Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
in Reservoir Fluids
Jianzhong Wu and John M. Prausnitz
Dept. of Chemical Engineering, University of California, Berkeley, and
Chemical Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA 94720
Abbas Firoozabadi
Reservoir Engineering Research Institute, Palo Alto, CA 94304
A preiously described molecular-thermodynamic framework, based on colloid theory, is used to correlate experimental asphaltene-precipitation data at high-temperature
and pressure conditions. In this framework, asphaltenes and resins are represented by
pseudopure components, and all other components in a crude oil are presented by a
continuous medium that affects an der Waals attractions among asphaltene and resin
molecules. Model parameters are ealuated systematically from aerage properties of
asphaltenes and resins in crude oils, and from dispersion-force properties of the oil
medium. Gien the composition of the medium, and asphaltene and resin concentrations, the molecular-thermodynamic model described here can be used to identify the
onset of asphaltene precipitation, and the total amount of precipitation at the gien
operation conditions. Calculated results for the effects of oil composition and pressure
on asphaltene precipitation are in good agreement with at least some experimental measurements for four reseroir fluids, including Texaco, Shell, Weyburn, and North-Sea
crude oils.
Introduction
Asphaltene precipitation is a perennial problem in production and refining of crude oils. To avoid precipitation, it is
useful to know the solubility of asphaltenes in petroleum liquids as a function of temperature, pressure, and liquid-phase
composition. In our earlier work Wu et al., 1998., a molecular-thermodynamic framework was developed to describe the
phase behavior of asphaltene-containing fluids. In this framework, we represent asphaltenes by attractive hard spheres,
resins by attractive hard-sphere chains, and all other components by a continuous medium that affects interactions between asphaltene ] asphaltene, asphaltene ] resin, and
resin]resin pairs. We consider explicitly associations between
asphaltene and asphaltene, and between asphaltene and
resin. The potential of mean force between asphaltene and
AIChE Journal
asphaltene, as well as that between asphaltene and resin, includes hard-sphere repulsion, van der Waals attraction, and
association. Based on experimental evidence, we postulate
that, while asphaltene molecules can associate themselves or
with resin chains, resin chains cannot associate with themselves. Resins, when associated with asphaltenes, stabilize asphaltenes, thereby reducing their tendency to precipitate. We
have shown that our molecular]thermodynamic framework
can explain essentially all experimental observations for the
effects of temperature, pressure, and crude-oil composition
on asphaltene precipitation. In this work, we present a quantitative description of phase behavior based on the previously
described framework, and we illustrate its reduction to practice: once the model parameters are fixed with a few measurements, our molecular]thermodynamic framework can
predict semiquantitatively asphaltene precipitation at a variety of operating conditions.
197
1.
where superscript id stands for an ideal-gas mixture of asphaltenes and resin chains at system temperature, volume,
and molecular number densities; hs stands for the contribution from hard-sphere repulsion when resin chains are disconnected; dw stands for the contribution from van der
Waals dispersion-force . attractions; assoc stands for the
contribution from asphaltene ]asphaltene and asphaltene ]
resin associations; and chain stands for the entropic contribution to A from connectivity of resin chains.
The ideal-gas contribution to the Helmholtz energy takes
into account the translational kinetic energy of asphaltenes
and resin chains in the solution. It is given by
Aid
s
kT
Ni ln r i L3i . y Nt ,
2.
is A , R
where k is the Boltzmann constant; T is absolute temperature; NA and NR are the number of asphaltene molecules
and resin chains; Nt s NA q NR is the total number of
molecules; rA s NArV and r R s NRrV are, respectively, the
number densities of asphaltene molecules and resin chains; V
stands for volume; L i stands for the thermal wavelength of
molecule i for is A, asphaltene molecule, and for cs R,
resin chain. Because L i depends only on temperature for a
given i, it cancels in phase-equilibrium calculations.
The contribution to the Helmholtz energy from hard-sphere
interactions among asphaltene and resin segments not resin
chains. is obtained from the equation of Mansoori et al.
