Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Syndromes
Endocrine Disorders
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Sleep Disruption
The prevalence of sleep complaints in cancer patients has
been studied primarily in cross-sectional studies using convenience samples with heterogeneous definitions and measures of sleep disturbances. In a large questionnaire study of
over 900 patients with different types of cancer, fatigue
(44%), leg restlessness (41%), insomnia (31%), and excessive sleepiness (28%) were the most prevalent complaints. 4
Another survey showed that 61% of the cancer patients had
significant sleep deficits, but there was no difference in sleep
complaints between the cancer patients and patients with
medical conditions other than cancer.5 Almost half of the
group had a poor sleep efficiency
1416
Section
15
Chapter
123
PATHOGENESIS
Pathogenesis of Sleep Disruption
Patients with cancer may complain of insomnia, hypersomnia, or both, but the pathogenesis of this sleep disruption can be quite varied. Chemotherapy, radiation therapy,
and hormone therapy may all contribute to the problem, but
studies looking at their different effects on sleep pat-terns are
lacking. In addition, commonly administered analgesics such
as opioids, and antiemetic medications such as
corticosteroids, are also known to disrupt sleep. 31 The
estrogen deficiency induced by chemotherapy and hormone
therapy, the abrupt cessation of hormone replace-ment
therapy at cancer diagnosis, or an ovary removal may each
trigger or exacerbate preexisting hot flashes. A study using
objective measurements of both sleep and hot flashes in
breast cancer survivors showed that nocturnal hot flashes
were associated with more wake time and more stage
changes to lighter sleep.32
The amount of insomnia in cancer patients can be as high
as the amount found in depressed patients, so clini-cians
should not overlook the possibility that poor sleep in cancer
patients may indicate some psychological distress. However,
there is evidence that, although insomnia and psychological
distress are interrelated, there are still a sig-nificant
proportion of patients who have only insomnia. In one
sample of newly diagnosed breast cancer patients, insomnia
was the most frequent symptom, reported by 88% of the
patients, and was correlated with high levels of distress and
anxiety.33 However, contrary to the belief that disturbed
sleep before treatment is attributable to the increased stress
and anxiety resulting from a recent diag-nosis of a lifethreatening illness, insomnia and fatigue were rated high
even in those patients who rated them-selves low on anxiety.
Similarly, another study revealed that 46% of prostate cancer
survivors with an insomnia syndrome did not have clinical
levels of anxiety or depres-sive symptoms.9
Pain has often been thought to be the cause of sleep
disruption, not only in patients with cancer but also in
patients with a multitude of other medical conditions. 2 It is
not yet known whether the pain contributes to poor sleep or
whether the pain medications contribute to poor sleep, or
both. One hypothesis is that pain may be the initial cause of
the frequent awakenings, but psychological distress prevents
the patient from falling back to sleep.34 A second hypothesis
is that while sleep leads to recovery and repair of tissue and
may offer a temporary cessation of the psychological
awareness of pain, poor sleep leads to difficulty managing
pain.35 In this way, a cycle of pain and poor sleep may
become self-perpetuating. In a study examining the
relationship between pain and sleep disrup-tion, patients with
breast cancer, lung cancer, insomnia (with no cancer) and
normal controls were questioned. Although those with breast
cancer reported pain before bedtime, neither their poor sleep
nor that of the patients with lung cancer was associated with
reports of pain.17 Another study conducted in patients with
advanced cancer showed significant correlations between
pain and poor sleep quality.36 Moreover, those patients with
poor quality of life had the most disturbed sleep and the
highest levels of pain.
Physiological factors
e.g., pain
anemia
Psychological factors
e.g., depression
anxiety
Fatigue
Social/cultural factors
e.g., education
socioeconomic status
Chronobiological factors
e.g., sleep
circadian rhythms
Pathogenesis of Fatigue
Fatigue is believed to be caused by multiple factors, including physical (e.g., cachexia, weight loss, and biochemical,
hematologic, and endocrine abnormalities) and psychological (e.g., depression) and social factors (Fig. 123-1).
Anemia and other biochemical abnormalities are found in
cancer patients and cause fatigue, although hemoglobin
levels are only moderately related to fatigue and quality of
life. One study examining the incremental effect of increasing hemoglobin on quality of life found that improving the
anemia improved quality of life only to a point, beyond
which there was no further improvement. 37 Alternative
possible physiologic mechanisms include inflammation (e.g.,
increased proinflammatory cytokines), serotonin dysregulation, hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis dysfunc-tion
(e.g., altered cortisol response), and altered muscle
metabolism.38 Among these potential mechanisms, inflammation is probably the one currently receiving the most
attention and is believed to be a common pathway through
which cancer and its treatment would lead to a variety of
behavioral consequences, including improved fatigue and
decreased sleep disturbances.38
Several studies have found significant relationships
between reports of fatigue and depression,26 but it is unclear
to what extent these are etiologically related. Indeed,
depression is far less common than fatigue in cancer patients,
which suggests that fatigue often occurs independently.
