Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
DOI 10.1007/s00253-013-4768-2
MINI-REVIEW
Received: 20 December 2012 / Revised: 8 February 2013 / Accepted: 9 February 2013 / Published online: 17 March 2013
# Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2013
Abstract Early biotechnology (BT) had its roots in fascinating discoveries, such as yeast as living matter being
responsible for the fermentation of beer and wine. Serious
controversies arose between vitalists and chemists, resulting
in the reversal of theories and paradigms, but prompting
continuing research and progress. Pasteurs work led to the
establishment of the science of microbiology by developing
pure monoculture in sterile medium, and together with the
work of Robert Koch to the recognition that a single pathogenic organism is the causative agent for a particular
disease. Pasteur also achieved innovations for industrial
processes of high economic relevance, including beer, wine
and alcohol. Several decades later Buchner, disproved the
hypothesis that processes in living cells required a metaphysical vis vitalis in addition to pure chemical laws.
Enzymes were shown to be the chemical basis of bioconversions. Studies on the formation of products in microbial
fermentations, resulted in the manufacture of citric acid, and
chemical components required for explosives particularly in
war time, acetone and butanol, and further products through
fermentation. The requirements for penicillin during the
Second World War lead to the industrial manufacture of
penicillin, and to the era of antibiotics with further antibiotics, like streptomycin, becoming available. This was
followed by a new class of high value-added products,
K. Buchholz (*)
Institute for Chemical Engineering,
Technical University of Braunschweig, Hans-Sommer Str. 10,
38106 Braunschweig, Germany
e-mail: k.buchholz@tu-bs.de
J. Collins
Life Science Faculty, c/o Helmholtz Centre
for InfectionResearch - HZI, AG Directed Evolution,
Technical University of Braunschweig, Inhoffenstr. 7,
38124 Braunschweig, Germany
e-mail: tojohncollins@gmail.com
Introduction
Fermentation has been of great practical and economic
relevance as a handicraft for thousands of years, notably
3748
3749
Beer fermentation
Wine fermentation
Soja fermentation
Industrial acetic acid fermentation
Technical application
Berzelius (1836)
(Birch 1990) and Geison (1995). The first basic question which
Pasteur definitively answered was that of the origin and character of fermentation: Was it brought about by living microorganisms, or by pure chemical phenomena, as Liebig, Berzelius
and their school believed? In the 1850s, Pasteur had visited a
factory for alcohol production on a nearly daily basis and took
samples of the fermentation broth which he investigated in his
laboratory. Losses in alcoholic fermentation were an initial
stimulus to work on a scientific explanation and on finding
technical solutions. After numerous microscopical observations, he observed yeast buds in normal fermentation runs,
but rods that he soon identified as lactic acid yeast, when
the fermentation ran sour (due to the formation of acetic or
lactic acid) (Pasteur 1857b). He investigated lactic acid fermentation in detail. In his paper on the topic, Pasteur (1857a)
elaborated the essentials of fermentation processes. He
presented the means with which to isolate microorganisms in
a pure culture. In his discussion he introduced (1) the biological
conception of fermentation as the result of the activity of living
microorganisms; (2) he discussed the practice of inoculation for
starting a reliable fermentation, that was also common practice
in beer fermentation; (3) the notion of specificity, according to
which each fermentation could be traced to a specific microbe;
(4) the essential experimental factor that the fermentation medium must provide the nutrients for the microorganism; and (5)
specific chemical features characterized by the main fermentation products and by products (Pasteur 1857a, b).
One of the mysteries of fermentation had remained highly controversial, the hypothesis of a generatio spontanea,
spontaneous generation of living organisms. Pasteur (1862)
addressed this basic and controversial question efficiently.
