Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
COMPREHENSIVE
COMPREHENSIV
Information Memorandum
Terratherma
March 2010
TM
LTD
Terratherma
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
TM
IMPORTANT INFORMATION: This Information Memorandum contains important information and requires your careful attention. It
should be read in its entirety. If you are in doubt as to its contents or the course of action you should take (if any), you should consult your
stockbroker, accountant, solicitor or other professional adviser immediately.
Ensure you read the IMPORTANT NOTICES section at the front of this Information Memorandum prior to reading the rest of this report or
making any decisions whatsoever in relation to the content contained herein.
NO RECOMMENDATION - The provision of this concise Information Memorandum is not and should not be considered an offer for
securities in the company, or as a recommendation in relation to an investment in the Company or its Projects, or that an investment in the
Company or its Projects is a suitable investment for the recipient or any other party.
Terratherma
Geothermal
Project Areas
Project Locations
Terratherma Ltds geothermal interests are located within
the world-class, highly prospective South Australian
Heat Flow Anomaly (SAHFA). A strategic selection of
16 geothermal exploration licences (GELs) is held by
Terratherma Ltd in 3 key geological provinces, covering
an area on 7923km2.
Project Rationale
Terratherma Ltd has secured geothermal project
areas with potential for the integrated utilisation of
geothermal resources, specifically; electricity production,
desalination and hydrogen production.
Company Status
Terratherma Ltd is a 100%, wholly owned subsidiary of
Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) listed, Eden Energy
Ltd (ASX: EDE).
(South Australia)
Courtesy of: Mike Bee
Terratherma
TM
LTD
Important Notices
Please read this section carefully.
Confidentiality
The information contained in this concise Information Memorandum is being provided on a confidential basis to the recipient
solely for the purposes of general information or potentially evaluating an investment in Terratherma Ltd (the Company) or its
Projects (the Project/s).
By accepting a copy of this Information Memorandum the recipient agrees, for itself and its related bodies corporate and each of
their management, officers, employees, agents, representatives and advisers, to maintain the confidentiality of this information.
Any reproduction or distribution of this Information Memorandum, in whole or in part, or any disclosure of its contents, or use of
any information contained in this Information Memorandum for any purpose other than to evaluate a potential investment in the
Company or its Project/s, is strictly prohibited.
Aspects of this Information Memorandum contain proprietary intellectual property including but not limited to the AGITM, alBOSSTM, al-SIAMTM, GAMTM and al-I&PITM developed by Activated Logic Pty Limited and utilised for the purposes of examining and
progressing the advancement of Terratherma Ltds Projects. All aspects of these methodologies, including their existence and
application should be treated as commercial in confidence at all times and should not be disclosed to any parties under any
circumstances. All sections of this Information Memorandum are considered confidential, including all supplementary materials.
(b)
by the Parties as to the truth, accuracy or completeness of any statement, opinion, forecast, information or other matter (whether
express or implied) contained in this Information Memorandum or its appendices or as to any other matter concerning them.
Recipients of this information are advised that the forecasts included in this Information Memorandum are forward-looking
statements and therefore are inherently speculative. Due to the subjective judgements and inherent uncertainties of statements
about future events, there can be no assurance that the Projects and/or Companys actual future results, or subsequent forecasts,
will not vary significantly from the forecasts and other forward-looking statements set out in this Information Memorandum. The
inclusion of the forward-looking statements set out in the Information Memorandum should not be regarded as a representation
or warranty with respect to their accuracy or the accuracy of the underlying assumptions or that the Company and its Projects will
achieve or is likely to achieve any particular results.
For a detailed list of the key risks, refer to Chapter 24 of this Information Memorandum.
Disclosure Notice
The publisher of this Information Memorandum, Activated Logic Pty Limited ABN 62 134 740 293 (Activated Logic), its directors,
officers, staff and their associates from time to time may hold investments in the securities mentioned in this publication and as a
result may benefit from any change in price of the relevant securities. Activated Logic and its advisers may earn brokerage, fees,
commissions, other benefits or advantages as a result of a transaction arising from any research or opinions mentioned in this
publication and distributed to existing and potential clients. Activated Logic may have provided corporate advice within the past
and may continue to provide corporate advice to companies (or related parties) concerned, for which Activated Logic may have
received gross fees and/or continue to receive fees.
No Recommendation
The provision of this Information Memorandum is not and should not be considered an offer for securities in the company, or as a
recommendation in relation to an investment in the Company or its Projects or that an investment in the Company or its Projects is
a suitable investment for the recipient. THIS INFORMATION MEMORANDUM DOES NOT CONSTITUTE INVESTMENT ADVICE.
Investor Enquiries
This Information Memorandum does not purport to provide all of the information the recipient may require in order to evaluate an
investment in the Company or its Projects. Recipients should make their own enquiries and evaluations they consider appropriate
to verify the information contained in the Information Memorandum and to determine the suitability of a potential investment in
the Company or its Projects (including regarding their investment objectives, financial situation, and particular needs) and should
seek all necessary financial, legal, tax and investment advice.
To the full extent permitted by law, no responsibility or liability (including in negligence) is accepted by the Parties:
(a)
for, or in connection with any act or omission, directly or indirectly in reliance upon; and
(b)
for any cost, expense, loss or other liability, directly or indirectly, arising from, or in connection with, any omission from or
defects in, or any failure to correct any information, in this Information Memorandum or any other communication (oral or written)
about or concerning them, or the issue of securities in the Company.
The delivery of this Information Memorandum does not under any circumstances imply that the affairs or prospects of the Company
or any information affecting it have been fully or correctly stated in this Information Memorandum or have not changed since the
date of this Information Memorandum or since the date at which the information is expressed to be applicable. No responsibility
or liability (including in negligence) is assumed by the Company for updating any such information or to inform the recipient of any
new information of which the Company may become aware.
Contact Details
For additional information or to clarify specific elements of this Information Memorandum contact Eden Energy Limited and
explicitly disclose how and when you obtained details of this Information Memorandum. Additional contact details in, Appendix 4.
Eden Energy Limited
Ph:
+61 (08) 9282 5889
Fax:
+61 (08) 9282 5866
Email: mailroom@edenenergy.com.au
Additional Information
Refer to the Appendices section of this Information Memorandum, or contact Eden Energy Limited.
This Information Memorandum contains forecasts and other forward-looking statements concerning the Company and its Projects.
These statements are based on a number of assumptions, expectations and estimates developed by the Company and its associates
that, while considered reasonable by the Company, are inherently subject to significant uncertainties and contingencies, many of
which are beyond the Companys control or reflect future business decisions which are subject to change.
RECIPIENTS OF THIS INFORMATION MEMORANDUM ARE CAUTIONED THAT THE COMPANY AND ITS PROJECTS ARE AT AN
EARLY STAGE OF DEVELOPMENT AND THAT ANY INVESTMENT IN THE COMPANY AND ITS PROJECTS CARRIES POTENTIALLY
SIGNIFICANT RISKS.
Table of Contents
1.
1.1.
1.2.
..............................................
13
..............................................
15
..............................................
18
..............................................
21
The Foundations
The Future
2.
2.1.
Introduction
3.
3.1.
3.2.
3.3.
3.4.
3.5.
Introduction
The Emissions Challenges
Fossil Fuel Dependency
ETS & Transition to Cleaner Fuels
Australian CO2 Emissions Targets
4.
4.1.
4.2.
4.3.
4.4.
4.5.
4.6.
4.7.
Introduction
Reduced Emissions Intensity
Installed Renewable Energy Capacity
Renewable Energy Development Drivers
Technology Capacity Factors
Geothermal Advantage
Issues with Intermittent Power
5.
5.1.
5.2.
5.3.
21
21
22
22
23
23
23
24
..............................................
28
Introduction
Opportunities & Challenges
Industry Structure
Market Structure
Electricity Production
Electricity Transmission Infrastructure
7.
..............................................
Introduction
Electricity Infrastructure
Electricity Demand Outlook
Renewable Energy Contribution
Opportunity for Geothermal Projects
8.
18
18
19
19
20
..............................................
6.1.
6.2.
6.3.
6.4.
6.5.
6.6.
7.1.
7.2.
7.3.
7.4.
7.5.
15
Historical Performance
Inflows by Investment Type
GFC Implications
6.
13
13
..............................................
8.1.
8.2.
8.3.
8.4.
8.5.
Introduction
Expanded MRET
Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs)
Renewable Energy Certificate Prices
Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme
9.
..............................................
24
25
25
28
28
28
28
29
29
31
31
31
32
33
33
34
34
34
35
35
35
36
14.
14.1.
14.2.
14.3.
14.4.
14.5.
14.6.
14.7.
14.8.
14.9.
14.10.
15.
15.1.
15.2.
15.3.
15.4.
15.5.
15.6.
15.7.
15.8.
15.9.
15.10.
16.
16.1.
16.2.
16.3.
17.
17.1.
17.2.
17.3.
18.
18.1.
18.2.
18.3.
19.
19.1.
19.2.
19.3.
20.
20.1.
20.2.
20.3.
20.4.
9.1.
9.2.
9.3.
9.4.
9.5.
Introduction
NEM Activity
The NEM & Spot Market Prices
Interstate Electricity Price Comparison
Forecast Electricity Prices
10.
..............................................
40
40
40
40
21.1.
21.2.
21.3.
21.4.
21.5.
..............................................
41
22.
10.1.
10.2.
10.3.
Introduction
Opportunity
Optimisation Benefits
11.
11.1.
11.2.
11.3.
11.4.
11.5.
11.6.
11.7.
Introduction
Desalination Technologies
Integrated Geothermal Desalination
South Australian Water Market
Water Capacity Additions
Terratherma Ltd Desalination
Terratherma Ltd Opportunity
12.
12.1.
12.2.
12.3.
12.4.
12.5.
12.6.
12.7.
..............................................
Introduction
Hydrogen Production Methodologies
Direct Geothermal Hydrogen Production
Integrated Hydrogen Production
Terratherma Ltds Hydrogen Advantage
Terratherma Ltd - Medium Term Market Opportunities
Terratherma Ltd - Long Term Market Opportunities
13.
13.1.
13.2.
13.3.
13.4.
..............................................
Introduction
Major Geothermal Energy Systems
Installed Global Geothermal Capacity
Forecast Global Geothermal Capacity
36
36
37
37
37
13.5.
