BY AUTHORITY

1
2

ORDINANCE NO. _____

COUNCIL BILL NO. 16-0626

SERIES OF 2016

COMMITTEE OF REFERENCE:
Safety, Housing, Education and
Homelessness

4
5
6
A BILL

7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15

For an ordinance amending Chapter 27 of the Denver Revised Municipal Code

concerning housing, establishing permanent funds to support city affordable housing
programs, adopting an affordable housing linkage fee applicable to new construction to
be effective October 1, 2017, and dedicating a portion of the citys existing property tax
revenue capacity to the funding of affordable housing programs beginning with 2017
property taxes to be collected in 2018.

16

WHEREAS, the Colorado Supreme Court has recognized that both the State of Colorado

17

and municipal governments have a significant interest in maintaining the quality and quantity of

18

affordable housing throughout the state; and

19

WHEREAS, the City and County of Denver has partnered with both the state and the

20

federal government since at least the Great Depression to improve the quality and quantity of

21

affordable housing for persons of low and moderate income, including the provision of transitional

22

housing for persons experiencing homelessness, through a wide range of housing assistance

23

programs and policies; and

24

WHEREAS, Colorado statutes require all counties and municipalities to include within their

25

comprehensive plans provisions which will promote affordable housing, and Denver has done so

26

by including within its Comprehensive Plan 2000 numerous goals and policies designed to expand

27

housing options for Denvers changing populations; and

28

WHEREAS, along with the federal and state governments, Denver has long maintained tax

29

and spending policies that help residents at the lowest income levels to afford and retain their

30

homes, including the citys property tax refunds for low-income seniors and disabled persons,

31

originally adopted in 1974; and

32

WHEREAS, Denver is currently experiencing a virtually unprecedented level of population

33

growth and a market environment in which the supply of housing within the city has not kept pace

34

with demand, particularly for households with low and moderate incomes; and

35
36

WHEREAS, Denver is also experiencing redevelopment trends in which formerly affordable

housing units and the residents who occupied such units are increasingly being displaced by the
1

1
2
3
4

construction of more expensive units, both in the for-sale and rental markets; and
WHEREAS, as a result of the foregoing trends, housing prices in Denver have been
increasing in recent years at twice the national average; and
WHEREAS, the federal sources of funds upon which Denver has traditionally relied to

support the citys affordable housing programs have declined by a third in recent years and are

expected to decline even further in the future; and

WHEREAS, the city estimates that up to 4,500 dwelling units currently located in the city

could lose affordability protections in the next 5 years, such as rental units that currently accept

federal Section 8 vouchers but will not do so in the future; and

10

WHEREAS, the city estimates that, among households in Denver earning 80% or less of

11

the area median income for the Denver metropolitan area, as many as 87,000 such households

12

are housing cost burdened in the sense of being required to pay in excess of 30% of their

13

monthly income for housing and utility costs; and

14

WHEREAS, the general lack of affordable housing for households of low and moderate

15

income, along with the large number of existing households that are housing cost burdened

16

cause many adverse social and economic impacts within the city, particularly impacts associated

17

with the fact that persons who are employed in Denver are increasingly unable to afford to live in

18

Denver near their place of employment; and

19

WHEREAS, the City and County of Denver, like cities throughout Colorado and the United

20

States, has long treated the promotion and provision of affordable housing for persons of low and

21

moderate incomes as an important and essential public service, and as a part of the citys

22

fundamental mission to promote the public health, safety and general welfare; and

23

WHEREAS, particularly in light of the ongoing decline in federal resources to fund

24

affordable housing programs, as well as the recent population and market trends described in

25

these recitals, the City Council deems it essential for the city to now adopt new forms of dedicated

26

revenue to support the citys affordable housing programs; and

27

WHEREAS, for the reasons set forth in Section 20-151 of this ordinance, the City Council

28

has determined that there is a direct nexus between new construction in the city, generation of

29

new employment, and increased demand for housing affordable to low and moderate income

30

households, justifying a linkage fee on new construction to support the citys affordable housing

31

programs; and

32

WHEREAS, Colorado state statutes, particularly 29-20-104 (1)(g), enable all municipalities

33

and counties to regulate the use of land on the basis of the impact thereof on the community, and

34

Denver is further empowered under its own plenary home rule authority to assess a linkage fee to
2

mitigate the impacts of new construction on the supply of affordable housing within the city; and

WHEREAS, referred measure 2A approved by Denver voters in 2012 granted the city the

authority to exceed the annual property tax revenue limitations set forth in Article X, Section 20

(7)(c) of the Colorado Constitution (TABOR), and to determine on a year-to-year basis how to

allocate the extra revenue for essential city services; and

WHEREAS, the Mayor and the City Council have determined to allocate, beginning for

2017 property taxes to be collected in 2018 and continuing in future years, a portion of the citys

lawful property tax revenue capacity for affordable housing programs in accordance with the

provisions of this ordinance; and

10

WHEREAS, the Mayor and the City Council expressly intend that a portion of dedicated tax

11

revenue for affordable housing shall be devoted to developing more permanent assistive housing

12

for residents of the city who are currently homeless and in the most desperate need of support and

13

assistance from the city.

