Sei sulla pagina 1di 110

KANNUR UNIVERSITY

SCHOOL OF
DISTANCE EDUCATION

II. M.Com
Paper XV
Corporate Accounting

Lessons Prepared by :

Chapters : 1,2,4 and 5


1) Ms. T. K. Jeeshma
P.G. Dept. of Commerce
S.N. College, Kannur-7

2) Chapter : 3
Prof . Jinachandran N.
P.G. Dept. of Commerce
S.N. College, Kannur -7

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form, by any means
(Electronic, Photocopying, Recording or otherwise) without prior written permission from the Kannur University.

Copy right Director, SDE 2007

SYLLABUS

PAPER XV CORPORATE ACCOUNTING

1. Amalgamation, Absorption and External Reconstruction of Companies - Inter-company owings inter-company holdings - internal reconstructions - scheme of capital reductions - steps for reconstructions
2. Liquidation of companies - meaning - methods of winding up - preparation of statement of affairsdeficiency/surplus account - liquidators final statement of accounts-receivers statement of accounts
3. Insurance claims - computation of fire claims-loss of profits - loss of stock - consequential loss
policy
4. Analysis and interpretation of financial statements - nature - characteristics - types of statements interpretation of statements - tools and techniques of analysis - common-size statements - comparative statements-trend analysis - common-size balance sheet and income statement.
5. Double account system-meaning-double account system Vs double entry system - main features of
double account system - advantages and disadvantages-accounts for electricity companies - legal
provisions - reasonable returns - clear profits - disposal of surplus - final accounts.

Books recommended :
1. S.N. Maheswari

: Corporate Accounting

2. S.P. Jain & K.L. Narang

: Advanced Accounting

3. Arulanandam & Raman

: Advanced Accounting

4. K. Br. Paul

: Accounting

5. B.S. Raman

: Advanced Accounting

6. R.L. Gupta

: Principles of Accounting

7. M.C.K Nambiar

: Advanced Accounts

CONTENT

Page No.

1. Amalgamation

5-37

2. Liquidation of Companies

38-51

3. Insurance Claims

52-59

4. Analysis and Interpretation of Financial Statements

50-97

5. Double Account System

98-110

UNIT - 1

AMALGAMATION; ABSORPTION AND


RECONSTRUCTION

OBJECTIVES
The objectives of this lesson are to:

Explain the meaning of Amalgamation, Absorption and Reconstruction

Discuss the methods of Accounting for Amalgamation and Reconstruction

STRUCTURE
1. 00

Meaning of Amalgamation, Absorption and Reconstruction

1. 01
1.02
1.03
1.04
1.05
1.06
1.07
1.08

Types of Amalgamation
Purchase consideration
Method of Accounting for Amalgamations
Journal entries to close the books of transferor company
Journal entries in the books of transferee company
Illustration
Alteration of share capital and Internal reconstruction
Illustration
Assignments

Amalgamation, Absorption and Reconstruction


1.00

MEANING

Amalgamation is a form of combination. It is brought about by blending of two or more undertakings


carrying on the same type of business or engaged in the same line of business activity. When two or more
existing companies merge themselves into a newly formed company, they lose their independent legal status.
Thus two liquidations and a formation characterise amalgamation.
Amalgamation may also be brought about by the transfer of one or more undertakings to an existing undertaking so as to result in merger of the undertakings. This form of combination is generally known as absorption.
However, the accounting standard (AS-14) of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India does not distinguish between amalgamation and absorption.
Reconstruction is a process by which the affairs of a company are reorganised by revaluation of assets,
reassessment of liabilities and by writing off the losses already suffered by reducing the paid up value of shares
and / or varying the rights attached to different classes of shares. The object of reconstruction is usually to
reorganise capital or to compound with creditors or to effect economies. Such a process is called Internal
Reconstruction which is carried out without liquidating the company and forming a new one. However, there
may be external reconstruction. Wherever an undertaking is being carried on by a company and is in substance
transferred, not to an outsider, but to another company consisting substantially of the same share holders with a
view to its being continued by the transferee company, there is external reconstruction. Such external reconstruction is essentially covered under the category amalgamation in the nature of merger in AS-14

1-1 Types of Amalgamation


The Companies Act, 1956 has not specifically defined the term Amalgamation. However, from several
legal decisions, the definition of Amalgamation may be inferred. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
has introduced Accounting Standard -14 (AS-14) on Accounting for Amalgamations. The standard recognises
two types of Amalgamation. They are:
(a) Amalgamation in the nature of merger and
(b) Amalgamation in the nature of purchase.
Amalgamation in the nature of merger is an Amalgamation which satisfies all the following conditions.
(i) All the assets and liabilities of the transferor company become, after Amalgamation, the assets and
liabilities of the transferee company.
(ii) Share holders holding not less than 90% of the face value of the equity shares of the transferor company
(other than the equity shares already held therein, immediately before the amalgamation, by the transferee
company or its subsidiaries or their nominees) become equity shareholders of the transferee company by virtue
of the amalgamation.
(iii) The consideration for the amalgamation receivable by those equity shareholders of the transferor company who agree to become equity share holders of the transferee company is discharged by the transferee
company wholly by the issue of equity shares in the transferee company, except that cash may be paid in respect
of any fractional shares.

(iv) The buisiness of the transferor company is intended to be carried on, after amalgamation, by the transferee company.
(v) No adjustment is intended to be made to the book values of the assets and liabilities of the transferor
company when they are incorporated in the financial statements of the transferee company except to ensure
uniformity of accounting policies.
If any one or more of the above conditions are not satisfied in an amalgamation, such amalgamation is called
amalgamation in the nature of purchase. For example, if the business of the transferor company is not intended
to be carried on by the transferee company after amalgamation, there is amalgamation in the nature of purchase.

1-2 Purchase consideration


The consideration or the price payable by the transferee company to the transferor company for taking over
the business of the latter, is known as a purchase consideration. Para 3 (g) of AS-14 defines the term Purchase
consideration as the aggregate of the shares and other securities issued and the payment made in the form of
cash or other assets by the transferee company to the shareholders of the transferor company. Therefore,
purchase consideration does not include the sum which the transferee company will directly pay to the creditors
of the transferor company.

Net Assets method


Net asset means excess of assets over liabilities taken over, if purchase consideration is to be as ascertained
under the net assets method, it is necessary to determine the fair value of assets and liabilities. Thus purchase
consideration is arrived at by adding the fair value of the assets taken over and deducting therefrom the total fair
value of liabilities taken over. While adding up the fair value of assets taken over, it is necessary to include cash
and bank balances also, if the transferee company takes over all the assets of the transferor company. However
fictitious assets in the nature of preliminary expenses, brokerage and underwriting commission, profit and loss
account and similar items shown under the head Miscellaneous Expenditure should not be included amongst
the assets taken over.

Net payment method


Under this method, the amount of purchase consideration is determined on the basis of the aggregate of the
shares and other securities issued and the payment made in the form of cash or other assets to the shareholders
of the transferor company. The aggregate should not, therefore, include any payment made to debenture
holders or other outside liabilities of the transferor company. The same is true of realisation or liquidation expenses paid by the transferee company. In the case of payment to debenture holders and other outside liabilities,
the presumption is that they will be taken over by the transferee company and then paid out.

Inter-company transactions
In the context of amalgamation, whether in the nature of merger or purchase, we usually come across
certain inter-company transactions which might have created debtor- creditor relationship between the transferor and transferee companies even before any scheme of amalgamation.

If, at the time of amalgamation, it is found that the transferor company owes money to the transferee
company, or vice versa, debtors and creditors or bills receivable and bills payable accounts of the respective
companies include amounts owing by one to the other such inter-company indebtedness is known as inter company owings.

Account treatment
1) In the books of transferor company :- inter-company transactions do not require any special accounting
treatment in the books of the transferor company. Even if such transactions resulting in inter-company owings
are found in the books of the transferor company, a Realisation Account is opened and any owing to or owing
from the transferee company is transferred to this account as if the transferee company has taken over these
items.
2) In the books of transferee company :Even in the books of transferee company the usual entries for taking over assets and liabilities of the
transferor company and payment of purchase consideration are passed in spite of the existence of inter-company owings. However, the following adjusting entries are also passed.
For cancelling Debtors and creditors
Transferee companys creditors A/c
To Transferor companys

Dr
Debtors A/c

Transferor companys creditors A/c

Dr.

To Transferee Companys Debtors A/c

Adjustment of value of Stock


Inter-Company owings arise usually from purchase and sale of goods; it is likely, therefore, that at the time
of the sale of business, the debtor company also has goods in stock which it purchased from the creditor
company. The Cost of the debtor company will include the profit made by the creditor company. After the
takeover of the business, it is essential that such a profit is eliminated. The entry for this will be made by the
purchasing company. If it is vendor company which has such goods in stock at the time of passing the acquisition
entries, the value of the stock should be reduced to its cost to the company which is acquiring the business;
automatically goodwill or capital reserves as the case may be, will be adjusted. But if the original sale was made
by the vendor company and the stock is with the company acquiring the business the latter company will have to
debit Goodwill or (or Capital Reserve) and credit stock with the amount of the profit included in the stock

Methods of accounting for amalgamation


There are two main methods of accounting for amalgamation
a) The pooling of interest method and
b) The purchase method

The First Method is used in case of amalgamation in the nature of merger and the second method is used in
case of amalgamation in the nature of purchase.
Under pooling of interest method, the assets, liabilities and reserves of the transferor company will be taken
over by transferee company at existing carrying amounts unless any adjustment is required due to different
accounting policies followed by these companies. As a result, the difference between the amount recorded as
share capital issued (plus any additional consideration in the form of cash or other assets) and the amount of
share capital of transferor company should be adjusted in reserves
Under purchase method, the assets and liabilities of the transferor company should be incorporated at their
existing carrying amounts or the purchase consideration should be allocated to individual identifiable assets and
liabilities on the basis of their fair values at the date of amalgamation. But no reserves other than statutory
reserves of the transferor company should be incorporated in the financial statements of transferee company.
Statutory reserves of the transferor company should be incorporated in the balance sheet of transferee company
by way of the following journal entry :
Amalgamation adjustment A/c.
Dr.
To statutory Reserves A/c.
When the above statutory reserves will no longer be required to be maintained by transferee company, such
reserves will be eliminated by reversing the above entry.
In purchase method, any excess of the amount of purchase consideration over the value of the net assets of
the transferor company acquired by the transferee company, should be recognised as goodwill in the financial
statement of the transferee company. Any shortfall should be shown as capital reserves.

1-4

Journal entries in the books of transferor company

1) For transfer of assets taken over


Realisation A/c

Dr

To Each asset A/c

(with book value)

_________________________________________________________________________________
2) For transfer of liabilities taken over
Each liability A/c

Dr.

(with book value)

To Realisation A/c
_________________________________________________________________________________
3) For purchase consideration due
Transferee company A/c

Dr

(with the amount agreed upon)

To Realisation A/c
_________________________________________________________________________________
4.) For expenses of realisation
Realisation A/c
To Bank A/c
(When paid for by the transferor company)

Dr.

(with the amount paid)

No entry
(when paid for by the transferee company)
Alternatively :
If liquidation expense are met by the purchasing company or to be reimbursed by purchase consideration
already paid
a) for payment of expenses:
Purchasing company A/c
Dr.
To Bank A/c
b) For getting the expense reimbursed
Bank A/c

Dr.

To purchasing Company A/c


_________________________________________________________________________________
5) For adjustment of premium
Realisation A/c

Dr.

To pref. Shareholders A/c

(With the premium)

___________________________________________________________________________________
6) For sale of assets not taken over
Bank A/c

Dr

(with total)

To Each asset A/c

(with Book value)

To Realisation A/c

(with profit on Sale)

__________________________________________________________________________________
7) For receipt of purchase consideration
Shares in Transferee company A/c
Dr.
Debentures in Transferee Company A/c Dr.
Bank A/c
Dr
To Transferee Company A/c
_________________________________________________________________________________
8) For liabilities not taken over
Each liability A/c

Dr.

(book value)

To Bank A/c
_________________________________________________________________________________
9) a) For profit on realisation
Realisation A/c
Dr
To Equity Share holders A/c
b) For loss on realisation

10

Equity shareholders A/c


To Realisation A/c

Dr.

_________________________________________________________________________________
10. For payment of preference share capital
a) Pref. Share capital A/c

Dr.

(With book value)

To pref. Share holders A/c


b) Pref. Shareholders A/c

Dr.

To Bank A/c
11. For Transfer of capital and retained earnings
Equity share capital A/c

Dr.

General Reserves

Dr.

Profit and loss A/c

Dr.

Capital Reserve A/c

Dr.

To Equity share holders A/c


_________________________________________________________________________________
12. For Transfer of accumulated losses and fictitious assets
Equity shareholder A/c

Dr.

To profit and loss A/c


To preliminary Expenses A/c
To underwriting commission A/c
To Discount on issue of shares A/c
To Advertising suspense A/c
____________________________________________________________________________________
13. For payment to equity share holders :
Equity share holders A/c

Dr.

To shares in Transferee company A/c


To Debentures in Transferee company A/c
To Bank A/c
The important ledger accounts to be opened in the books of the transferor company are Realisation A/c,
Transferee company A/c, Equity Share capital A/c, Preference share capital A/c, Equity share in Transferee
company A/c, pref. Shares in Transferee company A/c, Debentures in Transferee company A/c and any other
asset or liability account not taken over by the transferee company.

11

1.5 Journal entries in the books of Transferee company


I. Pooling of interests method
According to para 31 of the Standard (AS-14), when an amalgamation is considered to be an amalgamation in the nature of merger, it should be accounted for under the pooling of interests method. Under this method
of accounting, the following journal entries become necessary.

Journal entries
1. For purchase consideration due :
Business purchase A/c

Dr.

To liquidator of Transferor Co.


___________________________________________________________________________________
2. For taking over assets and liabilities :
Each Asset A/c

Dr.

To Each liability A/c


To Each provision A/c
To Profit & loss A/c

(With book value)

To Reserve
To Business purchase A/c
________________________________________________________________________________________
3. For payment of purchase consideration
Liquidator of Transferor Company A/c

Dr.

(With purchase consideration)

To Share capital A/c


To share premium A/c
To Bank A/c
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
4.For realisation expense borne :
a)

Liquidation expenses A/c

Dr.

To bank A/c
b)

Profit and loss A/c

Dr.

To liquidation expenses A/c


___________________________________________________________________________________________
5. For formation expenses :
Preliminary Expenses A/c

Dr.

To Bank A/c

12

II Purchase Method
According to para 32 of the Standard (AS-14), when an amalgamation is considered to be an amalgamation in the nature of purchase, it should be accounted for under the purchase method. Accordingly the
following entries should be passed in the books of transferee under this method.
Journal Entries
1. For purchase consideration due :
Business purchase A/c

Dr.

To liquidator of transferor Co.


_______________________________________________________________________________________________
2. For assets and liabilities taken over
Each Asset A/c

Dr.

To Each liability A/c

(With fair value)

To Business purchase A/c


(The difference in the total of debit and credit will be transferred to Goodwill or Capital Reserves)
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
3. For discharge of purchase consideration
Liquidator of transferor Comp. A/c
Dr.
To share capital A/c
To Share premium A/c
To Debentures A/c
To Bank A/c
___________________________________________________________________________________________
4.For Realisation expenses borne
Goodwill A/c
Dr.
(With the expenses)
To Bank A/c
__________________________________________________________________________________
5. Preliminary expense
Preliminary expense A/c

Dr.

To Bank A/c
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

1-6

Illustration -I (Amalgamation in the nature of merger)

The Pig Iron Company Ltd. agrees to absorb the business of the Iron Ore company Ltd. and to take
over the assets and liabilities at their balance sheet values, in exchange for which it is to issue 12 shares of
Rs. 10 each for every share of Rs 100 each in the Iron Ore Company Ltd. The expense of absorption Rs.
10,000 will be paid by the Pig Iron Company Ltd. On the date of absorption, ie, 31st March 2003, the balance
sheets of the two companies were as under:

13

The Iron Ore Company Ltd.


Liabilities

Rs.

Assets

Rs.

5000 Equity shares of


Rs 100 each

5,00,000

Land and Buildings

3,00,000
2,00,000

General Reserve

35,000

Machinery and plant

Bills payable

35,000

Sundry Debtors
less provision

55,000
5,000
50,000

Creditors

40,000

Stock

25,000

Bank

35,000

6,10,000

6,10,000

The pig Iron Company Ltd.


Liabilities

Rs.

1,00,000 Equity Shares

Assets

10,00,000

of Rs 10 each

General Reserve

80,000

Creditors

1,00,000

Rs.

Land and Buildings

5,00,000

Machinery and Plant

3,00,000

Goodwill

1,00,000

Stock

60,000

Debtors

1,20,000

Bank

1,00,000

11,80,000

11,80,000

You are required to :a) pass the necessary journal entries in the books of Pig Iron Company Ltd.
b) Prepare the balance sheet of Pig Iron Company Ltd. after the amalgamation in the nature of merger.
Solution
Purchase consideration
5000 x 12 = 60000 shares x Rs 10
= 6,00,000

14

Pig Iron Co. Ltd.


Journal Entries
Date

Particulars
Business purchase A/c

LF
Dr.

Debit

Credit

Rs

Rs.

6,00,000

To Liquidator of Iron Ore Co. Ltd.

6,00,000

(Being the purchase consideration due)


General Reserve A/c

Dr.

65,000

Land & Buildings A/c

Dr.

3,00,000

Machinery & Plant A/c

Dr

2,00,000

Debtors A/c

Dr.

55,000

Stock A/c

Dr.

25,000

Bank A/c

Dr.

35,000

To Bills Payable

35,000

To creditors

40,000

To Provision for doubtful debts

5,000

To Business purchase A/c

6,00,000

(Being the assets and liabilities taken over


from Iron Ore Co. Ltd)
Liquidator of Iron Ore Co. Ltd

Dr.

6,00,000

To Equity share capital A/c

6,00,000

(Being allotment of shares in Settlement


of purchase consideration)
Liquidation Expense A/c

Dr.

10,000

To Bank A/c

10,000

(Being the entry for payment of liquidation


expenses Iron Ore. Co. Ltd.)
General Reserves A/c

Dr.

To Liquidation Expenses A/c

10,000
10,000

(Being the entry for transfer of liquidation


Expenses to reserve)

15

BALANCE SHEET OF PIG IRON Co. As at 1-4-2003


Rs

Rs

SHARE CAPITAL

FIXED ASSETS

Issued and subscribed 16,000

Goodwill

1,00,000

Land & Buildings

8,00,000

(of these 60,000

Machinery & Plant

5,00,000

equity shares were issued for

CURRENT ASSETS

consideration other than cash)

Stocks

equity shares of Rs. 10 each

16,00,000

Debtors

85,000
1,75,000

Less provision

5,000

1,70,000

RESERVES & SURPLUS


General Reserve

5,000

Bank

1,25,000

CURRENT LIABILITIES
Creditors

1,40,000

Bills Payable

35,000
17,80,000

17,80,000

Note: The contents of para 35 of the standard (AS-14) are given effect to in the case of the pooling of
interest method applicable to an amalgamation in the nature of a merger as under
Purchase consideration

Rs

6,00,000

less: Equity share capital of


Iron Ore Co. Ltd.

