How does it differ from conventional mass marketing? How does it differ from non-store retailing? What are the features that distinguish it clearly? Why should it be treated as a distinctive/special form of marketing?
Difference between DM & conventional marketing
Direct marketing (DM) is the process by which a firm approaches its customers on one-to-one basis & markets its products directly to them. In conventional marketing, a firm approaches the customers on a mass basis & sells to them in directly.
Conventional Marketing is Mass Marketing; DM is Demassified Marketing
DM is demassified marketing; it deals with customers on a one-toone basis. In conventional marketing, the marketer sells to a multitude of customers treating them as a mass; he uses mass production, mass communication & mass distribution devices. In DM, the marketer approaches the customers individually, communicates with them on a one-to-one basis & even offers products that are modified to suit the requirements of the chosen customers. DM relies on customized production, individual distribution & individual communication. The mass approach is missing here totally. While mass marketing targets the average customer of the chosen segment & develops its offer for the average customer, DM targets the individual customer & develops its offer for him. 1
MODULE 5 MARKETING APPLICATION
33.2 DIRECT MARKETING DM is interactive marketing; Conventional marketing is a one-way activity. For ex, while mass marketing has to remain content with oneway messages, DM enjoys the advantage of two-way communication, between the firm & its customers. Here, both sides are able to seek & obtain clarifications in an interactive way. DM doesnt involve marketing channels/stores; Conventional marketing relies heavily on it. The marketer secures the sale directly from the consumer & enables the latter to receive the product without having to visit a retail store. DM does not involve advertising/mass promotion; conventional marketing relies heavily on it. DM compresses the steps in the marketing process. DM tackles all the component tasks of marketing, such as customer identification/demand generation, product adaptation, packaging modification, distribution, price negotiation, marketing communication/sales promotion in an integrated & compressed method. Differences between DM & Non-Store retailing: Just because DM does not involve marketing channels, one should not assume that DM & nonstore retailing are synonymous with one another. DM is not just a method of retailing; it is a method of marketing. It will thus be incorrect to consider DM as synonymous with non-store retailing. DM is a larger process than n on-store retailing. Differences between DM & Non-Store retailing: Just because DM does not involve a store, it does not become synonymous with non-store retailing. DM is a marketing method; non-store retailing is a mere retailing method. DM is a larger process than non-store retailing. DM compresses various steps of the marketing process. 2
MODULE 5 MARKETING APPLICATION
33.3 ADVANTAGES OF DIRECT MARKETING Delivers near-perfect solutions to customers problems: As the marketer is able to contact the consumer individually, he can know exactly what the consumer wants & make it available to him. The recent developments in IT have helped the marketer to gather & process vast amounts of personal data on consumers. Helps achieve excellence in products & services: Several marketers are of the view that mass marketing rests on a culture wherein it is almost impossible to offer products of excellence. DM is a welcome way-out in this respect. Facilitates relations building: DM scores over mass marketing convincingly when it comes to building customer relations/retention. While mass marketers are separated from the customers by W/S, distributors & retailers, direct marketers maintain direct touch with the customers. They can know why consumers buy a particular brand. Cost-effective: DM is also more cost-effective. This is largely because it eliminates channel costs & advertising costs, the 2 dominant elements of costs in conventional marketing. In B2B marketing too, direct marketing methods such as direct mail, telemarketing & on-line/web marketing, work out more cost-effective; the traditional alternative of reaching them through the sales force is quite expensive. Versatile form of marketing: One can literally hand pick the target audience in a direct marketing program. The campaign can also be timed as per convenience, so as to reach the prospects at the right moment. Moreover, a direct marketing communication generally enjoys higher readership. Benefits the consumers too: DM enables consumers to shop at their
homes. It saves their time & introduces them to different
products/brands. Industrial consumers too benefit from DM; they are able to learn about available products without spending a great deal of their time with the salespersons of the firm. 3
MODULE 5 MARKETING APPLICATION
33.4 REQUISITES FOR SUCCESS OF DIRECT MARKETING Comprehensive, Reliable & Updated Databases: Lack of proper database is the primary reason for several direct marketing programs ending up as a junk mail program. Direct marketers can select the names of consumers from internal lists compiled & maintained by them or buy relevant mailing list from mailing-list suppliers. Careful & Close Targeting of Markets/Prospects: On practical considerations, some grouping of consumers may be okay but one should not regress back to mass marketing & satisfied with the so-called average consumer. The most dangerous word in direct marketing is average. This is still mass marketing a smaller mass, but mass still. Service Guarantee & Product Warranty: Consumers should feel free to return the product if it falls short of their expectations. For ex, all products of TSN, which is a leading direct marketer, are backed by a satisfaction-cum-money back guarantee. Consumers should also be given all relevant information about the product & easy-to-follow instructions regarding its usage so that they can obtain the full benefits of the product. Backroom Logistics: Once the responses start flowing in, there must be a mechanism for attending to them properly. Also, there should be a systematic follow-up. Reminder mailers should also go out promptly wherever necessary. Fast delivery of the product is the most vital part of backroom logistics. An Eye for Details: Care should be taken in designing the mailer. The outside envelop, the sales letter, the reply form & the reply envelope all must be developed carefully. Sustained Effort: To derive full benefit out of direct marketing, it must be adopted as an integral part of the marketing endeavor; direct marketing is not so effective when it is carried out as a one-shot effort.