He referred to Schwann and others whose serious work he
repeated and confirmed, with significant experimental modifications (see also Geison 1995 p. 115). In addition to
highly precise experiments using various methods, Pasteur
undertook something of a show in 1860 with expeditions to
high altitude mountains, most spectacularly to the Alps and
the glacier Mer de Glace, to demonstrate the existence of
germ free air, in contrast to air under normal conditions
carrying germs causing infection in sugar juices (and in
fermentation). The results of these experiments were
presented by Pasteur first in a lecture to the Socit
Chimique de Paris in 1861 and then in a famous lecture at
the Sorbonne in 1864, a demonstrative performance for tout
Paris. The finding of yeasts and their living nature, as well
as the knowledge of their origin, eliminates the mystery of
the spontaneous occurence of fermentations of natural sugar
juices (Pasteur 1876, pp. 229, 230). Pasteur made a
radical attack against the chemical school, with Liebig as
the head, this being the central arena of dispute on fermentation (Pasteur 1860; Geison 1995).
Pasteurs book Etudes sur la Bire (Pasteur 1876) gave a
thorough experimental, theoretical and scientific account of
his investigations, results, and conclusions. He developed
3750
Table 2 The period from 1850 to 1890 (Scriban 1982, pp.13, 14; Buchholz and Collins 2010, chapters 3 and 4)
Time, scientists
1837/1838 Schwann
and Cagniard-Latour
1850 Rayer and
Davaine
18561877 Pasteur
1866 Mendel
1876 Koch
1877-86 Pasteur
1880 Winogradsky
1881 Pasteur
There are, of course, more scientists and events which have been relevant; however, inevitably, a selection must be made
3751
3752
3753
3754
Table 3 The period from 1890 to 1940 (Buchholz and Collins 2010, chapter 4; Roehr 1996)
Time, scientistsa
1894 E. Fischer
1897 Buchner
1900s Buchner
1905 E. Fischer and others
Specificity of enzymes
Fermentation due to enzyme action only
Rersearch on fermentation intermediates
Research in the nature of proteins
1910f Fernbach
1911f Fernbach and Strange;
1912f Perkin
1915f Weizmann
1915f Connstein and Ldecke
1916 Thom and Currie
1920s
1920s and 1930s Embden,
Meyerhoff and others
1925, 1930s Sumner, Northrup
1928 Fleming
1933 Reichstein
End of 1930s Florey and Chain
1940
Research on glycolysis
Enzyme crystallization
Finding of penicillin action
Sorbitol transformation into L-sorbose
Resumed research on penicillin
Protein structure solved
Selected scientists and events relevant for applied microbiology (see also first footnote in Table 2)
Most intermediates mentioned here, butanol, acetone, citric acid, etc., have been observed before, but not developed further for industrial
production
3755
3756
Table 4 The period from 1940 to 1975 (Buchholz and Poulson 2000; Bud 2007; Buchholz and Collins 2010, chapters 4 and 5)
Time, scientists
1941
1944
Structure of DNA
Development of immobilized enzymes
First biotech journal a
This and the following table overlap in time scale due to events that are part of the two different periods
6-APA 6-aminopenicillanic acid, intermediate for the production of ampicillin and other semisynthetic penicillin derivatives
a
Journal of Microbiological and Biochemical Engineering; it later became Biotechnology and Bioengineering
involved in BT research and development work were microbiology, cell biology, biochemistry, andto a limited
extentmolecular biology and genetics in addition to
chemical engineering. Recombinant DNA methods were
not mentioned since they were not available at the time of
writing the study (197274) (Buchholz 1979; Buchholz and
Collins 2010, chapter 5).