Moreover, it has been shown that cancer-related fatigue is
different from fatigue experienced by patients with
depression.
In addition, there is evidence that sleep disturbance is a
significant predictor of fatigue.39 Studies on symptom clusters have revealed that sleep and fatigue are often part of a
cluster of three or more symptoms. 40 Moreover, most crosssectional and prospective studies found a strong correlation
between self-reported sleep complaints and fatigue.
Evidence on the relationship between circadian rhythms
and subjective ratings of fatigue have been mixed, with most
studies finding a significant relationship. 24,41 Daytime
inactivity and nighttime restlessness were associated with
higher subjective ratings of cancer-related fatigue in one
TREATMENT
The complaints of sleep disturbances and fatigue in patients
with cancer are often overlooked in clinical practice and,
when a treatment is initiated, it is often a pharmacologic one
(e.g., sedative-hypnotics for insomnia, psychostimu-lants for
fatigue). While pharmacologic therapy may be appropriate at
times, there is accumulating evidence sup-porting the
efficacy of alternative treatments including psychological
treatments, activity-based interventions, and bright-light
therapy.
Sleep
PHARMACOTHERAPY
Hypnotic medications, particularly benzodiazepines, are by
far the most commonly prescribed treatment for sleep
disturbances in cancer patients.7 In 2005, the National
Institutes of Health (NIH) State of the Science Confer-ence
on Insomnia concluded that the newer, shorter acting
nonbenzodiazepines were safer and more effective than the
older, longer-acting benzodiazepines for the treatment of
insomnia.43 More recently, newer agents, such as a melatonin receptor agonist, have also been approved by the
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS: IS IT
SLEEPINESS, FATIGUE, OR
SOMETHING ELSE?
The clinician needs to determine the cause of a patients
symptoms, recognizing that the words used by the patient to
describe the symptoms may be vague. Is the symptom
related to sleepiness (the patient may describe unintended
episodes of falling asleep in the daytime or have an elevated
Epworth Sleepiness Scale score), or to fatigue (complaints of
muscular weakness, or lack of energy but not weakness)?
Patients may also have symptoms attributable to specific
effects of cancer or its treatment. When the patient has
complaints in one or more of these realms, they may become
very difficult to manage.
Sleepiness or Insomnia
When daytime sleepiness can be attributed to a specific sleep
disorder, treatment should target that sleep disorder. If a
patient has restless legs syndrome, the clinician should make
sure that the patient does not have iron deficiency, which
commonly occurs in patients with gastrointestinal
carcinomas. If the patient has developed movement disorders secondary to a chemotherapeutic agent, then a trial of a
dopaminergic agent should be initiated. If a patient has
developed obstructive sleep apneafor example, sec-ondary
to enlarged lymph nodes in the pharynx, as might occur with
lymphoma or with nasopharyngeal carcinoma then
continuous positive airway pressure treatment as well as
specific treatment directed at these areas should be initi-ated.
If the patient has developed clinical depression along with
insomnia, then concurrent therapy for the mood dis-order as
well as for the insomnia should be initiated.
Fatigue
As described earlier, fatigue, weakness, and loss of energy
are all hallmarks of cancer. Although the pathophysiology is
still poorly understood, the clinician should try to deter-mine
if the fatigue is caused in part by a correctable factor such as
electrolyte imbalance (this might occur in a patient on
chemotherapy with severe nausea or vomiting), an
underlying infection, or an undiagnosed metabolic disor-der
such as thyroid disease or diabetes mellitus. The latter
Acknowledgements
Supported by: NCI CA112035, NIA AG08415, Moores
UCSD Cancer Center, the Research Service of the Veter-ans
Affairs San Diego Healthcare System, the Canadian
Institutes of Health Research, the Canadian Breast Cancer
Research Alliance, and the Fonds de la recherche en sant
du Qubec.
This chapter is dedicated to the memory of Dr. J.
Christian Gillin, dear friend and colleague, who died of
cancer. He was fatigued but he never let it get to him. He
was an inspiration and a role model to us all.
REFERENCES
1. Zee PC, Ancoli-Israel S. Workshop Participants. Does effective management of sleep disorders reduce cancer-related fatigue? Drugs
2009;69(Suppl 2):29-41.
2. Fleming L, Gillespie S, Espie CA. The development and impact of
insomnia on cancer survivors: a qualitative analysis. Psychooncology In
Press 2010.