Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1
2
3
4
4
5
5
6
7
Professional context
Professional organisations
Other courses in the Conservation of Easel Paintings
8
8-10
11
11-12
22-23
24-26
27-28
29-31
32-35
36
37
37-38
38
39
40
41
42-43
44-45
46
47
48-49
50
51
52-55
56-60
61-62
62
63
64
65-66
67-68
69-70
71
72-75
SECURITY
Because it houses paintings, the Department has restricted access by means of
security entrance cards. The security cards are precious and if by chance you lose
yours it should be reported IMMEDIATELY to a member of staff or to Security
(Ext. 2531).
If you need a new security card you should complete the request form available on the
Student Intranet/VLE/at Student Services. The replacement card will cost 10 and will
not be ready to collect from the Student Services Centre in less than 3 to 5 working
days. If more information is required, email Karen Frost, Academic Registry.
You may enter the Department from 9.00 a.m. when the burglar alarms are
switched off, and stay until 7.00 p.m. After 7.00 p.m. the security staff will ask you to
leave. You may not enter the Department outside these hours, nor at week-ends. Only
in special circumstances may permission be granted for a student to come in at weekends, but this must be prearranged with a member of staff, and the security office must
be notified in advance. This is an essential rule to safeguard the staffs general
responsibility for your work on paintings, the security of the premises and the
insurance of paintings on the premises. Studio hours, when staff will generally be
available to supervise practical work, are between 9.30 a.m. and 5.30 p.m.
Please respect the Department's security. If there is someone you do not recognise
in the Department, ask them who they are or if you can help them, or tell a
member of staff. Make sure doors are never left open unnecessarily. You are also
strongly advised to keep your personal valuables in a locked locker (lockers are
available in the Department).
Luciana Akerlund
Amy Griffin
Chloe Head
Alysia Sawicka
Maureen Cross
Douglas MacLennan
Fiona Rutka
Claire Shepherd
Elisabeth Reissner
Judith Lee
Cleo Nisse
Alison Stock
Pearl OSullivan
Roxy Sperber
Christina Young
Anna Cooper
Olympia Diamond
Sarah Freeman
Kristina Mandy
If you feel unhappy, for any reason, or would simply like to change your Personal and
Academic Tutor who has been assigned to you, please just say so, and the change will
be made without further discussion.
DEPARTMENT LIBRARY
The Department Library is shared with the Department of Wall Paintings, and it is a
wonderful and often idiosyncratic resource.
As the library is located outside the Main Library, its viability depends on you.
That means being very responsible about recording loans and returning books.
A Student Assistant (part time) will be responsible for C&T library enquiries and reshelving. She/he will be responsible for supplying keys to the project cupboards and
updating the card index. The name of the Student Assistant will be given at the start of
the academic year.
Books:
All books, except those marked with an asterisk by the class mark, may be borrowed
on short term loan. Books that are not for loan are books that are either irreplaceable
unusually heavily used or exceptionally expensive.
The books are grouped on the shelves according to subject area, and then in
alphabetical order. Books on scientific topics are on the shelves in the Microscopy
Room.
The books belonging to the Department of Conservation and Technology are
catalogued in the Main Library, but are also recorded in the red card index boxes,
arranged alphabetically by author. The index cards will tell you in which category the
book is to be found and whereabouts it should be on the shelves. The books
themselves have a white label on the spine which will tell you the subject area to which
they belong and the authors name. The card index is regularly updated by the
Department Student Assistant and if you have problems finding a book she should be
able to help. The Department of Wall Paintings catalogue their own books and they
have a complete list on computer.
If you take a book out of the library, whether it belongs to the Technology
Department or the Wall Paintings Department, please record the loan in the red
notebook provided
When you bring the book back please leave it on the chest of drawers in front of
the fireplace, so that the Student Assistant can check it back in. Be sure to cross your
name off in the loans list book.
Periodicals:
A complete list of periodicals held in the Department is to be found in the black
looseleaf folder on the chest of drawers in the fireplace. The latest issues of
periodicals will be found in the book stands close to the entrance to the Library. Back
issues are shelved, in alphabetical order, on the shelves to the left of the fireplace or in
the Library corridor, adjacent to the Microscopy Room.
Periodicals may not be removed from the library.
We subscribe to an unusually large number of periodicals and new ones are made
available to you immediately they arrive, so that we can all keep ourselves up-to-date
with the latest work. Obviously if copies are removed this is not possible. If unbound
4
copies are removed they are easily lost and binding can be delayed. If bound volumes
are not returned they are irreplaceable. Often periodicals are required for quick
reference, for double-checking, for inspiration and so on. Please ensure that this is
possible for everyone by putting them back in their place and leaving them in the
Library.
Student Projects:
One of the most valuable resources in the Department Library is a complete set of
Third Year student research projects, dating back to 1976, which are kept in the
Department Library. A complete list of the projects is to be found in the Library in the
black looseleaf folder, together with the list of periodicals. Each project is numbered or
has been designated with a letter of the alphabet. The projects are kept in the Library,
under lock and key, in the grey steel cupboards. If you wish to refer to one of the
projects you will need to complete an application form (copies are in the plastic
folder on the cupboard door) and apply to the Student Assistant or another
member of staff. When you have finished with the project, you should hand it back
to The Student Assistant.