13.6.
13.7.
41
41
42
43
43
44
44
45
45
45
46
46
47
50
51
54
54
54
55
56
21.
57
58
59
..............................................
62
..............................................
72
..............................................
80
..............................................
84
..............................................
88
..............................................
92
..............................................
98
..............................................
101
Introduction
Identifying Geothermal Resources
Current Installed Capacity
Geothermal Heat Flow & Temperature
Geothermal Exploration Activity
Geothermal Market Development
Geothermal Market Expansion
Transition to Commercial Deployment
Financing Geothermal Market Expansion
Geothermal Energy Market Dynamics
Corporate Overview
Company History
Corporate Vision
Corporate Strategy
Segmented Geothermal Applications
Terratherma Ltds GEL Portfolio
Cost Implications of Deep Drilling
Terratherma Ltds Focus on the SAHFA
Geothermal Assessment MatrixTM
Geothermal Project Screening
Project Overview
Location & Geology
Commercial Potential
Project Overview
Location & Geology
Commercial Potential
Project Overview
Location & Geology
Commercial Potential
Project Overview
Location & Geology
Commercial Potential
Geothermal - Commercialisation
Introduction
Geothermal Resource Delineation
Geothermal Value Creation
Geothermal Financing
Introduction
100MW Electricity Generation Scenario
Conceptual Development Parameters
Commercial Development Pathway
Electricity Generation Assumption
62
62
62
64
64
65
67
68
69
70
72
72
73
73
74
75
75
76
77
78
80
80
83
84
84
87
88
88
91
92
92
95
98
98
99
100
101
101
103
103
103
22.1.
22.2.
22.3.
22.4.
22.5.
22.6.
22.7.
22.8.
22.9.
Introduction
Project Scale
TGP-FM Overview
100MW Scenario - Data Inputs
100MW Scenario - Data Outputs
TGP-FM - Operational Sensitivity
TGP-FM - Price Sensitivity
Advantages of Integrated Geothermal
Summary of TGP-FM Implications
105
23.
..............................................
112
24.
105
105
105
106
108
109
110
111
111
24.1.
24.2.
24.3.
Risks
..............................................
114
25.
Definitions
..............................................
120
26.
References
..............................................
122
Appendices
..............................................
125
114
119
119
Schedule of Figures
Figure 1 - Terratherma Ltd Project Development Schematic
Figure 2a - Global Atmospheric CO2 Concentration (last 800,000 years)
Figure 2b - World Energy Demand (1980 - 2030)
Figure 3 - CO2 Emissions by Conventional Fuel Type (CO2 emissions g/kWh)
Figure 4 - Australian 2020 Emissions Target Range (5-15 and 25% reduction scenarios)
Figure 5 - CO2 Emissions by Renewable Technology (CO2 emissions g/kWh)
Figure 6 - World Renewable Energy Generation (2000 - 2050) (50% Reduction Scenario)
Figure 7 - Typical Capacity Factors (various generation technologies)
Figure 8 - Renewable Energy (NEX) Index (comparison with Oil in US$ billions)
Figure 9 - Global new investment in renewable energy (US$ billions)
Figure 10 - Global Equity Investment in Renewable Energy (US$ billions)
Figure 11 - Global VC & PE Investment in Renewable Energy (US$ billions)
Figure 12 - Global Debt Financing of Renewable Energy (US$ billions)
Figure 13 - Electricity Market Structure
Figure 14 - Australian Electricity Generation (2006-07)
Figure 15 - Major Electricity Infrastructure Map (Australia)
Figure 16 - Electricity Transmission Map (South Australia)
Figure 17 - Electricity Supply & Demand Balance (S.A.)
Figure 18 - Electricity Supply & Demand Balance (South Australia)
Figure 19 - Renewable Electricity Generation (Australia)
Figure 20 - Wind Capacity Factors (South Australia)
Figure 21 - Wind Contribution during Peak Demand (South Australia)
Figure 22 - Forecast Renewable Energy Generation (As determined by MRET)
Figure 23 - REC Price Performance (2008-2009)
Figure 24 - REC Market Schematic (Overview)
Figure 25 - Regional Electricity Market Activity (2007-2008)
Figure 26 - Spot NEM Prices (1999-2008)
Figure 27 - Spot NEM Prices (1999-2008)
Figure 28 - Electricity Price Forecast ($MWh)
Figure 29 - Terratherma Ltd Project Development Schematic
Figure 30a - Desalination Pathway Schematic (derived from geothermal energy)
Figure 30b - Technologies
Figure 31 - Reverse Osmosis (process)
Figure 32 - Desalination (Multi-Stage Flash)
Figure 33 - Desalination (Multi-Effect Distillation)
Figure 34 - South Australia Water Allocations (trading intensity)
Figure 35 - Adelaide Desalination Plant
Figure 36 - Terratherma Ltd (Coastal GEL Portfolio)
Figure 37 - Major Water Infrastructure (Adelaide)
Figure 38a - Hydrogen production pathways (derived from geothermal energy)
Figure 38b - Technologies
Figure 39 - Hydrogen production (capacity by method)
Figure 40 - Direct Hydrogen Production (Geothermal)
Figure 41 - Hydrogen Sulphide Damage (Geodynamics)
Figure 42 - Modular Hydrogen Production (Electrolysis)
Figure 43 - Thermochemical Hydrogen Production
Figure 44 - Eden Energy (Hydrogen Technology Inventory)
Figure 45 - SEM Image of Carbon Nanotubes
Figure 46a - Denver Hythane (Emissions Comparisons)
Figure 46b - Hythane Market (Diesel genset)
Figure 47 - Distribution (First Indian Hythane Station)
Figure 48 - System Components (Sensor & Mixer)
Figure 49 - Hydrogen Production (SMR Technology)
Figure 50 - Hythane Bus (MCI Classic Bus, California)
Figure 51 - Hythane Car (Honda Civic - converted by Eden Energy Ltd)
Figure 52 - Hydrogen Internal Combustion Engine (150kW)
Figure 53 - Natural Gas Pipelines (Australia)
Figure 54 - Liquified Natural Gas Tanker (Japan)
Figure 55 - Geothermal Energy Systems (Overview)
Figure 56 - Installed Geothermal Capacity (Global)
Figure 57 - Segmented Geothermal Market (Global)
Figure 58 - Geothermal Development Pipeline (By Country)
Figure 59 - Forecast Geothermal Capacity (Global)
Figure 60 - Segmented Geothermal Market (Global)
Figure 61 - Geothermal Technology Market (Global - 2008)
Figure 62 - Segmented Geothermal Market (By Technology - Global)
Figure 63 - Segmented Geothermal Market (By Technology Maturity - Global)
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
13
18
19
19
20
21
22
23
24
24
25
25
25
28
29
29
31
32
32
33
33
33
34
35
35
36
37
37
37
40
41
42
42
42
42
43
43
44
44
45
45
45
46
46
46
46
47
47
48
49
49
49
49
50
50
51
51
51
54
55
55
56
56
57
58
58
58
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
59
59
59
60
60
62
62
62
63
63
64
64
65
66
67
68
68
69
70
70
73
74
75
75
76
76
77
80
80
81
81
82
83
83
84
85
85
85
85
85
85
86
87
88
89
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
98
99
100
100
101
102
103
104
106
106
107
107
108
108
109
109
110
110
Part A
.....................................
.....................................
13
15
The Vision
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
18
21
24
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
28
31
34
36
1.
..............................................
13
1.1.
The Foundations
..............................................
13
1.2.
The Future
..............................................
13
2.
..............................................
15
2.1.
Introduction
..............................................
15
.....................................
.....................................
40
41
45
.....................................
54
.....................................
62
.....................................
72
.....................................
80
84
88
92
.....................................
Part G
15.
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
Geothermal - Commercialisation
Geothermal - Conceptual Development
Geothermal - Conceptual Financial Analysis (TGP-FM)
Conclusion - Opportunities & Challenges
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
.....................................
98
101
105
112
Risks
Definitions
References
.....................................
.....................................
114
120
122
.....................................
125
.....................................
Part K Appendices
Various
10
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 11
LTD
TM
The Foundations
1.2.
Figure 1 -
The Future
Development
GEOTHERMAL PROJECTS
Geothermal Energy
ELECTRICITY
HYDROGEN
Desalination
WATER
12
13
14
(Feb 2008)
Seawater RO Desalination
Based
15
Part B
..............................................
18
3.1.
Introduction
..............................................
18
3.2.
..............................................
18
3.3.
..............................................
19
3.4.
..............................................
19
3.5.
..............................................
20
4.
..............................................
21
4.1.
Introduction
..............................................
21
4.2.
..............................................
21
4.3.
..............................................
22
4.4.
..............................................
22
4.5.
..............................................
23
4.6.
Geothermal Advantage
..............................................
23
4.7.
..............................................
23
5.
..............................................
24
5.1.
Historical Performance
..............................................
24
5.2.
..............................................
25
5.3.
GFC Implications
..............................................
25
16
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 17
LTD
TM
3.3.
As the worlds population approaches 7 billion, the insatiable demand for energy in both the developed and
developing economies, particularly India and China, has never been greater. Despite our increased awareness
of anthropogenic climate change and the rapid emergence of the renewable energy sector, we remain heavily
dependent on fossil fuels for both primary energy production and a range of industrial applications.
Introduction
Figure 2b -
18
CAGR = 1.7%
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
1980
2000
3.4.
Figure 3 -
400
380
360
340
320
300
280
260
240
220
200
180
160
800,000
700,000
600,000
500,000
400,000
300,000
18
The
increased
concentration
of
atmospheric carbon dioxide, to levels
not seen previously at any time during
human history is very significant.
200,000
100,000
Figure 2a -
2015
2006
- 0
3.2.
3.1.
19
Introduction
(Dec 2009)
Courtesy of: Foreign Affairs, Denmark
At the time of writing, the exact path for action is not entirely clear,
however there is wide consensus that increased efforts to reduce
greenhouse gases in the future will need to be implemented,
and these are expected to support renewable energy sources.
20
Figure 4 -
Copenhagen Opening
3.5.
Source: Adapted from Alpha Auctus, 2010 and proprietary Activated Logic data.
21
4.5.
4.4.