5,00,000
1,00,000

less: General Reserves of Iron


Ore Co. Ltd.

35,000

Balance in debt

65,000

General Reserve of Pig Iron Co. Ltd

80,000

less debit balance as above

65,000

To be shown in the Balance sheet after


amalgamation

15,000

16

Since liquidation expenses of Rs. 10,000 paid by the transferee company are to be charged to profit and loss
account, the same are set off against the balance of reserve in the absence of profit and loss account.
Illustration 2 (Amalgamation in the nature of purchase)
The X Co. Ltd. and Y Co. Ltd. carry on business of a similar nature and it is agreed that they should
amalgamate. A new company XY Ltd. is to be formed to which the assets and liabilities of the existing companies with certain exceptions, are to be transferred. On 31st March, 2003, the balance sheet of the two companies were as under:X Co. Ltd. Y Co. Ltd
Rs.

X Co. Ltd. Y Co. Ltd

Rs.

Rs.

Issued capital

Land & buildings

15,000 shares of
Rs 10 each

1,50,000

8,000 shares of Rs 10 each

80,000

General Reserve

80,000

Profit and loss A/c

20,000

5% Debentures
Creditors

20,000

Rs.

1,05,000

60,000

Plant & Machinery

25,000

15,000

Motor Vehicles

10,000

Stock

60,000

78,000

Debtors

82,000

21,000

Cash

43,000

18,000

3,25,000

1,92,000

60,000
75,000

32,000

3,25,000

1,92,000

The assets and liabilities are to be taken over at book values with the following exceptions:
a) Goodwill of X Co. and Y Co. to be valued at Rs. 80,000 and Rs 30,000 respectively
b) Motor Vehicles of X Co. are to be valued at Rs. 30,000
c) Debentures of Y Co. are to be discharged by the issue of 5% Debentures of X Y Co. at a premium
of 4%
d) Debtors and cash of Y Co. are to be retained by the liquidator, and creditors are to be paid out of the
proceeds thereof.
Compute the basis on which shares in X Y Co. will be issued to shareholders in the existing companies.
Pass journal entries in the books of X Co. Ltd, Y Co. Ltd. XY Co. Ltd and draw up the balance sheet of XY Co.
Ltd. as at Ist April 2003.

17

Solution
Assets taken over :
X Co. Ltd.
Land and Buildings
Plant & Machinery
Motor Vehicles
Stock
Debtors

Y Co. Ltd.

Rs
1,05,000
25,000
30,000
60,000
82,000

Rs.
60,000
15,000
-------78,000
--------

43,000

--------

Cash

__________________________________________________________________________________
3,45,000

1,53,000

--------

62,400

Less liabilities :
5% Debentures

__________________________________________________________________________________
3,45,000

90,600

75,000

--------

Creditors

__________________________________________________________________________________
Net tangible assets

2,70,000

90,600

80,000

30,000

Add: Goodwill

__________________________________________________________________________________
Net assets or Purchase consideration
Mode of discharge:
a) In shares of XY Co. Ltd
35,000 equity shares of
Rs. 10 each (assuming face value
of shares is Rs. 10)

3,50,000

1,20,600

3,50,000

12000 Equity shares of Rs 10 each

1,20,000

b) Cash to avoid fraction

600

__________________________________________________________________________________
3,50,000
1,20,600
____________________________________________
___________________________________
___
Although purchase consideration consists of only equity shares and cash to avoid fraction, the amalgamation is in the nature of purchase since all the five conditions laid down in para 29 of Standard (AS-14) are not
satisfied. For instance, all the assets and liabilities of the transferor company are not taken over. Further, assets
are not transfered to the transferee company at their carrying amounts.

18

In the book of X Co. Ltd.


Journal Entries
Date

Particulars

LF

Debit
Rs

Realisation A/c
Dr.
To Land and Buildings
To Plant & Machinery
To Motor Vehicles
To Stock
To Debtors
To Cash
(Being the transfer of assets taken over
by the transferee company)
Creditors A/c
To Realisation A/c
(Being the transfer of creditors to
Realisation A/c)

Dr

XY Co, Ltd
To Realisation A/c

Dr.

Credit
Rs.

3,25,000
1,05,000
25,000
10,000
60,000
82,000
43,000

75,000
75,000

3,50,000
3,50,000

(Being the purchase consideration due)


Equity shares in X Y Co. Ltd
To X Y Co Ltd
(Being the receipt of Purchase
Consideration)

Dr.

3,50,000
3,50,000

Realisation A/c
Dr.
To Equity shareholders A/c
(Being the profit on realisation transferred
to shareholders account)

1,00,000

Share Capital A/c


Dr.
General Reserve
Dr.
Profit and loss A/c
Dr.
To Equity shareholders A/c
(Being the transfer of amounts due to equity
shareholders A/c)

1,50,000
80,000
20,000

Equity shareholders A/c


Dr.
To Equity shares in X Y Co. Ltd.
(Being the payment to equity share holders)

3,50,000

19

1,00,000

2,50,000

3,50,000

Date

Particulars

In the Books of Y Co, Ltd.


LF

Debit

Credit

Rs
Realisation A/c

Dr.

Rs.

1,53,000

To Land and Buildings

60,000

To Plant & Machinery

15,000

To Stock

78,000

(Being the transferor of assets taken over


by the transferee company)
5% Debentures A/c

Dr

60,000

To Realisation A/c

60,000

(Being the transfer of debentures)


XY Co. Ltd.

Dr.

1,20,600

To Realisation A/c

1,20,600

(Being the Purchase consideration due)


Equity shares in XY Co.

Dr.

1,20,000

Cash A/c

Dr.

600

To XY Co. Ltd.

1,20,600

(Being receipt of Purchase consideration)


Creditors A/c

Dr.

32,000

To Bank A/c

32,000

(Being the entry for paying off Creditors)


Realisation A/c

Dr.

27,600

To shareholders A/c

27,600

(Being the entry for profit on realisation)


Equity share capital A/c

Dr.

80,000

Profit and loss A/c

Dr.

20,000

To Equity shareholders A/c

1,00,000

(Being the transfer of share capital and net


profit to shareholders A/c)
Equity shareholders A/c

Dr.

To Equity shares in XY Co.

1,27,600
1,20,000

To Cash

7,600

(Being the payment to equity share holders)

20

Date

Particulars

In the Books of XY Co. Ltd


Journal Entries
LF

Debit
Rs

Business Purchase A/c

Dr.

Credit
Rs.

4,70,600

To Liquidator of X Co. Ltd

3,50,000

To Liquidator of Y Co. Ltd.

1,20,600

(Being the entry for acquiring the business


of X Co.and Y Co.
Land and Building A/c

Dr.

1,65,000

Plant and Machinery A/c

Dr.

40,000

Motor Vehicles A/c

Dr.

30,000

Stock A/c

Dr.

1,38,000

Debtors A/c

Dr.

82,000

Cash A/c

Dr.

43,000

Goodwill A/c

Dr.

1,10,000

To 5% debentures in Y Co

62,400

To Creditors A/c

75,000

To Business purchase A/c

4,70,600

(Being the assets and liabilities taken over)


Liquidator of X Co. Ltd.

Dr.

3,50,000

Liquidator of Y Co. Ltd

Dr.

1,20,600

To Equity share capital A/c

4,70,000

To Bank A/c

600

(Being the payment of purchase


consideration)
5% Debentures Y Co. A/c

Dr.

To 5% Debentures A/c

62,400
62,400

(Being the entry for discharging the old


debentures of Y Co. at a premium 4%)

21

BALANCE SHEET OF X Y Co. Ltd. (After Absorption) as at 1-4-2003


Liabilities

Rs.

Assets

Rs.

FIXED ASSETS
SHARE CAPITAL
Issued and Subscribed :

Goodwill

1,10,000

47000 equity shares

Land and Buildings

1,65,000

of Rs 10 each

Plant and Machinery

40,000

(Issued to vendors

Motor vehicles

30,000

for consideration other than cash)

Current Assets :

RESERVES & SURPLUS

Stock

secured loan:

Debtors

82,000

cash

42,400

5% Debentures

4,70,000

62,400

1,38,000

Current liabilities:
creditors

75,000
6,07,400

6,07,400

Note: As per AS-14 excess of purchase consideration over the value of net assets of the transferor company should be treated as Goodwill in the transferee companys Financial Statements. Similarly, if the amount of
Consideration is less that the value of net assets, the difference should be treated as capital reserve (Para 37)
INTER-COMPANY HOLDINGS
With reference to inter-company holdings, there may be three situations
(i) Shares held by the transferee company in the transferor company.
(ii) Shares held by the transferor company in the transferee company
(iii) Share held by both the companies in each other
(i) Shares held by the transferee company in the transferor company :The transferee company being a shareholder of the transferor company has a right to proportionate net
assets of the transferor company. Therefore, the absorbing company (Transferee company) buys only the net
assets belonging to outside shareholders. Usually, the absorbing company issues its own shares and debentures
in payment of the purchase consideration. This it does only in respect of amount due to outsiders. For the amount
due to itself it cannot receive its own shares.
Accounting treatment will be as under :
In the books of transferor company :

22

Purchase consideration is calculated for the entire undertaking either by the net assets or net payment
method as the case may be. The transferee company is debited with the full price, but credited with only what
is received in respect of outsiders. This leaves a debit balance representing the amount still receivable from the
purchasing company towards purchase Price. Likewise, in the shareholders account, since only outside shareholders are paid, there will be a credit balance representing the amount payable to the purchasing company as a
shareholders of the transferor (Vendor) company. The amount in question is neither paid by the transferee
company as the buyer of the business nor received by it as a shareholder. These two accounts will be closed by
means of the following set of entry.
Shareholders A/c

Dr.

To Transferee company A/c


In the books of transferee company:
In the books of purchasing company, the first two entries are passed as usual. However, when the question
of settling the amount due to the liquidator arises, payment is shown only in respect of what is due to outsider
and for the balance the shares in the transferor company are surrendered by crediting the investment account.
The journal entry is as follows:
Liquidator of transferor Co. A/c Dr.

(with full purchase price)

To share capital/Debenture/bank

(Amount payable to outsiders)

To Shares in the transferor Co.

(amount due to transferee (purchasing) company)

Any difference in the Shares in the vendor company account will be transferred to Goodwill or capital
reserve, as the case may be.
(ii) Shares held by the transferor company in the transferee company
In this case when the assets of the transferor company are acquired by the transferee company the
latter company cannot purchase its own shares.
If net payment method of purchase consideration is adopted, deduct the number of shares already held by
the transferor company from the shares agreed to be issued. Thus the shares held by the transferor company
before its absorption continue to be with them and are treated as part payment of purchase consideration. The
investment of the transferor company in share of the transferor company is not taken over by the transferee
company. Therefore investment in the shares (of the transferee company) should not be transferred to realisation
account.
Sometimes the issue price of the shares now received and the price at which the previous investment has
been acquired may differ. In such a case the investment in the transferee company already made must be
revalued by adopting the latest price and any profit and loss on such revaluation must be transferred to shareholders
account.
If the purchase consideration is calculated under the net assets method, the assets in the form of investment
in shares of the purchasing company are not taken into consideration.
(iii) Shares held by both the companies in each other

23

This is the case of cross holdings. Accounting treatment is explained as under:


a) Net payment method. Under this method, purchase price is calculated as follows:
(1) Calculate the number of shares to be issued to outside shareholders in the absorbed company.
(2) Calculate the number of shares due to transferee company as shareholders in the transferor company.
These however will not be issued. The value of these shares would be set off against shareholders
account.
(3) Add the shares calculated under (1) and (2) to get the total number of shares
(4) From the total under (3) deduct the number of shares already held by the absorbed company.
(5) Multiply the number of shares arrived at under (4) with the issue price and the resultant figure is
purchase consideration.

Illustration-3
The Balance sheets of Z Ltd. and A Ltd. as on March 31, 2000 are given below :
Z Ltd.

A Ltd.

Z Ltd.

A Ltd.

Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

Equity share capital


Rs. 10 each
Reserves and surplus

2,00,000

4,00,000

Sundry Assets

3,10,000

6,00,000

40,000

1,00,000

Loan to A Ltd

30,000

--------

9% Debentures
(Rs. 100 each)

Investments
1,00,000

--------

Loan from Z Ltd.

--------

30,000

Sundry creditors

50,000

70,000

3,90,000

6,00,000

5000 shares of A Ltd

50,000

3,90,000

6,00,000

A Ltd. proposes to takeover Z Ltd. on the following terms :


1)

A Ltd. will issue a sufficient number of its shares @ Rs. 11 each and pay Re. 0.50 cash per share helo
by members of Z Ltd.

2)

9% debentures of Z Ltd are to be paid at 8% premium by issue of a sufficient number of 10%


debentures of A Ltd. @ Rs. 90.

Assumining that the take over has been complete, show journal entries and ledger accounts in the books of
the companies and draft the Balance sheet in the books of A Ltd. (ACS inter)
Solution:

24

Calculation of purchase consideration


Total number of shares in Z Ltd. is 20,000 shares and so the number of shares to be issued by
A Ltd. to Z Ltd.

20,000

less shares of A Ltd. already held in Z Ltd.


The new shares to be issued

5000
15,000
Amount

Form

Rs.
Value of 15,000 shares @ Rs 11 each

1,65,000

shares

cash @ Re. 0.50 per share on


20,000 shares

10,000

cash

9 % Debentures 1,00,000
Add. 8% premium 8000

1,08,000

10% Debentures
of A Ltd.

2,83,000

(1,08,000 x 100)
90
Face value = 1200

Z Ltd.
JOURNAL
L/F
Realisation A/c
Dr.
To sundry Assets
To Loan to A Ltd.
(Being the assets transferred)
_____________________________________________
Sundry creditors
Dr.
To realisation A/c

Dr.

Cr.

Rs

Rs.

3,40,000
3,10,000
30,000

50,000
50,000

(Being the creditors transferred)


_____________________________________________
A. Ltd A/c

2,83,000

To Realisation A/c

2,83,000

(Being the purchase consideration received)

25

Shares in A Ltd.

Dr.

1,65,000

Cash A/c

Dr.

10,000

10 % Debentures in A Ltd

Dr.

1,08,000

To A. Ltd

2,83,000

(Being the purchase consideration received)


_____________________________________________
9% Debentures A/c Dr.

1,00,000

Realisation A/c Dr.

800

To Debenture holders A/c

1,08,000

(Being the amount due to debenture holders with a


premium of 8%)
_____________________________________________
Debenture holders A/c

Dr.

1,08,000

To 10% Debentures in A Ltd

1,08,000

(Being the debentures settled)


_____________________________________________
Investment A/c

Dr.

5,000

To realisation A/c

5,000

(Being the profit on revaluation @ Re. 1 on the 5,000


shares in A Ltd. held)
_____________________________________________
Share capital A/c

Dr.

2,00,000

Reserves and surplus A/c

Dr.

40,000

To Shareholders A/c

2,40,000

(Being the share capital and reserves transferred)


_____________________________________________
Shareholders A/c
To realisation A/c
(Being the loss on realisation transferred)

Dr.

10,000
10,000

_____________________________________________
Shareholders A/c
Dr.
To shares in A Ltd. (165000x55000)
To cash A/c
(Being the final settlement made by the allotment
of shares of A Ltd. together with the shares already
held and cash)

26

2,30,000
2,20,000
10,000

Realisation Account
Rs.
To sundry assets
,, Loans to A Ltd.
,, Debenture holders A/c

Rs.

3,10,000

By Sundry creditors

30,000

50,000

,, A Ltd. (Purchase consideration)

2,83,000

,, Investment A/c (profit on revaluation)

8,000

(Premium)

5,000

,, share holders A/c (LOSS)

10,000

3,48,000

3,48,000

ShareholdersAccount
Rs.
To Realisation (loss)
To shares in A Ltd.
To Cash

Rs.

10,000

By Share capital

2,20,000

2,00,000

By Reserves and surplus

40,000

10,000
2,40,000

2,40,000

A Ltd.
JOURNAL
L/F
Business Purchase A/c
Dr.
To Liquidators of Z Ltd.
(Being the purchase consideration payable)
_____________________________________________
Sundry assets
Dr.
Loan to A Ltd
To Sundry creditors
To Business purchase A/c
To Capital Reserve A/c
(Being the assets and liabilities taken over)

27

Dr.

Cr.

Rs

Rs.

2,83,000
2,83,000

3,10,000
30,000
50,000
2,83,000
7,000

Liquidators of A Ltd.
Discount on Debentures A/c

Dr.
Dr.

2,83,000
12,000

To Equity Share capital A/c

1,50,000

To share premium A/c

15,000

To 10% debentures

1,20,000

To cash A/c

10,000

(Being the settlement of the purchase


consideration due)
_____________________________________________
Loan from Z Ltd.

Dr.

30,000

To Loan to A Ltd.

30,000

(Being the inter-company loan cancelled)

Balance sheet of A Ltd. as on April 1, 2000


Liabilities

Rs

Assets

Rs

Share capital :
55,000 shares of

Sundry Assets

Rs 10 each

5,50,000

Reserves and surplus

1,00,000

Share premium

15,000

Capital reserve

7,000

10% Debentures

1,20,000

Sundry creditors

1,20,000

Discount on debentures

9,12,000

9,00,000
12,000

9,12,000

Alteration of share capital and Internal Reconstruction


According to section 94 of the Companies Act, a limited company can, if authorised by its Articles of
Association alter the capital clause of its Memorandum of Association in any of the following ways.
(a) Increase its share capital by issue of new shares
(b) Consolidation of shares :- Consolidate its existing shares of smaller amounts into shares of larger
amounts. For example, the existing 10,000 shares of Rs 10 each may be consolidated into 1000 shares
of Rs. 100 Each. The journal entry will be :
Share capital A/c (Rs 10 each) Dr. 1,00,000
To Share capital A/c (Rs100 each) 1,00,000

28

c)

Subdivision :- Subdivide its share capital of larger amount into shares of smaller amounts.

The entry will be :


Share capital A/c (Rs. 100 each)

Dr.

1,00,000

To share capital Account (Rs. 10 each)


d)

1,00,000

Conversion : Convert its fully paid shares into stock or reconvert its stock into fully paid shares.
Journal entry is :
Equity Share capital A/c

Dr

Equity capital stock A/c

To Equity capital stock A/c

or

Dr.

To Equity share capital A/c.