Projects may not be photocopied. This rule is enforced to protect the author.
Student Projects may not, under any circumstances, be removed from the
library.
PROFESSIONAL CONTEXT
The Postgraduate Diploma course is a professional and vocational education and
there are a number of aspects of the course and events that aim to develop your
understanding of the contemporary and historical context of conservation and
the diversity of conservation practice. This section is intended to draw your
attention to them as, unlike most of the teaching, they will be dispersed throughout
your time here rather than organised in blocks.
The Department is the Conservation Department for The Courtauld Gallery and
Graeme Barraclough the Gallery Paintings Conservator works in the Third Year
Studio. In the First and Second Years some meetings with Graeme are scheduled in
order to introduce to you to collections care and the particular concerns for paintings in
our collection.
In the Second Year there will be a range of Studio Visits to conservation departments
in national museums and a variety of conservation studios in the independent sector.
At present the interchange of employment between the public and private sectors is
increasing. These visits will give you an understanding of the professional structure
and variety of approaches to conservation in England.
In the Second and Third Years the Study Trips to a centre of excellence will provide
an opportunity to visit conservation studios abroad, to understand different national
approaches to conservation and display and, among other things, to compare the
structure of the profession, professional education and approaches to the broad span
of conservation practice in other countries.
Professional organisations
When you graduate from the Postgraduate Diploma course you will be equipped to
become an active member of the conservation profession and work towards
accreditation. The following is a list of the various U.K. and international professional
bodies that you will come across and may wish to consider joining. All have regular
publications, meetings and conferences. Newsletters and conference information are
all on display in the Library. The staff are active members and contributors to these
organisations and conferences.
The Institute of Conservation (ICON)
3rd Floor, Downstream Building,
1 London Bridge, London SE1 9BG.
Tel:
Email:
Website:
icom.membership@ncs.org.uk
http://www.icom.museum
ICOMs headquarters is in Paris. ICOM has introduced student membership for those
studying full-time on a museum or museum-related course. An application form and
further details can be found on the website. The Committees and Working Groups of
ICOM each publish a Newsletter and may organise interim meetings. ICOM organises
triennial international conferences and embraces all aspects of conservation.
10
11
12
13
Students joining the course who have a background in one of the sciences will follow
an art history course based on the course for the B.A. art historians. Students with a
background in art history or fine art will follow a basic science course taught in the
Department one morning per week.
Conservation practice, both interventive and preventive, is the focus of your time
here. Whenever possible, scheduled classes are directly related to practical work, and
at all times the critical understanding and refinement of conservation practice on
paintings is their objective. The first few weeks will be devoted to making replicas of
historical painting techniques and introducing you to collections care, preventive
conservation, and the history of painting materials and techniques through a series of
lectures; after that you will begin working on actual paintings.
During the second term there will be a two week course taught by the Gallery paper
Conservator, Katharine Lockett, giving an overview of Paper Conservation.
The practical work in the studio is largely unstructured time. There will be Regular
Rounds (see page 63) twice a week, when some of the staff will look formally at what
you are doing, what you have achieved since the last Regular Round and what
problems you have encountered Appointments can then be made to discuss any
matter in greater depth. Outside these regular times you must feel free to find a
member of staff at any time if you need help or advice. The member of staff will
arrange an appointment to help you. We absolutely rely on you to do this.
We hope that you will work on as great a variety of paintings as possible during your
time here, but it will be impossible to do everything, and it is worth emphasising from
the beginning that it is very important to be alert to other activities within the
Department, especially the work of students in the years above. This is part of your
learning experience and it is quite normal to ask other people what they are doing and
why they are doing it. (It is good for them, too, to have to describe what theyre doing
in clear and concise terms!) This will be communicated more formally at regular
departmental Work in Progress meetings (see page 64)
Feedback
There is no continuous assessment and progression from year to year and award of
the Postgraduate Diploma depends on the examinations. During the course we
provide informal evaluation of your work in a variety of ways and on pages 61-62 you
will find two pages entitled Feedback: the formal structure. You will see that there are
many ways in which you will regularly hear how your work is progressing and there are
also opportunities provided for you to seek further guidance, support, explanation or
feedback.
We seek to maintain a flexible, non-competitive and positively cooperative
environment in the Department. We believe that this is beneficial from an educational
viewpoint and because teamwork is also a useful professional skill. One of the ways
we try to encourage this is by avoiding the usual numerical or notational systems of
marking. Ultimately, the Postgraduate Diploma is 'Pass' or 'Fail'. A consequence is that
you will have to listen carefully to the staff comments about written work or
conservation practice. There is, for example, normally some 'feedback' during a
Regular Round and it may sound like "you seem to be approaching that very well ....
that was a good choice". Quite often these comments are not received in the same
way as a percentage mark and, even if they are, it is still very common to feel
uncertain at times. Normally, a meeting with your Personal and Academic Tutor will be
useful at this point, and we expect that you will do this, not just at the regular meeting,
14
but at any time during the term. It is very important that uncertainty or anxiety
should not be left unattended to.
In direct response to student comments we have been developing the nature of Work
in Progress' meetings and providing written feedback that is also discussed with you
individually by your Personal and Academic Tutor. This informal evaluation is to guide
your development and progress.
