Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
By
Ricky Cobb
Philosophy 200
November 1, 2004
Cobb 2
Humanessence
Objective:
What is means to be human can only be symbolized through the constituents of
what a human is after what a human is not is eliminated.
A human being is a dying being. Because we live, we have to die. It has been said
that all doctors are ultimate failures because, in the end, people still die. We seek
immortality of body but ‘forget’ immortality of soul. Or some, knowing the body to be
impermanent, seek immortality of soul (a.k.a. the self). But what is self? Who am I? It’s a
good question to ask oneself and there’s only one lifetime to do it in (unless you believe
in multiple lives in which case you could just find out who you are in some future life,
sometime… maybe… but the only real time is now). So what does it mean to be Human
Being?
The body needs to eat to live. If it doesn’t get nourishment, it won’t live. It is
constantly shedding skin or hair, constantly renewing itself. The constant upkeep is such
a pain sometimes. Then no matter how well taken care of, or how well groomed and
supplemented, beautiful or ugly, it still dies. Plato wrote in his play Phaedo:
‘Other people may well be unaware that all who actually engage in
philosophy aright are practicing nothing other than dying and being
dead. Now if this is true, it would be odd indeed for them to be eager
in their whole life for nothing but this, and yet to be resentful when it
comes, the very thing they’d long been eager for and practiced.’
He goes on to explain why the body is something to be reviled and the soul (that
which is not the body) is to be revered and lead to the Good (Some people drop an ‘o’ and
call it God). For Plato the body inhibits the soul’s innate all-knowing (Plato 55).
That the body dies is obvious. It’s dying and creating every moment. One day, any
Cobb 4
day, it will stop creating and just pass away. Along with it goes the essence of whoever is
in it. Where that essence goes is not as important as the fact that it does go (if it goes
somewhere). What is evident is that a person’s ghost does not take up the life of a person
when the body dies. That ghost, or soul-essence, ‘moves on,’ or ‘blinks out of existence,’
or takes ‘rebirth’ in another body, or whatever your beliefs are. Therefore we must posit
that we are not the body. That is, we can not take our bodies with us no matter how much
we want to when we’re dead. What happens after we’re dead is unknown to us in life
Habit-a-holics Anonymous
Personality
Our essence is not the same as the body. So if we are to survive, which seems to
be an implanted urge we cannot escape, then there must be something else that is our
essence, a soul or self. It could be called personality, but personality changes. One could
claim to be the same person one was years ago but that would be incorrect to those that
know the person. No human can live and not undergo change to one’s ideas and
there. It is just the current collection of ideas and behaviors that enable distinction
Mmm. Doughnuts.
These ideas and behaviors could also be thought of as the urge to eat doughnuts...
or to compulsively act out any other behavior. Our habits are our ‘cruse control’ of a sort
where we told ourselves to act in a certain way in certain situations possibly long ago. So
Cobb 5
if you like doughnuts, then when you have the opportunity to eat one you probably will,
even if you’re currently full at the time and eating the doughnut would make you suffer
tend to get stuck in unless we purposefully slow down and take the time to make current
decisions.
Got Soul?
The question now becomes: Who (or what) is making the decisions? This is where
the idea of a soul comes in. A soul is said to be an immortal, non-corporeal substance
knowledge and appetition. Superior still to the sensitive soul is the rational
The rational soul is thought to be the will, that which decides. So what is this will
if we are to be it?
We have to choose. We have no choice but to choose what we’ve chosen. So all
hope for a different past must be given up. It can’t be willed to change. But the future can
be created by will (to the degree of available choices). Whether that will was
predetermined or not, it was still chosen, and since we have no way of knowing whether
Cobb 6
life’s entire story is scripted out in advance, it makes no sense for us to adopt a
predetermined view of our actions. Saying everything is predetermined is just a way out
Assuming a self necessitates personal responsibility, otherwise, it’s someone else’s fault.
This self, then, is a thing which chooses. It is also a thing which is conscious of
the senses. It ‘knows’ sounds, sights, smells, tastes, touches, and thoughts (the emotions
might be considered as thoughts). But the consciousness isn’t always there. In dreams, for
example, the senses are fooled by dream senses. The consciousness isn’t aware of the
Even without dreams the consciousness can still be latent as in the case when I
was anesthetized for surgery and had no sense impressions at all during the 2 hours I was
out. However I was aware that those two hours had passed in blank consciousness. I was
Other similar occurrences have happened to people who have Near Death
Experiences. They are not aware of their physical body sensations but somehow can
know of events going on without the physical sense organs. Therefore, consciousness
Going through this process of elimination to find the self we’re left with the
awareness of being. Consciousness can’t be the self because what is seen is not the seer,
in other words it’s just another impression upon the awareness and not the awareness
itself. The awareness is that which notices the change. Being the noticer of the change,
Cobb 7
that also makes it the change; that which is the change is therefore is the only constant.
But all traditional ideas of a ‘self’ must be given up for that to be seen. What is left is
This personality we think we own or always have will die or change, perhaps
slowly, perhaps rapidly. It is not the true self, if were to postulate a self at all. Perhaps we
are all mindless predetermined robots acting out programming, but it doesn’t seem that
way. To be human is to be aware that you can have impressions. Impressions are just
physical matter, senses, thoughts, emotions, and consciousness that ‘touch’ against
We’re still going to die, but this awareness seems eternal, not subject to death (or
birth). I say “seems” because I don’t know where I came from before I was born or where
I’m going after ‘I’ die; few can say with certainty that they do. Those who are certain,
that is, with conviction, are the ones to listen to, be they completely deluded or knowers
of the truth.
All of this is not meaningful if you don’t ask yourself the question of: “How is
this life meaningful to you?” To concluded, then, the meaning of what it is to be human is
up to the human that is being. Or, as it has been said in another way, “Life is what you
make of it.”
Cobb 8
Works Cited
Davis, Stephen F., and Joseph J. Palladino. Psychology 3rd ed. “Challenges to the Idea of
Consistency.” Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 2002, 502.
Plato, “Phaedo.” Classics of Philosophy 2nd ed. Pojman, Louis P. Ed., New York: Oxford
The Philosophy of Thomas Aquinas. “The Human Soul (Rational Psychology).” The