Internal Reconstruction or capital Reduction


Internal Reconstruction means the reduction of capital to cancel any paid up share capital which is lost or
unrepresented by available assets. This is generally resorted to write off past accumulated losses of the company.
The internal reconstruction and reduction of capital mean the same.
Reduction of capital is unlawful, except when sanctioned by the court because conservation of capital is one
of the main principles of the company law. The issued share capital of a company represents the security on
which the creditors rely. Companies usually, do not call the full value of shares at one time. The uncalled capital
acts as a future security for the companies creditors. Therefore, any reduction of capital reduces the security of
the creditors. Keeping this in view all safeguards have been provided for in the Companies Act to conserve the
capital of a company. However, in genuine cases, a company is permitted to reduce its share capital by section
100 in any of the following ways:
(a) Extinguish or reduce the liability
Where the shares of a company are partly paid-up, the company may extinguish or reduce the liability on its
shares. To that extent, the shareholders gain since they need not pay up the balance of uncalled share amount.
In this case, the total paid-up capital of the company remains the same although the partly paid-up shares
become fully paid-up.
The entry in the books of the company will be:
Equity share capital A/c (old)

Dr

To Equity share capital A/c (New)


( In both the cases the paid-up amount is the same)
Example :
X Ltd. having 10,000 equity shares of Rs 10 each, Rs. 7 paid up decides to cancel the liability of members to
the extent of Rs 3 per share and make shares of Rs 7 each fully paid. The entry is :
Equity share capital A/c (Rs 10)

Dr. 70,000

To Equity share capital A/c (Rs 7)


(Being the entry for converting partly paid up shares
of Rs. 10 each into fully paid-up shares of Rs. 8 each
by extinguishing liability of uncalled capital)

29

70,000

b) Refund or return of excess capital


When a company finds that it has a surplus capital, it may decide to reduce it by returning the surplus
part of capital to its members. Journal entries are as follows :
(i)

Equity share capital A/c (old)

Dr

To Equity share capital A/c (New)


To Equity share holders A/c (Amount to be returned)
(ii)

Equity shareholders A/c

Dr

To bank A/c
(On payment of money)
Example:
A Ltd with a share capital of 1,00,000 Equity shares of Rs 10 each fully paid decides to repay
members Rs. 2 per share thus making each share of Rs 8 fully paid.
The entry is:
Equity share capital A/c (Rs. 10)

Dr

10,00,000

To Equity share capital A/c (Rs 8)

8,00,000

To Equity share holders A/c (Rs. 2)

2,00,000

(Being the entry for reducing the face value


of each equity share of Rs. 10 each, to
Rs 8 each and refund of capital to share holders)
Equity shareholders A/c

Dr.

2,00,000

To bank A/c

2,00,000

(Being the entry for payment to shareholders)


c) Reduction of paid-up capital
When a company suffers losses continuously either due to bad investment policy or due to some other
reasons, it is often seen that the asset side of its balance sheet shows accumulated losses, and deferred expenses
like discount on issue of shares and debentures, preliminary expenses etc. In such companies any amount
appearing under heading goodwill is nothing but an example of an accumulated loss. In essence, capital of the
company, suffering losses continuously for a long period is not represented by the assets. The capital reduction
programme is a remedy under such circumstances. The according entry in this case would be:
Equity share capital A/c

Dr.

To capital Reduction A/c


(Being the entry for capital reduction)
Capital Reduction Account is a temporary account opened for carrying out the internal reconstruction and
will be closed when the scheme is carried out.
In case the face value of the equity / preference shares is changed with a view to reducing the paid-up value
of share capital, it becomes necessary to close the old share capital and open the new share capital account and

30

the difference between the two accounts should be credited Capital Reduction Account.
The entry would be:
Equity/preference share capital A/c (old)Dr.
To Equity/preference share capital A/c (New)
To capital Reduction A/c
(Being the entry for reducing the face value of shares and crediting
the amount of reduction to Capital Reduction Account)
In case the debenture holders and creditors agree to forgo a portion of the amount due to them, the entry
would be:
Debentures A/c

Dr.

Interest on Debentures A/c

Dr.

Creditors A/c

Dr.

To Capital Reduction A/c


(Being the entry for debenture holders
and creditors forgoing a portion of amount due to them)
Now, the losses can be written off with the help of Capital Reduction Account. The entry would be :
Capital Reduction Account

Dr.

To profit and loss A/c


To Preliminary expenses
To Discount on issue of shares
To Deferred revenue expenses
To Plant and Machinery
To Furniture and Fittings
To Goodwill
(Being the entry for fictitious assets and writing down other assets)
The balance, if any remaining in the Capital Reduction Account after writing off losses, will be transferred
to Capital Reserve Account. The journal entry is :
Capital Reduction A/c

Dr.

To capital Reserve.

31

Illustration:
The following was the Balance sheet of Universal Auto Ltd. as at 31st March 2000
Rs.

Rs.

Authorised Share Capital


10,000 shares of Rs 10 each

10,00,000

Goodwill

1,00,000

Fixed Assets

3,80,000

Issued, subscribed and paid-up

Cash

1000 9% of cumulative pref.

Profit and Loss A/c

shares of Rs. 100 each

1,00,000

3000 equity shares of Rs 100 each

3,00,000

13.5 % Debentures

1,00,000

9,000
61,000

credits (including Rs. 10,000


holding lien on some assets)

50,000
5,50,000

5,50,000

The Company decided on a scheme for reduction of capital which was duly authorised. The scheme provided as follows:
1) Two equity shares of Rs 100 each, Rs. 50 paid up per share to be issued for each preference share.
2) Each existing equity shares is to be reduced to Rs 50 paid up, the face value remaining the same at
Rs 100
3) 1,000 Equity shares were taken up by the Directors and paid for by them for the extent of Rs. 50
each.
4) Arrears of preference divided for the last four years to be cancelled.
5) Debenture holders to receive 800 Equity shares of Rs 100 credited as fully paid up.
6) Unsecured creditors to be paid immediately to the extent of 10% of their claims and they accepting a
remission of 20% of their claims.
7) The amount available as a result of the scheme to be used to write off a debit balance in the profit and
loss Account, to write down Fixed Assets by Rs. 10,000 and to adjust goodwill.
You are required to give journal entries to record the above and give the balance sheet after the reconstruction effected (I.C.W.A-Final)

32

Solution

UNIVERSAL AUTO Ltd.

JOURNAL ENTRIES
Particulars

Debit
Rs

Rs.

9% cum preference share capital A/c


Dr.
To Equity share capital A/c
(Being two Equity shares of Rs. 100 each Rs 50 paid
up per share issued for each preference share)

1,00,000

Equity share capital A/c


Dr.
To capital Reduction A/c
(Being the reduction of equity shares of Rs. 100 each
into shares of 50 each)

1,50,000

Bank A/c
Dr.
To Equity share capital A/c
(Being 1000 Equity shares taken up by the Directors
and paid for by them to the extent of Rs. 50 each)

50,000

13.5% Debentures A/c


Dr.
To Equity share capital A/c
To capital Reduction A/c
(Being 800 Equity shares of Rs. 100 each credited
as fully paid-up issued to debenture holders

1,00,000

Sundry creditors A/c


Dr.
To Bank
To Capital Reduction A/c
(Being unsecured creditors paid to the extent of 10%
of their claims and they accepting a remission of 20%
of their claims)

12,000

Capital Realisation A/c


To profit and loss A/c
To fixed Assets A/c
To Goodwill
(Being the past losses eliminated Goodwill
written off and other assets reduced

Dr.

Capital Reduction A/c


Dr.
To Capital Reserve A/c
(Being the balance in capital Reduction Account
Transferred to capital Reserve A/c)

33

Credit

1,00,000

1,50,000

50,000

80,000
20,000

4000
8000

1,71,000
1,61,000
10,000

7,000
7,000

UNIVERSAL AUTO LTD.


BALANCE SHEET as at 31st March 2000
(After reduction)
Liabilities

Rs.

Assets

Authorised Share Capital


10,000 shares of Rs 100 each

Fixed Assets
10,00,000

Cash/Bank

Rs.
3,70,000
55,000

Issued and subscribed: 6000 Equity


shares of Rs 100 each Rs 50
per share paid up
800 Equity shares of Rs 100 each

3,000,00
80,000

fully paid up
Reserves as surplus :
Capital Reserve

7,000

Current liabilities:
Sundry creditors including
Rs. 10,000
holding lien on some assets

38,000
4,25,000

4,25,000

Assignment

1. Differentiate between (i) pooling of interests method and (ii) the purchase method of recording
transactions relating to amalgamation.
2. Explain the terms amalgamation, absorption and reconstruction.
3. Explain reduction of share capital
4. Explain the factors you would take into account for suggesting a suitable scheme of reconstruction.

34

5. Following are the Balance sheet of X Ltd. and Y Ltd. as on 31st March 1995
Balance Sheet as on 31st March 1995
Liabilities

X Co. Ltd. Y Co. Ltd


Rs.000

Rs.000

50,00

30,000

Assets

X Co. Ltd. Y Co. Ltd


Rs.000

Rs.000

Land and Building

25,00

15,50

Plant and Machinery

32,50

17,00

Furniture & Fittings

5,75

3,50

7,00

5,00

12,50

9,50

Equity Share Capital


(Rs. 10 each)
14% Preference share
capital (Rs. 100 each)

22,00

1,700

General Reserve

5,00

2,50

Investments

Export profit reserve

3,00

2,00

Stock

1.00

Debtors

9,00

10,30

Cash and Bank

7,25

5,20

99,00

66,00

Investment Allowance
Reserve:
Profit and loss A/c

7,50

5,00

(Rs 100 each)

5,00

3,50

Trade creditors

4,50

3,50

Other current liabilities

2,00

1,50

99,00

66,00

13% Debentures

X Ltd. takes over Y LTd. on Ist April, 1995. X. Ltd. discharges the purchase consideration as below:
(i) Issued 3,50,000 equity shares of Rs 10 each at par to the equity shareholders of Y Ltd.
(ii) Issued 15% preference shares of Rs. 100 each to discharge the preference shareholders of Y Ltd. at
10% premium :
The debentures of Y Ltd. will be converted into equivalent number of debentures of X Ltd. The Statutory
reserves of Y Ltd. are to be maintained for 2 more years. Show the balance sheet of X Ltd. after amalgamation
on the assumption that:
(a)

The amalgamation is in the nature of merger.

35

(b)

The amalgamation is in the nature of purchase.

6. The following are the summerised Balance sheet of A. Ltd. and B. Ltd. as on 31st march 1997

A Ltd.
Liabilities

Rs.

Assets

Rs.

40,000 equity shares of Rs 100 each

40,00,000

Fixed Assets

30,00,000

General reserve

30,00,000

Investments

5,00,000

Current liabilities

30,00,000

Current assets

1,00,00,000

65,00,000
1,00,00,000

B Ltd.
Liabilities

Rs.

Share capital
20,000 equity shares of Rs 50 each

Assets
Goodwill

10,00,000

General Reserve

5,00,000

Current liablities

1,00,000

Provision for tax

1,00,000

Proposed dividend

1,00,000

Fixed assets
Current asstes

18,00,000

Rs.
50,000
3,50,000
14,00,000

18,00,000

B Ltd. is to be absorbed by A Ltd. on the following terms :


(i) B Ltd. declares a dividend of 10% before absorption for the payment of which it is to retain sufficient
amount of cash
2) The net worth of B Ltd. is valued at Rs 14,50,000
3) The purchase consideration is satisfied by the issue of fully paid up shares of 100 each in A Ltd.
Following further information is also to be taken into consideration.
a) A Ltd. holds 5000 shares of B Ltd. at a cost of Rs. 3,00,000
b) The stocks of B Ltd. include items valued at Rs. 1,00,000 purchased from A Ltd. (cost to A Ltd. Rs
75,000)
c) The creditors of B Ltd. include Rs 50,000 due to A Ltd.

36

Show ledger accounts in the books of B Ltd. to give effect to the above and balance sheet of A Ltd. after
completion of the absorption
7) Paradise Limited which had experienced training difficulties, decided to organise its finances on March
31, 2000 a final trial balance extracted from books of the company showed the following position.
Dr.
Rs

Share capital, Authorised and issued :


1500 6% cumulative preference shares of
Rs. 100 each
2000 Equity shares of Rs 100 each
Capital reserve
Profit and loss Account
Preliminary expenses
Goodwill at cost
Trade creditors
Debtors
Bank overdraft
leasehold Property, at cost
leasehold Property, provision for depreciation
Plant and Machinery at cost
Plant and Machinery, Provision for Depreciation
Stock in trade

Cr.
Rs
1,50,000
2,00,000
36,000

1,10,375
7250
50,000
42,500
30,200
51,000
80,000
30,000
2,10,000
57,500
79175
5,67,000

5,67,000

The approval of the court was obtained for the following scheme for reduction of capital:
a) The preference shares to be reduced to Rs 75 per share
b) The Equity shares to be reduced to Rs 12.50 per share
c) One Rs 12.50 Equity share to be issued for each Rs 100 of Gross Preference dividend arrears; the
preference dividend has not been paid for three years.
d) The balance in capital Reserve Account to be utilised
e) Plant and Machinery to be written down to Rs. 75,000
f) The profit and loss account balance and all intangible assets to be written off.
At the same time as the resolution to reduce capital was passed, another resolution was approved
resorting the total Authorised capital to Rs. 3,50,000 consisting of 1500 6% cumulative preference
shares of Rs 75 each and the balance in Equity shares of 12.50 each. As soon as the above resolution
has been passed, 5000 Equity shares were issued at part for cash, payable in full upon application. The
same were fully subscribed and paid.
You are required:
(i) To show the journal entries necessary to record the above transactions in the companys books and
(ii) To prepare the balance sheet of the company, after completion of the scheme.

37

UNIT - 2

LIQUIDATION OF COMPANIES

OBJECTIVES
By the end of this unit, you should be able to:

Understand the meaning and legal aspects of liquidation of companies

Learn the preparation of statement of Affairs, Deficiency/Surplus Account and Liquidators


Final statement of Accounts

STRUCTURE
2. 01

Meaning of liquidation.

2. 02

Modes of winding up or liquidation.

2. 03

Order of payments.

2. 04

Statement of affairs.

2. 05

Deficiency /Surplus Account.

2. 06

Liquidators Final Statement of Accounts.

2. 07

Liquidators Remuneration.

2. 08

Assignments.

38

2.01 Meaning of liquidation


Liquidation is a legal procedure by which the corporate life of a company is brought to an end. Any
company, when found necessary can be liquidated. It is not necessary that only insolvent companies should be
liquidated. Sometimes, even solvent companies are liquidated. When liquidation takes place, assets of the
company are realised , capital is collected and out of the proceeds, claims of creditors are settled. If any
surplus is left, it is returned to the shareholders of the company according to their rights. The job of realising
various assets and paying various liabilities in a systematic way is performed by a person called the Liquidator.
2.02

Modes of winding up or liquidation.

Section 425(1) of the Companies Act provides that a company can be liquidated in any of the following
three ways:
1. Compulsory winding up or winding up by the court,
2. Voluntary winding up
a) Members voluntary winding up
b) Creditors voluntary winding up.
3. Winding up under the supervision of the Court.

Compulsory Winding up.


A court may order the winding up of a company on anyone or more of the following grounds.
a) If the company has passed a special resolution to the effect that the company be wound up by the
court,
b) If default is made in filing statutory reports or in holding statutory meetings,
c) If the company does not commence business within a year from its incorporation or suspends its
business for a whole year,
d) If the number of members is reduced in the case of a public company below seven and in the case of
private company below two,
e) If the company is unable to pay its debts, and
f) If the court is of the opinion that it is just and equitable that the company be wound up.

Voluntary Winding up.


Voluntary winding up may be either members voluntary winding up or creditors voluntary winding up.
When a companys solvency is declared by the directors in voluntary winding up, it is called Members Voluntary
Winding up. When a companys solvency is not declared by the directors in voluntary winding up it is called
Creditors Voluntary Winding up.

Winding up under supervision of the court.


This is voluntary winding up with the supervision of court. The object of a supervision order is to ensure
the protection of interests of all persons concerned - the company, the contributories and the creditors.

39

Contributory
According to Sec.428 of the Companies Act, a contributory is every person liable to contribute to the
assests of a company in the event of its being wound up, and includes the holder of any shares which are fully
paid up and also any person alleged to be a contributory. A contributory can be either a present member or a
past member. A present member is that member whose name is included in the register of members when the
company is wound up. On the other hand, past members are those members who ceased to be shareholders
within one year of the winding up of the company and can be called upon to pay if the present contributories are
not able to pay the liabilities of the company. A contributory is not entitled to claim the set off in respect of any
amount due to him for dividend or any other sum. This means that a contributory must first pay the amount
demanded of him and then demand the amount due to him.
2.03
Order of payments.
The proceeds of assets not specifically pledged with any creditor and the surplus of assets specifically
pledged, if any, is available for distribution in the following order.
a) legal charges
b) liquidators remuneration
c) cost and expense of winding up
d) preferential creditors
e) creditors secured by floating charge and
f) unsecured creditors.
If still some surplus is left, it is distributed among contributories as follows:
i) Preference shareholders: Preference shareholders are entitled to the return of capital in priority to
any return of capital to equity shareholders.
ii) Equity shareholders: Any amount left after paying to preference shareholders will go to equity
shareholders. If any surplus is still left, it again goes to equity shareholders unless it is specifically mentioned
that preference share capital is a participating share capital. If preference shares are participating, then they
have the right to share the surplus left after paying equity capital.
Preference dividend: The position of preference dividend is as under:
a) If preference dividend has been declared but not paid, then they are paid as debt.
b) If preference dividend is in arrear for one or more years and it has not been declared, then the
position would be as follows:
arrears of preference dividend will be paid only when preference share capital and then equity share
capital are returned in full and surplus is left.
Preferential payments:
The amount of preferential creditors is paid out of the proceeds of assets not specifically pledged left
after retaining the amount necessary for cost and expense of winding up but before making any payment to any
other unsecured creditors. Sec. 530 of the Companies Act states the following as preferential creditors:
a) All revenues, taxes, cesses and rates due from the company to Central or State Governments or to

40

Local authority at the relevant date and having become due and payable within the 12 months next before that
date;
b) All wages or salaries of any employee inrespect of services rendered to the company and due for a
period not exceeding 4 months within the 12 months before the relevant date and any compensation
payable to any workman under any of the provisions of Charter V-A of the Industrial Disputes Act,1947,
provided the amount payable to any one claimant does not exceed Rs.1,000/-;
c) All accrued holiday remuneration becoming payable to any employee or in case of his death, to any
other person in his right, on the termination of his employment before, or by the affect of the winding
up order or resolution;
where a person advances money for the payment of employees wages or salary and holiday remuneration
stated above under (b) and (c) he will be treated as a preferential creditor.
d) Unless the company is being wound up voluntarily for reconstruction or amalgamation with another
company, all amounts due, in respect of contributions payable during the 12 months next before the
relevant date, by the company as the employer of any persons under Employees State Insurance Act,
1948;
e) All sums due as Compensation under the Workmens Compensation Act, 1923, in respect of death or
disablement of any employee of the company;
f)

All sums due to an employee from a Provident Fund, Pension Fund, or any other Fund for the welfare
of the employee maintained by the Company; and

g) The expenses of any investigation held under Sec.235 or 237 in so far as they are payable by the
company.

Interest on liabilities:
The date upto which interest on loan, debentures etc., is payable depends on the fact whether the
company is solvent or insolvent. In the case of solvent companies interest on loan, debentures etc.is payable upto
the date of payment and in case of insolvent companies the interest is payable upto the date of winding up. A
company is said to be solvent if the assets realised are sufficient to pay all creditors of the company in full and
some surplus is available for returning the capital. If not, the company is said to to be insolvent.

