Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Botero, et al.
www.cerf-jcr.org
ABSTRACT
www.JCRonline.org
Botero, C., Anfuso, A., Williams, A.T., Zielinski, S., Silva, C.P., Cervantes, O., Silva, L., Cabrera, J.A. 2013. Reasons
for beach choice: European and Caribbean perspectives In: Conley, D.C., Masselink, G., Russell, P.E. and OHare, T.J.
(eds.), Proceedings 12th International Coastal Symposium (Plymouth, England), Journal of Coastal Research, Special
Issue No. 65, pp. 880-885, ISSN 0749-0208.
Beach users preferences range greatly according to their cultural and educational heritage, national and local traditions,
social status, sex, etc. Questionnaire surveys carried out on beach user preferences (50 beach aspects) in Wales, UK (n
= 2,345); Hollywood beach, Florida, USA (n = 83), the Costa Dorada, Spain (n =157); Malta (n = 154) and Turkeys
Aegean coast (n = 245) showed that five parameters were of the greatest importance on beach choice: safety, facilities,
water quality, litter and scenery. Such kind of detailed surveys has never been carried out in Caribbean countries.
Consequently, a great uncertainty exists regarding beach users preferences. During Easter 2012, a total of 435 beach
users along eight beaches of the Caribbean littoral of Colombia (Mayapo, Riohacha, Taganga, Rodadero, Puerto
Colombia, Salgar, Bocagrande and Manzanillo) were interviewed. Specifically, persons were asked (i) to choose from a
list of parameters, the three most important aspects to be taken into account in choosing a beach and (ii) the reason they
decided to visit that specific beach. Dealing with the former, results differed from ones recorded in Europe in that
scenery was deemed not to be important. Concerning the latter, great variety of responses was recorded but the main
aspect in beach selection was proximity for both local and national visitors. Aspects such as a relaxed friendly
atmosphere and party atmosphere were mentioned. In this sense, it is interesting to notice the particular perception
that Caribbean beach users showed for the relaxed friendly atmosphere. On many occasions beaches classified as
such, were very crowded and extremely noisy because of loud music and peddlers. Results obtained constitute a first
step in the knowledge of Caribbean beach users preferences and therefore is one, which is of a great importance for
beach management.
ADDITIONAL INDEX WORDS: Beach users preferences, environmental quality, beach management, ICZM,
Colombia, Proplayas.
INTRODUCTION
Coastal occupation has been increasing in the past few
decades especially due to coastal tourism-related activities.
Tourism is now one of the worlds largest industries (Jones and
Phillips, 2011): in 2006, global tourism was worth US$733
billion, employed 8% of the global workforce and estimates were
for 1.6 billion international tourists by 2020 (UNWTO, 2008). In
the Mediterranean region tourism is the most important activity
with 298 and 400 million international and domestic tourist
arrivals in 2008. Along the Caribbean, tourist arrivals have
increased five fold, from 166 million in 1970 to 935 million in
2010 and cruise arrivals grew even more rapidly over the same
period increasing from 1.3 in 1970 to 20 millions in 2010
(Caribbean Tourism Organization, 2011). Despite the fact that
____________________
DOI: 10.2112/SI65-149.1 received 07 December 2012; accepted 06
March 2013.
Coastal Education & Research Foundation 2013
881
METHODS
As part of a research program into the preferences of tourists
for choosing a beach destination, this work was carried out as an
exploratory investigation, according to Hurtados (2010), views
who, i.e. dividing research into ten categories from exploratory to
evaluative. In consequence, observation techniques used allowed
identification of the widest range of events. Instruments used to
obtain information were questionnaires, as previous information
was not found regarding beach users preferences in this study
area.
Coastal questionnaire surveys are generally of two types:
postal or via interviewing the beach users (Williams and Micallef,
2009). The latter methodology was chosen for fieldwork carried
out in this paper, because it is most common in scientific literature
related with beaches in Europe (Ergin et al., 2004; Morgan et al.,
2000; Pereira da Silva, 2004) and Latin America (Cervantes et al.,
2008; Espejel et al., 2007; Polette, 2009).
