Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
almost all his freedoms sooner or later. But if he opts to live by society’s
rules, he has to be prepared to lose many an important freedom to the
greater freedoms of other more important people.
Are the rules the same for all? Not that I know of. There is no such
thing as a level playing field. The more money one has, the more influence
one wields, as is patently obvious to all who read the newspapers. Money
and influence help one to flout or bend the rules (remember the Jeffrey
Archer case? Sentenced to a four-year jail sentence for perjury, he is
alleged to have attended parties outside the jail premises, and was paroled
out after a mere two years. But then, he’s a Peer of the Realm. Some peer!
And Manu Sharma was caught carousing when out on parole after having
been convicted for the morder of an innocent girl who stood up to his
brattish bullying).
We live in times when individual liberties are being rapidly eroded. This
is especially true of the technologically advanced West. Electronic
surveillance via GPS systems and an excess of computerization that allows
‘the authorities’ to track each little transaction of our day-to-day lives have
brought Orwell’s 1984 uncomfortably close. We are on the verge of having
our identities replaced with numbers. Today, our identities run side by side,
from election cards and income tax Permanent Account numbers to ration
cards and driving licenses
But Nandan Nilekani’s UID number will tag all Indian citizens, replacing
the ID proff offered by all the other cards. Voila! We are reduced to a string
of digits in the State’s machine (Ben Hur was Number 41 on Quintus Arias’
galley), and will need to quote this ID number whenever we undertake any
type of transaction—financial, administrative, or legal. (There were riots in
China a couple of years ago over this issue, with the Chinese savouring – for
a short while – the tantalising aroma of civil liberty that arose in a post Mao
Tse-dong era).
So Big Brother intends to keep a sharp eye on us, so sharp, in fact, that
he’ll soon know more about us than we do ourselves. His super-computers
will churn out statistical tables that will be the envy of actuaries
everywhere. The minutiae of our lives will be monitored more closely than
those of chimpanzees in research laboratories...and all for the sake of
saving democracy. Are we witnessing the rise of neo-totalitarianism? Could
it possible that the earlier, less efficient system was better? Another
paradox now rears its head: opting out of one form of totalitarianism usually
means stepping into another one just as bad.
Money can preserve and extend life, while bringing true freedom of
action within reach. This is the basic reason why more and more people
today (more so, perhaps, than ever before in history) are obsessed with
acquiring more and more money and squirreling it away in tax havens or
Swiss banks, by whatever means. Control over one’s life varies in direct
proportion to one’s bank balance. It always has...but even more so now.
Whether it brings true happiness is quite another matter.
Fear is the key – as Alistair MacLean titled one of his books. Being the
opposite of love, fear begets hate…a useful tool for those who would incite
violence and bloodshed between men. Hate is taught, rationalized, and
organized into group action. Who benefits? Certainly not the common man.
But in an age when politics has become a no-holds-barred war-game for the
top of the pyramid, all tactics are admissible.
5
Thus politics and war have much in common. Money drives both.
Everyone breaks the rules…but only the victors get to erase their misdeeds
ere history is re-written. They are the good guys, with the losers always
ending up as the bad guys. After the courts exonerated Jayalalitha of the
multiple cases registered against her (does anyone remember?), she turned
upon her opponents and savaged them while the world looked on
helplessly. One can get away with murder, if one is willing to discount a few
people like Shibu Soren who were careless and got caught.
Where is Shibu today? Sitting pretty, is he? See, it’s just as we told you.
All you need are money or influence (which, in India, are synonymous, for
all practical purposes) to go scot free. The IPL imbroglio claimed an
amateurish Shashi Tharoor as a victim; he’s a too cerebral a guy to try and
dip his paws in the cesspool formed by the nexus between vulgar tamasha,
er…sorry…organized sport, politics and money. Good thing he’s decided to
take a breather and go off and get married to his attractive friend Sunanda
Pushkar. Spoilt brat Manu Sharma would have been roistering even today
had he not become so over-confident as to let his antics be captured by a
newsman’s lens.
The Nazis are still being bashed by Hollywood, 65 years after World
War II ended. And we have Gujarat, our very own 1984 anti-Sikh pogrom,
and Nandigram to live down. But will it be chronicled the way it actually
happened? Or will the facts be culled from the history books? We know
what’s going to happen, don’t we? I wonder how many more such events
await us in the future.
Subroto Mukerji