Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
<
M.
Casals,*
<`
<
P. Gorrindo,* E. Masdeu,* J. A.
A.
Cayla;*`
Orcau,*
<
and the
TB
was 6.4% in 2009 among the general population aged .16 years, and has been rising since
1993.
A recent population-based study showed a DM prevalence in adults of 13.8%, with
approximately 6% of cases remaining undiagnosed.11 In Barcelona, DM prevalence among
TB cases in 2013 was 6.6%. The increasing prevalence is related to an aging population, low
income levels, changes in lifestyles, obesity and improvements in diagnosis and notification,12 changes that are occurring ever more rapidly in low- and middle-income countries.13
Our hypoth- esis was that the epidemiological profile of industri- alised countries is different
from that of low-income countries due to better monitoring and control of DM.
The present study aimed to assess the relationship between DM and TB in an industrialised
country with an intermediate TB burden and to help establish priorities for epidemiological
control of both diseas- es, as suggested by other authors.2,3,6,14,15 The study also aimed to
analyse the evolution of DM prevalence and identify associated factors among adults with TB
Correspondence to: Antonio Moreno-Martnez, Epidemiology Service, Agencia` de Salut
Publica de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain. Tel: (34) 932 384 555. Fax: (34) 932 182 275. email: amoreno@aspb.cat
Article submitted 29 January 2015. Final version accepted 28 June 2015.
Subjects
All cases aged 718 years diagnosed with active TB between 1 January 2000 and 31 December
2013, residing in Barcelona and detected by the Programme for Prevention and Control of
Tuberculosis of Barcelona (PPCTB), were included in the study.
Variables
We analysed sociodemographic, clinical and treat- ment data that had been collected
systematically using PPCTB epidemiological questionnaires routine- ly administered by
nursing personnel of the Barcelona Public Health Agency (Agencia` de Salut Publica de
Barcelona, ASPB) Epidemiology Service and their evolution.
Definitions
A diagnosis of DM was based on information provided by the patient, recorded in medical
charts and systematically reviewed by public health person- nel and/or fasting plasma glucose
.126 mg/dl.18 TB cases were defined in accordance with epidemiolog- ical criteria. A TB
patient was defined as anyone who had been prescribed and had received anti-tubercu- losis
treatment, except for those who had died or defaulted from treatment due to side effects.
Diag- nosed TB cases were classified according to the European Surveillance Network
criteria: a possible TB case was defined as a subject who met the clinical criteria for TB; a
probable case as one who met clinical criteria for TB, and was also smear-positive or
presented granulomas on histological testing, or was positive on a nucleic acid amplification
test (NAAT); a confirmed TB case was defined as a case who, in addition to being smearpositive, was also culture- or NAAT-positive.19 Subjects were considered to have multidrugresistant TB (MDR-TB) if their strains were resistant to at least isoniazid (INH) and
rifampicin (RMP), or extensively drug-resistant TB when, in addition to MDR-TB, they were
also resistant to all fluoroquinolones and at least one of the three injectable second-line drugs.
Cases with non-tuberculous mycobacteria were excluded.
Statistical analysis
We conducted a descriptive study to calculate DM prevalence among the patients included.
We also calculated frequency distributions for qualitative variables, and measures of central
tendency and precision for quantitative variables. Potential factors associated with DM were
analysed at bivariate level by comparing proportions between groups using the v2 test. At
multivariate level, we fitted a logistic regression model using the stepwise-selection method
and included those factors found to be associated at bivariate level with P , 0.1. We calculated
odds ratios (ORs) and their associated 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Model fit was assessed
using the Hosmer-Lemeshow test. In all analyses, P , 0.05 was considered statistically
significant. Analyses were performed using IBM Statistical Package for the Social Sciences
Statistics, version 19 (IBM Corp, Armonk, NY, USA) and the compareGroups package of the
R statistical system (R Computing, Vienna, Austria). DM trends were obtained using the
classical v2 test for trends in proportions (as implemented in the R function prop.trend.test).
Ethical considerations
As the data were obtained from questionnaires administered by ASPB Epidemiology Service
nursing personnel as part of routine monitoring of notifiable diseases, ethics approval was not
considered neces- sary, and subjects were not required to provide informed consent. Data
were processed anonymous- ly, respecting strict confidentiality in accordance with the ethics
principles of the 1964 Helsinki Declaration (revised in 2000 by the World Medical
Association) and in accordance with the 1999 Spanish Data Protection Act.