14
15
16

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ENACTED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY AND COUNTY

OF DENVER:

17
18
19

Section 1. That Chapter 27 of the Denver Revised Municipal Code shall be amended by
the addition of a new Article V, to read as follows:

20
21

ARTICLE V. DEDICATED FUNDING FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING

22

Division 1. Affordable housing permanent funds

23

Sec. 27-150. Sources and uses of fund revenue

24

(a) Dedicated revenues. The affordable housing permanent funds shall

25

consist of the Affordable Housing Linkage Fee Revenue Fund created for the

26

exclusive purpose of receiving and accounting for all revenues derived from the

27

affordable housing linkage fees provided in Division 2 of this Article V; and the

28

Affordable Housing Property Tax Revenue Fund created for the purpose of receiving

29

and accounting for revenues derived from the portion of the citys property taxes

30

dedicated for affordable housing programs, as provided in section 20-26.

3

(b) Permitted uses of revenue in the Affordable Housing Linkage Fee

Revenue Fund. Revenue received in the Affordable Housing Linkage Fee Revenue

Fund shall be used exclusively for the following purposes:

(1) To increase the supply of affordable rental housing, including the funding

of renter assistance programs, for qualified households earning eighty percent

(80%) or less of AMI, in response to increased housing demand linked to new

construction and new employment.

(2) To increase the supply of for-sale housing for qualified households earning

one hundred percent (100%) or less of AMI, in response to increased housing

10

demand linked to new construction and new employment.

11

(3) To support homebuyer assistance programs, including by way of example

12

down payment and mortgage assistance programs, for qualified households

13

earning one-hundred and twenty percent (120%) or less of AMI, in response

14

to increased housing demand linked to new construction and new

15

employment.

16

(c) Permitted uses of revenue in the Affordable Housing Property Tax

17

Revenue Fund. Revenue received in the Affordable Housing Property Tax Revenue

18

Fund shall be used exclusively for the following purposes:

19

(1)

For the production or preservation of rental housing, including

20

the funding of rental assistance programs, for qualified households

21

earning eighty percent (80%) or less of AMI.

22
23

(2)

For the production or preservation of for-sale housing for

24

qualified households earning one hundred percent (100%) or less of

25

AMI.

26
27

(3)

For homebuyer assistance programs, including by way of

28

example down payment and mortgage assistance programs, for

29

qualified households earning one-hundred and twenty percent (120%)

30

or less of AMI.

31
4

(4) For the development of permanent supportive housing for

homeless persons, and for supportive services associated with such

housing; provided, however, in no event shall the amount expended

from the Affordable Housing Property Tax Revenue Fund for

supportive services under this paragraph (4) exceed ten percent (10%)

of the amount of revenue received in the fund for that year.

7
8

(5) For programs supporting low-income at-risk individuals in danger

of losing their existing homes, for mitigation of the effects of

10

gentrification and involuntary displacement of lower income

11

households in those neighborhoods of the city that are most heavily

12

impacted by rapidly escalating housing costs, for homeowner

13

emergency repairs, or for other housing programs.

14
15

(d)

Cap on administrative costs. Monies in the affordable housing

16

permanent funds may be expended to pay the costs incurred by the city

17

associated directly with the administration of the funds; provided, however, in

18

no event shall the amount expended from the funds for such administrative

19

expenses in any year exceed eight percent (8%) of the amount of revenue

20

received in both funds in that year.

21
22
23

(e)

Fund earnings. Any interest earning on any balance in either of

the affordable housing permanent funds shall accrue to that fund.

24
25

(f)

Administration of funds. The affordable housing permanent funds shall

26

be administered by the executive director of the office of economic development, in

27

coordination with the recommendations and assistance of the affordable housing

28

advisory committee as provided in Part C of this Article VII. The executive director

29

may promulgate rules and regulations consistent with this Article V governing the

30

procedures and requirements for expenditures from the funds. Expenditures from

31

the funds shall be made in accordance with the adopted 3-5 year strategic plan for

32

the funds, as provided in Sec. 27-164(a) and the comprehensive affordable housing

33

plan as provided in Sec. 27-164 (e).

5

1
2

(g)

Definition of AMI. As used in this section, the term AMI means the area

median income, adjusted for household size, for the Denver metropolitan area as

determined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

5
6

(h)

Review of article. No later than December 31, 2021, the office of

economic development shall conduct a policy review of this Article V, hold a

public hearing to gather input for the review, and report the findings and any

recommendations to the city council.

10
11
12
13

Division 2. Linkage fees

Sec. 27-151. Legislative findings and intent.

