Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
NYISO
Market Operations
the cornerstone
of the NYISO
Market Operation
LBMP
Objectives to Understand:
Basics of Locational Based
Marginal Pricing (LBMP)
LBMP and Impact of Congestion
LBMP Specifics
Bid
s
s
r
e
f
f
O
Bid
s
s
r
e
f
f
O
Definitions - Simplified
Energy - A quantity of electricity that is bid,
produced, purchased, consumed, sold, or
transmitted over a period of time, and
measured or calculated in megawatt hours.
Load - Energy demands on the power grid.
Load Serving Entity (LSE) - An entity that
supplies Energy to retail customers.
Definitions - Simplified
Bus - A common connection of two or
more electric circuits within a station.
Transmission Line - Conductors for
transmitting electric power
Transmission Constraint - Limits on the
ability of the Transmission Grid to transmit
energy. Recognition of Transmission
Constraints is necessary to maintain
reliable operation of the Transmission
System.
Zone - Geographical areas reflecting the
Transmission Owners traditional service
territories and External Control Areas
Marginal Pricing
the cost to serve the next MW of load
Economic Dispatch:
1. Determine the least costly way of producing
electric energy to meet the load
2. The price of producing an additional MW in a
specific location in the grid is called the
Locational Based Marginal Price (LBMP).
3. The LBMP will be the same at all buses when:
West
2 Zones
Buffalo
Gen#1
MW
$/MWh
East
2 Buses, Buffalo &
Albany, connected by
a Transmission Line
Albany
Note the arrows,
Generators
supply energy
Gen#2
MW
$/MWh
Transmission Line
Load A
MW of
Load
Load B
Note the arrows,
Load withdraws
energy
MW of
Load
Gen#1
MW of Capacity
Offer
Price
$/MWh
Gen#1
MW of Capacity
MW selected to $/MWh
meet Load
Assumptions:
No Transmission Limits
West
East
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Step 1:
West
East
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
Albany
Gen#2
$25
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Total Load is 30 MW
West
Total Load
30 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Step 2:
West
Total Load
30 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Step 3:
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
30 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
30 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Step 4:
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
30 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Total Load is 30 MW
Gen #1 provides 30 MW
Total Load is met
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
30 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Total Load
30MW
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
30 MW
$25
10 MW
Load A
10 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
20 MW
100 MW
$45
20 MW
Load B
20 MW
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
30 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Step 6:
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
30 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
30 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Total Load
31MW
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
31 MW
$25
11 MW
Load A
11 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
20 MW
100 MW
$45
20 MW
Load B
20 MW
Total Load
31MW
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
31 MW
$25
10 MW
Load A
10 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
21 MW
100 MW
$45
21 MW
Load B
21 MW
West
Total Load
31MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
$25
100 MW
30 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
LBMP = $25/MW
West
Total Load
30MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
30 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
Total Load
30MW
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
30 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
LBMP (West) =
$25/MWh
LBMP (East) =
$25/MWh
Total Load
30MW
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
30 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
20 MW
West + East =
10 MW + 20MW =
Total Load = 30 MW
Generator #1
$25 < $45
Generator #1 can
serve the next MW
30 MW
$25/MWh
Example 2
LBMP with No Congestion
Assumptions:
No Transmission Constraints
West
East
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
Albany
Gen#2
$25
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
What is the Total Load?
1. 60 MW
2. 100 MW
3. 150 MW
4. 90 MW
West
East
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
West
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
West
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Albany
Gen#2
$25
100 MW
100 MW
60 MW
East
40 MW
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Albany
Gen#2
$25
100 MW
100 MW
60 MW
Load A
60 MW
East
40 MW
100 MW
$45
40 MW
Load B
90 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Albany
$25
100 MW
100 MW
60 MW
Load A
60 MW
40 MW
East
50 MW
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
50 MW
90 MW
Load B
90 MW
West
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
50 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
Total Load
151 MW
Buffalo
Albany
$25
100 MW
100 MW
61 MW
Load A
61 MW
39 MW
East
Gen#2
100 MW
51 MW
$45
51 MW
90 MW
Load B
90 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
Total Load
151 MW
Buffalo
Albany
$25
100 MW
100 MW
60 MW
Load A
60 MW
40 MW
East
Gen#2
100 MW
51 MW
$45
51 MW
91 MW
Load B
91 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Load A
60 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
50 MW
Load B
90 MW
West
Gen#1
100 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$25
$45
50 MW
100 MW
Load A
Load B
60 MW
90 MW
West + East =
60 MW + 90 MW =
Generator #2 can
serve the next MW
150 MW
Generator #2
$45/MWh
West
Gen#1
100 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
$25
100 MW
Load A
60 MW
LBMP (West) =
$45/MWh
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
50 MW
Load B
90 MW
LBMP (East) =
$45/MWh
West
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Load A
60 MW
Total Load
150 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
50 MW
Load B
90 MW
The last two examples showed the Marginal Pricing of LBMP and the
process of Economic Dispatch
All of these examples had no Transmission Constraints on the
Transmission Lines resulting in equal LBMPs for both buses.
