Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
DOI 10.1007/s11940-011-0127-8
Epilepsy
Treatment of Depression
in Patients with Epilepsy
Katherine H. Noe, MD, PhD1
Dona E. C. Locke, PhD2
Joseph I. Sirven, MD1,*
Address
1,*
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic in Arizona,
5777 East Mayo Boulevard, Phoenix, AZ 85054, USA
Email: sirven.joseph@mayo.edu
2
Department of Psychiatry and Psychology, Mayo Clinic in Arizona,
5777 East Mayo Boulevard, Phoenix, AZ 85054, USA
Opinion statement
In this article, we review the current best evidence for the treatment of depression
in patients with epilepsy. Depression is a common epilepsy comorbidity, but it is
often unrecognized. The most important step in appropriately managing mood disorders in this population is making the diagnosis. Clinical vigilance and routine use
of a validated screening tool can improve detection and quality of care. As is increasingly the case for the general population, persons with epilepsy are often interested in exploring alternative therapies for chronic conditions, including
depression. Unfortunately, the benefit of complementary and alternative therapies
for depression currently is largely unproven for persons with a seizure history, although an early study of exercise for mild depression has shown some benefit. Concerns about drug interactions, side effects, and expense may be barriers to the
prescription of antidepressant medications for people requiring chronic antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy. For this reason, use of an AED with mood-stabilizing properties has appeal and may be appropriate for selected individuals with mild
depressive symptoms. Undue fear of lowering seizure threshold should not preclude
the prescription of an antidepressant medication, as the perceived risks are often
overestimated and rarely outweigh the risk of leaving depression untreated. At
present, the best evidence for efficacy and safety support the use of citalopram,
sertraline, or mirtazapine as initial pharmacotherapy, whereas bupropion should
be avoided. Start low, go slow, and use the lowest effective dose. Cognitive behavioral therapy is a valuable adjunct to antidepressant therapy in this population. For
people with refractory partial epilepsy and refractory depression, vagus nerve stimulation has some appeal, in that it may be beneficial for both conditions, but the
efficacy of vagus nerve stimulation in improving mood in patients with epilepsy
remains unclear.
372
Epilepsy
Introduction
Depression is increased in people with epilepsy, with a
lifetime prevalence of about 30% [1]. Patients with epilepsy are three times more likely to be prescribed an
antidepressant medication than the general population, and two times more likely to report suicidal
thoughts [1, 2]. Depression can be diagnosed at any
time during the course of epilepsy and may precede
the first seizure [3]. Multiple studies have demonstrated that depression has a greater negative impact on
health-related quality of life than seizure activity [4].
Furthermore, depression has been associated with
poorer seizure outcomes, increased rates of adverse
effects from antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), and increased
medical costs [4].
Despite the frequency and significance of depression
in persons with epilepsy, it remains underdiagnosed
and undertreated [4]. The causes of underrecognition
of depression in this population are multiple.
Though many will meet the full criteria for major depressive disorder as outlined in the DSM-IV, others
may have dysthymia, atypical features such as psychosis or irritability, or a waxing and waning of
mood that depends on seizure activity. Physicians,
patients, and family members may have difficulty
distinguishing depression from side effects of seizures or AEDs, or they may consider depressed mood
to be a natural consequence of psychosocial limitations imposed by uncontrolled epilepsy. The Neurologic Disorders Depression Inventory for Epilepsy
(NDDI-E), which has been validated as a screening
tool for major depression, avoids some of the confounding effects unique to this population, but few
neurologists use such screening tools as part of routine practice [5].
Even when depression is recognized, there may be
reluctance to treat. Expanding choices of antidepressant medication have increased therapeutic options
(Table 1), but also may have decreased the comfort
of treating neurologists, who may struggle to select
an appropriate antidepressant or may feel unfamiliar
with possible adverse effects. Fear of drug interactions
and exacerbation of seizure activity by the antidepressant medication are also potent barriers to care [4].
Lack of evidence-based guidelines or high-quality
studies specific to the epilepsy population further
add to confusion on best practice. To help guide
the neurologist or internist in managing depression
in patients with epilepsy, this article reviews the scientific evidence for management of depression, including not only conventional antidepressants but
also lifestyle factors, therapy-based interventions,
and surgical avenues.
Treatment
Diet and lifestyle
&
&
Noe et. al
373
&
II]. St. Johns wort has not been specifically evaluated in people with
epilepsy, and it carries some potential risk because induction of hepatic cytochrome P450 enzymes may alter serum AED levels [10,
Class IV]. St. Johns wort has also been reported to cause serotonin
syndrome when used in conjunction with serotonin reuptake
inhibitors [10, Class IV].
