Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
6171
Department of En ironmental and Resource Sciences MS 370, Uni ersity of Ne ada-Reno, Reno NV 89557, USA
b
En ironmental Sciences Di ision, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831-6038, USA
Received 27 September 1999; accepted 8 March 2000
Abstract
Naturally mercury-enriched substrate is a long-lived source of mercury to the global atmospheric mercury cycle.
Field flux chambers, laboratory gas exchange chambers and micrometeorological methods may be applied to estimate
emissions from these sources. However, field chamber experimental design may affect the magnitude of the fluxes
measured, and the laboratory chamber only provides a minimum estimate of flux. Many factors, such as mercury
concentration and speciation in substrate, light, precipitation, and temperature, influence the emission of mercury
from the substrate. Mercury concentration in the substrate is a dominant factor controlling emissions and may be
used to predict emissions from regions of mercury enrichment. Mercury fluxes measured from three areas of natural
enrichment and three areas with low levels of mercury enrichment are 15 orders of magnitude greater than the
value applied to global belts of natural enrichment. Preliminary scaling of emissions from one of these areas and for
western North America indicates that mercury enriched areas may be significant sources of mercury to the
atmosphere, and that their contribution to regional and global atmospheric budgets needs to be reassessed. 2000
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Mercury; Atmosphere; Emmisions
62
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
1. Introduction
Areas which are geologically or naturally enriched in mercury Hg. are concentrated globally
in association with plate tectonic boundaries, recent volcanism, precious and base metal mineralization, and high crustal heat flow. Although this
manuscript focuses on natural source emissions in
North America, those geologic settings where Hg
is enriched in substrate are distributed globally in
three broad belts. One belt extends from the
southern tip of South America along the western
edges of South, Central and North America to
Alaska. This belt then swings westward to northeast Asia and bifurcates north of Japan. One
splay follows the island arcs through Japan, the
Philippines and Indonesia to New Zealand
and eastern Australia. The second follows the
Himalaya and Alpine Belts to terminate in Spain
Pennington, 1959.. Recent work has documented
the deposition of mercury in sea-floor hydrothermal settings Stoffers et al., 1999. indicating that
mid-ocean ridge systems may be important sources
of mercury to the oceans. Areas containing important commercial concentrations of Hg are
found in China, Italy, Mexico, the Philippines,
Peru, Spain, the Soviet Union, the USA and
Yugoslavia. The worlds most important deposits
of mercury are found in the Mediterranean region, i.e. Almaden, Spain, Monte Amiata, Italy
and Idria, Slovenia Bailey et al., 1973.. In addition, some sedimentary rocks, especially shales
and those containing organic materials, may be
enriched in Hg Turekian and Wedepohl, 1961;
Marowsky and Wedepohl, 1971; Rasmussen et al.,
1998.. We consider the substrate to be enriched
in Hg when it contains ) 0.1 g gy1 of Hg. This
concentration was chosen because ; 0.06 g gy1
represents the average upper crustal abundance
of Hg Wedepohl, 1995. and ; 0.08 g gy1 , the
average concentration of Hg in igneous rocks
Turekian and Wedepohl, 1961; Marowsky and
Wedepohl, 1971.. It has long been recognized
that Hg-enriched substrate emits Hg vapor to the
air cf. Kothny, 1973.. Because of this, and the
association of Hg with precious and base metal
deposits, elevated concentrations of Hg vapor in
air have been used as an exploration tool cf.
Hawkes and Williston, 1962; Williston, 1964; McCarthy, 1972; Varenkamp, 1983; Klussman, 1993..
Mercury is considered a global pollutant because of its potential for long-range transport via
the atmospheric pathway and deposition in
ecosystems remote from anthropogenic Hg
sources. In contrast to anthropogenic point
sources of atmospheric Hg, which are short lived
and emit a high percentage of particulate and
reactive gaseous Hg, natural sources are long
lived ) 10 4 years. and emit primarily elemental
Hg. The latter form of Hg is considered to enter
the global atmospheric Hg pool, whereas particulate Hg and reactive gaseous Hg are deposited
locally and regionally. Estimates of the contribution of Hg from natural sources to the atmosphere have varied widely cf. Lantzy and
Mackenzie, 1979; Watson, 1979; Varenkamp and
Buseck, 1986; Nriagu, 1989; Lindqvist et al., 1991..