2. 04 Statement of affairs.
When a company is wound up under the order of the court or whcn the official liquidator has been
appointed by the court as provisional liquidator, the officers and directors of the company must submit within 21
days of the courts order a statement called statement of affairs.
FORM OF STATEMENT OF AFFAIRS
Statement as to the affairs of ............ Ltd. on the ........... day of ........... being the date of the winding
up order (or order appointing Provisional liquidator or the date directed by the official liquidator as the case may
be ) showing assets at estimated realisable values and liabilities expected to rank.

41

Assets not specifically pledged (As per list A )

Estimated
realisable Value
Rs.

Balance at Bank
Cash in hand
Marketable Securities
Bills receivable
Trade debtors
Loans and advances
Unpaid calls
Stock in trade
Work in progress
Freehold property, land and buildings
Lease hold property
Plant & Machinery
Furniture fittings, utensils etc.
Investment other than marketable securities
Livestock
Other property, etc.
Assets Specifically pledged (as per list B)]
(a)
Assets

(b)

(c)

(d)

Estimated
Due to
Deficiency ranking Surplus carried
realisable values Secured as unsecured
to Last colum
creditors
Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

Estimated surplus from assets specifically pledged


Estimated total assets available for preferencial creditors, debenture holders
secured by a floating charge and unsecured cretitors
Summary of Gross Assets
Gross realisable value of assets
Specifically pledged
Rs............
Other assets
Rs...........
Gross assets
...............
Liabilities
Gross Liabilities
Rs............
( To be deducted from surplus or added to
deficiency as the case may be )
secured creditors (as per list B ) to the extent to which

42

Rs.

Rs.

their claims are settled (item a or b


whichever is less)
(Insert in Gross Liabilities column only)
Preferential creditors (as per list C)
Estimated balance of assets available for debenture holders
Secured by a floating charge and unsecured creditors
Debenture holders Secured by a floating charge (as per list D)
Estimated Surplus/deficiency as regards debenture holders
Unsecured creditors (as per list E)
Estimated Surplus/Deficiency as regards unsecured creditors
(Being the difference between Gross assets and Gross liabilities)
Issued and called up capital
( ......... preference shares of ........... each Rs.........called up (as per List F)
........... equity shares of ......... each Rs.............called up ( as per list G )
Deficiency or surplus as regards contributories ( as per list H )
Procedure of preparation of statement of affairs.
1. Write down the assets which are not specifically pledged at their realisable values. This includes the
calls in arrears but does not include uncalled capital.
2. Add to those assets the surplus, if any existing from those creditors who have been secured on assets
specifically pledged.
3. From the total, first deduct preferencial creditors, then creditors having a floating charge and then
unsecured creditors.
4. After having deducted the unsecured creditors, deduct from the remaining Surplus (or add to the
deficiency) the amount of Share capital.
5. The balance left will be the Surplus or deficiency.

2. 05 Deficiency/Surplus Account.
The deficiency or Surplus as the case may be stated in the statement of affairs is to be proved separately by preparing another statement called the Deficiency/Surplus Account. The items contributing to deficiency are listed first followed by items reducing deficiency. The difference between totals is the deficiency or
surplus and must tally with the figures given in the statement of affairs.
List H. Deficiency or Surplus Account.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Items contributing to deficiency or reducing surplus.


Excess (if any) of capital and liabilities over assets
Net dividends and bonuses declared during the period.
Net trading losses
Losses other than trading losses
Estimated losses, not written off or for which provision has been made
in the books during the same period

43

6. Other items contributing to deficiency or reducing surplus.


Items reducing deficiency or contributing to surplus.
7. Excess of assets over capital and liabilities
8. Net trading profits.
9. Profits or income other than trading profits during the same period
10. Other items reducing deficiency or contributing to surplus.
Deficiency/Surplus as shown by the statement of affairs
Illustration - 1
Shri A.B. Govind is appointed liquidator of a company in voluntary liquidation on 01/07/2002 and the
following balances are extracted from the books on that date.
Rs.

Rs.

16000 shares of Rs.5/-each

80,000

Machinery

30,000

Reserve for bad debts

10,000

Leasehold properties

40,000

Debentures

50,000

Stock in Trade

Bank overdraft

18,000

Book debts

60,000

Liability for purchases

20,000

Investments

6,000

Calls in arrears

5,000

Cash in hand

1,000

Profit and Loss Account


1,78,000

1,000

35,000
1,78,000

You are required to prepare


(1) Statement of Affairs as regards creditors and contributories, and
(2) Deficiency or Surplus Account.
The Machinery is valued at Rs.60,000; the lease hold properties at Rs.73,000; investments at Rs.4,000;
Stock in trade at Rs.2,000; bad debts are Rs. 2000; doubtful debts are Rs.4,000, estimated to realise Rs.2,000.
The bank overdraft is secured by deposit of title deeds of lease hold properties. Preferencial creditors for taxes
and wages Rs.1,000. Telephone rent owing is Rs.80.

44

Solution :
STATEMENT OF AFFAIRS OF SHRI A.B. GOVIND AS ON 1st JULY 2002
Assets

Estimated
Releasable Value
Rs.

Assets not speficifically pledged ( as per List A )


Cash in hand

1,000

Book debts

56,000

Calls in arrears

5,000

Investments

4,000

Stock

2,000

Machinery

60,000
1,28,000

Assets specifically pledged ( as per list B )

Lease hold property

Estimated

Due to

Deficiency

Surplus

Realisable

Secured

ranking as

carried to

value

creditors

unsecured

last column

Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

73,000
____

18,000
____

__
_______

55,000
______

Estimated surplus from assets specifically pledged

55,000

Estimated total assets available for preferential creditors, debenture holders secured
by floating charge and unsecured creditors.

1,83,000

Summary of Gross Assets

Rs.

Gross realisable value of assets specifically pledged

73,000

Other assets

1,28,000
Gross Assets

2,01,000

45

Gross Liabilities
Rs.

Liabilities

Rs.

( To be deducted from surplus or added to deficiency as the


case may be )

18,000.

Secured creditors ( as per List B ) to the extent to which claims


are estimated to be covered by assets specifically pledged.

1,000.

Preferential creditors (as per List C )

1,000

Estimated balance of assets available for debenture holders


secured by floating charge and unsecured creditors
50,000

1,82,000

Debenture holders secured by a floating charge ( as per list D)


Estimated surplus as regards debenture holders

1,32,000

Unsecured creditors (as per list E )

Rs.

Liabilities for purchases

20,000

20,080

Telephone Rent outstanding

89,080

Estimated surplus as regards creditors

50,000

80

20,080
1,11,920

Issued and called up capital (as per list G. )

80,000

Estimated surplus as regards contributories (as per list H)

31,920

List H.

SURPLUS ACCOUNT

Items reducing surplus:


Excess of Capital and Liabilities over assets,
i.e. Profit and Losses Account

35,000

Estimated losses now written off for which provision has been
made for the purpose of preparing the statement:

Rs.

Investments (Rs.6000 - 4000)

2,000

Preferential creditors for taxes and wages

1,000

Telephone rent outstanding

80

3,080
38,080

Items contributing to surplus:


Machinery (Rs.60,000-30,000)

30,000

Lease hold properties (Rs.73,000-40,000)

33,000

Stock

(Rs.2000-1000)

1,000

Debtors provision for Bad debts Rs.10,000


Less Bad debts
Doubtful debts

Rs.2,000
2,000

4,000

Surplus as shown by the statement of Affairs

46

6,000

70,000
31,920

2. 06 Liquidators Final Statement of Account.


The main function of the liquidator is to realise the assets of the company under liquidation, and settle the
accounts of every creditor proving his claim against the company. It is, therefore, necessary for him, in every
mode of winding up, to maintain proper records of receipts and payments and submit a summary of the same to
the Court and to the company depending upon the mode of winding up. When the affairs of the company under
liquidaion are fully wound up, he has to prepare a final statement of account showing the amount realised and
then utilisation of the same for disbursement amongst the claimants.
Liquidators final statement of account takes the form of cash account, where on the left handside
records various receipts and the right hand side the payments. The various receipts shown on the left hand side
are:
i)

Realisation of assets,

ii) Surplus of securities,


iii) Payments by contributories,
iv) Receipts from delinquent directors and other officers of the company,
v) Any other receipts.
On the right hand side of the account are recorded the various payments made in the following order:
i)

Secured creditors,

ii) Legal charges,


iii) liquidators remuneration,
iv) costs of liquidation such as auctioneers charges, cost of notice in Gazette and newspapers, establishment and other expenses of liquidation.
v) Preferential creditors,
vi) Debentures with a floating charge,
vii) Unsecured creditors,
viii) Preference shareholders, and
ix) Equity shareholders.
2-07

Liquidators Remuneration.
The liquidator normally gets his remuneration in the form of commission which is usually based on the

value of assets realised and the payments made to creditors. While calculating the liquidators remuneration the
following points are to be borne in mind:
1.

He gets the commission, at the agreed percentage on all assets ( not specifically pledged ) realised by him.
If the payment to the secured creditors is made by him by way of selling the assets specifically pledged,
then he is entitled to the commission for the proceeds so realised by him. However, he is not entitled for the
commission if the assets given as securities are realised by the secured creditors themselves.

2.

Cash and Bank balances:- Unless otherwise stated, he is not entitled for the commission on such balances.

47

3.

When the liquidators commission is based on the amount paid to unsecured creditors, preferential creditors
are also taken into consideration because they are also unsecured creditors.
4. If the amount available is sufficient to make the full payment of unsecured creditors, the commission is
calculated as follows:
Liquidators remuneration : Amount due to unsecured creditors X % of commission
100
If the amount available is not adequate to make the full payment to the unsecured creditors, the commission
is calculated as follows:
Liquidators remuneration = Amount available for unsecured creditors X % of commission
100 x % of commission.
Illustration - 2
Given below is the position as on August 1st, 2002 of Ganges Silk Mills Ltd. on which date it goes into
liquidation.
1.
Share capital:
(a) 10,000 preference shares of Rs.10 each fully paid
(b) 5,000 Equity shares of Rs.10 each fully called
less calls-in arrears on 1000 shares at Re.1. per share
(c) 10,000 Equity shares of Rs.10. each at Rs.5. per share paid
(d) 20,000 Equity shares of Rs.10. each at Rs.3. per share paid

Rs.
1,00,000
Rs.50,000
1000

2.

Secured loan from bank (against pledge of stock of raw material)

3.

Unsecured dues :

Preference

49,000
50,000
60,000
38,000

Rs. 1,200

Others

1,01,800
Total

1,03,000
Rs.4,00,000

4.

Cash at Bank

5,000

5.

Stock of raw material

6.

Other stocks

1,50,000

7.

Other assets

1,45,000

8.

Profit and loss account ( debit balance )

50,000

50,000

4,00,000
Realisations were :
(a) Stock of raw material realised by bank Rs.30,000; (b) other stocks Rs.80,000; (c) Remaining assets
Rs.20,000.
The liquidator is entitled to the fixed remuneration of Rs.1,000. plus 3% of the gross amount realised by
him. Other costs and charges amounted to Rs.11,000. Equity share capital carry the same rights regardless of
the amount paid as far as capital repayment is concerned. Show the liquidators final statement of account.

48

Solution :
Liquidators Final Statement of Account.
Receipts

Rs.

Payments.

Other stock

80,000

Legal charges

Remaining assets

20,000

Remuneration of liquidators

Cash at bank

5,000

Rs.
Nil
4,000

Cost and expense of

Calls on shares

winding up

20,000 shares @Rs.5. per share (8-3) 1,00,000

11,000

Preferential creditors

1,200

Calls on shares
10,000 shares @Rs.3. per share (8-5) 30,000

Creditors secured by floating charge

Nil

Unsecured creditors 1,01,800 +


8,000
Preference Share holders

1,09,800
1,00,000

Equity Share holders


4,000 shares @ 2 - 4,000 X 2 = 8000.
1,000 shares @ 1 - 1,000 X 1 = 1000.
2,35,000

2,35,000

Working Note:a)
Liquidators remuneration.

b)

9,000

1,000 + 3% of 1,00,000.
Rs.4,000/-

2,26,000
1,05,000
_______
1,21,000

Calculation of loss per equity share


Calculation of deficiency.
Payment
(-)
Receipts

Add paid up equity Capital


49,000
50,000
60,000
Deficiency

1,59,000
2,80,000

Deficiency per equity share

=
=

49

2,80,000
35,000
Rs.8/- per share

Assignments:
1.

What is statement of Affairs? How is it prepared?

2.

Who are preferential creditors under Company Law?

3.

How is liquidators remuneration calculated?

4.

Give a proforma of liquidators final statement of account with imaginary figures.

5.

What are preferential creditors? State the various types of preferential creditors in the event of the
companys winding up.

List the preferential creditors who have to be paid off in priority over other creditors in the event of a
companys winding up.

1.

On January 31st, 2002, a compulsory order for winding up was made against X Co. Ltd. The following

particulars being disclosed.


Book Value

Estimated to
Produce

Rs.
Cash in hand

Rs.

100

100

4,000

3,600

Land and buildings

60,000

48,000

Furniture & fixtures

20,000

20,000

Unsecured creditors

20,000

Debtors

Debentures:
Secured on land and buildings

42,000

Secured on floating charge

10,000

Preferential creditors

6,000

Share Capital (3200 shares of Rs.100. each )

3,20,000

Estimated liability for bills discounted was Rs.6,000. Estimated to rank at Rs.6,000. Other contingent
liabilities were Rs.12,000. Estimated to rank at Rs.12,000.
The company was formed on January 1st, 1998 and has made losses of Rs.3,13,900
Prepare the statement of Affairs and the Deficiency Account.
2.

A company went into voluntary liquidation on 31/12/2002. Its position as on that date was as follows:
1000 preference shares of Rs.100. each, fully paid
2000 equity shares of Rs.100. each, fully paid
2000 equity shares of Rs.100 each, Rs.75. paid up.
Unsecured creditors

Rs.1,90,000.

50

Assets realised

Rs.3,20,000.

Liquidation expenses

Rs. 12,000.

Liquidators remuneration
5% on the amounts realised, and
3% on the amount distributed to unsecured creditors.
The liquidators made a call of Rs.25/- on the partly paid equity shares which was duly paid. Prepare
liquidators final statement of account.
3.

Balance sheet of Sona Ltd. as on 31st December, 2002 is as follows:


SONA LTD.
BALANCE SHEET AS ON 31ST DECEMBER 2002
Liabilities

Rs.

Assets

Paid up capital:
1000, 6% Preference shares of
Rs.100. each

1,00,000
2,00,000

3000, equity shares of Rs.100 each


Rs.50. paid

Land and Buildings

2,00,000

Plant and Machinery

2,20,000

Current Assets:

2000, equity shares of Rs.100 each


Fully paid

Rs.

Stock

1,00,000

Debtors

1,00,000

Cash at Bank
1,50,000

30,000

Miscellaneous expenditure:
Profit & loss A/c

1,00,000

Secured Loan:
6% debentures (floating charge on
all assets )

1,00,000

Others ( Mortgage on land & buildings) 1,00,000


Current liabilities :
Sundry creditors

90,000

Income-tax

10,000
7,50,000

7,50,000

The company went into liquidation on January 1,2003. The preference dividends were in arrears for 3
years and payable on liquidation.
The assets realised as follows: Land and Building Rs.2,40,000; plant and machinery Rs.1,80,000; Stock
Rs.70,000; Debtors Rs.60,000.
The expenditure of liquidation amounts to Rs.8000. The liquidator is entitled to a commission of 2% on all
assets realised and 3% on amounts distributed to unsecured creditors.
All payments were made on June 30, 2003. Prepare Liquidators final Statement of Account.

51

Unit III

INSURANCE CLAIMS OR FIRE CLAIMS

Fire insurance claim can be studied under two parts, 1) Loss of asset (a) loss of stock (b) loss of fixed
assets like building, machinery, furniture etc. 2) Loss of profit.
1.

Claims for Loss of Assets:When a fire occurs, it destroys all assets such as building, machinery, furniture, stock etc. The books of

account maintain accounts of all the assets except (usually) stock in trade. Claims in respect of building,
machinery, furniture etc, can be made on the book value of these assets. But difficulty arises in connection with
the loss of stock for which no account appears in the books. The value of stock in hand on the date of fire,
therefore, has to be estimated to make a claim against the Insurance company. For this purpose, a Memorandum Trading Account has to be prepared as shown below:

Memorandum Trading A/c


To

Opening Stock

--

By sales

--

Purchases

--

Closing stock

--

wages

--

carriage inwards

--

Gross profit (certain


percentage on sales )

(Balancing fig.)

--

Adjustments
Gross profit ratio is determined on the basis of the previous years trading results. Some times stock
might have been valued below cost or above cost. In such a situation, trading account will have to be prepared
with full cost of opening and closing stocks. The opening stock of current year should also be adjusted while
preparing the Memorandum Trading a/c for ascertaining the value of stock destroyed.
Loss of stock is calculated as follows.
Value of stock on the date of fire

---

Less value of salvaged (saved) stock

---

Loss of Stock

---

52

Illustration I
A fire occurred on 21st April 2004 in the premises of Appolo Ltd. and stock in trade was destroyed. The
following are the information.
Opening stock on 01-01-2004

Rs.11,000

Purchases upto 21-04-2004

Rs.45,000

Sales upto 21-04-2004

Rs.60,000

The stock in hand was always valued at cost price or market price whichever was lower. However, the
closing stock as at 31st Dec. 2003 was valued at market price which was 10% above cost. The percentage of
profit usually obtained in the business was 15%. The salvage realised only Rs.400. Compute fire claims.
Solution.
Memorandum Trading A/c 01-01-04 to 21-04-04
To op. stock (last year closing

By Sales

stock at cost price 11,000 X 100 )


110
To Purchases

10,000

60,000

By closing stock
(balancing figure )

4,000

45,000

To G.P (15% on sales )

9,000
64,000

64,000

Statement of fire claim


Value of closing stock

4,000

Less Stock salvaged

400
Rs.3,600

II

A fire occurred in the godown of a company on 20th March 2002. All stocks were destroyed except to

the extent of Rs.13,000. From the following figures ascertain the claim amount in respect of loss of stock by
fire.
Stock on 01-01-2001

Rs.40,000

Purchases less returns during 2001

Rs.1,40,000

Sales

Rs.2,00,000

Stock on 31-12-2001

Rs. 24,000

Purchases during 2002 upto the date of fire

Rs.1,46,000

Sales

Rs.1,60,000

Stocks were always valued at 80% of cost.


Solution.
The rates of gross profit to sales is not given; to find it out it is necessary to prepare Trading A/c for
2001.

53

Trading A/c for 2001


To Op. Stock
(40,000 X 100 )
80

50,000

To Purchases

By sales

1,40,000

2,00,000

closing stock
24,000 X 100
80

To G.P

30,000

40,000
2,30,000

2,30,000

Note: Both opening stock and closing stock are valued at 80% of cost. So it is necessary to bring them to the
level of actual cost.
G.P.Ratio

40,000 X 100
2,00,000

= 20%

Memorandum Trading A/c


To stock

30,000

Purchases

By sales

1,46,000

G.P (20% of sales )

Clo. stock

32,000

(Balancing figure)

2,08,000
Amount of claim:

1,60,000
48,000
2,08,000

Rs.