In the real world transmission limits exist! Now we are going to add
Transmission Limits to the remaining examples.
Marginal Pricing
the cost to serve the next MW of load
Example 3
LBMP with
Transmission Limits
And No Congestion
Assumptions:
Transmission Constraint of 50 MW
No Transmission Losses
West
East
Buffalo
Albany
Gen #1 $25
100 MW
Gen #2 $30
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
West
Total Load
220 MW
Buffalo
East
Albany
Gen #1 $25
100 MW
Gen #2 $30
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
West
Total Load
220 MW
Buffalo
East
Albany
Gen #1 $25
100 MW
Gen #2 $30
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
$25
??? MW
Gen #2 $30
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
??? MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
$25
100 MW
Gen #2 $30
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Remaining
Load
120 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
$25
100 MW
Gen #2 $30
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Remaining
Load
120 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
??? MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
??? MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Remaining
Load
20 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Remaining
Load
20 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$25
100 MW
$40
??? MW
East
$30
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Gen #4
??? MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$25
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
$40
20 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Gen #4
20 MW
West
Total Load
220 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
$40
20 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$25
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
20 MW
40 MW
100 MW
20 MW
80 MW
80 MW
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
$40
Load A
$30
140 MW
Load B
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
$40
20 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Gen #4
20 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
$40
20 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
LBMP (West) =
$40/MWh
LBMP (East) =
$40/MWh
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
$40
20 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Gen #4
20 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
$40
20 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
Total Load
220 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Gen #4
20 MW
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$30
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
$40
20 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
80 MW
140 MW
West + East =
80 MW + 140 MW =
220 MW
Generator #4
$40/MWh
Total Load
220 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
100 MW
$25
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
20 MW
40 MW
100 MW
20 MW
80 MW
LBMP (West) =
$40/MWh
80 MW
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
$40
Load A
$30
140 MW
Load B
140 MW
LBMP (East) =
$40/MWh
Congestion .
A Characteristic of Transmission System
Occurs when the Transmission Limit is
reached
Locational-Based
at a specific location in the grid
Example 4
LBMP with Congestion
Assumptions:
Transmission Constraint of 50 MW
No Transmission Losses
West
East
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
Albany
Gen#2
$25
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
What is the Total Load?
1. 10 MW
2. 70 MW
3. 60 MW
4. 100 MW
Total Load
West
70 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
$25
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load is 70 MW
Total Load
West
70 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
70 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
70 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
70 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Gen#1
100 MW
70 MW
Buffalo
Albany
Gen#2
$25
70 MW
East
100 MW
$45
?? MW
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Gen#1
100 MW
70 MW
Buffalo
$25
70 MW
Albany
East
Gen#2
60 MW
100 MW
$45
70 MW
10 MW
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Gen#1
100 MW
70 MW
Buffalo
$25
70 MW
Albany
Limit
Exceeded
60 MW
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
70 MW
10 MW
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
?? MW
70 MW
Buffalo
Albany
East
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Gen#1
100 MW
70 MW
Buffalo
$25
60 MW
Albany
East
Gen#2
50 MW
100 MW
$45
60 MW
10 MW
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
60 MW
70 MW
Congestion
At Limit
50 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
60 MW
10 MW
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
70 MW
Albany
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
Congestion
At Limit
$25
60 MW
East
50 MW
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
60 MW
10 MW
Load A
10 MW
50 MW
Load B
60 MW
Total Load
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
60 MW
60 MW
10 MW
Load A
10 MW
70 MW
Congestion
At Limit
50 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
10 MW
10 MW
60 MW
Load B
60 MW
Total Load
West
70 MW
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
60 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
10 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
61 MW
61 MW
11 MW
Load A
11MW
71 MW
Congestion
At Limit
50 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
10 MW
10 MW
60 MW
Load B
60 MW
Total Load
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
60 MW
60 MW
10 MW
Load A
10 MW
71 MW
Congestion
At Limit
50 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
11 MW
11 MW
61 MW
Load B
61 MW
Total Load
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
60 MW
70 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
10 MW
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
Total Load
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
$25
60 MW
70 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$45
10 MW
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
LBMP (West) =
$25/MWh
LBMP (East) =
$45/MWh
Total Load
70 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen#1
100 MW
60 MW
East
Albany
Gen#2
100 MW
$25
10 MW
$45
Load A
Load B
10 MW
60 MW
LBMP (West) =
$25/MWh
LBMP (East) =
$45/MWh
West + East =
10 MW + 60 MW =
70 MW
Total Load = 70 MW
