Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Quarter: 2nd
Learning competency: Compose an argumentative essay.
Authentic task: Resolve an issue through a debate.
Guidelines:
1. The task will be done by group which composes of 10 members each group.
2. All groups will be given 3 weeks to do their research, interviews, and data
gathering of necessary information, and preparation for the said debate.
3. Ask different person in a specific place about the issues in their place.
4. Identify one issue and propose a solution to resolve it.
5. Compose an argumentative essay on how to resolve the issue.
6. Through a debate, resolve the issue.
7. The attached rubric will be used to rate your performance.
Rubric
Criteria
Respect for
other team
Information
20
All
15
Statements
5
Most
1
Statements
statements,
and responses
statements
and/or body
body language,
were
and body
language were
and responses
respectful and
language were
consistently
were
use
respectful and
not respectful.
respectful and
appropriate
in appropriate
in appropriate
language but
language but
language.
once or twice
body language
sarcastic
was not.
All information Most
remark.
Most
Information
presented was
information
information
had some
clear, accurate
presented was
presented was
major
and thorough.
clear, accurate
clear and
inaccuracies or
and thorough.
accurate but
Every major
Every major
thorough.
Every major
point was
point was
Organization
Some points
were
several
others were
relevant facts
several
examples but
not.
and/or
relevant facts
the relevance
examples.
and/or
of some was
All arguments
examples.
Most
questionable.
Some of the
Most
were tied to
arguments
arguments
arguments
an idea
were tied to
(premise) and
an idea
to an idea
to an idea
organize in a
(premise) and
(premise) and
(premise) and
tight and
organize in a
logical fashion.
tight and
organize in a
organize in a
logical fashion.
tight and
tight and
logical fashion.
The team
Understanding
The team
The team
logical fashion.
Then team
of topic
clearly
clearly
seemed to
didnt show an
understood
understood
understand
adequate
the topic in
the topic in
the main
understanding
depth and
depth and
points of the
of the topic.
presented
presented
topic but
their
their
didnt present
information
information
with ease.
forcefully and
with ease.
convincingly.
All counter
Most counter
Most counter
Counter
arguments
arguments
arguments
arguments
were accurate
were accurate
were accurate
were not
relevant and
relevant and
relevant and
accurate
strong.
strong.
strong but
and/or
several were
relevant.
Rebuttal
weak.
30
Balanced
20
Information
10
Information
5
Central
presentation
provides
supports a
purpose is not
of relevant
reasonable
central purpose
clearly
and legitimate
support for a
and analysis is
identified and
information
central
basic or general.
analysis is
that clearly
purpose and
vague or not
supports a
displays
evident.
central
evidence of a
purpose and
basic analysis
shows a
of a
thoughtful, in
significant
depth analysis
topic.
of a
significant
Organization
topic.
The ideas are
The writing is
The writing is
arranged
arranged
arranged
not logically
logically to
logically to
logically,
organized.
support the
support the
although
Frequently,
purpose. They
central
occasionally
ideas fail to
flow smoothly
purpose. They
ideas fail to
make sense
from one to
are usually
make sense
together.
another and
clearly linked
together.
are clearly
to each other.
linked to each
Grammar,
other.
The writing is
There are
There are so
spelling, and
free from
occasional
many errors.
many errors
writing
errors.
errors but
that the
they dont
meaning is
represent a
obscured.
mechanics
major
distraction or
obscure
Use of
Compelling
meaning.
Professionally
references
evidence from
legitimate
attributions are
seldom cited
professionally
sources that
occasionally
to support
legitimate
support claims
given, many
statements.
sources is
are generally
statements
given to
present and
seem
Although
Reference are
unsubstantiated
Attribution is
clear and
fairly
fairly
represented.
represented.
Organization
Delivery
15
Demonstrate
10
Fulfills topic; uses
5
Does not give
substance and
appropriate
adequate coverage
depth; is
sources and is
comprehensive and
objective.
sources.
shows mastery.
Has a clear opening
Has opening
Has no opening
statement that
statement relevant
statement or
catches the
irrelevant
audience interest;
outline of speech.
statement, and
stays focus
leaves listener
throughout and
wondering where
summarizes main
the presentation is
points.
Have a modulated
Have a quite
headed.
Have a soft voice,
voice, projects
modulated voice,
projects
enthusiasm,
projects
enthusiasm,
interest and
enthusiasm,
interest and
confidence; uses
interest and
confidence; but
body language
confidence; uses
consistently.
language.
not that
Response to
Demonstrates full
consistent.
Shows ease in
question
knowledge of the
answering
information; has
questions but do
unclear answer to
elaborate all
not elaborate.
questions.
questions.
Shows grasp of