Closing stock

48,000

Less salvage

13,000
35,000

Gross Profit Ratio: G.P is the key factor while calculating stock destroyed by fire. G.P. is always
calculated on the basis of sales. If gross profit ratio is not given, it can be computed as
G.P. Ratio =

G.P X 100
sales

Average Clause.
In general insurance policies, there is a clause as average clause. If the stock is under insured and if
there is average clause in the insurance policy, the amount of claim for the loss of stock will be that proportion of
the sum insured bears to the actual value of the insured stock. For eg., if stock worth Rs.60,000 is insured for
Rs.40,000 and the loss of stock amounts to Rs.30,000, the amount of claim for the loss of stock will be
Claim
=
Actual loss X Amount of Policy
Value of stock on the date of fire

54

30,000 X 40,000
60,000

= Rs.20,000.

Illustration 2.
A fire occurred in the premises of a merchant on 18 September, 2003 and a considerable part of the
stock was destroyed. The merchant has taken out a fire insurance policy of Rs.21,000 covering his stock in
trade and the policy was subject to average clause.
The books disclosed that on 1st April, 2003 the stock was valued at Rs.66,500. The purchase to the date
of fire amounted to Rs.1,85,000 and the sales to Rs.2,82,500. Goods costing Rs.500 was taken for personal use
and goods sold for Rs.2,500 were returned to the merchant. On investigation, it is found that during the past 5
years the average gross profit on cost was 25%. The value of the stock saved was Rs.7,000/Prepare a statement showing the amount the merchant should claim from the insurance company in
respect of stock destroyed by fire.
Solution
The rate of gross profit on cost is 25%
The rate of gross profit on sales is 25%

Memorandum Trading A/c for the period upto 18, September, 2003
To opening stock
To purchases

66,500

By sales

1,85,000

Less goods for own use 500


To G.P (20% on 2,80,000)

Less returns

2,82,500
2,500

1,84,500

By Stock on date of fire

56,000

( Balancing figure )

3,07,000

2,80,000
27,000
3,07,000

Claims to be made :Stock on date of fire

27,000

Less salvage

7,000
20,000

Since there is average clause, the claim to be made is


Rs.27,000 stock is insured for
20,000 stock.

Rs.21,000

Claim =

21,000 X 20,000
27,000

Rs.15,556

Consequential loss or loss of profit.


An ordinary fire insurance policy covers the loss of stock on properties destroyed by fire, but it does not
cover loss of profit due to stoppage of production or sale on account of fire. So, a new type of insurance known

55

as loss of profits insurance or consequential loss insurance has come into vogue. This policy covers the
following losses due to fire.
1.
Loss of profits due to stoppage of business or reduced turnover.
2.
Loss of standing charges (ie. fixed charges ) due to their non-recovery or less recovery, because of no
production or less production as a result of fire. Examples for standing charges are salaries, rent, rates,
taxes, lighting, dpn. telephone charges etc.
3.
Loss due to increased working expenses during indemnity period ie., additional expenses during
dislocation period. eg: renting a new business place.
Explanation of Certain terms.
1). Indemnity period.
Indemnity period is the period covered by the consequential loss policy. For example, if A Ltd.
takes a loss of profit policy on 1-1-2004 for a year and if the fire broke out on 1-12-2004, then Indemnity period
runs from 1-12-2004 to 30, November, 2005.
2). Standing or fixed charges or constant expenses. It refers to those fixed expenses which are incurred irrespective of reduction in business during dislocation period.
Eg:
1)
Wages and salaries of permanent staff
2)
Rent, rates, taxes etc.
3)
Interest on loan, bank overdraft etc.
4)
Depreciation on fixed assets.
The standing charges which are insured are called insured standing charges.
3). Increased cost of working:
These are additional expenses incurred by the insured in order to carry on the business during

the

indemnity period.
4).Saving in expenses:
These are the expenses which are usually incurred by a business but are avoided during dislocation
period.
5). Rate of gross profit:
The term gross profit is not used in the sense as it has been understood commonly. It has different
meaning and is calculated as follows:
Net profit + Insured standing charges
G.P =

X 100

Turn over ( Previous year )

6).Short sales:
It is calculated by comparing the sales made during the period of business dislocation caused by fire to
the sales of the year preceding the period of fire.
7).Standard Turnover:
Refers to the sales during that period in the preceding financial year which corresponds to the period of
dislocation. Suppose the period of claim is 3 months ie., from 1-4-2004 to 30-06-2004.

56

Standard sales is the sales during 3 months from 1-4-2004 to 30-6-2004.

Computation of claim for loss of profit:


I. Calculation of the loss of profit during dislocation period. In order to calculate loss of profit following steps are
required.
a)

Determination of period of claim.


Period of claim is the period covered by the policy. (Period of indemnity or period of disloca
tion whichever is less).

b)

Ascertain short sales or loss of turnover.


Short sales

c)

Standard sales - sales during dislocation period.

Calculation of G.P. Ratio.


G.P. Ratio

Net Profit + Insured Standing Charges X 100


Last year sales

d)

Calculate loss of profit during dislocation period.


Loss of profit

Short sales X Gross profit ratio.

II. Computation of claim for increased Cost of working.


a)

If only a part of fixed charges are insured, then increased cost of working is proportionately

reduced as follows:
Increased cost of working

X Net profit + Insured standing charges


N.P.

+ all standing charges

Compare this with G.P on turnover saved. Only less is allowed.


b)

Calculate G.P. on turnover saved.


=

G.P X turnover saved.

Turnover is saved by incurring additional cost of working. But insurance company will pay only less by comparing these two ie., (1) increased cost of working (2) G.P. on turnover saved.
III.

Deduct the amount of expenses saved.


Gross claim for loss of profit

loss of profit on short sales + Increased working


expenses

expenses saved.

Gross claim is subject to average clause.


When average clause is applied, the amount of claim
=

Gross claim X

Amount of Policy
G.P. on sales of preceding 12 months of fire.

The result is the amount of claim.

57

Illustration 3.
ABB Ltd. has a Loss of Profit insurance policy of Rs.21,00,000. The period of indemnity is 3 months.
A fire occurred on 31-03-2003. The following information is available.
Sales for the year ended 31-3-2002

Rs.70,00,000

Sales for the period from 1st April 2002 to 30th June 2003

80,00,000

Sales for the period from 1st April 2002 to 30th June 2002

18,00,000

Sales for the period from 1st April 2003 to 30th June 2003

1,20,000

Standing charges for 2002

16,00,000

Profit for 2002

5,00,000

Savings in standing charges because of fire

50,000

Additional expenses to reduce loss of turnover

1,00,000

Assuming that no adjustment is to be made for the upward trend in the turnover, compute the claim to
be made on the insurance company.
Solution
Loss of profit during dislocation period
Short sales

Short sales X G.P. ratio

Standard sales - sales during dislocation period.

18,00,000 - 1,20,000

Short sales

16,80,000

G.P

Net Profit + Insured standing charges X 100


Last year sales

5,00,000 + 16,00,000 X 100


70,00,000

Loss of profit

= 30%

Short sales X G.P. Ratio

16,80,000 X 30
100

Rs.5,04,000

After calculating loss of profit during dislocation period, calculate claim for increase in cost of working.
Increase in cost of working

1 lakh.

Compare this with G.P. on turn over saved, less is allowed by insurance company.
If all standing charges are not insured, only proportionate amount of increase in cost of
working will be allowed and it is calculated
=

N.P + insured standing charges X increase in cost of working


N.P + all standing charges

In this problem it is assumed that all standing charges are insured ie., 1,00,000

58

G.P. on turnover saved

Turnover saved X G.P. Ratio

1,20,000 X 30
100

{ assume that sales during dislocation period is the turnover saved }.


=

Gross claim

1,20,000 X 30
100

Rs.36,000.

loss of profit + increased cost of working - standing charges saved.


=

5,04,000 + 36,000 - 50,000

Rs.4,90,000

In order to apply average clause, first find out whether there is under insurance. It can be calculated by
taking the sales of 12 months preceding the date of fire X G.P
=

80,00,000 X 30/100 = Rs.24,00,000

But sum insured is Rs.21 lakh. So there is under insurance


Actual claim

4,90,000 X 21,00,000
24,00,000

Rs.4,28,750.

59

UNIT IV

ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF


FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
OBJECTIVES
After studying this unit, you should be able to understand:

the Meaning of financial analysis and interpretation

the Tools of financial analysis

the Techniques of application of tools and making its interpretation

STRUCTURE
4. 01

Meaning of financial statements

4-02

Nature of financial statements

4-03

Analysis of financial statements

4-04

Analysis and interpretation

4-05

Types of financial analysis

4-06

Tools or Techniques of analysis

60

4-01 MEANING OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS


Financial Statements are the end products of financial accounting. They are statements containing financial
information of a business enterprise. Financial Statements may be defined as statements containing summaries
of detailed information about the financial position and performance of an enterprise.
Traditionally financial statements comprised two statements ie, Income Statement also known as Profit and
Loss Account and the Position Statements, also known as the Balance Sheet. In recent years however, the term
financial statements is given a broad connotation to include besides the income and position statements, cash
flow statement, fund flow statement, Statement of retained earnings, schedules, Annexure and Explanatory
Notes.

4-02 NATURE OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS


Financial statements report financial information to those who are external to business as well as those
interested in the accounting information relating to the business. The information conveyed is about the result of
business operations as also a true and fair view of the affairs of the business. These statements are prepared as
per the legal requirements. But yet, they exhibit the following characteristics.
Factual financial information : Financial statements present the net effect of the actual business transactions. Financial statements reflect only the recorded facts. They do not reveal the financial position of the
concern in terms of current economic conditions.
Influence of conventions: In the preparation of financial statements, certain Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, concepts and conventions are followed. For example, according to the convention of Conservatism profit should not be anticipated although loss may be anticipated and provided for. As a consequence of
applying this convention, the profit and loss account shows a position which is not really the position of the
concern, ie, much better than that reflected by the account.

Accountants discretion : Financial statements are affected by the accountants discretion or personal
judgement in the treatment of some items for purposes of preparing financial statements, for example, the
method of stock valuation, method of depreciation etc. depend on the personal judgement of the accountant.
4-03 ANALYSIS OF FINANCIAL STATEMENT
Financial analysis is the process of evaluation of relationship between component parts of financial statements to obtain a better understanding of the firms position and performance. It is the process of identifying the
strengths and weaknesses of the company with the help of accounting information provided by the profit and

61

loss account and Balance sheet. Financial analysis mainly measures the liquidity, solvency and profitability of
business concern.

4-04 ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION


The term interpretation means explaining the meaning and significance of the data so arranged.
Analysis and Interpretation are closely related. Interpretation is not possible without analysis and without
interpretation analysis has no value. So first the data in the financial statements are to be analysed. From
analysis of data, draw conclusion which mean interpretation. Interpretation is thus drawing of inference and
stating what the figures in the financial statement really mean. The most important objective of the analysis and
interpretation of financial statements is to understand the significance and meaning of financial statements data
to know the strength and weakness of a business undertaking, so that forecast may be made of the future
prospects of that business undertaking.

4-05 TYPES OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS


The classification of financial analysis can be made either on the basis of materials used or according to the
modus operandi of the analysis
TYPES OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

on the basis of materials used

on the basis of

or information used

modus operandi

External analysis

Internal Analysis

Horizontal analysis

Vertical analysis

A. On the basis of material used or information used financial analysis can be of two types :
a) External analysis
This type of analysis is done by those who are outsiders to the business. The outsiders are creditors,
investors, Government etc. This people mainly depend upon the published financial statements.
b) Internal Analysis
This analysis is done by those who have access to the books of accounts and other informations relating to
the business concern. This Analysis is done for managerial purpose. This is conducted by executives or employees of the firm.

62

B. On the basis of modus operandi, financial analysis can be of two types.


a) Horizontal analysis
This method of analysis is also known as Dynamic Analysis, as it analyses changes in the related
items in the financial statements of two or more accounting periods or two or more business concerns. Horizontal analysis portrays figures for a number of years and changes in these figures from the figures of a particular
year chosen as the standard or the base year. For example, study of profitability trend for a period of 5 to 10
years. In these current year figures are compared with standard or base year and shown as percentage.

b) Vertical Analysis
This type of analysis aims at making a static analysis of financial statements for one year only. In this type
each figure, representing a particular item is compared with the total of a single financial statement. For example, comparison of current Assets and current liabilities for one point of time or one accounting period.

4-06 TOOLS OR TECHNIQUES OF ANALYSIS


1. Comparative Financial Statements
2. Common-size statements
3. Trend analysis
4. Ratio analysis
5. Fund flow statement
6. Cash flow statement
1) Comparative Financial Statements
One of the techniques of financial statements analysis is the preparation of comparative financial statements
of the same concern for two accounting periods or for two or more concerns for a particular period. In this
statement figures of two or more years are placed side by side to facilitate comparison.
a)

Comparative Income Statement

The income statement discloses Net profit or Net loss resulting from the operations of business. A comparative income statement will show the absolute figures for two or more periods, the absolute change from one
period to another and if desired the change in terms of percentages. Since the figures for two or more periods
are shown side by side, the reader can quickly ascertain whether, sales have increased or decreased, whether
cost of sales has increased or decreased etc. This statement helps in deriving meaningful conclusions.
b) Comparative Balance Sheet
Comparative Balance sheet as on two or more different dates can be used for comparing assets and
liabilities and finding out any increase or decrease in those items. This facilitates comparison of figures of two or
more periods and provide necessary information which may be useful in forming an opinion regarding the

63

financial condition as well as progressive outlook of the concern.


Illustration-I: From the following Profit and Loss Account and Balance Sheet of X Ltd. you are required to
prepare a Comparative Income Statement and a Comparative Balance Sheet.

PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT


for the year ended 31st December
(Rupees in Lakhs)

To cost of goods sold

2002

2003

2002

2003

Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

Rs.

600

750

To Administration expenses

20

20

To Selling expenses

30

40

150

190

800

1000

To Net profit

By Sales

800

1,000

800

1000

BALANCE SHEET
as at 31 st December
(Rupees in Lakhs)
Liabilities

2002

2003

Rs.

Rs.

Assets

2002

2003

Rs.

Rs.

Equity capital

400

400

Land and Building

400

370

6% pref. capital

300

300

Plant and Machinery

400

410

Reserves

200

245

Stock

200

300

8% Debentures

100

150

Debtors

200

300

50

75

Cash

100

140

250

350

1300

1520

1300

1520

Bills Payable
Sundry creditors

64

Solution :
X Ltd.

COMPARATIVE INCOME STATEMENT


For the years ended 31-3-02 and 31-3-2003
Particulars

2002

2003

(Rupees in lakhs)

Absolute increase or Percentage increase


Decrease in 2003

or decrease in 2003

Net Sales

800

1000

+200

+25

Cost of goods sold

600

750

+150

+25

Gross profit (A)

200

250

+50

+25

Administration expenses

20

20

------

------

Selling expenses

30

40

+10

+33.33

Total (B)

50

60

+10

+20

150

190

+40

+26.67

less operating expenses :

Operating profit (A) - (B)

X Ltd.

COMPARATIVE BALANCE SHEET as at 31st Dec. 2002 and 2003


(Rupees in lakhs)
2002

2003

Absolute increase or Percentage increase


Decrease in 2003
or decrease in 2003

Cash

100

140

+40

+40

Debtors

200

300

+100

+50

Stock

200

300

+100

+50

Total Current Assets

500

740

240

48

Land and Building

400

370

-30

-7.5%

Plant and Machinery

400

410

+10

+2.5%

Total of fixed Assets

800

780

-20

-2.5%

1300

1520

+220

ASSETS:
Current Assets :

Fixed Assets:

Total Assets

65

+17%

LIABILITIES:
Current Laibilities:
Bills payable

50

75

+25

+50%

Sundry creditors

250

350

+100

+40%

Total of Current liabilities

300

425

+125

+41.67 %

8% Debentures

100

150

+50

Total liabilities

400

575

+175

+43.75%

6% Preference capital

300

300

-----

-----

Equity capital

400

400

-----

-----

Reserves

200

245

+45

+22.5%

Total Shareholders Funds

900

945

+45

+5%

1,300

1,520

+220

+17%

Long-term liabilities:
+50%

Capital and Retained Earnings :

Total Capital & liabilities

2. Common - Size Statements


Common-size financial statements are those in which figures reported are converted into percentages to
some common base. According to Kohler, they are accounting statements expressed in percentage of some
base, rather than rupees. The base selected may be sales which is an item of the income statement and the
same is assumed to be equal to 100. Similarly, capital or total assets of the position statement may be the base
converted to 100, and all other items in the financial statements are expressed as a percent of sales, capital or
total assets as the case may be. Since the bases selected represent 100 percent in the financial statements, there
is a common basis for analysis and the statements are known as 100 percent statement or common-size statements.
Illustration 2
On the basis of data given in Illustration 1 prepare a common-size income statement and common size
Balance sheet of X Ltd. for the years ended 31st march 2002 and 2003.