1971.:
Ah s
kT
s Nts
j 23
j 0 j 32
y1 ln 1y j 3 .
3j 1 j 2
j 0 1y j 3 .
j 23
j 3 j 0 1y j 3 .
Ad w
V
s
kT
Ui j
ri r j kT ,
4.
i s 1 js 1
w . 2
where Ui j s 4p Hs`i jWi d
r r dr with si j s si q sj .r2. In Eq.
j
4, Ui jrV is the mean-field. average pair-dispersion energy
for all ij pairs, that is, for all pairs formed by asphaltene and
resin segments in the oil medium Ui j is similar to parameter
a i j in the van der Waals equation of state for mixtures.. The
w .
potential of mean force, Wi d
r , due to dispersion interacj
tion between two segments in an oil medium is given by Wu
et al., 1998.
w
Wi d
r . sy
j
Him j
p 2r i0r j0 r 6
5.
6.
3.
Nt kT
s Na X A ln xa q
q X R ln xb q
1y xa
2
1y xb
2
/
/
7.
where X A and X R are, respectively, mole fractions of asphaltene molecules and resin chains on a medium-free basis; xa
is the fraction of association sites at asphaltene molecules
AIChE Journal
y1
y1
8.
9.
where rA, r R are as before; the number densities of asphaltene molecules and resin chains in the oil medium; Daa , Dab
are given by
hs
Daa s g 11
s 11 . w exp z aarkT . y1x s 113 k a a
10.
hs
Dab s g 12
s 12 . exp z a brkT . y1 s 123 k a b ,
11.
1
1y j 3
3 si sj
j2
si q sj . 1y j 3 .
q2
si sj
si q sj
j 22
1y j 3 . 3
12.
hs
s NR 1y l R . ln g 22
s 22 . ,
13.
h s
where g 22
s 22 . is the contact value of the pair correlation
function between resin segments given by Eq. 12. Equation
13 takes into account the difference in hard-sphere contribution of the Helmholtz energy between hard-sphere chains and
unconnected hard spheres.
Calculations presented earlier Wu et al., 1998. showed that
the above molecular-thermodynamic framework can explain
essentially all observed experimental results for asphaltene
precipitation in crude oils, that is, the effects of temperature,
pressure, and composition. To apply this framework to asphaltene precipitation at reservoir conditions, we first need
to establish a reliable method to estimate required model parameters. Because asphaltene precipitation at reservoir conditions is often accompanied by a vapor]liquid equilibrium
VLE., and because the Hamaker constant of the medium
depends on its density and composition, we also need a reliable method for estimating liquid density and VLE for reservoir fluids. For this purpose, we use the volume-shifted
Peng-Robinson equation of state with an appropriate C 7q
AIChE Journal
199
a 02 I
4 4pe 0 . 2
15.
CH 4
N2
H2S
CO 2
3
a0 , A
I, Ev
B=10 78 , J ? m6
2.59
1.74
3.86
2.91
12.51
15.58
10.45
13.77
10.1
5.67
18.7
14.0
a 0 and I are from CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 76th ed.,
CRC Press, New York 1995 ..
14.
Bs
p 2 Bi j ri r j ,
16 .
'
AIChE Journal
mXA s mYA
17.
mXR s mYR
18.
19.