Meet Load without exceeding Transmission Limits
West
$25 for 60 MW
Gen #1
East
$45 for 10 MW
Gen #2
West
$25/MWh
East
$45/MWh
Example 5
LBMP with Congestion
Assumptions:
No Transmission Losses
West
East
Buffalo
Albany
Gen #1 $25
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
West
Total Load
270 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1 $25
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
??? MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
Gen #1
270 MW
?? MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Remaining
Load
170 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Remaining
Load
170 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
100 MW
??? MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
??? MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Remaining
Load
120 MW
West
Total Load
270 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Remaining
Load
120 MW
West
Total Load
270 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #4 $40
100 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total
Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Gen #4
?? MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
100 MW
$40
100 MW
20 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
?? MW
100 MW
Load A
East
20 MW
50 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
180 MW
50 MW
100 MW
100 MW
100 MW
20 MW
50 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
$40
Load A
$30
20 MW
20 MW
Limit
Exceeded
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
100 MW
??? MW
$40
?? MW
Load A
20 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
100 MW
East
20 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
240 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
150 MW
50 MW
70 MW
70 MW
20 MW
50 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
$40
Load A
$30
200 MW
20 MW
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
240 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
100 MW
70 MW
#4
Gen
100 MW
East
Albany
Congestion
At
150Limit
MW
Gen #2
50 MW
50 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
70 MW
20 MW
20 MW
50 MW
150 MW
$40
Load A
$30
200 MW
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
$40
70 MW
East
Albany
Congestion
At Limit
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #3 $50
100 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Gen #4
70 MW
Remaining
Load
50 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
70 MW
$30
$50
??? MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Gen #4
70 MW
Remaining
Load
50 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
70 MW
$30
$50
50 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Gen #4
70 MW
Gen #3
50 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
150 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
50 MW
50 MW
70 MW
50 MW
$40
20 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
50 MW
70 MW
Load A
$30
250 MW
20 MW
Congestion
At Limit
Load B
250 MW
West
Total Load
270 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
70 MW
$30
$50
50 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
West
Total Load
271 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
70 MW
$30
$50
50 MW
Load A
Load B
21 MW
250 MW
West
Total Load
271 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
$25
Gen #2
50 MW
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
70 MW
$30
$50
50 MW
Load A
Load B
21 MW
250 MW
Total Load
271 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
150 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
71 MW
$40
50 MW
50 MW
50 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
50 MW
71 MW
Load A
$30
21 MW
250 MW
21 MW
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
271 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
150 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
71 MW
$40
50 MW
50 MW
50 MW
21 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
50 MW
71 MW
Load A
$30
21 MW
250 MW
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
150 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
70 MW
$40
50 MW
50 MW
50 MW
20 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
50 MW
70 MW
Load A
$30
20 MW
250 MW
Load B
250 MW
West
Total Load
271 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
70 MW
$30
$50
50 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
251 MW
Total Load
271 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
50 MW
150 MW
50 MW
70 MW
51 MW
$40
20 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
51 MW
70 MW
Load A
$30
20 MW
Congestion
At Limit
251 MW
Load B
251 MW
Total Load
271 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
150 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
70 MW
50 MW
50 MW
51 MW Gen #3
100 MW
$40
20 MW
$50
51 MW
70 MW
Load A
$30
20 MW
251 MW
Load B
251 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
150 MW
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
East
100 MW
70 MW
$40
50 MW
50 MW
50 MW
20 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
50 MW
70 MW
Load A
$30
20 MW
250 MW
Load B
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
$40
70 MW
East
Albany
Congestion
At Limit
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
50 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
LBMP (West) =
$40/MWh
LBMP (East) =
$50/MWh
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
$40
70 MW
Albany
Congestion
At Limit
Gen #2
50 MW
$30
50 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$50
50 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
LBMP (West) =
$40/MWh
East
LBMP (East) =
$50/MWh
[$50/MWh-$40/MWh=$10/MWh]
West
Total Load
270 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
$30
$50
50 MW
70 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Gen #4
70 MW
Gen #3
50 MW
West
Total Load
270 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
$25
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
$30
$50
50 MW
70 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
Total Load
270 MW
Gen #1
100 MW
Gen #2
50 MW
Gen #4
70 MW
Gen #3
50 MW
Total Load
270 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #2
50 MW
$25
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
$30
$50
50 MW
70 MW
Load A
Load B
20 MW
250 MW
West + East =
20 MW + 250 MW =
270 MW
Meet Load without
exceeding
Transmission
Limits ..
