Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
in Services
Lecture and case introduction
3 hours
"Premium clothing" teams'
results
"Premium
clothing"
Roland Berger
results
Break
Service growth
theoretical course
"EADS
Airbus" case
presentation
60 min
30 min
30 min
50 min
10 min
Tools
1 development matrix
Strategic
segmentation
Attractiveness /
Accessibility analysis
GEOGRAPHY
1>
2'
Develop Business
on Customer Base
Develop Business on
Competitors' Base
e.g. advanced pilot training
e.g. leasing
Secure Core
Business
Capture
Competitors' Business
e.g. provision of
spare parts
On own products
Western Europe
North America
Latin & South America
Asia
Spare parts
Maintenance
Logistics
Operators
Training
Retrofit
20
Mobilization
Transformation
phase launch
Definition of
the working
principles
Mobilization Acceleration
Definition of
action plans
?
Time
Weaknesses
identification
New orientation
top-down
Productivity/
develop
cooperation
Coal plant
Gas plant
Nuclear plant
PLATFORM
(power plant type)
Attractiveness
=
Revenue
x
Growth
x
Profitability
Accessibility
=
Rivalry Intensity
x
Entry barriers
for a new
entrant
x
Company
capabilities
Most promising
services market segments
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
LOW
MEDIUM
HIGH
Accessibility
for the company
21
Objectives
of a partnership / acquisition
Continuous
improvement
on all levels
3. Learning experience
Time
SUCCESS FACTORS
> Achieve management alignment and commitment
> Identify "Champions" and leverage "Multipliers"
> Mobilize employees around repeated "quick hits"
Plant operators
Institutions
1,2
23
Emotional
curve
Implementation
Large industries
Private consumers
Small & Medium
industries
END-USERS
SUPPORT
& SERVICES
Make or Buy
policy
Attractiveness
for the company
Strategic
analysis
MAKE
YES
1
Is it core?
NO
YES
Operational
analysis
Is it risky to
outsource?
NO
YES
3
Is it easy to
implement?
YES
Is it cost effective
internally?
31
28
BUY
PARTNER
25
Preliminary remark
Agenda
Services can be offered all along the life-cycle of a product, but most
Services are after sales services
Standard Services offered
CONCEPTION
PRODUCTION
Need analysis
UTILIZATION
Disposal/dismantling
Training
Financial services
(leasing)
PRODUCT
SALE
AFTER SALES
Maintenance
Repair
Spare parts
Modification/ upgrades
Logistics
Facility management
Pool management
Configuration management
Testing/ audit of product
Consulting services
2016.03.11 - 2. Growth Strategies in Services - Course.pptx
Accessories/ consumables
23%
15%
16%
17%
25%
18%
10%
Northrop Lockheed
Grumman Martin
Finmeccanica
Boeing
Thales
Tier-1 suppliers
Cobham
BAE
Tier-1 suppliers
Integrators
Source: Companies Data, Roland Berger Top Management Issue Radar 2013
10
11
Agenda
15
PHASE 2
Strategic analysis
Attractiveness of
market
segments
Accessibility
of market
segments
Market strategic
segmentation
Most
Promising
Business
opportunities
PHASE 3
Moving forward
Internal
implications
Priority
Business
opportunities
FOR THE
COMPANY
Gap
analysis
Selection
of strategic
options
Strategic
roadmap
External
implications
Risks of
market
segments
Competitive
environment
Organizational
Implications
Strengthening of
Company
capabilities
Target
screening
potential
acquisitions /
partnerships
Business
and
implementation
Plan
Competitiveness
of the Company
per market
segment
Company
capabilities
16
PHASE 2
Strategic analysis
PHASE 3
Moving forward
Attractiveness
Market strategic
segmentation
Accessibility
Priority
Business
opportunities
FOR THE
COMPANY
Most
Promising
Business
opportunities
Internal
implications
Gap
analysis
Risks
Competitive
environment
Strategic segmentation
Strategic
roadmap
External
implications
Strengthening of
Company
capabilities
Target
screening
potential
acquisitions /
partnerships
Business
and
implementation
Plan
Competitiveness
of the Company
per market
segment
KSF
Key Success Factors
Key Selection Criteria
KSC
Selection
of strategic
options
Organizational
Implications
Company
capabilities
Emotional curve
18
Tools
Strategic segmentation
19
2'
Develop Business
on Customer Base
Develop Business on
Competitors' Base
e.g. leasing
Secure Core
Business
Capture
Competitors' Business
e.g. provision of
spare parts
On own products
1>
20
Western Europe
North America
SUPPORT
& SERVICES
END-USERS
Private consumers
Small & Medium
industries
Large industries
Plant operators
Institutions
Coal plant
Gas plant
Nuclear plant
PLATFORM
(power plant type)
21
Tools
22
Attractiveness
=
Revenue
x
Growth
x
Profitability
Accessibility
=
Rivalry Intensity
x
Entry barriers
for a new
entrant
x
Company
capabilities
Most promising
services market segments
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
LOW
MEDIUM
HIGH
Accessibility
for the company
23
Tools
Make or buy
24
Strategic
analysis
MAKE
YES
1
Is it core?