66

X Ltd.
COMMON-SIZE INCOME STATEMENT
for the years ended 31st March 2002 and 2003
(Figures in percentage)
Particulars

2002

2003

Net Sales

100

100

less cost of goods sold

75

75

Gross profit

25

25

Operating expenses:Administration expenses

2.50

Selling expenses

3.75

Total operating expenses

6.25

18.75

19

Operating Profit

Interpretation
Here each expense is shown as a percentage of net sales. The sales figure is assumed to be 100% and all
figures are shown as a percentage of net sales. The statement shows that though in absolute terms, the cost of
goods sold has gone up, the percentage of its cost to sales remains consistent at 75 %. Therefore Gross profit
continues at 25% of sales. Similarly, in absolute terms the amount of administration expenses remains the same
but as percentage to sales, it has come down by 5%. Selling expenses have increased by 25%. This all leads to
Net Profit by 25% (ie. from 18.75 % to 19%)
X Ltd.
COMMON-SIZE BALANCE SHEET
as at 31st Dec. 2002, 2003
Assets

2002

2003

100

100

7.70

9.21

Debtors

15.38

19.74

Stock

15.38

19.74

Total Current Assets

38.46

48.69

Current Assets:
Cash

67

Fixed Assets:
Land and Building

30.77

24.34

Plant and Machinery

30.77

26.97

61.54

51.31

Total fixed assets


Total Assets
Liabilities and Capital

100

100

2002

2003

100

100

Current Laibilities
Bills Payable

3.84

4.93

19.23

23.02

23.07

27.95

7.70

9.87

6% preference share capital

23.08

19.74

Equity share capital

30.77

26.32

Reserves

15.38

16.12

Total Shareholders fund

76.93

72.05

Sundry creditors

Long term liabilities


8% Debentures
Capital and Reserves

Total liabilities and capital

100

100

Interpretation
Each asset is shown as a percentage of total asset and each liability and capital as a percentage
of total liability and capital. The percentage of current assets to total assets was 38.46 in 2002. It has gone up
to 48.69 in 2003. Similarly, percentage of current liabilities to total liabilities has gone up from 23.07 in 2002 to
27.95 in 2003. Thus proportion of current assets has increased by a higher percentage (about 10) as compared
to increase in the proportion of current liabilities (about 5) This has improved the working capital position of the
company. The proportion of shareholders fund in the total liabilities has come down from 69.23% to 62.18 %
while debentures has gone up from 7.70 % to 9.87 %

3) Trend Analysis
Both the comparative and common size statements suffer from a major limitation ie. absence of a

68

basic standard or a reference level to indicate whether the proportion of an item is normal or abnormal. This
limitation is overcome in the case of the trend analysis.
Trend analysis is an important tool of financial analysis. Under this method, a particular year, usually the first
year, is taken as the base year and the figures of the succeeding years for every item in the financial statements
are expressed as percentage of the same item. In other words, under this method, a representative year is
selected as the base and the values of items in the base year are assumed to be 100. Later, the relationship of
each item to the same item in the base year is expressed as a percentage. Thus when an item is expressed as
100, all other values expressed in terms of the base year will reflect a tendency in relation to 100. This tendency
expressed numerically is known as the Index number. The trend percentage of each item is compared with its
percentage of the preceding year for getting an idea of the progress of the concern.
Illustration 3- From the following information extracted from the Balance sheet of a company for five
previous financial periods, calculate the trend percentages taking 1998 as the base year.
in Rs 000
1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

Current Assets:
Cash

80

100

120

200

110

Bank

100

130

150

100

120

Debtors

150

200

300

500

800

stock

300

400

600

900

1000

500

500

600

600

600

1000

1000

1200

1200

1200

2130

2330

2970

3500

3830

Fixed assets:
Building
Plant and Machinery

Solution:

TREND PERCENTAGES
(Rs. in 000)

Trend percentages

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

Cash

80

100

120

200

110

100

125

150

250

137.50

Bank

100

130

150

100

120

100

130

150

100

120.00

Debtors

150

200

300

500

800

100

133

200

333

53.00

Stock

300

400

600

900

1000

100

133

200

300

333.00

Current Assets:

69

Fixed Assets:
Building

500

500

600

600

600

100

100

120

120

120.00

Plant

1000

1000

1200

1200

1200

100

100

120

120

120.00

Total

2130

2330

2970

3500

3830

100

109

139

164

180.00

4. Ratio Analysis
The ratio analysis is one of the most useful and common methods of analysing fianancial statements. As
compared to other tools of financial analysis, the ratio analysis provides very useful conclusions about various
aspects of the working like financial position, solvency, liquidity and profitability of an enterprise. Ratio analysis
as a tool for the interpretation of fianancial statements is also significant because ratios help the analyst to have
a deep peep into the data given in the statements. Figures in their absolute forms shown in financial statements
are neither significant nor able to be compared. In fact, they are basically dump. Ratios provide the power to
speak.
A ratio is a mathematical relationship between two related items expressed in quantitative form. When this
definition of ratio is explained with reference to the items shown in financial statements, then it is called accounting ratio. So Accounting ratios are relationships, expressed in quantitative terms, between figures which
have a cause and effect relationship or which are connected with each other in some manner or the other.
Accounting ratios can be expressed in various forms
i) As pure ratio, for eg: ratio of current assets to current liabilities 2:1
ii) As rate, for example, stock turn over 4 times a year
iii) As percentage, for example Gross profit to sales 25%

Steps involved in ratio analysis


1. Selection of relevant data from the financial statements depending upon the objectives of the analysis
2. Calculation of appropriate ratios
3. Comparison of calculated ratios with those of previous years or similar ratios of other concerns in the
same industry.
4. Interpretation of this ratios
Uses or
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

advantages of Ratio Analysis.


Facilitates analysis of financial statements
Ratio analysis facilitates intra-firm and interfirm comparison
It reveals operational efficiency.
Planning device
Ratios may be used as instrument of management control.

70

6. Ratio analysis communicate the financial strength or weakness of a firm.


In a more easy and understandable manner.
Llimitations of Ratio Analysis.
1. May get false results, if based on incorrect accounting data
2. The technique is quantitative in nature; it ignores the qualitative factors.
3. Problem of window dressing
4. Price level changes make the ratio analysis difficult
5. Lack of adequate standard
6. No idea of probable happenings in future
7. Divergent methods of computing ratios
Classification of Accounting Ratios
(A) Classification according to accounting statement
(1) Balance sheet ratios
(2) Profit and loss account ratios
(B) Classification according to importance
(1) Primary ratios
(2) Secondary ratios
(C) Classification according to nature or purpose
1) Liquid Ratios, 2) Leverage Ratios, 3) Activity Ratios, 4) Profitability Ratios
(1) Liquidity Ratios: These ratios measure the capacity of a firm to meet its short-term liabilities out of the
short term resources
a) Current ratio :- This is the ratio of current assets to current liabilities. It shows the relationship between total
current assets and total current liabilities.
Current Ratio =

Current assets
Current liabilities

Current assets of a business consist of those assets that can be converted into cash in the ordinary course of
business, and within a short period of time. These include cash, bank, marketable securities, stocks, sundry
debtors bills receivables and pre-payments. Similarly current liabilities include trade creditors, bills payable, bank
overdraft, provision for taxation, outstanding liabilities etc.
Current ratio is a test of short-term solvency of the firm. The higher the current ratio, the greater the firms
ability to meet short term debts. Conventionally, a current ratio of 2:1 is considered satisfactory.
b) Liquid ratio or Quick Ratio
It is a measure of the immediate debt paying capacity of a firm. It shows the relationship between Quick
assets and Quick liabilities or current liabilities. Quick assets comprise all current assets with the exception of
inventories and pre-payments. Liquid liabilities are current liabilities minus bank overdraft. This ratio is also
known as Acid Test Ratio. It is computed as follows:
Liquid Ratio =

Liquid assets
Liquid liabilities

or

Liquid assets
Current liabilities

71

2) Leverage Ratios: These are also called capital structure ratios. This ratios analyse long term solvency or
financial position of a firm. Ratios to test long term solvency are as follows:
(a) Debt - Equity Ratio:- This ratio is also known as the external-internal equity ratio as it relates external
equity to internal equity. It shows the proportion of funds provided by the owners as against outsiders. It is
computed as follows.
Debt - equtiy ratio =

Total outside liabilities or long -term debt


shareholders funds

Shareholders equity

A high debt-equity ratio indicates that outsiders have contributed more funds than the owners and hence,
they have a larger claim on the firms assets. A low ratio, on the other hand, signifies that outsiders claim on the
firms assets is less.
b) Proprietary Ratio:
This ratio is also known as the ratio of networth to total assets. This ratio establishes the relationship between
proprietors fund and total assets. Proprietors funds comprise equity and preference share capital as well as
reserves and surplus. Assets comprise both fixed and current assets, excluding fictitious assets. Intangible
assets may be included provided they have realisable value. It is computed as follows:
Proprietary Ratio

Shareholders funds
Total assets

A high proprietary ratio indicates a relatively favourable position to the creditors at the time of liquidation. A
low ratio indicates a higher risk and danger to creditors.
c) Ratio of Fixed Assets to proprietors funds :

It states the relationship between fixed assets and

shareholders funds. It shows what portion of proprietors funds have been invested in fixed assets. A very high
ratio of fixed assets indicates that a considerable part of proprietors funds is locked up in fixed assets. This ratio
is computed as follows :
Fixed assets to proprietors funds =

Fixed assets
shareholders funds

d) Capital Gearing ratio :


This is one of the important ratio used to analyse the capital structure of a company. The capital gearing ratio
is computed as follows.
Capital Gearing ratio = Fixed income bearing funds
Equity shareholders fund

72

Fixed income bearing funds include preference share capital, debenture and long term loans. A company
would be highly geared, if the proportion of preference share capital and debenture is high ie. equity capital is
less and a company is said to be low geared, if the proportion of preference capital and debenture is low ie.
equity capital is high.
e) Coverage ratios :
Financial Coverage ratios calculated in flow terms, are known as coverage ratios which assess
the degree of risk associated with lending. The following are the coverage ratios.
(i) Interest coverage ratio :
This ratio relates the fixed interest charges to the operating profit or the earnings before interest and tax
(EBIT) it is computed as follows:
Interest coverage Ratio =

Earnings Before Interest and Tax (EBIT)


Interest

A high interest coverage ratio indicates that the concern has the ability to pay fixed charges. A very low ratio
indicates inefficient business operations and excessive use of borrowed funds.
(ii) Preference Dividend coverage Ratio
This ratio measures the ability of a concern to pay the fixed dividend on preference shares after payment of
tax.
Preference coverage Ratio = Earnings after taxes
Preference Dividend

3. Activity Ratios
These are also known as turnover ratios. These ratios indicate how effectively the resources are being
utilised by a firm. These ratios reflected the efficiency of a firm in the asset management. They express the
relationship between sales and the different types of assets, showing the speed with which these assets generate
sales. Important activity ratios are enumerated below.
a)

Current assets turnover

Sales
Current assetes

b)

Fixed assets turnover ratio

Sales
Fixed assets

c)

Total assets turnover ratio

Sales
Total assets

d)

Inventory turnover ratio

Sales
Average inventory

e)

Debtors turnover ratio

Sales
Average debtors

73

4. Profitability Ratios
The success of any business depends upon its profitability ie. its ability to earn profits. Profitability is also a
measure of business or operational efficiency. These ratios are calculated by relating the profits either to sales
or to investment or to the equity shares. Important ratios are listed below:
A. Profitability related to sales.
a) Gross profit ratio =

Gross profit
sales

b) Net profit ratio

Net profit (earnings after tax)


Sales

c) Operating profit ratio

EBIT (Earining Before Interest and Tax)


Sales

d) Administrative expenses ratio = Administrative exp.


Sales
e) Selling expenses ratio

Selling expenses
Sales

f) Operating expenses ratio

administrative exp. +selling exp.


Sales

g) Operating ratio

Cost of goods sold + operating exp.


Sales

B. Profitability related to investment


a) Return on assets

Earnings after tax


Total assets

b) Return on capital employed =

EBIT
Total capital employed

c) Return on equity

EAT
Shareholders equity

C. Profitability related to equity shares


a) Earnings per share (EPS)
= Net profit available to equity share holders
Number of equity shares
b) Earnings yield =

EPS
Market price per share

c) Dividend yield =

DPS ( Dividend per share)


Market price per share

74

d)

Dividend payout ratio

DPS
EPS

e)

Price earnings ratio

Market price per share

(P/E ratio)

EPS

D. Overall profitability (Earning power)


Return on Investment (ROI) =

EAT

Sales

sales

Total assets
or
EAT

Total assets
The overall profitability is measured by the return on investments which is the product of net profit ratio and
investment turnover.
Thus Ratio analysis is a method of interpreting the financial statement of a company. A single ratio by itself
is not of much use. A comprehensive evaluation of the financial performance of a company emerges only from
a study of all the important ratios.
Illustration:The summarised Balance Sheet of Goods Value Traders Ltd. for the year ended 31-3-03 is given below:
(Rs. in Lakhs)
Rs.
Equity Share capital
(fully paid up)

Rs.
fixed Assets (at cost)

140

Less: Depreciation

210
25

Reserves and Surplus;

45

185

Profit and Loss Account

20

Current Assets:

.Provision for taxation

10

Stock

25

Sundry Creditors

40

Debtors

30

Cash

15
70

255

255

The following further particulars are also given for the year:
Sales
120
Earnings before interest and tax (EBIT)
30
Net profit after tax (PAT)
20
Calculate the following for the company and explain the significance of each in one or two sentences.
i) Current ratio, (ii) Liquidity ratio, (iii) Profitability ratio, (iv) Profitability on funds employed (v) Debtors Turnover.

75

(vi) Stock turnover (vii) average collection period and (viii) return on equity ( I.C.W.A Inter; June 1998.
Adapted)
(i)

Current Assets
Current Ratio

Current Liabilities

70 = 1 40 : 1
50
Current ratio indicates short-term solvency of a concern, i.e., whether the concern is capable of meeting its
immediate commitments out of its current assets, The standard being 2:1, the concern is not up to the standard.
(Provision for tax is treated as a current liability.)
ii)

Liquidity Ratio

Liquid Assets

Current Liabilities

45 = 09:1
50
The liquid ratio tells us whether the position of a concern is liquid enough to meet its current liabilities, ie ,
whether the current assets can be converted into ready cash for meeting the claims of creditors. The standard
ratio being 1 : 1, the concerns liquidity position also is not up to the standard .
EBIT
iii)

Profitability Ratio (on funds employed =

Capital employed

x 100

30
x 100 = 14.63 %
205
iv)

Profitability Ratio

EBIT
x 100
Sales

30 x 100 = 25%
120
While the profitability ratio on funds employed measures the return on investment, the latter shows the
margin of profit on sales.
v)
Debtors Turnover Ratio =
Sales
Average Debtors
120
= 4 times
30
According to this ratio, debtors are converted to cash four times during the period of operating cycle.
vi)
Stock Turnover Ratio
=
Cost of goods sold
Sales
OR
Average stock
Average stock
120
= 4.8 times
25
This ratio indicates that stock is turned over as sales 4.8 times.

76

vii)

Average collection period

Average Debtors + Average B/R


Credit Sales
30
120

viii)

Return on Equity

x 360 days = 90 days

PAT
Equity
20

x 100 =9.76 %

205
This ratio indicates the percentage of profit earned by the equity shareholders on their funds.
Illustration -6
Using the following data, complete the balance sheet of X Limited as at 31-3-2000
a)

Gross profit 25 % of sales

b)

Gross proft = Rs 1,20,000

c)

Shareholders equity Rs. 20,000

d)

Credit sales to total sales 80%

e)

Total turnover to total assets = 4 times

f)

Cost of sales to inventory = 10 times

g)

Average collection period = 5 days. Assume 365 days in a year.

h)

Long-term debt = ?

i)

Current ratio = 1.5

j)

Sundry creditors = Rs. 60,000

BALANCE SHEET OF X LIMITED as at 31-3-2000


Liabilities

Rs

Assets

Sundry Crditors

Cash

Long-term. Debt

Sundry Debtors

Share Capital

Inventory

Rs.

Fixed Assets

(CA Inter Nov. 2000)

77

Solution:
Gross Profit Ratio
25
25 Sales
Sales

Gross Profit x 100


Sales

1,20,000 x 100
Sales

= Rs. 1,20,00,000
= Rs. 4,80,000

Sales-Gross profit

= Cost of goods sold

4,80,000- 1,20,000

= Rs. 3,60,000

Current Ratio

Current Assets
Current Liabilities
Current Assets

1.5

Current Assets

60,000
60,000x1.5 = Rs. 90,000

Cost of sales to inventory 10 times.


Cost of sales
10

Inventory

10

10 Inventory

3,60,000

Inventory

Rs. 36,000

Average Collection Period

Debtors
x No. days in year
Credit sales

5 days

Debtors

3,60,000
inventory

3,84,000

x 365 days

365 Debtors

19,20,000

Debtors

Rs. 5,260

(Credit sales is 80% of total sales

4,80,000 x 80
100

Total Turnover-to total assets

4 times.

Total turnover
Total assets

4 Total assets

4,80,000

78

= Rs. 3,84,000 )

Total assets

Rs. 1,20,000

Current Assets

Rs. 90,000

Inventory

Rs. 36,000

Debtors

5,260
41,260

Cash

48,740

Total Assets

Rs. 1,20,000

Current Assets

90,000

Fixed Assets

Rs. 30,000

BALANCE SHEET OF X LIMITED as at 31-3-2000


Rs.

Rs.

Creditors

60,000

Cash

48,740

Long-term debt (balancing figure)

40,000

Debtors

Share capital

20,000

Inventory

36,000

Fixed Assets

30,000

5,260

1,20,000

1,20,000

Illustration -7 : From the following information relating to a company, prepare a statement of Proprietors
Funds :
i)

Current ratio

ii)

Liquid ratio

1.5

iii)

Fixed Assets / Proprietary Funds

3/4

iv)

Working capital

v)

Reserves and Surplus

50,000

vi)

Bank overdraft

10,000

Rs. 75,000

There were no long- term loans or fictitious assets

(CA Inter, Revision Test Nov. 1997

Solution:
Current Ratio

Current Assets
Current Liabilities

Current Assets
Current Liabilities

Current Assets

2 Current Liabilities

Working capital

Current Assets - Current Liabilities

75,000

2 Current Liabilities - Current Liabilities

Current Liabilities

Rs. 75,000

79

Since current assets are equal to 2 current liabilities, and current liabilities being Rs. 75,000 current assets
should be 75,000 x 2 = Rs. 1,50,000
Liquid Ratio

Current Assets - Stock


Current Liabilities

1.5

1,50,000-stock
75,000

1,50,000-Stock

1,12,500

Stock

1,50,000-1,12,500=Rs.37,500

Proprietary Funds+Current Liabilities =

Fixed Assets + Current Assets

Fixed Assets are 3/4 of Proprietary Funds. If proprietary funds were x:


x + 75,000

3/4x + 1,50,000

x-3/4x

1,50,000 - 75,000

1/4x

75,000

Rs. 3,00,000 and fixed assets are 3/4 of


Rs 3,00,000=Rs2,25,000

Proprietary funds include share capital and retained earnings. Accordingly, Rs. 3,00,000-Reserves and Surplus
of Rs. 50,000 = Rs. 2,50,000 is share capital.
STATEMENT OF PROPRIETORS FUNDS
Rs.

Rs.

Sources :
Share capital
Reserve and Surplus

2,50,000
50,000
3,00,000

Application:
Fixed Assets
Current Assets:
Stock
Liquid Assets

2,25,000
Rs.

37,500
1,12,500
1,50,000

Current Liabilities:
Bank overdraft
Others

10,000
65,000
75,000

Working capital being excess of current assets


over current liabilites

75,000
3,00,000

80

Illustration 8
From the following details find out - (a) Sales (b) Sundry Debtors (c) closing stock (d) Sundry creditors.
Debtors velocity

3 months

Stock velocity

8 months

Creditors velocity

2 months

Gross profit ratio -

25%

Gross profit for the year ended 31st Dec. 1998 amounts to Rs. 4,00,000. Closing stock of the year is
Rs. 10,000 above the operating stock. Bill receivable amounts to Rs. 25,000 and Bills payable to Rs. 10,000

Solution
1) Sales :-

G/P ratio

25%

G/P

4,00,000

... Sales

4,00,000 x 100 = Rs. 16,00,000


25

Debtors velocity

3 months

Debtors velocity

Drs + B/R
x l2
Credit Sales

3 months

Drs + B/R
16,00,000

Sundry Debtors

3)

x 12

Drs x 12

16,00,000 x 3

(Drs + B/R)

1,60,000 x 3
12

Rs. 4,00,000

Drs

4,00,000 - 25,000

Rs. 3, 75,000

Stock Velocity

8 months

Stock velocity

Average Stock x 12
Cost of sales

Average stock x 12

Cost of sales x 8

Cost of sales

Rs. 12,00,000

Rs. 8,00,000

Closing stocks

16,00,000-4,00,000

... Average stock x12

12,000,00 x8

Average stock

12,00,000 x 8
12

Total of opening stock + closing stock =


=

8,00,000 x 2
Rs. 16,00,000

81

As closing stock is more by 10,000


Opening stock

... Closing stock


d)

16,00,000 - 10,000
2

Rs. 7,95,000

7,95,000 + 10,000

Total Crs + B/P

Rs.8,05,000

Sundry creditors
Creditors Velocity

x12 =

2 months

Credit purchases
Purchases

Closing stock + cost of goods sold - opening stock

8,05,000 +12,00,000 - 7,95,000

Purchases

Rs. 12,10,000

Creditors Velocity

Crs + B/P

x 12

12,10,000
(Crs + B/P) +2

12,10,000 x 2
12

Crs + BP

2,01,667

Crs.

