Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
FACULTY OF ARTS
Department of English and American Studies
Methodology 3
Alexandra Fintov
VUAjm
2011/2012
Table of contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................................1
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Conclusion..............................................................................................................................17
Bibliography...........................................................................................................................19
Appendix
Introduction
Weve chosen the topic of teaching listening skills as listening is an important part of
any language. Hearing the language is the first thing when we get in touch with it, not just
with foreign languages but also with our mother tongue. As we are not in an English speaking
2
country, most of the time we meet English by hearing it on the TV, radio or in the school.
Language production is rarer this is the reason why this work aims to emphasize the
importance of language acquisition and also language comprehension. This work also intends
deal with the most important issues of teaching listening skills, and to describe and compare
theories and views of different authors on the issues of teaching listening skills.
At first, we would like to introduce listening as a language skill, consider its
importance and place within the other skills by its categorizations. Later on we would like to
introduce two contrasting views on language, namely having purpose to communicate and
being exposed to the language without communicative purpose and consider their importance
in teaching listening skills.
Furthermore, we would like to describe bottom-up and top-down processing by the
points of views of several authors, then analyse Harmers basic methodological model for
teaching receptive skills. We would like to comment also on his suggestions on
appropriateness and difficulty issues of a chosen text in teaching listening skills.
After these two parts, which intends mainly to create a general overview on teaching
listening skills, we would like to go deeper in details by describing and contrasting views on
transactional and interactional listening, then by linking Harmers extensive listening to
Richards listening as acquisition. Here we would like to emphasize the importance of
listening to English language outside the classroom, and show opportunities of using
extensive listening in the classroom by showing some of Richards suggestions to it, including
David Nunans view on this issue.
Still considering the importance of language acquisition, we would like to deal with
drama as a tool for teaching listening skills as it is a tool for creating context to language. This
potential of drama is very important this is the reason why we have chosen to include it in the
work.
As teaching listening skills includes mainly the part of listening comprehension tasks,
we would like to link also Harmers intensive listening to J.C. Richards listening as
comprehension. This part intends to discuss and comment on the main stages in teaching
listening skills, namely the framework of pre-listening, while-listening and post listening; and
also to name some of the most frequent and effective tasks in them.
The last part would deal with the importance of the usage of music and video as these
are most important media in which we and our students can meet the English language. There
would be Nick Peacheys application of the framework for listening to a song which might be
a good example how to use this media in our classroom. There would be also provided some
viewing techniques which might be applicable to watching videos in the classroom.
The practical part would include three activities, one original, one modified, and one
invented. The first activity would focus on listening for gist, the second on listening on
details and the invented activity would be based on the applied framework of Peachy to a
popular song.
In conclusion, this work aims to give the reader a general idea of what teaching
listening skills is and what it includes. It provides examples some issues which can come up
and give some examples of effective tasks and language teaching tools.
and also are present in language learning. On the base of these points, listening can be divided
into listening as comprehension and listening as acquisition.
This division is perfectly pointed out by Jack C. Richards in his work Teaching
Listening and Speaking: From Theory to Practice (2008) where he is dealing with the
traditional way of thinking about the nature of listening. He says that in most methodologies,
listening is considered to be the synonym to listening comprehension and it is based on that
the function of listening in second language learning is to foster the understanding of spoken
discourse. (Richards, 2008:3). However we should not forget about the importance of
language acquisition.
The time we expend on teaching and learning a second language should be effectively
and demandingly used, to create and absorb a strong and meaningful input of the foreign
language. This means that methodologically appropriate tasks should be prepared, language
should be placed to a meaningful context, so the students could profit from it. It is not true
that there is not profit from listening activities in which the students brain is not switched
on we can still absorb pronunciation of sounds, intonation and also stress. We should think
about our childhoods favourite pop songs we were able to sing them phonetically however
we didnt understand the meaning as our level of English was low but we can still recall the
rhythm and the phonetic sounds. Getting the meaning comes with time or never at all I
personally still have moments when I remember a song and I start to sing, then I realize that
the meaningless syllables have meaning.
