Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
0 INTRODUCTION
Hartalega Holdings Bhd. manufactures a wide range of latex gloves. The Company's products
include natural rubber examination gloves, nitrile examination gloves, nitrile clean room
gloves and natural rubber surgical gloves. Hartalega has beginning their business in this
rubber glove industry in 1988. Hartalega has always been in the forefront of the glovemaking industry.
Hartalega also the strong company that offers a range of products, superior in quality and
critical protection. For Hartalega there is no compromise in their manufacturing standards, in
fact they consistently exceed international quality standards. This makes hartalega are known
and trusted in worldwide.Hartalega SdnBhd has since become a reputable manufacturer of
Latex and Nitrile gloves and is now a public listed company on the Main Board of Bursa
Malaysia Securities Berhad.
Hartalegas continued technological innovations help ensure our gloves are manufactured
with equal emphasis on efficiency and quality this are the key reason Hartalega being trusted
as the OEM manufacturer for some of the worlds biggest brands. Hartalega produce the
product for the manufacturing, healthcare and laboratory environment. They are concern
about the comfortable for the customer when they are using their product, protection, hygiene
and cost-effectiveness in Hartalegas range of glove.
For over 2 decades, Hartalega has been a reputed OEM, delivering consistent quality with
reliable turnaround time for some of the world's famous brands. Their promise of quality,
efficiency and cost-effectiveness has made them a sought-after producer for many famous
global brands. Their export markets include high quality demand countries such as America,
Germany, Japan and Australia among many others.
This report is to analyze Hartalegas internal strengths and weaknesses, external opportunities
and threats, competitors, financial strengths, the strategies, and their current position by
looking at the SWOT Analysis, strategic group map, financial ratio, space matrix and BCG
matrix.
OPPORTUNITIES
3.1.1
years and 50 percentages of largest rubber glove exporters in this world. There is a
supportive environment in Malaysia for rubber glove industry and it plays a role in the
success of the Malaysian rubber glove players. In Malaysia rubber glove industry gets
strong government backing from bodies such as the Malaysian Rubber Export
Promotion Council (MREPC) and Malaysian Rubber Board (MRB). Also, Malaysia is
located near the key source of the major raw material, natural latex, which mainly
comes from Thailand. Malaysia is also blessed with good infrastructure, reliable
energy supply and a relatively stable government compared to some countries in the
region.
3.1.2
Market covers
Hartalega Holding Berhad has huge market covers and its give an opportunities for
them to expand their markets. Hartalega Holding Bhd is headquartered at Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia, and it is exports products more to 137 international clients in 39
such as North America, Europe, Asia Pacific and other region. However, Hartalega
has made business meeting arranged by MATRADE in 2009 with Brazilian buyers
which is effort to expand their target market to Latin American and it successful in
registration for approval license. This is to gain the potential sales and initials to enter
Brazilian market.
The overall industry is poised for growth with huge potential in emerging markets due
to the increased awareness of health care and global health. The reforms, especially
the market for rubber gloves in Brazil is expanding because of the abated rules for
imports of rubber gloves while China's health care reform is set to boost its health
care industry. Therefore, Hartalega to focus on Brazilian market and it may able to
expand to Latin America.
3.2
THREATS
3.2.1
Hartalega price is not stable and it could rise in the future. Even though most rubber
glove companies include Hartalega Berhad have pricing power and are able to pass on
any cost increase or savings back to its customers, the volatile Hartalega and weak
US$ could dampen their margins and earnings in the period before the prices are
adjusted.
3.2.2
The overall industry is poised for growth with huge potential in emerging markets due
to the increased awareness of health care and global health. According to the graph
below, shown the Health care spending has grown much faster than the rest of the
4
economy in recent decades. The reforms, especially the market for rubber gloves in
Brazilian is expanding because of the abated rules for imports of rubber gloves while
China's health care reform is set to boost its health care industry. Therefore, Hartalega
to focus on Brazilian market and it may able to expand to Latin America.
3.2.3
The availability of substitute product from other companies encourages the price
competition in examination glove segment. The substitute product comes from Top
Glove, Adventa, Kossan, Latex and Supermax. Therefore, it may cause Hartalega
decrease their economy of scale by other company.
3.2.4. Difficult to differentiate brand product
It is hard to identify two major companies between Top Glove and Hartalega which is
Top Glove is stand the largest in producing natural rubber gloves and Hartalega stand
the largest in producing nitrile gloves. Those companies are playing a significant part
on producing medical gloves. According to the medical gloves, it is made of different
polymers including latex, nitrile rubber, vinyl and neoprene. Due to increasing rate of
people who allergic latex that become wide used. On the other hand, due to
substantial rise of the latex price by cost of product nitrile gloves lower than natural
latex gloves. Recently, many players have started to shift from natural rubber to nitrile
rubber for medical fraternity. This may cause some players not sure to cater for nitrile
especially new target market even Hartakega already lead while the other players. The
comparison may summarize refer to the table below.