Research work in the field of BT proceeded as subtopic
within a motley collection of scientific and engineering disciplines with a low level of coherence and little integration up
till the 1960s and 1970s. During the 1940s, Stephensons
Bacterial Metabolism and of Kluyvers Chemical Activities
of Micro-Organisms appeared, the Grungschemische
Praktikum, by Bernhauer was published in 1936 (Bud
1993). Later, textbooks dealt with specific topics (not on
BT as an integrated field), signifying increased attention to
the field: on applied microbiology (Rehm 1967, Pirt 1975), as
well as on biochemical engineering (Aiba et al. 1965; Bailey
and Ollis 1977). The first encyclopedias and series on BT
were issued by Rehm and Reed (1981) and Flickinger and
Drew (1999). Thus, biotechnology did not exist as a scientific
discipline and there were no books, rather no journals, curricula or scientific conferences devoted to the subject. A few
UK and American universities offered special courses;
University College London established a curriculum granting
a Master of Science in Biochemical Engineering in the 1960s,
and another BT curriculum was established in the 1970s at
the Technical University of Berlin (Buchholz 1979, pp. 69,
71). The first BT journal of high reputation was established in
1958 by Elmer Gaden as the Journal of Microbiological and
Biochemical Engineering. It later became Biotechnology and
Bioengineering and is still a leading journal in the field. A
few other journals appeared in the 1950s and 1960s, for
example Applied Microbiology, renamed Environmental and
Applied Microbiology and Applied Microbiology and
Biotechnology.
3757
3758
Technical application
These topics are difficult to assign, a range of arguments being raised in terms of their classification as technical application, not fundamental
research
Walsh 2007, pp. 297, 298); this was at a time when some
heads of European pharmaceutical companies did not believe that a recombinant DNA product would ever be approved for clinical use. This precedent , notably the
approval human insulin as the first recombinant DNA
product on the market, was followed by a series of further
recombinant products, mostly drugs, which in general could
not be produced by other technical means, and which are of
great medical interest. Some of these products previously
isolated in small amounts from human blood or tissue were
in danger of being contaminated with human pathogenic
viruses (not all known at that time, e.g. AIDS virus, HCV).
In this respect, this alternative production route provided products not only in sufficient quantity for general use but also with
an improved and reproducible quality. The products included
human growth hormone in 1983, -interferon, and a hepatitis
B vaccine in 1986, tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) in 1987,
and erythropoietin in 1989 (product approval). Actually, recombinant proteins, including hormones and growth factors,
blood clotting factors, cytokines, monoclonal antibodies and
vaccines are most important biopharmaceuticals, with a market size estimated of some $50 billion per year around 2010
(Walsh 2007, Aggarwal 2007). Antibiotics remained an important sector of biopharmaceuticals, with many different
specialties and sales estimated at more than $50 billion per
year (Hubschwerlen 2007).
Large investment by multinational companies, the foundation of many small new companies, a few of which have
grown remarkably, and state funded big research merged in
a gold rush into the New Biotechnology, as recombinant
technology was termed in the USA. Key steps toward the
transfer of science into the economic sphere resulted in the
foundation of new BT companies, the first being Cetus,
started in 1971, later the originator of the polymerase chain
reaction (PCR; Kary Mullis) which gave birth to the era of
gene diagnostics and personalized medicine. Herbert Boyer
and Robert Swanson founded Genentech in 1976; amongst
the most important companies founded were Biogen (1978),
Amgen (1980) and Chiron (1981), later bought by Cetus
(Demain 2001, 2003, personal communication; Buchholz
and Collins 2010, chapters 5, 6, 17; for a recent survey,
see Table 17.5).
Industrial products, other than pharmaceuticals, expanded
as well, based both on traditional and recombinant methods,
with sales worldwide estimated over 50 billion . The most
important bulk products are ethanol, amino and organic
acids, produced in large amounts, vitamins, and biopolymers. Metabolic engineering has been used successfully for
the optimization of yields, e.g. for the production of amino
acids (for a survey, see Buchholz and Collins 2010, chapter
16). A very large sector for application of biotechnology is
in fact environmental technology which has become an
important industry. This includes waste water treatment,
3759
3760
expectation, e.g. with respect to drug targeting, the following comment was put forward a transformational technology will always have its immediate consequences
overestimated and its long-term consequences underestimated,
and ....you may just start to imagine all the projects that will
spin-off (C&EN 2010). Much progress took place
largely through the involvement of flexible biotech companies such as Genentech, Cetus, Amgen and Biogen which
concentrated on innovative development in parallel with a
lethargy and bad management in large (particularly
European) pharmaceutical companies which lost their
dominance in this new field.