14

The city council has determined that Denver is experiencing an

15

unprecedented escalation in housing costs, and thus a critical lack of housing

16

opportunities for households with low or moderate incomes. In recent years, Denver

17

has ranked at or near the top of national reports of U.S. cities in terms of inflation in

18

housing costs. The declining availability of low and moderately priced housing in

19

Denver forces persons employed in the city to either spend a disproportionate

20

percentage of their disposable income on housing, thus sacrificing other necessities

21

of life, or forces them to seek housing opportunities outside the city. The

22

extraordinary housing cost increases in Denver are driven, in part, by the pace of

23

population and job growth in the city, resulting in a situation where demand for

24

housing has far outpaced supply, especially for persons who may find jobs in

25

Denvers growing economy but are employed at low or moderate income levels.

26

The city council has determined that it is in the public interest to address the

27

severe social and economic impacts to the city and its citizens caused by the

28

increasing gap between supply and demand for housing by funding programs

29

designed to preserve and increase the supply of affordable housing available to low

30

and moderate income households. The city council specifically finds that it is

appropriate to fund a portion of the costs of such programs from a linkage fee on

new development for the following reasons:

(a)

with the generation of new jobs at various income levels, with the number of jobs

associated with any particular development being correlated with the type and size of

the development.

(b)

consequence of new non-residential development, employees receiving such

incomes will experience a lack of housing availability and affordability in Denver

10

under current market conditions unless efforts are taken by the city to increase

11

housing opportunities to keep pace with job growth.

12

(c)

13

residential development is directly related to the income and spending capacity of the

14

household occupying the residence and that the size of the residence, as measured

15

in gross square footage, correlates with the income and spending capacity of the

16

residents, thus causing a larger residence to drive more job growth and more

17

concomitant secondary housing demand than a smaller residence.

18

(d)

19

nexus between both non-residential and residential development, job growth, and

20

demand for new housing that is affordable to households with low or moderate

21

incomes.

22

(e)

23

cannot exceed an amount that is justified by the impacts caused by the

24

development. The city council has determined that the fees set forth herein fall far

25

below the amount of revenue that would actually be necessary to meet the demand

26

for new affordable housing driven by the job growth that is associated with new

27

development, and thus these fees do not exceed the applicable standards that

28

define the maximum legally justifiable fee.

29

(f)

30

provided herein must be used, not to address the existing gap between supply and

31

demand for affordable housing in the city, but instead to mitigate future increases in

New residential and non-residential development is demonstrably associated

When jobs at a low or moderate income level are generated as a direct

The city council also specifically finds that job growth associated with new

For the foregoing reasons, the city council has determined there is a direct

The city council acknowledges that monetary exactions on new development

The city council further acknowledges that the revenue derived from the fees

the gap caused by new construction which will lead to new employment opportunities

in the city, and the increased demand for affordable housing associated with such

employment.

(g)

forth herein at a level much lower than those imposed by other cities, in an effort to

ensure that the fees do not impair the feasibility of any development project in the

city.

(h)

Nexus Study prepared for the City and County of Denver by David Paul Rosen &

The city council has determined to set the affordable housing linkage fees set

The foregoing findings are supported by the Denver Affordable Housing

10

Associates and dated September 8, 2016, the contents of which are expressly

11

incorporated herein as a part of the legislative findings of the city council.

12

(i)

13

impose nearly the range or amount of development impact fees as are imposed by

14

virtually every other municipality throughout the Denver metropolitan area, the fees

15

set forth herein will not place the city at a competitive disadvantage in relation to

16

neighboring jurisdictions in terms of accommodating future population growth and

17

economic development.

The city council has further determined that, since the Denver does not

18
19

Sec. 27-152. Definitions.

The following words and phrases, as used in this Division 2, have the

20
21
22

following meanings:
a.

Dwelling, single unit; dwelling, two-unit; and dwelling, multi-unit shall have the

23

same meaning as these terms are used in Article XI of the Denver Zoning

24

Code.

25

b.

Gross floor area shall have the same meaning as the term is defined in Article

26

XIII of the Denver Zoning Code, excluding garages and any other structures or

27

areas used for the storage or parking of vehicles.

28
29

c.

Primary agricultural uses shall have the same meaning as the term is used in
Article XI of the Denver Zoning Code.
8

d.

the term is used in Article XI of the Denver Zoning Code.

2
3

e.

f.

Primary industrial, manufacturing and wholesale uses shall have the same
meaning as the term is used in Article XI of the Denver Zoning Code.

6
7

Primary commercial sales, services and repair uses shall have the same
meaning as the term is used in Article XI of the Denver Zoning Code.

4
5

Primary civic, public and institutional uses shall have the same meaning as

g.

Primary residential use shall have the same meaning as the term is defined in

Article XI of the Denver Zoning Code, and shall be deemed to include any and

all primary residential uses and all uses accessory to a primary residential

10

uses, except accessory dwelling units, as set forth in Article XI of the Denver

11

Zoning Code

12

h.