Questionnaire surveys were conducted at eight beaches in four
territorial departments on the north Caribbean coast of Colombia
(Figure 1). In total 435 beach users were interviewed during
Easter Week of 2012, and asked about general beach preferences
(which are three most important aspects for choosing a beach as a
destination?) and specific beach preference (why did you choose
this beach?). Although all beach users were asked for three
aspects in the first question, many of them only answered one or
two aspects and the total responses were 1223. Data obtained was
included in statistical software (IBM SPSS 18th Edition) and
processed to assess the relative priority levels of beach users
preferences. The questionnaire survey included also other
questions about coastal scenery not discussed in this paper.
The beach survey personnel applied as many surveys as
possible during a half day, covering in some cases all tourists on
the beach (e.g. Salgar, Manzanillo).
RESULTS
Beach user profile
The majority of studies concerning beach perceptions divide
users into two categories of origin: locals/residents and
foreign/visitors (Cervantes et al., 2008; Marin et al., 2009;
Rangel-Buitrago et al., 2012, Roca and Villares, 2008; Williams
and Micallef, 2009). However, foreign tourists in Colombian
beaches are few in comparison with nationals (Botero et al., 2012;
Daza, 2012), therefore users were divided into three categories:
locals (57.8%), nationals (35.8%) and foreign (5.0%). Local users
are people who live in the same city or municipality in which the
beach is placed and other Colombian users were classified as
nationals. This criterion allowed analysis of the importance of
national tourism in Colombian beaches and explains many results
obtained for proximity as a major reason for choosing a beach
In general, the gender of users was similar (female: 52.3%,
male: 45.4% and no answer: 2.3%), but the proportion of foreign
males were much higher than females The age of users was
882
Botero, et al.
Table 1. Top five general beach users preferences in rural and urban beaches (n=1,223)
RURAL
QUANTITY
URBAN
TOTAL
RURAL
113
154
267
22,29%
21,51%
21,83%
RELAXED-FRIENDLY
ATMOSPHERE
54
87
141
10,65%
12,15%
11,53%
FACILITIES
64
64
128
12,62%
8,94%
10,47%
34
73
107
6,71%
10,20%
8,75%
FAMILY-FRIENDLY
ATMOSPHERE
30
47
77
5,92%
6,56%
6,30%
TOTAL
295
425
720
58,19%
59,36%
58,87%
TOP 5
PERCENTAGE
URBAN
TOTAL
883
Table 2. Five most important general beach users preferences in eight Colombian beaches (In italic letters non-top 5 preferences)
DEPARTMENT
BEACH NAME
1st Preference
Guajira
Mayapo
Magdalena
Riohacha
Taganga
El Rodadero
Water and
Water and
Water and
Water and
sand quality sand quality sand quality sand quality
2nd Preference
Facilities
Party
atmosphere
Proximity
3rd Preference
Relaxedfriendly
atmosphere
Security and
safety
Relaxedfriendly
atmosphere
4th Preference
Security and
safety
5th Preference
Familyfriendly
atmosphere
Total Responses
Atlntico
148
Salgar
Facilities
Bolvar
Puerto
Colombia
Manzanillo
Bocagrande
Water and
sand quality
Relaxedfriendly
atmosphere
Water
activities
RelaxedSecurity and
friendly
Cheap prices Crowding
Facilities
safety
atmosphere
FamilyFamilyFamilyfriendly
Crowding
friendly
friendly
Proximity
atmosphere
atmosphere atmosphere
221
196
159
123
58
Facilities
Relaxedfriendly
atmosphere
Relaxedfriendly
atmosphere
Facilities
Security and
safety
Security and
safety
Scenery
Crowding
40
278
DISCUSION
884
Botero, et al.
CARIBBEAN
EUROPE
1st
st
2nd
GENERAL
Water and sand
21,83%
quality
Relaxed-friendly
11,53%
atmosphere
3rd
Facilities
4th
Security and
8,75%
safety
Family-friendly
6,30%
atmosphere
58,87%
5th
Total
10,47%
SPECIFIC
Proximity
Discover new
places
Interest in
destination
35,57%
9,01%
8,55%
7,16%
CONCLUSIONS
Beach users preferences in the Caribbean are similar to
Europe, but not enough to manage beaches on the same way. In
countries, such as, the United Kingdom or Malta aspects, such as,
safety and scenery are of the utmost importance, in Colombia
preferences are related mainly with the atmosphere on the beach.