All in all, listening as comprehension should create the core of teaching listening
skills, and listening as acquisition should be the side dish because both are natural parts of
any language.
Furthermore, Nunan suggests that in the listening process we store meanings, not
linguistic forms (1991:18) - this is the reason why it is important to start a listening activity
with switching on the brain and activating the general knowledge that we all carry.
The methodological model, or procedure that Harmer suggests starts with a lead in
which switches on that general knowledge so basically he would start with top-down
procedure. This concerns mainly general topics different for the proficiency levels or age
groups. For instance: the topic of family, house, towns or people for beginners and maybe the
causes of the global warming for intermediate students. When we look at course books, we
can see that they are built up by these topics. Considering all of this, we have to make
students to get in touch with that knowledge or schema. We can make this by giving them
various key words or showing them pictures.
7
In the basic methodological model for teaching receptive skills Harmer furthermore
suggests starting with the first type of tasks where general understanding is in the focus
students have to extract the most general idea of the text maybe by answering some questions.
Then feedback, directed by teacher goes on, which is followed by text-related tasks and
follow up activities. The text has to be recycled using tasks of the second type, using bottomup procedure, where students go deeply into the text.
In teaching listening, we have to be careful choosing appropriate text there might be
some problems with comprehension. Students have to understand most of the words, because
if there is a dominance of unknown words, they could not get the general idea maybe this is
the reason why he would begin with the top-down procedure. However, this barrier can be
erased by pre-teaching vocabulary. On the other hand there should be some words left
unknown, mainly kind of topic words which can be guessed out of the context. This might
develop the ability of students to understand a text, heard or written, without knowing all of
the words. Harmer suggests (2007:272) other kinds of activities in which there are given
unknown words. Students have to find and research the meaning of the words and guess what
topic may contain them. This might be a perfect lead in activity to listening by bottom-up
procedure.
Texts should be appropriate also in difficulty. Although it is important to choose a text
or recording appropriate for the level, more importance is on the appropriateness of the
follow-up activities. According to Nunans suggestion that listening tasks can be classified as
tasks which involve only listening and which demand some form of oral interaction (Nunan,
1991:20), activities should be designed appropriately considering the objectives and the
purpose of listening. If there is need for oral interactions, students should be prepared also for
that. The activities have to be challenging, but they also should be achievable. Harmer has
suggestions for the issue of appropriateness of the activities, he provides the example of a
news broadcast where the language level is very challenging may be entirely appropriate of
the task only asks them at first to try to identify the five main topics in the broadcast.
(Harmer 2007: 275). However, it might make sense just with higher proficiency and age
levels as their higher general knowledge and longer concentration time would make it more
purposeful- to be in a more life-like language situation
In conclusion, in teaching listening skills, we have to be well-prepared and we have to
think through the whole deeply so we would be able to teach effectively. We have to pay
8
attention to pre-listening activities to activate students brain; we have to make sure that the
text is appropriate to age and proficiency levels, and of course that there are appropriate
follow-up activities regardless the chosen procedures.
3. Transactional Listening and Interactional Listening
There is a differentiation between transactional and interactional purpose for
communication by several authors like Richards or Vandergrift but also Joan Morley. The
descriptions are basically the same: Interactional use of language is socially oriented mainly
to satisfy social needs, like small talk and casual conversations, which means that it is highly
contextualized, involving interaction with a speaker. Transactional use of language is, on the
other hand, message oriented and its main function is to communicate information, or giving
instructions, explaining, describing, giving directions, ordering, requesting and verifying
understanding. (Morley, 2001:79) Vandergrift states that the main difference is between the
two that transactional listening requires accurate comprehension of the message without an
opportunity to clarify it with the speaker. On the other hand Morley suggests that the speaker
may contradict the listener if he or she appears to have misunderstood. Furthermore, Morley
claims that the most important difference between them is that interactional language is a
social type talk it is person oriented rather than message oriented.