4.6.
dro
Hy
rge
La
ine
(C
CG
T)
al
Co
ar
Ga
sT
urb
cle
Nu
aic
Vo
lt
ola
oto
Ph
gS
tin
tra
Geothermal Advantage
22
Wa
v
en
Co
nc
ind
2050
2040
2035
ore
2030
Ge
2025
10
Tid
a
2,000
20
sh
4,000
On
Hydro
ind
6,000
30
Wind
dro
Solar PV
8,000
40
ore
Solar CSP
10,000
50
Hy
Biomass, Waste
12,000
Of
fsh
Geothermal
Given
baseload
power
generation requires a capacity
factor of above 90%, it is
unlikely many of the renewable
technologies will be able to
compete as the primary source
of power, but will instead
become
supplementary
sources of power.
Due to limitations on existing
installed wind capacity in
South Australia, the network
requires additional baseload
power to ensure stable power
supplies for when the wind
infrastructure is not producing
power.
60
ss
14,000
70
all
Tidal
2020
Conventional
80
ma
Other
16,000
Research
and
development
incentives have been important
in the development of the
renewable energy sector, however
the ultimate scale and timing
of specific renewable energy
technologies will be determined
by markets and competitive
project economics.
Sm
18,000
2015
90
20,000
2010
100
2005
Renewables
2000
Figure 7 -
al
Figure 6 -
Bio
4.7.
erm
Installed
oth
4.3.
Unlike
CSP Installation
(Apr 2009)
Courtesy of: Alla Leitus
23
5.2.
The development, commercialisation and adoption of renewable energy projects such as geothermal energy
powered electricity generation, are highly dependent on high investment inflows into the sector. During the
last decade as the price of fossil fuels has increased, competing renewable energy sources have become more
competitive and as a result, have attracted increased investment into the renewable energy sector.
5.1.
Figure 10 -
Historical Performance
With the onset of the global financial crisis in late 2008, asset
valuations and new investments across all sectors fell sharply,
with increased risk and liquidity challenges experienced in
capital markets in the early part of 2009.
Figure 8 -
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
2006
2005
2004
2003
2008
2007
2010
2009
AMEX Oil
Figure 9 -
32.5
28.3
28.8
24.0
23.2
24.3
25.2
24.9
18.0
14.9
13.3
11.7 11.7
4.5
Q1
04
3.3
3.5
Q2
04
Q3
04
5.7
Q4
04
7.6
Q1
05
8.8
Q2
05
8.5
Q3
05
Q4
05
Q1
06
Q2
06
Q3
06
Q4
06
Q1
07
Q2
07
24
Q3
07
Q4
07
Q1
08
Q2
08
Q3
08
Q4
08
Q1
09
Q2
09
5.3.
5.7
4.4
3.9
2.0
0.2
0.2
0.1
Q1
04
Q2
04
Q3
04
0.4
Q4
04
0.7
Q1
05
1.0
Q2
05
1.7
4.7
3.4
3.1
2.9
2.5
1.6
2.4
1.3
0.7
Q3
05
0.1
Q4
05
Q1
06
Q2
06
Q3
06
Q4
06
Q1
07
Q2
07
Q3
07
Q4
07
Q1
08
Q2
08
Q3
08
Q4
08
Q1
09
Q2
09
Figure 11 -
4.2
3.5
2.6
2.2
1.7
0.7
0.2
Q1
04
Q2
04
0.3
0.4
0.4
Q3
04
Q4
04
Q1
05
0.7
Q2
05
0.5
Q3
05
0.9
Q4
05
1.2
Q1
06
Q2
06
Q3
06
1.6
1.2
Q4
06
Q1
07
Q2
07
1.9
Q3
07
2.5
2.4
1.8
Q4
07
Q1
08
Q2
08
Q3
08
Q4
08
Q1
09
1.4
Q2
09
Figure 12 -
25.5
23.7
25.4
23.5
21.5
19.4
20.5
18.6
16.6
12.0 11.6
5.0
4.1
2.4
Q1
04
Q2
04
6.5
7.1
7.2
Q2
05
Q3
05
8.8
8.8
Q4
05
Q1
06
11.4
3.1
Q3
04
Q4
04
Q1
05
Q2
06
Q3
06
Q4
06
Q1
07
Q2
07
Q3
07
Q4
07
Q1
08
Q2
08
Q3
08
Q4
08
Q1
09
2.2
GFC Implications
Q2
09
Finance,2009.
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
25
Part C
..............................................
28
6.1.
Introduction
..............................................
28
6.2.
..............................................
28
6.3.
Industry Structure
..............................................
28
6.4.
Market Structure
..............................................
28
6.5.
Electricity Production
..............................................
29
6.6.
..............................................
29
7.
..............................................
31
7.1.
Introduction
..............................................
31
7.2.
Electricity Infrastructure
..............................................
31
7.3.
..............................................
32
7.4.
..............................................
33
7.5.
..............................................
33
8.
..............................................
34
8.1.
Introduction
..............................................
34
8.2.
Expanded MRET
..............................................
34
8.3.
..............................................
35
8.4.
..............................................
35
8.5.
9.
..............................................
36
9.1.
Introduction
..............................................
36
9.2.
NEM Activity
..............................................
36
9.3.
..............................................
37
9.4.
..............................................
37
9.5.
..............................................
37
..............................................
35
HV Powerline Sunset
(May 2006)
Courtesy of: Christof van der Bij
26
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 27
LTD
TM
6.5.
The Australian electricity market consists of a national electricity grid on the east coast of Australia linking major
population centres, and regional satellite electricity grids in the Northern Territory and Western Australia. With
the exception of significant wind generation in South Australia and the Snowy hydro-electric scheme in NSW, the
majority of power generation in Australia is predominantly from coal and gas fired generation facilities.
6.1.
Introduction
6.2.
28
Industry Structure
oil 1%
hydro 2%
gas 11.6%
wind and
solar PV 0.9%
6.4.
6.6.
Across
Australia, the majority of electricity generation
and transmission infrastructure is divided into two distinct
geographic profiles. On the east-coast the National Electricity
Market (NEM) is generally concentrated around population
centres (figure 15) with the exception of far north Queensland
and regional South Australia, which service major mining
operations. In contrast, a significant proportion of Western
Australia and the Northern Territorys power generation is
remote and designed to service regional townships and
specific mining related projects and is not intended for regional
transmission. The contrast in the density of power generation
between the east coast and the west coast of Australia due to
the presence or lack of transmission infrastructure is significant
(figure 15).
A network of high voltage electricity transmission infrastructure,
typically in the order of 275 - 500kV links major towns and capital
cities on the east coast of Australia, including a direct link to the
giant Olympic Dam mine in remote South Australia (figure 15). A
high voltage, underwater DC line connects Tasmania to the NEM
through Victoria.
brown coal
27.4%
Market Structure
Figure 15 -
Tom Price
Paraburdoo
, Denham
Kalbarri
transmission
network
plant dispatch instructions
generators
distribution
network
load dispatch instructionsa
AEMO
determines the amount
of power required
PERTH
Collie
Margaret River
consumers
Georgetown
Tennant Creek
Townsville
Collinsville
Moranbah
Ti-Tree
Alice Springs
Barcaldine
Kings Canyon
Yulara
Mt Stuart
Proserpine
Mackay
Stanwell
Rockhampton
Gladstone
Bundaberg
Birdsville
Roma
Mt Keith
W indimurra
W orsley
Murrin Murrin
Menzies
Kalgoorlie/Boulder
Kambalda
Maryborough
Tarong
Esperance
Hopetoun
Albany
BRISBANE
Olympic Dam
Leigh Creek
Woomera
Coffs Harbour
Broken Hill
Gunnedah
Nyngan
Port
Whyalla
Dubbo
Macquarie
Buronga Hillston
Hunter Valley
Newcastle
Hay Griffith
Berri
SYDNEY
Port Lincoln
ADELAIDE
Bendigo
Canberra
Albury
MELBOURNEDC link
Gordon
Cairns
Mt Gambier Anglesea
purchase bids
electricity settlement payments
Borroloola
McArthur River Barron Gorge
Daly Waters
Mt Magnet
Donga ra
W oodada
Nhulunbuy
Katherine
Kununurra
Argyle
Fitzroy Crossing
Carnarvon Plutonic
Wiluna
Jabiru
Pine Creek
Shay Gap
Marble Bar
Telfer
Nullagine
Wittenoom
Jimblebar
Newman
Karratha
Ge raldton
Figure 13 -
DARWIN
DC LINE
500 kV
Power Station
330 kV
Substation
275 kV
Geothermal
220 kV
Derby
132 / 110 kV
Broome
66 kV
33 / 22 kV Port Hedland
1 ]
6.3.
Electricity Production
HOBART
29
Introduction
7.2.
Electricity Infrastructure
Terratherma GELs
SA Wind Farm
(Oct 2009)
30
31
7.3.
7.4.
22,000
actual
GWh
16,000
14,000
12,000
Figure 19 -
10,000
432
155
565
505
2,500
2011-12
2012-13
2013-14
2014-15
2015-16
2016-17
2017-18
2018-19
32
MW
MW
MW MW
NSW
VIC
QLD
SA
WA
TAS
NT
Other
68
78
17
22
27
5
1
16
0
359
0
6
0
0
42
0
15
10
6
0
0
36 4 275
34 566
4 659
0
5
63
32
0 2 276
0
0
Aust
218
380
73
total
MW
MW
18
134
13
740
201
144
0
4.0
0.7
0.4
0.7
0.7
0.0
1.6
63
0.5 4459
0.0
813
0.1 1066
0.0
778
0.0
336
0.0 2425
0.0
3
63
71
1 9 942
Figure 21 -
MW
Figure 20 Calendar
Year
Starfish
Hill
Lake
Bonney
S1
Cathedral
Rocks
Wattle
Point
Mt Millar
Hallett
S1
Lake
Bonney
S2
Snowtown
S1
2006
34%
31%
23%
19%
30%
7%
2007
38%
29%
28%
33%
35%
15%
2008
34%
29%
28%
35%
35%
19%
32%
25%
27%
2009
26%
26%
21%
26%
32%
24%
35%
21%
39%
9%
The
90%
3,000
2010-11
MW
100%
328
59
2009-10
MW
4,000
245
woodother
biogas bagasse waste renewables hydro wind solar other
ADDITIONAL CAPACITY
REQUIRED
2018-19
4,500
2017-18
2016-17
2015-16
2014-15
2013-14
2012-13
2011-12
2010-11
2009-10
2008-09
2007-08
2006-07
3,500
2005-06
Figure 18 -
high
low
base
18,000
7.5.
