Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
2. INTRODUCTION
13.UNICEF IN INDIA
15.SUPPORT UNICEF
16.UNICEF IN EMERGENCIES
17.CONCLUSION
INTRODUCTION
Child labor is one of the more harrowing aspects of 19th century history and
undoubtedly an emotive topic. To get employment reform acts passed as legislation,
reformers highlighted stories of the horrific treatment of children in mills and down
the mines.
Not all work is bad for children. Some social scientists point out that some kinds of
work may be completely unobjectionable — except for one thing about the work
that makes it exploitative. For instance, a child who delivers newspapers before
school might actually benefit from learning how to work, gaining responsibility,
and earn a bit of money. But what if the child is not paid? Then he or she is being
exploited. As UNICEF's 1997 State of the World's Children Report puts it,
"Children's work needs to be seen as happening along a continuum, with
destructive or exploitative work at one end and beneficial work - promoting or
enhancing children's development without interfering with their schooling,
recreation and rest - at the other. And between these two poles are vast areas of
work that need not negatively affect a child's development." Other social scientists
have slightly different ways of drawing the line between acceptable and
unacceptable work.
Children's participation in economic activity - that does not negatively affect their
health and development or interfere with education, can be positive. Work that does
not interfere with education (light work) is permitted from the age of 12 years under
the International Labor Organization (ILO) Convention 138. So child engaged in
part time work to learn practical skill linked to social or inherited custom or crafts
is not child labor. It becomes "child labor" only when child weaves carpet in a
factory or factory; earns money to support family without schooling, social
development. On the other hand if child works for 3-4 hours to learn or earn for
self or parents after schooling, would not be known as child labor as is additional
education and practical skill that a child learns.
CHILD LABOUR IN INDIA
Child Labour
A girl working in the reconstruction effort carries a tile on her head in the city of Choluteca, Honduras
An estimated 158 million children aged 5-14 are engaged in child labour - one in
six children in the world. Millions of
children are engaged in hazardous
situations or conditions, such as
working in mines, working with
chemicals and pesticides in agriculture
or working with dangerous machinery.
They are everywhere but invisible,
toiling as domestic servants in homes,
labouring behind the walls of
workshops, hidden from view in
plantations.
In Sub-Saharan Africa around one in three children are engaged in child
labour, representing 69 million children.
In South Asia, another 44 million are engaged in child labour.
The latest national estimates for this indicator are reported in Table 9 (Child
Protection) of UNICEF's annual publication The State of the World's
Children.
Children living in the poorest households and in rural areas are most likely to be
engaged in child labour. Those burdened with household chores are
overwhelmingly girls. Millions of girls who work as domestic servants are
especially vulnerable to exploitation and abuse.
Labour often interferes with children’s education. Ensuring that all children go to
school and that their education is of good quality are keys to
preventing child labour.
Child Labour in India
Millions of children in today's world undergo the worst forms of child labor which
includes Child Slavery, Child prostitution, Child Trafficking, Child Soldiers. In
modern era of material and technological advancement, children in almost every
country are being callously exploited. The official figure of child laborers world
wide is 13 million. But the actual number is much higher. Of the estimated 250
million children between the ages of 5 and 14 who are economically active, some
50 million to 60 million between the ages of 5 and 11 are engaged in intolerable
forms of labor. Among the 10 to 14year-old chil dren the working rate is 41.3
percent in Kenya, 31.4 percent in Senegal, 30.1 percent in Bangladesh, 25.8
percent in Nigeria, 24 percent in Turkey, 17.7 percent in Pakistan, 16.1 percent in
Brazil, 14.4 percent in India, 11.6 percent in China.
ILO estimated that 250 million children between 5 and 14 work for a living, and
over 50 million children under age twelve work in hazardous
circumstances. United Nations estimate that there were 20 million bonded child
laborers worldwide. Based on reliable estimates, at least 700,000 persons to 2
million, especially girls and children, are trafficked each year across international
borders. Research suggests that the age of the children involved is decreasing. Most
are poor children between the ages of 13 and 18, although there is evidence that
very young children even babies, are also caught up in this horrific trade. They
come from all parts of the world. Some one million children enter the se x trade,
exploited by people or circumstances. At any one time, more than 300,000 children
under 18 - girls and boys - are fighting as soldiers with government armed forces
and armed opposition groups in more than 30 countries worldwide. ILO estimates
that domestic work is the largest employment category of girls under age 16 in the
world.