All in all, the most important thing, in which both authors agree, is that teachers need to
provide practice experiences in both transactional talk and interactional talk and that student
need to know the purpose and the context of listening in order to know what they need to
listen for specifics or meaning.
would be exposed to the language without a specific comprehension purpose; they would be
in an environment in which they can just acquire the language. I dont say, that there wouldnt
be purpose at all we can give the students tasks for example which are suggested by
Richards for listening as acquisition, which are noticing activities and restructuring activities:
Noticing activities involve returning to the listening texts that served as the basis for
comprehension activities and using them as the basis for language awareness. For example,
students can listen again to a recording in order to:
- Identify differences between what they hear and a printed version of the text
- Complete a cloze version of the text
- Complete sentences stems taken from the text
- Check off entries from a list of expressions that occurred in the text
Restructuring activities are oral or written tasks that involve productive use of selected items
from the listening text. Such activities could include:
-
Listening without purpose is also discussed by David Nunan in his Language Teaching
Methodology. He suggests that an important factor in interactive listening is whether or not we
are taking part in the interaction. If not, it might seem a waste of time to involve learners in
classroom tasks in which they are just listening to others. However, authentic conversations
can provide learners with insights into ways in which conversations work and also with
strategies for comprehending conversation outside the classroom. (1991:24)
In conclusion, there are plenty of things we can do with our students in order to teach
them a second foreign language and that we can and we have to make the learning of the
foreign language the natural part of their lives, outside the classroom also. We, as teachers
should motivate students and guide them to this direction. As being in an environment full of
language with a purpose to listen or without - is natural in our mother tongue, so we should
try to make it also natural in the foreign language. Making extensive listening part of our
classroom would have this effect and also it would be good for creating positive attitude
towards foreign language learning.
10
a shop, a bus station, a restaurant, a van in a train, etc. These scenes create great contexts not
just for learning vocabulary, but they are also bringing grammatical structures alive.
In conclusion, in the context of listening skills, drama plays an important role in
bringing extensive and intensive listening, or listening as comprehension and listening as
acquisition under the same roof as it provides opportunities in developing both and the most
important is that is creates the context to any language learning.
12
actual listening more effective, however as it was also suggested, there are opportunities to
teach unknown vocabulary or phrases inductively.
After this preparatory stage is finished, we can move on to the while-listening stage.
As it was discussed before, we should start with the top-down processing, so we have to make
the first task connected with the general idea of the text. As in the first listening the students
are firstly exposed to a new language, with new accent, voice and language, we shouldnt put
pressure on them by demanding tasks. Students should at first get familiar with the voice,
situation, happening and language which is on the recording. We should just give them simple
questions to look for in the first listening as now we are listening with purpose for
example questions of how many characters are talking, where are they, why are they there. It
should be also obvious that as we are listening, students shouldnt have the tape script in front
of them.
The second listening should be more demanding; students should look deeply into the
text and also look for deeper understanding of the meaning. The most typical tasks here are
gap-fills, ticking items, information search, charts, comparing, correcting, matching, etc.
After these tasks, the third listening should come in order to check their answers, and could be
the base for post-listening activities. Evaluation of the results of decisions during a listening
task is a very important part. Prof. Vandergrift suggests that the teacher should encourage selfevaluation and reflection by asking students to assess the effectiveness of strategies that they
used - group or class discussions can also stimulate reflection and evaluation.
Post-listening is focusing mainly to the reaction to the text. We can ask comprehension
questions, students can do problem solving activities; they can summarize or retell the story
and also write or speak about the heard recording in specifics.
This framework of pre-listening activities and post-listening activities create the
complexity and effectiveness of intensive listening. We, as teachers, should not forget about
them, because listening as comprehension would lose its purpose and sense.