Structure shall have the same meaning as the term is defined in Article XIII of

13

the Denver Zoning Code, but shall not include any partially enclosed or open

14

structures such as porches, balconies, courtyards, and similar structures.

15
16
17

Sec. 27-153. Imposition of linkage fee.

(a)

In general. Effective October 1, 2017, and except as provided in

18

section 27-154, an affordable housing linkage fee shall be imposed prior to the

19

issuance of a building permit for any new structure or for any addition to an existing

20

structure that increases the gross floor area of the existing structure, according to the

21

following fee schedule:

22

(1)

Structures containing any single-unit dwelling, any two-unit

23

dwellings, any multi-unit dwellings designed and regulated under the

24

International Residential Code, or any primary residential use other

25

than the multi-unit dwellings provided in paragraph (2): $.60 per

26

square-foot of gross floor area.

27

(2)

28

regulated under the International Building Code: $1.50 per square-foot

29

of gross floor area.

Structures containing multi-unit dwellings designed and

(3)

wholesale uses, or any primary agricultural uses: $.40 per square-foot

of gross floor area.

(4)

and repair uses, or any primary civic, public, or institutional uses: $1.70

per square-foot of gross floor area.

(b)

Structures containing any primary industrial, manufacturing and

Structures containing any primary commercial sales, services

Mixed use structures; split properties. When a structure is

proposed to be constructed and used for any combination of the uses set forth

in subsection (a) of this section, the required linkage fee shall be determined

10

based upon an apportionment of the gross floor area in the structure

11

attributable to each of the proposed uses. When a structure is proposed to be

12

constructed upon any property that is partially subject to either of the

13

exceptions to applicability of the fee as set forth in section 27-154 (a) or (b), the

14

required linkage fee shall be applied only to the gross floor area of construction

15

that is physically located outside of the portion of the property to which the

16

exception applies.

17

(c)

Modification of existing structures. The linkage fees imposed by

18

this section shall not be required for the issuance of building permits associated

19

with any improvement, repair, remodeling, tenant finish, or any other

20

modifications to an existing structure unless the modification increases the

21

gross floor area of the structure

22

(d)

Annual Inflation adjustment; future fee increases.

23

(1)

On July 1, 2018 and on each July 1 thereafter, the fees set forth

24

in subsection (a) of this section shall be adjusted in an amount

25

equal to the percentage change from the previous year in the CPI-

26

U. The adjustments will be reflected in a fee schedule issued by the

27

executive director (manager) of the department of community

28

planning and development and made publicly available in advance

29

of the fees becoming effective. The annual inflation adjustment

30

shall apply to and be collected in conjunction with the issuance of

31

any building permit on or after July of the year in which the

10

adjustment is made, regardless of when the application for the

building permit was made.

(2)

As used in this subsection (d), the term CPI-U means the

United States Department of Labor Statistics (Bureau of Labor

Statistics) Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, All

items, for the Denver-Boulder-Greeley, Colorado metropolitan area

(1982-84-100). In the event that the CPI-U is substantially changed,

re-named, or abandoned by the United States Government, then in

its place shall be substituted the index established by the United

States Government that most closely resembles the CPI-U.

10
11

(3)

Except as provided in paragraph (1) of this section the fees set

12

forth in this section shall not be increased prior to January 1, 2022.

13

On and after January 1, 2022, the fees set forth in this section shall

14

not be increased in excess of the inflation adjustments set forth in

15

paragraph (2) unless and until the city commissions another study

16

to evaluate whether the fee increase will affect the economic

17

feasibility of any type of development to which the fee increase is

18

proposed to be applied.

19
20
21
22
23

Sec. 27-154. Exceptions.

The payment of linkage fees as set forth in section 27-53 shall not be required
for the issuance of a building permit under any of the following circumstances:
(a) Construction upon any property which is, alone or in combination with

24

other properties, the subject of a preexisting contractual commitment or covenant

25

enforceable by the city to construct affordable housing, including by way of example

26

any development or subdivision agreement which includes an affordable housing

27

covenant and to which the city is a party, or any city-approved plan to build

28

moderately priced development units (MPDUs) under Article IV of this Chapter 27.

29

The exception provided by this subsection (a) shall apply only for so long the

30

preexisting contractual commitment or covenant to construct affordable housing

31

remains in existence. Construction upon property that, alone or in combination with

11

other properties, was originally developed under such a contractual commitment or

covenant and is subsequently proposed for redevelopment shall be subject to

payment of linkage fees hereunder unless the redevelopment is governed by a new

contractual commitment or covenant to construct affordable housing, or otherwise

qualifies for an exception under any other provision of this section.

6
7
8
9

(b) Construction upon any property subject to a preexisting obligation as a

condition of zoning to provide affordable housing on the property.
(c) Affordable housing projects that are constructed with the support of any
combination of federal, state or local financial resources, including private activity

10

bonds, tax credits, grants, loans, or other subsidies to incentivize the development of

11

affordable housing, including support from the affordable housing permanent funds

12

created in section 27-150, and that are restricted by law, contract, deed, covenant, or

13

any other legally enforceable instrument to provide housing units only to income-

14

qualified households. This exception shall apply to any housing project financed or

15

constructed by or on behalf of the Denver Housing Authority.