India has the dubious distinction of being the nation with the largest number of
child laborers in the world. The child labors endure miserable and difficult lives.
They earn little and struggle to make enough to feed themselves and their families.
They do not go to school; more than half of them are unable to learn the barest
skills of literacy. Poverty is one of the main reasons behind this phenomenon. The
unrelenting poverty forces the parents to push their young children in all forms of
hazardous occupations. Child labor is a source of income for poor families. They
provide help in household enterprises or of household chores in order to free adult
household members for economic activity elsewhere. In some cases, the study found
that a child's income accounted for between 34 and 37 percent of the total
household income. In India the emergence of child labor is also because of
unsustainable systems of landholding in agricultural areas and caste system in the
rural areas. Bonded labour refers to the phenomenon of children working in
conditions of servitude in order to pay their debts. The debt that binds them to their
employer is incurred not by the children themselves but by their parent. The
creditors cum employers offer these loans to destitute parents in an effort to secure
the labor of these children. The arrangements between the parents and contracting
agents are usually informal and unwritten. The number of years required to pay off
such a loan is indeterminate. The lower castes such as dalits and tribal make them
vulnerable groups for exploitation.
Meanwhile, the Census data for 2001 suggest a much lower incidence, with 12.5
million child labourers identified, which would be less than 5 per cent of the
relevant age group. This represents a declining incidence compared with the 1991
figure of 6.4 per cent of the children between 5 and14 years.
There is of course a lot of debate about these figures. Because so much of child
labour is in informal activities, and is anyway a shadowy thing that very few
parents or employers want to admit to allowing, there is no way of being sure of the
accuracy of any calculations. The larger estimates (which are typically derived by
looking at the number of children who are out of school and who are therefore
assumed to be working) give a picture of an enormous national sweatshop, with
production growth based on the exploitation of children. But there are reasons to
be sceptical about the much larger estimates, even though it is certainly the case
that those children who have never attended school or have dropped out of school
are far more likely to be drawn into the work force.
Bangalore, October 6.
For obvious reasons, this is a highly emotive issue. It can and should generate
strong responses, but the high social tolerance of inequity and exclusion in India
has unfortunately meant that some of the
strongest responses have come from outside
the country. The international community
has become increasingly aware of some of
the more egregious practices of child labour
exploitation in certain export industries
such as carpet weaving, which have led to
calls for boycotts and sanctions on exports.
Domestically, the response has been to cry
foul and decry the protectionism inherent in
this approach, which somehow implies that
only the child labour in export industries
should be dealt with.
In actual fact, export industries account for
a very small proportion of the child labour
in India, and the worst conditions are not to
be found there but in other activities. In any
case, urban child labour is by all accounts a
very small proportion of the total, well below 10 per cent. According to both official
data and most studies, nearly half the child labour in India is involved in
agriculture. Most of the rest is involved in informal and service sector activities or
in small home-based or cottage enterprises.
Ukhrul, Manipur, October 10.
This does not mean, of course, that such children are not
exploited or deprived of both their childhood and their future
prospects. But the preponderance of informal activities does
create real problems for dealing with this through policy and for
eliminating child labour. However, there are other areas where the
prevalence of child labour should be much easier to control and
yet where it continues to persist.
The most appalling form of this is in the continuing prevalence of
bonded child labour, which is completely illegal and yetpersists in
many regions and activities. There are certain industries that are
known to be heavily reliant on bonded child labour and certain
geographical locations that have become infamous for it as well.
The fireworks producers of Sivakasi in Tamil Nadu, the carpet
industry in Mirzapur in Uttar Pradesh, the glass bangle makers of
been Jaipur in Rajasthan, the brassware industry of Uttar Pradesh
and the gems industry of Mumbai have all been associated with
substantial use of child labour. Other activities thathave known to
use bonded child labour include knitwear- and matchstick-making
units, beedi-making, tea plantations and some cultivation
operations in cotton and sugarcane. Bonded and other child labour
is also frequently found in services, especially in tea shops and
truck shops, domestic service and commercial sex work.