13
Music and video is all around us in this modern world and it is a natural part of our
lives. It creates context and they contain much of language. Why not use them also in foreign
language?
Music lyrics in English language are all around us we hear them in TV, in our
favourite movies on the radio, and in our MP3players. When discussing extensive learning,
we emphasized the importance of listening outside the classroom music has a big potential
for this. Students, mainly teenagers are influenced by music, so motivation would be natural.
On the other hand, music can be used also in the classroom. In the already mentioned article
of Peachey, there is an example of the application of the framework for listening to a song:
Pre-listening
1.
2.
Students describe one of their favourite songs and what they like about it
3.
While listening
1.
2.
Students listen again and order the lines or verses of the song
3.
Students listen again to check their answers or read a summary of the song with errors in
and correct them.
Post-listening
Focus on content
1.
2.
Decide whether they would buy it / who they would buy it for
3.
4.
Focus on form
1.
Students look at the lyrics from the song and identify the verb forms
2.
Students find new words in the song and find out what they mean
3.
while listening into our lessons and we can encourage students to do so outside the classroom
as in extensive listening.
There are some viewing techniques provided by Harmer (2007: 309) which we would
like to shortly describe: fast forward (to talk about the fast forwarded sequence), Silent
viewing for language (to guess what was said/compare), Silent viewing for music (to guess
the mood), freeze frame (prediction), partial viewing (predicting/guessing).
In conclusion, there are lots of other possibilities in both, using music and video in our
classrooms and also outside it. In my opinion, we should not leave them out of our syllabus,
as they can create positive atmosphere in the classroom and towards the language. I also think
that using them in classrooms would make students more aware of the language which would
give them motivation for learning the language also outside the classroom. Other important
thing is that teachers can stay fresh and up-to date which would support the connection
between them and the students.
15
PRACTICAL PART
1. Activity taken from a source
The following activity is taken from Harmers The Practice of English Language
Teaching, where listening for gist of a story is in the focus.
Sorry Im late
Activity: getting events in the right order
Skills: predicting; listening for gist
Age: Young adult and above
Level: lower intermediate
Procedure:
- Make pairs or groups!
- Discuss what is happening on each picture and try to put pictures into a correct order!
- Discuss your prediction with the other groups. Do not confirm or deny their
predictions.
- Play the recording! (Read the tape script.)
- Students check their answers with each other and then, if necessary, listen again to
ensure that they have the sequence correct.
- Play the recording again or give them the tape script. Note phrases which express
regret and apology and the use of repetition in order to be judgmental.
- Write dialogues /role-play similar scenes in which they have to come up with stories
and excuses for being late for school or work.
Aids: pictures, tape script
(Harmer, 2007:311)
Comments: Ive had chosen this activity because I think that the turning point in the story
would interest the students. I think it would also motivate them that it is not an activity from
the course book which can create the illusion of doing something new. The activity doesnt
need too much preparation on the side of the teacher, which makes it practical. I would like to
use this activity, and some other activities designed on the base of this activity, in my future
classroom. Maybe I would involve some drama techniques, mainly in the follow up activities,
when acting it out. (The same persons would have different characteristics in different groups
(good-working/hysterical), different emotions (happy/tired), different situations (platonic
love), etc.
Students will be able to : listen for specific information, create questions and
Procedure
Pre-taught grammar: be going to questions and
short answers, positive and negative sentences
Pre-listening
While
listening
MY MODIFICATION:
Discussion/topic: Plans
What activities do we usually do on Saturdays?
1.) Make pairs! Choose an activity and act it in front
of the others! When guessed, write on the board!
2.) Revision: How do we make questions with
going to? T acts one of the actions written on
the board, Ss ask Qs: Are you going to watch
TV? Who guessed, takes turn.
1.) Listen. What are the people going to do on
Saturday morning? Write the activities. (Fill in
the chart).
1.) Work with a partner. Ask about the people.
2.) Ask and answer with a partner about the
activities.