NO
YES
2
Operational
analysis
Is it risky to
outsource?
NO
YES
3
Is it easy to
implement?
YES
4
Is it cost effective
internally?
BUY
PARTNER
25
Business
Model
Target
services
segments
"Make
or Buy"
strategy
Iterative
Partnerships/
Acquisitions
26
Tools
27
3. Learning experience
28
Partnerships hide many pitfalls and should not be seen as easy and
short term ways to access technologies, products, or markets
Main pitfalls to consider in a partnership
Pitfall # 1
Pitfall # 2
Overestimating the importance of formal governance structures in alliances when learning is the goal
Pitfall # 3
Limiting the risk-analysis of the partnership to its internal boundaries without taking into account
following spill-over effects:
> Time horizon related: after termination of the partnership, the partner becomes a new competitor in the
market
> Product related: the partner benefits from one parent expertise to diversify its product offering to
become a new competitor
> Geographic: the partner builds on the skills acquired to become a new entrant in a market outside the
partnership boundaries
Pitfall # 4
Not preparing oneself for the termination of the partnership: 50% of JVs end before 5 years and
termination of a JV does not mean a failure:
> Organize to benefit from the JV in the predictable time horizon
> Organize to be independent in the long term and sustain the benefits of the JV
> Anticipate before closing what should be the relative competitive positioning of both partners after
termination
Pitfall # 5
29
Tools
Emotional curve
30
Mobilization
Transformation
phase launch
Definition of
the working
principles
Mobilization Acceleration
New orientation
top-down
Productivity/
develop
cooperation
Implementation
Definition of
action plans
?
Time
Weaknesses
identification
Continuous
improvement
on all levels
Time
SUCCESS FACTORS
> Achieve management alignment and commitment
> Identify "Champions" and leverage "Multipliers"
> Mobilize employees around repeated "quick hits"
Source: Roland Berger
31
Portfolio / strategy
Back office
> Sharing basic functions without
burdening Services with highcost (e.g. quality standards)
Organization
& Processes
Sales
> Key account management and
adequate to TBOs for services
> New customers
> Management of cross-fertilization:
potential bundled offers
Suppliers' management
Product support
Such fundamental
changes requires:
> Perseverance
> Top management
attention and
involvements
> Clear communication
of objectives
> Dedicated resources
and capabilities
32
3 hours
"Premium clothing" teams'
results
"Premium
clothing"
Roland Berger
results
Break
Service growth
theoretical course
"EADS
Airbus" case
presentation
60 min
30 min
30 min
50 min
10 min
33
Airbus ~65%
Eurocopter ~10%
Astrium ~11%
DS ~12%
Other ~2%
Products
> Commercial (93%): A320
family, A330/340, A350
XWB, A380
> Military (7%): CN-235,
C295, A330 MRTT, A400M
Products
> EC225/EC725
> NH90
> EC135/EC145
> Ecureuil family
> Tiger
Products
> Eurostar 3000
> Ariane S
> Paradigm
Products
> Missile systems
> UAVs
> Eurofighter
> Security solutions
Products
> ATR
> EADS North America (UH72A helicopter)
34
Ambitious
Realistic
High-value
-Added
Committing
43 Bn
Other
divisions
28 Bn
35%
98%
Airbus
65%
2%
EADS
Services
Airbus
35
2. Training
(focus on commercial)
3. Airport operations
4. Logistics
5. Engineering, consulting
& RDT
6. Facility management
7. In-flight connectivity
8. Technical assistance
9. Large System
Integration management
12. Financing
> Leasing
> Billing "by the hour"
> PFI
36
Trad. clients /
Trad. needs
Trad. clients /
New needs
E.g. airports
New clients /
New needs
New clients /
Trad. needs
E.g. Aircraft
maintenance
Product related
services
"From well know clients in well established regions to serve traditional needs to new
concepts saved potentially in new regions to new clients"
CLIENTS / REGIONS
Source: Roland Berger
37
2. On one priority segment to be selected, what strategic roadmap should Airbus adopt?
> organic vs. partnership vs. external growth
> if applicable what partners / targets
> rationale
3. How does it contribute to the EADS 2020 Vision? (macro business case)
Any innovative strategy on the other segments would be appreciated if relevant
2016.03.11 - 2. Growth Strategies in Services - Course.pptx
38