Serum folate levels have been negatively correlated with depression
scores in two case series of adults with epilepsy [11, 12; Class IV]. The
effect of folate supplementation on mood in the epilepsy population, however, has not been investigated beyond one report of positive outcome in four patients [13, Class IV].
Pharmacologic treatment
Antiepileptic drugs
&
374
Epilepsy
&
Traditional antidepressants
Evidence for efficacy: Unfortunately, few studies of the efficacy of conventional
antidepressants have focused on people with epilepsy. Khn et al. published a retrospective study of 75 adults with temporal lobe epilepsy and comorbid major
depression who were identified from an inpatient epilepsy service, comparing
outcomes for treatment with citalopram, mirtazapine, and reboxetine [19, Class
IV]. At 20 to 30 weeks, there was a 40% reduction in symptoms of depression, and
15% to 20% of patients overall were in remission. The dropout rate was about
10% in each group but was significantly greater for mirtazapine than for citalopram or reboxetine. No patients had worsening of seizure control. Kanner et al.
Noe et. al
375
examined the efficacy of sertraline in 97 adults with epilepsy and depressive disorder in a prospective, open-label study [20, Class III]. Sertraline was initiated at
25 to 50 mg per day and titrated as needed to 200 mg per day. At 1 year of followup, 54% of patients had complete resolution of symptoms. There have been two
small, open-label, prospective studies of citalopram in the epilepsy population.
The first, using flexible dosing in 43 patients with major depression, reported a
65% response rate (defined as a 50% reduction in depression rating scale score)
at 2 months [21, Class III]. The second examined low-dose citalopram (20 mg/d)
over 4 months for patients with at least mild depression and found improvement
in both depression score and improved seizure control [22, Class III]. An expert
consensus statement from the Epilepsy Foundation of America suggests initial
monotherapy with citalopram, escitalopram, venlafaxine, or mirtazapine; if that
therapy is ineffective, a transition to an alternative agent from this list as monotherapy is appropriate [4, Class IV]. Major depression that fails to respond to
two trials of an antidepressant or is associated with suicidal ideation is best referred to a psychiatrist.
&
376
Epilepsy
&
Surgery
Fluoxetine
Fluvoxamine
Sertraline
increased.
Adapted from Spina et al. [27].
Carbamazepine
Phenytoin
Carbamazepine
Lamotrigine
Noe et. al
377
trol in the VNS group. Therefore, the role of VNS in treating depression in epilepsy remains unclear.
&
&
&
Emerging therapies
&
&
378
Epilepsy
Disclosure
Conflicts of Interest: K. Noe: none; D. Locke: none; J. Sirven: Consulting fees from Novartis, honoraria from
UCB.
Of importance
Of major importance
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
Alper K, Schwartz KA, Kolts RL, Khan A. Seizure incidence in psychopharmacological clinical trials: an
analysis of Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
summary basis of approval reports. Biol Psychiatry.
2007;62:34554.
Johnston JA, Lineberry CG, Ascher JA, et al. A 102center prospective study of seizure in association
with bupropion. J Clin Psychiatry. 1991;52:4506.
Gross A, Devinsky O, Westbrook LE, Wharton AH,
Alper K. Psychotropic medication use in patients
with epilepsy: effect on seizure frequency. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2000;12:45864.
Spina E, Santoro V, DArrigo C. Clinically relevant
pharmacokinetic drug interactions with second-generation antidepressants: an update. Clin Ther.
2008;30:120627.
George MS, Rush AJ, Marangell LB, et al. A one-year
comparison of vagus nerve stimulation with treatment as usual for treatment resistant depression. Biol
Psychiatry. 2005;58:36473.
Rush JA, Marangell LB, Sackeim HA, et al. Vagus
nerve stimulation for treatment-resistant depression:
a randomized, controlled acute phase trial. Biol
Psychiatry. 2005;58:34754.
Harden CL, Pulver MC, Ravdin LD, et al. A pilot
study of mood in epilepsy patients treated with vagus
nerve stimulation. Epilepsy Behav. 2000;1:939.
Deckersbach T, Gershuny BS, Otto MW. Cognitive
behavioral therapy for depression. Applications and
outcome. Psychiatr Clin North Am. 2000;23:795
809.
Dobson KS. A meta-analysis of the efficacy of cognitive therapy for depression. J Consult Clin Psychol.
1989;57:4149.
Robinson LA, Berman JS, Neimeyer RA. Psychotherapy for the treatment of depression: a comprehensive
review of controlled outcome research. Psychol Bull.
1990;108:3049.
McLean PD, Hakstian AR. Relative endurance of
unipolar depression treatment effects: longitudinal
follow-up. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1990;58:4828.
Ramaratnam S, Baker GA, Goldstein LH. Psychological treatments for epilepsy. Cochrane Database Syst
Noe et. al
379