20,000
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
20%
95% level
50% level
30%
10%
output f or the 95% level
0%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Percen tage of Time
70%
80%
90%
100%
33
Introduction
Figure 22 -
8.2.
Expanded MRET
By
8.3.
8.4.
The current REC spot price is approximately $35 for each certificate
(figure 23) which represents 1 MWh. REC prices have decreased in
response to binding cuts not being achieved at Copenhagen. The
Coalition of Australian Governments (COAG) recently increased
REC penalties from A$40 per MWh to A$65 per MWh.
Figure 23 -
Figure 24 -
certainty.
8.5.
34
35
9.3.
Since the mid 1990s, major changes in the Australian electricity industry, including privatisation and less
prohibitive competition policy have contributed to fundamental changes in the industry, most notably the
emergence of integrated electricity generators and retailers. The Australian electricity transmission network is
increasingly interconnected with state electricity prices slowly converging towards a national average.
9.1.
Introduction
The
Figure 25 -
51.3 TWh
57.2 TWh
QNI
534
9.2.
Directlink
70
78.3 TWh
73.1 TWh
SnowyNSW
state
56
Snowy
$45/MWh
0.5 TWh
3.4 TWh
148
VicSnowy
South Australia
$74/MWh
13.3 TWh
13.0 TWh
Heywood
Victoria
$47/MWh
15
Murraylink
15
52.2 TWh
53.4 TWh
BassLink
(operational in 2005)
261
Tasmania
NEM Activity
$55/MWh
10.3 TWh
Western Australia
na
20.7 TWh e
20.7 TWh e
Northern Territory
na
1.6 TWh e
1.6 TWh e
36
8.1 TWh
Figure 26 -
Figure 27 -
9.5.
Figure 28 -
200
150
Average
Queensland
Victoria
Snowy Region
Tasmania
VIC
TAS
SNOWY
100
SA
50
QLD
NSW
$/MWh
1999
Dec
Dec
Dec
Dec
Dec
2000
2001
2002
2003
Dec
Dec
2005
Dec
Dec
2007
2008
37
Part D
..............................................
40
10.1.
Introduction
..............................................
40
10.2.
Opportunity
..............................................
40
10.3.
Optimisation Benefits
..............................................
40
11.
..............................................
41
11.1.
Introduction
..............................................
41
11.2.
Desalination Technologies
..............................................
41
11.3.
..............................................
42
11.4.
..............................................
43
11.5.
..............................................
43
11.6.
..............................................
44
11.7.
..............................................
44
12.
..............................................
45
12.1.
Introduction
..............................................
45
12.2.
..............................................
45
12.3.
..............................................
46
12.4
..............................................
46
12.5.
..............................................
47
12.6.
..............................................
50
12.7
..............................................
51
Transformer Interconnector
(Nov 2009)
Courtesy of: Terna Spa
38
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 39
LTD
TM
The presence of thermal energy and exploitation of this energy through hot-water in geothermal energy systems,
lends these projects to the strategic application of logically integrated technologies, specifically desalination and
hydrogen production. The integration of these potentially attractive downstream processes, presents Terratherma
Ltd with a number of exciting opportunities to capture increased value across the broadened value chain.
A number of established desalination technologies exist, specific technologies require either thermal energy,
electrical energy or a combination of both to extract fresh water from seawater. Geothermal projects are ideally
suited to cascaded integration with desalination projects as geothermal projects produce vast amounts of direct
heat, waste heat and have high capacity factors producing large amounts of electricity, even during off-peak periods.
10.1. Introduction
10.2. Opportunity
11.1. Introduction
Figure 29 -
Technologies
GEOTHERMAL
Exploration
Thermal Energy
Figure 30b -
Electrical Energy
Thermal/Distillation Methods
Multi-Stage Flash Distillation
Development
Multi-Stage Flash Distillation
Mechanical Work
Direct Source
Multi-Effect Distillation
Vapour Compression Distillation
GEOTHERMAL PROJECTS
Geothermal Energy
Solar Humidification
Distillation Process
ELECTRICITY
Membrane Process
Reverse Osmosis
HYDROGEN
Desalination
WATER
Electrodialysis Reversal
40
Electrodialysis
WATER
Membrane Methods
41
Figure 31 -
Heat Source
Steam derived from
either low-grade,
heat, waste heat or
from direct steam
from Geothermal
plant.
fresh water
Figure 34 -
Figure 35 -
sea water
pump
brine to sea
42
Figure 32 -
Recent prolonged drought conditions in the greater MurrayDarling Basin catchment area, particularly in New South Wales
have resulted in reduced inflows into the river system. The severe
water shortages have been exceptionally problematic in South
Australia, as the state is highly dependent on the River Murray
inflows, yet the state is last to receive the river flows as it is down
stream from both New South Wales and Victoria.
The reverse osmosis desalination process does not involve the boiling of water, therefore
the energy requirements are relatively low when compared with competing sources of
desalination, however the upfront capital cost are high. Furthermore, the technology is
scalable, but does not benefit from major gains in efficiency or from economies of scale
as the efficiency is derived from the membrane surface.
Figure 33 -
43
Figure 36 -
Terratherma GELs
The integration of a hydrogen production process with geothermal power generation presents a range of exciting
opportunities to accelerate the adoption of hydrogen as a renewable fuel, whilst improving the commerciality
of Terratherma Ltds geothermal projects. Terratherma Ltds parent company, Eden Energy Ltd has developed a
range of innovative technologies for the economic production and effective utilisation of hydrogen.
12.1. Introduction
The adoption of a global hydrogen based energy system
commonly referred to as the hydrogen economy, to replace the
existing fossil fuel based energy systems, is increasingly gaining
momentum. Hydrogen is considered to be an ideal energy source
as its use in fuel cells produces water instead of harmful carbon
dioxide, nitrous oxides, unburnt hydrocarbons and particulate
matter. Hydrogen may also be used directly in an internal
Figure38a -
Technologies
GEOTHERMAL
Thermal Energy
Figure 38b -
Electrical Energy
Thermal Methods
Hydrocarbon Reforming
Source: Adapted by Activated Logic, 2010. Terratherma GEL Portfolio super imposed on Electranet Map, 2009.
Thermochemical Cycles
Mechanical Work
Direct Source
Electrolysis Methods
Figure 37 -
Electrolysis
Methane Pyrolysis
44
Hybrid Cycles
HYDROGEN
Alkaline Electrolysis
Terratherma
Figure 39 -
45
Hydrogen Products
Existing
Technologies
Emerging
Technologies
Hythane Fuel
Source: Adapted by Activated Logic, 2010. From Eden Energy Ltd, 2009.
46
Figure 44 -
Introduction
Terratherma Ltds objective of renewable hydrogen production
integrated with a geothermal energy system is supported by the
extensive experience developed in this area by Terratherma Ltds
parent company, Eden Energy Ltd. Through inhouse research
Figure 45a -
47
Figure 45b -
Figure 45c -
48
Figure 47 -
Figure 49 -
Emissions (grams/mile)
Figure 46a -
Figure 48 -
Hythane - Overview
During the late 1980s, scientists developed a range of enhanced
natural gas (predominantly methane) blends incorporating
approximately 20% hydrogen gas by volume (7% by energy).
The addition of hydrogen was incorporated into natural gas to
improve both the speed of ignition and the extent of combustion
as hydrogen is powerful combustion stimulant for accelerating
the combustion of methane within an engine. Hydrogen is also
a powerful reducing agent for efficient catalysis at lower exhaust
temperatures.
Figure 46b -
Hythane - Market
The market for the premium natural gas blend, Hythane is
substantial and is forecast to grow rapidly. Hythane is suitable in
both the transport and power generation industries, as the fuel is
suitable for use in most vehicles including locomotives and also
gas turbine and internal combustion generators (figure 46b).
Source: Adapted from Colorado Department of Health & Eden Energy Ltd, 2009.
49
Figure 50 -
Eden
Figure 52 -
Figure 54 -
50
resources.
51
Part E
Geothermal Energy
13.
..............................................
54
13.1.
Introduction
..............................................
54
13.2.
..............................................
54
13.3.
..............................................
55
13.4.
..............................................
56
13.5.
..............................................
57
13.6.
Geothermal Technology
..............................................
58
13.7.
..............................................
59
52
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 53
LTD
TM
13.1. Introduction
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
Terratherma
GEOTHERMAL RESOURCE
TYPE, LIMITED TO VOLCANIC
REGIONS
10,000
Capacity (MW)
In its purest form, geothermal energy refers to the energy contained within the earths crust, mantle and super-hot
core, with estimates that temperatures at earths core is approximately 5,000oC, and may exceed 7,000oC . The
utilisation of the energy within the earth for power generation, or other energy harnessing objective is commonly
referred to as geothermal energy, and has been increasingly exploited during the last century.
Added
TM
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
Balanced Portfolio
POWER
PLANT
INSULATING
SEDIMENTS
POWER
PLANT
INSULATING
SEDIMENTS
SANDSTONE OR
CARBONATE
HEAT EXCHANGER
HEAT
EXCHANGER
VOLCANIC
HEAT SOURCE
HEAT SOURCE
54
TRANSMISSION
INSULATING
SEDIMENTS
FRACTURED
GRANITE
(CLOSED LOOP)
HEAT EXCHANGER
RADIOGENIC GRANITE
HEAT SOURCE
INNOVATIVE TECHNOLOGY
By conducting exploration
activities across a range of
geologically diverse basins,
Terratherma Ltd believes it
has improved the probability
of being able to delineate
attractive geothermal resources.
Terratherma Ltd is confident
the combination of balanced
exposure
to
different
geothermal systems, with a
comprehensive understanding
of the key commercial drivers
in geothermal development,
will enhance the likelihood
of
achieving
commercial
outcomes.
