Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
P RESSURE L OSSES IN T HE
C IRCULATING S YSTEM
INTRODUCTION
The pressure at the surface is the summation of the frictional pressure losses in the
components of the circulating system. The pressure at the surface is given by Equation 6-1 and
is illustrated in Figure 6-1.
Equation 6-1
Normally in good drilling operations, the pressure loss through the bit will be approximately 50
percent of the surface pressure. The flow regime through the surface connections and inside
the drill string is turbulent and is usually 60 to 80 percent of the remaining 50 percent of the
surface pressure. The flow regime in the annulus is generally laminar and is usually 20 to 40
percent of the circulating frictional pressure losses excluding the bit.
TURBULENT FLOW
The majority of the pressure losses in the circulating system are in turbulent flow. These
include the pressure losses in the surface connections, drill pipe and drill collars. A turbulent
6-1
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
R e = 15.47
6-2
Dv m
Equation 6-2
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
PV
.
3 .2
The frictional pressure loss is related to the friction factor by Equation 6-3.
P=
m v 2 lf
Equation 6-3
9.298(10 4 )D
0.100000
Riveted Steel
0.010000
Concrete
1
e=0.03
2
e/D
e=0.01
0.001000
e=0.003
e=0.001
e=0.00085
0.000100
e=0.0005
e=0.0004
5
e=0.00015
0.000010
1
e=0.000005
10
100
6-3
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
Certainly, the friction factor diagrams can be used; however, for convenience, most draw a best
straight line and write the equation for that line. Equation 6-4 is the line for e / D = 0.0006 which
corresponds to commercial steel with a 4 inch diameter.
f =
0.0458
Re
Equation 6-4
0.19
For drawn tubing of a similar diameter which is hydraulically smooth, the relationship is given by
Equation 5.
f =
0.058
Re
Equation 6-5
0.22
Combining Equations 6-2, 6-3, and 6-4 and substituting PV / 3.2 for viscosity gives Equation 66 for pressure losses in commercial steel pipe with an inside diameter of approximately 4
inches.
P=
Equation 6-6
Similarly, combining Equations 6-2, 6-3, and 6-5 and substituting PV / 3.2 for viscosity gives
Equation 6-7 for pressure losses in hydraulically smooth pipe such as plastic coated drill pipe of
approximately 4 inches in diameter.
P=
7.86(10 -5 ) m
0.78
Q 1.78 PV 0.22 l
D 4.78
Equation 6-7
Equations 6-6 and 6-7 may be modified for annular flow and are given as Equation 6-8 and 6-9
respectively.
P=
P=
7.86(10 -5 ) m
(D h D p ) 3 (Dh + D p )1.81
0.78
Q 1.78 PV 0.22 l
Equation 6-8
Equation 6-9
Hydraulic calculators offered by different service companies offer frictional pressure loss
calculations based on equations similar to Equations 6-6 through 6-9 and are considered
sufficiently accurate for field use.
The surface connections are the segment from the pressure gauge on the standpipe to the top
of the drill pipe and are composed of the standpipe, hose, swivel and kelly. Generally, one of
four cases or combinations is applicable. The four classes commonly considered are given in
6-4
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
Table 6-1. The frictional pressure loss in the surface connections may be determined by
applying Equation 6-6 or 6-7 to each component or by utilizing one of the commercially available
hydraulic calculators. Consider Example 6-1.
Table 6-1. Surface Connection Combinations
STANDPIPE
HOSE
SWIVEL
KELLY
40' - 3"
45' - 2"
20' - 2"
40' 2"
40' 3"
55' 2"
25' 2"
40' 3"
45' - 4"
55' - 3"
25' - 2"
40' 3"
45' - 4"
55' - 3"
30' - 3"
40' - 4"
Example 6-1
Given:
Determine:
Solution:
Using Equations 6-6 and 6-7 and two hydraulic calculators, determine the
frictional pressure loss in:
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
A.
Surface connections
6-5
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
The following data can be obtained from Table 4-5 (Chapter 4 Drilling
Fluids).
m = 15 ppg
PV = 29 cp
Yp = 7 lbf/100ft2
The ID and lengths of each of the components can be found in Table 6-1.