But these laws have been singularly ineffective. They have rarely been even
monitored, much less enforced. A study by Human Rights Watch conducted over
1995 and 1996 in several States of India found that all of these laws were routinely
flouted, with absolutely no risk of any punishment to the offender ("The small hands
of slavery: Bonded child labour in India"; Human Rights Watch Asia, 1996). Many
other instances of blatant violation of the laws have been documented by Neera
Burra and Lakshmidhar Mishra.
3. This project would help in increasing the literacy level of the district.
4. This project would give employment to the rural educated youth especially girls
who would work as teachers at the centers.
Donations: You can adopt a child for as small an amount as Rs.500/- and see
him/her through a certificate from the National Institute of Open Schooling
(NIOS).
The project coordinator and field workers of AIF carried out regular meetings
with the parents, guardians and important persons of the community from time to
time. These meetings are very important for building enabling environment for
generating interest in education. It also helped us in the centers where there was
high dropout of the girls and reluctance and apathy of the parents towards our
project. AIF also organized film shows 'Meena ki Kahani' which deals with issues
concerning education for girls and gender issues in the target villages.
VISITORS TO THE RURAL SCHOOLS
Ms Tinku Khanna,Ms Janki and Mr Kalam from Aapne Aap Women International
an NGO working in Calcutta and Forbesganj visited Thakurganj and Chattargach
rural schools on 23rd December. The children welcomed them with a song and
displayed their learning skills. They were impressed with the progress of the
children especially the girls. The main objective of their visit was to replicate the
same programme in their intervention area. Azad India Foundation hosted Mr
Alvise Fabretto a volunteer from Italy. He visited all the rural schools. Sports Day
was celebrated at rural school at Pothia on 26th Janaury where 60 children
participated from the two villages. They presented a small cultural
programme.The winners were given prizes by Mrs Yuman Hussain and Mr Alvise
Fabretto. UNESCO and National Open School (Ministry of HRD) conducted
survey for the relevance and efficacy of Open Basic Education in 5 NGOs in India.
Rural Schools of Azad India Foundation were chosen from Bihar where an
independent agency carried out survey and interaction with 100 students in the
month of July. The final report is awaited.
Child Labour Prohibition
Child is said to be the father of man and a citizen of tomorrow. Child in some strata
of today’s society is being deprived of the opportunity to evolve into a fuller human
being of the future.
The employment of children under age 14 is inhuman as well as illegal. The
problem of child labour is inter-linked with various socio-economic conditions.
Poverty is considered its main cause, which leads to illiteracy, low productivity,
poor health and low life expectancy. Some of the industries that depend on child
labour are match and fireworks, bangle-making, beedi-making, power looms and
manufacturing processes using toxic metals and substances, such as lead, mercury,
manganese, chromium, cadmium, benzene, pesticides and asbestos. A certain
number of child labour is also found at brick kilns, handicrafts-making, silk and silk
products, soldering processes in electronics industries and on floriculture and
vegetable farms. Child labour is an evil that must be eliminated.
The Child Labour (Prohibition & Regulation) Act(External website that opens in a
new window), 1986 of India prohibits the employment of children below the age of
14 in factories, mines and in other forms of hazardous employment, and regulates
the working conditions of children in other employment. The Act also regulates the
working conditions of children in all other employment, which are not prohibited
under the child labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986.
Increasing attention is being paid to strengthening the enforcement machinery
related to child labour. Soon after the enactment of the comprehensive Child
Labour (Prohibition & Regulation) Act, 1986, the Government of India recognized
the need to protect child labour from exploitation and from being subjected to work
in hazardous conditions that endanger such children’s physical and mental
development, and the need to ensure the health and safety of children at the
workplace. It recognized that they should be protected from excessively long
working hours and from night work. Even work in non-hazardous occupations
should be regulated, and all working children should be provided with sufficient
weekly rest periods and holidays and then Government adopted a National Child
Labour Policy in 1987. The Policy focusses on areas known to have high
concentration of child labour and to adopt a project approach for identification,
withdrawal and rehabilitation of working children.