STRENGTHS
3.1.1
The Hartalega play a major role producing nitrile glove producers in the world. The
production technology and the stringent product quality have earned Hartalega Berhad
various international accreditations. This has been proven when they received all its
products are in compliance with ASTM, JIS T9113, JIS T9115, EN455, ISO 11193
and AS/NZ 4011 standards. The high quality product produced by Hartalega Berhad
has strengthened their reputation and facilitated the Group in winning new customers.
Hartalega has the latest high speed production lines which have ability to producing
45,000 pieces of glove per hour per line.
3.3.2
Hartalega Berhad had invested heavily on research and development to develop new
application of glove. According to, over the previous years, Hartalega have received
numerous awards and received prestigious awards for outstanding R & D, innovation
and quality and good manufacturing practices. In 2007, they have received the award
from Selangor State Investment Centre in term of excellent in product design, product
6
safety, product research and development, technology and care towards the
environment and welfare and safety of workers.
3.3.3
Product patent
Hartalega Berhad has applied for worldwide patents for its products and envisions a
growing market for its new and innovative application-nitrile and latex gloves. It
make hard for the competitors to imitate their product.
3.4.4
Hartalega was a leader in the nitrile glove and latex gloves market causes was also
maintaining the high efficient and profitable glove maker. It presents the strong
financial result that gains the highest return on equity and net profit margin in the
industry. Moreover, Hartalega increasing profit for 11.7 percentages on ended March
31, 2015 which is from RM54.93million to RM49.15 million reported by Hong Leong
Investment Bank Research, (2015).
3.4.5 Technical recognition
Hartalega has mastered the technological know-how of rubber glove manufacturing
and is embarking on aggressive capacity expansion to keep pace with demand. There
is high in-house technical knowledge base to produce this application-nitrile glove
(including surgical glove) and latex gloves which are hard earned trust of the most
critical users, place Hartalega Berhad among the elite few in the industry capable of
attaining worldwide acceptance. Based on technological breakthrough, it have
mentioned that Hartalega Holding Sdn stand in the First in the industry on many
different term such as
First and only manufacturer that is able to run a production speed up to 35,000
gloves piece per hour on line.
First in biomass energy plant in the industry registered to the United Nations
Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCC) or Kyoto protocol in
2007.
First in develop Robotic Stripping System in 1995 on the mimic human hand
motion
This is support the good view in the brand image of Hartalega and causes the
company recognition in the world gloves industry. Moreover, the company has
received many awards as in 2010 on Overall Best Managed Company in Malaysia
2010 (Small Cap) by Asiamoney.
3.4
WEAKNESSES
3.4.1
Declining Profitability
According to the first quarter ended June 30, 2014 stated the Hartalega Holding
Berhad net profit have fell for 9.3 % to RM57.1 million which is compare to last 2
year. There are several reasons that cause the company wear down on their operation
profit margin. First, there are high competitive selling price in glove manufacturing
industry so Hartalega started reduced in their average selling price. Second, the
increase in the electricity tariff, natural gas tariff and maintenance cost that was play
an important impacts to wears down their operation profit margin.
3.4.2. Higher tax rate
Since the profit fell down that it causes largely due to big amount cost of NGC and
some branding expenditure. The higher tax rate that pull down the net profit and
declared to interim dividend, it is lower than last years 3.5 sen/share. The company
crises effect directly to decrease the profit and impact to increase their tax.
S-strength
W-weakness
Declining Profitability
development (R&D)
Product patent
Technical recognition
O-opportunity
T-treat
Market covers
Weight
Hartalega
COMPANY
Score Top Glove Score
Latexx
Market share
0.13
3
0.39
4
0.52
Compatibility
0.11
3
0.33
3
0.33
Innovation Capability
0.13
3
0.39
3
0.39
Manufacturing Capability
0.10
3
0.30
4
0.40
Price competitiveness
0.10
3
0.30
4
0.40
Product quality
0.13
4
0.52
4
0.52
Consumer loyalty
0.13
3
0.39
4
0.52
Financial position
0.09
3
0.27
3
0.27
Brand name
0.08
3
0.24
4
0.32
Total
1.00
3.13
3.67
The CPM ratings represent:4: major strength; 3: minor strength; 2: minor weakness and 1: major weakness.