The second major event may be considered the understanding of the factors which control pluripotent and totipotent stem-cells and the controlled reprogramming of many
differentiated cells to such stem cells. This opens a new area
of medical research, production of models for genetic
diseases (for personalized medicine), and a radical new
approach to understanding cancer, developments which will
give potential to a new area of biotechnological development. This found its origin in the work of those studying the
molecular biology of cell differentiation and embryogenesis,
originally in insect, worm or animal models, as did for
example the Nobel laureate Christiane Nusslein-Volhardt
and as those most recently recognized with a Nobel Prize
(2012 Physiology or Medicine) for Sir John B. Gurdon and
Shinya Yamanaka.
A further event that received inordinate publicity was the
chemical synthesis of the entire genome of Mycoplasma
genitalium by the group of Craig Venter; transferring this
DNA into a foreign Mycoplasma caused replacement of the
resident genome by the completely synthetic genome,
forming a novel strain capable of continuous self-replication
(Gibson et al. 2010). The scientific relevance of this experiment, however, has been extensively debated, but subsequent
steps in synthetic biology may become a key technology
(Bornscheuer 2010). Although it is definitely not creation
of life, as many journalists sensationalized this milestone, it
may still be considered as a further step in the tradition of
Pasteur making use of living organisms, e.g. creating novel
cells with new synthetic potential.
Conclusions
The history of biotechnology comprises exciting developments over more than 200 years, from mysterious concepts
to rational science and technology, with great social and
medical achievements, and commercial impact. A review
of this history suggests that basic research and the solution
to open problems and unknown phenomena, have provided
a rational basis for a range of major technical innovations,
with which new industries emerged. Thus might be
interpreted the development from early fermentation research to Pasteurs concept of microbiology and technical
innovations, from Buchner and Fernbach towards Perkins
and Weizmanns processes, from Fleming towards Floreys
and Chains work, and the penicillin project, and Watsons
and Cricks solution of the DNA structure towards the
cloning concept by Berg, Cohen, Boyer, and towards the
establishment of new companies and New Biotechnology.
Recently, applied microbiology, biochemical engineering
and molecular biology have merged to form biotechnology
as a new scientific discipline in its own right, sharing a
common paradigm at the molecular level with all the other
life sciences (Buchholz 2007). Biotechnology continues, as
well, as a field of technology, to develop new technical
processes and products based on a rational scientific basis.
A diversification arose through the formation of subdisciplines, such as genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics, metabolic flux analysis with quantitative analysis of complex
metabolites, and finally biochemical engineering, which
merged into biosystems engineering.
Finally, we note that critical events during the historic
development of Biotechnology are associated with exceptional personalities who often had the vision and insight of
how their findings could be developed for the benefit of
science and humanity, translating them into practical invention finally leading to innovation. Public and private investment programs often came slowly on advice or practical
validation of radical advances by a few pioneers (This latter
aspect is treated in more detail throughout Buchholz and
Collins 2010).
References
Abraham EP, Chain E (1940) An enzyme from bacteria able to destroy
penicillin. Nature 146:837
Aggarwal S (2007) Whats fueling the biotech engine? Nat Biotechnol
25:10971104
Aiba S, Humphrey AE, Millis NF (1965) Biochemical engineering.