2,01,666 -B/P

2,01,667-10,000

Rs. 1,91,667

Crs.

Illustration 9
From the following information, prepare a Balance sheet. Show the workings.

1. Working Capital
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

Reserves & Surplus


Bank overdraft
Current Ratio
Liquid ratio
Fixed Assets to proprietors funds
Long term liabilities
Current Ratio
Working Capital
Working Capital
W.C
.75

Rs. 75,000
1,00,000
60,000
1.75
1.15
0.75
Nil
1.75:1
C.A - C.L
1.75 - 1
.75
75,000

=
=
=
=
=
=
=
82

... Current Assets (1.75)

75,000 x 1.75
.75

Rs. 1,75,000

Current Liabilities (1)

Rs. 1,00,000

Liquid Ratio

75,000 x 1
.75
Liquid Assets
Current Liabilities

or

L.A
L.L

liquid liability

=
=

1,00,000-Bank overdraft
1,00,000 - 60,000
=

1.15:1

=
=

40,000
40,000 x 1.15

...
...

Liquid Ratio
Liquid Liabilities (1)
Liquid Assets
Stock in trade

Fixed assets to proprietors funds

Share capital

Rs. 46,000

1
Current Assets - Liquid Assets
1,75,000 - 46,000
=
Rs. 1,29,000

=
=
F.A

=
.75
P.F
This means that .25 or 25 % Proprietors fund is invested in working capital
... .25
=
75,000
.. . Fixed Assets (.75)
=
75,000 x75
=
.25
Proprietors fund

40,000

Rs. 2,25,000

75,000 x 100 or Fixed assets + working capital


.25

=
=
=

2,25,000 + 75,000
Rs. 3,00,000
Proprietors fund - Reserves & Surplus

=
=

3,00,000 - 1,00,000
Rs. 2,00,000

83

Balance Sheet
Liabilities

Rs.

Assets

Share capital

2,00,000

Fixed Assets

Reserve & Surplus

1,00,000

Current Assets

Current Liabilities

Rs.
2,25,000

Stock

Sundry Creditors

40,000

Bank overdraft

60,000

1,29,000

Liquid Assets

46,000

4,00,000

4,00,000

Illustration 10
With the following ratios and further information given below, prepare a trading Account, Profit and loss
account and a Balance sheet.
1.

Gross profit ratio

25 %

6. Fixed Assets / Capital

2.

Net Profti Sales

20%

7. Fixed Assets/Total

3.

Stock Turnover

10

4.

Net profit / Capital

/5

8. Fixed Assets

= 5
7
= 10,00,000

5.

Capital to total liabilities

9. Closing stock

= 1,00,000

Fixed Assets / Capital

Fixed Assets

10,00,000

5
4

10,00,000
Capital

5
4

10,00,000 x 4

5 x Capital

Capital

10,00,000 x 4
5

Capital

Rs. 8,00,000

Current Assets

Solution
1.

Fixed Assets
Capital

/4

84

= 5
4

2.

Capital to Total Liabilities


Capital

8,00,000 x2

Rs. 16,00,000

1
5

Total Liabilities
8,00,000
Total Liabilities
Total Liabilities x 1

3.

Net Profit to capital


N/P
Capital

4.

5.

= 1/5 ie

N/P
8,00,000

/5

ie N/P x 5

8,00,000

NP

8,00,000 = 1,60,000
5

Net profit is 20 % on sales


20%

1,60,000

Sales (100%)

1,60,000 x 100
20

Rs. 8,00,000

8,00,000

Stock Turnover ratio


S.T ration

=
=

10
Cost of sales
= 10
Average stock

Cost of sales

=
=
=

Sales - G/P
8,00,000 - 2,00,000
Rs. 6,00,000

=
=
=

10
6,00,000
6,00,000
10

=
=
=
=
=

6,00,000
60,000 x 2
1,20,000
1,00,000
20,000

G/P is 25 % on sales
G/P

6.

6,00,000
A Stock
A.S. x 10
A.S
Average stock
So Total Stock (opening + Closing)
Closing stock
Opening Stock

85

x 25
100

Rs. 2,00,000

Rs 60,000

F.A
C.A

/7

ie. F.A x 7

C.A x 5

1,00,000 x 7
C.A. x 5
C.A

=
=
=

Current Assets
Less stock
Other Current Assets

=
=
=
=

C.A x 5
1,00,000 x 7
1,00,000 x 7
5
Rs. 14,00,000
14,00,000
1,00,000
13,00,000

Fixed Assets to total current Assets


=

5
7

Trading and profit and Loss Account


To Opening Stock
,, Purchases
(Bal. fig.)
,,
G/P

,, Expenses
,, N/P

20,000
6,80,000

By sales
,, closing stock

2,00,000
9,00,000
40,000
1,60,000
2,00,000

8,00,000
1,00,000

9,00,000
By G/P

2,00,000
2,00,000

Balance sheet
Capital
Opening 6,40,000
Add N/P 1,60,000
Liabilities

8,00,000
16,00,000

Fixed Assets
Closing Stock
Other Current Assets

24,00,000

Illustration 11
From the following figures and ratios, draw out Balance sheet and Trading and P&L a/c
Share capital
Rs.
1,80,000
Working capital
63,000
Bank overdraft
10,000

86

10,00,000
1,00,000
13,00,000

24,00,000

There is no fixed assets. In current assets there is no asset other than stock, debtors and cash. Closing stock
is 20 % higher than the opening stock.
Current ratio
=
2.5
Net Profit ratio
=
10%
Proprietary ratio
=
0.7
(to average capital employed)
Stock velocity
=
4
Quick ratio
=
1.5
G/P Ratio
=
20% to sales
Debtors velocity
=
36.5 year

Solution
Current ratio
2.5-1
1.5
Current Assets (2.5)

=
2.5:1
= 63,000
= 63,000

Quick ratio
Current liabilities (1)
Bank overdraft

63,000 x 2.5
1.5
= Rs. 1,05,000

=
=
=

= 63,000 x 1
1.5
= Rs. 42,000
Closing stock
= C.A - L.A
= 1,05,000 - 48,000
= Rs. 57,000
Closing stock is 20% higher than opening stock
So opening stock
= 57,000 x 100
120
= Rs. 47,500
Average stock
= 57,000 + 47,500
2
= Rs. 52,250
Stock velocity
= Cost of Sales
=
Average stock

Quick liabilities (1) =


Quick assets (1.5) =

Current liabilities

Cost of sales

G/P on sales
(ie. 1/4 on cost)
Cost of sales
G/P (1/4)
Sales

1.5:1
42,000
10,000

=
=
=
=

Average stock x 4
52.250 x 4
Rs. 2,09,000
20%

= Rs. 2,09,000
52,250
= Rs. 2,61,250

87

= Rs. 48,000

32,000
32,000 x 1.5
1

Debtors velocity

= 36.5 year
Drs
=
x 365
Cr. sales

= 36.5

Drs
x 365
= 36.5
2,61, 250
Drs
= 2,61,250 x 36.5
365
Drs
= Rs. 26,125
Proprietary Ratio
=
0.7
It means 70 % of proprietary fund represents Fixed Assets and 30 % is invested in working capital
30% = 63,000
F.A (70%)
= 63,000 x 70
=
Rs. 1,47,000
30
Working capital 30 %
So proprietary fund

= 63,000
=
1,47,000 +
63,000
Rs. 2,10,000

Net profit
Let net profit be x
x
x
x

= 10% of (opening Capital + Closing Capital)


2
= 10% of (Closing capital -x + closing Capital)
2
= 1 (2,10,000 - x + 2,10,000)
20

20x
20 x
20x + x
21 x
x

=
=
=
=
=

1 (4,20,000 - x)
20
1 (4,20,000 - x)
4,20,000 - x
4,20,000
4,20,000
4,20,000
21
=

88

Rs. 20,000

Trading and Profit and loss A/c


To Opening stock
,, Purchases (Bal. fig)

47,500
2,18,500

G/P. c/d
,, G/P c/d
,, Expenses (Bal. fig)
,, N/P

52,250
3,18,250
32,250
20,000

By sales
,, Closing stock

2,61,250
57,000

By Gross Profit b/d

3,18,250
52,250

52,250

52,250

Balance Sheet
Share Capital
Reserve & Surplus
P & L a/c
Bank overdraft
Creditors

1,80,000
10,000
20,000
10,000
32,000

fixed Assets
Current assets---Closing stock
Debtors
Cash (Bal. fig)

2,52,000

1,47,000
57,000
26,125
21,875
2,52,000

Illustration 12
From the following information, make out a statement of proprietors funds with as many details as possible.
Current ratio=2.5; liquid ratio = 1.5 propietary ratio (fixed assets / proprietary fund = 0.75 Working capital
Rs. 1,20,000; Reserves and surplus Rs. 80,000 and Bank overdraft Rs. 20,000.

Solution
Working Capital
1.5
Current Assets (2.5)

=
=
=
=

Current liabilities

Bank overdraft
Creditors & Others
Proprietary fund

2.5 - 1 = 1.5
1,20,000
1,20,000 x 2.5
1.5
Rs. 2,00,000

1,20,000 x 1
1.5
Rs. 80,000

=
=
=

20,000
60,000
75 % in Fixed Assets

89

So 25 % is working capital
25%
=
...Proprietary fund
=

Capital
Capital
Fixed Assets 75%
Liquid ratio
Liquid Assets
Liquid liabilities
Liquid Assets
60,000

=
=
=
=
=

Rs. 4,80,000
Proprietors fund - reserves
4,80,000 - 80,000
4,00,000
4,00,000 x 75
= Rs. 3,60,000
100

1.5

1.5
1

Liquid Assets

=
=
=

Stock

Rs. 1,20,000
Rs. 1,20,000 x 100
25

1.5
1
60,000 x 1.5
Rs. 90,000
2,00,000 - 90,000
(C.A - L.A)

= 1,10,000

Statement of Proprietors funds


Capital employed :Equity Capital

4,00,000

Reserves & Surplus

80,000

4,80,000

Employment of Capital :Fixed Assets

3,60,000

Current Assets ------Stock

1,10,000

Liquid Assets

90,000
2,00,000

Less current liabilities :Bank overdraft


Creditors

20,000
60,000

80,000

1,20,000
4,80,000

90

Illustration 13
From the following details, draw up a Balance sheet in summary form.
Stock velocity

6;

Capital Turnover ratio

Fixed Assets Turnover

4;

G/P ratio

20%

Debt collection period

2 months;

creditors payment period 73 days`

The gross profit was Rs. 60,000. Closing stock was Rs. 5000 in excess of the opening stock.

Solution
1.

Gross profit ratio

20%

... Sales

G/P
Sales

60,000 x 100
Sales

60,00,000
20
Rs. 3,00,000

=
2.

Stock velocity

Average stock

=
=

Opening stock

... Closing stock


3. Capital Turnover
2
Capital x 2
Capital

x 100

Cost of goods sold


Average stock
3,00,000 - 60,000
Average stock
2,40,000
6
Rs. 40,000

=6

Total stock - 5000 = 40,000 x 2 - 5000


2
2
Rs. 37,500

Rs. 42,500

Sales
Capital

3,00,000
Capital
3,00,000
3,00,000
2

=
=

(37,500 + 5000)
=2

= Rs. 1,50,000

91

4.

Fixed Assets Turnover


ratio

4
F.A
5.

Debt collection period

Debtors

=
=
=

3,00,000
F.A
Rs. 75,000
Debtors
Net sales
Drs
3,00,000

x 12 =2
x 12

Rs. 50,000

Opening stock + Purchases - Closing Stock


Purchases

7.

=
=

6.

Sales
=4
Fixed Assets

Credit payment period

Creditors

= Cost of goods sold

2,40,000 - 37,500 + 42,500

Rs. 2,45,000

Crs
x 365 = 73
Purchases

73 = Creditors x 365
2,45,000
Rs. 49,000

Balance Sheet
Rs.
Capital
Sundry creditors

Rs.

1,50,000
49,000

1,99,000

92

Fixed Assets

75,000

Stock

42,500

Sundry debtors

50,000

Cash (Bal. fig)

31,500
1,99,00

Illustration 14
From the following information, prepare a Balance sheet.
1. Current ratio

= 1.75

6. Reserves & Surplus to capital = 0.2

2. Liquid ratio

= 1.25

7. Turnover to fixed assets

= 1.2

= 9

8. Capital gearing ratio

= 0.6

4. Gross profit ratio

= 25%

9. Fixed Assets to net worth

= 1.25

5. Debt collection period

= 11/2 months 10.Sales for the year

3. Stock Turnover ratio


(Cost sales/closing stock)

Solution
1. Cost of sales

= Sales - Gross profit


= 12,00,000 - (12,00,000 x 25 )
100
= 12,00,000 - 3,00,000
= Rs. 9,00,000

2. Stock turnover ratio

Cost of sales
Average stock

9,00,000
stock

Rs. 1,00,000

11/2 months

= Drs x 12
12,00,000

1 1/ 2

Drs

= 12,00,000 x 3
2

Drs x 12

Drs

= 18,00,000
12

Rs. 1,50,000

Stock

9,00,000
9

3. Debtors
Debt collection period

Current Assets
Current Assets

Drs x 12
Net sales

Current ratio
Stock ratio

x stock

= 1.75 x 1,00,000 = Rs. 3,50,000


0.5

93

= Rs. 12,00,000

(Stock Ratio

= Current ratio - Liquid ratio)


= 1.75 - 1.25

Calculation of liquid assets

0.50

= Current Assets - stock


= Rs. 3,50,000 - Rs. 1,00,000
Rs. 2,50,000

Calculation of cash
cash

= Liquid Assets - debtors


= Rs. 2,50,000 - Rs. 1,50,000
= Rs. 1,00,000

Fixed Assets
Fixed Assets

Cost of sales
Fixed Assets Turnover
= 9,00,000
1.2
= Rs. 7,50,000

Current Liabilities
Current ratio

Current Assets
Current Liabilities

Current Assets
Current ratio

or
Current Liabilities

= 3,50,000
1.75
= Rs. 2,00,000
Share capital
Share capital

= Net worth - Reserve & Surplus


= 6,00,000 - 1,00,000
= Rs. 5,00,000

Long term liabilities


Long term liabilities

= Share capital x Gearing ratio


= 5,00,000 x 0.6
= Rs. 3,00,000

Notes
Calculation of Net worth
Net worth

Fixed Assets
Fixed assets to Networth

94

= 7,50,000
1.25
= Rs. 6,00,000
Calculate of Reserves & Surplus
Reserves

= Networth + Ratio of Reserves and surplus to capital


Total Ratio
= 6,00,000 x 0.2
1.2
= Rs. 1,00,000

Calculation of Total ratio


Share holders worth

= Capital + Reserves

Let capital be 1, then share holders worth 1.2 ie (1 + 0.2) Thus total ratio = 1.2
Balance sheet
Liabilities

Rs.

Assets

Rs.

Share capital

5,00,000

Fixed Assets

7,50,000

Reserves & Surplus

1,00,000

Stock

1,00,000

Long term Liabilities

3,00,000

Debtors

1,50,000

Current liabilities

2,00,000

Cash

1,00,000

11,00,000

11,00,000

95

5. Fund Flow analysis


Fund flow analysis has become an important tool available to financial analysts for their work. The Balance
Sheet of a business reveals its financial status at a particular point of time. Both the B/S and Income Statement
do not explain the changes in the firms financial position during a particular period of time. They do not indicate
the causes of changes or the movement of funds between two periods.
Fund flow analysis reveals the changes in working capital position. It tells about the source from which the
working capital was obtained. Thus it explains how working capital is raised and used during an accounting
period.
Under funds flow analysis, we prepare two statements- (i) Statement of changes in the working capital (ii)
Fund flow statement
Statement of changes in working capital is prepared with the help of current assets and current liabilities.
This statement shows changes in current assets and current liabilities. The purpose of this statement is to find
out the net changes in working capital.
Fund flow statement shows the sources and application of funds. It is prepared with the help of non current
assets and non current liabilities. It is a statement showing the changes in financial position between two balance
sheet dates. It shows the sources from which funds have been derived and the uses to which the funds were put.

6) Cash flow analysis


Income Statement and B/S are normally based on the accrual method of accounting instead of actual cash
receipt basis. They do no reveal the actual cash flow position of a firm. In order to determine the actual cash
flow position the income statement and B/S should be translated into a statement called cash flow statement. It
is an important tool of cash planning and control. A cash flow statement is a statement depicting change in cash
position from one period to another. The cash flow statement summarises the reasons for increase or decrease
in the amount of cash between two balance sheet dates.

Assignments
1.

What do you understand by analysis and Interpretation of Financial Statements ?

2.

What are the different types of financial analysis ?

3.

Give an analytical note on common-size statements and state the procedure of computing them.

4.

What is trend analysis ?

5.

Write short notes on common - size statement.

6.

Explain the significance of accounting ratios in financial statement analysis.

96

1.

The balance sheet of X Ltd. for the year 2000 and 2001 are given below :
BALANCE SHEET

Liabilities
Equity share capital

31-12-2000

31-12-2001

6,00,000

12,00,000

5,00,000

9,00,000

Assets

31-12-2000

31-12-2001

15,00,000

28,00,000

5,00,000

8,00,000

10,00,000

20,00,000

Fixed Assets:

10% Preference
share capital

Gross block
Less depreciation

Reserve Fund

4,00,000

5,00,000

Net block

Profit & Loss account

2,00,000

3,00,000

Investments

4,00,000

5,00,000

Long term Loans

2,00,000

5,00,000

Inventories

4,50,000

6,50,000

Creditors

1,00,000

3,00,000

Debtors

1,00,000

4,00,000

50,000

1,50,000

Cash
_________

_________

_________

_________

20,00,000

37,00,000

20,00,000

37,00,000

Your are required to comment on the financial position of the business with the help of comparative Balance
Sheet technique.
2. Following are the ratios relating to the trading activities of National traders Ltd:
Debtors s Velocity
3 months
Stock Velocity
8 months
Creditors Velocity
2 months
Gross Profit Ratio
25%
Gross profit for the year ended 31st December, 2001 amounts to Rs. 4,00,000. Closing stock for the year is
Rs. 10,000 above the opening stock. Bills Receivable amounts to Rs. 25,000 and Bills Payable amounts to
Rs. 10,000. Find out:
i) Sales, ii) Sundry Debtors, iii) Closing Stock, and iv) Sundry Creditors.
(C.A. Inter, May 2000)

Books Recommended for further reference


S.P IYENGAR

Advanced Accounting, Volume -II

Dr. B.S. RAMAN

Advanced Accountancy

Dr. S.N. MAHESWARI

Management Accounting and Financial Control

S.P. JAIN &

Advanced Accountancy

Dr. M.A. ARULANANDAM &

K.L. NARANG

97

UNIT - 5

DOUBLE ACCOUNT SYSTEM

OBJECTIVES

To understand the meaning and features of Double Account System.