Written feedback is also provided on written seminar papers, documentation and the
end of year viva voce assessments, summarising the examiners' observations and
comments.
Finally, it is worth saying that this is a two way process, tutors appreciate your
feedback as well!
15
STUDIO PRACTICE
Students from each year of intake are based in their own studio. It is each years
responsibility to keep their studio safe, clean and tidy.
It can be difficult working very close to other people in a shared space, but some
problems can be minimised if you are tidy and sensitive to others. Please ensure that
personal belongings (not related to work) are kept in the grey lockers provided. Keys
will be given for the lockers at the beginning of the first term (5 deposit). Although we
are in an area supposedly with restricted access, there have been a number of thefts
of purses and personal stereos by people entering the department without authority, so
valuables should always be kept locked up, if possible.
Conservation is an intellectual, as well as a practical activity, and concentration is
always critical. For that reason there should be no tapes, personal stereos or
radios playing in the studio or being listened to through headphones. The
Institute is a mobile phone free zone. You may use a mobile on the landings within the
Department, but please avoid using it in the studio and keep your mobile on silent or
turned off.
Safe and considerate studio practice is a professional skill, so when working in
the studios, ensure that you have organised things in the best possible way, for
instance:
Are you exposing yourself and your colleagues to solvents or other
hazardous materials?
Can you use extraction, masks, and keep containers closed for more of the
time?
Is your equipment set up safely with regard to you, others and the painting?
o Is there a tripping hazard?
o If jars fall over are they going to spill near the painting?
o Is lighting too close to the painting?
o Are passing people likely to knock anything?
o Is your easel secure?
Are things safe to be left unattended?
o Is equipment switched off?
o Is it obvious where the painting is?
Do not use extension leads in the spray room when there are solvent
fumes; there is a hazard from sparks.
Work materials should be kept tidily on your trolley, and must be properly
labelled. Materials and equipment should be put away at the end of every day.
Solvent-containing materials must be stored in your tray, and put in the solvent
cupboards at the end of the day.
Glassware and other containers should be washed up and put away, and cupboards
and trolleys cleared of defunct pots of experimental varnishes, old solvent mixtures etc
regularly. NB. Unless jars are airtight (and the ones with the black lids are not), solvent
mixtures alter as the solvents evaporate, so they should not be kept for longer than a
few days. The method for washing jars containing residues of varnish is to leave
residues to dry, and then soak in Decon 90 overnight, after which time it should be
easy to wash them clean. Decon does not work on varnishes still wet with solvents.
Its up to you whether you have some sort of rota for washing up within your year.
16
NOTICES
There is a noticeboard in the Library where you will find job advertisements and
conference announcements. There is another noticeboard near the kitchen which is for
more informal, general messages.
KITCHEN
You may never eat or drink in the studios for health and safety reasons. There is a
kettle, fridge and microwave available for general use upstairs. Most people tend to
bring their lunch and we all enjoy celebrating birthdays together.
Please keep the sink and kitchen area clean and tidy. The cleaners are expected to
clean the sink and the surfaces, but they cannot do so if they are covered in dirty
crockery. It is the students' responsibility to wash-up and a rota can be set up to
ensure that this is done.
Seminar room 5 is used by the Institute as a whole and may be booked by other staff
when not used by Wall Painting Conservation or C&T. You are welcome to have tea
and coffee and eat your lunch in the Seminar Room 5 when it is not in use, but please
make sure that it is left clean and tidy when you leave. It is likely that it will be
needed for teaching immediately afterwards.
18
Ordering materials
If you notice that a particular material is needed, stocks are getting low or a piece of
equipment is broken or missing, please make a note of it on the whiteboard on the
landing between the Second and Third Year studios (please date and initial it) and
then tell the appropriate member of staff.
Maureen is the member of staff who has responsibility for the ordering and receiving of
general supplies, but other members of staff take responsibility for ordering the
following:
Photographic and x-ray consumables
Alison Stock
Christina Young
Books
Maureen Cross
Elisabeth Reissner
Equipment
Members of staff who are responsible for particular equipment and will respond to your
enquiries are:
Photography, photographic equipment
Christina Young
Alison Stock
Aviva Burnstock
Christina Young
Maureen Cross
In some cases emergency supplies of cheap items may be bought out of petty cash. If
you buy something, keep the receipt, it is needed to recover the cost. Petty cash
vouchers can be obtained from members of staff; they should be filled out and signed
by Aviva Burnstock you should then take it to the Finance Office to be reimbursed.
Expenditure over 25.00 must be pre-arranged and claimed using an Expenses Form
signed by Aviva and will be reimbursed directly into your bank account by the Finance
office. The Expenses Form can also be obtained on the Intranet.
Special purchases relating to conservation treatments
Sometimes special purchases are made for specific paintings in which case a
purchase order should be obtained from a member of staff and signed off by Aviva.
The costs may be passed on to the owner of the painting. NB. Costs of materials and
Purchase Order Numbers (SB/CTE) should be listed in the documentation
relating to the treatment.
19
20
21
22
23
INTELLECTUAL SKILLS
Developing confidence in the application of theoretical knowledge and
understanding to conservation practice is the key to the second year. About three
quarters of the time in the second year is directed towards conservation practice of
different types (individual paintings treatments in the studio, work on site,
environmental monitoring), and practice is interpreted to encompass intellectual skills
especially problem solving, decision making and planning, understanding the
context of the painting and the values it embodies.
