Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ABSTRACT
An empirical study which identifies 251 technical
interoperability standards implemented in a modern laptop
computer, and estimates that the total number of standards
relevant to such a device is much higher. Of the identified
standards, the authors find that 44% were developed by
consortia, 36% by formal standards development
organizations, and 20% by single companies.
The
intellectual property rights policies associated with 197 of
the standards are assessed: 75% were developed under
RAND terms, 22% under royalty free terms, and 3%
utilize a patent pool. The authors make certain
observations based on their findings, and identify
promising areas for future research.
Keywords standards, SDOs, consortia, intellectual
property rights (IPR), RAND, royalty free
1. OVERVIEW
RF.
This category included standards that were
created under terms that prohibit the participating
companies or individuals from collecting patent
royalties for essential patent claims (usually subject to
important limitations). For our purposes, IPR models
such as RF-RAND (royalty-free RAND) and
RAND-Zero (RAND with zero royalties) fall into
this category. We also included standards with IPR
policies that rely on promises not to assert essential
patent claims here. Note that our designation of a
standard as RF does not mean that the standard is in
fact royalty free to implement, as entities not bound by
the IPR policy could assert patents, for example.
REFERENCES
[1] IPO Standards Setting Committee, Standards Primer:
An Overview of Standards Setting Bodies and PatentRelated Issues that Arise in the Context of Standards
Setting Activities, 2009 IPO Articles & Reps., Pats. Sec.
No. 16 (10/09/2009). Available to IPO members via
http://ipo.org;
excerpts
publicly
available
at
<http://standardslaw.org/seminar/class-2/excerpts-from-ipostandards-primer/>.
[2] Per Anderson, Evaluation of Ten Standard Setting
Organizations With Regard to Open Standards, IDC Study
commissioned by the Danish National IT and Telecom
Agency, January 2008. Available at <http://www.itst.dk/itarkitektur-og-standarder/standardisering/abnestandarder/baggrundsrapporter/Evaluation%20of%20Ten%
20Standard%20Setting%20Organizations.pdf>.
APPENDIX:
LIST OF STANDARDS/SPECIFICATIONS
Name of
standard/specification
.NET
Developer
3GPP
SDO
RAND
IEC
SDO
RAND
AC'97 v2.3
Intel
COMPANY
NA
T13 INCITS
SDO
RAND
ACPI
CONSORTIA
RAND
ACS-2 [ATA/ATAPI
Command Set 2]
Advanced Configuration
and Power Interface Spec
3.0
Advanced eXpress I/O
Module [AXIOM]
AES (U.S. FIPS PUB 197)
AGP
AIFF
ALC889
Microsoft
Developer
type
COMPANY
IP
type
NA
VESA
CONSORTIA
RAND
ATI
COMPANY
NA
NIST
SDO
NA
Intel
COMPANY
NA
Apple
COMPANY
NA
Name of
standard/specification
DirectX
Display Identification Data
[DisplayID] Structure v1.1
Display Port Panel
Connector
Display Subsystem Power
Management
DisplayPort
Interoperability Guidline
v1.1
DLNA
RealTek
COMPANY
NA
open source
project
ANSI
CONSORTIA
RF
SDO
RAND
ANSI
SDO
RAND
ANSI
SDO
RAND
ANSI
SDO
RAND
APM
Microsoft
COMPANY
ASF
Microsoft
Atom
AVI
Microsoft
Developer
type
COMPANY
IP
type
NA
VESA
CONSORTIA
RAND
VESA
CONSORTIA
RAND
VESA
CONSORTIA
RAND
VESA
CONSORTIA
RAND
Digital Living
Network
Alliance
Intel
CONSORTIA
RAND
COMPANY
NA
RAND
IETF
CONSORTIA
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
DVB/ETSI
SDO
RAND
DVD Forum
CONSORTIA
POOL
DVI
DDWG
CONSORTIA
RAND
Digital
Display
Working
Group
ECMA
CONSORTIA
NA
CONSORTIA
RAND
ECMA C#
ECMA
CONSORTIA
RAND
NA
ECMA CLR
ECMA
CONSORTIA
RAND
COMPANY
NA
ECMA-378
ECMA
SDO
RAND
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
ECMA-384
ECMA
SDO
RAND
Microsoft
COMPANY
NA
T13 INCITS
SDO
RAND
Bluetooth spec.
