Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
The East-Central
European
Cultural Model
III
2
Stefan Arteni
3
Roman Relief, Three-Headed Sphinx Holding the Wheel of Fortune
4
Stefan Arteni
The East-Central European Cultural Model. 3. Intermezzo.
The Neo-Orwellian Madness.
[April 6, 2009]
Motto.
Daddy, where there is no morality, there is corruption, and if a society lacks
principles, that means it does not have any! (Ion Luca Caragiale)
Czesław Miłosz observes: “If nihilism, as Nietzsche says, consists in the loss of
memory, recovery of memory is a weapon against nihilism”. Gerhart Niemeyer
has exposed the nihilistic core of Communist ideology found in Marx's assertion
that the point is not to understand the world as it is but to change it, by which he
meant transforming it into something it is not. Niemeyer says: "Totalitarianism
would not be possible in practice if it were not for a long period of intellectual
erosion preceding the advent of the activist". He continues: “The fruit of
Communist rule must be spiritual chaos and progressive barbarization.”
5
self-confident, self-conscious and impartial, without being conceited. In sum, the
elite of a society can only perform if it is given stable and calm conditions for its
activity, and if its values, its 'chosenness' is generally recognised both by the
others and by itself…The puzzling fact that the collapse of the much-hated
communist regime was not much perceived as a break in most countries of the
region is due to the fact that it did not end transitoriness, the central characteristic
of life under communism, only altered its modality.”
Abram de Swaan describes the inevitable result: “Obviously, what occurs under
these conditions is the bureaucratization of barbarism.”
In the case of Romania, the pre-war elite was deliberately decimated and
marxism-leninism. contributed to what can be termed culturecide —the attempt to
erase and replace the cultural model and the ancient customs and rites. The
‘new’ or ‘postcommunist’ overlords have risen from among the old communist
6
cadres -- collectively known as either the nomenclatura, or the ‚new class’
described by Milovan Djilas, or the ‚communist aristocracy’, that is to say the
only ones privileged under the communist regime -- mainly due to their
advantageous positioning in the old networks and access to resources. They are
inescapably linked to structures, networks, thinking, and practices of the past.
The process of recruiting real elites, untainted by involvement with the old
structures, was gridlocked by the old cadres. Co-option by Western institutions
has helped restore the ‘communist aristocracy's’ past prominence.
There is an old Romanian proverb that says: “The mouth of a sinner tells the
truth”. It will then suffice to quote a few lines written by Sorin Antohi, one of the
‘boyars of the mind’, known now as the pseudo-Doctor (he falsely claimed to
hold a Ph.D. in History from the University of Iaşi) who had also served as an
informer for Romania's communist-era Department of State Security. In an
article entitled “Romanian culture is a fiction”, published in Contrafort 3-6
(77-80), March-June 2001, Antohi has jotted down a short note about his fellow
neo-culturniks: “The cultural elite…ultimately a tiny minority, is totally alienated
from the society it comes from and which it should help orient itself. From the
political and ideological viewpoint, most top cultural and intellectual figures of
contemporary Romania have broken their relationship with society (if they ever
had any!). Betting immoderately on a sketchy and bovaric westernization, being
(like state communism) narcissistic and despising the people’s stirrings and ills,
our cultural elite…has failed in its historical mission…” These are the facts we
should reflect on. We should also recall Homi Bhabha’s words: “Mimicry and
masquerade are born from the desire to be equal, accepted and recognized;
nevertheless, mimicry does not bring us closer to the essence, it only creates
empty masks and meaningless forms of imitation“.
7
stronger than the spells we cast on it. It might come back to life." It re-appears, it
circles, it re-enters the stage.
8
Lucian Blaga, Poems (Poems of Light), 1919
9
Lucian Blaga, The Mioritic Space, 1936
10
Lucian Blaga, The Genesis of Metaphor and the Meaning of Culture, 1937
11
Gheorghe Bratianu, Bessarabia: National and Historic Rights, 2004 (first edition
published in 1943)
12
13
Dominique Noguez, Lenine Dada, Le Dilettante, 2007
14
Stefan Arteni
The East-Central European Cultural Model. 4.The Avantgarde and Marxism.
[April 6, 2009]
Motto.