Individual treatments are the opportunity to stimulate individual responsibility for the
identification of issues presented by paintings and the critical evaluation of evidence of
all types and its implications for interventive or preventive proposals.
24
By the end of the year students should have the confidence to begin to make informed
decisions and to undertake a range of treatments and work independently under
supervision.
Written and verbal reasoning is developed through discussion at Regular Rounds,
Work in Progress Meetings, Documentation and Seminar papers. Written informal
evaluation and tutorials may support studio discussion.
Seminar papers, as well as the issues presented by paintings undergoing treatment,
develop the ability to synthesise information from a wide range of sources and to
evaluate that information critically.
Visual intelligence and sensitivity in the interpretation of conservation problems is
developed through guided responsibility for diagnosis of condition and impact of
treatment on paintings, through discussion and through advanced understanding of
technical examination and analysis of materials and techniques.
The Environmental Survey Report provides an opportunity to work as a team to
monitor an environment, to critically interpret the data and to make appropriate
recommendations, applying the principles learnt in the first year to an actual situation.
Research skills are at the heart of our approach to teaching and in the second year
they are developed in seminars, seminar papers and presentations and through selfstudy in relation to individual paintings and treatments. Small numbers facilitate staff in
bringing contemporary research and practice into discussion and into the studio.
Knowledge and understanding of conservation materials is revised and developed
through seminars.
PRACTICAL SKILLS
Manual and visual skills are developed through the experience of conservation
practice of different types; these include individual treatments, witnessing first hand
a variety of work carried out in the Department, and projects outside the Department.
Development of written and spoken communication skills
Self-reliance, the capacity to work independently and constructively as a
member of a team, is developed through practical work of different types.
The practical work requires efficient management of time and resources.
Students will be introduced to the concept of establishing goals and estimating time for
the completion of treatments or stages of treatments during Regular Rounds from the
first year. In subsequent years, students will be asked to establish goals and to
estimate the time for completion of treatments and may make contracts with their
Personal and Academic Tutor, or another member of staff, for completion of the work,
to facilitate learning this aspect of professional practice and to achieve the goals set.
Students will also be expected to make a contract with their Personal and Academic
Tutor naming a date for the submission of their documentation prior to the
summative assessments which take place at the end of each year. They will be
expected to assemble their documentation of condition and treatment reports outside
studio hours (9.30 a.m. - 5.30 p.m.).
25
26
INTELLECTUAL SKILLS
The Third Year is characterised by increasingly complex problem solving,
decision-making and planning, and understanding of the context of the painting
and the values that it embodies. In the Third Year students are expected to reach a
standard where they are able to make self-directed independent assessment of a
painting and structure a treatment proposal that takes account of conservation
principles and context, and integrates the theoretical framework of knowledge with
conservation practice. The completion of treatments is the opportunity to demonstrate
visual intelligence and sensitivity.
The use of independent research to develop critical judgement and to situate this
in relation to knowledge and understanding in the field is important.
The Research Project (10,000 words, plus or minus 10%) carried out under
supervision is the principal means of developing independent research skills to an
advanced level. It provides an opportunity to develop specialist skills and expertise as
well as acquire transferable skills and to present work to a professional standard both
verbally and in writing.
27
PRACTICAL SKILLS
In contrast with the Second Year conservation practical work is focussed in the
Departments studios. Students should achieve a professional standard of safe,
informed and reflective practice and have experience of a range of treatments
(individual paintings treatments carried out; treatments witnessed first hand in the
Department or on visits; projects outside the Department including in situ work and
environmental monitoring). Students continue to develop their practical and visual skills
and increased emphasis is placed on taking responsibility for decision making and
planning. All treatments should be brought to a conclusion.
The need to prepare for the final assessment and to bring treatments to a conclusion
requires good management of competing priorities. Students will be expected to
establish goals and estimate time for the completion of treatments or stages of
treatment and may make contracts with their Personal and Academic Tutor, or another
member of staff, for completion of the work, to facilitate learning this aspect of
professional practice.
Students will also be expected to make a contract with their Personal and Academic
Tutors naming a date for the submission of their documentation prior to the
summative assessments at the end of the year. They will be expected to assemble
their documentation of condition and treatment reports outside studio hours (9.30 a.m.
- 5.30. p.m.).
Communication skills are brought to a high standard through verbal presentation of
treatments undertaken, written and photographic documentation and research.
Students are supported in identifying and capitalising on career opportunities.
Students are referred to the syllabus and timetable for Third Year
28
29
31
32
25% ACTIVITIES
The activities include a programme of lectures, visits, seminars and workshops that
deal in greater depth with topics introduced during the first year. Over the course of the
year, the student should assimilate the skills and ideas gained from these activities into
their studio based work.
There are seven main themes (these may vary from year to year):
1. Research Skills
Activities to enable the student to practice the skills of finding relevant information, and
critically evaluate it, from a variety of sources e.g. published papers, data sheets,
manufacturers, professional conservators, library databases, and the web.
Research Skills Seminar:
Each student will review a published research paper on a particular theme and
present the review at a seminar.