Hydraulic Calculator A: Using Equation 6-6 for the standpipe:
P=
P=
7.68(10 5 ) m
0.81
Q 1.81PV 0.19 l
D 4.83
7.68(10 5 )(15) 0.81 (147 )1.81 ( 29) 0.19 ( 40)
(3.5) 4.83
= 1 psi
Hose:
P=
= 7 psi
Swivel:
P=
= 3 psi
Kelly:
P=
= 1 psi
Psurf = 1 + 7 + 3 + 1 = 12 psi
Hydraulic Calculator B: Using Equation 6-7, the results for the standpipe:
P=
Hose: P =
6-6
= 1 psi
= 7 psi
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
Swivel:
P=
= 3 psi
Kelly:
P=
= 1 psi
Psurf = 1 + 7 + 3 + 1 = 12 psi
B.
Hydraulic Calculator A
P = 15 psi
Hydraulic Calculator B
P = 15 psi
Drill pipe
Equation 6-6
Pdp =
= 1,766 psi
Equation 6-7
Pdp =
C.
Hydraulic Calculator A
Hydraulic Calculator B
= 1,665 psi
Drill Collars
Equation 6-6
Pdc =
= 1,262 psi
Equation 6-7
Pdc =
(1.5) 4.78
= 1,157 psi
6-7
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
v =
24.5Q
Equation 6-10
D2
(24.5)(147 )
2.602 2
= 532 fpm
R e = 15.47
R e = 15.47
Dv m
Figure
6-3,
m v 2 lf
9.298(10 4 )D
Pdp =
E.
from
= 1,638 psi
( 24.5)(147 )
1 .5 2
= 1,601 fpm
(1.5)(1,601)(15 )
= 61,492
( 29 / 3.2)
6-8
= 1,127 psi
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
As illustrated in Example 6-1, the frictional pressure loss calculations made with the hydraulic
calculators are in good agreement with the calculated values. Generally, neglecting the
pressure loss in the surface connections will not result in significant error. Use of the calculators
for other parts may result in errors of ten percent or more. In addition, knowledge of drill pipe
condition can affect accuracy. Coated drill pipe should be hydraulically smooth or at least
approach those values of roughness for drawn tubing. However, uncoated or old drill pipe can
be very rough inside and under those conditions; the roughness of commercial steel should be
used. Diameters significantly different from the 4 inches assumed in developing Equations 6-6
and 6-7 demand that the friction factor chart approach be used. The friction factor charts are
most accurate. Equations 6-6 and 6-7 are more accurate within their defined limits than are the
hydraulic calculators. When in doubt, dig in and check it out.
It should be equally obvious that the turbulent frictional pressure losses are significantly affected
by the volume rate of flow. Pump efficiencies can be almost anything. Check pump efficiency
by isolating a tank of known volume such as a trip tank and measure the time required to pump
a known volume. This exercise is necessary if accuracy is required.
9 .14 (10 5 ) m Q 2
An
Equation 6-11
Example 6-2 shows how the Equation 6-11 can be used to calculate pressure loss through the
bit.
Example 6-2
Given:
Determine:
Solution:
An = / 4 S12 + S 22 + S 32
Equation 6-12
11 2 11 2 12 2
An = / 4 + + = 0.2961 in2
32 32 32
Using Equation 11, the pressure loss at the bit is:
6-9
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
Pbit =
Pbit =
9.14(10 5 ) m Q 2
An
9.14(10 5 )(15)(147 ) 2
(0.2961) 2
= 338 psi
LAMINAR FLOW
Laminar flow is a smooth ordered flow. Fluids are either Newtonian, such as water, or nonNewtonian such as drilling mud. Drilling muds most often follow the power law model of
behavior. That is, the shear stress-shear rate diagram is a straight line when plotted on log-log
paper with slope ' n ' and intercept ' k '.
The velocity profiles for laminar and turbulent
flow are compared in Figure 6-5.
As
illustrated, the turbulent velocity profile is very
flat with the maximum velocity approximately
equal to the average velocity. For Newtonian
liquids, the maximum velocity is exactly twice
the average velocity.
For non-Newtonian
fluids, the average velocity is more than onehalf the maximum velocity. Generally, the
more non-Newtonian behavior exhibited, the
flatter the velocity profile.
Highly nonNewtonian fluids are characterized by yield
point to plastic viscosity ratios greater than
one. They are also characterized by the
combination of very low power law ' n ' in
combination with a high ' k '. Expenditures to
do nothing more than flatten the velocity
profile cannot be justified. In addition, some
have suggested that "plug" flow can be
obtained such that over some finite portion of
the velocity profile, the change in velocity with
distance ( dv / dr ) is zero. (See Figure 6-5B.)