In developing recent Hg emission inventories,
most researchers have considered the natural
source term to have contributed a constant
amount of Hg to the atmosphere overtime. A rate
equivalent to ; 1.5 ng my2 hy1 is now widely
used to represent large scale average emissions
from global belts of natural Hg enrichment cf.
Lindqvist et al., 1991; Mason et al., 1994.. This
value has often been derived from the difference
between global anthropogenic emissions and deposition Nriagu and Pacyna, 1988; Nriagu, 1989;
Lindqvist et al., 1991; Mason et al., 1994., neither
of which are well constrained cf. Porcella et al.,
1995; Pai et al., 1998.. Recent measurements of
Hg emissions from naturally enriched areas e.g.
Ferrara et al., 1998; Rasmussen et al., 1998;
Gustin et al., 1999; this paper. suggest that the
contribution of Hg from natural sources to the
regional Hg budgets may be underestimated. In
addition, there are no reliable data to demonstrate that natural source emissions have remained constant over time. Given that the disturbance of naturally enriched areas through
processes such as mining and land development
has resulted in an increase of the exposed surface
area of naturally enriched substrate over time, it
is unlikely that emissions have remained constant.
Emissions from natural sources need to be
better constrained in order to assess the effec-
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
tiveness of regulations and controls for Hg emissions imposed on point sources, and to develop a
complete understanding of the biogeochemical
cycling of Hg in the environment. In order to
develop regional estimates of Hg emissions from
naturally enriched landscapes we must: 1. determine whether methods applied to constrain
emissions from naturally enriched terrains obtain
representative data; 2. determine those environmental factors most important in controlling natural emissions; 3. develop a database of emissions from representative landscapes; and 4. develop a means of scaling up Hg fluxes measured
in situ to large areas. We describe here our
assessment of the current state of these research
needs.
2. Methods assessment
The methods that have been used to measure
Hg emissions in situ include field flux chambers
cf. Xiao et al., 1991; Kim and Lindberg, 1995;
Carpi and Lindberg, 1997; Gustin et al., 1999.
and micrometeorological methods Lindberg et
al., 1995; Poissant and Casimir, 1998; Gustin et
al., 1999.. In addition, laboratory gas exchange
chambers may be used to provide a minimum
estimate of in situ flux from substrate Gustin et
al., 1999a.. These methods were recently compared as part of the Nevada SToRMS mercury
flux methods intercomparison held in Reno,
Nevada cf. Gustin, 1998; Gustin et al., 1999;
Lindberg et al., 1999; Poissant et al., 1999;
Wallschlaeger et al., 1999.. This study demonstrated that micrometeorological methods provide
a useful areal average of Hg fluxes from naturally
enriched areas. However, because the terrain associated with naturally enriched areas is often
rugged and complex, micrometeorological methods may not generally be applicable, and more
portable field chambers must be utilized. Intercomparison of Hg fluxes obtained using these two
methods during Nevada SToRMS demonstrated
that the mean Hg emissions obtained with field
chambers underestimated the flux derived from
micrometeorological data by approximately a factor of 3 Gustin et al., 1999.. Recent research has
63
64
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
Fig. 1. Scatter plot showing the logarithm of Hg flux vs. the logarithm of substrate mercury concentration. Mercury fluxes were
measured using a variety of field chamber designs.
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
65
Fig. 2. Map showing the field sites discussed in this manuscript. The Canadian locations are the research sites of Rasmussen et al.
1998.. This figure is from Gustin et al. 1999a..
Fig. 3. Mercury emissions measured from three areas where a range of concentration of mercury enrichment in substrate is
present. Numbers at the end of the bars represent the mercury concentration in substrate at each site in micrograms per gram.