To understand the distinctions between Double Account System and Double Entry System.

To learn the technique of preparing Revenue A/c, Net Revenue A/c, Capital A/c and General
Balance Sheet
To learn the determination of reasonable return, clear profit, surplus and Disposal.
To learn the preparation of final accounts of electricity companies.

STRUCTURE
5. 01

Meaning of Double Account System.

5. 02

Features of double account system.


Double entry system and double account system.
Advantages of Double Account System.
Disadvantages of double account system.
Accounts of Electricity companies.
Replacement of asset.
Assignments.

5. 03
5. 04
5. 05
5. 06
5. 07
5.08

98

DOUBLE ACCOUNT SYSTEM


5. 01

Meaning:
The Double Account System is a system of presenting annual financial statements originally adopted in

England by Public Utility Organisations such as Railways, Electricity, Water and gas undertaking etc. These
public utilities enjoy monopolistic rights in their business of rendering service to community. These undertakings
are formed under Special Acts of Parliament and function subject to the restrictions imposed on them by the
relevant Acts and are required to prepare and present their annual accounts in the forms prescribed.
Public utility concerns are required to invest huge amount in fixed assets. A large part of the capital is
raised from the public and hence the undertaking has a moral responsibility to give full information to the public
as to the sources from which the fixed capital was raised and how the amount was utilised in the acquisition of
fixed assets. This is done by splitting the balance sheet into two parts, viz, Receipts and Expenditure on Capital
Account (Capital account ) and General Balance sheet. It is on account of this doubling of Balance Sheet, the
system has come to be called Double Account System.
5. 02

Features:

The main features of double account system are as follows:


1.

The concerns which adopt this system of presenting their final accounts require a large amount of fixed
capital.

2.

This is a special form of final accounts in greater detail accompanied by a number of statistical statements.

3.

Another special feature of this system is that the Balance sheet is prepared and presented in two parts, i.e.,
Capital Account and General Balance Sheet. The Capital Account shows Capital receipts on the credit side
and capital expenditure on the debit side.

4.

Since public utility concerns are not expected to aim at profit, they do not prepare Profit and Loss Account.
Instead, they prepare a Revenue Account which takes the place of a profit and loss account. Similarly, the
Profit and Loss Appropriation Account is replaced by net Revenue A/C.

5.

Depreciation is not shown as a deduction from fixed assets. Thus fixed assets are shown at original cost
plus additions during the year and depreciation is provided by creating reserves or fund which is shown on
the liability side of the General Balance sheet.

6.

Loans and debentures are treated as capital and shown in the capital account.

7.

Interest on debentures and loans are shown in the Net Revenue Account as an appropriation of profit.

8.

Discount and premium on issue of shares and debentures are permanently retained as capital items.

5. 03 Double Entry System and Double Account System.


The method of recording transactions systematically in the formal books of account, by recognising the
double aspect of each transaction, is known as the double entry system. Double account system is merely a
method of presentation of annual accounts. But this does not mean that double account system is fundamentally
different from double entry system. In fact, even under double account system, transactions are recorded on the

99

basis of double entry and the trial balance is extracted to test whether the total debits of accounts in the ledger
are equal to the total credits. Up to the preparation of Trial balance there is no difference between the double
entry and double account systems. The difference arises only in the preparation of the Revenue Accounts and
Balance Sheet.
5. 04 Advantages of double account system.
The main advantages of double account system are as follows:
1. Public utility concerns which adopt the double account system enjoy monopolistic rights granted by the
State. The prescribed form of presentation of accounts enables the state to ensure that the concern
renders the most efficient service at reasonable cost.
2. Depreciation fund is compulsorily created and invested in securities. This helps in the replacement of
assets without affecting cash resources of the undertaking.
3. Double account system presents clear cut statement as to Capital raised and its utilisation in the
acquisition of permanent assets.
4. Capital account helps in comparing receipts and expenditure of fixed nature which is not possible in
the case of ordinary Balance sheet. The balance of capital account is useful for making future plans
of capital nature.
5. Revenue Account is concerned purely with the operating activities of the undertaking. All items
which are extraneous to the actual working of the concern are taken to the Net Revenue Account.
5. 05 Disadvantages of Double Account System.
The main disadvantages or criticisms against Double Account System are as follows:
1. All assets are shown in the capital account at cost and hence the balance sheet does not reveal the true
position.
2. When an asset is replaced, it is not always possible to calculate the amount to be charged to revenue.
3. Capital Account includes assets having very short life. Such assets appear in the account even after
they are reduced to scrap value.
4. The Revenue Account is not able to disclose a fair and true view of the trading results since it does not
include interest paid or received. As renewals are usually charged to revenue, profits of any year are
not always correctly stated.
5. It is difficult to make a proper distinction between capital and revenue.
6. The general public cannot easily understand the accounts and the accompanying statements.
5. 06

Accounts for Electricity Companies.

Legal provisions relating to Electricity companies.


The electricity supply being a public utility service, the business is controlled by the Government. Electricity
undertakings are governed by the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply ) Act, 1948. These
concerns prepare and present their annual accounts in accordance with the form laid down by Schedule VI of

100

the Companies Act. However, Rule 26 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956 makes the following provisions in
accordance with Sec. 11 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 for final accounts of Electricity (Supply) Companies.
(1) Every electricity company shall prepare its accounts to 31st March and shall render them to the State
Government within six months from such date.
(2) The accounts shall be made in the prescribed forms as set in Annexure V to the Indian Electricity
Rules, 1956.
Besides, the provisions regulating annual accounts, the following provisions should also be noted:
Depreciation.
Under the Amended Electricity (Supply) Act, 1978, which came into force from 1st April 1979, depreciation
can be charged only on the straight line method. The central Government has been empowered to prescribe, by
notification, the life of various assets. Further, no depreciation can be written off when an asset has been written
down to 10% of its original cost. Again, no depreciation is to be written off when asset goes out of use due to
obsolescene, inadequacy, superfluity or any other reason. Any debit balance remaining on such an asset account
is to be charged to Contingencies Reserve. In case of profit or loss on the discarded asset, the same should also
be charged to this account.
Reasonable Return.
The law seeks to prevent an electricity undertaking from earning exorbitant profit. For this purpose, the concept
of reasonable return has been introduced. The reasonable return comprises:
(a) an yield at the standard rate, which is the Reserve Bank Rate plus 2% on the Capital base;
(b) income from investment except investments made against Contingencies Reserve;
(c) an amount equal to 1/2% on loans advanced by the Electricity Board
(d) an amount equal to 1/2 % on the balance of Development Reserve and
(e) an amount equal to 1/2 % on Debentures.
Capital base means:
(a) the original cost of fixed assets available for use and necessary for the purpose of the undertaking less,
contribution, if any, made by consumers for construction of service lines;
(b) the cost of intangible assets;
(c) the original cost of work-in-progress;
(d) the amount of investments compulsorily made against Contingencies Reserve; and
(e) monthly average of current assets.
From the total of above items, deduct
(i) the amounts written off or set aside on account of depreciation of fixed assets and amounts written
off in respect of intangible assets;
(ii) loans advanced by the State Electricity Board;
(iii) debentures issued;
(iv) security deposits of consumers;
(v) amount to the credit of Tariff and Dividends Control Reserve,
(vi) amount set apart for Development Reserve; and

101

(vii) amount carried forward in the accounts of the license for distribution to consumers.
The resulting figure is the Capital base.
Clear Profits.
Clear Profits means the difference between the total income and the total expenditure plus specific
appropriations such as Development Reserve, Contingency Reserve, Reserve and appropriations permitted by
the concerned state governments etc. The calculation of Clear profits will be done in the following manner:

Statement of Clear Profit


Expenditure

Rs.

Income

Rs.

1. Cost of generation and purchase of energy

....

2. Cost of distribution and sale of energy

....

3. Rent rates and taxes.

....

2. Rental of meters, etc. lamps.

....

4. Interest on loans.

....

3. Sales and repair of lamps

....

5. Interest on Security deposits.

....

4. Rent.

....

6. Bad debts.

....

5. Transfer fees.

....

7. Audit fees.

....

6. Interest from investments fixed and

....

8. Management expenses.

....

9. Depreciation.

....

1. Receipts from sale of energy .


Less discount

all deposits and bank balances


7. Other taxable receipts.

....

.....
....

10. Other admissible expenses for


tax purposes

....

11. Contributions to P.F., Gratuity etc.

....

12. Bonus to employees.

....

Special appropriations:

....

1. Past losses.

....

2. Income Tax.

....

3. Amounts written off from intangibles

.....

4. Transfer to contingencies reserve

....

5. Arrears of depreciation.

....

6. Transfer to development reserve.

....

......
Balance b/d

....

7. Other special appropriations permitted


by the State Government

....

Balance being Clear Profit

....
.....

.......

102

Disposal of Surplus.
Surplus is the excess of Clear profit over reasonable return. If the clear profits exceed the reasonable
return, the surplus has to be disposed in the following manner:
(1) One-third of the surplus, not exceeding 5% of the reasonable return, will be at the disposal of the
undertaking;
(2) of the balance of excess, one-half will be transferred to Tariff and Dividends Control Reserve; and
(3) the balance will be distributed among consumers by way of reduction of rates or by way of specific
rebate.
Illustration. I
The following are the balances extracted from the books of Tata Electric Company Limited for the
year 31st December, 2002.
31-12-2001.
Rs.
50,000

Capital (3,000 shares of Rs.100 each, Rs.80. paid up-)

30,000

Land

20,000

Building

11,000

Plant and machinery

6,000

Dr.

Cr.

Rs.

Rs.
2,40,000.

1,00,000
60,000
1,11,000

Transformers

16,000

Debentures

1,50,000

Reserve Fund

17,000

Depreciation Fund

10,000

Premium on shares

7,000

Mains

80,000

Furniture

20,000

Coal and Fuel

19,000

Stores on Land

7,000

Wages

63,000

Preliminary expenses

5,000

Directors fees

6,000

Law charges

2,000

Sales of current

87,800

Rent of meters

50,000

Sundry creditors

22,000

Net Revenue Account

16,000

Sundry debtors

40,000

103

Cash at Bank

47,000

Dividend paid for 2001

5,000

Transfer fees

200

Interest on Debentures

19,000
6,00,000

6,00,000

Other informations:
Depreciation to be provided on opening balances on Building 10%, plant and machinery 5%, Transformers
8%, and Furniture 1%.
you are required to prepare:
a) Revenue Account, b) Net Revenue Account, c) Capital Account, and d) Balance sheet.
Solution:
Tata Electric Company Limited
REVENUE ACCOUNT for the year ended 31st DEC. 2002

Dr.

Rs.

Cr.
Rs.

To Coal and Fuel

19,000

By sales of current

87,800

To wages

63,000

By rent of meters

50,000

To Directors fee

6,000

By Transfer fees

200

To Law charges

2,000

ToDepreciation
Building @10%

6,000

Plant and Machinery @5%

5,550

Transformers @ 8%

1,280

Furniture @ 1%

200

To Balance carried to
Net Revenue Account

34,970
1,38,000

Dr.

1,38,000
Cr.

NET REVENUE ACCOUNT for the year ending 31st December, 2002
Rs.

To Interest on Debentures
To Dividend paid
To Balance carried to Balance sheet

Rs.

19,000

By Balance b/d

16,000

5,000

By Revenue A/c

34,970

26,970
50,970

50,970

104

Dr.

Cr.

TATA ELECTRIC COMPANY LIMITED


RECEIPTS AND EXPENDITURE ON CAPITAL ACCOUNT for the year ended 31st December,2002
Expenditure

Expenditure Expenditure
Upto 31st during the
Dec.2001
year
Rs.
Rs.

Total
Rs.

105

To Land

30,000

70,000

1,00,000

Building
Plant and Machinery

20,000

40,000

60,000

11,000

1,00,000

1,11,000

6,000

10,000

16,000

80,000

80,000

20,000

20,000

5,000

5,000

1,72,000

2,20,000

3,92,000

Transformers
Mains
Furniture
Preliminary expenses
Balance on Capital A/c

Receipts

By Capital
Debentures
Premium on shares

Receipts
Upto 31st
Dec.2001
Rs.
50,000
1,50,000

Receipts
during the
year
Rs.

Total
Rs

1,90,000 2,40,000
-

1,50,000

7,000

7,000

2,07,000

1,90,000

3,97,000

5000
1,72,000

2,20,000

3,97,000

GENERAL BALANCE SHEET


as on 31st DECEMBER 2002
Rs.
Receipts on Capital A/c

Rs.

3,97,000

Expenditure on Capital A/c

3,92,000

Reserve Fund

17,000

Stores in hand

7,000

Depreciation Fund

23,030

Sundry Debtors

40,000

Sundry creditors

22,000

Cash at Bank

47,000

Net Revenue A/c

26,970
4,86,000

4,86,000

Illustration - 2.
The following balances have been extracted from the books of Kanpur Electricity Company at the end
of 2001.
Rs.
Share Capital

10,00,000

Reserve fund ( invested in 41/2 %Government Securities at par )

5,00,000

Contingencies Reserve ( Invested in 5% state loan )

1,00,000

Loan from State Electricity Board

6,00,000

8% Debentures

2,00,000

Development reserve

1,00,000

Fixed assets

20,00,000

Depreciation Reserve on fixed assets

5,00,000

Consumers deposits

5,50,000

Amounts contributed by consumer for fixed assets

10,000

Intangible assets

50,000

Tariffs and dividends control reserve

50,000

Current assets ( Monthly average )

2,00,000

The Company earns a profit of Rs.70,000 (after tax ) in 2001. Show how the profit is to be dealt
with by the company, assuming the Reserve Bank Rate is 9 %.
Solution.

Kanpur Electricity Company Limited


STATEMENT SHOWING DISPOSAL OF PROFIT for the year ended 31-03-2001
CAPITAL BASE:
Fixed assets

20,00,000

Less: Depreciation reserve

5,00,000
15,00,000

106

Add:

Intangible assets

50,000

Current assets

2,00,000

Contingent reserve

1,00,000

Total

18,50,000

Less:
Loan from State Electricity Board

6,00,000

Debentures

2,00,000

Development Reserve

1,00,000

Consumers Deposits

5,50,000

Amounts contributed by consumers for


fixed assets

10,000
50,000

Tariff and dividend Control reserve

15,10,000
Capital Base

3,40,000

Reasonable Return:
a)

Yield at Standard rate


(9% Bank rate plus 2%) 11% on 3,40,000

b)

41/2% on Reserve fund investment


( 5,00,000 X 4.5% )

c)

22,500

1/2% on loan from Electricity Board


( 6,00,000 X 0.5% )

d)

3,000

1/2% on Development Reserve


(1,00,000 X .5% )

e)

37,400

500

1/2% on debentures
( 2,00,000 X 0.5% )

1,000

Reasonable return
Surplus earned

64,400

Clear Profit - reasonable return.

75,000 - 64,400

10,600

Disposal of Surplus:
a)

To be retained by the Company

Reasonable return + 1/3 of the surplus not


exceeding 5% of reasonable return

64,400 + 5% of 64,400

Rs.67,620.

107

b)

To be transferred to Tariffs
and Dividends Control Reserve

c)

One half of the balance

1/2 of (10,600 - 3,220 )

Rs. 3,690

The balance ie. Rs. 3690

To be distributed among
consumers by way of reduction
of rates or otherwise

5. 07 Replacement of an Asset.
The distinction between capital and revenue expenditure is important in the Double Account System,
when entries are made for replacement of an asset. In the Single Account System, the amount standing in the
book against an asset is written off when the asset is replaced by another and the cost of new asset is capitalised. But the treatment is different under Double Account System. In this system, the original cost of the old
asset to be replaced is not touched at all and continues to appear in the books even after its replacement. The
estimated cost of the replacement of old asset ( in the original form ) is calculated. Out of the estimated cost, the
sale proceeds of old materials or the value of materials re-used in reconstruction is deducted. The amount left
is charged to the Revenue Account. The difference between the total cost of the work and the estimated
replacement cost ( without reducing it by the amount of materials used or sold ) of the old asset is capitalised.
The accounting entry will be:
a)

For the amount spent on new works:


New works A/c Dr.

(With the amount to be capitalised)

Replacement A/c Dr.

( With the estimated cost of replacement )

To Bank A/c
b)

For the sale of Old materials


Bank A/c..

Dr

To replacement A/c
c)

For the value of old materials re-used in the construction.


New works A/c ...

Dr.

To Replacement A/c.
d)

The balance in the Replacement Account represents a charge to revenue.


Revenue A/c...

Dr.

To Replacement A/c

108

5. 08 Assignments.
1.

Discuss the special features of double account system.

2.

Distinguish between double entry system and double account system.

3.

What are the advantages of double account system ?

4.

Discuss the limitations of double account system.

5.

How is reasonable return computed under the Electricity (Supply ) Act, 1948 ?
Problem - 1
From the following Trial Balance of Moon Light Company and other information, prepare:
(1) Revenue a/c (ii) Net Revenue a/c (iii) Capital A/c and (iv) General Balance sheet.
TRIAL BALANCE as on 31st December, 2002.
Dr.

Cr.

Rs.

Rs.

Share Capital

1,20,000

Debentures

75,000

Depreciation fund

5,000

Freehold land

46,500

Buildings

25,000

Machinery

50,000

Mains

40,000

Transformers

10,000

Meters

7,500

Electrical Instruments

2,000

General stores

11,750

Office Furniture

1,250

Coal and Fuel etc.

9,500

Salaries

15,750

Wages

20,000

Office expenses

4,500

Sale by meters

43,750

Sales by contracts

25,000

Meter rent

1,500

109

Creditors

5,000

Debtors

15,000

Cash in hand

16,500
2,72,250

i.

2,72,250

Additions made during the year were:


Share capital

20,000

Buildings

5,000

Machinery

20,000

Mains

15,000

Transformers

5,000

Meters

5,000

Electrical Instruments

500

General Stores

3750

ii.

Provide interest on Debentures @6%

iii.

Provide depreciation on:


Building 21/2%, Machinery 71/2%, Mains 5%, Transformers 10%, and Meters 15% on opening
balances.

Books for further reference:


1.

ADVANCED ACCOUNTANCY

- R.L. GUPTA & M. RADHASWAMY


2.

ADVANCED ACCOUNTANCY.
Corporate Accounting ( Part 2 )
- M.A. ARULANANDAM
B.S. RAMAN

3.

ADVANCED ACCOUNTING - Volume II


- S.P. IYENGAR

110

Potrebbero piacerti anche