In other words, the center of the flow stream
would behave as a solid. Obviously, such a
condition cannot exist. However, since the
drilling fluid is shear thinning, the velocity
profile is flatter at low velocities. This concept
is well known in cementing to improve
displacement when turbulent flow is
impossible or undesirable. There is no known
procedure to quantify any (if there is any)
advantage to drilling.
Distinguishing between turbulent and laminar
flow has always been a problem. With classic
Figure 6-5. Velocity Profiles
6-10
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
fluids such as water, turbulence occurs at a Reynolds Number of 2,000. With non-Newtonian
fluids, the transition can occur anywhere between Reynolds Number of 2,000 to 4,000. Below a
Reynolds Number of 2,000, turbulent flow is not possible. Critical velocity is normally defined as
that velocity at which the flow regime becomes turbulent. In drilling operations, the critical
velocity should be defined as that annular velocity below which turbulence is impossible and
above which turbulence is possible. It is important to distinguish that turbulence is possible but
not certain. By this definition, the critical velocity would be the velocity at Reynolds Number
equal to 2,000. Equations 6-13 and 6-14 define the velocity at Reynolds Number equal 2,000
above which turbulence may occur.
Pipe Flow
1
3.88(10 4 )k
1 .6 3 n + 1 2 n
V2,000 =
2 n
m
D 4n
Equation 6-13
1
2.4 2n + 1 n
2.59(10 4 )k
2 n
V2,000 =
2 n
Dh D p 3n
Equation 6-14
Annular Flow
The equations for calculating n and k were given earlier in Chapter 4 Drilling Fluids, but are
repeated here.
n = 3.32 log 2
1
where 2 = 2 1
k=
1
n
dv
dr 1
Example 6-3 shows how the equations can be used to determine the velocity where the flow
may be turbulent.
Example 6-3
Given:
Determine:
a.
b.
Velocity inside the drill pipe when the Reynolds Number is 2,000.
a.
Solution:
n = 0.43
6-11
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
k = 2.45
1
2.4 2n + 1 n
2.59(10 4 )k
2 n
V2,000 =
2 n
Dh D p 3n
1
0.43
2.59(10 4 )(2.45)
2.4 (2)(0.43) + 1 20.43
V2,000 =
= 212 fpm
20.43
15
6.5 3.5 (3)(0.43)
The annular velocity in the drill pipe annulus at 147 gpm can be
calculated as follows:
v =
v =
24.5Q
Equation 6-15
(D h 2 D p 2 )
(24.5)(147 )
( 6.5 2 3.5 2 )
= 120 fpm
Since the actual annular velocity is less than the critical velocity,
the flow in the drill pipe annulus is laminar.
b.
3.88(10 4 )k
1 .6 3 n + 1 2 n
V2,000 =
2 n
m
D 4n
0.43
3.88(10 4 )(2.45 )
1.6 (3 )(0.43 ) + 1 20.43
V2,000 =
= 250 fpm
20.43
15
2.602 ( 4)(0.43 )
The velocity inside the drill pipe can be calculated using Equation
6-10.
v =
(24.5)(147 )
2.602 2
= 532 fpm
Since the velocity inside the drill pipe is greater than the critical
velocity, the fluid is in turbulent flow.
Example 6-3 illustrates that the annular velocity of 120 fpm is below 212 fpm which is the
annular velocity at Reynolds Number 2,000 and, therefore, could not be turbulent. By similar
analogy, the velocity inside the drill pipe of 532 fpm is well above 250 fpm, the velocity at
Reynolds Number equal to 2,000; therefore, the flow inside the drill pipe could be turbulent.
The flow regime is best determined by analyzing the frictional pressure losses. Consider the
representative friction factor chart in Figure 6-6. Remembering from Equation 6-3 that the
frictional pressure loss is to be determined at points 'A and B and that the flow regime is
6-12
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
unknown. At point A, the laminar friction factor, fL and therefore, the laminar frictional
pressure loss, PL is greater than corresponding fL and PT. By examination, the flow is
laminar. At point B, the opposite is true. The turbulent friction factor, fT, and corresponding
frictional pressure loss, PT, are greater than the values, assuming laminar flow and by
observation the flow is turbulent. Therefore, to determine the flow regime and determine the
proper calculation, calculate both the laminar and turbulent pressure losses. The greater
numerical value is more accurate and determines the flow regime.