66
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
Fig. 4. Mercury emissions measured from areas with low levels of mercury enrichment associated with precious metal mineralization Carlin and Comstock. and with organic rich shales Rove Shale.. The estimated flux from global mercuriferous belts is from
Lindqvist et al. 1991. and the data from the Rove Shale is from Rasmussen et al. 1998..
surrounding the area of mining and ore processing all within an ; 1-km2 area.. The Steamboat
Springs data includes an average emission from
the Nevada SToRMS field site, part of an undisturbed area of low Hg-enrichment surrounding an
area where Hg was mined. Mercury flux was also
measured at the Steamboat Mine site, which has
been anthropogenically disturbed and altered.
Fig. 4 shows emissions measured from areas
with low levels of natural enrichment, which cover
far more surface area than those zones of high
Hg enrichment. The average flux estimated for
mercuriferous belts in global models is shown for
comparison. The Carlin Trend and Comstock ore
zones of Nevada have Hg enrichment associated
with gold and silver mineralization. The Proterozoic Rove Shale, that outcrops in the USA and
Canada, covers 300 km2 . Rasmussen et al. 1998.
measured a flux of 35 ng my1 hy1 from this unit.
5. Scaling up
In order to derive estimates of annual Hg flux
for a given district or region, individual flux measurements must be integrated over space and
time. This process is complex because of the large
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
67
Fig. 5. Geologic map of New Idria mining district modified from Eckel and Myers 1946..
68
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
Fig. 6. Map showing the mercury flux values assigned to the New Idria Mining District based upon in situ flux measurements, rock
types and rock alteration.
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
69
Table 1
Parameters used for scaling up mercury emissions from identified areas of mining or prospecting in the western USA
Production
flasks of Hg.
Area applied
km2 .
Emission rate
applied
ng my2 hy1 .
) 1000
1001000
- 100
Prospect or
occurrence
Geothermal
areas
25
20
15
100
30
30
30
10
7
5
4
9
39
11
200
911
100
1259
Annual emission
kg yeary1 .
Number of
reported areas
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by EPRI project manager, Mary Ann Allan. and an EPA-STAR
Grant R825249 project manager, William
Stelz.. The authors thank the participants in the
Nevada SToRMS Project and Cambior Exploration USA, Inc. who provided the database
for Mexican mercury deposits.
References
Bailey E, Clark A, Smith R. United States mineral resources:
mercury. USGS Prof Paper 1973;820:404414.
Bailey E, Phoenix D. Quicksilver deposits in Nevada. Univ
Nevada Bull 1944;38-5:206. Geology and Mining Series no.
41..
Carpi A, Lindberg S. Sunlight-mediated emission of elemental
mercury from soil amended with municipal sewage sludge.
Environ Sci Technol 1997;31:20852091.
Ebinghaus R, Kock H, Hempel M. Determination of mercury
in ambient air using highly time resolved online methods.
Gefahrstoffe-Reinhaltung der Luft 2000, in press.
Eckel E, Myers W. Quicksilver deposits of the new Idria
district San Benito and Fresno counties, California. Calif J
Mines Geol 1946;42:81124.
Ferrara R, Maserti B, Anderson M et al. Atmospheric mer-
70
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
M.S. Gustin et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 259 (2000) 6171
Varenkainp J. Hg anomalies in soils: a geochemical exploration method for geothermal areas. Geothermics 1983;
12:2947.
Varenkamp J, Buseck P. Global mercury flux from volcanic
and geothermal processes. Appl Geochem 1986;1:6573.
Watson W. In: Nriagu JO, editor. Economic considerations in
controlling mercury pollution. Biogeochemistry of mercury
in the environment. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1979:4177.
Wedepohl K. The composition of continental crust. Geochim
Cosmochim Acta 1995;59:12171232.
Williston S. The mercury halo method of exploration. Eng
Min J 1964;165:98101.
71
Wallschlaeger D, Turner R, London J et al. Factors influencing the measurement of mercury emissions from soils measured with field flux chambers. J Geophys Res Atmos
1999;104D17.:21 85921 871.
Xiao Z, Munthe J, Schroeder W, Lindqvist O. Vertical fluxes
of volatile mercury over forest soil and lake surfaces in
Sweden. Tellus 1991;43B:267279.
Zhang H, Lindberg S. Processes influencing the emission of
mercury from soils: a conceptual model. J Geophys Res
Atmos 1999; in press.