2
2
2
3
3
3
2
2
2
Scor
e
0.26
0.22
0.26
0.30
0.30
0.39
0.26
0.18
0.16
2.33
Based on the table, it shows that Top Glove has more competitive advantage compare with
Hartalega and Latexx. Based in the score, Top Glove gains the highest score for the critical
success factor which is 3.67 and followed by Hartalega which is 3.13. Hartalega get second
highest which is in the middle between top glove and latex. Based on that score, we can
conclude that Hartalega are the one of top competitors in this rubber glove industry and they
also have strong competitive advantage compare to Latexx. Therefore, to make this company
be more success in this industry and be the market leader, Hartalega should improve and
implement a new strategy to make sure that they can compete with Top Glove.
A strategic group is a collection of companies that tend to behave in relatively the same way.
There are clusters of firms that share similar strategies. Mapping the position of competitors
in an industry allows for the identification of important strategic groups.
This graph shows the Malaysian rubber glove industry strategic group map based on quality
and price. The x-axis represents the quality of product and y-axis represents the price of the
product. We are using high, medium and low as a measurement. This map consists of 5
companies which are Hartalega, Top Glove, Supermax, Latexx and Kossan. We choose this
company because, this are the strategic group for Hartalega.
The size of circle represents the size of the company gain in the market share of the industry.
For the Hartalega and Supermax have almost the same market share in industry, which is they
have larger market share compare Kossan and Latexx. For the bigger market share, its lead by
the Top Glove.
Top Glove, Hartalega and Supermax make up a strategic group because they are close to each
other on these two strategic dimensions in this industry. Even though they are close but the
size of market share that they gain is different because of the others factor. For top glove, they
be a leader in this market share are because of the product quality that they produce, make
11
their customer be mo loyalty towards them. They also have a strong brand name in the
market. But Hartalega also try to make sure that their product will get place at their customer.
They produce the product with the high quality and make an innovation towards their
product. Based on the quality, Hartalega is the competitor that threatens them the most.
Furthermore, we also can compare these 5 companies based on the breadth of product line.
For Hartalega, has lower market share because of the variety of product that they produce and
the less breadth of product line. Hartalega focus on the healthcare, laboratory and industrial
while Top Glove produce gloves for examination, surgical, household, cleaning and apron
purposes and they expand globally to China, Thailand, USA and Germany. With more
breadth of product line than the other company, they manage to outperform the others and are
rated high on the map. Supermax, on the other hand, expands in more countries compared to
Top Glove, which is USA, Brazil, Germany, Canada, Australia, and Belgium. However they
produce less breadth of product line compared to Top Glove.
Meanwhile, Hartalega is in the middle. Although Hartalegas market share is larger than
Supermax, but they only expand in America, German, Japan and Australia, which is fewer
than Supermax. Hartalega expands in four other countries, same as Top Glove, but they
produce fewer breadth of product line.
In order to be at that place in the strategic group map, Hartalega should increase thequalityof
the product and breadth of their product line than Top Glove and expand in more countries
than Supermax. These are the strategies that can Hartalega use to make sure that they can lead
in market share.
Hartalega also should use this strategic group map to identify barriersto mobility and
opportunities to protect them from being attack by Top Glove and Supermax. The strategic
group map can also help cart the future directions of Hartalegas strategies and are helpful in
thinking through the implications of each industry trend for the strategic group as a whole.
6.0 FINANCIAL RATIO ANALYSIS
Financial ratios are mathematical comparisons of financial statement accounts or categories.
These relationships between the financial statement accounts help investors, creditors, and
internal company management understand how well a business is performing and areas of
needing improvement.Ratios allow us to compare companies across industries, big and small,
to identify their strengths and weaknesses. Financial ratios that we analysis, we had divided
12
up into five main categories which is liquidity ratio, solvency ratio, efficiency ratio,
profitability ratio and market prospect ratio..
Financial analysis is not just a tool for financial managers but also can be used effectively by
investors, lenders, suppliers, employees, and customers. Basically, managers use financial
ratios to:
Prepare, at both the firm and division levels, financial projections such as those
associated with the launch of a new product.
Within the internal company environment, financial ratios can be used by:
14
13
12
11
13
Current ratio
3.83
3.25
4.42
3.63
Quick ratio
2.94
2.54
3.28
2.81
Working capital
RM
RM
RM
RM
292,443,524
207,220,295
310,474,334
275,300,426
Summary of Hartalegas quick ratio performance within 5 years.
14
LAVERAGE RATIO
13
12
11
0.056
0.065
0.086
0.119
total assets
long term debt-
0.984
0.986
0.988
0.992
to- capital
debt to equity
long term debt
0.01
62.45
0.02
69.76
0.04
84.91
0.08
124.02
to- equity
higher the degree of leverage, and consequently, financial risk. This is a broad ratio that
includes long-term and short-term debt (borrowings maturing within one year), as well as all
assets which include tangible and intangible.