Segment diameter, A
Hamaker constant, 10 20 , J
SAFT k-parameter
Asphaltene
Resin Chain
2,000
1,200
1
15
13.2
0.05
800
1,000
10
5
9.06
0.05
201
N2
CO 2
C1
C2
C3
i-C 4
n-C 4
i-C 5
n-C 5
C6
C 7q
HCGU
mol %
Oil a1
mol %
Oil a2
mol %
3.17
17.76
30.33
26.92
13.09
1.26
4.66
0.77
1.26
0.78
0.00
0.57
2.46
36.37
3.47
4.05
0.59
1.34
0.74
0.83
1.62
47.96
0.51
1.42
6.04
7.00
6.86
0.83
3.35
0.70
3.46
3.16
66.67
329
0.96
16.8
21.5
281
0.90
9
12.25
MC q, Da
C 7q density, grml
wt. % asphalteneUU
wt. % resin
Weyburn Oil
mol %
C1
C2
C3
i-C 4
n-C 4
i-C 5
n-C 5
C6
C 7q
North-Sea Oil
mol %
0.1
0.48
2.05
0.88
3.16
1.93
2.58
4.32
84.5
N2
CO 2
H2S
C1
C2
C3
i-C 4
n-C 4
i-C 5
n-C 5
C 6q
0.96
0.58
0.3
4.49
2.99
4.75
0.81
1.92
1.27
2.19
79.74
250
0.96
3.9
14.1
C 6 q .
C 6 q .
230
0.870
4.7
8.51
N2
CO 2
C1
C2
C3
i-C 4
n-C 4
i-C 5
n-C 5
C6
C 7q
Sep. Oil
mol %
Sep. Gas
mol %
0
0
8.365
4.848
7.888
1.486
5.586
2.201
3.263
4.53
61.833
2.357
0.426
67.496
12.793
9.733
1.215
3.027
0.815
0.761
0.619
0.758
218
0.83
0.9
2.8
UU
mA s
mR s
/
/
NA
20.
T , V , NR
NR
P sy
21.
T , V , NA
/
V
22.
T , NA , N R
ing or simplex algorithm is used to search for the global minimum of the tangent-plane distance Pan and Firoozabadi,
1998a..
When an asphaltene-containing crude oil is in contact with
a gas phase, we need to find the composition of the oil
medium, as well as the asphaltene and resin concentrations
of the crude-oil phase from the vapor]liquid equilibrium. For
this purpose, we use the volume-shifted PREOS. Binary parameters k i j for interactions among the light components are
obtained from Katz and Firoozabadi 1978.. For interactions
among heavy hydrocarbons, we use the Chueh-Prausnitz correlation 1967.:
23.
24.
25.
k i j s1y
2Vc1r6
Vc1r6
i
j
Vc1r3
qVc1r3
i
j
26.
AIChE Journal
AIChE Journal
that actually present in the crude oil. The fitted weight percents of resins of two Texaco oils are also listed in Table 3.
Figure 4 shows asphaltene precipitation from mixtures of
Texaco oil a1 and a scrubber gas at 373 K and 20.9 MPa. At
the conditions shown in this plot, the applied pressure is lower
than the saturation pressures of the mixtures; therefore, the
crude oil is in contact with a gas phase. Figure 4 presents the
amount of asphaltene in both the asphaltene-rich liquid phase
and in the solvent-rich phase after asphaltene precipitation.
Due to experimental uncertainties, measured amounts of asphaltenes in the two equilibrated liquid phases do not satisfy
material balances. Both experiment and calculated results
show that the amount of asphaltene precipitated falls slightly
as the overall concentration of the scrubber gas rises. The
decline in the amount of asphaltene precipitation is because
the liquid density of the oil medium increases as more scrubber gas dissolves in the crude oil at the prevailing temperature and pressure. Our calculated results agree reasonably
well with the experimental measurements.
Figure 5 shows the effect of pressure on asphaltene precipitation for the same crude oil as that discussed in Figure 4.
Because we have fixed all model parameters and resin content, no additional adjustable parameters are used in these
calculations. The saturation pressure of the crude oil is about
200 bar. Both experiment and our theory show a weak nonmonotonic pressure effect on the amount of asphaltene precipitation. This nonmonotonic effect is related to the saturation pressure of the mixture. When the applied pressure is
lower than the saturation pressure of the mixture, an increase in pressure dissolves more gas, causing more asphaltene precipitation; on the other hand, when the pressure is
higher than the saturation pressure, the density of the medium
increases with applied pressure. The amount of asphaltene
precipitation decreases as the density of the medium rises.