RESULTS
Of the 5849 adult TB patients included in the study, 349 (5.97%) had DM. The proportion
with DM among the included patients rose slightly over the 14- year study period, from 6.2%
in 2000 to 6.7% in 2013 (P 0.351) (Figure). The median age of the DM patients was 63
years (Quartile [Q] 1 50, Q3 74);
study found that DM prevalence among adult TB patients in Barcelona had remained stable
in recent years. The prevalence observed in 2013 was similar to the estimate for the general
population, between 4.8% and 18.7%,15 and lower than the 13.8% observed in a populationbased survey conducted in Spain.11 In 2006, however, a study carried out in Madrid among
the TB population aged .64 years concluded that DM was the second greatest risk factor for
TB, with a prevalence of
12.3%.21 Other chronic health-affecting behaviour, such as smoking, or new treatment
regimens using immunosuppressors, have also been identified as risk factors for the
development of TB.21,22 This study found no differences on multivariate analysis, al- though
immunosuppressive treatment was more common among adults with DM, and no differences
were found on the basis of smoking, homelessness, or history of incarceration or of previous
TB.
One of the factors found to be associated with DM among TB patients included being
Spanish-born. Differences between the Spanish-born (8.1%) and the immigrant population
(3%) may be due to the lower prevalence of overweight subjects and perhaps also lower DM
prevalence among immigrants, who tend to be younger than native Spaniards with TB.12,13
According to Spains National Health System Strategy for DM (Estrategia en Diabetes del
Sistema Nacional de Salud), DM, especially type 2 DM, was related to obesity, age .68 years,
lower physical activity and low education level, and the non-Spanish born seem to have a
lower prevalence of DM.12 More studies should be performed to analyse the reasons for
these differences.
Sex was not associated with DM, while age 740 years was. Although we could not determine
the type of DM in subjects analysed in this study due to the manner in which data for this
variable were collected, it is known that the prevalence of type 2 DM increases with age.12
Adults with DM were more likely to require hospitalisation and present with adverse effects
than non-diabetics. Infections can contribute to glycaemic imbalance and may occasionally
require the admin- istration of insulin during the initial phases. It should also be noted that
some anti-tuberculosis drugs may favour the appearance of disorders associated with DM, as
is the case with INH, or may alter the metabolism of other chronic treatment drugs and
increase glucose levels, as is the case with RMP.5
Although DM has been related to M. tuberculosis resistance5 and to delayed sputum
conversion,20 this study did not find DM to be associated with INH or RMP resistance or
MDR-TB, nor to the degree of positivity of sputum cultures at the initiation of antituberculosis treatment. The reason may be the low prevalence of resistance in our setting,
particularly among native Spaniards. In 2012, the rate of INH resistance was 6.4% among
native Spaniards and 8.6% among immigrants; the corresponding figures for RMP were
respectively 0.9% and 1.7%.17
Contrary to reports from India,6 we found no clear association between extra-pulmonary or
purely pul- monary forms of TB (in comparison to mixed forms) among adults with DM.
However, we did find an association between presence of cavitation on CXR, as reported by
some authors,5,22 and the number of cases for which no CXR information was available.