Based on the analysis, the data show an improvement on their total debt to total assets ratio. It
shows the decreasing order of ratio year by year. Year 2011 shows the highest ratio which is
0.119 which indicated their company consequently at the highest risk compare to the other
year. Therefore, a company with a high degree of leverage may find it more difficult during a
recession than one with low leverage, but as we see, in year 2014 shows it the lowest ratio
which is 0.056. This indicated that company manages to endure the risk within their leverage.
6.2.2 Long term debt to capital ratio
The proportion of company long term debt relative to its available capacity. By using this
ratio, investor can identify the amount of leverage utilized by a specific company and
compare it with other to help analyzed the companys risk exposure. Generally, company that
finances a greater portion of their capital through debt is considered riskier than those the
lower leverage ratio.
From the above data, Hartalegas show the decreasing amount of ratio year by year. It slightly
decreases by 0.4% in 2012, 0.2% in year 2013 and 2014. In this analysis, they able to manage
their creditworthiness and balance sheet strength. Year 2014 shows the lowest amount which
is 0.984 which may indicates that the lower the ratio, the greater the capacity to borrow
additional funds.
6.2.3 Debt to equity
The debt to equity ratio shows the percentage of company financing that comes from
creditors and investors. A higher debt to equity ratio indicates that more creditor financing
(bank loans) is used than investor financing (shareholders).
From the data above, company are currently able to manage to balance between debt (fund
borrow both short and long term) and the amount invest in the interprise. In year 2014,
company shows the lower amount of ratio which is 0.01 which indicated they have a higher
credit rating and greater the companys ability to borrow additional funds. This is a good
signal in their balance sheet strength compare to 2013, 2012, and 2011.
6.2.3 Long term debt to equity
16
It shows the balances between long term debt and stockholders equity in the firm long term
capital structure.
From the analysis above, company are capable to manage their long term debt and
stockholder equity. It shows the company have drop down their debt in year to year. As we
can see, in year 2014, their long term debt to equity has the lower amount of ratio which is
62.45 compare to before. Company is trying to lower down their debt from 124.02 in year
2011 until 62.45 in year 2014. The difference is about 61.57 percent which means company
has greater capacity to borrow additional funds if needed.
6.3 Efficiency ratio
Efficiency ratios also called activity ratios measure how well companies utilize their assets to
generate income. Efficiency ratios often look at the time it takes companies to collect cash
from customer or the time it takes companies to convert inventory into cash. In other words,
make sales. These ratios are used by management to help improve the company as well as
outside investors and creditors looking at the operations of profitability of the company.
Summary of Hartalegas efficiency ratio:
RATIO
14
EFFICIENCY RATIO
13
12
11
Days of
48.49
46.27
56.11
51.11
inventory
Inventory
7.53
7.89
6.50
7.14
turnover
Average
49.26
45.62
45.92
50.16
collection period
17
The data shows us that year 2013 has the shorter days which are 46 days compare to other
year. This show that, it that year the company inventory moves as fast as possible to minimize
cost and to increase cash flow. Whereas in year 2014, it take 3 days more to sell their entire
inventory
6.3.2 Inventory turnover.
It measures how many times average inventory is "turned" or sold during a period. In other
words, it measures how many times a company sold its total average inventory dollar amount
during the year. This ratio is important because total turnover depends on two main
components of performance. The first component is stock purchasing. If larger amounts of
inventory are purchased during the year, the company will have to sell greater amounts of
inventory to improve its turnover. If the company can't sell these greater amounts of
inventory, it will incur storage costs and other holding costs.The second component is sales.
Sales have to match inventory purchases otherwise the inventory will not turn effectively.
The data shows that the company manages to increase their total turnover year by year. As we
can see in year 2012 it have the higher amount of ratio and good inventory control which is
7.89 times which mean the company does not overspend by buying too much inventory and
wastes resources by storing non-salable inventory. It also shows that the company can
effectively sell the inventory it buys. While the difference between year 2014 and 2013 is
about 36% only. Currently company is trying to manage their inventory control.
6.3.3 Average collection period
The average collection period is the average number of days between 1) the date that a credit
sale is made, and 2) the date that the money is received from the customer. The average
collection period is also referred to as thedays' sales in accounts receivable. It is indicated the
average length of time the firm must wait after making a sales to receive cash payment.