Our calculations agree reasonably well with measurements
over the pressure interval studied in the experiments. Figures
4 and 5 suggest that, once model parameters are fixed using
203
was determined by tangent-plane stability analysis of the system Pan and Firoozabadi, 1998a.. Figure 7 shows calculated
and measured pressures at the onset of asphaltene precipitation for tank oil a1 in contact with propane. In this calculation, the number of association sites per asphaltene molecule
is again equal to 6, but association energy parameters are
obtained by fitting to the experimental onset-pressure data,
zA ArkT0 s 5.26 and zA RrkT0 s 7.92, where T0 s 298 K. The
same set of parameters was then used to predict the onset of
asphaltene precipitation for a mixture of tank oil a1 and normal decane in contact with propane at different temperatures. Figure 7 also shows predicted and measured pressures
at the onset of asphaltene precipitation for the mixture of
tank oil a1 and normal decane in contact with propane. For
this Shell tank oil, agreement between predicted and experimental results is reasonably good. In this example, several
experimental points are neglected in Figure 7 because one
point is a duplicate, and because at low temperature, wax
precipitation was expected as indicated by the original authors.
AIChE Journal
Figure 8. Effect of CO 2 injection on asphaltene precipitation for Weyburn oil at 16 MPa and 332 K.
Points are measurements by Sirvastava et al. 1995 .; line is
calculated.
Figure 9. Calculated and measured saturation pressure, and density of mixtures of separator oil
and separator gas of the North-Sea oil at 365
K.
Points are experimental data by Fotland et al. 1997 .; lines
are calculated.
205
Acknowledgments
This work was supported, in part, by the Director, Office of Energy Research, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Chemical Sciences
Division of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DEAC03-76SF00098. For initial support, we are grateful to the University of California Energy Institute.
Literature Cited
Figure 10. Calculated and experimental pressure at onset of asphaltene precipitation for North-Sea
oils at 365 K.
Points are experimental data by Fotland et al. 1997.; line
is calculated.
Fotland et al. also reported experimental data on asphaltene precipitation for the same crude oil at 333 K. They found
that temperature has essentially no effect on the pressure at
the onset of asphaltene precipitation, and on the bubble-point
pressure of the crude oil. It is difficult for us to interpret
these results. Our model predicts that the onset pressure is
sensitive to temperature changes, because a change in temperature not only affects interactions among asphaltenes and
resins, but also changes the equilibrium composition of the
asphaltene-containing liquid phase.
Conclusions
The effect of the oil medium on asphaltene precipitation is
determined only by its Hamaker constant as obtained from
the oils density and from the concentration of light components in the oil. At reservoir conditions when the crude oil is
in equilibrium with light-component gases, the properties of
the medium, and the contents of asphaltene and resin in the
oil phase can be reliably calculated using the volume-shifted
PREOS with an appropriate C 7q characterization procedure
and with suitable binary interaction parameters. In general,
because the asphaltene content in the oil is not large, asphaltene precipitation does not significantly affect oil-vapor equilibria.
The molecular]thermodynamic model discussed here has
been tested with experimental data for a few reservoir fluids
to describe the effects of pressure and oil composition on
asphaltene precipitation. This model can be applied to identify 1. the operation conditions at the onset of asphaltene
precipitation, and 2. the amount of precipitation under various reservoir conditions. Most parameters in our model can
be estimated independently from average properties of as206
Alexander, G. L., A. L. Creagh, and J. M. Prausnitz, Phase Equilibria for High-Boiling Fossil-Fuel Distillates. 1. Characterization,
Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam., 24, 301 1985..
Artok, L., Y. Su, Y. Hirose, M. Hosokawa, S. Murata, and M. Nomura, Structure and Reactivity of Petroleum-Derived Asphaltene, Energy Fuels, 13, 287 1999..
Burke, N. E., R. E. Hobbs, and S. F. Kashou, Measurement and
Modeling of Asphaltene Precipitation, J. Pet. Technol., 42, 1440
1990..
