Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ENGINEER IN
SOCIETY
ASSIGNMENT 1 :
Environmental Impact
of Bauxite Mining
Figure 1: Shows the Bauxite Mineral with characteristic red iron staining and pisolitic mineral
structure.
Al(OH)3. The aluminum hydroxide is then calcined to form alumina, Al2O3. Then the aluminum
is smelted from the alumina using the Hall-Heroult Process. In the Hall-Heroult Process, the
alumina is dissolved in a molten bath of cryolite (Na3AlF6). Now, the molten aluminum is
extracted from the solution by electrolysis. This process consumes an enormous amount of
electricity. Aluminum is usually produced where electricity costs are very low.
The various minerals found in Bauxite proved to be very useful in various applications.
Calcined alumina is a synthetic Corundum which is a very hard material. It has a scale of 9 on
the Mohs Hardness Scale which is very close to diamond. Calcined alumina is crushed, separated
by size, and used as abrasive in various applications such as aluminum oxide sandpaper,
polishing powders and polishing suspensions are made from calcined alumina.
Besides the Calcined alumina, sintered bauxite is often used in various industry as a sandblasting abrasive as it proved to be low cost and very effective. It is produced by crushing
bauxite minerals into a small powder forms and then fusing it into spherical beads at a very high
temperature. These beads have good hardness quality and proved to be very durable. The beads
are then sorted by their size for applications in different types of sandblasting equipment and for
different sandblasting applications. Besides that, their round shape reduces wear on the delivery
equipment as it exerts lower pressure on the equipment.
Sintered bauxite is commonly used and possibly the favourite of the oil and gas industry
as an oil field proppant. In off-shore oil field drilling applications, the reservoir rock is often
fractured by pumping fluids into the oil well under extremely high pressures. The pressure builds
up to a dangerously high levels and that causes the reservoir rocks to fracture. When fracturing
occurs, water and suspended particles known as "proppants" rush into the fractures and push
them open. When the pumps are turned off, the fractures close, trapping the proppant particles in
the reservoir. If an adequate number of crush-resistant particles remain in the reservoir, the
fractures will be "propped" open, allowing for a flow of oil or natural gas out of the rocks and
into the well. This process is known as hydraulic fracturing. Powdered bauxite can be used to
fused into tiny beads at very high temperatures. These beads have a very high crush resistance,
and that makes them suitable as a proppant. They can be produced in almost any size and in a
range of specific gravity. The specific gravity of the beads and their size can be matched to the
viscosity of the hydraulic fracturing fluid and to the size of fractures that are expected to develop
in the rock. Manufactured proppants provide a wide selection of grain size and specific gravity
compared to a natural proppant known as frac sand.
problem of limited increase of erosion and turbidity of the soil and the roads of around the
mining site. Besides that, there is also the disturbance of hydrology. Lastly there is pollution,
which leads to eutrophication of streams.
Fishery Pollution
The fishing industry will also be damaged due to the poisonous chemicals from the red sludge as
fish can subsequently be vanishing or even become extinct. According to researches carried out
by American and Italian scientists, red sludge can cause the genetic distortion of fish in the
ocean. The health and lives of the people living southeast of Saigon and its fish consumers can
be greatly affected as well.
Toxicity Affecting Human Lives
The red sludge puts health and human lives at risk of being lost or harmed due to air, water and
fish pollution. The medical statistics prove that prolonged toxicity may cause encephalopathy,
osteoporosis, anemia, and possibly Parkinson diseases. An Australian researcher in Australia
where bauxite mining is largely developed proved that red sludge causes lung cancer and uterus
deformation in rat experiments. The common symptoms of toxicity on humans are dizziness,
vertigo, nausea, fainting, or comatose if breathing or taking in a large dosage.
According to OSHA, the sodium hydroxide (NaOH) is the primary waste in red sludge and it is
harmful to human beings after prolonged contact, say 15 years. Direct contact may cause skin
irritation, or inflammation of the respiratory system such as blistering of the throat, mouth or
nose.
The Economic Effectiveness
The Economic effectiveness of bauxite mining depends on the density of aluminum. In general, 4
tons of bauxite yield an average of 2 tons of aluminum oxide and generate 4 tons of red mud in
order to produce 1 ton of pure (~99.6%) aluminum.
In order to produce 1.2 million tons of pure aluminum per annum, which is the ultimate goal as
spelled out by Vietnam, we can do a simple math and arrive at how large a surface is needed
annually for a dumping ground of red mud!
For comparison, 1 hectare of rubber tree plantation yields 1.5 tons of rubber which is equivalent
of US$4,500.00 as 2008 market price. Moreover, the land can be subsequently harvested for the
next 20 years.
In contrast, one ton of alumina costs only US $270.00 (2008 market price). In order to have the
same yield of rubber plantation, it needs to dig 35 tons of bauxite ore. However, the land after
exploitation cannot be reused but also generating 40 tons of toxic waste of red sludge and
polluted dust.