Art is going to sleep for a new world to be born. (Tristan Tzara)
Milan Kundera has defined national identity in this way: "The identity of a people
and of a civilisation is reflected in what has been created by the mind - in what is
known as 'culture.' If this identity is threatened with extinction, cultural life grows
correspondingly more intense, more important, until cultural life itself becomes
the living value around which all people rally." Once our historical past and our
culture, that which gives our present actions and reality meaning (by being a part
of the transcendent/eternal) has been deconstructed - seen to be totally false and
oppressive - there is nothing left to hold society together. “Breaking the continuity
with the past, wanting to begin again, is a lowering of man and a plagiarism of
the orangutan,” writes Jose Ortega y Gasset.
15
Realism’s appropriation of nineteenth century official Academic styles, may
suggest a relation between noticing one’s own insufficiency and an economy of
revenge.
16
modernist design and architecture, revealing thus the relationship between
fascism and modernism. (Saviona Mane, The Jewish Mother of Fascism,
August 7, 2006, http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/735492.html ) Many
futurists went on to become the leading artists of Novecento. The Strapaese
group founded by Giorgio Morandi and joined by Soffici, Rosai and Carrà, also
advocated a return to tradition.
The affiliation with communism of many dadaists and surrealists is well known,
Dan C.Mihailescu calls them “comintern’s toys”. We will mention only a few
names: Victor Brauner (agent of the comintern), Jules Perahim (zhdanovist
satrap), Gherasim Luca (Gilles Deleuze’s favourite; in 1967 Gherasim Luca
wrote on the mural Cuba Collectiva dedicated to Fidel Castro: «La poésie sans
langue, la révolution sans personne, l’amour sans fin.»). Many prophets of utopia
and internationalist Tendenzkunst (art engagé) willingly implemented the
‘proletcult’ doctrine and the bolshevik policy of desecration and destruction – they
were seeing the promised land, they were proclaiming the primordiality of
17
politically correct content and, consequently, novelty was guaranteed by the
‘new’ content.
A recent exhibition dedicated to Italian art of the 20th century closed with the
section ‘Tabula Rasa’ devoted to three artists of the post-war period who
intended to reactivate the spirit of the avantgarde: Fontana, Burri, and Manzoni.
‘Tabula Rasa’ signifies an attempt at creation ‘ex nihilo’. It is a messianism
without the Messiah whose outcome has been described by Mircea Platon: “the
hideousness of a wasteland”.
(The Novecento. Abstraction. Italian art of the 20th century, 5 February 2005 –
24 April 2005, Saint Petersburg, Hermitage Museum, Museo di arte moderna e
contemporanea di Trento e Rovereto,
http://english.mart.trento.it/context_mostre_mondo.jsp?ID_LINK=346&area=62&
page=2 )
18
Futurist Manifesto, 1909 (Italian version)
19
Gino Severini, Portrait of Filippo Tommaso Marinetti, 1913
20
Ardengo Soffici, 1915
21
Enrico Prampolini, study for the cover of Noi Rivista d’Arte Futurista, 1923
22
Margherita Sarfatti’s biography of Mussolini,
published in 1926 by Mondadori. The book was immediately
translated in 18 languages.
23
Umberto Boccioni, Portrait of Fiammetta Sarfatti, Margherita Sarfatti’s daughter,
1911
24
Mario Sironi, Portrait of Margherita Sarfatti, 1916-1917 (?)
Carlo Socrate, Portrait of Margherita Sarfatti with her daughter Fiammetta, 1929
25
Achille Funi, 1930
26
Achille Funi, 1942
27
Achille Funi, study for mosaic, 1963-1964
28
Carlo Socrate, 1937
29
Mario Sironi, undated
30
Mario Sironi, 1920-1930
31
Mario Sironi, 1930-1935
32
Mario Sironi’s study for a University of Rome fresco, 1935
Mario Sironi, L'Italia tra le Arti e le Scienze, 1935, Rome, Aula Magna
of the Rectorate, University La Sapienza
33
Mario Sironi, 1935
34
Mario Sironi, 1936
35
Mario Sironi’s mosaic for the Palazzo della Giustizia, Milano, 1936
36
Mario Sironi, 1936
37
Mario Sironi, 1940
38
Mario Sironi, 1940
39
Mario Sironi, 1945
40
Mario Sironi, 1945-1950
41
Mario Sironi, 1950
42
Mario Sironi, 1952
43
Mario Sironi, 1955
44
Mario Sironi, date unknown
45
Massimo Campigli, 1927. Campigli’s first marriage in 1927 to the Romanian
painter Magdalena (‘Dutza’) Radulesco had a bearing on his change of outlook.