Chapman, W. G., G. Jackson, and K. E. Gubbins, Phase Equilibria
of Associating Fluids, Chain Molecules with Multiple Bonding
Sites, Mol. Phys., 65, 1057 1988..
Chapman, W. G., K. E. Gubbins, G. Jackson, and M. Radosz, New
Reference Equation of State for Associating Liquids, Ind. Eng.
Chem. Res., 29, 1709 1990..
Chueh, P. L., and J. M. Prausnitz, Vapor-Liquid Equiibria at High
Pressures: Calculation of Partial Molar Volume in Non-Polar Liquid Mixtures, AIChE J., 13, 1107 1967..
Cotterman, R. L., and J. M. Prausnitz, Flash Calculations for Continuous or Semi-Continuous Mixtures using Equation of State, Ind.
Eng. Chem. Process Des. De., 24, 434 1985..
Fotland, P., H. Anfinsen, H. Foerdedal, and H. P. Hjermstad, The
Phase Diagrams of Asphaltenes: Experimental Technique, Results
and Modeling on Some North Sea Crude Oils, Symposium on the
Chemistry of the Asphaltene and Related Substances, Cancun,
Mexico 1997..
Hansen, J. P., and I. R. McDonald, Theory of Simple Liquids, 2nd ed.,
Academic Press, San Diego 1986..
Hirschberg, A., L. N. J. de Jong, B. A. Schipper, and J. G. Meyers,
Influence of Temperature and Pressure on Asphaltene Flocculation, SPE J., 283 1984..
Hong, S. G, K. A. Green, and K. D. Luks, Solubility and Volumetric Behavior of Methane and Carbon Dioxide Plus C 7 q Pseudocomponents of an Oil, Fluid Phase Equilibria, 95, 267 1994..
Huang, S. H., and M. Radosz, Equation of State for Small, Large,
Polydisperse and Associating Molecules, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res.,
29, 2284 1990..
Israelachvili, J., Intermolecular & Surface Forces, Academic Press,
London 1991..
Katz, D. L., and A. Firoozabadi, Predicting Phase Behavior of CondensaterCrude-Oil Systems Using Methane Interaction Coefficients, J. Pet. Technol., 1649 1978..
Kokal, S. L., and S. G. Sayegh, Gas-Saturated Bitumen Density
Predictions Using the Volume Translated Peng-Robinson Equation of State, J. Can. Pet. Technol., 29, 77 1990..
Mansoori, G. A., N. F. Carnahan, K. E. Starling, and T. W. Leland,
Equilibrium Thermodynamic Properties of the Mixture of Hard
Spheres, J. Chem. Phys., 54, 1523 1971..
Michelsen, M. L., The Isothermal Flash Problem. I. Stability, Fluid
Phase Equilibria, 9, 1 1982..
Mitchell, D. L., and J. G. Speight, The Solubility of Asphaltenes in
Hydrocarbon Solvents, Fuel, 53, 149 1973..
AIChE Journal
volume-shifted method has been successfully applied to calculate the densities of gas-saturated bitumen Kokal and
Sayegh, 1990..
Our application of the volume-shifted PREOS is different
from that of Kokal and Sayegh 1990. for supercritical components. We calculate the volume-offset of a supercritical
component by comparison with molar volumes obtained from
the Schreiber-Pitzer equation 1989. at system pressure and
temperature. Further, because the Rackett constant is often
unavailable, especially for pseudocomponents, we calculate
the Rackett constant from a single measured liquid density.
For a discrete component of a crude oil, the required experimental liquid density is available at ambient conditions. For a
pseudocomponent, the required single liquid density is provided by our C 7q characterization procedure, as discussed in
Appendix B.
To illustrate, Figure A1 shows calculated and observed liquid molar volumes for two crude oils at saturation conditions.
