Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
: equal opportunity,
not lead to equal outcomes across all social groups? What role do
teachers play in reproducing class-based educational inequality?
looking
into
sociology
in
education
has
consistently
that,
through
various
mechanisms,
result
in
the
social
inequality,
and
how
does
class-based
inequality
result
in
one
another
(Thomson
2002).
Cultural
capital,
or
the
and
dispositions
along
with
an
individuals
combined
experiences that guide the way they perceive, understand and respond to
the world (Tyler 2001, Bok 2010). Within the context of the classroom
alone, teachers exert a level of autonomy through their pedagogical
practices and choices, from the seating arrangements to the behaviour
management strategies, all of which impact on the social climate of the
classroom (Tyler 2001). This in turn impacts on how the students utilise
their habitus and the resources within them (Tyler 2001). Appadurais
(2004) theorisation of aspiration is also pertinent here. The capacity to
aspire, or the ability to read a map of a journey into the future, is
influenced by previous experiences, navigational information and the
courage to explore unmapped pathways (Appadurai 2004). That students
from lower-class backgrounds with less knowledge about and experience
with such maps have less developed capacities to realise their
aspirations suggests that aspiration is a cultural capacity, and not a
personal motivational trait (Bok 2010). While a few students may be able
to adapt to this environment and go against the trends, for most of these
students, this unsuccessful experience becomes the foundation upon
which their future navigational capacities are built. It is understandable,
then, since the capacity to aspire thrives and survives on practice,
repetition, exploration, conjecture and refutation (Appadurai 2004), that
these
students
are
unsuccessful
at
negotiating
their
educational
pathways. As teachers, we need to support these students from lowerclass backgrounds in navigating their aspirational maps, so that they do
not perceive and accept their subordinate positions to be the natural
order of things (Bok 2010). I will also endeavour to build strong,
meaningful relationships with my students because I believe that students
who are able to identify with their teachers and school are more likely to
think of themselves as learners.
The virtual schoolbag refers to the knowledge and skills students
bring with them to school (Thomson 2002). According to Thomson (2002),
a successful student is one who acquires much of the dominant habitus
from their schooling. This means that students whose cultural capitals are
less valued in education and whose virtual schoolbag contents are less
congruent with the academic curriculum have to reinvent themselves in
order to fulfil the required conditions to achieve success, and usually at
some psychological cost (Thomson 2002, Reay 2002). Reays (2002)
telling of the story of a young boys struggle to achieve educational
success in a working-class school setting while maintaining white workingclass
masculinities
shows
the
prominent
implication
of
class
on
my
practices
and
approaches
incorporate
strategies
appropriate for all my students, and that I integrate where possible their
different systems of being and knowing. It is also necessary that I
maintain pedagogical standards and practices that open access to the
aspirations
low
may struggle
to
implement.
van Zanten (2005) has also shown in his research that effective
schools are characterised by a central focus on learning, as well as a
philosophy centred around the hypothesis that all children can learn. It
has already been suggested by Lam (1997) that working-class parents,
owing to financial limitations, may lower their expectations of their
children with regards to their educational achievement (Frohard-Dourlent
2009). It needs to be clarified here that this is not due to the hostile
culture of working-class homes to academic success or the unsupportive,
lackadaisical attitudes of working-class parents towards their childrens
future success as previously suggested research has shown this to be
level
of
parental
involvement
that
educators
and
school
co-workers
and
colleagues
to
transform
our
practices
and
help
establish
and
perpetuate
class-based
educational
(1650 words)
References:
Appadurai, A, 2004, The capacity to aspire: Culture and the terms of
recognition, Culture and public action, pp. 5984.
Bok, J 2010, The capacity to aspire to higher education: Its like making
them do a play without a script, Critical Studies in Education, vol. 51, no.
2., pp. 163-178.
Bourdieu, P 1980, The Logic of Practice, Stanford, Stanford University
Press.
Bourdieu, P 1984, Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste,
London, Routledge.
Frohard-Dourlent, H 2009, Why the school system fails to equalize: the
influence of socioeconomic background on childrens achievement in
school, Sojourners: Undergraduate Journal of Sociology, vol. 1, pp 37-45.
Nieto, S 2000, Placing Equity Front And Center Some Thoughts On
Transforming Teacher Education For A New Century, Journal of Teacher
Education, vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 180-187.
Reay, D 2002, Shauns Story: troubling discourses of white working-class
masculinities, Gender and Education, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 221-234.
Thomson, P 2002, 'Vicki and Thanh' in Schooling the rustbelt kids: making
the difference in changing times, Allen & Unwin, Crows Nest, NSW, pp. 116.
Tyler, S 2011, Transforming inequality in the classroom: Not as easy as it
sounds, Journal of Student Engagement: Education Matters, vol. 1, no. 1,
pp. 21-28.
van Zanten, A 2002, New Modes of Reproducing Social Inequality
Education:
the
changing
role
of
parents,
teachers,
schools
in
and