Bluetooth Sig
CONSORTIA
RF
Blu-ray Disc
Association
Blu-ray Disc
Association
Blu-ray Disc
Association
ANSI/ISO
CONSORTIA
POOL
Intel
COMPANY
NA
VESA
CONSORTIA
RAND
IEEE
SDO
RAND
open source
CONSORTIA
RF
Allegro 4.9.19
ANSI INCITS 2071991[R2007]
ANSI INCITS 3462001[r2006]
ANSI INCITS 407-2005
ANSI INCITS 417-2006
CONSORTIA
POOL
Embedded DisplayPort
Standard (eDP)
Ethernet [802.3]
CONSORTIA
POOL
EXT4
SDO
RAND
C++ (ISO/IEC
14882:2003)
CD audio ("Red book") IEC 60908
CDROM
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
IEC
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
CIM [Common
Information Model] 2.250
Cinepak
DMTF
CONSORTIA
RAND
SuperMac
Technologies
Khronos
COMPANY
NA
COLLADA 1.5
Compact Flash
CSS (Cascading Style
Sheet)
CSS (Content Scramble
System)
DDR3
Dirac
DVD Multi
Developer
Fat16
ECMA
SDO
RAND
Fat32
Microsoft
[Open Spec]
IEEE
COMPANY
NA
SDO
RAND
Adobe
COMPANY
NA
Firelight
Technologies
IETF
COMPANY
NA
CONSORTIA
RAND
DVD Forum
CONSORTIA
POOL
DVD Forum
CONSORTIA
POOL
ITU-T
SDO
RAND
SDO
RAND
HDCP
ITUT/ISO/IEC
JVT
DCP
COMPANY
NA
HDMI
HDMI
CONSORTIA
RAND
HFS
Apple
COMPANY
NA
Firewire/1394
Flash (FLV, F4V)
FMOD
FTP
CONSORTIA
RF
Compact
Flash Ass.
W3C
CONSORTIA
RAND
CONSORTIA
RF
DVD Forum
CONSORTIA
NA
JEDEC
SDO
RAND
BBC
Research
VESA
COMPANY
RF
CONSORTIA
RAND
Microsoft
COMPANY
NA
DirectCompute API
Microsoft
COMPANY
NA
HFS+
Apple
COMPANY
NA
ISO/IEC 24739-1:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
HTML5
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
ISO/IEC 24739-2:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
HTTP
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
ISO/IEC 24739-3:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
HTTPS
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
ISO/IEC 24757:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
Rudiak-Gould
COMPANY
NA
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
HuffYUV
IEC 60320
IEC
SDO
RAND
IEC
SDO
RAND
IEEE
SDO
RAND
IEEE
SDO
RAND
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
IMAP
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
INCITS 370-2004(1510D):
ATA Host Adapter
Standards
INCITS 437-2008
T13 INCITS
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 9995-3:202
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 9995-4:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
INCITS 452-2008(D1699):
AT Attachment 8
ATA/ATAPI Command
Set
Intel 64 architecture
x2APIC Spec
Intel AHCI
T13 INCITS
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 9995-5:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 9995-7:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 9995-8:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC TR 24784:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
Intel
COMPANY
NA
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 29171:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 29171:2009
[iVDR spec]
ISO/IEC 29500 Office
Open XML
ISO/IEC 9995-1:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 9995-2:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
Intel
COMPANY
NA
ISO/IEC TR29106:2007
Intel
COMPANY
NA
ISO 32000-1:2008
Intel
COMPANY
RAND
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
Magsafe
IPv4
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
MATHML
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
Matroska
ISO 9241-300:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO 9241-302:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO 9241-303:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO
SDO
RAND
Java
Community
Process
Apple
CONSORTIA
RF
COMPANY
NA
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
open source
project
IETF
CONSORTIA
RF
CONSORTIA
RAND
CONSORTIA
RAND
SD
Association
MIDI
Manufacturer
s Ass'n
IETF
CONSORTIA
NA
CONSORTIA
RAND
ISO 9241-304:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO 9241-305:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO 9241-306:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
MIME
ISO 9241-307:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
Mini Displayport
VESA
CONSORTIA
RF
ISO 9241-400:2007
ISO
SDO
RAND
MINI-DVI
Apple
COMPANY
NA
ISO 9241-400:2007
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
MiniSD
RAND
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO 9241-410:2008
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