MODULE 5 MARKETING APPLICATION
33.5 DIRECT MARKETING CATCHES UP IN INDIA Forms of Direct Marketing:
Mail Order Marketing/Catalogue Marketing
Direct Mail Marketing Direct Response Marketing/Database Marketing Telemarketing/Teleshopping (Home Shopping) Online Marketing/Marketing on the Web
Many firms are diverting a sizeable part of the ad-budget to DM. In
several product categories, DMs share of the promotion budget has been steadily increasing. Earlier, DM was being used mostly in industrial products & services. It is now slowly spreading to consumer softs & durables, though industrial products still account for a major part of all DM spend. Wipro, Modi Xerox, Welcome Group hotels, Philips India, ANZ Grindlays, Madura Coats & TVS-Suzuki are some of the organizations that have used DM to a significant extent. Several factors have contributed to the rise of DM. raising media costs, increasing fragmentation of media & their glowing clutter, have been making mass communication increasingly expensive. Companies are naturally tempted to try DM. The new competitive pressure in the market place is the 2 nd factor. The entry of many MNCs into India who are used to DM in their home markets, has been another contributor to the spread of DM. With product/brand clutter, market segmentation & targeting have become increasingly complex & difficult. The risk has also been increasing. Marketers are naturally attracted to DM, which helps work out & reach finely focused targets at a relatively low cost & low risk. The fact that product differentiation has been getting increasingly blurred has significantly contributed to the growth of DM. 5
MODULE 5 MARKETING APPLICATION
33.6 DIRECT MAIL MARKETING Direct Mail Marketing (DMM) is similar to Mail Order Marketing (MOM). Usually, when a trading house markets various products by mail order, we refer to it as MOM or MOB (mail Order Business). In direct mail marketing, not only letters/brochures are mailed to the prospects, but free product samples, gifts & compliments are also mailed, depending on the context. A few examples: HLL using DM for Denim Aftershave: HLL had relied on direct mail to a sizeable extent in marketing its aftershave brand, Denim. The target was the members of the elite clubs in the metros. Each prospect was mailed a 3-color brochure with a Scratch n Sniff coating as a sample. Order forms were included in the brochure. Campaigns by Datamatics Direct: Datamatics direct is one of the leading, independent direct marketing outfits in India. It relies heavily on direct mail. It targets the upper middle class/middle class consumers. In a given campaign, it concentrates on selling just 1 or 2 products. Datamatics campaign for ANZ bank: Datamatics Direct did a direct mail campaign for ANZs loan on equity shares. ANZs OD facility on equity shares comes as a branded product cashetts (cash against assets). Datamatics campaign for Lux soap: In another direct mail campaign, Datamatics focused on HLLs Lux. As per the arrangement it had worked out with HLL, Datamatics Direct made a special concessional offer to prospects buying Lux beauty shower & Lux beauty bar soaps. The direct mail communication stated that mail order received through the enclosed business reply card would receive prompt attention & the item on order would be delivered at the doorsteps of the customer & cash could be paid on delivery.
Contract Direct campaign for Hyatt Regency: Contract Direct did a
direct mail campaign for Hyatt regencys Oasis membership. Hyatt was collecting membership for its discotheque, Oasis. The campaign offered complementary membership to businessmen, professionals & members of other discos. It was a well-targeted DM exercise. It managed to garner a high conversion rate, a response rate of 41% 7 a final conversion rate of 35.3%. 6
MODULE 5 MARKETING APPLICATION
33.7 TELESHOPPING Teleshopping has been gaining ground in India in a steady manner. A variety of favorable factors have made it possible. 1st, the relevant technologies are available, 2nd, India is now more open to such marketing methods & 3rd, TV channels have multiplied & TV as a medium has matured in the country; telecom infrastructure too has grown. The Early entrants: Three TV channels grabbled the idea early & set apart a good slice of their telecast time for the new concept: DD, Zee & United Television (UTV). Similarly 4 TSNs entered the arena as pioneers: Dees Home shopping (Dees), Teleshopping Network (TSN), United Teleshopping (UTS) & Asian sky shop (ASS). UTS was a division of UTV; ASS a division of Zee; Dees & TSN were independent networks. Teleshopping will expand in India in the coming years. Two major engines are driving India into electronic shopping: Consumers redefinition of shopping convenience & technologys impact on consumer shopping behavior. Requisites of successful teleshopping: Teleshopping too needs to be targeted tightly in order to be effective. The products hawked & the consumers targeted must match closely. The networks must recognize that certain categories of products blend particularly well for teleshopping, like: household appliances, jewellery, toys, cosmetics, watches, office stationary, auto accessories, leather products & financial products. Selection of the right kind of people as the hosts & hostesses is also important. The hosts & hostesses can make/break a teleshopping program. It makes sense to select as hosts, persons who are not celebrities but are people whose personality goes well with the products they sell. When one uses a celebrity as a host, the focus shifts to the celebrity rather than the product aired. A pleasant, viewer-friendly person will do for most products. 7
(Handbooks in Economics 1) Kenneth J. Arrow, A.K. Sen, Kotaro Suzumura (Eds.) - Handbook of Social Choice and Welfare, Volume 1 (Handbooks in Economics) - North-Holland (2002) PDF