POWER
PLANT
TRANSMISSION
Caribbean
East
Africa
Indonesia
Iceland
Russia
Canada
Chile
TRANSMISSION
ENHANCED GEOTHERMAL
SYSTEM (EGS)
Central
America
Philippines
Italy
NZ
US
Mexico
Japan
Turkey
Drivers of near-term
global growth
Nascent geothermal
markets with significant
growth potential
Hungary
Germany
India
China
EGS
HOT SEDIMENTARY
AQUIFER (HSA)
VOLCANIC
Australia
0.2
1.2
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
55
Figure 58 -
5,000
Figure 60 -
4,500
4,000
3,500
Emerging Pure-Play
Developers
Operating
Develop
Developers with
Operating Assets
Announced Pipeline
3,000
2,500
2,000
Own
Ownership Oriented
Utilities and IPPs
Established Owners with
In-House Development
Teams
Megawatts (MW)
1,000
500
0
TM
Terratherma
Diversified IPPs
Exploring Increased
Involvement
1,500
LTD
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
45,000
High Case
Base Case
40,000
Installed 2008
Increased growth internationally, with
Southeast Asia, Latin America, Chile,
Mexico, and East Africa complementing
steady growth in the US. Mega -scale
projects in New Zealand also brought
online, with potential for additional
growth in Iceland
35,000
30,000
Near -term growth driven by
the US, New Zealand, and
increased activity in Indonesia
and Turkey
MW
25,000
Renewable Developers
Active in geothermal
Figure 59 -
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
56
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
20,000
2008
2014
EGS Focused
Developers
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
57
Technology Overview
Dual Flash Figure 61 - Geothermal Technology Market (Global - 2008)
The type of power generation technology utilised inPhilippines
the development
Hybrid
of a geothermal field is largely determined by the characteristics of
7%
Dry Steam
Binary
the geothermal reservoir being developed.
9%
US
Dry Steam
US
25%
The simplest fields to develop are dryMexico
steam fields, as the naturally
Italy
Binary Cycle
Dual Flash
occurring steam is able to be utilised directly in power generation.
14%
10,676 MW
Indonesia
High temperature volcanic resources are developed withUSflash
based systems where the geothermal fluid flashes to steamNew
when
Zealand
Japan
Iceland
it is brought to surface, as the atmospheric
pressure
is
lower.
Indonesia
Single Flash
EGS/Hot Rock
Iceland
Kenya
45%
Alternatively, lower temperature
geothermal Iceland
resources often
utilise
Germany
Guatemala
relatively new binary geothermal technology, where the benefits of France
Japan
a working fluid with a lower boiling temperature are exploited. USAustralia
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
700
600
Dry Steam
Double Flash
Binary
500
400
300
200
100
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
Figure 63 -
Single Flash
Dual Flash
Philippines
Dry Steam
US
US
Mexico
Italy
Japan
Iceland
US
New Zealand
Indonesia
Iceland
Japan
Iceland
EGS/Hot Rock
Kenya
Germany
Guatemala
France
Australia
US
58
Flash Systems
The primary advantage of flash systems
is the large capacity of turbines which
can be utilised (>50MW) resulting in
low per megawatt installation costs. A
number of flash plant variations exist,
including dual-flash systems where
the same configuration incorporates
both a high-temperature and a lower
Hybrid
temperature7% bottoming cycle to
Binarypower generation capacity.
optimise
9%
Figure 64a -
Figure 65 -
Figure 64b -
Dry Steam
25%
Binary Cycle
Indonesia
Dry Steam
Many of the early geothermal fields
developed, particularly in the United
States and Italy consist of dry steam
reservoirs, where the steam is used
directly to turn a turbine for power
generation.
Although dry-steam
geothermal fields present attractive
development
opportunities,
the
presence of these types of fields is very
limited and almost all identified fields
have already been developed.
Introduction
Recent exploration efforts towards identifying suitable
geological settings for enhanced geothermal systems (EGS), are
driven by the need to expand geothermal production outside
predominantly volcanic regions. Engineered geothermal
systems consist of artificially created or enhanced geothermal
reservoirs (as illustrated in figure 55) in hot dry rocks. Unlike
conventional geothermal systems which involve reservoirs with
high permeabilities and porosities, EGS projects are typically
developed in hard, non-porous rocks, including granites.
59
Part F
Commercial Demonstration
Recent successful demonstrations of EGS projects in a number
of different geographical and geological settings, has given
confidence to geothermal developers to pursue commercial
scale EGS development (figure 67).
Figure 66 -
GEL 185
Terratherma Ltd
14.
..............................................
62
14.1.
Introduction
..............................................
62
14.2.
..............................................
62
14.3.
..............................................
62
14.4.
..............................................
64
14.5.
..............................................
64
14.6.
..............................................
65
14.7.
..............................................
67
14.8.
..............................................
68
14.9.
..............................................
69
14.10.
..............................................
70
Figure 67 -
Installed EGS
750
1,500
2,250
3,000
3,750
3
4,500
8
5
5,250
6,000
2006
2007
2008
2009
2011
2012
Project
Country
MW
Project
Country
MW
Soultz-sous-Forets
France
2.0
Gro Schnebeck
Germany
2.0
Landau
Germany
2.5
Cooper Basin
Australia
25
Aktiengesellschaft
Germany
5.0
Germany
1.3
Paralana
Australia
7.5
Coso
US
2.5
Desert Peak
US
n/a
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Emerging Energy Research, 2009
60
2010
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 61
LTD
TM
Figure 71 -
With the exception of a small binary geothermal plant in regional Queensland, the use of geothermal energy in
Australia is almost non-existent. The Australian continent does not host any of the conventional shallow depth,
high temperature volcanic geothermal resources exploited in other parts of the world, however it is home to some
of the hottest high-heat producing granites in the world.
14.1. Introduction
Figure 68 -
Figure 69 -
Terratherma
TM
LTD
Figure 72 -
Figure 70 -
Cooper Basin
(South Australia)
Terratherma
TM
LTD
62
63
Introduction
The development of the Australian geothermal energy sector is
influenced by the supportive regulatory environment, and the
major technical progress achieved by independent geothermal
explorers assessing a range of geothermal projects. Despite
the significant potential, the Australian geothermal industry is
considered an emerging industry with major risks. The size of
the Australian geothermal sector, as determined by the market
value of Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) listed geothermal
companies is approximately $500 million. In comparison, many
small to medium-tier oil and gas companies with significantly
reduced upside potential, regularly trade with capitalisations
similar to the entire Australian geothermal sector.
During 2009, Dr Graeme Beardsmore from Hot Dry Rocks Pty Ltd
compiled heat flow measurements from a number of regional
datasets to compile a surface heat flow map for Australia (figure
71). The map is a useful guide in highlighting potential regions
of interest for geothermal exploration, however is severely
limited in many regions due to the scarcity of local heat flow
data. An earlier version of the heat flow map was developed
(figure 72) in 2007 from data obtained from Geoscience Australia
up until 2005, and was used to make estimates of subsurface
temperatures at a depth of 5,000m across Australia. The crustal
temperature map suffers from similar limitations to the heat
flow map.
Figure 73 -
Investment Performance
A recently published research report by Activated Logic (AGI,
2009) found that the value of the Australian geothermal sector
as measured by the Australian Geothermal IndexTM (figure 75)
had decoupled from the broader Australian equities market
since April 2009.
Figure 75 -
600
400
350
500
Expenditure A$ million
300
400
250
300
200
150
200
100
100
50
0
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
64
2007
Annual
Cumulative
2008
2009
Figure 74 -
Industry Development
The Australian geothermal industry through its two peak
bodies, the Australian Geothermal Energy Association (AGEA)
and the Australian Geothermal Energy Group (AGEG) have
identified key challenges facing the industry.
Approximately
50
companies
holding almost 400 geothermal
exploration licences (figure 73) are in
the process of exploring, evaluating
and
developing
geothermal
resources in Australia. Since the
year 2000 when the first geothermal
exploration Licences were issued
in South Australia, geothermal
activity has escalated rapidly, with
annual investment into the Australia
geothermal sector approaching
$200 million during 2009 (figure
74). With a number of geothermal
projects reaching more advanced
stages, the rate of investment is
forecast to accelerate further.
Regulatory Environment
The key market mechanism for ensuring the large scale
adoption of renewable energy in Australia is the mandatory
renewable energy target (MRET) set by the Federal Government.
In addition, the government is pressing ahead with a proposed
carbon pollution reduction scheme (CPRS) with the emissions
trading scheme at the heart of the plan, although the plan has
been met with resistance in parliament (figure 76).
Additional information, refer to Chapter 8.
Geothermal Technology
The development and adoption of new technologies is essential
for the development of the Australian geothermal sector,
and was addressed by the Geothermal Industry - Technology
Roadmap (DRET, 2008).
Additional Information, refer to Section 13.2.
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
65
2050
2040
2030
2020
Figure 76 -
2019
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
pre
2007
Source: Activated Logic, 2009. Compiled from various proprietary and public sources.
66
Scaled-up Plants
Commercial Electricity Production
2015
Figure 77 -
2016
2017
2018
2014
67
Economies of Scale
Small scale geothermal projects, including early stage
demonstration projects are expensive on a per megawatt basis
(figure 79), as many major costs such as drill rig mobilisation are
fixed costs, independent of the size of the project. Larger projects
are able to take advantage of these economies of scale. The
recently awarded, renewable energy demonstration program
(REDP) grants are important in funding early stage projects.
Introduction
As outlined in previous sections (figures 9 - 12), the expansion of
the global geothermal industry has been progressing strongly.
However, particularly in the post global financial crisis (GFC)
environment, the shortage of capital is proving to be the major
bottle-neck in the commercialisation and broader adoption of
geothermal energy, globally. The lack of capital is severe across
all levels of the geothermal value-chain, but is particularly
problematic at the earlier exploratory stages of development,
where risks are deemed to be unacceptable for prospective
investors.
Large, proven, conventional geothermal projects at the advanced
stages of development, in established geothermal areas such
as the western United States or Indonesia have been able to
raise capital through project financing. In contrast, smaller,
earlier stage projects with unproven geology and speculative
(inferred) geothermal resources, particularly EGS projects are
experiencing major difficulties in raising capital to explore and
develop these projects. The immediate priority for the majority
of Australian geothermal projects is to raise additional capital to
be able to conduct proof of concept activities.