3.) Ask your partner. What are you going to do at
these times?
Aids
Time
Course
book
5-7
Blackboard
,
chalk
CD player
CD
Course
book
Course
book
5-7
5-7
Post-listening
MY MODIFICATION:
1.) Make pairs and give them the handouts infogap activity. (act. 2+3) English Lesson
Battleship
17
10
MY COMMENTS: The original listening activity remained the same, I added just some prelistening activities and prepared a handout for an information gap activity, which I think is
very suitable for this level - it is entertaining and interesting. They can practice questions and
also short answers in be going to. The pre-listening warm-ups are based on pre-taught
grammar and vocabulary which is practiced with some drama. Adding interesting pre- and
post- listening activities to classic course book activities brings them alive and supports
effective language teaching.
3. My own activity
The following activity is based on the applied framework of Peachy. I would like to apply it
on the popular song: Gotye: Somebody That I Used to know.
Activity: filling the gaps
Skills: listening for specifics, grammar - Past simple
Age: teenagers
Time: 45
Level: Beginners - Pre Intermediate
Stage
Procedure
Pre
-listenin
g
While
-listenin
g
Post
-listenin
g
Aids
Time
Blackboar
d
Chalk
Handout 1
Handout 2
Handout 3
Handout 4
18
5
7
10
2
10
My comments: Ive chosen this song because it is very popular nowadays, it has clear and
understandable lyrics. The lyrics contain Past Simple tense which fits the needs of beginners
or lower intermediate students. I was also curious about the application of Peacheys
framework to a song, and I am sure that I would apply it in the future in my classroom, as I
emphasized how important is to use music as a listening skill teaching tool.
Conclusion
The main focus of this work was to deal with the most important issues of teaching
listening skills and describe and compare theories and views of different authors on them.
Furthermore, the work intended to emphasize the importance of language acquisition and also
language comprehension within teaching listening skills.
The first two parts of this work were dealing with listening as a language skill, and we
introduced its categorizations. On the base of considering listening skill as a receptive skill,
two contrasting views were introduced: listening with purpose and without purpose. It was
defined that both are natural parts of any language which puts higher the importance of
bringing both into the teaching of listening skills.
Later on, we described the bottom-up and top-down processing by the points of views
of several authors, then we analysed Harmers basic methodological model for teaching
receptive skills also by commenting on his suggestions on appropriateness and difficulty
issues. We also emphasized the importance of choosing appropriate tasks and texts in order to
prevent problems, and we also provided some solutions to them, like pre-teaching of the
unknown vocabulary.
After these two parts, which intended to create a general overview on teaching
listening skills, we were dealing with describing and contrasting views on transactional and
interactional listening; and with the importance of language acquisition by linking Harmers
extensive listening to Richards listening as acquisition. We provided some of Richards
suggestions on using extensive listening in the classroom including Nunans view on this
issue. We were also dealing with the importance of listening outside the classroom. We have
to motivate students to do so because it might create positive attitude towards language
learning.
19
Because of the importance of language acquisition and the reason that language is
commonly in context, we have to bring context also to our classrooms. This is why we
included in this work drama as a tool for teaching listening skills.
As this work intends not just to emphasize the importance of language acquisition, but
language comprehension, we linked Harmers intensive listening to Richards listening as
comprehension. Here we discussed the most important stages of teaching listening skills ,
namely the framework of pre-listening, while listening and post-listening, and we named
some of the most frequent and effective tasks in them.
Finally, the last part is dealing with music and video and the possibilities of using them
in teaching listening skills. Here we provided Nick Peacheys application of the framework to
a song, which is the base of my own activity in the practical part, which includes also an
activity from a stated source and a modified activity.
In conclusion, the aims of this work were fulfilled as we discussed everything we
intended to. In my opinion, this work gives the reader a general overview on the issues of
teaching listening skills and provides important information like the framework and
methodological model of teaching listening skills and also their possible applications.