A toll-free helpline (1098) has been made operational from 10th October 2006 to
receive distress calls about employing children in the banned sectors, presently
working in the following 72 cities:
Agartala, Aurangabad, Chennai, Guwahati, Kanchipuram, Kozhikode, Nadia,
Pune, South 24 Paraganas, Varanasi, Shimla, Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Coimbatore,
Hyderabad, Kanyakumari, Kutch, Nagapattinam, Puri, Thiruvananthapuram,
Vijayawada, Ludhiana, Ahmednagar, Baroda, Cuddalore, Imphal, Karaikal,
Lucknow, Nagpur, Rourkela, Thirunelveli, Vishakhapatnam, Akola, Bhopal, Delhi,
Indore, Kochi, Mangalore, Nasik, Ranchi, Thrissur, Waynad, Allahabad,
Bhubaneshwar, East Midanapore Jammu, Kolkata, Madurai, New Jalpaiguri,
Salem, Tiruchirapalli, West Midnapore, Alwar, Chandigarh, Goa, Jaipur, Kollam,
Mumbai, Patna, Shillong, Udaipur, Agra, Amarawati, Cuddalore, Gorakhpur,
Kalyan, Kota, Murshidabad Port Blair, Sholapur, Ujjain and Gurgaon.
ELEMENTRY EDUCATION AND CHILD LABOUR IN INDIA
Elementary education and child labour are intimately linked. The mission of the
recent Global March Against Child Labour in which thousands of organizations in
almost 100countries participated acknowledges this clearly: 'to mobilise world-
wide efforts to protectand promote the rights of all children, especially the right to
receive a free, meaningfuleducation and to be free from economic exploitation and
from performing any work thatis likely to be damaging to the child's physical,
mental, spiritual, moral or social development'. The National Human Rights
Commission of India recently stated that child labourcan never be eradicated
unless compulsory primary education up to the age of 14 isimplemented.
A comparison between the states of Kerala and Uttar Pradesh in India for example
defiesthe claim that it is predominantly poverty that prevents the poor from sending
their children to school. In both states the proportion of people living below the
poverty line isaround 45%. Nevertheless Kerala has an average literacy rate of
90% whereas in Uttar Pradesh this figure is around 40%. In terms of average
income per capita Kerala is in themiddle range of Indian states, but it spends much
more on primary education.It is a well-established fact that children in India are
working on a large scale in the household, in family enterprises or in income-
earning activities outside the home. It ishowever not so well-established how many
children are working, how much time they
spend on that work and how much is the income thus earned or saved (by
allowingparents to earn income). Estimations of the number of working children
vary from 11 million to at least 90 million children. The former figure is from the
Census of 1991 while the latter is based on the official number of non-school
attending children. Unofficial estimates of the number of non-school going children
go up to 114 million.
It is usually assumed that (almost) all non-school going children are working a
major part of the day. But if one looks at the number of working children mentioned
by anti-childlabour organizations such as the South Asian Coalition on Child
Servitude (SACCS) - 55to 60 million - it shows that there is a large group of
children who are neither in schoolnor at work most of their time. This is
corroborated by a recent survey (the Public Reporton Basic Education -PROBE-
survey) in four of the poorest and most child-labour endemic states: Bihar, Uttar
Pradesh, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh. The surveyindicated that one third of the
children had not done any work during school hours on theday preceding the
survey. The same study showed that 18% of the out-of-school children worked more
than eight hours, while about half worked less than three hours.
The surprising figures about the relatively short time spend on either household
work or income-earning activities of most out-of-school children are supported by a
large number of other field-level investigations in different states of India (Kiran
Bhatty, Economic andPolitical Weekly, July 4, 1997). The author states that all
available studies indicate that domestic work is the most common and regular kind
of work. Especially girls spent onaverage twice to sometimes even three times as
much time working as boys, mostly on domestic duties. The studies he quotes
nevertheless indicate that especially young children up to 10 devote about 1 to 4
hours (the latter only in the agricultural peak season) on average to both domestic
and (other) productive work. For the older age group of 10 to14 years this
increases while 'it is only after the age of 15 that children begin to make substantial
contributions (Bhatty)'. If non-school participation would be largely driven by the
time devoted by children to household and income-earning activities one would
expect that drop-outs from primary school would increase with age as the time
devoted to these
activities is increasing. The opposite is the case. Most studies show that drop-outs
tends to be heavily concentrated in grades 1 and 2, which suggests other reasons
for dropping out than poverty and work.