16

(d) Residential dwelling units that are built by any charitable, religious, or

17

other non-profit entity and deed-restricted to ensure the affordability of the dwelling

18

unit to low and moderate income households.

19

(e) Non-residential projects that are built by any charitable, religious or other

20

non-profit entity and that are primarily used to provide, shelter, housing, housing

21

assistance, or related services to low income households or persons experiencing

22

homelessness.

23

(f) Construction by or on behalf of the federal, state or local governments or

24

any department or agency thereof, to the extent any or all of the gross floor area in

25

the structure will be used solely for a governmental or educational purpose.

26

(g) Any structure that is being reconstructed due to involuntary demolition or

27

involuntary destruction as defined in Article XIII of the Denver Zoning Code, but

28

which also includes involuntary man-made forces.

29
30

(h) An addition of four-hundred (400) gross square feet or less to an existing

structure containing a single-unit dwelling or a two-unit dwelling.
12

(i) Accessory dwelling units as defined in Article XI of the Denver Zoning

1
2

Code.

3
4
5

Sec. 27-155. Build alternative.

(a) As an alternative to the linkage fee requirement set forth in section 27-

153, an applicant for a building permit for any structure subject to the requirements

of this Division 2 may elect to build or cause to be built affordable housing units on

the subject property or within a one-quarter mile radius of the subject property, with

the required number of affordable housing units to be determined by the following

10

formulas:

11

(1)

12

(Gross square feet of structure / 1000) X .0168 = number of units

13

Structures containing multi-unit dwellings:

(2)

Structures containing any primary industrial, manufacturing and

14

wholesale uses or primary agricultural uses:

15

(Gross square feet of structure / 1000) X .0054 = number of units

16

(3)

Structures containing any primary commercial sales, services and

17

repair uses or any primary civic, public and institutional uses:

18

(Gross square feet of structure / 1000) X .0228 = number of units

19

(4)

Developments consisting of 50 or more single-unit dwellings or two-unit

20

dwellings: number of affordable housing units shall equal two percent

21

(2%) of the total number of housing units in the development.

22

In the event the application of the formulas set forth in this subsection to a particular

23

project creates an obligation to build a fractional housing unit, any fraction of .5 or

24

greater shall be converted into an additional unit.

25
26

(b)

Any housing units to be provided under the build alternative shall be

restricted to households earning 80% or less of AMI, as defined in section 27-150.

13

(c)

An applicant who chooses to comply with the requirements of this

Division 2 through the construction of affordable housing units shall submit to the

executive director of the office of economic development sufficient information to

enable the director to determine that the applicant will construct or cause to be

constructed the affordable housing units, and enter into a binding agreement with the

city to covenant-restrict such units in order to ensure their affordability, to stipulate

when the affordable housing units will be built, and to include any other terms of

conditions as may be imposed by the executive director to enforce the requirements

of this section. The executive director may require in any such agreement forms of

10

financial security to ensure that the units are built. If the executive director approves

11

a build alternative under this section and an agreement is executed and recorded,

12

the director shall deliver to the department of community and planning and

13

development written notice of such approval and a copy of the agreement. Only

14

after the agreement is executed and recorded may any building permits be issued for

15

a project for which the applicant has elected to use the build alternative as provided

16

in this section.

17
18
19

Sec. 27-156. Collection and remittance of linkage fees.

(a)

The responsibility for the calculation and collection of linkage fees shall

20

reside with personnel in the department of community planning and development,

21

and the fees required by this division shall be collected in conjunction with the

22

administration of the citys system for issuing building permits. Any and all linkage

23

fees applicable to a construction project shall be paid in full prior to the issuance of

24

any building permit, excluding the shoring or excavation permit, for that project. For

25

projects such as townhomes where units receive separate building permits, fees

26

shall be assessed on a permit-by-permit basis. All fees collected by the department

27

shall be remitted to the Affordable Housing Linkage Fee Revenue Fund as provided

28

in section 27-150 and used exclusively for the purposes set forth therein.

29

(b)

If, after the issuance of a building permit and collection of the

30

applicable linkage fees but before the issuance of a certificate of occupancy, the

31

amount of gross square footage of the construction project increases or a decision is

32

made by the applicant to change the use of the structure to a use category for which
14

a higher linkage fee would be imposed under section 27-153, then the applicant shall

be required to pay additional linkage fees in compliance with this division.

(b) Any dispute over the applicability or calculation of the linkage fees may be

appealed by the applicant for a building permit to the executive director (manager) of

the department of community planning and development, who shall determine such

appeals in consultation with the executive director of the office of economic

development.