Pipe Flow
Bingham Plastic:
Power Law:
P=
(PV )v l
90,000D
Yp l
225D
1.6v 3n + 1
P =
D 4n
kl
300D
Equation 6-16
Equation 6-17
6-13
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
P=
Equation 6-18
300 D
1.6v 3n + 1
D 4n
rpm =
Equation 6-19
Equation 6-20
1.7
Annular Flow
(PV )v l
P=
Power Law:
2.4v 2n + 1
kl
P =
Dh D p 3n 300(Dh D p )
P=
60,000(Dh D p )
+
2
Yp l
Bingham Plastic:
200(Dh D p )
Equation 6-21
Equation 6-22
Equation 6-23
300(Dh D p )
2.4v 2n + 1
D h D p 3n
Equation 6-24
Example 6-4 will demonstrate the use of the above equations in calculating the frictional
pressure loss in the drill pipe annulus.
Example 6-4
6-14
Given:
Determine:
b.
c.
d.
Hydraulic Calculator
e.
f.
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
Solution:
g.
a.
Pdpa =
b.
(PV )v l
60,000(Dh D p )
Yp l
200(Dh D p )
(7)(16,375 )
= 297 psi
200(6.5 3.5)
2.4v 2n + 1
kl
Pdpa =
Dh D p 3n 300(Dh D p )
(2.4)(120 ) (2)(0.43) + 1
Pdpa =
6.5 3.5 (3)(0.43)
c.
0.43
( 2.45 )(16,375 )
= 371 psi
300( 6.5 3.5)
The direct shear stress approach using Equations 6-23, 6-24 and
6-20.
2.4v 2n + 1
D h D p 3n
(2.4)(120 ) (2)(0.43 ) + 1
= 138 sec -1
rpm =
rpm =
1.7
138
= 81 rpm
1.7
d.
(16,375 )(20 )
= 364 psi
300(6.5 3.5)
6-15
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
e.
The frictional pressure losses in the drill collar annulus using the
Power Law Model can be calculated using Equation 6-22, but first
calculate the velocity in the drill collar annulus.
v =
( 24.5)(147 )
( 6 . 5 2 4 .8 2 )
= 188 fpm
(2.4)(187 ) (2)(0.43) + 1
Pdca =
6.5 4.8 (3)(0.43)
f.
0.43
(2.45)(818 )
= 51 psi
300(6.5 4.8)
g.
Theoretically, when the system pressure losses are plotted against flow
rate on log-log paper, a straight line will result. By plotting two points on a
piece of graph paper and drawing a straight line through those points, the
flow rate at any pressure can be determined. It has already been
determined that a flow rate of 147 gpm will result in a standpipe pressure
of 3,594 psi. An arbitrary flow rate of 100 gpm was chosen for the second
point on the graph. A standpipe pressure of 1,942 psi was calculated
using the procedure for the pressure at 147 gpm. Figure 6-7 can be
6-16
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
constructed using these two data points. From this figure, a flow rate of
134 gpm will yield a standpipe pressure of 3,100 psi. If the flow rate of
147 gpm represents a pump efficiency of 92%, then the actual pump
efficiency in this case is 85%.
As illustrated in Example 6-4, the Bingham Plastic Model does not result in accurate solutions.
The Power Law Model and Direct Shear Stress approach should result in the same answer.
Part "e" illustrates that the value obtained using the hydraulic calculator is considerably less
than that obtained from any other approach. All hydraulic calculators assume a turbulent model.
Pursuant to the previous discussion, the assumption of a turbulent model will result in low
values when the flow is actually laminar.
The total system pressure loss is calculated to be 3,594 psi. In this actual field example, the
surface pressure was observed to be 3,100 psi. The pump efficiency was assumed to be 92%.
As illustrated in Figure 6-7, an actual volume rate of flow of 134 gpm, which represents a pump
efficiency of 85%, would result in a surface pressure of 3,100 psi. Another source could be the
effect of temperature in the annulus. Another source could be eroded drill pipe. It should be
obvious that blindly calculating without considering these variables can lead to garbage for
answers. An accuracy of plus or minus 10 percent should be easily obtained.
Figure 6-7. Plot of Flow Rate versus Pressure for Example 6-4
6-17
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
Pdpa + Pdca
Equation 6-25
(0.052)(TVD )
The equivalent circulating density is just a way of making it easier to understand annular friction
losses. While circulating, the annulus sees higher pressures. The pressures within the annulus
are equal to a column of mud with the density equivalent to the ECD and the pump off.