He also points at the 'apathy of the people' but relates this to a 'fundamental lacuna
in our democracy: the failure to provide an organized means of putting pressure
and demanding change' as well as to the 'continued social and political
marginalization of large sections of the population, particularly of the poor'. Also
recent Nobel prize winner Amartya Sen writes in his book 'Economic Opportunity
Development and Social Opportunity' (1995)', co-authored by PROBE coordinator
Jean Dreze: 'The fact that the government was able to get away with so much
neglect in the field of primary education relates to the lack of political clout of the
illiterate masses'. There are however a number of cases where 'putting pressure and
demanding change' did have important effects on the provision of good primary
education, also for presently working children. We will come to them later.
Summing up: the fact that children work rather than go to school does not
necessarily mean that poverty or parental disinterest is to blame for their failure to
attend school. Looking at the evidence it is the other way around: children work or
remain idle becauseschool-going is not possible or very unattractive. Parents often
use the labour of their children after they have dropped out of school, for reasons
unconnected to poverty.
Bhatty calls it 'child labour as a default activity' and concludes that 'parents are
keen to educate their children provided they are assured of basic quality'.
Even in cases where poverty is a real constraint, it has been shown regularly - also
in the example of an NGO whose work will be described later - that parents are
willing to make sacrifices for the education of their children if a decent form of
primary education is offered. Incentive programmes like free midday-meals can
also be of help but are not a substitute for good primary education.
IT is not new for economies to use the productive labour of
children. The history of capitalism is replete with such instances,
especially in phases of rapid industrialisation. Dickensian stories of
cheap child labour being exploited by rapacious early
capitalists were some of the cultural staples of the Industrial
Revolution in England. More recently, child labour has been widely
associated with poverty and seen as a sign of backwardness.
Yet it is remarkably persistent and remains widespread in much of
the developing world, including in the booming parts of the
world economy. A 2003 survey by the International Labour
Organisation suggested that there are 246 million child labourers
(aged 14 years or less) in the world, and that as many as 180
million of them are engaged in hazardous activities that put them
at direct physical risk. While this may be an overestimate, it
should not be completely dismissed either.
Allahabad, October 12.
Within this, it is generally accepted that India has the largest
number of child labourers in the world. The United Nations
Children's Fund (UNICEF) estimates that there are more than 35
million such children, accounting for 14 per cent of the
children in the 5-14 age group. Other unofficial estimates are
much higher, ranging between 60 and 125 million child labourers.
Meanwhile, the Census data for 2001 suggest a much lower
incidence, with 12.5 million child labourers identified.
C
ause
sof
O
VERP
OPU
LAT
ION
m out
hstof
e ed
,Ch
ild
rena
re
f
o r
m sofwork
.
I
L L
ITE
RAC
Y
n
eedf
o rap
rope
r
d
eve
lop m
ento
fach
ild
.
P
OVE
RTY
ORPHANS: C hildren born out of wedlock, children with no
parents and relatives, often do not find anyone to support them.
Thus they are forced to work for their own living.
WILLINGNESS TO EXPLOIT CHILDREN : This is at
the root of the problem E ven if a family is very poor, the
incidence of child labour will be very low unless there are
people willing to exploitthese children.
UNEMPLOYMENT OF ELDERS
: E lders often find it
difficult to get jobs. The industrialists and factory owners find it
profitable to employ children. This is so because they can pay
less and extract more work. They will also not create union
problem.
Consequences
Children..
Physical injuries and
maintained machinery o
accidents in plantations,
encountered in industrie
fireworks manufacture
Long-term health
disease, asbestosis a
common in countries
work with dangerous
HI V/ AI DS and oth
diseases are rife amo
forced into prostituti
addiction and menta
among child prostitu
Exhaustion and m
underdeveloped child
labour, working long
L
National Policy on
Initiatives
formulated in towa1987
Child Labour
prohibition of child
hazardous occupati
Poverty being the m
decided to generate
The government has mad
supplementary
Child nuti
labor laws in India
and Regulation)
ups so as to
Government has according
pr
mainstream
problem throughschool
strict en
with simultaneous rehabili
T H E C H IL
(P r o h ib itio n
PENAL
S e c tio-3n sh a l
n o t b e less th a
w h ich sh a ll n o
UNICEF in India
Children are rem
resilient - bu
fragile
©
“ So let us
UN
IC
EF
In
di
a
A
sc
ho
And shap
ol
gir
l
pa
rti
cip
at
es
in
a
cla
ss.