Materials Seminar:
Each student will present a seminar or a specific practical demonstration on a
topic of interest agreed by the year and tutors. This could be for example
historical technique, approaches to inpainting or varnishing.
The seminars are presented at a student led meeting and discussed with tutors
present.
2. Analysis
Lectures and seminars combined with practical studio or laboratory work and visits to a
range of both of scientific departments in National Museums and conservation
departments (national and independent). Visits to scientific departments are organised
to compliment the teaching and familiarise the students with the various analytical
techniques.
Typical visits include:
Kings College, London, Departments of Chemistry and Physics:
instrumental analytical equipment including SEM/EDX and sample preparation
procedures, microscopy, gas and liquid chromatography with mass
spectrometry GC-MS.
Birkbeck College, Department of Chemistry:
Conservation research using a range of analytical techniques, including thermal
analysis, FTIR and Dielectric.
Institute of Archaeology:
Conservation and research.
National Gallery Scientific Department:
Research into the materials and techniques of paintings in the National
Collections using techniques taught on the course.
Tate Scientific Department.
British Museum Scientific Department.
33
35
36
2.
3.
1.
The art history examination pass mark is 50%, in line with the Postgraduate
Diploma in the History of Art. Failure leads to a resit in September of the following
academic year. (See p. 46 below for further details).
The science examination pass mark is 50%. A mark of 47-50% leads to
Referral and additional work set, to be completed satisfactorily and handed in one
month after the end of the summer term. A mark of below 47% leads to an examination
resit in September. (See p. 46 below for further details).
2.
Poor performance in the Open Examination is judged to be when the candidate
fails to satisfy the dimensions assessed by the inability to access, order and evaluate
information. This leads to Referral and additional work set, to be completed
satisfactorily and handed in before the beginning of the autumn term. Failure is
assessed when the candidate fails to demonstrate any understanding of the framework
of knowledge that defines the scope of the subject or the fundamental principles, or the
intellectual skills. The Criteria for Assessment in the First Year are detailed in the
following section. Failure will result in the candidate being asked to leave the course if
there is no other evidence to balance against their performance in the examination.
(See p 47 below for further details).
37
3.
Practical work, including written and photographic documentation, is assessed
by two internal and one external marker, during a discussion in the studio in front of the
paintings (viva voce).
Students are expected to make a contract with their Personal and Academic Tutor
naming a date for the submission of their documentation prior to the assessments and
the external marker will have familiarised themselves with the students' work in
advance of the viva voce assessment.
The viva voce may, in special circumstances (e.g. the provision of medical evidence),
be undertaken again in September.
(See pp. 48-51 below for further details).
Attention is drawn to the fact that these are qualifying examinations and inadequate
performance normally indicates that the candidate is unlikely to be able to complete
the course satisfactorily.
38
2.
Research Project
1.
Practical work, including written and photographic documentation (which must
be submitted at least one week in advance of the examination) is assessed by two
internal and two external markers, during discussion in the studio in front of the
paintings.
The practical work requires efficient management of time and resources and students
will be expected to make a contract with their Personal and Academic Tutor naming a
date for the submission of their documentation at least one week prior to the
assessments.
It will not be possible to submit all practical work undertaken for discussion at the time
of the viva, but the examiners will be familiar with the range of work undertaken based
on their reading of the documentation and their studio visits and they will take this into
account. It is essential that at least three complete and finished treatments are
presented for examination; these will normally represent work mainly carried out during
the Third Year. (See pp. 48-51 below for further details).
2.
The Research Project is examined by one internal and one external marker.
(See pp 56-60 below for further details)
39
40
Practical skills:
Students should undertake and complete replicas of historical painting techniques and
one or two treatments of paintings as well as witnessing a variety of treatments in the
Department.
This work should demonstrate:
Core practical skills at a good standard
Clear and comprehensive written and photographic documentation
Ability to carry out technical examination of a painting
Understanding principles of environmental monitoring
Verbal communication skills (with staff and possibly owner/curator)
Safe and appropriate use of materials and equipment
Safe and considerate studio practice
Time management.
41
43
44
45
46
47
48
The "unseen" painting aims to test a fundamental professional skill and the ability to
think on your feet. While you are looking at the painting it may be useful to talk/think
through the structure of one of the standard examination forms. Do make good use of
lights, feel free to move the painting, read any labels on the back and generally behave
normally. The examiners will not have examined the painting in any detail prior to the
assessment.
Prior to assessment day there will be opportunities to practice the examination of an
"unseen" painting, but it is also important that you do not divorce this aspect of the
examination from everyday experience. During an in situ survey or when you receive a
new painting for treatment you will be putting into practice the same skills and
experience as you are required to demonstrate at the viva voce.
At the end of the viva voce the examiners will discuss their assessment of the
students work based on:
The students discussion of their work
The quality of work demonstrated in the paintings submitted
The documentation, written and photographic
Any additional background research (technical, scientific, historical)
Additional information about the students progress during the academic year (if
appropriate)
A student will be assessed as having passed the examination if he/she is able to meet
the criteria for each year and to fail if he/she is found unable to meet these
requirements.
Students are reminded that the criteria they are required to satisfy are clearly
identified on pages 40-45 of the Handbook.
