Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Pages: 23562366
I. BACKGROUND
Shortly after the Spring 2010 ASA meeting in Baltimore, I was notified that I would be awarded the 2010 Rossing Prize in Acoustics Education. Although I was delighted,
as well as extremely flattered, to be its recipient, I also was
puzzled. Our Society has many outstanding educators, and I
could not identify the unique things that I had done that warranted my selection. There is an aphorism that states No
pain, no gain, which is exemplified by the requirement that
recipients of the Rossing Prize give a lecture on education at
the meeting where they receive the Prize. Thus it was imperative that I identify the aspect of my career that caused me to
be selected. Self-deliberation did not lead to the answer, so I
decided to call a good friend to gain his insight. An exchange
of updates on our current status was followed by my explanation of the dilemma I was attempting to address. A 10-s
pause was followed by a twist of a political phase from the
1992 Presidential election. He replied Its your books! He
omitted the stupid part, probably out of consideration for
our friendship. Upon reflection, he should have added it.
While our conversation continued, Fig. 1 came to mind.
There the reader will find the covers of the textbooks I have
written. The first four are first and second editions of undergraduate textbooks in statics and dynamics,14 which are
core courses in the curriculum for many engineering disciplines. I began to write the first editions of these books when
I was an assistant professor at Purdue University. My coauthor was Dr. Joseph Genin, who shared with me the duty of
coordinating all course sections in these subjects as well as
a)
2356
0001-4966/2012/131(3)/2356/11/$30.00
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
2357
II. MOTIVATION
I cannot provide you with the drive and focus that will
be required to see your project to fruition. However, I can
provide several compelling reasons why you should embark
on a writing expedition that will preoccupy you for an
extended period. Before I tell you why you should write a
book, let me tell you why you should not. Financial reward
does come to a few who write successful lower-level undergraduate textbooks in subjects that have large enrollments.
For the rest of us, there are few activities that pay less per
hour than writing a textbook. This is especially so if one
adds the hours required to organize your efforts, to review,
revise, and rewrite several times, to monitor all aspects of
the production process, and to prepare a solutions manual.
There usually will be financial compensation in the form of
royalties, and it certainly is nice to receive that compensation
well after your project is finished. However, if the amount of
compensation is important, you probably would earn more
if, instead of writing a book, you clerked at a supermarket.
It might surprise you to learn that a reason to write a
textbook is that it will make you famous. Not with the universality of a political figure or a movie star, only to those
who you touch through your role in their education. I have
not found any professional activity that makes me feel as
good as meeting a person at a university or a professional
meeting or even in an airport who pauses to tell me how
much they enjoyed and benefited from one of my books.
Such rewards are greatly enhanced when the individual who
pays you such compliments has achieved a high level of success. This is not merely a stroking of ones ego, for it bears
on a key aspect of authorship of textbooks as part of our legacy. The research we do, if it is any good, will be a stepping
stone for further progress by others. Even if you are teaching
very large classes, the number of people you affect through
your teaching will be relatively small. But a good textbook
has a wide reach and great longevity, and it might even
2358
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
2359
specific topic. You might be having difficulty selecting alternative approaches or you might have some idea of the scope
but cannot decide on the specific content or you might have
tried many phrasings of a difficult passage without liking
any. In such cases, you need an interruption, such as that
afforded by a pet. Dogs and cats are very handy because you
can talk to them without people thinking you are crazy. For
my most recent book, I had a very large Alaskan Malamute
named Tundra (she is the subject of several examples and
homework problems therein) who was always ready for a
long walk, regardless of the time of day or weather. There
were many occasions when we embarked on an excursion at
2 AM, with her acting as my sounding board. I doubt that
her woos and wolf-like howls as she heard me talk about
some topic had much technical content, but they provided
the break that I needed to resume writing. Children also
work for this purpose, but they seem to object to waking up
in the middle of the night to go for a walk.
If you infer from the preceding that I work late at night,
you would be correct. Doing so fits my biological clock. All
of us have a time of the day or night at which we are most
creative and work at peak efficiency. That interval is precious and should be devoted to the greatest extent possible to
your book. As I grew older, it became increasingly difficult
for me to recover from any interruption; working late had
the extra benefit of minimizing interruptions. For the same
reason, I never allowed my E-mail program to check automatically for new messages; I never subscribed to Twitter or
Facebook or other interactive messaging services, and I
occasionally turned off all telephones if things were flowing
especially well.
Of course, we have other responsibilities that cannot be
avoided. I recommend that you not resume work on your
book if you know that something requiring your attention is
coming up soon. Doing so will help you sustain a positive
aspect in your interaction with others, and it will help you
write at a later time because your ideas will not be dissipated
by the interruption.