West
Gen #4
East
Gen #3
West
$40/MWh
East
$50/MWh
Example 6
LBMP with Congestion
Assumptions:
No Transmission Losses
West
East
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Albany
$55
Gen #4
$75
100 MW
Gen #2
$50
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
Gen #3
$40
100 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
Load A
40 MW
Load B
270 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
$55
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #2
100 MW $50
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
Gen #3
100 MW $40
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
Load A
40 MW
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
$55
Gen #2
$50
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
?? MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
Gen #3 is selected for:
150 MW
50 MW
100 MW
40 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
$75
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
$55
Gen #2
100 MW $50
Gen #3
100 MW
100 MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Remaining
Load
210 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
$55
Gen #2
100 MW $50
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Remaining
Load
210 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Select the next generator that is the most
economic (cheapest)
Gen #1
Gen #2
Gen #4
Gen #5
Gen #6
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
$55
Gen #2
100 MW $50
Gen #3
100 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
Gen #5 is selected for:
1. 150 MW
2. 50 MW
3. 100 MW
4. 40 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
?? MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
$55
Gen #2
100 MW $50
#3
Gen
100 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Remaining
Load
160 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Gen #5 is selected for 50 MW
Still need to select generation to
meet the remaining load of 160 MW.
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
$55
Gen #2
100 MW $50
Gen #3
100 MW
100 MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$45
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Remaining
Load
East
160 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100 MW
$55
$50
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
50 MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$45
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
$55
100MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$50
100MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
50 MW
$45
$60
40MW
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
100 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100 MW
Albany
Limit
Exceeded
$55
East
Gen #4
100 MW $75
100MW
160 MW
$50
100MW
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
$60
40MW
Load B
270 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
??? MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100 MW
$55
$50
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
50 MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$45
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
90MW
$50
100MW
150MW
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Albany
Congestion
At Limit
$55
East
$60
40MW
Load A
40 MW
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Remaining Load
70 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
$55
Gen #5
50 MW
$50
$45
50 MW
#3
Gen
100 MW
East
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Remaining Load
70 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100MW
150MW
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Albany
Congestion
At Limit
$55
East
$60
40MW
Load A
40 MW
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Remaining Load
70 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW $75
$55
90MW
150MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$50
100MW
50MW
100 MW
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
40MW
Load A
40 MW
$45
$60
200MW
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Remaining Load
70 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Albany
$55
150MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Remaining Load
70 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Albany
$55
150MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
?? MW
Load A
40 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Gen #6
?? MW
Remaining Load
70 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Albany
$55
150MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$50
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
50 MW
Load A
40 MW
Total Load
Gen #4
100 MW $75
Gen #5
50 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
$60
Load B
270 MW
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
Remaining Load
20 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
150MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$50
$75
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
50 MW
Load A
40 MW
Total Load
20 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
$60
Load B
270 MW
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
Remaining Load
20 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
?? MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$50
$75
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
100 MW
50 MW
Load A
40 MW
Total Load
20 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
310 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
Gen #4
20 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Based on the Generators and MWs
selected, how many MWs will cross
the Buffalo/Albany Line?
1. 100 MW
2. 150 MW
3. 180 MW
4. 160 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
90MW
150MW
20 MW
20MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
Total Load
50MW
40MW
50MW
270MW
Gen #5
50 MW
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
Gen #2
90 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
Gen #4
20 MW
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
310 MW
Gen #3
$75
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$55
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
20 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
50 MW
Load B
270 MW
West
Total Load
311 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$55
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$75
20 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
Load A
41 MW
If Load in the West increases by one MW .