The data above show that year 2013 has the shorter period of time which is 45.62 times
compare to other year. It indicated that the company takes only around 46 times to collect on
its customers. While in year 2011, company has the problems in waiting to receive cash
payment from their customers. This could also indicate the company has loosened its credit
policies with customers, meaning that they may have been extending credit to companies
where they normally would not have. This could temporarily boost sales, but could also result
in an increase in sales revenue that cannot be recovered.
18
PROFITABILITY RATIO
14
13
12
11
Gross profit
0.332
0.336
0.319
0.372
margin
Return on sales
0.938
0.9537
0.9538
0.949
Return on total
20.98
24.84
26.58
29.97
assets(ROA)
Return on
24.71
30.55
32.52
34.89
stockholder
equity
19
period to another, unless the industry it is in has been undergoing drastic changes which will
affect the costs of goods sold or pricing policies.
6.4.2 Return on sales
This measure of how much is profiting from its sales. A high return on sales indicated that
the company is selling its products well and its profits are likely sustainable while a low
return on sales indicates the opposite. Management often uses the return on sales to determine
how efficient the company is.
As the data analysis above, year 2012 and 2013 show the higher amount of ratio which is
0.954 which means the company sells their products well and the company is growing
efficiently. Whereas in year 2011 has the second highest percentage which 94.9% and in year
2014 it only has 93.8%. The different between these two years is around 1.1%. The company
should try to increase their percentage of return on sales so that the trends will be upward and
they are able to manage the company efficiency as well to their profits.
6.4.3 Return on assets
The ratio that measures the net income produced by total assets during a period by comparing
net income to the average total assets. In other words, the return on assets ratio or ROA
measures how efficiently a company can manage its assets to produce profits during a period.
Since company assets purpose is to generate revenues and produce profits, this ratio helps
both management and investors see how well the company can convert its investments in
assets into profits.
The data above shows that the company shows the fluctuation trend. The amount shows the
downward trend. The highest ratio is 29.97% in year 2011 then slowly fluctuated year by year
until 2014 which is 20.98%. The different between 2011 and 2014 is around 8.99% which
mean company need to improve their efficiency in managing their assets in order to produce a
higher profits.
6.4.4 Return on stockholder equity
Ratio that measures the ability of a firm to generate profits from its shareholders investments
in the company. In other words, the return on equity ratio shows how much profit each dollar
of common stockholders' equity generates.
20
So a return on 1 means that every ringgit of common stockholders' equity generates 1 ringgitr
of net income. This is an important measurement for potential investors because they want to
see how efficiently a company will use their money to generate net income.
The data above shows that in year 2014, the data tend to decrease 24.71, this indicate that
company is not able to use its investors funds effectively compare to other year. Whereas in
year 2011 it show the highest return on stockholders equity which means at that year
company are perform well and company progress.
6.5 MARKET PROSPECT RATIO
Market Prospect ratios are used to compare publicly traded companies' stock prices with
other financial measures like earnings and dividend rates. Investors use market prospect
ratios to analyze stock price trends and help figure out a stock's current and future market
value.
In other words, market prospect ratios show investors what they should expect to receive
from their investment. They might receive future dividends, earnings, or just an appreciated
stock value. These ratios are helpful for investors to predict how many stock prices will be in
the future based on current earnings and dividend measurements.
Summary of Hartalegas market prospect ratio:
RATIO
Earnings per
14
31.39
share (sen)
Price earning
5.81
6.43
11
26.18
6.92
2014 it shows slightly decrease by 0.49 sen. Basically company are in good performance
because they are showing a good trends and even though there are slightly decrease but the
value are still maintain by 31.39 sen.
22
TOP GLOVE
SUPERMAXX
Ratin
Weighted
Ratin
Weighted
Weight
Score
Score
Rating
Score
Marketing strategy
0.10
0.6
0.7
0.60
Customer service
0.10
0.7
0.7
0.6
quality
0.15
1.2
1.2
1.05
Brand Image
0.13
0.91
1.17
0.91
Technology skill
0.15
1.2
1.35
1.2
0.13
1.04
0.17
0.91
Financial resources
0.14
1.12
1.12
0.98
Product innovation
0.10
0.7
0.7
0.6
Total Score
1.00
strength
10 Major Strength
7.47
5 Average
Weighted
8.11
6.85
1 Major Weakness
23
push more content and offer good quality of product. It has its eyes set on future growth and
regional expansion in their operational business.
Moreover, with other strength measure Hartalega also getting the high mark in the
rating because they stay strong with their product and service. Since its establishment,
Hartalega has been providing a by providing consistently superior, safer, and more
convenient gloves in chosen product markets. They also relay on their technology skill to
produce more quality and safer product to the customer. Hartalega also significant growth and
strong track record of bringing innovation, excellent customer service and value to
stakeholders has won the company numerous awards over the year.
