Sei sulla pagina 1di 9

Sales Bulletin

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Comparison - TL360Z Vs Competition


Prepared by: IMG Wheeled

TL360Z

COMPARISON WITH HM2021


Particulars

TL 360Z

HM2021

Engine HP

129HP @ 2400
RPM

115HP @ 2300
RPM

Higher engine power translates to higher


payload, speeds, and increases overall
productivity significantly

Maximum
Torque

44kgf(430Nm)
@ 1800 rpm

415 Nm @1500
rpm

Higher torque translates to better load carrying


capacity.

Engine
Displacement

5.675 Litres

6.494 Litres

Efficient operation by providing higher HP with


lower engine displacement. This reduces the
cost per tonne of production.

Transmission

ZF
4 WG 130

AVTEC
TT2221

Heavy duty power-shift transmission.


Shifting of gears does not involve clutch
operation as opposed to the manual
transmission of HM2021.

Operating
Weight

12,110 kg

11,960 kg

Higher Operating weight better stability

3600 kg

3000 kg

Payload

7.32 / 14.27 /
25.27

Reverse 7.71 / 15.03 / 26.4


Rear Axle
oscillation
Steering
System

Higher Payload capacity translates to higher


productivity
TL360Z has higher speeds, translating to
higher productivity.

Speeds
Forward

Remarks

28 degrees
60lpm separate
Vane pump

Stage1 : 3.2 / 12.3


Stage2 : 7.2 / 25.8
Stage1 : 4.5
Stage2 : 9.3
25 degree
No separate pump
for steering Priority valve

Bucket Capacity

Std 2.0cum

Std 1.7cum

Break-out force

11,600 kg

10,875 kg

Reach @ 45
degree

1380

1070

Automatic Kickdown function

Yes

No

Easy transition of speeds without the hassle of


stages.
TL360Z can move from 7to 25kmph with a flick
of gears.
Better Stability
Separate pump for steering and hydraulics
helps in achieving dual operations for of travel
and steering
Higher Bucket size due to higher payload
capacity.
Higher break-out forces translates to better
performance for digging into the stock-pile
Higher reach, means easier centre loading for
tippers and wagons. Higher productivity.
While carrying loading or biting in material the
machine automatically steps down from 2nd gear
to 1st gear for greater tractive effort.

COMPARISON WITH JCB 430Z Plus


Particulars

TL 360Z

JCB 430Z

Remarks

Engine

TATA 697 TCIC


129 HP @2400 rpm

Ashok Leyland H6ETIC3RU


133 HP @ 2200
RPM

Engine service is provided by THCM and


unlike in JCB where the engine service is
provided by Ashok Leyland.
Tata Engine, easy availability of parts and
maintenance.

Payload

3600 kg

3300 kg

Forward

7.32 / 14.27 / 25.27

4.9 / 8 / 19 / 25.9

Reverse

7.71 / 15.03 / 26.4

4.8 / 8 / 19.4

Higher Payload capacity translates to


higher productivity

Speeds

Steering System

60lpm separate
Vane pump

No separate pump
for steering - Priority
valve

Cycle Time (in sec)

10.3 sec

11.2 sec

Bucket
Capacity(Heaped)
in cum

Standard Bucket
2.0 cum

Standard Bucket
1.9 cum

TL360Z has higher speeds, translating to


higher productivity

Separate pump for steering and


hydraulics helps in achieving dual
operations for of travel and steering

Lower cycle time means higher productivity

Higher bucket capacity

Range of Buckets in
Highest bucket capacity is 3.0cum compared
1.5 / 1.8 / 2.0 / 3.0 / 3.3 1.5 / 1.7 / 1.9 / 2.3 / 2.5
cum
to 2.5cum of 430Z
Payload

3600 kg

3300 kg

Higher payload capacity, better productivity.

Operating Weight
(Kg)

12,110

11250 kg

Higher Operating weight means better


stability and load carrying capacity

PARKING BRAKE

SPRING APPLIED AIR


Mechanical type disc Higher life and better safety aspect
RELEASED

Cabin Access

2 Doors, Easy Access

1Door, Restricted
Access

Easier access and better safety

COMPARISON WITH JCB 432


Particulars

TL 360Z

JCB 432

Remarks

Engine

TATA
697 TCIC

Cummins
6BTA5.9150C

Operating Weight

12,110 kg

12,000 kg

Higher Operating weight better stability

Payload

3600 kg

3650 kg

Similar Payload Capacity with lower fuel


consumption.

Engine Power

129 HP

150 HP

Optimum balance between the power and payload,


culminating to efficient loader operation

Forward

7.32 / 14.27 /
25.27

6.7 / 12.2 / 23.2 /


37.5

Reverse

7.71 / 15.03 / 26.4

7 / 12.8 / 24.3

TATA Engine has wide spread service & parts


support network. Tata engine has lower
maintenance cost.

Speeds

Axles

Rear Axle oscillation

Steering System

Cabin Access

ZF MTL 3075
FIXED

TL360Z has higher speeds, translating to higher


productivity

ZF axles and transmission, works seamlessly to


Graziano PR 10
provide better tractive effort to aide in load and carry
Front / PR10 Rear
operations.