UNICEF has been working in India since 1949. The largest UN organisation in
the country,UNICEF is fully committed to working with the
Government of India to ensure that each child born in this vast
and complex country gets the best start in life, thrives and
develops to his or her full potential.
The challenge is enormous but UNICEF is well placed to meet it.
The organisation uses quality research and data to understand
issues, implements new and innovative interventions that address
the situation of children, and works with partners to bring those
innovations to fruitition.
What makes UNICEF unique in India is its network of 13
state offices. These enable the organisation to focus
attention on the poorest and most disadvantaged
communities, alongside its work at the national level.
UNICEF uses its community-level knowledge to develop innovative
interventions to ensure that women and children are able to
access basic services such as clean water, health visitors and
educational facilities, and that these services are of high quality.
At the same time, UNICEF reaches out directly to families to help
them to understand what they must do to ensure their children
thrive.
UNICEF also wants them to feel a sense of ownership of these
services. That same knowledge and interface with communities
enables the organisation to tackle issues that would otherwise be
difficult to address: the complex factors that result in children
working, or the growing threat that HIV/AIDS poses to children.
UNICEF knows that key to addressing these challenges are its
partnerships with sister UN agencies, voluntary organisations
active at the community level, women’s groups and donors.
The organisation also works with an array of celebrities, including
members of the Indian cricket team and leading actors from the
Indian film industry, as well as hundreds of thousands of unnamed
volunteers who tirelessly give their time and influence to ensure
that, together, they are able to help every child realise his or her
full potential.
Celebrities Supporting UNICEF’s Work in India
The overall goal of the 2008-2012 Country Programme is to
advance the fulfilment of the rights of all women and children in
India to survival, development, participation and protection...
The Country Programme, 2008-2012
The overall goal of the 2008-2012 Country Programme is to
advance the fulfilment of the rights of all women and children in
India to survival, development, participation and protection...
Health
Despite improvements over last 30 years health challenges for
children in India remain. An increased effort is needed to ensure
the necessary reduction in maternal, infant and young child
mortality.
Nutrition
UNICEF supports the Government in its objectives to reduce and
prevent malnutrition and to improve the development of children
under three years old, especially those in marginalised groups.
Water, environment and sanitation
UNICEF supports the national and state governments in
developing and implementing a range of replicable models for
sanitation, hygiene and water supply.
HIV/AIDS
As a part of the joint UN response and within the context of
NACP-III, UNICEF collaborates with the Government of India
and other partners in four key programme areas we call the four
Ps.
Education
The number of children who are not in school remains high and
gender disparities in education persist despite a major
improvement in literacy rates during the 1990s.
Child protection
UNICEF India’s programmatic approach to child protection aims
to build a protective environment in which children can live and
develop in the full respect of their fundamental rights.
Bottom of Form
Support UNICEF
For around six decades UNICEF, along with the Government and
other partners, has worked in India to ensure that each child gets
the best start in life, thrives and develops his or her full potential."
Now the children need your help too.
Donate on-line now
Donate through SMS
Now the donors in India can also donate through SMS.
UNICEF in Emergencies
Over the last two decades, India has borne the brunt of several
major natural disasters including the Latur Earthquake in 1993;
the Orissa super-cyclone in October 1999, the Bhuj earthquake in
January 2001, the Tsunami in December 2004, the earthquake in
Jammu & Kashmir in October 2005, major flooding in Bihar, Uttar
Pradesh, Assam, Orissa, West Bengal and other states in 2007
and 2008, major avian flu outbreak in West Bengal and Kosi
floods in Bihar in 2008.
In 2009, the eastern Indian State of West Bengal was hit by
cyclone Aila which affected 6.8 million people and resulted in a
loss of 138 human lives. In addition, a number of relatively
smaller-scale emergencies, primarily floods, but also droughts,
landslides, cholera and avian flu outbreaks have occurred. Tens of
millions people are affected annually in India, most of them from
the poorest strata of the population, a high proportion of whom
are children.
CONCLUSION
Over all conclusion is that child labour in developing country is a very critical
position behind this lots of reason we mentioned on above report. so it’s a very
necessary that government and public both work on this issues.