`kUmgWcffYWh"DUf_gUfYaiW\hci[\YfhcaUbU[Yh\Ubh\Ym
UddYUf"8cbUh]cbgZfcah\YkYU`h\mcZhYbWcaYk]h\ghf]b[gUhhUW\YX"DiV`]WgYWhcfViX[Yhg
UfYbchib]Zcfa`mWcbghfU]bYX"5bXh\Y[YbYfU`diV`]W]gWcad`UWYbhcb`mibh]`UWcbhfcjYfgm
Uf]gYg"
=bg\cfh WcbgYfjUbW]YgUfYbch[iUfUbhYYXk]bbYfg"GcaY\UjYVYYbk]`X`mgiWWYggZi`
ch\Yfg\UjYghfi[[`YXjU`]Ubh`m UbXUZYk\UjYZU`hYfYX^igh`]_Yh\YUffUmcZ[cjYfbaYbh
U[YbW]Ygh\YmdUfhbYfk]h\"7cbgYfjUbWm`YUXYfgaighWcbghUbh`mVYUkUfYcZh\YYbj]fcbaYbh
]bk\]W\h\YmUfYZibWh]cb]b[bchcb`mYWc`c[]WU`VihU`gcbUbW]U`UbXdc`]h]WU`"AcbYmWUb
VY\i[Y`mX]ghcfh]b[ dc`]h]WgWUbVf]b[bUghmgifdf]gYg UbXZYkW]hm]bgh]hih]cbgUfYUgdUgg]cb!
UhY`mckbYXVmh\YdiV`]WUg]Wcb]WdUf_g"
H\Y`YggcbgZfcah\YifVUbdUf_WcbgYfjUbWmYldYf]YbWYh\igZUf\UjYVYYbW`YUf"
7cbgYfjUbWmcdYfUh]cbgbYYXhcVYhfUbgdUfYbh WcbgYfjUbWmVcUfXgaighVYVfcUX!VUgYXUbX
fYdfYgYbhUh]jYcZh\YdiV`]W WcbgYfjUbWm]bdihUbXXYW]g]cb!aU_]b[aighVYWUfYZi``mdUWYX
UbXkY``!diV`]W]nYX WcbgYfjUbWmghUZZaighVYhfYUhYXUgkY``Ugkcf_Yfg]bh\YdiV`]WgYWhcf
UbXWcaaib]WUh]cbk]h\h\YdiV`]WaighVYcihghUbX]b[ZfcadfYggfY`YUgYghcg][bU[Y"=b
aUbmkUmg UWcbgYfjUbWmaighXcYjYfmh\]b[h\UhUW]hmdUf_U[YbWmXcYg k\]`YU`gc[YbYf!
Uh]b[U`chcZXcbUh]cbg"5`h\ci[\WcbgYfjUbW]YgWUbgcaYh]aYgcdYfUhYk]h\[fYUhYfZfYYXca
UbX`Uh]hiXYh\UbW]hmU[YbW]Yg h\YmaighhU_YWUfYbchhcWcaa]hh\YUVigYgh\UhdfcadhYX
[cjYfbaYbhfi`Yg]bh\Yfghd`UWY"
K]h\h\]g]ba]bXUbXk]h\U[YbYfcig kY``!WcbbYWhYX \UfX!kcf_]b[VcUfXcZX]fYWhcfg
UbXUgUjjmYlYWih]jYUWcbgYfjUbWmWUbfU]gYUdUf_idhc\Y][\hg]h\UgbhgYYb]bXYWUXYg ]Z
YjYf"Cbh\Ych\Yf\UbX UWcbgYfjUbWmh\Uh]gWUgiU``mWcbghfiWhYXcf]bUXYeiUhY`mbifhifYX
WUbfib]bhch\YgUaYgYhcZdfcV`Yagh\Uh`YXhcUdUf_gXYW`]bYibXYf]hgcf][]bU` U``!
[cjYfbaYbhaUbU[YaYbhghfiWhifY"KY\cdYh\]gfYdcfh\Y`dgW]hmdUf_`cjYfgcZYjYfmghf]dY
fYUdh\YVYbYhgUbXghYYfW`YUfcZh\Yd]hZU``g"
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
47
Acknowledgments
K\]`YU``YffcfgcZZUWhcf]bhYfdfYhUh]cbUfYgc`Y`mh\YUih\cfg kYk]g\hcUW_bck`YX[YUbX
h\Ub_h\YZc``ck]b[]bX]j]XiU`gZcf[fYUh`mUgg]gh]b[h\]gdfc^YWh.
9`U]bY5gUfW\ ?Uh\m6`U\U 8ci[6`cbg_m MjYhhY6ckXYb >YggY6fUW_YbVifm 7Ufc`7\Ub[
AY[7\YYjYf @]bXU7cl >i`]Y7fcW_gZcfX F]W\UfX8c`Yg\ GiY8cbc[\iY ;Ycf[Y
8igYbVifm DYhYf9``gkcfh\ H\caUg<YffYfU!A]g\`Yf @Yg`Ym<cZZUfh\ >Ybb]ZYf<cddU 8Ub
>cbYg @]bXU?YYbUb AUfh\U?Y``m <Ybfm@YY @]bXm9]W\YbVUia@Ybh >UW_@]bb ?Uh\fmb
Chh@cjY`` >]aAUbb 8YVV]YAW7ckb @UifUAcff]g 5bbYC`gcb 6]``Dcc`Y GigUb
FUXYaUW\Yf 7Uh\mFcgYbVUia A]_YGYafUi Fc[YfG\ck`Ym 6YhgmGa]h\ 8cfYYbGhc``Yf
H]bUGi``]jUb HiddYfH\caUg BUca]JUbHc` AUf[UfYhKU``g =f]gKY]bg\U`` UbXA]a]
N]bb]Y`"
flickr/lauren parker
DYhYf<Ufb]_]gX]fYWhcfcZH\YHfighZcfDiV`]W@UbXg7YbhYfZcf7]hmDUf_9lWY``YbWY
UbXUih\cfcZbiaYfcigUfh]W`YgUbXVcc_g ]bW`iX]b[C`PO\5`SS\(7\\]dObWdS>O`YaT]`@Sac`US\b
1WbWSa5VVmAUfh]b]gfYgYUfW\WccfX]bUhcfcZh\Y7YbhYfUbXYX]hcfcZh\YUbbiU`1Wbg>O`Y
4OQba"5XX]h]cbU`fYgYUfW\Zcfh\]gfYdcfhkUgdfcj]XYXVm7c`YYb;Ybh`Yg"
Shelby Farms Park Conservancy reinvigorated Memphiss largest park, a former penal farm.
Among the new features is the 3.5-acre Woodland Discovery Playground, which the conservancy
built and now maintains.
48
public spaces/private money: the triumphs and pitfalls of urban park conservancies
7YbhYfZcf7]hmDUf_9lWY``YbWY
H\YHfighZcfDiV`]W@UbX
**$DYbbgm`jUb]U5jY"G9 Gi]hY($%
KUg\]b[hcb 8"7"&$$$'
&$&")('"+))&
b^Z]`UQQ^S
BUh]cbU`CZZ]WY
H\YHfighZcfDiV`]W@UbX
%$%Acbh[caYfmGh" Gi]hY-$$
GUb:fUbW]gWc 75-(%$(
(%)"(-)"($%(
b^Z]`U