49
5 minutes
10-15 minutes
The examiners will all have read your documentation for all the paintings you have
treated and may ask you about any aspect of it. All paintings being treated should be
present at the assessment.
The examiners will spend further time, apart from the 30 minute period, looking at the
quality of your practical work as demonstrated by the treatments you submit.
You are assessed according to the criteria described on pages 40-43 of the Handbook.
Third Year:
45 minutes is allowed for the candidate to discuss their work with the examiners.
10 minutes
10 minutes
15 minutes
Discussion
10 minutes
Unseen Painting
The examiners will all have read your documentation for all the paintings you have
worked on and may ask you about any aspect of it.
The examiners will spend further time, apart from the 45 minute period, looking at the
quality of your practical work as demonstrated by the three treatments you submit.
You are assessed according to the criteria described on pages 40-45 of the Handbook.
50
51
52
53
Negatives are stored in glassine pockets. On the front, you should fill in:
Painting number
Negative type (e.g. verso/recto, ordinary light)
Stage (e.g. Before treatment, or After varnish removal)
Your Initials
Date
Aperture (number) and exposure time
Printing details can also be added on the glassine pockets.
The filled glassine pockets should be placed in archival envelopes. Please use
separate envelopes for negatives taken in:
Ordinary light (in which case the envelope should be marked OAT),
UV Fluorescent light (FAT),
Infra-Red light (RAT),
and X-rays (XAT).
The Painting Number, Title, Artist and Owner in that order, should be put on the
outside of the envelope.
The negatives enclosed in each envelope should be listed on the outside, using lower
case letters to identify them (e.g. (a) Before treatment, recto)
A unique code can now be added for each negative in the top right hand corner of
each glassine pocket. This consists of the lighting code (OAT, FAT etc), painting
number, and the lower case letter.
Thus OAT 1755 (a) = painting no. 1755, taken in ordinary light, negative (a).
The envelopes should be left at the back of your conservation report.
X-radiographs
X-radiograph plates go into large brown envelopes, available on top of the X-ray filing
cabinets. On the top right hand corner of the envelope you should write the Painting
Number, Title, Artist and Owner in that order, and the date, exposure, and number of
plates.
Please remove every trace of self-adhesive tape from x-radiographs before finally
putting them away.
Normally x-radiographs should be photographed (b/w 5x4), or scanned. The test plate
should be filed with documentation remaining at the Courtauld Institute of Art.
Digital Images
Colour digital images should be of good resolution and colour corrected.
For documentation, save the images as JPEG format at 300 dpi. You may want to
save images at higher resolution (up to 720 dpi) and in TIFF format separately for
future use in presentations, publications or when you feel it is particularly useful and
relevant to the treatment. However, this is not necessary as the record of the painting
is the black and white (5 x 4) photograph.
54
Digital photography may be used for recording close up details of the work (in this case
use the dedicated departmental high resolution cameras only), on-site work, and
photography of treatments in progress. The digital images DO NOT take the place of
5 x 4 B&W for key stages of the treatment. All digital images should be colour
corrected (i.e. it should be the same colour as the real object). All digital images should
be in focus. Refer to the latest departmental Photographic and Imaging Handbook for
help with photography.
In each hard copy of a report, a maximum of ten sides of A4 of colour digital images is
suggested. Your IT account will be credited with enough money for 20 A4 pages of
colour printing per painting to cover the cost of colour printing for the CIA and owners
copies. Additional colour digital images should not be necessary, and can only be
included at your own cost. Do not embed images in the text. If you encounter a
problem then go to the IT department for help (to log a request follow links for the IT
helpdesk on the VLE).
CD Rom
The conservation report should be in Microsoft Word format. The CD Rom version of
the documentation should include all text and digital images (figures). One Read Only
CD Rom will be provided for each painting.
As well as a folder for the report itself, all images included in the report should
additionally be saved (as JPEGS and TIFFS only when relevant) to a separate
folder on the CD Rom (and labelled with the CIA number, captions, and Figure
numbers, corresponding to the report). This is so that the images can be easily
accessed in the future.
Additional images, including those of scanned photographs, may be included as a
separate folder on the CD Rom, named 'Additional images', with a word document
listing the images with captions.
Both the CD Rom and the protecting cover should be clearly labelled with the Painting
Number, Title, Artist, Name of student and Date
55
Introduction
The research project is an important part of the Postgraduate Diploma course and a
student must pass the assessment of their project in order to be awarded the Diploma.
The project is carried out in the first term (Michaelmas) of the final year and should
occupy substantially all of the students time in this period: the time allocated to the
project is thus 10 weeks. The student will have an internal supervisor, and sometimes
also an external supervisor if the project is undertaken with the collaboration of another
institution.
A typed written report on the project, of 10,000 words plus or minus 10%, must be
submitted by the deadline in the first week of the Spring term. Any material submitted
after this date will not be considered for assessment.
2.
56
These aims and objectives should be seen as forming the basis of both the
undertaking and assessment of the project; successful completion of the project would
be through demonstrated achievement of the aims and objectives.
3.
Supervision of Projects:
Assessment of Projects:
The project should be considered satisfactory and worthy of a pass if it has achieved
the aims stated above. More specifically, the student should have demonstrated most
of the following:
The ability to identify a research issue and to plan a research scheme to
address that issue, and the understanding of the relevance of the subject in
the context of a wider field of knowledge.