Experimental data are from Hong et al. 1994.. Compared
with the original PREOS, the improvement of the volumeshifted method is significant. As pointed out by Peneloux
1982., the volume-shifted method does not affect VLE calculations provided that the volume correction is applied to
both liquid and vapor phases.
207
of phase equilibria of reservoir fluids. The C 7q characterization for a heavy crude oil should be based on experimental
measurements from distillation or chromatographic fractionation Alexander et al., 1985.. Unfortunately, such detailed
information is generally not available in the literature for asphaltene-containing mixtures. Some methods characterize a
C 7q fraction based on molecular weight or boiling-point temperature; the C 7q fraction is represented by a set of pseudocomponents or by a continuous distribution function Whitson et al., 1990, and references therein .. The advantage of a
traditional method is that it can represent reasonably well
one particular property of the C 7q fraction such as molecular-weight distribution ., but it usually provides no information for other properties of practical interest such as
boiling-point temperature or density.. As a result, when a cubic equation of state is used to describe the phase behavior
of a reservoir fluid, the equation-of-state parameters are estimated using empirical correlations based only on one property. Subsequent calculations could be unreliable because
components having one identical property may differ significantly in other properties.
The need to include both molecular-weight and density information was shown over 20 years ago by Katz and Firoozabadi 1978.. Here we describe an alternative method to
characterize C 7q fractions.
First, a C 7q fraction is divided into a set of pseudocomponents based on known average molecular weight and on an
assumed variance; here the molecular weight of the C 7q fraction is represented by a G-distribution function, and the
Gaussian quadrature method is used to convert the continuous distribution to obtain pseudocomponents Cotterman and
Prausnitz, 1985.. Then the density of each pseudocomponent
at ambient conditions is calculated from a correlation between the density and molecular weight. Our C 7q characterization method requires average and variance of molecularweight distribution, and average density at ambient conditions. If an experimental variance is not available, we use 700
for a typical crude oil. Six quadrature points are used in most
of our calculations. In general, VLE calculations are not sensitive to the variance and number of quadrature points.
However, dew point calculations are sensitive to the distribution of very heavy components.. This new procedure represents each pseudocomponent, with two properties, molecular
weight and liquid density, at ambient conditions.
The correlation between density at ambient conditions, d i ,
grmL. and molecular weight Mi grmol. of a C 7q pseudocomponent is empirically represented by
1
1
s
di
Table B1. Molecular Weight (MW) and Density ( d ) of
C 7 Hydrocarbons
Hydrocarbon
Toluene
c-Heptane
1,2-Dimethylcyclopentane, cis
1,2-Dimethylcyclopenane, trans
Ethylcyclopentane
Methylcyclohexane
1-Heptene
2,3,3-Trimethyl-1-butene
n-Heptane
2-Methylhexane
3-Methylhexane
2,2-Dimethylhexane
2,3-Dimethylhexane
2,4-Dimethylhexane
3,3-Dimethylhexane
3-Ethylpentane
2,3,3-Trimethylbutane
Average
U
TU
K
293
293
289
289
289
289
293
293
293
293
293
293
293
293
293
293
293
292.1
MW
Da
d=10y3
kgrm3
92.141
98.189
98.189
98.189
98.189
98.189
98.189
98.189
100.205
100.205
100.205
100.205
100.205
100.205
100.205
100.205
100.205
0.867
0.81
0.777
0.756
0.771
0.774
0.697
0.705
0.684
0.679
0.687
0.674
0.695
0.673
0.693
0.698
0.69
98.90
0.73
208
c1
c2
Mi2
Mi
1.2
B1 .
M
c1 s
1
y
1.2
y M02
1
1
y
d 0 1.2
xi
1y M0
i
M0
c 2 s M0
1
d0
1
y
1.2
yM
xi
Mi
B2 .
Mi
1y M0
xi
1
y
1.2
B3 .
Mi
AIChE Journal
AIChE Journal
Manuscript receied Jan 22, 1999, and reision receied Aug. 2, 1999.
209