No
Yes
Multivariate
analysis
n
Clinical form of TB
Pulmonary, smearpositive
Pulmonary, smearnegative,
culture-positive
Extra-pulmonary
Pulmonary, culturenegative
Sex
Female
Male
Age group, years
1839
740
Country of birth
Foreign
Spain
n (%)
n (%)
OR
(95%CI)
P value
OR
(95%CI)
P value
0.88 (0.66
0.379
1.17)
0.99 (0.76
1597 1498(93.8 99 (6.2)
0.957
1.30)
0.87 (0.58
606 573 (94.6)33 (5.4)
0.474
1.27)
1498 1415(94.5)83 (5.5)
Reference Reference
2.84 (2.20
1.46 (1.11
3388 3113(91.9)275(8.1)
,0.001
0.008*
3.72)
1.96)*
New case
Yes
No
506
Reference Reference
1.00 (0.66
476 (94.1)30 (5.9)
0.989
1.44)
Chest X-ray
1.27 (0.97
1.42 (1.08
0.079
,0.001*
1.64)
1.86)*
Abnormal, no cavitation3409 3221(94.5)188(5.5) Reference Reference
1.76 (0.81
2.36 (1.06
Unknown
98
89 (90.8)9 (9.2)
0.143
0.021*
3.37)
4.71)*
1.10 (0.81
1.16 (0.85
Normal
1033 971 (94) 62 (6)
0.548
0.317*
1.46)
1.58)*
Homelessness
Yes
428 405 (94.6)23 (5.4) Reference Reference
1.12 (0.74
No
5421 5095(94) 326(6)
0.606
1.78)
Alcoholism
Yes
1212 1129(93.2)83 (6.8) Reference Reference
0.83 (0.64
No
4637 4371(94.3)266(5.7)
0.150
1.07)
Smoker
Yes
2418 2268(93.8)150(6.2) Reference Reference
0.93 (0.75
No
3431 3232(94.2 199(5.8
0.521
1.16)
Cavitation
History of incarceration
Yes
161
No
156 (96.9)5
IDU/HIV status
IDU, HIV
IDU, HIV
300
299 (99.7)1
(0.3)
IDU, HIV
336
330 (98.2)6
(1.8)
IDU, HIV
70
63
Hospitalisation
No
Yes
Unknown
Prior
immunosuppressive
treatment
No
Yes
Adverse effects of
treatment
No
Yes
Died
No
Yes
(90) 7
0.05 (0.00
,0.001
0.24)
0.27 (0.10
,0.001
0.55)
1.63 (0.67
(10)
0.259
3.35)
0.04
(0.002
0.001*
0.19)*
0.27 (0.10
0.002*
0.57)*
1.85 (0.74
0.144*
3.99)*
* Statistically significant.
OR odds ratio; CI confidence interval; TB tuberculosis; IDU injection drug use;
negative; HIV human immunodeficiency virus; positive.
Some studies have suggested that DM increases not only the risk of acquiring TB but also the
severity of the disease, the number of relapses and the risk of death due to TB.5,2325
However, this study did not find the rate of any-cause mortality during anti- tuberculosis
treatment to be significantly associated
with DM. The lack of clinical and analytical data did not permit us to establish a relationship
between these events and poor DM control, as suggested in some studies.5,26
In this study, HIV infection was associated with a lower probability of DM, in contrast to the
results of
to be taken into consideration when developing TB control pro- grammes to achieve better
coordination among programmes targeting DM, smoking, HIV, etc.
Acknowledgements
Other members of TB-Diabetes Working Group of the Barcelona TB Investigation Unit
(Unidad de Investigacion en Tuberculosis de Barcelona, UITB): M L De Souza-Galvao, M
A Jimenez-Fuentes (Unitat de Tuberculosi, Vall dHebron-Drassanes Hospital Uni- versitari,
Vall dHebron, Barcelona); I Molina, A Curran (Infectious Diseases Department, Hospital
Universitari de la Vall dHebron, Barcelona); M A Sambeat, V Pomar (Infectious Diseases
Unit, Hospital de la Santa Creu i Sant Pau, Barcelona); H Knobel, F Sanchez-Martnez
(Hospital del Mar, Instituto Hospital del Mar de Investigaciones Medicas, Barcelona); J A
Martnez, J M Miro (Infectious Diseases Service, Hospital Clnic de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain).
Conflicts of interest: none declared.
References
1 World Health Organization. Diabetes. Fact sheet N8 312. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO,
2014. www.who.int/mediacentre/ factsheets/fs312/en/ Accessed July 2015.
2Walker C, Unwin N. Estimates of the impact of diabetes on the incidence of pulmonary
tuberculosis in different ethnic groups in England. Thorax 2010; 65: 578581.
3Jeon C Y, Murray M B. Diabetes mellitus increases the risk of active tuberculosis: a
systematic review of 13 observational Studies. PLOS MED 2008; 5: e152.
4Martnez N, Kornfeld H. Diabetes and immunity to tuberculosis. Eur J Immunol 2014; 44:
617626.