Figure 80 -
Financing Challenges
In general, all geothermal investment requirements up until a
small scale power plant is built on site, are funded by at-risk
capital, effectively equity from private investors, venture capital
funds, or other early stage investors (figure 80). In late 2009,
Australian geothermal company - Geodynamics, indicated
that in order to be able to access more attractive capital from
traditional project finance (debt) sources, an intermediate sized
(25MW) commercial demonstration plant (figure 66) would
need to be built and operated successfully for a year.
Additional information, refer to Chapter 5.
Securing
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from AGEA & MMA data, 2009.
Figure 79 -
68
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from AGEA & MMA data, 2009.
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
69
Part G
Figure 81 -
..............................................
72
15.1.
Corporate Overview
..............................................
72
15.2.
Company History
..............................................
72
15.3.
Corporate Vision
..............................................
73
15.4.
Corporate Strategy
..............................................
73
15.5.
..............................................
74
15.6.
..............................................
75
15.7.
..............................................
75
15.8.
..............................................
76
15.9.
..............................................
77
15.10.
..............................................
78
Cycle efficiency
Source: Activated Logic, 2009. Adapted from MMA data, 2008 & data from Garnaut Review, 2008.
$120
$97
$100
$99
$98
$63.70
$60
$40
$20
$0
HSA
EGS
Average
Geothermal
Cycle Efficiency
Heat Exchanger
70
Combined
Improvement in Geothermal
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from AGEA 2009 Survey data, and QGECE efficiency estimates.
Combined innovations
$82.32
$79.38
$80
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 71
LTD
TM
The goal to identify and potentially commercialise geothermal resources in Australia is well advanced for
Terratherma Ltd, as the company was one of the first in Australia to apply for geothermal exploration licences.
With the assistance of parent company Eden Energy Ltds expertise in the hydrogen market, Terratherma Ltd has
the opportunity to potentially commercialise a number of highly prospective geothermal projects.
Company Status
MEMBER
AGEA
Australian Geothermal
Energy Association
MEMBER
AGEG is an organisation focused on
improving the technical capability of
the Australian Geothermal Industry.
72
Figure 83 -
Technical Drivers
Commercial Drivers
Terratherma
TM
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
Source: Activated Logic, 2010. Adapted from Eden Energy Ltd, 2009.
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
73
Resource
Classification
The rates of reaction and thermal conversion efficiencies are typically high for high temperature
geothermal resources, however at these temperatures resources are less common.
90 C
o
Moderate
Temperature
HYDROGEN PRODUCTION
150oC
ELECTRICITY GENERATION
High
Temperature
350oC
Figure 85 -
Licence
number
Ltd
has
assembled
robust
Licence holder
Interest (%)
100
30
70
Origin Energy Limited is earning a 70% by having paid $1m to Eden Energy Ltd
upfront and making a contribution of $500,000 to exploration expenditures.
Terratherma
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
Low
Temperature
40oC
The extraction of energy from low temperature geothermal resources, is difficult as these resources
contain low levels of energy, and the thermal conversion efficiencies are typically very low.
Source:: Activated Logic, 2010.
74
Terratherma
Ltd
proposes
an
innovative
Figure 86 -
75
Figure 87 -
Prominent Hill
Olympic Dam
TECHNICAL DRIVERS
Figure 88 -
Leigh Creek
Pt Aug
Augu
A
Augusta
ug
100
Reservoir Volume
A given sub-surface space hosted within a prospective geological
sequence in which geothermal energy is hosted and is suitable
kilometres
Figure 89 -
Reservoir
Volume
-3
Heat production (Wm )
76
Reservoir
Temperature
Reservoir
Flow Rate Capacity
TECHNICAL
DRIVERS
Power Cycle
Technology
Proximity to
Infrastructure
High value
Markets
Project
Integration
COMMERCIAL DRIVERS
77
Part H
COMMERCIAL DRIVERS
The key commercial drivers utilised in the Geothermal
Assessment MatrixTM are determined by a combination of cost,
location and market driven parameters. The specific exploration
and development costs, the operation and maintenance costs,
the distance to major electricity markets, and the availability of
high value markets are some of the major commercial drivers.
A brief explanation of each of the key commercial drivers
essential for geothermal development is described below:
Proximity to Infrastructure
The distance a prospective geothermal project is located
from infrastructure will influence both the exploration and
development costs, as remote projects incur higher costs in
relation to rig-mobilisation and other transportation sensitive
items. In addition, the distance to electricity transmission
infrastructure (figure 16) is another important commercial
consideration as the construction of high voltage powerlines
and sub-stations is a very capital intensive activity.
High Value Markets
The commercial value created by geothermal development is
ultimately derived from being able to generate project revenues
which will exceed the cost of developing and operating a given
geothermal project, over the operating life of a geothermal
project. High value markets provide the greatest opportunity
for significant project profits to be generated, and can be found
in regions of the NEM where the production of peak-time
electricity is lucrative, such as South Australia.
Project Integration
The systematic integration of geothermal development with
other industrial applications, provides opportunities to improve
project economics and overall commerciality by realising overall
economies of scale, and shared development costs. Terratherma
Ltd has numerous opportunities to potentially integrate both
desalination and/or hydrogen production (figure 29) across its
geothermal project portfolio, presenting significant commercial
opportunities.
16.
..............................................
80
16.1.
Project Overview
..............................................
80
16.2.
..............................................
80
16.3.
Commercial Potential
..............................................
83
17.
..............................................
84
17.1.
Project Overview
..............................................
84
17.2.
..............................................
84
17.3.
Commercial Potential
..............................................
87
18.
..............................................
88
18.1.
Project Overview
..............................................
88
18.2.
..............................................
88
18.3.
Commercial Potential
..............................................
91
19.
..............................................
92
19.1.
Project Overview
..............................................
92
19.2.
..............................................
92
19.3.
Commercial Potential
..............................................
95
78
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 79
LTD
TM
Figure 90 -
VH
Electricity Production
Hydrogen Production
Figure 92 -
Desalination
TM
Prominent Hill
Olympic Dam
Leigh Creek
PROJECT LOCATION
Adelaide
Area of High Heat Flow
Terratherma Ltd GELs
100
kilometres
80
Figure 93 -
Pt Augu
Au
A
Augusta
ugu
The two closest and most relevant drill holes to GEL 169,
Noarlunga-1 and Aldinga-1 (figure 94) intersected basement
between 1500 m and 1600 m below surface. Temperature at
the basement interface is less than 100C at both locations,
implying that any commercial geothermal energy resource in
GEL 169 will be located within the basin basement. The precise
basement lithologies are not yet known.
The available data suggest that heat flow is 100 mW/m within
Noarlunga-1, and 119 mW/m within Aldinga-1. Note that the
figure for Noarlunga 1 is based on what Terratherma considers
to be a conservative estimate of bottom hole temperature, and
thus represents a conservative estimate of heat flow.
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
Bollards Lagoon
81
Figure 94 -
Figure 95 -
Figure 96 -
Terratherma Ltd
GEL 169
82
83
Figure 97 -
Prominent Hill
Olympic Dam
Leigh Creek
Pt Augu
Au
A
Augusta
ugu
PROJECT LOCATION
Adelaide
Area of High Heat Flow
Terratherma Ltd GELs
100
kilometres
84
Figure 98 -
Figure 102 -
Figure 103 -
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
Moomba North
Figure 101 -
Whilst no heat flow wells exist within the licence area (figure
104), numerous heat flow measurements have been calculated
from well temperatures directly to the south of GEL 185. Heat
flow within the licence area is expected to be a low risk, as the
majority of heat flow measurements from a large sample size in
the Cooper Basin indicate typically high values (figure 98).
TM
VH
Figure 100 -
A seismic line (figure 99) which intersects GEL 185 in a northsouth direction was interpreted by HDRPL, and the results
confirm the deepening of the basement geology towards the
northern end of the licence, away from the Moomba gas field.
The sediments which overlay the basement in this area are the
thickest in the entire Cooper Basin and are often associated
with the majority of oil and gas reservoirs in the Cooper Basin,
but have not been drilled at this location as they are in a trough,
a poor petroleum exploration target. The topographic peak
of the regional geological structures in the licence area is the
Moomba gas field, and the thickness of sediments increase
away from the structural high (figures 100 - 103).
Figure 99 -
85
Figure 104 -
Figure 105 -
86
87
Figure 106 -
VH
TM
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
Coorichina
Prominent Hill
Olympic Dam
Leigh Creek
PROJECT LOCATION
Adelaide
Area of High Heat Flow
Terratherma Ltd GELs
100
kilometres
88
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
Interpreted Seismic Section (through GEL 329, refer to Figure 109 for location)
Pt Augu
Au
A
Augusta
ugu
89
TM
Figure 109 -
Figure 110 -
Terratherma Ltd
GEL 329 & 330
90
91
Figure 111 -
VH
Figure 112 -
Terratherma
TM
LTD
Technical Prospectivity
Commercial Prospectivity
Electricity Production
Terratherma Ltd
GELs
Regional
Heat Flow
101mW/m2
Hydrogen Production
Desalination
TM
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
Pirie
Prominent Hill
Olympic Dam
Leigh Creek
Pt Augu
Au
A
Augusta
ugu
PROJECT LOCATION
Adelaide
Area of High Heat Flow
Terratherma Ltd GELs
100
kilometres
92
Regional
Heat Flow
101mW/m2
Regional
Heat Flow
91mW/m2
93
Figure 113 -
Figure 114 -
94
95
Part I
Commercialising Geothermal
20.
Geothermal - Commercialisation
..............................................
98
20.1.
Introduction
..............................................
98
20.2.
..............................................
98
20.3.
..............................................
99
20.4.
Geothermal Financing
..............................................
100
21.
..............................................
101
21.1.
Introduction
..............................................
101
21.2.
..............................................
101
21.3.
..............................................
103
21.4.
..............................................
103
21.5.
..............................................
103
22.
..............................................
105
22.1.
Introduction
..............................................
105
22.2.
Project Scale
..............................................
105
22.3.
TGP-FM Overview
..............................................
105
22.4.
..............................................
106
22.5.
..............................................
108
22.6.
..............................................
109
22.7.
..............................................
110
22.8.
..............................................
111
22.9.
..............................................
111
23.
..............................................