SD
Association
IETF
CONSORTIA
ISO 9241-410:2008
CONSORTIA
RAND
CONSORTIA
RAND
CONSORTIA
RAND
MIDI
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
MMS
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 11989:2010
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 13170:2009
ISO
SDO
RAND
Monitor Control
Command Set [MCCS]
Standard v2.2
MP3 (MPEG-1 Layer 3)
ISO/IEC 14772-2:2004
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 14776-150:2004
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 15412:1999
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 15948:2004
ISO
SDO
RAND
Open Mobile
Alliance
VESA
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 19774:2006
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 19775-1:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 19775-2:2004
ISO
SDO
RAND
MXF
ISO/IEC 19776-1:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 19776-2:2008
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 19776-3:2007
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 19777-1:2006
ISO
SDO
RAND
ISO/IEC 19777-2:2006
ISO
SDO
RAND
Microsoft
COMPANY
NA
SMPTE
CONSORTIA
NA
MXM
Group/SIG
CONSORTIA
RF
MXM
Group/SIG
CONSORTIA
RF
Net2Display Remoting
Standard (N2D)
NTFS
NTP (time
synchronization)
OGG
VESA
Microsoft
[Closed Spec]
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
COMPANY
NA
CONSORTIA
RAND
Sorenson
Sorenson
COMPANY
NA
ISO/IEC
SDO
RAND
RAND
IEC
SDO
SVG
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
UEFI
CONSORTIA
RAND
UEFI
CONSORTIA
RAND
Trusted
computing
Group
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
CONSORTIA
RAND
Xiph.Org
Foundation
IEEE
CONSORTIA
RF
SDO
RAND
Trusted
computing
Group
Intel
CONSORTIA
RAND
COMPANY
NA
Xiph.Org
Foundation
Creative
Technology
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
COMPANY
RF
CONSORTIA
RF
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
Theora
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
TKIP
OpenGL SC 1.0
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
OpenGL Shading
Language 4.00.7
Specification
OpenKode
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
OpenAL
OpenCL
TCP
OpenMAX
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
OpenML
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
OpenSL/ES
Khronos
Group
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
CONSORTIA
RF
OpenVG
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
UEFI
CONSORTIA
RAND
UEFI
CONSORTIA
RAND
UEFI
CONSORTIA
RAND
UEFI Specification
Version 2.3
Universal Audio
Architecture
UPnP
UEFI
CONSORTIA
RAND
Microsoft
COMPANY
NA
RF
OpenWF
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
PCI-SIG
CONSORTIA
RAND
PCI-SIG
CONSORTIA
RAND
PCI-SIG
CONSORTIA
RAND
UPnP Forum
CONSORTIA
USB-IF
CONSORTIA
RF
USB
USB-IF
CONSORTIA
RF
SMPTE
CONSORTIA
NA
Various
companies
VESA
CONSORTIA
NA
CONSORTIA
RAND
VGA
IBM
COMPANY
NA
VOB
DVD Forum
CONSORTIA
NA
VP5
On2
Technologies
On2
Technologies
Google
COMPANY
NA
COMPANY
NA
COMPANY
NA
COMPANY
NA
PGA-989 socket
Intel
COMPANY
NA
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
PNG
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
POP
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
Quicktime
Apple
COMPANY
NA
RealNetworks
COMPANY
NA
TIA
SDO
RAND
RealVideo 3&4
RJ-11 (TIA-968-A)
RSS
VESA DDC2/E-DDC
VP6
Various
CONSORTIA
NA
RSVP
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
RTMP
Adobe
COMPANY
RF
RTP
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
RTSP
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
S/MIME
SATA
SD
SDL 1.3
SDP
SDRAM
SHA-1 (FIPS PUB 180)
SIP
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
Serial ATA
Int'l Org.
SD
Association
open source
project
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
CONSORTIA
RAND
JEDEC
VP8
WAV
MSFT and
IBM
Khronos
CONSORTIA
RF
Wireless
Gigabit
Alliance
IEEE
CONSORTIA
RF
SDO
RAND
IEEE
SDO
RAND
CONSORTIA
NA
COMPANY
NA
CONSORTIA
RF
CONSORTIA
RAND
WMV
Wireless HD
Consortium
Microsoft
SDO
RAND
WSDL
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
NIST
SDO
NA
x.509
ITU-T
SDO
RAND
Wireless HD 1.0
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
Intel/AMD
COMPANY
NA
Toshiba
COMPANY
NA
XHCI
Intel
COMPANY
NA
SMTP
IETF
CONSORTIA
RAND
XML
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
SOAP
W3C
CONSORTIA
RF
JEDEC
SDO
RAND
SmartMedia
SODIMM