20
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Harmer, J. The Practice of English Language Teaching. Essex: Longman Group
UK Limited, 1991, 296 p. ISBN 0-582-04656-4.
Harmer, J. The Practice of English Language Teaching. 4th ed. Essex: Pearson Education
Limited, 2007, 448 p. ISBN 978 1 4058 4772 8.
Nunan. D. Language Teaching Methodology: A Textbook for Teachers, Prentice Hall, 1991,
264 p. ISBN 0-13-521469-6
Richards, J.C.Teaching Listening and Speaking From Theory to Practice. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2008, 44p. ISBN 13 978-0-521-95776-2
Morley, J. Aural Comprehension Instruction: Principles and Practices. In Celce-Murcia M.
(Ed.), Teaching English as a Second or Foreign Language, 3rd ed. Boston: Heinle and Heinle,
2001, 584 p. ISBN-13: 978-0-8384-1992-2
Online sources:
Peachley, N. A framework for planning a listening skills lesson [online] 10. February, 2010.
[quoted 3. May, 2012.]. < http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/articles/a-framework-planninga-listening-skills-lesson>.
Vandergrift L. Listening: theory and practice in modern foreign language competence
[online] [quoted 5. June, 2012.] <http://www.llas.ac.uk/resources/gpg/67>.
Practical part:
Harmer, J. The Practice of English Language Teaching. 4th ed. Essex: Pearson Education
Limited, 2007, 448 p. ISBN 978 1 4058 4772 8.
Hutchinson T. Project 2 Students Book, 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008, 79p.
ISBN 978 0 19 476305 9
Source of inspiration:
Maley A., Duff. A. Drama Techniques: A resource book of communication activities for
language teachers, 3rd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005, 246 p. ISBN 978-0521-60119-1
21
APPENDIX
Im sorry
1. pictures
2. Tape script
22
Tapescript:
23
Place 2 rubbers, 1 ruler, a Project book, 2 pens and 1 homework on the desk.
My Desk
Stay
in bed
Go
swimming
Dance
Speak
English
Play
the
piano
Ride
a bike
Go
shopping
This
evening
A rubber
A ruler
Project book
After
school
A pen
On Sunday
afternoon
Homework
At New
Year
On
Saturday
morning
On your
next
birthday
Tomorro
w
evening
My Partner
s Desk
Stay
in bed
This
evening
After
school
On Sunday
afternoon
At New
Year
On
Saturday
morning
On your
next
birthday
Tomorro
w evening
Call a square!
F.e: Are you going to go shopping on Sunday afternoon?
Your partner answers:
Yes, I am.
24
Go
swimming
Dance
Speak
English
Play
the
piano
Ride a
bike
Go
shopping
HIT - X
No, Im not.
MISS O
HANDOUT 1
1.) What kinds of music styles do you know? Write down at least 5 of them!
2.) Choose one style which you like and which you dont like in your group! Give reason
why! Write one sentence for each.
We like _____________________________ because________________________________
We dont like_________________________ because ________________________________
3.) What expressions might be in a love song? Suggest at least 5!
___________________________________________________________________________
HANDOUT 2
Listening 1
1.) Answer the questions!
a.) Is the song happy or sad? Why? ___________________________________________
b.) How many characters are there? __________________________________________
c.) What is between them, are they in love?_____________________________________
Listening 2
2.) What are the characters talking about? Look for key words!
25
Have your friends collect your records and then _____________ your number
I guess that I don't need that though
Now you're just somebody that I used to know
(...)
HANDOUT 4
1.) Make the list of 10 verbs in Past Simple and write their Present Simple form .
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
2.) Find 5 verbs which are in Present Simple!
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
3.) Find the verbs which are in Present Continuous!
___________________________________________________________________________
4.) Work in pairs! Try to guess why they broke up! Write a short dialogue! Act it out!
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
5.) Write another verse for the song! Use the key words in Handout 1/3 and Handout 2/2.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
27
28