8
9

(c) Linkage fees previously paid by an applicant at building permit issuance

may be refunded from the Affordable Housing Linkage Fee Revenue Fund if it is

10

later determined on appeal or otherwise by the executive director (manager) of

11

community planning and development that the fees were not due and owning under

12

this division, if a decision is made by the applicant after a building permit has been

13

issued to reduce the gross square feet of the construction project or to change the

14

use of the structure to a use category for which a lower linkage fee would be

15

imposed under section 27-153, or if the building permits for the project lapse or are

16

relinquished by the applicant without the project being built. The executive director

17

(manager) of community planning and development shall not be obligated to make

18

any refund under this subsection (c) unless the applicant files a written request for a

19

refund with the executive director within sixty (60) days from the day any grounds for

20

a refund arise.

21

(d) After a building permit has been issued and the applicable linkage fees

22

have been paid, no additional fees shall be required under either of the following

23

circumstances:

24

(1) If the original building permit is cancelled in order to issue a replacement

25

building permit to change the general contractor; or

26

(2) If modified drawings for the construction project are submitted and logged

27

in for review, so long as the modified drawings do not increase the overall

28

gross square-footage of the project.

29
30

Sec. 27-157. Reductions and Waivers.

15

(a)

The executive director of the office of economic development may

reduce or waive the amount of linkage fees that would otherwise be imposed upon a

specific development under Sec. 27-153 if the applicant for a reduction or waiver

demonstrates that the required amount of fees exceeds the amount that would be

needed to mitigate the actual demand for affordable housing created by the

development. An application for such a reduction or waiver shall include information

showing the reduced affordable housing impacts created by the development, based

upon the actual characteristics of the development including, for example: (A) the

unique characteristics and space utilization of the workforce that will occupy a non-

10

residential development and the demand of that particular workforce for affordable

11

housing; (B) a non-residential development that will involve a structure built for and

12

suitable solely for a specific use involving few or no employees; or (C) the unique

13

characteristics of the residents who will occupy a residential development, and the

14

likelihood those particular residents, due to their disposable household income or

15

projected spending patterns, will not drive additional employment requiring additional

16

affordable housing.
(b)

17

The executive director shall promptly notify in writing the executive

18

director (manager) of the department of community planning and development of any

19

reduction or waiver or linkage fees granted under the authority of this section.

20
Division 3. Affordable housing advisory committee

21
22

Sec. 27-158. Committee created.

There is hereby created an affordable housing advisory committee. The committee

23
24

shall consist of eleven (11) members as follows:

25

(a)

26

everywhere (H&OPE).

27

(b) The following five (5) members appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the city

28

council:

Executive director of the mayors office of housing and opportunities for people

29

(1) Housing finance expert.

30

(2) Representative of a major employer.

16

(3) Representative of the private-sector, commercial real estate industry.

(4) Representative of the private-sector, market rate multi-family real

estate industry.

(5) At-large community member.

(c) The following five (5) members appointed by the city council:

(1) Two (2) members of the city council.

(2) For-profit affordable housing developer.

(3) Non-profit affordable housing developer.

(4) At-large community member

10
11

Sec. 27-159. Term of appointed committee members.

12

(a) The appointed members of the committee shall serve for a period of three (3)

13

years, with terms to be staggered by initially appointing one-third of the appointed

14

members for three-year terms, another third for two years, and the remaining third for

15

one year. Initial terms shall be set by the appointing authority.

16

(b) Committee members may be reappointed for successive terms.

17
18

Sec. 27-160. Vacancies.

19

Any vacancy in any appointed position of the committee shall be promptly filled

20

by the appropriate appointing authority to serve the remainder of the unexpired term of

21

the member who vacated the position.

22
23

Sec. 27-161. Compensation

24

The members of the committee shall serve without compensation; provided,

25

however, that members may be reimbursed for reasonable expenses incurred in

26

performance of their duties pursuant to the rules and regulations of the city for such

27

reimbursement.

17

1
2
3
4

Sec. 27-162. Officers.

The committee shall elect from its membership, a chairperson and such other
officers as it may designate who shall serve for two-year terms.

5
6
7

Sec. 27-163. Meetings and procedures.

(a)

The schedule of regular meetings of the committee shall be established by

a majority of the membership, but the schedule must provide for at least one regular

meeting per month. Additional meetings shall be called as needed by the chair of the

10

committee.

11

(b) All meetings of the committee shall be subject to city requirements for open

12

meetings, as set forth in Article III of Chapter 2 of the code. Participation and voting in

13

committee business by members of the committee shall be subject to the requirements

14

and limitations of the Code of Ethics, as set forth in Article IV of Chapter 2 of the code.

15
16
17

(c) The committee may adopt additional bylaws and procedures for the conduct
of its meetings and the performance of its duties as set forth in section 27-164.

18
19

Sec. 27-164. Powers and duties.