112
96
Terratherma
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION
MEMORANDUM I 97
LTD
TM
Terratherma Ltds geothermal projects are at various stages of development, It is envisaged that the exploration
and development of the geothermal projects may be accelerated through the delineation of significant geothermal
resources, and the subsequent rapid commercialisation through the rapid development of an attractive business
model. The integrated geothermal applications are expected to enhance project competitiveness.
20.1. Introduction
Figure 115 -
Terratherma
- Inferred
- Indicated
Figure 116 -
- Measured
Geothermal Reserve
- Probable
- Proven
Terratherma
98
99
Terratherma Ltd holds a large geothermal exploration portfolio in South Australia, and is in the unique position
of being able to potentially develop integrated applications for exploiting the significant geothermal potential.
In order to demonstrate the vast value which may be realised from Terratherma Ltds geothermal portfolio, a
conceptual plan has been prepared for one possible scenario based on a 100MW electricity generation project.
Figure 118 -
21.1. Introduction
Figure 119 -
Development
GEOTHERMAL PROJECTS
Geothermal Energy
ELECTRICITY
HYDROGEN
Desalination
100
WATER
101
Figure 120 -
STAGE 1
Proof of Concept
STAGE 2
Validation & Optimisation
STAGE 3
Commercial Scale-up
Objective:
To drill test the target geothermal reservoir and confirm the presence of a
suitable geothermal reservoir for either HSA or EGS based on the interpreted
geological model. Target temperatures are expected to be in the range of
170oC - 220oC. Successfully fracture stimulate the injection well,
then optimally drill a production well and improve the connectivity of the
reservoir through stimulation. Demonstrate productive interconnectivity between wells
and confirm through extended closed-loop flow test.
Start Date:
Confirm the proof of concept results, by validating additional geological data including
stress testing and reservoir growth monitoring, additional reservoir engineering
and testing to determine optimal strata for well completion based on pressure,
porosity, flow rate and temperature. Incorporate information into optimal well
configurations and power plant, size, type working fluid.
Start Date:
Figure 121 -
Start Date:
102
30 years
170oC
If;
the average reservoir temperature is:
Objective:
Source: Tester, 2006. Adapted from Professor Hal Gurgenci QGECE, 2008.
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
103
Figure 122 -
2050
2040
2030
Start.
Proof of Concept
Proof of concept based on fluid circulation
between two wells achieved December 31st 2013.
Reservoir Engineering
104
Finalise
Validation & Optimisation
Commercial Scale-up
2020
~ 1,000 MWe
~ 500 MWe
~ 250 MWe
~ 200 MWe
2019
A detailed financial model, the Terratherma Geothermal Project - Financial Model (TGP-FM) has been developed
to provide a structured understanding of the impacts of key input variables such as power output per well, to the
overall project economics. The systematic and dynamic assessment of Terratherma Ltds geothermal projects
through the TGP-FM allows for project optimisation and also prioritisation.
22.1. Introduction
The Terratherma Geothermal Project - Financial Model (TGPFM) is a Microsoft Excel based dynamic spreadsheet (Appendix
2) with approximately 50 input variables and a number of
interlinked worksheets which provide key data outputs. The
TGP-FM is a valuable tool in rapidly assessing the impacts of
changes to key project parameters, provides an indication
of possible valuations and also highlights the prospective
commerciality of a conceived geothermal development.
2018
~ 100 MWe
2017
2016
~ 30 MWe
Proven Reserve
2015
~ 5 MWe
Probable Reserve
EXPLORATORY PRE-FEASIBILITY
2014
Measured Resource
Inferred Resource
pre 2014
~ 1 MWe
FINANCIAL MODEL
Terratherma
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
TM
105
Figure 124 -
Figure 125 -
Full details of the rationale and explanation for each of the data
inputs is provided in the actual TGP-FM (Appendix 2), however
an overview of each of the data input tables is given below.
Input Table 1.1 (figure 123)
This conceptual development scenario assumes major funding
for the proposed project will come from the listing of the project
entity in an initial public offering (IPO), with the founders (the
parent company) receiving a proportion of the issued equity.
For the purposes of conducting this specific scenario analysis,
and consistent with the Validation and Commercial Scaleup Timeline (figure 122) it is assumed the 100MW conceptual
development will be completed during 2017.
Input Table 1.2 (figure 124)
The conceptual development scenario assumes 18
production wells will be required with a production capacity
of approximately 5.6MW (electrical) per well to achieve the
proposed 100MW nameplate capacity target. The capacity
factor assumed in the analysis was 95%, which is very high
for any form of power generation, but frequently achieved
for binary cycle based geothermal systems (figure 7) as the
geothermal fluids do not come in contact with important
power plant components due to the working fluid. The assumed
Figure 123 -
106
107
Figure 128 -
Figure 129 -
12.4%
$100 million
Payback period
9 years
$6 million
$48.27
4.8%
7.2%
53%
Figure 127 -
Figure 130 -
Based
108
109
Figure 131 -
Figure 132 -
110
The sensitivities (figures 129 - 132) conducted for the TGPFM provide insights into the ultimate benefit of synergies
which may be realised through an integrated geothermal
development. The impacts of a high capacity factor (figure
130) are significant in maximising project value as measured by
NPV, and highlight the importance of ensuring the geothermal
capacity is utilised as intensively as possible.
111
Based
112
Part J
Supplementary Information
24.
Risks
..............................................
114
24.1.
..............................................
114
24.2.
..............................................
119
24.3.
Other Risks
..............................................
119
25.
Definitions
..............................................
120
26.
References
..............................................
122
LTD
TM
24. Risks
There are a number of risk factors, both specific to the Company (Terratherma Ltd) and of a general nature, which
may affect the financial position, financial performance, cash flows and growth prospects of the Company, the
ability of the Company to pay dividends and the outcome of an investment in the Company. There can be no
guarantee that the Company will achieve its stated objectives or that forward looking statements will be realised.
Discussed below are certain, but not all, risks associated with an investment in Terratherma Ltd or its projects. Each of the risks
set out below could, if they eventuate, have an adverse material impact on the performance of Terratherma Ltd or its projects.
Any potential investment in the Company carries risk and, before deciding to invest in the Company, potential Applicants should
read this Information Memorandum in its entirety and, in particular, should consider the risk factors that could affect the financial
performance of the Company.
Neither Terratherma nor its officers, employees, agents and advisers guarantee that any specific objectives of Terratherma will be
achieved or that any particular performance of the Shares, including those offered under this Prospectus, will be achieved.
selecting project areas the Company has relied on interpretations of the likely depth to geothermal resources based on in house
and public domain data. These project areas have only limited direct information about the actual rocks present in the project
areas, generally from a limited number of drill holes. In most cases, drilling has only penetrated a short distance into the areas in
question. Interpretations of the geology at depth have therefore been extrapolated from geological maps, available drilling results
and interpretation of geophysical data. These interpretations are therefore largely based on geophysical and other data that may
not be unique and the source data used in these interpretations may not therefore be fully representative of the regional geology
of the project area. A significant risk exists that geothermal resources of economic temperatures may not be present at depths
reachable with commercial drilling technology. Additionally, viable resources rely on the depth of cover rocks and on the insulating
ability of the cover sequence.
Temperature Modelling
A fundamental part of the Companys proposed exploration approach is mapping heatflow using data from shallow drill holes
and then extrapolating those results to reservoir depths. Measuring heat flow in shallow holes and extrapolating the results to
significant depths assumes heat is only transferred by conduction through the rock column. However, groundwater flow through
rocks can redistribute heat by convection. Heat distribution may have a positive or negative impact on predicted temperature at
depth, and it is difficult to quantify or predict without independent evidence of groundwater flow. The Company believes that the
proposed modelling approach (which assumes no heat redistribution) is an appropriate tool to use, but should the assumptions of
this model prove inaccurate then misleading results may be obtained.
Nature of the Reservoir
A key component of the Companys philosophy is that a reservoir of heat will exist at a depth reachable by drilling, and that the
reservoir will be, or can be made to be, permeable enough to allow sufficient heat transfer between the reservoir and injected
waters such that the injected waters return to the surface hot enough to drive surface electricity generating equipment. The size,
depth, temperature and permeability characteristics of the Companys target reservoir(s) is uncertain at present. These factors will
be a focus of the Companys evaluation and technical work programme.
Induced Seismicity
The process of enhancing a deep reservoir to increase water permeability will affect the stress levels in the reservoir and this may
result in induced seismicity. The amount of seismicity rarely is at the level that is able to be felt by people on the surface. A study
commissioned by the International Energy Agency found that such induced seismicity is below the background coefficient of
ground acceleration, meaning that building design standards adequately cater for the maximum expected seismicity. It should be
noted that the phenomenon of induced seismicity is usually associated with the stimulation and enhancement of deep geothermal
reservoirs and not the utilisation of shallower, aquifer hosted geothermal resources that will be explored nearer urban areas.
available water;
the presence of adequately permeable aquifers or a rock unit susceptible to artificial permeability enhancement; and
The operations of the Company may be affected by various factors including failure to locate or identify commercially viable
geothermal resources, the failure to achieve predicted temperatures and circulation in exploration and production, difficulties in
commissioning and operating plant and equipment, mechanical failure or plant breakdown, inability to obtain satisfactory joint
venture partners, difficulties in obtaining requisite planning approvals and adverse weather conditions. No assurances can be given
that the Company will achieve commercial viability through the successful exploration and (subject to appropriate regulatory
approvals) production of its tenements or its tenement interests. Until the Company is able to realise value from its projects, it will
incur ongoing operating losses.
114
Even assuming that viable geothermal resources are located, the quality and rate of production of hot water will be variable
(depending, for example on the size of the geothermal resources, timing and/or success of development work and reservoir
quality). Production may be impacted or shut down for considerable periods of time due to any of the following factors:
operational and technical difficulties;
government regulation;
pipeline and processing interruptions;
equipment failure;
equipment or manpower shortages;
diminished pipeline capacity;
reservoir failures;
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
115
force majeure;
24.1.6 Competition
well blowouts;
Competition may have a material adverse effect on the Company. There is always the risk of competition both in relation to the
extraction of geothermal energy by other producers and the creation of electricity from other non-renewable energy (such as coal,
oil and gas) and renewable energy (such as wind, hydro or solar power) sources. These other energy sources may be able to produce
energy at lower costs, thus reducing demand for the Companys geothermal energy. One of the advantages for geothermal energy
is that it produces no carbon dioxide. However, other alternative clean energy systems, such as wind or solar, produce very low
levels (if any) of carbon emissions.