The formation of a deep knowledge in the subject
The ability to locate relevant reference material, to understand and assess
critically that material.
Logical, independent and creative thought.
Ability in generating, recording and interpreting information and/or ideas by
research.
Ability to draw convincing and appropriate conclusions from the research
results.
Ability to report the research investigation, results and conclusions clearly,
and concisely.
Examiners should consider also aspects of style and presentation; issues such as
organisation, accessibility, clarity, conciseness, use of figures, diagrams, or other
visual materials, etc. If these aspects are not satisfactory the project may be referred
back to the student for correction.
5.
Results
The project will be read and evaluated pass or fail by the supervisor (internal
marker) and by an external marker.
The external marker is asked to return their report and the project by 28th
February. After that the supervisor will provide verbal feedback and, with the
agreement of the external marker, a copy of their written report. The student
should arrange a feedback session with their supervisor within one month of
the return of the project.
The supervisor will advise the student as to whether they and the external
marker have recommended a pass or a fail for the project, or whether the
project is likely to be referred, but the final result is subject to ratification by
57
the Courtauld Institute of Art's Board of Examiners which will meet at the end
of June.
The final examination results will be formally posted on the Institute's
general notice board.
6. Amendments
If a project report contains a significant number of errors, misprints, etc. it will be
returned to the student who will be required to make amendments to their project
within one month of the date of the final Examiners Meeting (please note that such
students will have an asterisk next to their name on the Pass List). Students planning
to leave London at the finish of their studies should be aware of this possibility, and
should leave an address and telephone/fax number and e-mail address where they
can be contacted at the beginning of July.
Submission Procedure
Your Project must be handed in before the end of the day on the deadline (in the first
week of the Spring Term) to Student Services. Please check the Student Services
opening times.
2.
Length
The length of the project shall be 10,000 words, plus or minus 10%, excluding
footnotes, appendices and bibliography. Projects substantially shorter than this limit
may be penalised. In the case of a dissertation exceeding this limit, you will be asked
to rewrite it in order to reduce the word count.
3.
Number of Copies
One hard copy and one CD of your Research Project should be handed in on the
submission date. These will be retained by the Courtauld Institute of Art and will be
stored in the Department of Conservation and Technology Library. Further hard copies
or copies on CD may also be requested by External Supervisors or by any outside
institution which has cooperated with your research project. Should this be the case,
printing facilities or CDs will be supplied by the Department.
4.
58
Please ensure that you allow enough time to print and collate the contents of
the project, bearing in mind that extensions CANNOT be allowed for
computing/printing problems.
It is especially important not to assume that word-processing agencies will
meet deadlines of only a few days, even when promises are given, since
particularly difficult problems have been caused in this way in the past.
If you are planning to work on one of the computers in the Courtauld Institute
IT Centre you will be able to ask for help and advice there. If you are intending
to print your project report there and will be using software other than
Microsoft Word you are advised to check with IT staff about compatibility
issues well in advance of the deadline date.
5.
Digital Images
Format
A copy of your project on CD-ROM is also required. One Read Only CD Rom will
be provided for this purpose. Both the CD and the protecting cover should be clearly
labelled. DVDs are not accepted for the examined project.
The CD Rom version should contain two folders:
1. There should be one named folder for the main documentation. This should
be in PDF format and include:
All the text, together with any embedded digital images (figures)
Non-embedded images referred to in the printed version of the
document, in jpeg format at a resolution of 300dpi.
An index in Word format listing all images, including those not included
in the printed version of the document.
A 150 word abstract in Word format as a separate file.
2. Images not embedded in or referred to in the printed version of the
document should be placed in a second folder named Additional Images.
These images should be saved in jpeg format at a resolution of 300dpi.
You may provide an additional CD or DVD of images at higher resolutions in tiff format.
However, this will not be used as part of your assessment.
7. Plagiarism
You are reminded that all work submitted as part of the requirements for any
examination of the University of London must be your own, expressed in your own
words and incorporating your own ideas and judgements. Plagiarism - that is, the
presentation of another person's thoughts or words as though they were your own must be avoided. Direct quotations from the published or unpublished work of others
must always be clearly identified as such by being placed inside quotation marks, and
a full reference to their source must be provided in the proper form. Remember that a
series of short quotations from several different sources, if not clearly identified as
such, constitutes plagiarism just as much as does a single unacknowledged long
quotation from a single source. Equally, if you summarise another person's ideas or
judgements, you must refer to that person in your text, and include the work referred to
in your bibliography. Failure to observe these rules may result in an allegation of
cheating. You should therefore consult your tutor or course director if you are in any
doubt about what is permissible.
In addition, plagiarism is a breach of trust between students. You, therefore, have a
role in policing plagiarism by creating a culture in which plagiarism is not tolerated and
in the last resort by informing a member of staff.
60
61
6.
Evaluation forms.
At the introductory sessions at the beginning of the year, students are informed of the
extrapolated data from the evaluation forms that they have filled in, any action taken,
and the reasoning if action is deferred or the status quo is retained.
Written work
1.
Seminars:
Seminar presentations are discussed on the day and written comment is provided as
long as the written text is handed in promptly following the meeting.
2.