20

The general purpose of the committee is to render advice and recommendations

21

to the executive director of the office of economic development and the city council in

22

regard to the planning and implementation of city programs and services to preserve

23

and increase the supply of affordable housing in the city, The specific powers and duties

24

of the committee shall be:

25
26

(a)

To recommend goals, objectives and policies to inform the adoption of 3-5

27

year strategic plans for the permanent funds established in Division 1 of this Article V,

28

including but not limited to:

18

(1)

Goals for a mix of housing affordable to households in various

ranges of area median income (AMI), subject to the AMI limitations set

forth in section 27-150;

(2)

Goals for a mix of affordable rental and for-sale housing;

(3)

Parameters for usage of a portion of the revenue in the permanent

fund derived from the dedicated affordable housing property tax levy for

supportive services; and

8
9
10

(4)

Parameters for usage of a portion of the revenue in the permanent

funds for land banking and other tools to preserve locations in city for
future development of affordable housing.

11
12

(b) To recommend goals, objectives and policies to inform budget priorities for

13

expenditures to be made from the permanent funds established in Division 1 of this

14

Article V prior to the submission of such priorities by the executive director to the mayor

15

and the city council as part of the citys annual budget process.

16

(c)

To review semi-annual and annual performance and outlook reports

17

regarding past and potential future uses of revenue in the permanent funds established

18

by Division 1 of this Article V, as shall be submitted by the executive director to the

19

committee.

20
21
22
23

(d) To recommend to the executive director on an ongoing basis:

(1)

Concepts for new programs and services to achieve the purposes

of the permanent funds;

(2)

Metrics to be tracked in order to monitor the success of the

24

expenditures from the permanent funds in achieving the purposes of the

25

fund;

26

(3)

Community engagement strategies;

27

(4)

Housing priorities, including geographic priorities for creating or

28
29
30

preserving affordable housing within the city.

(5)

Methods to leverage and maximize expenditures from the

permanent funds.
19

(e)

To conduct an independent study of the city s overall affordable

housing needs and then then to formulate and recommend for the approval of

the city council by October 1, 2017 a comprehensive affordable housing plan that

will govern all future expenditures by the city from all other sources of revenue to

promote or preserve affordable housing. The plan shall include, at a minimum,

the following elements:

(1)

Identification of all sources of revenue for housing programs over

and above revenues dedicated to the permanent funds, including but not

limited to social impact bond revenue, CDBG funds, other city-

10

administered federal funds, other city funding, grant funding, and tax

11

increment funding through the Denver Urban Renewal Authority.

12

(2)

13

separately and in combination where applicable.

14

(3)

15

comprehensive affordable housing plan to prioritize and allocate all

16

housing revenues based on current conditions tied to specific targets,

17

flexible to adjustment based upon predetermined periodic reviews and

18

assessment.

19

(4)

20

of gentrification and displacement of lower income households in

21

neighborhoods with the most rapidly escalating housing costs.

22

(5)

23

implementation of housing expenditures and compliance with the

24

affordable housing plan by the office of economic development, with such

25

reports to be delivered to the affordable housing advisory committee and

26

the city council.

27

(6)

28

comprehensive plan every three to five years, or at such other interval as

29

may be recommended by the affordable housing advisory committee and

30

agreed to by the city council.

Establishment of measurable goals for each category of revenue,

A requirement for an annual action plan within the overall

Specific provisions for expenditures designed to mitigate the effects

requirement

for

annual

progress

reports

evaluating

A requirement for independent review and updating of the

20

(7)

A requirement that no affordable housing funds shall be expended

except in furtherance of the goals set forth in the plan.

(f)

To study and make recommendations regarding measures to

provide property tax relief to low and moderate income households, particularly

lower income households in neighborhoods experiencing the greatest impacts

from gentrification and involuntary displacement due to rapidly increasing

housing costs, including by way of example proposals to increase the scope and

eligibility for the type of property tax refunds provided by Article XI of Chapter 53

of the code.

10
11
12
13
14

Sec. 27-165. Staffing and administrative support.

Staffing and other administrative support for the committee shall be provided by
the office of economic development.

15
16
17
18

Section 2. That section 2-32, D.R.M.C. concerning Open Meetings shall be amended by
adding a new paragraph (2)(ddd), to read as follows:

19
20

Sec. 2-32. - Definitions.

21
22

(2) Public body:

23
24

(ddd) The affordable housing permanent funds advisory committee.

25
26
27
28

Section 3. That paragraph (b)(1) and subsection (e) of section 20-26, D.R.M.C., shall be
amended by adding the language underlined, to read as follows:

29
30
31

Sec. 20-26. Constitutional revenue limitations.

(b) Definitions. As used in this section, the following terms have the meanings
21

herein set forth:

(1) Affected funds means the general fund, the human service fund,

the police pension fund, the fire pension fund, for which a millage rate

has been itemized in the annual certification of city and county

property taxes, offset by temporary property tax credits or rate

reductions between tax years 1996 and 2011 in order to comply with

the constitutional property tax revenue limitation; and the affordable

housing property tax revenue fund,.