5Dooley K E, Chaisson R E. Tuberculosis and diabetes mellitus: convergence of two
epidemics. Lancet Infect Dis 2009; 9: 737 746.
6Viswanathan V, Kumpatla S, Aravindalochanan V, et al. Prevalence of diabetes and prediabetes and associated risk factors among tuberculosis patients in India. PLOS ONE 2012; 7:
e41367.
7Magee M J, Foote M, Maggio D M, et al. Diabetes mellitus and risk of all-cause mortality
among patients with tuberculosis in the state of Georgia, 20092012. Ann Epidemiol 2014;
24: 369375.
8Kibirige D, Ssekitoleko R, Mutebi E, Worodria W. Overt diabetes mellitus among newly
diagnosed Ugandan tuberculosis patients: a cross sectional study. BMC Infect Dis 2013; 13:
122 129.
9Ponce-de-Leon A, Garcia-Garcia M L, Garca-Sancho M C, et al. Tuberculosis and diabetes
in southern Mexico. Diabetes Care 2004; 27: 15841590.
La regression logistique a et utilisee pour calculer les odds ratios (OR) et leurs intervalles
de confiance (IC) a` 95%.
Sur un total de 5849 patients TB, 349
R E S U LTAT S :
(5,9%) avaient un DM. La prevalence annuelle du DM allait de 4,0% a` 7,2%. Les facteurs
associes au DM ont et naissance en Espagne (OR 1,46 ; IC95% 1,111,96) ;
RESUME
age de 740 ans (OR 6,08 ; IC95% 4,368,66) ; profil cavitaire de la radiographie pulmonaire
(OR 1,42 ; IC95% 1,081,86) ; survenue de plus deffets secondaires au traitement antituberculeux (OR 1,86 ; IC95% 1,282,64) ; et hospitalisation au moment du diagnostic (OR
1,8 ; IC95% 1,402,31). Linfection a` virus de limmunodeficience humaine a et associee
avec une probabilite plus faible de DM, chez les sujets ayant des antecedents dutilisation
de drogues injectables (OR 0,27 ; IC95% 0,100,57) et ceux sans ces antecedents (OR
0,04 ; IC95% 0,0020,19).
C O N C L U S I O N : La prevalence du DM parmi les adultes atteints de TB a` Barcelone
est faible et est restee stable tout au long des 14 annees. Cependant, les patients TB avec
DM ont et potentiellement plus contagieux et plus compliques en termes de prise en charge
clinique.
M A R C O D E R E F E R E N C I A: La diabetes mellitus (DM) puede contribuir al
desarrollo de tuberculosis (TB).
O B J E T I V O: Analizar la prevalencia de DM entre los adultos con TB y los factores
asociados en una gran ciudad de un pas industrializado.
Estudio poblacional realizado en adultos
M E T O D O S:
diagnosticados de TB entre 2000 y 2013 en Barcelona. Se estudiaron factores sociodemogra
ficos, clnicos y epidemiologicos potencialmente asociados. Se utilizo regresion logstica
para calcular odds ratios (OR) con intervalos de confianza (IC) del 95%.
R E S U LTA D O S: De un total de 5849 pacientes con TB, 349 (5,9%) tenan DM. La
prevalencia anual de DM fue del 4,0% al 7,2%. Los factores asociados con DM fueron ser
espanol (OR 1,46; IC95% 1,111,96); tener 740 anos (OR 6,08; IC95% 4,368,66);
cavitacion en
RESUMEN
la radiografa de torax (OR 1,42; IC95% 1,081,86); presentar ma s efectos secundarios del
tratamiento antituberculoso (OR 1,86; IC95% 1,282,64); y hospitalizacion en el momento
del diagnostico (OR 1,8; IC95% 1,402,31). La infeccion por virus de la inmunodeficiencia
humana se asocio con una baja probabilidad de tener DM, tanto con antecedentes de abuso
de drogas inyectadas (OR 0,27; IC95% 0,10 0,57) como en su ausencia (OR 0,04; IC95%
0,002 0,19).
C O N C L U S I O N E S: La prevalencia de DM entre los adultos con TB en Barcelona es
baja y ha permanecido estable entre 2000 y 2013. Sin embargo, los pacientes con TB y DM
son potencialmente mas contagiosos y su manejo clnico mas complicado.