There is a risk that exploration costs may be greater than estimated in this Information Memorandum as a result of cost overruns
in drilling and other equipment failure. Adverse weather conditions over a prolonged period can also adversely affect exploration
costs. Should the Company proceed to the development phase, the design and construction of efficient generation facilities will
need to remain within capital expenditure budgets in order for development to be commercially successful.
Interests in exploration and mining tenements in Australia are governed by legislation and are evidenced by the granting of
leases or licences. Each lease or licence is for a specific term and carries with it annual expenditure and reporting conditions as
well as other conditions requiring compliance. These conditions include the requirement, particularly for exploration licences, for
compulsory reduction in the area held under licence from time to time. The Company could also lose title to the tenements it has
applied for (assuming they are granted) or its interest in the tenements the subject of the Deed of Assignment, if it or Eden (prior
to the date when the tenements the subject of the Deed of Assignment are assigned to the Company) does not meet the licence
conditions or if insufficient funds are available to meet expenditure commitments. The loss of granted tenements or the inability to
obtain new tenements may have a material adverse effect on the Companys financial position, financial performance, cash flows,
growth prospects, ability to pay dividends and Share price. Further, it is possible that the Company may in the future enter into
joint ventures with third parties, which raises the possibility of disputes and potential conflict with such joint venture parties which
would have a material adverse effect on the Company and its projects
The Company is planning to raise sufficient funds to cover approximately two years of working capital requirements and, subject
only to the terms of any joint venture which may be entered into, the Company is likely to have to raise further capital prior to
the initial capital being exhausted. In this regard, capital costs in developing any of the tenements and tenement applications
in which the Company has an interest and bringing it into production will be significant. Any project areas that proved to be
commercially viable would ultimately require further major funding for deep circulation wells, reservoir fracturing, power plants
and infrastructure. The Companys ability to raise further equity or debt, or to divest part of its interest in the said tenements and
tenement applications, and the terms of such transactions, will vary according to a number of factors, including the success of
exploration results and the future development of projects, stock market conditions and energy prices. There is no guarantee that
such additional funds will be available to the Company and the Company may be adversely affected in a material way if, for any
reason, access to such funds is not available.
The Company will have to obtain retention licences and production licences to extract or release geothermal energy. Native title
legislation could apply to the grant of these licences and require the Company to follow the right to negotiate procedure before
such tenements could be validly granted.
The geothermal energy industry is newer and riskier than other energy industries. In order to access geothermal resources, drilling
is generally required at a deeper level. The deeper the drilling the higher the operational risk. Exploration and commercialisation
technology for geothermal resources is newer and relatively untested compared to other more established energy industries.
Whilst direct heat application of geothermal waters has been exploited at a number of places in the world, this has not been done
on a widespread scale. In respect of electricity generation, there is currently only one example of a Hot Dry Rock type geothermal
system producing electricity into a grid anywhere in the world and, while quite common throughout the world, only one small
scale conventional hydrothermal power system is in operation in Australia. As such, the commercial barriers to entry may not yet
be fully understood.
The geothermal exploration licences (GEL) granted to the Company and Eden Energy Ltd (in the later case, being the subject of the
Deed of Assignment) by the South Australian government have been made available on the basis that the Native Tile Acts (NTA)
Right To Negotiate (RTN) procedure does not apply. The basis for this interpretation has never been tested by any Court. If this
interpretation were tested, the Company may be required to reapply for its GELs and comply with the right to negotiate process
or negotiate an agreement with native title parties. There may be areas in the tenements and tenement applications in which the
Company has an interest or
116
in the future may acquire such an interest (including under the Deed of Assignment) over which legitimate common law native
title rights of Aboriginal Australians exist. If native title rights do exist, the ability of the Company to obtain the consent of any
TERRATHERMA LTD I INFORMATION MEMORANDUM I
117
relevant land owner, or to progress from the exploration phase to the development and production phases of the operation, may
be adversely affected. The NTA provides a series of procedures which the Company may need to comply with in order to be granted
additional rights in relation to land in respect of which native title has been determined to exist or a native title claim has been
registered. These procedures may require the negotiation of significant agreements with native title parties and may require the
payment of compensation for loss of or impairment of any native title rights and interests. Significant resources may be required
to administer any native title agreements in relation to which the Company is required to become a party. The success and costs of
administration of these native title issues may have a material adverse impact on the Company and its projects.
24.1.14 No Valuation
No formal valuation of any of the tenements and tenement applications in which the Company has an interest or the Shares has
been carried out. The Company makes no representation as to the value of the tenements and tenement applications in which it
currently holds an interest. It is recommended that Applicants and their advisors should make their own assessment as to the value
of the Companys project areas.
24.1.18 Insurance
Insurance of risks associated with the development of geothermal resources may not be available or may attract large premiums.
Accordingly, if a commercially viable geothermal resource is located, no assurance can be given that the Company will be able to
obtain such insurance coverage at reasonable rates, or that any coverage it arranges will be adequate and able to cover all claims
which may possibly arise out of its operations. If the Company incurs uninsured losses or liabilities, this could have a material
adverse effect on the Company or its projects.
118
119
25. Definitions
Activated Logic means Activated Logic Pty Limited, the
company which has assisted the Company in the preparation
of this Information Memorandum;
AEMC means Australian Energy Market Commission;
AEMO means Australian Energy Market Operator;
AGEA means Australian Geothermal Energy Association;
AGEG means Australian Geothermal Energy Group;
AGITM means Australian Geothermal Index, an equity
index published by Activated Logic;
AGRCC means the Australian Geothermal Reporting
Code Committee;
ASIC means the Australian Securities & Investment
Commission;
Associate has the same meaning as in the Corporations
Act;
ASX means the Australian Securities Exchange Limited;
BFS means Bankable Feasibility Study;
BFS means Bankable Feasibility Study;
BHT means Bottom Hole Temperature;
Business Day means a day, other than a Saturday or
Sunday, on which banks are open for general banking
business in Adelaide;
Geothermal
Industry
Development
120
energy
consulting
Market
Electricity
National
MT means Magnetotellurics;
121
26. References
This Information Memorandum has been prepared
for a specific purpose and is not intended for general
circulation. Various proprietary sources including
privileged and strictly confidential information
generated and held by Eden Energy Ltd, Terratherma
Ltd and Activated Logic Pty Limited have been used in
the preparation of this Information Memorandum.
The below list of references is intended as a general
overview of some of the public information sources
used to generate this information memorandum, but is
not intended to provide an exhaustive list of resources.
47. DRET, 2008. Australian Geothermal Industry Development Framework. Department of Resources,
Energy and Tourism. December 2008.
48. DRET, 2008. Australian Geothermal Industry - Technology
Roadmap. Department of Resources, Energy and Tourism.
December 2008.
49. CPRS, 2008. Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme White
Paper. Department of Climate Change. December 2008.
Accessed in July 2009 at; http://www.climatechange.gov.
au/whitepaper/index.html
40. UNEP, 2009. The Global Financial Crisis and its Impact on
Renewable Energy Finance. United Nations Environment
Program. April 2009.
11. NWC, 2009. Australian Water Markets Report, 20082009. National Water Commission. November 2009.
122
9. Zactruba, 2009.
Multistage Flash Desalination.
Published by Haresh Khemani. December 2009.
12. HDRPL, 2009. Surface Heat Flow Map. Hot Dry Rocks Pty
Ltd. November 2009.
123
Part K
Geothermal Resources by 2020. McLennan Megasanik
Associates. August 2008.
59. Dundee, 2008. Geothermal Energy - An Oversight
Success in 104 Years. Tharp, I. & Mahesh, S. Dundee Capital
Markets - Investment Research. 17 March 2008.
Appendices
..............................................
126
..............................................
127
..............................................
128
..............................................
130
..............................................
131
124
Terratherma
TM
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
LTD
TM
Licence
number
Licence holder
Area
(km2)
100
01-Feb-2011
498
166
30
70
07-Jan-2011
494
2
165
Origin Energy Limited is earning a 70% by having paid $1m to Eden Energy Ltd upfront and
making a contribution of $500,000 to exploration expenditures.
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
100
100
03-Oct-2013
03-Oct-2013
497
496
2
2
166
165
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
13-May-2014
498
500
495
499
485
498
500
498
498
470
499
498
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
166
166
165
166
161
166
166
166
166
156
166
166
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
Terratherma Limited
EXPLORATORY PRE-FEASIBILITY
FINANCIAL MODEL
Terratherma
TM
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
126
127
Additional ASX announcements made by Eden Energy Limited, including the Term Sheet announcement to scale-up the
innovative Pyrolysis Technology with India Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL) on the 5th of February is available for download from
the Eden Energy Limited website (refer to Appendix 4) or by visiting the Australian Securities Exchange website.
128
129
Contact Details
Eden Energy Limited
Ph:
+61 (08) 9282 5889
Fax:
+61 (08) 9282 5866
Email: mailroom@edenenergy.com.au
Web: www.edenenergy.com.au
Corporate Structure
Terratherma Ltd (ABN: 75 126 933 140) is a 100% wholly owned
subsidiary of ASX-listed, Eden Energy Ltd (ASX: EDE).
Energy Assets
(Ireland)
(Various)
Hythane
Company LLC
Eden Energy
India Pvt Ltd
Coal Seam
Methane
Natural Gas
South Australia
(USA)
(India)
(Wales, UK)
(Australia)
Terratherma
TM
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
MEMBER
AGEA
Australian Geothermal
Energy Association
MEMBER
AGEG is an organisation focused on
improving the technical capability of
the Australian Geothermal Industry.
Terratherma Ltd
(Australia)
Terratherma Ltd holds a significant
geothermal exploration portfolio in South
Australia consisting of 16 Geothermal
Exploration Licences (GELs), covering an
area of 7923km2.
Eden Energy Limited is seeking prospective
project development partners or investors to
assist with the evaluation and the potential
development of the geothermal portfolio.
Terratherma GELs
Source: Adapted from Electranet, 2009.
130
131
TM
Terratherma
LTD
SUSTAINABLE GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
TM