(e) Use of restored property tax revenues. Restored property tax revenues shall

10

be expended exclusively for the following purposes, with the allocation of revenue

11

between and among these purposes to be determined on a year to year basis as a part of

12

the annual budget and appropriation process: public safety, services for children, street

13

maintenance, parks and recreation, libraries, and other essential city services; payments

14

to low-income elderly and disabled persons as provided in section 53-498; and business

15

incentive programs to retain and attract businesses to Denver. For 2017 property taxes to

16

be collected in 2018, the citys certification of levies in support of the affected funds shall

17

include a separate itemized levy at the rate of one-half of one mill (.5 mill) for the purpose

18

of funding affordable housing programs through the affordable housing property tax fund.

19

For 2018 taxes to be collected in 2019, and in each subsequent, the city shall continue to

20

maintain a separately itemized levy to fund affordable housing programs and, as provided

21

in subsection (d)(2) of this section, shall adjust the levy annually in coordination with the

22

adjustment of the levies for the other affected funds to the extent necessary to comply

23

with the city property tax revenue limitation, until such time as the credited mills are

24

entirely eliminated.

25
26

Section 4. Establishment of Affordable Housing Permanent Funds.

27

A. There is hereby established in the Community Development Special Revenue Fund,

28

Fund Number 16000, an Affordable Housing Property Tax Revenue Fund, Accounting No. 16606,

29

for the purpose of receiving and expending certain tax revenue and revenue from other sources to

30

promote the provision of affordable housing in accordance with the laws of the city. Revenues

31

derived from the component of the citys property taxes dedicated to affordable housing, as
22

provided in Section 20-26, D.R.M.C., including any such revenues transferred from the TABOR

excess revenue fund, Fund No. 19000, shall be deposited into the Treasury of the City and

credited to the Affordable Housing Property Tax Fund.

B. There is hereby established in the Community Development Special Revenue Fund,

Fund Number 16000, an Affordable Housing Linkage Fee Revenue Fund, Accounting No. 16607,

for the exclusive purpose of receiving and expending revenues derived from the city affordable

housing linkage fees, as provided in Article V of Chapter 27, D.R.M.C. Any and all such fee

revenues shall be deposited into the Treasury of the City and credited to the Affordable Housing

Linkage Fee Revenue Fund.

10

(C) The Affordable Housing Property Tax Revenue Fund and the Affordable Housing

11

Linkage Fee Revenue Fund shall collectively be known as the citys Affordable Housing

12

Permanent Funds.

13

C. Expenditures are hereby authorized for the Affordable Housing Permanent Funds in an

14

amount not to exceed the total of deposits described in subsections (A) and (B) of this section, to

15

be expended by the Executive Director of the Office of Economic Development for the purposes

16

set forth in the governing law for each fund.

17

ordinances of the city, expenditures from the Affordable Housing Permanent Funds shall be

18

subject to annual appropriation by the city council.

19

Notwithstanding any other provision of the charter or

D. The Chief Financial Officer (Manager of Finance) of the City and County of

20

Denver is hereby authorized and directed to make such book and record entries and to do

21

such other things as may be necessary to accomplish the purposes of this ordinance.

22
23

Section 5. Effective Date.

24

1.

25

final publication.

26

2.

Except as otherwise provided herein, this ordinance shall be effective upon

The provisions of this ordinance imposing an affordable housing linkage fee

27

shall become effective October 1, 2017; provided, however, that the fee shall not apply to

28

any applicant for a building permit who has, prior to close of business on Friday, September

29

29, 2017 submitted to the Department of Community Planning and Development either a

30

site development concept plan or a building permit application with associated permit

31

drawings and paid all applicable plan review fees, and the department has logged-in such

32

submissions for review by the department. An applicant for a building permit for residential
23

construction who has submitted only a residential zoning plan prior to October 1, 2017, shall

not be exempt from payment of linkage fees under this ordinance on and after October 1,

2017.

4
5

COMMITTEE APPROVAL DATE: August 24, 2016.

MAYOR-COUNCIL DATE: August 30, 2016.

PASSED BY THE COUNCIL __________________________________________________

__________________________________________ - PRESIDENT

APPROVED: _______________________________ - MAYOR ______________________

10
11
12
13

ATTEST: __________________________________ - CLERK AND RECORDER,

EX-OFFICIO CLERK OF THE
CITY AND COUNTY OF DENVER

14

NOTICE PUBLISHED IN THE DAILY JOURNAL _____________; ________________

15
16

PREPARED BY:

David W. Broadwell, Asst. City Attorney; DATE: September 8, 2016

17
18
19
20
21
22

Pursuant to section 13-12, D.R.M.C., this proposed ordinance has been reviewed by the office of the
City Attorney. We find no irregularity as to form, and have no legal objection to the proposed
ordinance. The proposed ordinance is not submitted to the City Council for approval pursuant to
3.2.6 of the Charter.

23

Denver City Attorney

24
25

BY: _____________________, Assistant City Attorney

26
27
28

24

Sep 8, 2016
DATE: __________________