More specifically, the research inside Vietnam by Nguyen Dong Hai, Ph.D, Nguyen Thanh Son,
Ph.D, and Nguyen Ngoc was reported on the VietnamNet web site, shows that the total annual
income from Bauxite mining is only 1,450 billion Dong (Vietnamese piasters) versus 2,200
billion for rubber trees and 5,800 billion for coffee trees harvesting for the same amount of land
used to produce aluminum in the Highland of Dak Nong,
Hence, the ability to repay the debt for tree investment is 5 times faster than bauxite investment.
According to their calculation, it costs 3,000 billion Dong Vietnam for 4,000 hectares (equivalent
to 8,800 acres) of bauxite. However, the same amount of money can be used to invest in 35,000
hectares of rubber trees or 58,000 hectares of coffee trees.
In plus, bauxite exploitation is not tax advantages. It brings in about 30 billion Dong VN versus
701 billion Dong VN for rubber trees and 2,175 billion Dong VN for coffee trees.
In socio-economic standpoint, bauxite mining does not create more jobs to the area because the
Chinese labor force and heavy duty digging equipments are utilized.
It requires only 5 thousand laborers for the Dak Nong site (equivalent to 1.25 labors/hectare) as
compared to 170,000 laborers for rubber plantation and 590,000 laborers for coffee plantation.
The Social and Cultural Effects on the Ethnic Minorities
There are numerous ethnic groups (about 15) in the Central Highlands of Vietnam and they are
very sensitive to the invasion of the Vietnamese (called "Kinh," people from the Capital). Their
habitats and lands are getting smaller and smaller due to the encroachments of Vietnamese
migration into the area and the infusion of minorities coming from the North, deliberately
fostered by the government, which have brought a huge population increase, from an original 1.4
million to an estimated 4 million.
Of the original (native) 1.4 million, about 90% are ethnic highlanders. Now, their estimated
number is down to around 400,000. This decrease of their population is due to their retreating
deeper into the forest lands to the West and/or to the neighboring countries of Laos and
Cambodia.
According to plan, Vietnam is expected to develop 5 more locations in Dak Nong province
beside Nhan Co (area: 510 Km2) such as: Trung Duc (354 Km2), Dak Song (300 Km2), Gia
Nghia North (329 Km2), 1 Thang 5 (197 Km2), Quang Son (159 Km2). All planned areas of
bauxite exploitation would come to more than 1/3 of the surface of Dak Nong province.
Digging Bauxite in this area is a serious matter of concern to the people of Dak Nong because
with their agricultural land being invaded and further restricted starvation becomes a distinct
possibility. Migration (move to another area) and separation of families will become necessary
for survival, therefore, it will disturb its social structure and may damage family values due to
the Chinese occupation and cultural invasion.
IMPACTS OF BAUXITE MINING IN PAHANG
Noise pollution
Noise is an important consideration in the context of mining, and a factor that can potentially
have serious health impacts across a wide range of determinants. Noise pollution usually occurs
in three phases: access to the bauxite mining area, extraction of bauxite using heavy machinery
and movement of lorries from mining area to stockpile places. Some of the mining activities are
located very close to and within community settlement which make environmental pollution a
real concern to the community. If the problem persists, environmental noise has a great impact
on the health of the people. The potential health effects identified include hearing loss or loss of
hearing sensitivity, sleep disturbance, cardiovascular and physiological effects, mental health and
behavioural effects, cognitive performance including poor performance by school children
Water pollution and risk of mud flood
Water pollution was widely reported by mainstream and social media. The sources of water
pollution are mainly related to extensive land clearing, extraction of bauxite leading to soil
erosion and sedimentation; washing of bauxite and effluent from the bauxite washing pond water
were discharged into Sungai Taweh which flows downstream causing severe pollution to Sungai
Riau. Generally, bauxite contains mainly Aluminum oxide (4050%), ferric oxide (20%) and 3
5% combined silica. However, according to Rajah, bauxite in Kuantan is characterised by high
ferric oxide content ranging from 14.4 to 40.6% depending on the area. Because of its
composition, aluminum and iron are the main contaminants that pollute the water resources but
depending on the geological characteristics of the land and surrounding land use activities, other
toxic metals such as arsenic, mercury, cadmium, lead, nickel and manganese may also
contaminate drinking water resources when the natural ecosystem is aggressively removed and
excavated.
Chronic exposure to toxic metals may cause multiple organ toxicity and increase cancer risk.