After multiplying each score by its given weight, we were able to add all scores to
determine the strongest company. Hartalega ended up on second rank with the overall
strength rating is 7.47; left behind the Top Glove with the overall strength rating is 8.11. Even
though Hartalega did not get the highest rating, it still shows that Hartalega is one of the
stronger competitors among other companies in that rubber glove industry.
From the table above, we also can see that Hartalega position in the rubber glove
industry is strong because they are the nearest competitor for Top Glove with the different
between their strength ratings is only 0.64, and followed by Supermax.
We conclude that, from this analysis Hartalega should increase reasonable marketing
plan to make sure that their customer still loyalty with their product. Besides, its important
for them to do be acknowledging by customers and other stakeholders in order to increase
more market share and profit in their operating business.
24
Strengths
1. High level of production
efficiency
Weaknesses
1. Declining Profitability
2. Higher tax rate
2. Active involvement in
research and development
(R&D)
3. Product patent
4. Strong in return on
equity(ROE) and net profit
margin
5. Technical recognition
Opportunities
1. Supportive
environment for
rubber glove
industry in
Malaysia
2. Market covers
3. Global hospital
supplies markets
4. Rising Healthcare
Expenditure
So strategy
Wo strategy
1.(S5, T3)
1.(W1,O1,O2)
2.(S2, T1)
Based on the strength which the are
good and active in research and
development to develop a new
application, so it is very good as they
manufactured in malaysia that have
supportive environtment for rubber
glove industry as their opportunity.
Expanding the business not only in
Malaysia but establish themselves in
globalization by expanding in many
countries in the world as they can get
eassier the material not only in
2.(01, 03)
Since the company has the weaknesses
in decline profitability, they can use
the opportunity in demand of global
hospital suplies market.Hartalega
should do the segmentation by region
that they should focus that can give
more profit. They can produce more
on application nitrite glove that get
25
3.(S1,T1)
Threats
1. Unstable price
and weak US$
2. Rising in energy
cost
3. Availability of
substitute product
Ts strategy
Wt strategy
1. (S1,S5,3T)
1. (T1, W1)
Offering
discounts
and
customer-oriented products in
order
to
competitors
overcome
in
term
the
price
2. (S4,T1, T2)
26
supplier
customer
relationship.
3.(S5,S1, 3T)
The high technology strategic that
may ensure their productivity,
create something different and
uniqueness.
It
response
the
27
28
9.1.2
Rate the factors using rating system specific to each dimension. Rate competitive
advantage (CA) and environmental stability (ES) using rating scale from -6 (worst) to
-1 (best). Rate industry strength (IS) and financial strength (FS) using rating scale
9.1.3
9.1.3 Plot the average scores for IS, CA, FS, and ES on the appropriate axis in the SPACE
Matrix.
9.1.4
Add the average score for the competitive advantage (CA) and industry strength (IS)
9.1.5
dimensions. This will be the final point on axis X on the SPACE matrix.
Add the average score for the SPACE matrix environmental stability (ES) and
financial strength (FS) dimensions to find the final point on the axis Y.
9.1.6
Draw a directional vector from the origin of the SPACE Matrix through the new
intersection point. This vector reveals the type of strategies recommended for the
organization: aggressive, competitive, defensive, or conservative.
Ratings
4.0
4.0
4.0
3.5
3.5
19.0
-2.0
-2.0
-2.5
-2.0
-2.5
-11.0
Axis Y
Financial strengthRating is 1 (worst) to 6 (best)
Ratings
29
5.0
3.5
4.5
FS Total
ES Total
3.0
4.0
20.0
-4.0
-3.0
-2.5
-3.5
-2.0
-15.0
Industry strength:
Competitive advantage:
Financial strengths:
Environment stability:
19 / 5 =
-11 / 5 =
20 / 5 =
-15 / 5 =
3.8
-2.2
4.0
-3.0
Total
axis
ES)
Totatttl
axisYYscore
score (FS
(FS +
+ ES)
4.0 + (-3) = 1.0
Conservative
FS
Aggressive
CA
IS
Defensive
ES
Competitive
For the industry strength dimension, it is considers as the external forces that belong to the
industry where the company develops its activities. We have rating Hartalega based on
growth potential, financial stability, profit potential, productivity and resources utilization
with the rating scale from 1 (worst) to 6 (best).
For the growth, financial stability and profit potential factors of Hartalega are good, so they
have been scored as 4.0.Whereas, in Hartalegas place at the forefront of the industry is
credited to their progressive systems which enhance the speed, efficiency and cost
effectiveness of their production. So for the productivity and resources utilization, we score it
for 3.5. Then, the total amount of scores for industry strength is 19.0.