Therefore, the annulus experiences pressure increases while circulating. In most cases, the
ECD is small but the ECD can be significant in deep wells with smaller diameter holes.
Example 6-5 illustrates the calculation of the equivalent circulating density for the well in
Example 6-1.
Example 6-5
Given:
Example 6-1 and the annular friction losses in Example 6-4 b. and e.
Determine:
Solution:
From Example 6-4b, the friction losses in the drill pipe annulus are 371
psi and from Example 6-4e, the friction losses in the drill collar annulus
are 51 psi.
ECD = m +
ECD = 15 +
Pdpa + Pdca
(0.052)(TVD )
371 + 51
= 15.47 ppg
(0.052 )(17193 )
In Example 6-5, the annular friction losses are equivalent to 0.47 ppg and the equivalent
circulating density is 15.47 ppg. If the hydrostatic pressure was close to the frac gradient, the
ECD in this well could make a significant difference.
NOMENCLATURE
6-18
An
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
Dh
Dp
dv
dr
ECD
Length, feet
Power Law constant, normally the slope of shear stress-shear rate diagram
on log-log plot
P
Pbit
Pdc
Pdca
Pdp
Pdpa
Ps
Psurf
Pressure loss in surface connections from the gauge to the top of the drill
pipe, psi
PV
Q
Plastic viscosity, cp
Re
rpm
S1
S2
S3
TVD
V2,000
v
Yp
=
=
viscosity, cp
1 and 2
6-19
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
SI UNITS
The Equations given in the chapter are given below in SI units
d p f Vs
Equation 6-2:
Rp =
Equation 6-3:
P=
Equation 6-6:
P=
Equation 6-7:
P=
6,190,000 m
Equation 6-8:
P=
4,550,000 m
Equation 6-9:
P=
Equation 6-10:
v =
Equation 6-11:
Pbit =
Equation 6-26
60 e
m v 2 lf
Equation 6-27
1,804D
Equation 6-28
D 4.83
0.78
Q 1.78 PV 0.22 l
Equation 6-29
D 4.78
0.81
Q 1.81PV 0.19 l
Equation 6-30
Equation 6-31
(D h D p ) 3 (D h + D p )1.78
1,273,000Q
Equation 6-32
D2
184,000 m Q 2
An
Equation 6-33
Equation 6-13:
9,720,000k 2n 41 3n + 1 2n
V2,000 = 0.3048
m
D 4n
Equation 6-34
Equation 6-14:
1
n
6,490,000k 2n 61 2n + 1 2n
V2,000 = 0.3048
m
Dh D p 3n
Equation 6-35
Equation 6-15:
v =
6-20
1,273,000Q
Dh 2 D p 2
Equation 6-36
Drilling Practices
Pressure Losses in The Circulating System
(PV )v l
P=
Equation 6-17:
133v 3n + 1
P =
D 4n
Equation 6-18:
P=
Equation 6-19:
133v 3n + 1
D 4n
Equation 6-21:
P=
(PV )v l
Equation 6-22:
200v 2n + 1
4kl
P =
Dh D p 3n (Dh D p )
Equation 6-23:
P=
Equation 6-24:
Equation 6-25:
ECD = m +
1.88D 2
5.33Y p l
Equation 6-16:
Equation 6-37
D
n
4kl
D
4l
Equation 6-38
Equation 6-39
1.23(Dh D p )
Equation 6-40
+
2
6.05Y p l
( Dh D p )
Equation 6-41
4l
Equation 6-42
Equation 6-43
(Dh D p )
200v 2n + 1
Dh D p 3n
Pdpa + Pdca
(0.0098 )(TVD )
Equation 6-44
Equation 6-45
D
Dh
Dp
Diameter of hole, mm
dv
dr
Pipe roughness, mm
ECD
6-21
Drilling Practices
Chapter 6
Length, meter
Power Law constant, normally the slope of shear stress-shear rate diagram
on log-log plot
P
Pbit
Pdc
Pdca
Pdp
Pdpa
Ps
Psurf
Pressure loss in surface connections from the gauge to the top of the drill
pipe, kPa
PV
Q
Re
rpm
S1
Diameter of nozzle 1, mm
S2
Diameter of nozzle 2, mm
S3
Diameter of nozzle 3, mm
TVD
V2,000
Critical velocity where the Reynolds Number is equal to 2,000, meters per
minute
Yield point, Pa
1 and 2
v
Yp
6-22