Nevertheless, the presented results are merely exploratory and
more research is needed to obtain strong conclusions. In any case,
tourism on the Caribbean coast should be based on natural and
cultural realities of whole-year round destinations.
Proximity is the main reason to visit a beach on the north coast
of Colombia. This has been quoted by several authors in many
countries, and beach managers should include distance from the
beach to urban areas as a crucial factor in making decisions. If
results of this study are the pattern for the entire Caribbean, a rural
or urban classification could be less relevant than proximity to
populated areas from which visitors come.
68,82%
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This work is a result of the Joint Research Program
Environmental Quality of Tourist Beaches on the North
Caribbean Littoral of Colombia (University of Magdalena,
Technical University Comfenalco and University of La Guajira).
Furthermore, this work is a contribution to the Andalusia Research
Group RNM-328 and the Ibero-American Network of Beach
Management and Certification PROPLAYAS.
LITERATURE CITED
Botero, C., Zielinski, S., Pereira., C. and Escudero E.M., 2012. Informe
del programa de investigacin en calidad ambiental de playas tursticas
(CAPT) en el Caribe Norte Colombiano 2010 2014. Periodo ENE
DIC 2011. Santa Marta, Colombia: Universidad del Magdalena,
Informe Tcnico, Grupo de Investigacin en Sistemas Costeros, 60p.
Caribbean Tourism Organization, 2011. Caribbean tourism - State of the
industry, 2011 edition. St. Michael, Barbados: Caribbean Tourism
Organization, 19p.
Cervantes, O., Espejel, I., Arellano, E. and Delhumeau, S., 2008. Users
Perception as a Tool to Improve Urban Beach Planning and
Management. Environmental Management, 42(2), 249-264.
Daza, A., 2012. Propuesta de un instrumento de evaluacin para la playa
turstica de la zona urbana de Riohacha mediante el uso de variables
ambientales, socioculturales y de infraestructura. Santa Marta,
Colombia: University of Magdalena. Masters thesis, 152p.
Ergin, A., Karaesmen, E., Micallef, A. and Williams, A.T., 2004. A new
methodology for evaluating coastal scenery: fuzzy logic systems. Area,
36, 367-386.
Ergin, A., Williams, A.T. and Micallef, A., 2006. Coastal scenery:
appreciation and evaluation. Journal of Coastal Research, 22(4), 958964
Espejel, I.; Espinoza-Tenorio, A.; Cervantes, O.; Popoca, I.; Mejia, A. and
Delhumeau, S., 2007. Proposal for an integrated risk index for the
planning of recreational beaches: use at seven Mexican arid sites.
Proceedings of the 9th International Coastal Symposium, Journal of
Coastal Research, Special Issue, No.50. Gold Coast (Australia), ISSN
0749-0208, pp.47 51.
House, C. and Phillips, M.R., 2007. Islands of theory in a sea of practice:
Implementation theory and coastal management. In: Ozhan, E. (ed.),
Proceedings of 8th International Conference on the Mediterranean
Coastal Environment - MedCoast 07. Ankara (Turkey), pp. 105116.
Jones A. and Phillips M. (eds.), 2011. Disappearing destinations: Climate
change and future challenges for coastal tourism. Wallingford, Oxford:
CABI, 296p.
Lagos, M. and Dammert, L., 2012. La Seguridad Ciudadana - El problema
principal de Amrica Latina. Lima, Peru: Organizacin
Latinobarmetro, 61p.
Marin, V., Palmisani, F., Ivald, R., Dursi, R. and Fabiano, M., 2009.
Users perception analysis for sustainable beach management in Italy.
Ocean & Coastal Management, 52, 26827.
McKenna, J., MacLeod, M., Power, J. and Cooper, A., 2000. Rural Beach
Management: A Good Practice Guide, Lifford, Co. Donegal, Ireland:
Donegal County Council, 116p.
Micallef, A., Morgan, R. and Williams, A.T., 1999. User preferences and
priorities on Maltese beaches: Findings and potential importance for
tourism. In: Randazzo, G. (ed.), Coastal Environmental Management.
EUCC-Italy/EUCC (CD-ROM).
Morgan R., Jones T.C., and Williams A.T., 1993. Opinions and
perceptions of England and Wales Heritage Coast beach users: Some
885