Research Projects:
There are regular weekly meetings with supervisor(s) for guidance and comment
during the project term. Initial, but informal comment and feedback is provided by the
internal marker (supervisor) soon after submission, but formal and complete feed-back
cannot be provided until receipt of the external markers report. The guidelines to
external markers include the request for such reports to be provided by the end of
February.
3.
Written and Photographic Documentation:
Students should submit a draft of their Examination and Treatment Reports and
Documentation to their Personal and Academic Tutor, on completion of that
treatment, for assessment and guidance. This should be done in time to consider and
make revisions before final submission for assessment at the end of the year.
Students will be expected to make a contract with their Personal and Academic Tutor
naming a date for the submission of their documentation and to assemble their
documentation of condition and treatment reports outside the studio hours of 9.30 a.m.
- 5.30 p.m.
Written and photographic documentation is examined at the end of the year by internal
and external examiners.
62
REGULAR ROUNDS
Regular Rounds are an important element of the teaching strategy and serve, in
an informal way, a number of functions.
On two mornings of every week, when practical work is in progress, members of staff
assemble and circulate in the studio, and discuss with individuals the painting or
paintings under treatment.
This ensures that the staff are all aware of the state of progress of that treatment and
of the nature of the problems to be addressed. It allows for an informal discussion, the
content and direction of which will be suggested by the nature of the current issues
and the degree of experience of the student.
In the first year, it provides an opportunity for discursive guidance, and an introduction
to the diagnostic and prognostic processes that might govern an informed approach to
the treatment, and the selection and application of appropriate materials.
It is also an opportunity for the student to express uncertainties or concerns, and to
make an appointment to address more fully and directly the particular problem
encountered.
In the second and third years, the student is, increasingly, expected to develop
independent treatment proposals and strategies, but still within a discursive format,
and all, of course, with the supportive and re-assuring elements experienced in the
First Year.
There is also an element of continuous oral feedback in the form of re-assurance
and encouragement. This is, in itself, positive. Your Personal and Academic Tutor is
always available if you need further or particular support. It is important that you feel
free to seek out a member of staff at any time that you feel you need advice,
instruction or guidance. If a Regular Round leaves you feeling uncertain then do not
hesitate to ask for further discussion.
63
64
Year:
Paintings Presented:
P Practical Skills
Quality and standard of practical work
Visual skills
Application of theory to practice
Independence/self reliance/ decision
making
Management of time and
resources/planning
C Communication
Photography and documentation
Verbal presentation
Intellectual Skills
Independent research skills
Critical judgement, insight, new ideas
Ability to synthesise information
Understanding of the context of
the painting and the values it embodies
P.T.O.
65
Date:
Particular strengths
This is a list of areas within which we expect you to develop. It is not a system
of marking, but it is intended to strengthen our ability to assess your work and
your awareness of that assessment. It may be referred to at the end of the year
when your work is reviewed. You are responsible for discussing any aspects
that you are uncertain about or disagree with your Personal and Academic
Tutor. Feedback is a two-way process.
Please fill in the box below to let us know your own comments and to draw our
attention to any specific needs you may have.
Student Comments
Signed:
Date:
66
Date:
Subject:
Research
Breadth and initiative.
Choice, range and relevance of material
to substantiate argument.
Originality.
Factual accuracy.
Critical skills
Identification of problem.
Critical use of evidence
in formulating an argument.
Scientific method;
development of independent position.
Critical visual skills;
development of independent observations.
P.T.O.
67
Argument
Grasp of issues.
Focus and clarity.
Originality.
Presentation
Demonstration or practical
examples.
Verbal or written presentation
(where appropriate
illustrations, bibliography, citations).
Organisation.
Use of resources
This feedback form is not a system of marking, but it is intended to strengthen our
ability to informally evaluate your work and your awareness of that evaluation. It may
be referred to at the end of the year, when your work is reviewed.
You are responsible for discussing any aspects that you are uncertain about or
disagree with your Tutor. Feedback is a two-way process.
68
Name :
Year:
Date:
Painting Treated:
Record of Treatment
Description of methods
Record of materials
Critical report of arguments leading to decisions
P.T.O.
69
Photographic Record
(Black and white/digital)
Student's Comments:
Signed:
Dated:
This feedback form is not a system of marking, but it is intended to strengthen our
ability to assess your work and your awareness of that assessment. It may be referred
to at the end of the year, when your work is reviewed. You are responsible for
discussing any aspects that you are uncertain about or disagree with your Tutor.
Feedback is a two-way process.
70
EVALUATION FORMS
71
clear
unclear
yes
no
very well
poorly
very well
poorly
coherent
incoherent
stimulating
routine
too much
too little
Please feel free to elaborate here on any of the above points or to make any general comments or
observations on the course as a whole, particularly with regard to any areas which were especially good
or which could do with reconsideration.
Particularly good aspects of the course:
72
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
good
poor
yes
no
WRITTEN WORK
too much
too little
yes
no
yes
no
73
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
(D) SCIENCE (For Arts students) (Please put a cross in the relevant box)
stimulating
routine
yes
no
good
poor
yes
no
too much
too little
74
(E) ART HISTORY (if applicable) (Please put a cross in the relevant box)
yes
no
stimulating
routine
yes
no
very good
poor
yes
no
too much
too little
75