Academic Press, New York
AIChE (1970) The history of penicillin production. Chem Eng Progr
Symp Ser No. 100, vol. 66, American Institute of Chemical
Engineers, New York
Bailey JE (1991) Towards a science of metabolic engineering. Science
252: 16681675
Bailey JE (1996) Metabolic engineering. Advances in Molecular and
Cell Biology 15:289296
Bailey JE, Ollis DF (1977/1986) Biochemical engineering fundamentals,
1st, 2nd edn. McGraw-Hill, New York
Bchamp MA (1864) Sur la fermentation alcoolique. Bulletin de la
Socit Chimique de Paris 1:391392
3761
Connstein W, Ldecke K (1919a) Preparation of glycerol by fermentation. J Soc Chem Ind 38:691A692A
Connstein W, Ldecke K (1919b) ber Glyceringewinnung durch
Grung. Ber 52:13851391
Dechema F (1974) Biotechnologie. Dechema, Frankfurt
Deckwer W-D, Jahn D, Hempel D, Zeng A-D (2006) Systems biology
approaches to bioprocess development. Eng Life Sci 6:455469
Delaunay A (1951) Pasteur et la Microbiologie. Presses Universitaires
de France, Paris
Demain AL (1981) Industrielle Mikrobiologie. Spektrum der
Wissenschaft, November: 2126
Demain AL (2001) J Ind Microb Biotechnol 27:352356
Elder AL (1970) The role of the government in the penicillin program.
AIChE (1970) pp. 111
Fernbach A (1910) Sur la dgradation biologique des hydrates de
carbonne. Comptes rendus des sances de lAcadmie des sciences (Paris) 151:10041006
Fernbach A, Strange EH (1911) Fermentation process producing amyl,
butyl, or ethyl alcohol, butyric, propionic, or acetic acid, etc.
British Pat 15:203
Fischer E (1909) Einflu der Konfiguration auf die Wirkung der
Enzyme. In: Untersuchungen ber Kohlenhydrate und Fermente.
Springer, Berlin, pp 836844
Flickinger MC, Drew SW (eds) (1999) Encyclopedia of bioprocess
technology. Wiley, New York
Florkin M (1975) The discovery of cellfree fermentation. In: M Florkin
(ed) A history of biochemistry. Comprehensive Biochemistry,
Vol. 31, pp. 2337
Frey JF (1930) Lactic acid. Ind Eng Chem 22:11531154
Fruton, JS, Simmonds, S (1953) The scope and history of biochemistry. In: General Biochemistry. Wiley, New York; (a) 114, (b) 17
19, (c) 199205
Geison GL (1995) The private science of Louis Pasteur. Princeton
University Press, Princeton
Gibson DG, Glass JI, Lartigue C, Noskov VN, Chuang R-Y, Algire
MA, Benders GA, Montague MG, Ma L, Moodie MM,
Merryman C, Vashee S, Krishnakumar R, Assad-Garcia N,
Andrews-Pfannkoch C, Denisova EA, Young L, Qi Z-Q, SegallShapiro TH, Calvey CH, Parmar PP, Hutchison CA III, Smith
HO, Venter JC (2010) Creation of a bacterial cell controlled by a
chemically synthesized genome. Science 329:5256
Greene AJ, Schmitz AJ Jr. (1970) Meeting the objective. AIChE, p. 7988
Hodgkin D (1979) Crystallographic measurements and the structure of
protein molecules as they are. In: Srinivasan PR, Fruton JS, Edsall
JT (eds) The origins of modern biochemistry. New York Academy
of Sciences, New York, pp. 121148
Hotchkiss RD (1979) The identification of nucleic acids as genetic
determinants. In: Srinivasan PR, Fruton JS, Edsall JT (eds) The
origins of modern biochemistry. New York Academy of Sciences,
New York, pp. 321342
Hubschwerlen C (2007) -Lactam antibiotics. In: Plattner JJ, Desai
MC (eds) Comprehensive medicinal chemistry II, vol 7. Elsevier,
Amsterdam, pp 497517
Jasanoff S (1985) Technological innovation in a corporatist state: the
case of biotechnology in the Federal Republic of Germany. Res
Policy 14:2338
Jrdening H-J, Winter J (2005) Environmental Biotechnology. WileyVCH, Weinheim
Jr Perkin WH (1912) The production and polymerization of butadiene, isoprene, and their homologues. J Soc Chem Ind
31:616623
Judson HF (1979) The eighth day of creation: makers of the revolution
in Biology. Simon & Schuster, New York
Kendrew JC, Bodo G, Dintzis HM, Parrish RG (1958) A threedimensional model of the myoglobin molecule obtained by xray analysis. Nature 181:662666
3762
Klein-Marcuschamer D, Yadav V, Ghaderi A, Stephanopoulos GN
(2010) De novo metabolic engineering and the promise of synthetic DNA. Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol 120:101131
Knapp F (1847) Lehrbuch der chemischen Technologie, Vol. 2, F.
Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig
Kohler R (1975) The history of biochemistrya survey. J Hist Biol
8:275318
Khne, W (1877) Ueber das Verhalten verschiedener organisierter und
sog. Ungeformter Fermente. (On the behaviour of different organized and so-called unformed ferments). Verhandlungen des
Naturhistorisch-Medicinischen Vereins, vol. 1, p. 190
Ktzing F (1837) Microscopische Untersuchungen ber die Hefe und
Essigmutter, nebst mehreren anderen dazu gehrigen
vegetabilischen Gebilden. (Microscopic researches on yeast and
mother of vinegar, besides several other relevant plant formations). J Prakt Chem 11:385409
Langlykke AF (1970) The engineer and the biologist. AIChE pp. 8997
Liebig J (1839) Ueber die Erscheinungen der Ghrung, Fulnis und
Verwesung und ihre Ursachen. J Prakt Chem 18:129165
May OE, Herrick HT (1930) Some minor industrial fermentations. Ind
Eng Chem 22:11721176
Metz, H (1997) Nutzung der Biotechnologie in der chemischen Industrie.
In: Technikgeschichte als Vorbild moderner Technik Vol. 21,
Schriftenreihe der Georg-Agrikola-Gesellschaft, Gttingen,
pp. 105115
Nathan F (1919) The manufacture of acetone. J Soc Chem Ind
38:271T273T
Ohno M, Otsuka M, Yagisawa M, Kondo S, Heinz Oppinger H,
Hoffmann H, Sukatsch D, Hepner D, Male C (2000) Antibiotics.
In: Ullmanns encyclopedia of industrial chemistry, Wiley-VCH,
Weinheim, New York; www.mrw.interscience.wiley.com/emrw/
Ost H (1900) Lehrbuch der Chemischen Technologie. Gebrder
Jnnecke, Hannover
OTA (1984) Impact of applied genetics. Washington
Otto, J (1838) Lehrbuch der rationellen Praxis der landwirtschaftlichen
Gewerbe. Vieweg, Braunschweig; Reprint VCH, Weinheim, 1987
Papini M, Salazar M, Nielsen J (2010) Systems biology of industrial microorganisms. Advances in Biochemical Engineering/
Biotechnology 120:5199
Pasteur L (1857a) Mmoire sur la fermentation appele lactique. Comt
Rend XLV(22): 913916; also: (1858) Ueber die Milchsureghrung.
J Prakt Chem 73: 447451
Pasteur L (1857b) Mmoire sur la fermentation alcoolique. Compt
Rend 45: 10321036; also: (1858) Ueber die alkoholische
Ghrung. J Prakt Chem 73: 451455
Pasteur L (1860) Mmoire sur la fermentation alcoolique. Ann Chim
Phys 58:323426
Pasteur L (1862) Ueber die Ghrung und die sogenannte generatio
aequivoca. J Prakt Chem 85:465472, also: Comt Rend 52(LII):
344 and 1260; and 48 (XLVIII): 753 and 1149
Pasteur L (1873) Improvement in the manufacture of beer and yeast.
US patent 141 072
Pasteur L (1876) Etudes sur la Bire. Avec une Thorie Nouvelle de la
Fermentation. Gauthier-Villars, Paris
Payen A (1874) Handbuch der Technischen Chemie. Nach A Payens
Chimie industrielle, II. Band, F. Stohmann and C. Engler (eds), E.
Schweizerbartsche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Stuttgart