28 degrees

22 degree

Better Stability

60lpm separate
Vane pump

No separate
pump for steering
- Priority valve

Separate pump for steering and hydraulics helps in


achieving dual operations for of travel and steering

2 Doors, Easy
Access

1Door, Restricted
Easier access and better safety
Access

COMPARISON WITH L&T 9020


Particulars

TL 360Z

L&T 9020

Transmission

ZF - 4 WG
130

AVTEC-TT2221

Operating Weight

12,110 kg

11,500 kg

3600 kg

3500 kg

Payload

Speeds
7.32 / 14.27 /
25.27

Reverse

7.71 / 15.03 /
26.4

Steering System

Heavy duty power-shift transmission.


Shifting of gears for higher speeds is
progressive. No Need to

Higher Operating weight better stability

Higher Payload capacity translates to higher


productivity

TL360Z has higher speeds, translating to


higher productivity.

Forward

Rear Axle oscillation

Remarks

28 degrees

60lpm
separate
vane pump

Stage1 : 4.2 /
16.1
Stage2 : 8.7 / 26 Easy transition of speeds without the hassle
of stages.
TL360Z can move from 7to 25kmph with a
Stage1 : 5.7
Stage2 : 11.8 flick of gears.

24 degree

Better Stability

No separate
pump for
steering Priority valve

Separate pump for steering and hydraulics


helps in achieving dual operations for of
travel and steering
Higher break-out forces translates to better
performance for digging into the stock-pile

Break-out force

11,600 kg

11,200 kg

Automatic Kickdown function

Yes

No

While carrying loading or biting in material the


machine automatically steps down from 2nd
gear to 1st gear for greater tractive effort.

COMPARISON WITH SDLG 936 & 938

Particulars

TL 360Z

LG936L

LG938L

Engine Make
& model

Tata 697 TC
IC

Duetz
BF6M2012C

Duetz
BF6M2012C

Chinese Make engine, no local support.

Transmission

ZF - 4 WG
130

SDLG make
mechanical
transmission

ZF Chinese
Make

Heavy duty power-shift transmission.


Shifting of gears for higher speeds is
progressive. No Need to

12,110 kg

10,700 kg

3600 kg

3000 kg

Forward

7.32 / 14.27 /
25.27

Stage1 : 0-13
Stage2 : 0-38

7 / 12 / 27 / 35

Reverse

7.71 / 15.03 /
26.4

Stage1 : 4.5
Stage2 : 9.3

7 / 12 / 27

Operating
Weight

Payload

Remarks

Higher Operating weight better stability

Higher Payload capacity translates to


higher productivity

Speeds

Steering
System

Bucket Capacity
Reach @ 45
degree

Automatic Kickdown function

TL360Z has higher speeds, translating to


higher productivity

60lpm
separate vane
pump

No separate
pump for
steering Priority valve

No separate
pump for
steering Priority valve

Std 2.0cum

Std 1.8cum

Std 1.8 cum

1380mm

1050mm

1050mm

Higher reach, means easier centre loading


for tippers and wagons. Higher productivity.

Yes

While carrying loading or biting in material


the machine automatically steps down from
2nd gear to 1st gear for greater tractive
effort.

Yes

No

Separate pump for steering and


hydraulics helps in achieving dual
operations for of travel and steering

Higher Bucket size due to higher payload


capacity.

COMPARISON WITH LIUGONG CLG836


Particulars

TL 360Z

LG936L

Engine Make &


model

Tata 697 TC IC

Duetz Weichai
WP6G125E310

Chinese Make engine, no local support.

Transmission

ZF - 4 WG 130

Not Mentioned

Heavy duty power-shift transmission.


Shifting of gears for higher speeds is
progressive. No Need to

12,110 kg

10,300 kg

3600 kg

3000 kg

Operating Weight

Payload

Remarks

Higher Operating weight better stability

Higher Payload capacity translates to higher


productivity

Speeds

Forward

Reverse

Steering System

Max 35 kmph Loader


seldom travels in max
7.32 / 14.27 / 25.27
speed. First gear
speed not mentioned TL360Z has higher speeds, translating to
higher productivity
Max 14.5 kmph
Loader seldom travels
7.71 / 15.03 / 26.4
in max speed. First
gear speed not
mentioned

60lpm separate
vane pump

No separate pump
for steering - Priority
valve

Separate pump for steering and hydraulics


helps in achieving dual operations for of travel
and steering
Higher Bucket size due to higher payload
capacity.

Bucket Capacity

Std 2.0cum

Std 1.7cum

Break-out force

127KN

100KN

Significantly Higher break-out forces translates to


better performance for digging into the stock-pile

Automatic Kickdown function

Yes

No

While carrying loading or biting in material the


machine automatically steps down from 2nd gear
to 1st gear for greater tractive effort.

Ref: 1512007SB/IMG/Wheeled
Please contact IMG-Wheeled for any inputs/clarifications

-END OF REPORT-

Potrebbero piacerti anche