$60
Load B
270 MW
West
Total Load
311 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$55
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$75
20 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
41 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
50 MW
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
311 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
91 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
91MW
150MW
20 MW
20MW
$50
100MW
50MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
41 MW
41MW
50MW
270MW
$75
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
311 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
91MW
150MW
20 MW
20MW
$50
91 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100MW
50MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
41 MW
41MW
$75
50MW
270MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
50 MW
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
90MW
150MW
20 MW
20MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100MW
50MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
41MW
$75
50MW
270MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
50 MW
Load B
270 MW
West
Total Load
311 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
$55
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
20 MW
$50
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
Load A
40 MW
If Load in the East increases by one MW .
$60
Load B
271 MW
West
Total Load
311 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
$55
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
20 MW
$50
$45
50 MW
#3
Gen
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
Which generator (most economic) can provide the
additional MW of Load in the East?
East
Gen #1
Gen #2
Gen #3
Gen #4
Gen #5
Gen #6
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
271 MW
Total Load
311MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
90MW
150MW
21 MW
21MW
$50
100MW
50MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
40MW
50MW
271MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
271 MW
Total Load
311 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
90 MW
150MW
21 MW
21MW
$50
100MW
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
40MW
50MW
271MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
271 MW
Total Load
310MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
90 MW
150MW
20 MW
20 MW
$50
100MW
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
40MW
50MW
271MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$55
100 MW
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
20 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
$40
Load A
40 MW
LBMP (West) =
$50/MWh
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
LBMP (East) =
$75/MWh
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$55
$50
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
#3
100 MW
Albany
20 MW
90 MW
Gen
100 MW
East
$40
Load A
40 MW
LBMP (West) =
$50/MWh
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
LBMP (East) =
$75/MWh
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$55
$50
Gen #4
100 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
#3
100 MW
Albany
20 MW
90 MW
Gen
100 MW
East
$40
Load A
40 MW
LBMP (West) =
$50/MWh
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
LBMP (East) =
$75/MWh
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
$55
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$75
20 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
East
Gen #5
50 MW
$45
50 MW
$40
100 MW
Load A
40 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$60
50 MW
Load B
270 MW
West
Total Load
310 MW
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
90 MW
$55
100 MW
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
20 MW
$50
Gen #5
50 MW
$75
$45
50 MW
#3
Gen
100 MW
East
$40
Load A
40 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
50 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
Total Load
310 MW
West
Buffalo
Gen #1
100MW
Gen #2
100 MW
Albany
Gen #4
100 MW
$55
20 MW
Gen #5
50 MW
$50
90 MW
Gen #3
100 MW
100 MW
East
$75
$45
50 MW
Gen #6
50 MW
$40
50 MW
Load A
40 MW
$60
Load B
270 MW
West + East =
40 MW + 270 MW =
West
East
Determine the Cost of serving the
Next MW of Load.
310 MW
Meet Load without
exceeding
Transmission
Limits ..
Gen #2
Gen #6
Gen #4
West
$50/MWh
East
$75/MWh
Recognize:
To maintain an efficient and reliable
Transmission System a departure from
economic dispatch may be necessary to
ensure Transmission Limits are not
exceeded.
Congestion occurs when the transmission
limit is reached
Congestion results in unequal LBMPs at
different locations.
(1) Energy
LBMP
Locational
Based
Marginal
Pricing
(2) Congestion
(3) Losses
(1) Energy:
Selecting the generation that is the most
economic (cheapest) to meet the Load
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
(2) Congestion:
Ensuring transmission limits are not exceeded.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
(3) Losses:
Accounting for the Generation lost.
(3) Losses:
Accounting for the Generation lost.
2 MW Lost
At $20/MW
100 MW
delivered.
Zonal LBMP is a
Load Weighted
Average for the
Zone.
NYCA Zones
A West
B Genesee
C Central
D North
E Mohawk Valley
F Capital
G Hudson Valley
H Millwood
I
Dunwoodie
4 External Zones
Hydro Quebec
PJM
IMO
NYCA Zones:
11 Internal
4 External
Energy
Congestion
LBMP
Losses
the cornerstone
of the NYISO
Market Operation