I suppose that every author has a personal approach for
attacking their project. I have realized that I did not proceed
linearly. Rather, the strategy I followed tended to maximize
my quantitative output at the early stages, perhaps as a way
of avoiding discouragement before I was fully committed to
the project. It appears that I established a specific sequence
by which I proceeded through the subject matter. First were
those topics for which I had class notes. (This tended to be a
small component because I usually only prepared notes if
the assigned text did not adequately cover a topic.) Then I
addressed the topics for which I had innovative ideas. I had
been contemplating these ideas for some time before deciding to begin the project, so describing them tended to be relatively straightforward. The next group of topics to be
attacked was those that I considered to have been inadequately presented in other texts. A corollary of having identified what I did not like is that I had made some decisions
about what should be presented. The last topics I addressed
were those with which I was the least familiar, concurrently
with those whose treatment is standard and common to
many texts. Progress through the unfamiliar topics was the
Jerry H. Ginsberg: On writing textbooks
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
2361
Completion of your manuscript is an occasion to celebrate, but your work is far from done. Your first, and most
important, task following completion is to attempt to edit it
as a single entity. Presumably, you reviewed your work as
you wrote, but now you must take an overview. One of the
issues to consider is whether your approach is consistent. Do
you see coverage gaps, topics that you failed to address suitably or that you needlessly included? Did you fail to follow
through when you wrote in an early chapter that something
would be covered later? Did you switch notation without explanation? This editorial review must also identify errors.
Typographical and minor mathematical errors are unavoidable, but it is possible that significant technical errors have
entered. This situation is most commonly encountered in the
solutions of examples, so it is advisable to solve each example once again, independently of your prior effort.
Regardless of how conscientious you are, you will fail
to identify all errors. Presumably, you have furnished some
or all of your work to others when you were writing. Now
students can assist you. Give a copy of your near-final draft
manuscript to your current and former students. Exhort them
to examine your work and give you corrections and critical
remarks, especially the negative ones. Set up an anonymous
drop, but reward any one who identifies themself. Some welcome an acknowledgement in the book. I tried a modest
monetary award for each error that was identified, but very
few accepted it.
If you have not already done so, completion of a near
final draft is the time to seek the help of your colleagues.
Offer it to any who are willing. Most will be too busy to give
your work more than a cursory review, but any one who is
actively involved in teaching your subject is likely to find it
very useful. They might not be comfortable in giving you
negative remarks, but you must do your best to assuage their
concerns, for this is your last chance to make alterations.
While you are finalizing your manuscript, it is time to
select a publisher. Most will require sample chapters. Give
them any that you believe will be most attractive to other
faculty. Some of the issues that might arise in your negotiations are royalty percentage rate, publication format (hardcover, softcover, electronic), creation of artwork or
compensation for having done it yourself, editorial and
proofreading assistance, overall design, indexing, promotion,
and number of complementary copies. There might be some
variability in royalty rates proffered by different companies.
Given that you are not likely to retire on the income from
your book, these differences are not extremely important. I
am ambivalent about advances against future royalties,
which are not always proffered in the negotiations. An
advance does have the attribute of financially obligating the
company to follow through on the project, but that commitment is always present because production entails considerable outlays on the part of the publisher. My negative
sentiment regarding an advance originates from my first
books, wherein the amount advanced was sufficiently large
that my first royalties were used to repay it. I missed not having a check as a reward for completing the project.
Jerry H. Ginsberg: On writing textbooks
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
formatting, header and footer styles, and sequential numbering styles need to be carefully considered. The designer or
publishing company will also send you a design for the
cover. This is another item that requires your critical input,
for a well designed cover will draw the attention of a prospective adopter. Do not fear altering or rejecting any element of the design. In all matters requiring your approval,
remember that you have used textbooks far more than the
people involved in producing your book.
At this stage, everything will become a blur. On any
day, you might receive some illustrations from the artist,
some typeset pages from the compositor, or some pages laid
out with figures. All will require your approval, accompanied with the request that you return the material quickly.
You will consider the date requested for return to be unreasonable because the material will arrive when you have an
urgent deadline on a research project or a major commitment
in teaching or your personal life. It is imperative that you not
rush reviewing and correcting the material you receive. This
is your last chance to make sure that it is the best product
possible, and you can be sure it will not be if you rush your
participation in the production.
Concurrently with monitoring production, there are
major tasks that you will need to carry out. You will need to
prepare a list of some or all of the answers to the homework
exercises. Traditionally this list has been inserted into the
back of a textbook, but lately there has been some movement
toward providing it via the Internet. You also will be
expected to provide a solutions manual. Some individuals
use computer software for this purpose, which requires considerable effort. I have always created such material by scanning handwritten pages, but that requires extra effort to
prepare the material in a presentable manner. In addition, the
book cannot be printed until you submit the index. All these
chores are very important. Above all, make sure that every
aspect of the final product is correct and of the best possible
quality, regardless of how long it takes.
VI. YOUR PROFESSIONAL LIFE
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
2363
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms
2365
J. H. Ginsberg and J. Genin, Statics, 1st ed. (Wiley, New York, 1977).
J. H. Ginsberg and J. Genin, Dynamics, 1st ed. (Wiley, New York,
1977).
3
J. H. Ginsberg and J. Genin, Statics, 2nd ed. (Wiley, New York, 1983).
4
J. H. Ginsberg and J. Genin, Dynamics, 2nd ed. (Wiley, New York, 1983).
5
A. D. Pierce, Acoustics: An Introduction to Its Physical Principles and
Applications (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1981), p. 2.
6
J. H. Ginsberg, Advanced Engineering Dynamics, 1st ed. (Harper and
Row, New York, 1986).
7
J. H. Ginsberg, Advanced Engineering Dynamics, 2nd ed. (Cambridge
University Press, New York, 1995).
8
J. H. Ginsberg, Engineering Dynamics (Cambridge University Press, New
York, 2008).
2
2366
Downloaded 29 Aug 2013 to 129.162.1.37. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/terms