For the competitive advantage dimension,this is the next variable considered in the internal
strategic dimension. Customer loyalty, product quality, market share, technologyknow-how
also brand and image are some of the variables to be considered. As in the other internal
strategic dimension, each variable considered is given a numerical value, but in this case from
-1 (being the best) to -6 (being the worst).
As Hartalega moves from strength-to-strength, new technologies will be continuously
embraced and introduced and they are dedication to developing new and innovative gloves
reflects their commitment to future progress.So we scored as -2.0 for customer loyalty,
technology know-how and for product quality factors because this is what they are excellent
at. Besides that, the rate for market share also brands and image we score as-2.5, making the
total for competitive advantage is -11.0.
31
For financial strength dimension,it includes everything that refers to the financials of the
company. Each one of these variables is given a numeric value from 1 (worst) to 6 (best)
according to our perception of how good the company is doing regarding that variable.the
rating given to Hartalega are based on earning per share, leverage, liquidity, working capital,
and efficiency ratio.
We can consider the earning per sharewith the higher earnings per share is always better
because the company is more profitable and the company has more profits to distribute to its
shareholders so for that factor we score Hartalegafor 5.0 because of their upward trend of
earning per share. For the leverage factor, we rate it as 3.5 because the company is able to
manage their debt whereas for liquidity we score it as 4.5 and 3.0 for working capital factor.
Hartalega are good in handling their liquidity ratio and lastly for efficiency factor we scored it
as 4.0 because the company tends to have an upward trend in their management efficiency. So
after we total up, for financial strength dimension is 20.0 scores.
Last, environment stability is considered. It refers to how stable is the market where the
company operates. Things like rate of inflation, price competing product, technology change,
competitive pressure and demand variability are considered. The more stable is the market;
more favorable is for the company to operate in it. A score from -1 (best) to -6 (worst) is
given to each of the variables considered.
The rate of inflation factors, we score it as -4.0 and for price competing product we rate it as
-3.0. As we know in group mapping Hartalega was the second highest competing in market
share. Because of innovation forms the foundation to Hartalega's global success and
Hartalega's status as the world's largest manufacturer of clinical Nitrile gloves, can be
attributed to their innovative manufacturing technologies and advanced technologies so that,
for technology change and competitive pressure, we score it around -2.5 and -3.5. Whereas,
in demand variability, we rate is as -2.0 because of their efficiency and cost effectiveness of
their production. Then, the total amount of scores for environment stability is -15.0.
After plotting the scored on the graph, Hartalega suggested strategy type is aggressive.
The aggressive posture in the SPACE Analysis Matrix occurs when all the dimensions are
positive. The implicit strategy is to aggressively grow the business raising the stakes for all
competitors.
32
Some of strategies that the company may follow are continue to invest in innovation to
sustain and build the competitive advantage which exists. Basically, company has a strong
competitive position inthe market so they only have tofollow up on possible opportunities in
the market (backward or forward vertical integration) as well to increase their rapid
growth.Besides that, companyalso needs to use their internal strengths to develop a market
penetration and market development strategy. This may include some integration with other
companies, product development, and acquisition of competitors.
33
Stars:The business units or products that have the best market share and
generate the most cash are considered stars. Monopolies and first-to-market
products are frequently termed stars. However, because of their high growth
rate, stars also consume large amounts of cash. This generally results in the
same amount of money coming in that is going out. Stars can eventually
become cash cows if they sustain their success until a time when the market
II.
34
the potential to turn into stars. Companies are advised to invest in question
marks if the product has potential for growth, or to sell if it does not.
Cash cows: Cash cows are the leaders in the marketplace and generate more
III.
cash than they consume. These are business units or products that have a high
market share, but low growth prospects. Cash cows provide the cash required
to turn question marks into market leaders, to cover the administrative costs of
the company, to fund research and development, to service the corporate debt,
and to pay dividends to shareholders. Companies are advised to invest in cash
cows to maintain the current level of productivity or to "milk" the gains
IV.
passively.
Dogs: dogs have low market share and low growth rate and thus neither
generate nor consume a large amount of cash. However, dogs are cash traps
because of the money tied up in a business that has little potential. Such
businesses are candidates for divestiture.