Whereas, high level exposure to aluminum in the stomach prevent the absorption of phosphate, a
chemical compound required for healthy bones and may cause bone diseases in children. Chronic
exposure to aluminum was hypothesized to cause Alzheimer disease but scientific evidence to
date is inconsistent. Based on a continuous drinking water monitoring conducted by the
Department of Pahang State Health, so far the concentration of aluminum in treated water taken
from the affected water treatment plants were below the Provisional Tolerable Weekly Intake
(PWTI) of 0.9mg/l. The concentration of other heavy metals were also below the National
Drinking Water Quality Standard. Apparently the conventional treatment method used in these
water treatment plants is capable of managing the treat of heavy metals contaminations.
In Malaysia, the active bauxite mine is located in Gebeng, Pahang. However, the mine - while
strengthening the economy as well as serving as a lucrative source of income for many people is also causing intense suffering to the locals.
Bauxite mining has indeed caused pollution around Bukit Goh, Gebeng and the Kuantan Port.
For months, certain areas in the district - particularly Bukit Goh - have suffered serious air
pollution from bauxite dust and residue that were released by the processing plants or leaked
during transportation to the Kuantan Port.
This pollution has damaged the roads, the river and more recently, the bauxite residue has been
flowing out to the sea due to heavy rain showers . It was previously reported that local citizens
had been alarmed at the colour of the sea turning red.
Several fatal accidents were also caused by lorries transporting bauxite. These lorries caused
further traffic congestion as the drivers parked their lorries indiscriminately on the roads.
Additionally, the poorly regulated mining of bauxite could be just as severe, as the ecosystem
may never recover from this. Such irresponsible practices has caused adverse health effects to the
people who live near the mining sites, too. Natural bauxite ore consists of aluminum hydroxide,
iron oxide, titanium oxide and reactive silica - the substances of which affect human health.
Aluminum hydroxide is the main content of the bauxite ore, which is 32-52 percent. Excessive
exposure of aluminum hydroxide could be detrimental to health as pain and reddening of the
nose, coughing, pain and redness of the skin, along with peeling and itching eyes, are among the
significant effects of exposure to bauxite dust.
Studies have shown that these materials could lead to neurological problems such as chronic
brain syndrome, anxiety for no reason, forgetfulness, or Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease in
adults.
It is noted that the content of iron oxide in bauxite is 15-34 percent, less compared to aluminum
hydroxide. Iron oxide is the substance that causes the roads, river and sea to become reddish.
Long-term exposure of iron oxide to the respiratory system could lead to the accumulation of
iron in the liver tissue and affect the functioning of the liver system. The situation is thus
worsened for people with thalassemia and hemophilia or those suffering from swelling of the
liver and spleen.
Next, titanium oxide is the third content in bauxite. Exposure of this substance may give an
adverse effect to those who suffer from eczema skin, heart problems and liver problems.
Moreover, the content of reactive silica in bauxite is 1-8 percent. Exposure to high
concentrations can cause shortness of breath, chest pain, fatigue, fainting or even death. Longer
periods of exposure cause the inflammation of the lungs. Then it will become worse and cause
problems such as chronic bronchitis or acute respiratory infections silicosis.
Bauxite mining has become a good source of income for many people - especially low-income
earners. However, a responsible action plan should be taken by the regulators to strictly enforce
safety and health regulations and ensure the consumers well-being. The bauxite mining industry
may become a good fortune for every person if and only if the mining operators and the transport
contractors responsibly manage the mining and transportation operations according to the rules
and regulations that have been set.
There are various alternatives to bauxite mineral to produce alumina. These alternatives include
clay minerals, alunite, anorthosite, power plant ash, and oil shale. But, at a higher cost due to
more complex and different processes that is involved. Besides that, Silicon carbide can be used
to substitute bauxite abrasives in the industry applications.
Improving the efficiency of manufacturing processes
The World Resources Institute is conducting research on resource and materials
use. WRI has been working to develop databases and indicators that document the flow of
materials through industrial economies. Material flows analyses track the physical flows of
natural resources through extraction, production, fabrication, use and recycling, and final
disposal, accounting for losses along the way.The goal of the materials flow studies is to develop
new thinking, new metrics, and new management tools that will help bring about the transition to
more efficient and less environmentally-harmful patterns of material use in modern societies.
CONCLUSION
Uncontrolled bauxite mining operation in Kuantan has caused severe environmental
pollution. Destruction of ecosystem threatens our access to the most fundamental requisites for
human existence: safe water, clean air, safe food and shelter. The impact may persist if there is no
proper rehabilitation plan done to the exploited area. While mental distress due to unpleasant
living environment become apparent, more studies are needed to quantify the impact on chronic
physical illness. Even though chronic physical illness are not apparent now due to it slow
pathogenesis, the diseases may appear many years later if the current risk is not properly
addressed and controlled. All responsible agencies should focus on a wider aspect of health
determinants rather than waiting for the occurrence of diseases to before acting. It is important to
emphasize on sustainable mining practices in order to avoid compromising the health of people
in the future.