After a journey to Romania, he developed a style inspired by ancient murals.
46
Massimo Campigli, fresco, 1938
47
Massimo Campigli, study for the University of Padua fresco
(the fresco was painted in 1939-1940)
48
Massimo Campigli, University of Padua fresco, detail
49
Massimo Campigli, University of Padua fresco, detail
50
Massimo Campigli, 1941
51
Massimo Campigli, 1944
52
Massimo Campigli, 1950
53
Gino Severini, 1922
54
Gino Severini, 1929
55
Gino Severini, 1930
56
Gino Severini, reverse painting on glass, date unknown
57
Gino Severini, 1930
58
Gino Severini, 1937
59
Gino Severini, 1934-1935
60
Gino Severini, 1942
61
Gino Severini, 1943
62
Gino Severini, 1946
63
Fortunato Depero, tarsia of cloths, 1921
64
Fortunato Depero, study for advertisement, 1925
65
Fortunato Depero, Trento Costumes and Landscapes, 1936, tapestry
66
Fortunato Depero, Le Professioni e le Arti, mosaic, 1942
67
Giorgio Morandi, 1943
68
Ottone Rosai, 1943
69
Ardengo Soffici, 1942
70
Carlo Carrà, 1937
71
Emil Nolde, Life of Christ, 1911-1912. Expressionist Emil Nolde was a supporter
of the National Socialist party from the early 1920s. Nolde's work was officially
condemned by the Nazi regime. He was not allowed to paint—even in private—
after 1941.
72
Karl Schmidt-Rottluff, Die Lesende, 1911. Expressionist Karl Schmidt-Rottluff
was considered a ‘degenerate artist’ by the Nazi regime and was prohibited from
exhibiting in 1936 and fom painting at all in 1941.
73
Alexej von Jawlensky, 1910. In 1921, Russian expressionist Alexej von
Jawlensky had settled permanently in Germany. In 1933 Jawlensky was
forbidden by the Nazi regime to exhibit his work. He died in 1941.
74
Alexej von Jawlensky, 1932
75
Zbigniew Pronaszko, date unknown
76
Andrzej Pronaszko, 1916
77
…art is a hammer with which to shape reality.
(Bertold Brecht)
78
Lajos Tihanyi (after the fall of the Hungarian Soviet Republic, he emigrated to
Vienna, and from 1924 he lived in Paris), Portrait of Tristan Tzara, 1926
79
Kazimir Malevich, 1915
80
Lenin and Yakov Sverdlov,1918
81
Vladimir Tatlin, Monument to the Third International, 1920
82
Soviet agitprop train, 1920
83
Poster by Vladimir Maiakovsky, 1920
84
Alexander Rodchenko, 1924
Sergei Senkin, Under the banner of Lenin for the second five-year plan!, 1931
85
Matsa, Mikhailov, Novitsky,
VOPROSY RAZVITIYA PROLETARSKOGO ISKUSSTVA (Questions of
Development of the Proletarian Art), first edition,
Moscow, Komakademia, 1931
86
Isaak Ivanovich Izrailevich Brodskiy, Lenin in front of Smolny, before 1925
87
Andre Breton, Valentine Hugo, Greta Knutson and Tristan Tzara. Cadavre
Exquis (Exquisite Corpse), 1933
88
Alexander Mikhaylovich Gerasimov, Portrait of Joseph Stalin,1939
Iraklii Toidze, Under the banner of Lenin, with the leadership of Stalin, forward to
the victory of Communism, 1940
89
Jules Perahim, Fighting for Peace, date unknown
90
Mural Cuba collectiva, 1967, and detail (Gherasim Luca’s verse)
oil on canvas
501 x 1 083 cm (6 panels)
Museo Nacional de Bellas Artes
Havana, Cuba
91
Enei Church, Bucharest, Romania. The church was deliberately demolished by
the communist regime on March 10, 1977, six days after the earthquake,
although the church had not been damaged.
92