Latex Gloves
Nitrile Gloves
NITRILE GLOVE
SOUTH CHINA EUROP
AMERIC
LATEX GLOVE
SOUTH
CHINA EUROP
AMERICA
A
SALES
REVENUE
9 649
182
5 352
3 446
542
5 865
(PAIRS)
PERCENTAG
1.2%
37.8%
20.6%
6.2%
51.8%
-7.6%
E CHANGE
EXPORT GROWTH
RAW
35
ID
SEGMENTS
A
B
NITRILE GLOVE
LATEX GLOVE
SOUTH
AMERIC
A
74
26
CHIN
A
EUROPE MATERIAL
PRICE
25
75
48
52
15%
5%
QUESTION MARKS
INDUSTRY
GROWTHCASH
RATE
COWS
DOGS
Low
High
RELATIVE
MARKET
SHARE
Low
1. Stars
Business segment for Nitrile glove is fall under Stars. Nitrile glove has gain the higher
industry growth and also gain the higher relative market share in rubber glove industry.
Because of the innovation and the concept of sustainability that they implement, they get
high revenue in South America. Not only that, based on the geographical segment, mostly
nitrile glove get the higher revenue in each of the segment. This will give the
opportunities to Hartalega to stabilize their nitrile gloves market at each country.
36
2. Question marks
From the BCG Matrix, we found that latex glove is fall under question marks categories.
Thats means latex glove have higher in industry growth but gain low in relative market
share. Hartalega should improve their strategy to improve the market share of the latex
glove to make sure that it will become the star. Indirectly, Hartalega will increase their
profit in this product. Moreover, even though latex glove has gain low market share, but
in Europe segment, this product get higher revenue. So, Hartalega should increase their
effort to make sure that consumer want their product so that they can get higher market
share and will become the star.
37
11.0 CONCLUSION.
As a conclusion, based on our term paper we analyze the major initiatives taken by Hartalega
holding, involving the performance in internal and external environments. Hartalega has the
strength in technology and innovation through their R&d but with the many weaknesses of
the company such as dechline profitability makes the Hartalega could not gain the
competitive advantage in the industry.
Then, in the competitive industry of the rubber industry is the field which admittedly
challengingHartalega need to rapidly expanding the business activities in various forms of
investments, especially those focused on the creating a new products and improvement the
product to the customer. Then, the greater supportive environtment and market demand can
open the opportunity for Hartalega to become more competitive in the industry.
Moreover, based on our analyzing on the competitor movement, we already provide the
strategy to overcome the weaknesses and reduce threat with the strength and opportunities
that Hartalega holding have. This is important because every of their movement is very
important to make sure the decision is not by the self-interest and Hartalega need to have
deep understanding to make sure Hartalega can beat the entire competitor in the industry.
Moreover, this we call a competitive advantage when Hartalega can use the blue ocean
strategy to make sure the company not going into the red ocean strategies that have many
competitors compete in the industry.
Lastly, Hartalega fight was far from complete. Efforts to strengthen Hartalega position as a
reputable company still continues. Hartalega needs to improve efficiency and make the
diversification on the strategic area by enhancing the new products to satisfy the customer
38
expectation to make sure Hartalega emerging to become top tier of rubber provider in the
future.
39
Reference
http://www.nst.com.my/node/83141
http://www.thesundaily.my/news/1132659
http://www.tendersinfo.com/business-intelligence/doc/38154-cr-hartalega-holdings-berhadharta-financial-and-strategic-swot-analysis-review#
http://www.hartalega.com.my/about-us/awards/
http://harta.irplc.com/medianews.htm?filepath=harta/HARTA-The%20Star-07052015.pdf
http://www.bionity.com/en/studies/4875/hartalega-holdings-berhad-harta-financial-andstrategic-swot-analysis-review.html
http://www.medica-tradefair.com/cipp/show,lang,2/oid,30405/xa_nr,2392565/~/WebExhDatasheet/exh_datasheet
http://www.solmed.com.au/coats-nitrile-gloves/
http://www.hartalega.com.my/innovation/manufacturing/
http://www.financialreport.biz/File/AR/2011/7/26/5168%20-%200100537896849.pdf
http://www.mrepc.com/marketplace/public/supplier/aboutus.php?userid=110
http://www.hartalega.com.my/about-us/
http://www.topglove.com.my/
http://www.supergloves.com/
https://www.google.com/search?
q=hartalega+market+share&espv=2&biw=1366&bih=643&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&
ei=vBNlVZWqEseIuwT4wIPgCA&ved=0CAcQ_AUoAg#imgrc=pmQceR1DqlQMCM
%253A%3BtAZZwnB7Juq6VM%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252F3.bp.blogspot.com%252FZuMfRpdFr6w%252FUHkwhBjXNDI%252FAAAAAAAABhU%252FVDZj3SdWMlE
%252Fs1600%252FComparison.png%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.intellecpoint.com
%252F2012%252F10%252Fgloves-industry-still-attractive.html%3B925%3B474
40